﻿

   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
About This Book
Six reasons CAM practitioners should not be licensed | J Bellamy
A right to science | J Bellamy
Bring on the Evidence: A new regulatory approach to CAM | S Gavura
The Cure | J Bellamy
CAM and the Law Part 1: Introduction to the issues. Brennen McKenzie
CAM and the Law Part 3. Malpractice. Brennen McKenzie 
CAM and the Law Part 2: Licensure and Scope of Practice Laws. Brennen McKenzie 
CAM and the Law Part 4: Regulation of Supplements and Homeopathic Remedies. Brennen McKenzie 
2026: State Legislatures as Vectors of Health Misinformation and Anti-Science | S Gavura
Regulating Fringe Practitioners | S Novella
Is “CAM” Fraud? Published by Jann Bellamy.
“CAL”: a Medico-Legal Parable. Kimball Atwood
CAM practitioners as primary care providers under the Affordable Care Act: Part 1 | J Bellamy
CAM practitioners as primary care providers under the Affordable Care Act: Part 2 | J Bellamy
Repealing Legislative Alchemy | J Bellamy
Georgia on my mind. John Snyder.
A pox on your bank account: failure to vaccinate and its legal consequences. Jann Bellamy.
Supreme Court Saves Nation’s Immunization Program. John Snyder
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., vaccines, the EPA, and the interface with science-based medicine and public policy. David Go
Attacking vaccines through the misunderstanding of medical ethics | D Gorski
Pitfalls in Regulating Physicians. Part 1 Kimball Atwood
Pitfalls in Regulating Physicians. Part 2. The Games Scoundrels Play Kimball Atwood
How State Medical Boards Shoot Themselves (and You) in the Foot Kimball Atwood
The North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners, Dr. Rashid Buttar, and protecting the public from practitioners of non-science-based medicine. David Gorski
Physicians and “CAM” | J Bellamy
Is (Conversion) Therapy Speech? | S Novella
SCOTUS conversion therapy decision “opens a dangerous can of worms” | J Bellamy
Idaho allows faith-based medical neglect to kill children | J Bellamy
Naturopathy
Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 1 Kimball Atwood
Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 2 Kimball Atwood
Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 3 Kimball Atwood
Bastyr University’s MPH and MPH/ND programs should not be accredited | J Bellamy
What naturopaths really want | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy I: Naturopathy. Jann Bellamy
Licensing Naturopaths: the triumph of politics over science | J Bellamy
Naturopaths push for licensing in Massachusetts (again) | J Bellamy
Here we go again: A bill licensing naturopaths rears its ugly head in Michigan | D Gorski
Nobody licenses quacks in my state! HB 4531 and the licensing of naturopaths in Michigan | D Gorski
Legislative Alchemy: Michigan House Bill 4531 gives naturopaths a broad scope of practice | J Bellamy]
Maryland legislature passes naturopathic licensing bill, but with damage control | J Bellamy
Naturopathic organ repositioning coming soon to Pennsylvania? | J Bellamy
Night of the living naturopaths | J Bellamy
Legislative alchemy (briefly) revisited: Naturopathy in Vermont and colloidal silver | D Gorski
Legislative Alchemy: The New Year | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: 2012.5 | J Bellamy
2013 Legislative Review: placenta take out | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathy 2013 | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Acupuncture and Homeopathy 2013 | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2014 (so far) | J Bellamy
2014: Chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists lose in state legislatures | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathic licensing and practice expansion 2015 | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2015: Another losing season for CAM practitioners | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2017: Naturopaths push licensing and practice expansion while in damage control over IV turmeric death | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2017: Naturopathy | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2018: naturopathic licensing and practice expansion shutout? | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathic licensing bill now before Wisconsin Senate Committee | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2019: Naturopaths gain licensure in two states, try for authority to grant vaccination medical exemptions | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Undaunted by rejection in 2020, naturopaths return to state legislatures seeking licensing and practice expansion | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: “Naturopathic Doctor” licensing is bad medicine for Florida | J Bellamy
Naturopaths cannot call themselves “Medically Trained” in New Brunswick | S Gavura
Legislative Alchemy: Michigan naturopathic licensing bill passes Senate | J Bellamy
Connecticut “modernizes” naturopathic scope of practice | J Bellamy
Oh no, not again! Massachusetts Legislature passes naturopathic licensing bill | J Bellamy
Naturopathic conquest of New England nears completion | J Bellamy
SFSBM Report upsets naturopaths. We’re fine with that. | J Bellamy
California legislature should repeal naturopathic licensing | J Bellamy
Board Disciplinary Actions. What Naturopaths Really Do Not Want You To Know | M Crislip
Chiropractic
Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic. Jann Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Chiropractic 2013 | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2016 Update: Acupuncturists win; naturopaths and chiropractors don’t (so far) | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2019: Chiropractors seek scope of practice expansion, including authority to prescribe drugs | J Bellamy
The Exciting Conclusion | J Bellamy
Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way! | H Hall
The DC as PCP? Revisited | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? The battle continues | J Bellamy
Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy | J Bellamy
H.R. 2654 forces Medicare to treat chiropractors and MDs as equals | J Bellamy
The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full chiropractic scope of practice | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? Drug Wars Resume |J Bellamy
The CAM Docket: Texas MDs v. DCs | J Bellamy
Chiropractors Lobby for Acceptance by the VA and TRICARE | H Hall
Direct Primary Care Agreements and Chiropractors: A bad deal for patients | J Bellamy
Congress can easily end Medicare waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, saving billions | J Bellamy
Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Legal Support for Inappropriate Use of Spinal Manipulation | S Homola
Chiropractors, Naturopaths, Concussions and Senate Bill 1535 | M Crislip
Chiropractic Strokes Again! A Landmark Lawsuit in Canada. Harriet Hall.
CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: State licensing of “the profession of reflexology” | J Bellamy
Acupuncture
Legislative Alchemy III: Acupuncture. Jann Bellamy 
Legislative Alchemy 2017: Acupuncture | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2018: Acupuncturists seek practice expansion and competition elimination | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2019: Acupuncturists score Medicare coverage and scope of practice expansion | J Bellamy
Acupuncture practice acts: legalized quackery | J Bellamy
California Acupuncture Board: a Mockery of Consumer Protection | J Bellamy
California Acupuncture Licensing: Sinking Lower in the Slime! | B Kavoussi
“Integrative medicine” advocates: Co-opting the opioid crisis to promote funding for acupuncture by Medicaid | Science-Based Medicine
Medicare proposal covers acupuncture for back pain study participants: A prelude to full coverage? | J Bellamy
Damn the evidence and regulations: VA goes full speed ahead with medical pseudoscience | J Bellamy
HB 4710: Licensing and expanding the scope of practice of acupuncturists in Michigan | D Gorski
Legislative Alchemy: Licensing reflexologists and other practitioners of pseudoscience | J Bellamy
Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left | J Bellamy
More Political Science: Proposed laws protect “Lyme literate” doctors from discipline | J Bellamy
Political Science: Chronic Lyme Disease | J Bellamy
Nevada’s new quack protection law | J Bellamy
The Quack Full Employment Act | J Bellamy
Ayurvedic practitioners push for licensing in Colorado | J Bellamy
Missouri tackles primary care shortage with “assistant physicians” | J Bellamy
Legislating Ignorance | J Snyder
Vaccination mandate exemptions: gimme that ol’ time philosophy | J Bellamy
An antivaccine tale of two legal actions | D Gorski
California Bill AB 2109: The Antivaccine Movement Attacks School Vaccine Mandates Again | D Gorski
Battles over non-medical exemptions to vaccination festering in state legislatures | J Bellamy
Anti-vaxxers try to kill Florida bill ending childhood vaccination religious exemption | J Bellamy
The war in California over nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates | D Gorski
The war in California over nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates, part 2 | D Gorski
California SB 277: New evidence that restricting nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine requirements works | D Gorski
Laws Limiting Vaccine Exemptions Work | S Novella
NY federal court hands triple loss to anti-vaccination ideology | J Bellamy
Review of Vaccine Whistleblower: A Legal Perspective | D Reiss
Maine considers protecting quacks from accountability to regulators and patients | J Bellamy
Sen. Rubio’s proposed tax shelters for quackery | D Gorski
Legislators want “pharmaceutical cost transparency”. Are they asking the wrong question? | S Gavura
No Education? No Training? No License? No Problem! Jann Bellamy 
   
Science-Based Medicine Reviews: Law and CAM
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction 
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

About This Book

As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 
So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections
The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.
You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 5000 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.
Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 


Six reasons CAM practitioners should not be licensed
Jann Bellamy on June 27, 2013
Link
States license “complementary and alternative” (CAM) practitioners (chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists/TCM practitioners and homeopaths) via the magic of “legislative alchemy.” Ironically, licensing statutes are enacted based on the states’ constitutional power to protect the health, safety and welfare of the public. Yet these CAM practice acts actually increase public vulnerability to unsafe and ineffective health care practices. It is, in short, a bad idea. (A point we’ve discussed many times on SBM.) Here are six reasons why. Feel free to add to the list.
1. Practice acts grant CAM practitioners a broad scope of practice, including legalization of scientifically implausible and unproven (or disproven) diagnostic methods, diagnoses and treatments.
Like medical doctors, dentists and nurses, CAM practitioners must practice under licensing legislation, also referred to as a practice act. Otherwise, they risk prosecution for the unlicensed practice of medicine or other licensed profession unless they are exempted by one of the so-called “health freedom” laws, which basically give everyone the right to practice medicine.
Chiropractic practice acts incorporate the absurd notion that patients are suffering from “subluxations” that adversely affect their (or their children’s) health. Acupuncture practice acts are based on the equally absurd notion that the body contains “meridians” which, when blocked, cause ill health, but can be relieved by sticking people with needles. Naturopaths can diagnose and treat conditions they invented out of whole cloth, such as chronic yeast overgrowth, ubiquitous “food sensitivities,” and adrenal fatigue. Homeopaths can treat patients with expensive little bottles of water. (You can find out much more about these CAM practices in the pull-down menu accessed via the “Categories” tab to the right of this post.)
Although there are exceptions, most practice acts grant CAM providers the right to diagnose and treat any patient, no matter what age or physical condition, suffering from any disease or condition, as long as the disease or condition is described in the terms of the practice act and the treatment is within the scope of practice. This is perhaps best illustrated by examples. Suppose a patient sees a chiropractor for vertigo. The chiropractor is legally allowed to diagnose the cause of vertigo as one or more subluxations of the spine and to treat the patient with adjustments. What if the patient sees an acupuncturist? If the acupuncturist diagnoses blockage of “qi” as the cause of vertigo and performs acupuncture to unblock the “qi,” the acupuncturist has done nothing outside his scope of practice. And if the patient sees a naturopath? The naturopath is free to diagnose, for example, “toxins” as the cause of the vertigo and proceed to treat these toxins with colonic irrigation. How about a homeopath? Same result: the patient is treated with what is essentially water. None of this will address the patient’s vertigo but it is all perfectly legal.
There is no better way to demonstrate the legalization of quackery accomplished by licensing legislation than to quote from the law itself. A few examples:
Nevada: Defines “homeopathic medicine” or “homeopathy” as
employing substances . . . [p]repared according to homeopathic pharmacology by which the formulation of homeopathic preparations is accomplished by the methods of Hanemannian dilution and succession or magnetically energized geometric patterns applicable in potencies above 30X, as defined in the official Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia . . . and . . . prescribed . . . in accordance with the principle that a substance which produces symptoms in a healthy person can eliminate those symptoms in an ill person.
Nevada’s homeopathy practice act also permits “cell therapy, neural therapy, . . . neuromuscular integration, [and] orthomolecular therapy. . .” [As is the case with other terms in CAM practitioner statutes, I do wonder what “magnetically energized geometric patterns” are and how they are “applicable in potencies above 30X.”]
North Carolina: Defines the practice of chiropractic as
[T]he science of adjusting the cause of disease by realigning the spine, releasing pressure on nerves radiating from the spine to all parts of the body, and allowing the nerves to carry their full quota of health current (nerve energy) from the brain to all parts of the body.
Colorado: It is distressing to report that the Colorado’s naturopathic licensing bill was passed by the legislature and signed by the governor. It defines the practice of “naturopathic medicine” in a broad fashion typical of naturopathic licensing statutes:
A system of health care for the prevention, diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of injuries, diseases and conditions of the human body through the use of education, nutrition, naturopathic preparations, natural medicines and other therapies, and other modalities that are designed to support or supplement the human body’s own natural self-healing processes.
2. CAM practitioner education is inadequate preparation for the scope of practice permitted.
Almost without exception, state statutes simply require that a CAM practitioner have graduated from a school accredited by an accrediting agency approved by the U.S. Department of Education. These accrediting agencies are run by the schools and practitioners themselves. And while the Department gives lip service to the goal of assuring educational “quality,” it does not address the scientific validity of what these schools teach. Nor does it have jurisdiction to determine whether further clinical education is necessary for practice after graduation. While medical doctors and osteopaths must complete an additional three years to practice as primary care providers in a grueling residency program, no such residency requirement exists for CAM providers. In addition, these CAM schools have low admission requirements compared to medical schools. For example, unlike medical and other professional educational institutions, there is no admissions test.
CAM providers also create their own licensing exams – exams which are not vetted by, or have even been seen by, outside sources. And, because there is no residency requirement, unlike medical doctors there is no further testing for licensing eligibility during residency training.
Yet, as noted elsewhere in this post, some states specifically allow practitioners to practice “primary care” – like M.D.s and D.O.s – without nearly the quality, or quantity, of education and training medical doctors must have. As discussed in a previous post, chiropractors are now promoting themselves as primary care physicians, in the form of “advanced practice chiropractors.” This includes the right to prescribe certain drugs, including drugs no respectable physician would use, based on a flimsy prescription drug education course.
The only fact-based, well-reasoned analysis of CAM practitioner education I’ve ever seen was done by SBM’s own Kimball Atwood, M.D. In 2001, he authored a scathing analysis of the practice of naturopathy and the insufficiency of naturopathic “medical” education. Unfortunately, he and Arthur Relman, M.D., members of a 2001 committee created to vet the possibility of licensing naturopaths in Massachusetts, ended up issuing a minority report opposing naturopathic licensing due to the bias in favor of licensing apparent in other members of the committee. Dr. Atwood chronicled his experience for SBM readers, as well as the many foibles of naturopathic practice, in posts collected here. (Fortunately, naturopaths still aren’t licensed in Massachusetts, although they came awfully close last year. This year brings a fresh attempt.)
3. The fox is allowed to guard the henhouse (self-regulation).
CAM practitioner licensing acts typically allow self-regulation via boards empowered to enact rules governing practice and to discipline practitioners, in the same fashion as medicine, nursing, optometry and similar boards regulate the practice of other professions. These boards are usually made up of practitioners and a couple of public members. In turn, the boards, in some cases, simply default to the CAM schools and trade associations to set standards for education and practice. In addition, via their authority to enact rules, the boards are able to approve even more quack practices not specifically mentioned in the practice acts. Boards can administer, without answering to anyone, a light hand in disciplining practitioners even in the most egregious of cases. In other words, the fox guards the henhouse.
Some examples:
Nevada: In case you have not heard of some of the homeopathic practices permitted by Nevada law (see above), these Nevada Administrative Code regulations enacted by the Board of Homeopathic Medical Examiners fill in the gaps.
“Neuromuscular integration” is “the progressive harmonization of the endocrine system, immune system, autonomic nervous system, skeletal system and smooth muscle system of a patient with the cognitive and noncognitive faculties of a patient.”
“Orthomolecular therapy” is “the treatment and prevention of disease, including, without limitation, infection, malignancy and degenerative illness, by adjusting the natural chemical constituents of the body on the molecular level.”
Other permitted homeopathic treatments are defined as well, including the use of “bio-oxidative substances” which are “used to promote healing at the cellular level by the use of oxygen in its various forms” and “thought field therapy,” defined as “a technique that uses the energy meridians of the body which are used in acupuncture . . . to treat abnormal patterns of thought that cause emotional and psychophysiological distress.”
Alaska: Chiropractic-board-approved “specialty programs” include the “Chiropractic Diagnosis and Management of Internal Disorders (DABCI) program administered by the American Chiropractic Association Council on Family Practice” and the “Certificate in Chiropractic Pediatrics program administered by the International Chiropractors Association (ICA) Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics.” (The “D” in “DABCI” stands for “Diplomate.”)
California: Regulations enacted by the chiropractic board state that a “duly licensed chiropractor may treat any condition, disease, or injury in any patient, including a pregnant woman, and may diagnose, so long as such treatment or diagnosis is done in a manner consistent with chiropractic methods and techniques and so long as such methods and treatment do not constitute the practice of medicine by exceeding the legal scope of chiropractic practice . . .”
Oklahoma: The chiropractic board defines “scope of practice” to include all diagnostic methods and treatments “taught by an accredited chiropractic college and approved by the Board of Chiropractic Examiners.” As well, chiropractors are authorized to use naturopathic and homeopathic remedies.
4. Mandatory public and private insurance coverage
Once licensed, CAM providers inevitably lobby for mandatory public and private insurance coverage. (This sharing of CAM costs via insurance premiums and tax dollars is in addition to the billions Americans spend each year on “alternative medicine.”) For example, Florida law mandates that whenever an insurance policy “provides for the payment of medical expense benefits or procedures” the policy “shall be construed to include payment to a chiropractic physician who provides the medical service benefits or procedures which are within the scope of a chiropractic physician’ license.” Coverage of such services under Florida’s no-fault insurance law saw chiropractors, acupuncturists and massage therapists become the top-paid providers under the program, an unsustainable situation recently addressed by the state legislature.
As another example, in Oregon naturopaths and acupuncturists are covered providers under a publicly funded medical assistance program for Native American patients. As we have seen, naturopaths are now demanding that they be permitted to practice in coordinated care practice groups serving Medicaid patients, even though they reject evidence-based medicine, a quality and cost-saving requirement of all practitioners per Oregon law.
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) may exacerbate this problem via its non-discrimination provision (Section 2607), which prohibits discrimination against any health care provider who is acting within the scope of his or her license. Inclusion of CAM in essential health benefits and as providers in practice groups per the ACA may offer additional means of accessing insurance dollars. California already includes acupuncture as an essential health benefit under the ACA and other states include chiropractic.
5. Licensing confers undeserved legitimacy causing public confusion.
Once licensed, CAM practitioners enjoy an imprimatur of legitimacy as “doctors.” This causes public confusion about who is a medical doctor and who is another type of practitioner. This is no doubt exacerbated by the fact that many statutes defined CAM practitioners as providers of “primary care.” And some statues permit practitioners to call themselves “physicians.”
This status as “doctors” and “physicians” allows practitioners to insinuate themselves into other situations formerly denied them. For example, some states allow chiropractors to perform sports and school physicals. Arizona’s regulations governing child care group homes includes in its definition of “physician” persons licensed to practice “naturopathic medicine” and “homeopathic medicine.”
6. Licensing decreases important health care consumer protections.
Incorporating pseudoscience into practice acts and permitting self-regulation decreases consumer protection. Obviously, if the state chiropractic practice act permits the detection and correction of subluxations, a chiropractor is not going to be disciplined by the state chiropractic board for detecting and correcting subluxations, even though there is no such thing as subluxations and they cannot be detected. If the patient attempts to sue a chiropractor for fraud in a civil action, the chiropractor can raise the affirmative defense that he is permitted to detect and correct subluxations under state law.
Once CAM practitioners are licensed and governed by their own boards, the medical boards have little authority to prosecute these practitioners for the unlicensed practice of medicine. Even in the rare case where the medical board might attempt it, the CAM practitioner will raise the defense that his practice is exclusively under the jurisdiction of their state board.
And there is that most egregious assault on the health care consumer in the form of “health freedom” statutes. Unfortunately, another state’s citizens are now subject to the imaginative treatments of charlatans: the “Colorado Natural Health Consumer Protection Act, or, as I prefer, the Quack Full Employment Act, recently passed the Colorado legislature and was signed by the governor. This statute (as do others) almost completely removes the despicable snake oil salesmen who prey on the sick from the jurisdiction of the medical board.
A couple of cases highlight how consumer protection has been sacrificed by the legalization of quackery.
In Yow v. Dept. of Health, the Washington Court of Appeals upheld a state medical board finding that Yow, a practitioner of colonic irrigation who did not hold any sort of health care practitioner license, was engaged in the unlicensed practice of medicine. The court also upheld a fine of $444,000.
Testimony before the medical board revealed that Yow claimed colonic irrigation would purge accumulated “toxins” and referred to irrigation as a “detoxification process.” He sometimes added herbs to the water used for irrigation.
Yow admitted that the benefits of colonic irrigation were “anecdotal.” A gastroenterologist testified that the procedure carries the potential for colonic perforation and that introduction of herbs into patients’ colons could cause side effects, such as difficulty breathing, and may result in allergic reactions. This expert also testified that irrigation creates a risk of electrolyte shifts and subsequent cardiac arrhythmias.
But note that colonic irrigation is perfectly legal in Washington if performed by a licensed naturopathic doctor, as is true in any state that licenses naturopaths. In Florida, massage therapists are licensed to perform colonic irrigation. The facts have not changed: there is no evidence of effectiveness (anecdotes are not evidence), “toxins” are not removed by the procedure (not that toxins are present in the first place), and there are recognized risks. The only difference is the legality of the procedure.
In Ames v. Dept. of Health, the Washington Supreme Court upheld the state’s imposition of sanctions against Ames, an M.D., for falling below the standard of care for medical doctors and use of an ineffective device. Ames used a galvanic skin response device to diagnose and treat patients. The inventor of the device himself testified at the hearing that the machine – called “LISTEN” – was a biofeedback device and not approved by the FDA for the diagnosis and treatment of disease. According to testimony at the administrative hearing:
Ames instructed P1 [Patient 1] to lie on his back while holding a small brass probe in his hand. The probe connected to LISTEN. While P1 lay prone, Ames performed a basic muscle resistance test by asking P1 to resist downward pressure on his upraised forearm, which P1 ably achieved. Next, Ames typed the word “eggs” into LISTEN’s computer interface and performed the resistance test again. Apparently, Ames was able to force P1’s arm down.
Based on this absurd test, Ames diagnosed the patient with egg allergies.
The LISTEN machine, as employed by Ames, is a type of electrodermal diagnostic device. According to Quackwatch:
Thousands of practitioners use “electrodiagnostic” devices to help select their recommended treatment. Many claim to determine the cause of any disease by detecting the “energy imbalance” causing the problem. Some also claim that the devices can detect whether someone is allergic or sensitive to foods, deficient in vitamins, or has defective teeth.
Yet the Arizona Board of Homeopathic and Integrated Medicine Examiners not only approves the use of electrodermal testing, it also permits “homeopathic physicians” to train persons not registered by the Board in this testing by providing “180 hours of homeoptherapeutic instruction and 100 hours of supervised clinical experience.” Likewise, the Florida Board of Acupuncture rules provide that “traditional Chinese medical concepts and modern oriental medical techniques shall include . . . electrodermal screening.”
There is also the problem posed by an amorphous standard of care when a patient sues the CAM practitioner for malpractice. As Bob Baratz, M.D., D.D.S., pointed out in a recent discussion of CAM practitioner licensing acts:
One only has to go as far as the basic textbooks of naturopathy to see that these are not centered on a theme of method, so much as they are a collection of a hodge-podge of “treatments” without following the basics of medical care. At a minimum these should be: defining the condition with a set of criteria which any practitioner could see and evaluate, defining the condition being treated with knowledge of the natural history of this condition/disease/malady when untreated, and then confirming a diagnosis with physical examination and confirmatory tests, followed by a treatment plan which could then be objectively assessed with objective criteria of success or failure of the treatment.
This is equally true of subluxation-based chiropractic, acupuncture and homeopathy. And this lack of a systematic approach presents a problem: an incoherent system necessarily creates an incoherent standard of care. If each naturopathic treatment is “individualized,” how can there be a standard of care applicable to all patients? How could a chiropractor possibly fall below the standard of care for detection of subluxations when there are no reliable parameters for diagnosing a subluxation? And how would one ever determine whether “qi” is successfully unblocked when there is no “qi” in the first place?
Conclusion: A single standard of care excludes unscientific practitioners
An Institute for Science in Medicine policy statement, “State Licensing and Regulation of CAM Practitioners,” succinctly summarizes many of the points I’ve made in this post and correctly concludes:
The world’s health care systems need to be rooted in a single, science-based standard of care for all practitioners. Effective, reliable care can only be delivered by qualified professionals who practice within a consistent framework of scientific knowledge and standards. Practitioners whose diagnoses, diagnostic methods, and therapies have no plausible basis in the scientific model of medicine should not be licensed by any government, nor should they be allowed to practice under any other regulatory scheme. Any statute permitting such practices should be amended or repealed as necessary to achieve this policy. Unscientific practices in health care should further be targets of aggressive prosecution by regulatory authorities.

A right to science
Unless forced to do so, the state and federal governments will continue to base law and policy on bad science. Maybe it’s time for a constitutional amendment guaranteeing a “right to science.”
Jann Bellamy on October 11, 2018
Link

Our society will benefit from using the best available science for governmental regulation and policy.
John P.A. Ioannidis, “All science should inform policy and regulation.”
Undeniably true. Unfortunately, there is no legal mechanism for requiring all governmental regulation and policy to use the best available science. Dr. Ioannidis was lamenting a proposed EPA regulation limiting the types of research it will consider in making policy, a move that he says will “practically eliminate” science from the decision-making process, leaving regulation to “depend uniquely on opinion and whim”. Pretty much the entire scientific community, as well as some industries the EPA regulates, join him in his concern.
Here at SBM, we are all too familiar with opinion and whim beating out science in legislation and regulations. In addition to the Legislative Alchemy that turns pseudoscience into legalized health care practices, a topic I’ve covered many times, examples of this regrettable lack of a scientific basis for government action abounds. Some examples we’ve covered on SBM:
    • State “Right to Try” laws, allowing patient access to drugs that have not passed all safety and efficacy testing required for FDA-approval, based on the dubious notion that there is a plethora of life-saving drugs being suppressed by an unwieldy and unyielding government bureaucracy.
    • State laws protecting so-called “Lyme literate” physicians from discipline for substandard practice, forcing insurers to pay for discredited treatments for “chronic Lyme,” and requiring burdensome and misleading disclosures be given to patients about Lyme disease.
    • The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, passed based on absurd claims from alternative medicine proponents about the health benefits of herbs and vitamins.
    • Federal law requiring Medicare coverage for the detection and correction of non-existent chiropractic “subluxations.”
    • State laws permitting non-medical vaccination exemptions.
    • Veterans’ Health Administration policy adopting quackery like reflexology and reiki in the treatment of veterans.
    • State laws promoting auricular acupuncture for substance abuse treatment.
    • GMO regulation and labelling.
And some that we haven’t:
    • A Department of Justice guideline for interviewing crime victims with communication or cognitive disabilities recommending the thoroughly-debunked technique of facilitated communication as valid.
    • The Delaney Clause of the FD&C Act, which says the FDA cannot approve the use of any food additive that has been found to induce cancer in humans or animals at any dose, even if the FDA determines the additive does not pose a risk to public health as normally used.
It is especially appalling that the government, on the one hand, uses taxpayer monies to fund research on, for example, cancer treatments and climate change, then deprives those same taxpayers of the fruits of that research through legislation like the new federal “Right to Try” law and administrative actions like removing climate change information from government websites.
All of this raises the question in my mind: Should there be a way to prevent “opinion and whim”, or even just bad science, in government policy where the best available science counsels otherwise? If so, what form should it take? To afford the most protection, do we need a “right to science”, established in the U.S. Constitution, like due process, freedom of speech, and the right to peaceably assemble? What would that look like? And how would it work?
In fact, a “human right to science” was established in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948 and the right to enjoy the benefits of scientific progress was incorporated in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in 1966. (Unfortunately the article is behind a paywall.) The right, which has not received wide attention and has not been fully explicated, does not specifically include the aspiration that all laws and other forms of government regulation be science-based. In 2012, a report to the UN on the meaning and application of the right did identify as a “core component”:
access by everyone, without discrimination, to the benefits of science and its applications, including scientific knowledge.
“Best available science”
The idea of a constitutional right to science appeals to me because the need certainly exists and I cannot come up with any good reason why legislation enacted by Congress and the states, as well as agency rules, affecting our health, safety and welfare shouldn’t be based on the best available science. Perhaps you can. I also cannot find a single mention of any such proposal in the legal literature, but maybe other lawyers don’t spend as much time as I do contemplating the ill effects of pseudoscience on the nation’s welfare.
However, it is the exact wording that I find problematic. I could not locate an exemplar in the Constitution expressing a remotely similar prohibition, but let’s give it a try anyway:
Neither Congress nor any State shall make or enforce any law unless it is based on the best available science.
(Legally, this would necessarily include agency regulations as well.)
Of course, one might well ask: What does “best available science” mean? To Dr. Ioannidis, in using science as a basis for making policy decisions,
it is essential to examine evidence in its totality, recognize its relative strengths and weaknesses, and make the best judgment based on what is available.
It is worth noting that we’ve worked out the definition of more ambiguous words than “best available science” in our Constitution: due process of law, establishment of religion, freedom of speech, unreasonable searches and seizures, probable cause, equal protection of the laws, and impartial jury, among others.
I’ll leave it there, with no pride of authorship and the conviction that better minds could draft a Constitutional amendment if the political will is there, an issue we’ll return to in a moment.
Wording and politics aside, the government’s experience in actually applying a scientific standard gives me confidence that the competent execution of a right to science is possible. Scientific standards do exist in current statutes and agency rules and are regularly enforced. And the courts, the ultimate arbiters of the constitutionality of legislation and regulations, are experienced in deciding questions of scientific validity (however imperfectly).
For example, the Federal Trade Commission requires the best available science, in the form of “ competent and reliable scientific evidence“, to support health claims in advertising and regularly brings enforcement actions against companies that do not comply. As the agency said in warning letters to marketers of weight loss products:
It is unlawful to advertise that a product causes weight loss unless you possess well-controlled human clinical studies of the product, or a substantially similar product, substantiating that the claims are true. Such studies must be randomized, double-blind, and placebo-controlled, and conducted by researchers who are qualified by training and experience to conduct such studies.
As well, the courts are frequently called upon to assess scientific evidence, as they would be in any challenge to a statute or regulation brought pursuant to our putative Constitutional amendment. First, the Federal Rules of Evidence and case law require that expert testimony on matters of science meet certain reliability requirements. In the Daubert case, the Supreme Court
set forth a non-exclusive checklist for trial courts to use in assessing the reliability of scientific expert testimony. The specific factors explicated by the Daubert Court are (1) whether the expert’s technique or theory can be or has been tested—that is, whether the expert’s theory can be challenged in some objective sense, or whether it is instead simply a subjective, conclusory approach that cannot reasonably be assessed for reliability; (2) whether the technique or theory has been subject to peer review and publication; (3) the known or potential rate of error of the technique or theory when applied; (4) the existence and maintenance of standards and controls; and (5) whether the technique or theory has been generally accepted in the scientific community.
Second, in cases challenging the teaching of unscientific “theories” like creationism as violative of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, courts have been required to demarcate science from pseudoscience. For example, in Kitzmiller v. Dover, which challenged the teaching of “intelligent design” in public school science classes, a federal district judge, after hearing extensive testimony from both sides, ruled that intelligent design
is not science and cannot be adjudged a valid, accepted scientific theory as it has failed to publish in peer-reviewed journals, engage in research and testing, and gain acceptance in the scientific community.
But, politics
While we should be able to draft a reasonable scientific standard against which legislation and regulations should be measured, and while we may already have the legal infrastructure in place to interpret and enforce that standard, it’s very hard to amend the U.S. Constitution. (If you want the details, you can read about it here.) Remember, we haven’t been able to add an amendment guaranteeing the equal rights of women, a proposition that doesn’t seem like it should be all that controversial, but is. (There is no time limit on ratifying an amendment, by the way.) Maybe good science would be an easier sell than my equal rights under the law is now or my right to vote was in the last century. (Ironically, opposition to the latter was in part based on bad science.) However difficult the battle might be, I think a constitutionally-protected right to science is well worth considering.

Bring on the Evidence: A new regulatory approach to CAM
Complementary and alternative medicine is popular, but it’s poorly regulated, and most products lack good evidence of efficacy. A new approach proposed in Australia may help consumers make more informed, science-based health decisions.
Scott Gavura on February 23, 2017
Link

A recurring topic at this blog is the regulation of “dietary supplements” and other forms of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). CAM is not medicine, but may be used alongside, or instead of conventional medicine. And despite the “mom and pop” image that some firms project, CAM is a huge industry. In fact most Americans today take some sort of dietary supplement. This is despite that fact there’s little evidence to demonstrate the vast majority of CAM offers any meaningful or proven health benefits. So how are these products allowed for sale? The answer lies with the regulator. In most countries, CAM is the “Wild West” of health care, where a deliberate double-standard has been created for anything considered to be a dietary supplement or natural health product. Now that double-standard may be changing. In the past few months, there has been encouraging signs in both the United States and Canada that pro-consumer changes may be coming, one that helps CAM purchasers make more informed health decisions. Now Australia has announced a new framework that will create a new licensing category for CAM: products that are supported by good evidence.
A regulatory double-standard for CAM
Regulators must balance different responsibilities when determining the commercial “rules” for the sales of CAM and other health products. In general, governments around the world have tended to tilt the rules towards a company’s desire to sell CAM, rather than to a consumer’s right to access products that are proven to be safe and effective. That is, manufacturers of CAM face relatively light regulation (compared with drug products), with the expectation that consumers will make their own self-care decisions effectively. Different countries take slightly different approaches, with generally the same intent. There’s no question that this “light hand” has led to a boom for the vendors of CAM. Supplements used to be a niche product in pharmacies– now they’re found in almost every store, sometimes with more than one aisle dedicated to herbal remedies, vitamins and products that make me think that patent medicines are back. Even homeopathy, which is an elaborate placebo system masquerading as medicine, is routinely stocked alongside real medicine in many pharmacies in Canada and the United States.
There are numerous problems with lax regulatory standards for CAM. Consumers may not be able to distinguish between products that are approved based on scientific standards, and those that are based on prescientific ideas of medicine. As Steven Novella noted in a recent post,
If we look at the big picture, society is being harmed by increasing acceptance of loose scientific standards in health care specifically designed to allow for dubious products and practices. The consumer is being harmed by this, and each piece of lax regulation contributes to the overall phenomenon. This phenomenon includes convincing the public (and even many scientists and practitioners) that placebo effects alone justify a treatment, that anecdotes are useful, that unblinded studies can determine efficacy, and that certain special magical kinds of treatments cannot be tested by standard scientific methods. The alternative medicine phenomenon is playing off of and contributing to public scientific illiteracy. There is therefore also societal harm, which further includes wasting tremendous resources researching, regulating, and purchasing treatments that cannot possibly work.
What principles for CAM are important?
Before examining the regulatory frameworks for CAM, it’s worth considering some key ethical principles of commercial markets, including the market for health care products. In a paper that Professor Chris MacDonald and myself published in the peer-reviewed journal Bioethics, “Alternative Medicine and the Ethics of Commerce“, we acknowledged two important principles that provide support for the sale of CAM:
Respect for individual (consumer) autonomy: It is morally good to respect the choices that people make in marketplaces, and it is generally better to avoid paternalism. More choices in the “marketplace” for health mean more unique needs can be met. If consumers prefer CAM, then it is good that these products be available to purchase.
The respect for a competitive marketplace: Markets tend to work effectively when there are lots of choices from many vendors. Competition keeps prices low and keeps firms competitive. Restricting CAM restricts markets. By definition, these products are alternatives to medicine and in particular, often considered to be legitimate substitutes for products and services considered “conventional” medicine.
In that paper, we proposed the following commercial framework:
Participants in commerce should endeavor to:
     1.  Offer a product that works – a product that is, in the language of commercial law, ‘merchantable.’
     2.  Only sell products to people who understand their fundamental characteristics, and who are reasonably capable of understanding (either on their own or with suitable professional help) whether that product will meet their needs. This implies a general demand for honesty on the part of sellers, and a refusal to profit from the ignorance of consumers.
     3.  Take reasonable steps to ensure that third parties (those who do not consent to participate in a particular market exchange) are not harmed.
It’s worth pointing out that these principles not only benefit consumers and health professionals, but can benefit manufacturers as well. CAM manufacturers that make high-quality products that are backed by good evidence must currently fight to stand out among products with exaggerated claims and unclear product quality and safety. Looking at a bottle on the shelf, it’s not easy for consumers (or health professionals) to determine if that product is safe, or if it even contains what it says on the label. A marketplace that allows consumers to easily identify high-quality CAM products from those that are more dubious offers a potential advantage to those products and could potentially help to improve the overall quality of the CAM marketplace. That’s the approach that regulators seem to be taking with recently proposed changes.
Positive signals in Canada and the USA
A few months ago I wrote about potential changes to the regulatory system in Canada. Health Canada, which is Canada’s drugs (and natural health products) regulator, noted that the level of evidence required to make a similar effectiveness claim was much higher for a drug that for a “natural” product, where non-scientific evidence is currently acceptable. Health Canada is now proposing to regulate products with similar risk profiles in the same way, regardless of whether they’re “natural” or not. Effectiveness claims will need to be backed by scientific evidence – not anecdote and “long history of use” claims. Health Canada’s consultation on the new framework ended in October, and we’ll see what the final framework looks like.
There has also been encouraging signals from the FTC in the United States regarding homeopathy. Following a review by the FDA and FTC of the regulation of homeopathic remedies, the FTC announced it would require the same standard of evidence as is required for conventional drug products. In short, homeopathic manufacturers must provide scientific evidence to substantiate health-related claims. We’re still waiting to see what the FDA’s position on homeopathy may be.
Australia moves to strengthen regulation
The Government of Australia has now announced a consultation on a number of reforms that are proposed to enhance the regulation of CAM through the creation of a new category of products:
Australia currently has a two-tiered system, which is fairly similar to Canada and the United States, where medicines are subject to strict regulations, including the pre-testing requirements and the submission and review of clinical evidence for any health claims. CAM is considered low-risk and subject to few regulatory requirements. There is no pre-marketing review by the regulator at all for CAM.
The consultation proposes a new, middle tier. Sitting between drugs and the current CAM category, this tier is intended for CAM that is backed by good scientific evidence. Manufacturers wishing to sell products in this tier will be required to submit evidence of efficacy, just as occurs with drug products. Products approved under this framework will be flagged with specific statements and potentially even a visual symbol (e.g., a green check) to distinguish these products from other CAM.
Under the new proposal, the low-risk category will remain, but with more controls and limits on any form of claims of effectiveness. CAM in this category will not be able to make that claim that products have been assessed by the regulator for efficacy.
The regulator is also proposing market exclusivity changes for companies that develop and test new products, in an effort to develop the evidence-based for CAM products. This will support more research and development into CAM, and may encourage more clinical trials.
Science-based changes ahead?
While science-based CAM manufacturers may welcome these changes, others will likely lobby hard to maintain the status quo. If implemented, Australia’s approach may not only improve the marketplace for health professionals and consumers, it has the potential to promote more appropriate, science-based use of these products. I’d encourage anyone interested in promoting rational CAM regulation to review the consultation document and consider commenting before the March 28 deadline.

The Cure
Jann Bellamy on October 20, 2011
Link
Legislative Alchemy
In Legislative Alchemy I: Naturopathy, II: Chiropractic and III: Acupuncture, we learned how state legislatures transform scientifically implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments into legal health care practices. Examples typical of the sheer nonsense found in both proposed and actual legislation include:
Naturopathic health care [is] a system of health care practices for the prevention, diagnosis, evaluation and treatment of illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body through the use of education, nutrition, natural medicines and therapies and other modalities which are designed to support, stimulate or supplement the human body’s own natural self-healing processes.
[Chiropractic is] the science of adjustment, manipulation and treatment of the human body in which vertebral subluxations and other malpositioned articulations and structures that may interfere with the normal generation, transmission and expression of nerve impulse between the brain, organs and tissue cells of the body, which may be a cause of the disease, are adjusted, manipulated or treated.
[Acupuncture is] a form of health care that is based on a theory of energetic physiology that describes and explains the interrelationship of bodily organs or functions with an associated acupuncture point or combination of points that are stimulated in order to restore the normal function of the bodily organ or function.
This is gobbledygook, tarted up with a few scientific-sounding terms — “physiology,” “tissue cells,” “diagnosis.”
We know in fact that:
    • Naturopathy’s basic premise is simply a restatement of long-discredited vitalism.
    • The chiropractic “vertebral subluxation” does not exist, so it can’t “interfere” with anything,nor can it be “adjusted.”
    • There is no “energetic physiology,” theoretical or otherwise.
The legalization of nonsense as health care has a deleterious effect on the public. Each year, millions in the U.S. visit state-licensed naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists, exposing themselves to diagnoses of conditions that do not exist and treatments for these non-existent conditions, as well as treatment of real diseases with implausible and ineffective therapies. They will spend millions of dollars on these visits, paying with either their money or yours.
Although it is reasonable to assume that correct diagnosis of a real disease or condition will be at times foregone and effective treatment delayed in these visits, we don’t really know the full extent because no one appears to be looking at this issue in a systematic way, although we do have anecdotal reports. As well, it is reasonable to assume that these unnecessary treatments for imagined conditions will be injurious in and of themselves in some cases. Again, all we have are anecdotal reports, as no one is collecting the data in any systematic way.
Which brings us to . . .
The Cure
One possible solution is that states stop further licensing of “CAM” providers. Although I have not researched the issue, I do know of one instance in which this occurred. In 1959, the Florida legislature abolished the licensing authority for naturopaths, although anyone who had a license at that time was allowed to continue practicing. Anyone else holding himself out as a naturopath in Florida can be prosecuted for the unlicensed practice of a health care profession. Attempts to re-established naturopathy licensing in Florida have failed.
As you can well imagine, it would be a long, contentious, expensive and laborious process to halt the licensing of chiropractors in all 50 states, acupuncturists in 43 states and naturopaths in the 16 states where they are currently licensed.
A second, simpler solution presents itself in the form of curtailing the use of implausible and unproven practices via legislation without directly repealing the “CAM” provider practice acts. The basic premise is that scientifically plausible health care practices can be used unless and until they are shown not to work. Implausible practices, however, must meet a higher standard. In other words, it is in essence “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” fashioned into health care consumer protection law.
Before looking at how this might be achieved, let’s begin with proposed legislative findings. These are typically recited at the beginning of a bill and become part of the bill’s legislative history. In turn, should a court need to interpret particular language in the bill once it is enacted into law, the legislative history can be used in determining what the legislature meant, referred to as “legislative intent.”
We will call our proposed state legislation
The Science-Based Healthcare Practices Act
Legislative Findings:
Whereas, the Legislature finds that those healthcare practices not based on generally accepted scientific principles and those healthcare practices which have been proven ineffective:
cause unnecessary expenditure of time and money by the public for ineffective treatments; and
expose the public to the risk of delay of appropriate and timely diagnosis and treatment; and
violate nationally and internationally accepted ethical norms; and
pose an unnecessary risk to the public health by exposing the public to treatments that carry risk of harm without a sufficient benefit to justify that risk.
Whereas, the Legislature finds that healthcare practices not based on generally accepted scientific principles misrepresent the sciences of biology, physiology, anatomy, physics and chemistry to the public, which undermines the legitimate public interest in a scientifically literate citizenry.
Therefore, the Legislature finds that it is in the best interest of the public health, safety and welfare to protect the public from healthcare practices which are not based on generally accepted scientific principles or have proven ineffective.
“Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”
The proposed statute would read, in part, as follows:
Sec. XXX.xxx, (Your State’s Name Here) Statutes
(1) Notwithstanding any other provision of (Your State) law, no healthcare practitioner licensed by this state shall engage in the diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription for any human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or other physical or mental condition if such diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription is implausible because its implied mechanisms or putative effects contradict well-established laws, principles, or empirical findings in chemistry, biology, anatomy or physiology, and it is either
(i) not supported, to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, by good quality randomized, placebo-controlled trials, or
(ii) not supported, to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, by a Cochrane Collaboration Systematic Review or a systematic review or meta-analysis of like quality.
The standard “is implausible because its implied mechanisms or putative effects contradict well-established laws, principles, or empirical findings in chemistry, biology, anatomy or physiology” was taken from “Illinois Department of Professional Regulation Medical Disciplinary Board (MDB). Board Policy Statement: Complementary and Alternative Therapies. November 1999,” quoted in an SBM post by Dr. Kimball Atwood. While the Illinois Department of Professional Regulation’s policy was, as a whole, disappointing, its definition of “implausible” is useful.
The level of evidence required in for implausible practices is based on R. Barker Bausell, Snake Oil Science: The Truth About Complementary and Alternative Medicine (New York: Oxford University Press 2007), Chapter 11 (“What High-Quality Trails Reveal About CAM”) and Chapter 12 (“What High Quality Systematic Reviews Reveal About CAM”).
Why, you may ask, if a practice is implausible, would we allow it at all? Why the provision regarding studies?
This is a perfectly reasonable criticism and if you wish to go ahead with the process of eliminating such practices altogether from state law, please do. I simply offer this as a solution which might be politically achievable, as the proposed legislation does not actually do away with any “CAM” provider type.
In opposition to this legislation, “CAM” providers would be put in the position of arguing that their diagnostic methods and practices are not implausible, which is fairly easily defeated per the legislation’s definition. Alternatively, they would have to argue that, even if implausible, their diagnostic methods and therapies should be permitted anyway. This is, of course, what is already happening — they are used despite implausibility and lack of evidence,a position “CAM” providers currently need not defend once they achieve licensed health care provider status.
I also agree that it is not a good idea to spend considerable resources testing biologically implausible claims and this post is not an argument that even more resources should be expended doing so. But, while the U.S. government is at it, we might as well put the results to some good use.
The proposed legislation’s “out” based on high-quality trials also helps avoid a claim of direct conflict between the “CAM” practice acts and the new law, a conflict that would invariably wind up in the courts. For example, the proposed law does not prevent a chiropractor from claiming he can detect “subluxations” in a patient and proceeding to “adjust” them for the purpose of, say, treating the patient’s asthma. But because detection and adjustment of subluxations in general and its effectiveness in treating asthma in particular are highly implausible, a chiropractor will need an high level of evidence to legally make this claim. That evidence does not currently exist — and let me just go out on a limb here and predict it never will.
Likewise, an acupuncturist is not prevented from recommending acupuncture to treat infertility but, again, because of the implausibility of the proposed underlying mechanism of acupuncture and its putative effect on infertility, he must meet a high level of evidence to make that recommendation and commence treatment. Again, the evidence isn’t there and, again, I’ll predict it won’t be in the future.
Ordinary claims require ordinary evidence
But, what about those diagnostic methods and therapies, like chelation, which, at least initially, seemed plausible, but, even though disproved, continue in use?
For them, we have this:
(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of (Your State) law, no health care practitioner licensed by this state, shall engage in the diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription for any human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or other physical or mental condition even if such diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription is plausible because its implied mechanisms or putative effects are in accordance with well-established laws, principles, or empirical findings in chemistry, biology, anatomy or physiology, if
(i) good quality randomized, placebo-controlled trials, or
(ii) a Cochrane Collaboration Systematic Review or a systematic review or meta-analysis of like quality,
demonstrate, within a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, that said diagnosis, treatment, operation or prescription is not effective for said human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or other physical or mental condition.
The Science-Based Healthcare Practices Act would not eliminate all implausible and unproven healthcare. For example, a diagnostic method like thermography for breast cancer detection might slip by the implausibility test and remain on the market, not because it’s a reliable diagnostic tool, but because no trial meeting our statutory standard says it isn’t reliable.
And just to be sure
I propose a few other provisions to avoid attempted end-runs around the legislation’s purpose.
To help forestall any fudging on the science, the following would be included:
“Each term in this section shall be interpreted according to its generally accepted meaningin the scientific community.”
To make clear that “subluxations,” “qi,” vitalism and the like do not get a pass on science simply by virtue of their inclusion in the practice acts:
“It shall not be a defense to prosecution for a violation of this section that a diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription is within the scope of practice, as defined in Chapter X, (Your State) Statutes, of a healthcare practitioner accused of said violation.”
And, to help ensure that poor quality trials cannot be used to buoy scientifically implausible health care practices (with thanks again to R. Barker Bausell, Ph.D.),
“Good quality, randomized placebo controlled trial,” shall mean a trial meeting the following minimum criteria:
(i) involving the random assignment of participants to a credible placebo control group; and
(ii) employing at least fifty participants per group; and
(iii) losing no more than 25 per cent of its participants over the course of the study; and
(iv) published in a high-impact, peer-reviewed research journal.”
Enforcement
Now that we’ve created a prohibition against implausible practices without really good evidence that they actually work, as well as plausible ones that don’t work, how to enforce it?
That authority could be given to the various boards which currently oversee health care practitioners but this seems inconsistent with the purpose of the act. If the legislature is trying to erect a barrier of scientific evidence (both basic and clinical) between the practitioner who employs implausible diagnostic methods and therapies and the patient, then the very practitioners who ignore science would not seem best suited to the task.
The medicine and osteopathic boards might be suitable to enforce our proposed legislation as against M.D.s and D.O.s, but even medical boards have proven reluctant to discipline physicians whose practice includes implausible and unproven therapies. In fairness, perhaps they were hamstrung by lack of statutory firepower sufficient to specifically address implausible, unproven and disproven practices.
One solution is to give enforcement authority to the state agency overseeing the unlicensed practice of a health care profession. This agency would already have the investigational and prosecutorial bureaucracy in place to proceed. Here, our proposed statute adopts its enforcement procedures from Florida’s “Unlicensed practice of a health care profession” statute, which gives the Department of Health (DOH) the authority to investigate and prosecute.
Briefly, if the DOH has probable cause to believe the Science-Based Healthcare Practices Act has been violated, it can issue a cease and desist order and impose a civil penalty. If the violator is recalcitrant, DOH can go to court seeking an injunction and the consequences escalate from there. Of course, the alleged violator can dispute the charges and have his day in court.
Conclusion
The Science-Based Healthcare Practices Act is an imperfect solution to the problem of legislative alchemy. It is preferable to avoid licensing practitioners whose tenets violate basic science. Given the impracticability of repealing over 100 separate state practice acts, imposing an evidence requirement for implausible practices offers — if I may — an alternative solution. The Act would also have the beneficial effect of curtailing the use of diagnostic methods and therapies which, although not implausible, have proven ineffective.
Suggestions for improvement are welcome.

   CAM and the Law, Part 1: Introduction to the issues
Brennen McKenzie
Link
When I write or talk about the scientific evidence against particular alternative medical approaches, I am frequently asked the question, “So, if it doesn’t work, why is it legal?” Believers in CAM ask this to show that there must be something to what they are promoting or, presumably, the government wouldn’t let them sell it. And skeptics raise the question often out of sheer incredulity that anyone would be allowed to make money selling a medical therapy that doesn’t work. It turns out that the answer to this question is a complex, multilayered story involving science, history, politics, religion, and culture. 
While we science types tend to be primarily interested in what is true and what isn’t, that is a sometimes surprisingly minor factor in the process of constructing laws and regulations concerning medicine. What I hope to do in this series of essays is look at some of the major themes involved in the regulation of medical practice, particularly as they relate to alternative medicine. I will begin by touching on some of the general philosophical and legal issues that have defined the debate among the politicians and lawyers responsible for shaping the legal environment in which medicine is practiced. The I will review some of the specific domains within this environment, including: medical licensure and scope-of-practice laws; malpractice law; FDA regulation of drugs, homeopathic remedies, and dietary supplements; truth-in-advertising law; and anti-trust law.
But first…
The Disclaimer
Obviously, an exhaustive and comprehensive look at the Byzantine and unstable landscape of medical law is beyond the scope of both this blog and my own knowledge and expertise. I am no lawyer, and for the details of the laws and judicial opinions concerning this subject I must rely on sources whose accuracy I am not qualified to verify independently. Much of the published material I have found on CAM and the law seems written from a political and ideological perspective sympathetic to the postmodernist notion of multiple equally legitimate “ways of knowing,” and also to a laissez-faire approach to regulation generally. So clearly the details provided and the interpretations given in such writings may not fairly represent the legal or regulatory environment. In any case, while I hope to provide some useful insight into how CAM fits into the system of medical law and regulation in the United States, nothing I say should be taken as the definitive word on the law or as legal advice. 
Caveat Emptor v. Caveat Venditor
There is a deep ideological divide in America on the subject of who is responsible for ensuring that the products we buy are safe and perform as advertised, and the area of medicine is not exempt from this political debate. On one extreme is the self-identified “health freedom” lobby, which argues that the consumer and the market should be the only forces to regulate healthcare products and services. As an example, economist Randall Holcombe has written:
An auto mechanic does not have to be a medical expert to use market information to find good health care, any more than a doctor has to be an automobile expert to find a good car…Deregulation not only provides incentives for patients to look for, and physicians to offer, better care, it permits all parties concerned the freedom to decide what better care is. For instance, in the debate over alternative medicine, such as herbal treatments, chiropractors, acupuncture, and so on, the question is not only whether alternative medicine is effective, but whether people should be allowed to use these alternatives even if their physical health may not improve or may even suffer….In a free country, people should be free to choose whatever health care options they want for whatever purpose…even if healthcare professionals believe that care is substandard.1
Those more sympathetic to laws and regulations intended to protect consumers from unsafe and ineffective therapies argue against this concept of “medical anarchism:”
Why not let the market decide? Why not trust the citizenry to sort out what works from what doesn’t work in medicine as we do in other aspects of life?
The answer has to do with knowledge and risk. People do let the market decide with regard to goods like ice cream cones and baseball bats, and services like travel booking. If the ice cream is not good, people won’t buy it; if the service is defective, people will go elsewhere. However, in such situations, people are easily able to evaluate the quality and value of the goods and services they receive…Nor are such services administered under duress, nor are they represented as necessary for one’s health or well-being…
But in the area of medicine, too much is at stake. If one chooses the wrong therapeutic modality, once can lose health, life, and limb. Furthermore, few individuals are sufficiently wealthy, educated, or possessed of the resources to test putative medical therapies. In fact, there are so many putative therapies, that it is impossible for an individual to try them all. When people are ill, they do not have time to test even a handful.2
These arguments tend to run in parallel, and to be only tenuously connected, with the usual focus of this blog; the question of how one evaluates medical therapies and what the evaluation indicates about safety and efficacy. Of course, many proponents of CAM who invoke the “health freedom” position do actually believe the therapies they promote are beneficial. But the fundamental position itself does not hinge on this, since from a perspective such as Dr. Holcombe’s people should be free to choose even therapies that are ineffective or harmful without “burdensome” government regulatory interference. The self-evident notion that it is the role of government to protect the public from quackery turns out not to be self-evident to many Americans, and thus demonstrating that a given approach is quackery may not be sufficient to convince them that it should be prohibited or even officially discouraged. 
The Right to Privacy v. State Police Powers
In the legal arena, the political conflict between those favoring or opposing aggressive consumer protection regulations in the area of healthcare takes the form of statutes and judicial opinions balancing the competing constitutional principles of an individual right to privacy and a governmental authority, or even mandate, to protect the public health. Neither a right to privacy or absolute authority over one’s own body nor a government role in regulating healthcare are specifically mentioned in the U.S. Constitution, but both are held to exist by long-standing interpretation. A right to privacy, including control over one’s own body and the care of it, is generally believed to be established by a broad reading of the 14th Amendment, though there is some controversy about this as about most areas of constitutional law. The authority of the state to abrogate this right in the process of protecting the public health is usually understood to be based in the “police powers” established by the 10th Amendment.
In 1824, the Supreme Court made reference to “health laws of every description” as encompassed within the “state police powers,” those powers not specifically delegated to the federal government nor prohibited to the States which are thus held, under the Tenth Amendment, to be the prerogative of the individual states.3 The court cited and expanded this opinion in a subsequent case in 1905, in which a state mandate to protect the public health was held to override, at least in some circumstances, the individual right to control one’s own body. The case involved a man prosecuted for refusing a mandatory smallpox vaccination. The opinion stated:
The authority of the state to enact this statute is to be referred to what is commonly called the police power…this court …distinctly recognized the authority of a state to enact quarantine laws and “health laws of every description…”
The defendant insists that his liberty is invaded when the state subjects him to fine or imprisonment for neglecting or refusing to submit to vaccination…and that the execution of such a law…is nothing short of an assault upon his person. But the liberty secured by the Constitution of the United States…does not import an absolute right in each person to be, at all times and in all circumstances, wholly freed from restraint. There are manifold restraints to which every person is necessarily subject for the common good.4
The court went on to specifically balance the “liberty secured by the 14th Amendment,” including “the control of one’s body” against “the power of the public to guard itself against imminent danger” and concluded that under at least some circumstances the authority to protect the public health trumps he right of an individual to control his or her own body. 
This precedent was further developed and expanded in subsequent cases to validate the state’s authority to define and regulate medical practices, to control what practices could be offered and by whom via licensing and scope-of-practice laws, and to prohibit individual’s from choosing specific medical treatments if these were considered to be ineffective or dangerous. I will discuss the specifics of these cases in subsequent posts. But for now I simply want to illustrate that the legal basis for the regulations of medical practice which today pertain to CAM, as well as scientific medicine, is generally seen by the courts as a balance between the individual right to privacy and the state authority to protect public health.1,5
Just the Facts, Ma’am?*
I feel it is important to emphasize again that the question of the medical facts in such cases, and how these are established, are not always seen by the courts to be as relevant as the legal or political issues. For example, in Jacobson v. Massachusetts the court specifically addressed the factual claims by the defendant that the vaccine was ineffective and unsafe. The court’s reasoning will seem familiar, and disturbing, to those of us dealing with the anti-vaccination movement today:
The appellant claims that vaccination does not tend to prevent smallpox, but tends to bring about other diseases, and that it does much harm, with no good. It must be conceded that some laymen, both learned and unlearned, and some physicians of great skill and repute, do not believe that vaccination is a preventative of smallpox. The common belief, however, is that it has a decided tendency to prevent the spread of this fearful disease…While not accepted by all, it is accepted by the mass of the people, as well as by most members of the medical profession…A common belief, like common knowledge, does not require evidence to establish its existence, but may be acted upon without proof by the legislature and the courts…The fact that the belief may be wrong, and that science may yet show it to be wrong, is not conclusive; for the legislature has the right to pass laws which, according to the common belief of the people, are adapted to prevent the spread of contagious diseases. In a free country, where the government is by the people, through their chosen representatives, practical legislation admits of no other standard of action, for what the people believe is for the common welfare must be accepted as tending to promote the common welfare, whether it does in fact or not. Any other basis would conflict with the spirit of the Constitution, and would sanction measures opposed to a Republican form of government.4
While the decision in this case, to support the authority of the state to enforce mandatory vaccination as a public health measure, might be welcomed by supporters of science-based public health policy, the decision itself was by no means based in science or scientific reasoning. 
The laws and judicial opinions which govern the practice of medicine may sometimes support and sometimes oppose legitimate, science and evidence-based medicine. But the legislators, lawyers, and judges responsible for these laws and opinions are not scientists, and their reasoning about scientific and medical issues often has a philosophical and epistemological basis often incompatible with the scientific approach. Such policy mistakes as DSHEA and NCCAM are much easier to understand, and hopefully prevent, if we clearly understand this.
If we are to be effective at promoting scientific medicine and containing unscientific approaches and ineffective or unsafe therapies, we must be aware of the limitations of scientific and fact-based arguments in persuading legislators and judges, as well as the general public. Though science and facts derived from scientific knowledge and investigation must be the foundation of our medical approach, they are not always the most effective means of making the case for this approach, even with our colleagues much less with the citizens, politicians, and legal professionals who ultimately control what sort of influence and oversight government has on medicine. Non-scientists tend to view debates about regulation of CAM in terms of individual rights, consumer protection, truth-in-advertising, fair competition in the marketplace, and other such political and philosophical frames which are as important, or even more important, to them as the issue of what is factually true about CAM and whether particular therapies help or harm. 
In this series of essays, I will look at laws and regulations concerning CAM primarily from these perspectives. The kinds of questions that arise in this process may initially seem odd to those of us accustomed to a straightforward emphasis on the relevant facts and evidence. Are doctors allowed to offer unproven or even clearly bogus therapies? Are they required to offer them if a patient wants them? Can a mainstream doctor, be sued for providing or failing to provide an alternative therapy? Can an alternative practitioner be sued for providing, or failing to provide, mainstream scientific medical care? Can and should patients have whatever care they want regardless of whether science supports it? And from my perspective as a veterinarian, since pets are legally property not persons, is there any legal or regulatory control over alternative veterinary medicine at all? Such questions and the reasoning behind asking and answering them, shapes the landscape within which we operate as healthcare providers and advocates for science-based medicine, so I hope an examination of them will be interesting and useful.
* Our friends at snopes.com tell me that Joe Friday never actually said this, but due to its cultural resonance I choose to invoke the phrase anyway. Oh, I hope all this exposure to legal argument and reasoning hasn’t damaged my respect for actual facts! Return to text.
References
     1.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 279. Return to text.
     2.  Ramey DW, Rollin BE. Untested therapies and medical anarchism. In: Complementary and alternative veterinary medicine considered. Ames (IA), USA: Iowa State Press, 2004. p.168-9. Return to text.
     3.  Gibbons v. Ogden, 22 U.S. 1, 78 (1824). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 26. Return to text.
     4.  Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 26-29. Return to text.
     5.  Cohen MH. Legal issues in alternative medicine: A guide for clinicians, hospitals, and patients. Victoria (BC), Canada: Trafford Publishing, 2003. Return to text.

   CAM and the Law Part 3: Malpractice
Brennen McKenzie 
Link
It is with some trepidation I venture into the next subject in this series — malpractice law. This is a touchy subject for healthcare providers, for obvious reasons. Regardless of the flaws in the system, however, malpractice law is one of the mechanisms put in place by government to regulate the practice of medicine. Like the other such mechanisms touched on so far, licensure and scope of practice law, malpractice laws apply to alternative medicine practices in ways that are broadly similar, but sometimes subtly and significantly different, from how they apply to scientific medicine. 
So far, alternative practitioners are sued for malpractice relatively infrequently compared with physicians, presumably because they represent a much smaller fraction of the care provided, they tend to be utilized by those with an ideological bias in favor of their approaches, and they are not viewed as nearly as rich a target for litigation. But this may change if the political and cultural winds blow in the direction of greater utilization of alternative medical approaches. 
General Principles of Malpractice Law
In order to establish a claim of medical malpractice, a plaintiff must show four basic elements.1
1. A duty was owed by the defendant to the plaintiff.
2. That duty was breached.
3. The breach was the proximate cause of an injury.
4. The injury involved actual damages.
It is in the interpretation of what constitutes a duty and the breach thereof and the establishing of causation that much of the opportunity for judicial interpretation lies. Such interpretation also comes into play when typical defenses against malpractice claims are invoked, such as theories of contributory negligence and assumption of risk. One of the most contentious issues with regard to malpractice cases involving alternative therapies is what constitutes an appropriate standard or care, which defines the duty and condition of breach.
Standard of Care
Traditionally, medical doctors accused of malpractice were judged according to the so-called “local rule,” in which a doctor was expected to adhere to the standards of other doctors in his or her geographic area. This has been largely supplanted by the “national rule,” in which physicians are judged by the standard or other physicians in the same specialty.1 However, what about chiropractor, acupuncturists, naturopaths, etc? What standard is used to judge their duty and quality of care? (It may seem in the subsequent discussion and examples that I am picking on chiropractors. This is just an artifact of the volume of legal opinions concerning this method, since chiropractors are the most widespread, legally recognized, and often sued of alternative medicine practitioners).
A key case looked to as a precedent in many states was Kerkman v. Hintz, argued before the Supreme Court of Wisconsin.2 In this case, a patient was seen by a chiropractor, diagnosed with a cervical subluxation, and treated with several chiropractic adjustments. His condition worsened, whereupon he was seen by a neurosurgeon who identified a ruptured intervertebral disk. After two surgeries for this, the patient had significant lingering disability. The patient sued the chiropractor for malpractice, arguing that the D.C. ought to have recognized that his problem was not suitable for chiropractic treatment and referred him for appropriate care.
The legal standard of care invoked by the plaintiff in this case was a 1923 ruling in which it was held that “in evaluating a patient’s condition prior to treatment, a chiropractor must exercise the same degree of care and skill which is usually exercised by a recognized school of the medical profession.”3 However, the state supreme court overruled this precedent, arguing that while chiropractors were not a separately licensed profession in 1923, and so could be viewed as just another “recognized school of medicine,” by 1988 the practice of chiropractic had been defined, limited, and specifically distinguished from the practice of medicine by state licensing statutes. Since these statutes limit chiropractors to “the analysis and correction of subluxation,” it is not appropriate to allow or require them to make medical judgments that go beyond this. The court did not seem perturbed at all by the issue of whether the “subluxation” was a real medical entity or a phantasm. It was only concerned about whether it was a recognized entity from the point of view of state law, which it is.
Based on this reasoning, the court established a new standard for chiropractic.
In summary, we hold that a chiropractor has a duty to (1) determine whether the patient presents a problem which is treatable through chiropractic means; (2) refrain from further chiropractic treatment when a reasonable chiropractor should be aware that the patient’s condition will not be responsive to further treatment; and (3) if the ailment presented is outside the scope of chiropractic care, inform the patient that the ailment is not treatable through chiropractic means. In determining whether a chiropractor breaches these duties, the chiropractor is held to that degree of care, diligence, judgment, and skill which is exercised by a reasonable chiropractor under like or similar circumstances.2
Moreover, the court specifically exempted chiropractors in Wisconsin from any duty to refer patients for care by a physician.
Having explained to the patient that the problem is not within the chiropractor’s license to treat, the chiropractor does not have a duty to refer the patient to a medical doctor…because implicit in a requirement that a chiropractor refer a patient to a medical doctor is the imposition on the chiropractor to make a medical determination that the patient needs medical care, such a determination could not be made without employing medical knowledge. Because a chiropractor is not licensed to make such a determination, we hold that a chiropractor does not have a duty to refer.2
From a science-based perspective, of course, this seems ludicrous. Chiropractors are specifically licensed to treat an imaginary cause of diseases, and they are given the sole authority to decide as a community which illnesses will or will not respond to treatment of this faux etiology. They are expected to tell patients when their treatment is not going to work, but they aren’t expected to recognize if these same patients have a condition for which they should be seen by a medical doctor, because making that judgment would require them to know something about real medicine, which they are legally prohibited from doing. 
Kerkman v. Hintz is a widely cited ruling that has had a significant impact on the assessment of standard of care for alternative medicine practitioners, but not all states follow this opinion, and other courts or state legislatures have imposed a duty to refer on chiropractors. The Supreme Court of New Jersey, for example, ruled in a 1984 case that chiropractors are “expected to diagnose and refer patients whose conditions require medical or other treatment.”4 Other appeals courts, in Washington and Colorado for example, have also upheld judgments against chiropractors for failing to recognize a problem they were not qualified to treat and for not referring the patient to a medical doctor. 
And in California, the regulations that govern licensed chiropractors in that state specifically identify failure to refer a patient whose condition is not amenable to chiropractic treatment as an example of “unprofessional conduct.”5 This is ostensibly only intended to be the basis of action against the license of the chiropractor, but some scholars hold that such regulatory provisions can be the basis for establishing a standard of care in a malpractice case. There are, however, also rulings that do not allow practice act standards to be used in this way (e.g. Wengel v. Herfet Court of appeals of Michigan (1991) 6). As usual, then, there is a lack of consistency among the states in the legal theories or specific interpretations of relevant law and precedent.
Breach of Duty or Standard of Care
Once a standard of care is defined, a malpractice case hinges next on whether this standard has been breached. In addition to failing to recognize a problem not amenable to the alternative method of treatment being used, and failure to refer for medical care where required, there are several other ways in which alternative practitioners may breach the applicable standard of care.
For physicians utilizing alternative therapies, one possible breach of the standard of care is simply by utilizing methods that deviate from accepted medical practices. In a case involving Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez, of the infamous Gonzalez Regime for cancer treatment, the Supreme Court of New York articulated what seems to me a simple and rational view of the issue that is seldom seen outside of science-based medicine advocacy circles:
The standard for proving negligence in a malpractice case is whether the treatment deviates from accepted medical standards…it would seem then that no practitioner of alternative medicine could prevail on such a question as the reference to the term “non-conventional” may well necessitate a finding that the doctor who practices such medicine deviates from “accepted” medical standards. This indeed creates a problem for such physicians which perhaps can only be solved by having the patient execute a comprehensive consent containing appropriate information as to the risks involved.7
In other words, since alternative medicine by definition does not conform to accepted standards of care, it should only be defensible if it is undertaken as an experimental therapy, with all of the informed consent requirements and other protections for patients participating in clinical trials. 
Of course, this standard only applies to medical doctors who employ alternative methods, so the principle unfortunately cannot be applied to chiropractors or others licensed in specific alternative methods who are held to different standards. And in practice, alternative therapies are usually not subject to automatic classification as malpractice by virtue of being alternative, because the courts have more frequently held that they should not be judged by the standards of conventional or scientific medicine, but only by their own internal standards.
Malpractice Defenses
The most straightforward defenses against a malpractice claim (insofar as any issue subject to litigation can ever be straightforward) are that the actions of the defendant were not the cause of any injury and that no actual damages were sustained. These are, for the most part, questions of fact which can often be substantiated in relatively objective ways. However, greater ambiguity and complexity are involved in defenses which address whether a duty of care exists or has been breached. 
As we have seen, alternative practitioners have some avenues of defense in arguing that they cannot be guilty of breaching a duty based on standards of conventional medicine but only on those limited standards that pertain to their particular mode of treatment. One form this defense takes is the so-called “two schools of thought” doctrine.8 This is a Byzantine bit of legal reasoning in which the courts try to avoid adjudicating scientific disputes between factions within the medical community. This seems at first a quite appropriate goal given that lawyers, judges, and juries are not generally qualified in knowledge or training to determine the scientific truth behind disputes among scientists. 
However, it leads to the unfortunate consequence that courts may make the mistake journalists so often make of treating the two “sides” in a scientific dispute as equal when in fact the dichotomy may actually be between an overwhelming majority backed by solid evidence and a few extremists with a wild, unsupported notion.
One case before the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, Jones v. Chidester, illustrates this doctrine nicely.9 According to the court, “a medical practitioner has an absolute defense to a claim of negligence when it is determined that the prescribed treatment or procedure has been approved by one group of medical experts even though an alternate school of thought recommends another approach.” 
The court then examines in detail different standards previous courts have used to determine whether a given position constituted a legitimate “school of thought” to which this rule could be applied. Some courts have used a quantitative standard, ruling that a “considerable number” of experts must approve of an approach for it to be deemed legitimate. Other courts have used a more qualitative standard, for example acceptance of the approach by “respectable, reputable, and reasonable” practitioners. The most generous standard seen in some states is requiring only a “respectable minority” of physicians to agree with an idea for it to be an acceptable “school of thought.” Ultimately, the Pennsylvania court chose to apply a combination of quantitative and qualitative standards:
Where competent medical authority is divided, a physician will not be held responsible if in the exercise of his judgment he followed a course of treatment advocated by a considerable number of recognized and respectable professionals in his given area of expertise.8
The court left the details of words like “considerable” and “recognized” or “respectable” to the discretion of other courts hearing particular cases. And they specifically placed the onus of supporting the contention that one’s approach is a legitimate “school of thought” on the defendant: “The burden of proving that there are two schools of thought falls to the defendant. The burden, however, should not prove burdensome…Once the expert states the factual reasons to support his claim that there is a considerable number of professionals who agree with the treatment…there is sufficient evidence to warrant an instruction to the jury on the two ‘schools of thought.’ It then becomes a question for the jury to determine whether they believe that there are two legitimate schools of thought such that the defendant should be insulated from liability.”8
Clearly, under this doctrine widely accepted practices like chiropractic and acupuncture would qualify as legitimate schools of thought, and no claim of liability based solely on the scientific evidence against their claims would be allowed. This leads to a pretty glaring inconsistency. The courts wish to avoid adjudicating scientific disputes, and yet as an alternative they make determining the legitimacy of a medical therapy a sort of popularity contest and then leave it to a jury to decide if the approaches employed are sufficiently popular to be acceptable.
Informed Consent and Assumption of Risk
In addition to straightforward factual defenses and to the approach of establishing that one’s treatment is consistent with the practices of a legitimate “school of thought” within the medical community, practitioners accused of malpractice can defend against liability by arguing that the patient had implicitly or expressly assumed any risk of treatment by assenting to the treatment, thus absolving the practitioner of liability for damages. As The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit argued, “we see no reason why a patient should not be allowed to make an informed decision to go outside currently approved medical methods in search of an unconventional treatment. While a patient should be encouraged to exercise care for his own safety,[eschewing conventional treatment] is within a patient’s right ‘to determine what shall be done with his own body.”10 And if a patient makes such an informed decision, then it would make no sense to hold the practitioner liable for any undesirable outcome that was an inherent risk of the treatment. 
In order to lay the basis for this assumption of risk defense, practitioners need to inform patients of the potential risks of treatment and of the alternatives. Courts have wrestled with the details of defining the parameters of this informed consent. There are two dominant standards in use. About half of the states use the so-called “patient standard,” in which a provider is expected to disclose any fact which might reasonably be expected to affect the patient’s decision whether or not to undergo the therapy. No expert testimony is required to establish if adequate disclosure occurred under this standard because this would imply that medical experts, rather than lay people, should determine what constitutes adequate disclosure, and this is considered by some to be paternalistic or open to abuse if physicians ultimately decide what patients need to know. 11
The rest of the states use the “professional standard,” which requires disclosure of any fact that a reasonable physician in the same circumstances would disclose. Under this theory, expert testimony is needed to establish what a “reasonable physician” would be expected to do in the specific circumstances and whether or not the defendant did it.12
How then are the principles of informed consent and assumption of risk applied in malpractice cases associated with alternative medicine? In one scenario, a provider may be sued for failing to adequately disclose the risks of forgoing conventional medical care. 
An example of this is the case previously referenced, Charell v Gonzalez, in which a victim of the Gonzalez cancer regime sued Dr. Gonzalez after undergoing his bogus treatment. In this case, the state supreme court did find that Dr. Gonzalez failed to provide adequate disclosure concerning the risks of his therapy and of eschewing conventional cancer treatment. However, the court also concluded that the patient “was a well-educated person who, together with her husband and daughter, did a significant amount of investigation regarding the treatment…and hence became quite knowledgeable on the subject…[Thus] it was within the province of the jury, based on the evidence, for it to find that plaintiff independently obtained sufficient information about the treatment so as to conclude that there was an implied assumption of risk when she agreed to follow defendant’s protocol.”7
By this reasoning, it would seem very difficult for someone who sought out an alternative therapy to successfully sue for malpractice even if the risks of the therapy were not adequately explained to them since it might be assumed by the court that in seeking the therapy they had discovered and understood the risks well enough to make an informed choice to accept them.
Of course, alternative practitioners may be sued, just like physicians, for failing to adequately disclose the risks of the therapies they provide. When his happens, the courts will judge the duty to disclose under whichever of the two standards described above is used in that jurisdiction, the “patient” or “professional” standard. However, the details of the risks involved and what the practitioner can reasonably be required to know and disclose are likely to be judged by the standards of the particular “school of thought” the practitioner belongs to. 
Therefore, for example, the court may view the risk of stroke associated with cervical chiropractic manipulation as chiropractors do, as an unproven or at least very rare complication balanced by the overall safety and efficacy of the treatment, rather than as a thoroughly unjustifiable risk of an ineffective and unscientific treatment, as many of us in scientific medicine view it.
In a strange twist to informed consent rules, some physicians have been sued for not informing patients of the availability of alternative therapies. So far the courts seem to have taken the position that there is no duty to inform a patient of the availability of a therapy that is generally not accepted by the medical community. However, as more doctors and medical schools integrate alternative therapies into their practices, there may come a time when not telling a patient that they could try acupuncture, chiropractic, or some other form of alterative therapy instead of conventional treatment could be viewed as a failure to provide sufficient disclosure to allow an informed consent/assumption of risk defense.
Summary
As usual, of course, the rules and standards set by state legislatures and courts are inconsistent and variable, so firm, predictable rules cannot be deduced. However, it is possible to make a few tentative generalizations about the position of alternative medicine with regard to malpractice law:
Alternative therapies generally cannot be successfully attacked through malpractice litigation solely on the basis of their implausibility or lack of convincing scientific evidence for safety and efficacy. Particularly in the case of widely accepted and often state licensed approaches such as acupuncture and chiropractic, charges of malpractice will be judged by standards set within the paradigm of the particular method, not by any broader scientific or evidence-based standard.
Alternative medicine providers can, of course, be guilty of malpractice if they perform their interventions below the commonly accepted standards of their own communities. They may also have liabilities for injuries caused by discouraging patients from seeking conventional care and, in some jurisdictions, for not recognizing when a patient’s condition is beyond the scope of their form of treatment and subsequently referring the patient for treatment by a medical doctor.
The courts and legislatures give great weight to the autonomy of the individual to make decisions about their own healthcare, and they are likely to view sympathetically malpractice defenses based on the theory that by choosing an alternative approach a patient understands and assumes the risk of that approach.
The licensure of alternative methods by states, their integration into academic institutions, and the tacit approval of their legitimacy conveyed by government organizations like NCCAM and insurance provider who pay for them all contribute to the perception of these methods as legitimate alternatives to scientific medicine, and this makes it very difficult for patients injured by these approaches to successfully pursue a malpractice action despite the lack of good scientific evidence that these methods are safe and effective. As we have seen repeatedly, when evaluating alternative medicine the law is far less concerned with scientific evidence than with political, cultural, and philosophical arguments.
References
     1.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010 
     2.  Kerkman v. Hintz, Supreme Court of Wisconsin, 418 N.W. 2d 795 (1988). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 103-11. 
     3.  Kuechler v. Volgman, 180 Wis. 238, 192 N.W. 1015 (1923). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 105. 
     4.  Rosenberg v. Cahill, 492 A.2d 371, N.J. (1984). from website: http://www.fpamed.com/forensic_psychiatry/2008/05/a-paradox-about.html 
     5.  State of California, Board of Chiropractic Examiners Rules and Regulations, Rev. June, 2010. Article 2, § 317. from website: http://www.chiro.ca.gov/res/docs/pdf/business/chiroregs_june2010.pdf 
     6.  Wengel v. Herfert, Court of Appeals of Michigan, 473 N.W.2d 741 (1991). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 114-16. 
     7.  Charell v. Gonzalez, Supreme Court of New York, New York County, 173 Misc. 2d 227 (1997). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 117. 
     8.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 146-152. 
     9.  Jones v. Chidester, Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 531 Pa. 31 (1992). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 146-152. 
     10.  Schneider v. Revici, United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, 817 F.2d 987 (1987). cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p.152-4. 
     11.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 160-73. 
     12.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 174-8. 

   CAM and the Law Part 2: Licensure and Scope of Practice Laws
Brennen McKenzie 
Link
This post is intended to illustrate a bit about how medicine, including alternative medicine, is defined and limited legally by state licensure. This is, of course, an enormous topic, especially given the variety of laws and regulations among the 50 states and District of Columbia, and the many, often mutually inconsistent, court decisions interpreting them. A comprehensive survey would resemble Gibbon’s history of Rome and would likely be out-of-date the moment it was finished. My more modest goal here is to highlight a few of the ways in which licensure and scope of practice laws intersect the practice of CAM and give a few representative examples. 
The Rise of Medical Licensure
In the 19th century, a bewildering variety of different approaches to maintaining health and treating disease competed for the trust, and dollars, of prospective patients (or their owners, in the case of animal patients). Caveat emptor was the rule in an unregulated medical marketplace. Mainstream medicine was a competitor in this marketplace, though it was hardly science-based to any great extent compared to conventional medical practices today. Homeopathy was another pretty big player, along with osteopathy and numerous other more or less organized schools, as well as many individual snake oil salesmen, faith healers, local providers of folk remedies, and so on.1,2
Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, state legislatures passed medical practice acts defining the practice of medicine, the criteria for medical licensure, and the criminal penalties for the unlicensed practice of medicine. The American Medical Association, founded in 1846, played a powerful role in driving and shaping these early enactments of the state police authority to regulate medicine. The AMA-sponsored Flexner Report on medical education released in 1910 did much to shape the criteria states used to award licensure, and thus to shape the content of accepted medical practices. Veterinary medicine lagged a bit behind in this initial licensure movement, with California apparently being the first state to license vets in 1893, but the general legal trend has been much the same as for regulation of human medicine.1,3
What is the Practice of Medicine?
There is some variation in the details of how the practice of medicine is defined in different state practice acts, but all the definitions are quite broad. They give physicians great latitude in the therapies they provide, but they also leave some uncertainty as to what actually constitutes practicing medicine, and there is room for the courts to interpret and clarify the law.
In New York, for example, the law reads:
The practice of medicine is defined as diagnosing, treating, operating or prescribing for any human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition.4
In California, the definition is even broader:
[A]ny person who practices or attempts to practice, or who advertises or holds himself or herself out as practicing, any system or mode of treating the sick or afflicted in this state, or who diagnoses, treats, operates for, or prescribes for any ailment, blemish, deformity, disease, disfigurement, disorder, injury, or other physical or mental condition of any person…5
State veterinary practices acts are also very broad, sometimes even more so than medical practice acts. For example, in California:
A person practices veterinary medicine, surgery, and dentistry, and the various branches thereof, when he or she does any of the following:
(a) Represents himself or herself as engaged in the practice of veterinary medicine, veterinary surgery, or veterinary dentistry in any of its branches.
(b) Diagnoses or prescribes a drug, medicine, appliance, application, or treatment of whatever nature for the prevention, cure or relief of a wound, fracture, bodily injury, or disease of animals.
(c) Administers a drug, medicine, appliance, application, or treatment of whatever nature for the prevention, cure, or relief of a wound, fracture, bodily injury, or disease of animals…
(d) Performs a surgical or dental operation upon an animal.
(e) Performs any manual procedure for the diagnosis or pregnancy, sterility, or infertility upon livestock or Equidae.
(f) Uses any words, letters or titles in such connection or under such circumstances as to induce the belief that the person using them is engaged in the practice of veterinary medicine…6
With such general legal language, it might seem that physicians and veterinarians could do almost anything and call it practicing medicine. And it might also seem dangerous for people who are not licensed to practice medicine to do anything at all to a sick person or animal for fear of violating their state’s medical practice act. However, the states and the courts have created numerous exceptions and limitations to these very general standards. 
Some common exceptions are quite sensible and obvious. For example, nurses and other healthcare providers working under physician supervision, physicians working for federal agencies, properly supervised students, lay people providing reasonable first aid or lifesaving care or using widely accepted over-the-counter remedies, and many other similar activities are defined as legitimate and not the unlawful practice of medicine.1 
Other exceptions are sometimes less obvious, and they may provide loopholes for alternative medical providers to ply their trades. For example, animals are considered property, not persons, under the law, so their owners and anyone they authorize can do almost anything they like to treat them, within only the limitations of animal cruelty laws, which have very high standards of proof and lax enforcement.3 Some states, such as California, also provide other specific exemptions, such as this one:
Nothing in this chapter [the Medical Practice Act] shall.…regulate, prohibit, or apply to any kind of treatment by prayer, nor interfere in any way with the practice of religion.7
In addition to defining the practice of medicine, the state practice acts also define the criteria required to obtain and maintain a medical license. These often include graduation from an approved educational program with coverage of specified subject matter, practical clinical training, a passing score on licensing examinations, and ongoing professional education. In the early days of medical licensure, it was the development of these criteria that had the greatest impact in terms of promoting scientific medicine and limiting the ability of practitioners of alternative approaches to continuing practicing their forms of medicine. 
Licensure of Non-Physicians
In addition to physicians, states also license a number of other medical professions, including providers of alternative therapies. The relevant legislative acts define the scope of practice and criteria for licensure for these providers just as they do for physicians and veterinarians, though the scope of acceptable activities is often far more limited and narrowly defined. 
The major CAM methods are the most commonly licensed. Chiropractors are licensed in all 50 states, non-M.D. acupuncturists are licensed in 37 states, naturopaths are licensed in 17 states (though they are specifically prohibited from practicing in 2 states), and “homeopathic physicians” are licensed in 3 states.8 States that do not license such providers do sometimes still explicitly regulate the more common alternative methods, such as acupuncture, within other health or professions statues. 
Laws licensing alternative therapists are often very specific, while still leaving a surprising amount of room for subsequent interpretation and controversy. In California, for example, the Acupuncture Licensure Act defines acupuncture directly while also managing to fit in a much broader ideological statement:
In its concern with the need to eliminate the fundamental causes of illness, not simply to remove symptoms, and with the need to treat the whole person, the Legislature intends to establish in this article, a framework for the practice of the art and science of Asian medicine through acupuncture…
“Acupuncture” means the stimulation of a certain point or points on or near the surface of the body by the insertion of needles to prevent or modify the perception of pain or to normalize physiological functions, including pain control, for the treatment of certain diseases or dysfunctions of the body and includes the techniques of electroacupuncture, cupping, and moxibustion.9
The relevant legislation in California concerning chiropractic licensure defines the scope of practice for chiropractors very specifically:
(1) A duly licensed chiropractor may manipulate and adjust the spinal column and other joints of the human body and in the process thereof a chiropractor may manipulate the muscle and connective tissue related thereto. 
(2) As part of a course of chiropractic treatment, a duly licensed chiropractor may use all necessary mechanical, hygienic, and sanitary measures incident to the care of the body, including, but not limited to, air, cold, diet, exercise, heat, light, massage, physical culture, rest, ultrasound, water, and physical therapy techniques in the course of chiropractic manipulations and/or adjustments. 
(3) Other than as explicitly set forth….a duly licensed chiropractor may treat any condition, disease, or injury in any patient, including a pregnant woman, and may diagnose, so long as such treatment or diagnosis is done in a manner consistent with chiropractic methods and techniques and so long as such methods and treatment do not constitute the practice of medicine by exceeding the legal scope of chiropractic practice as set forth in this section. 
(4) A chiropractic license issued in the State of California does not authorize the holder thereof: 
(A) to practice surgery or to sever or penetrate tissues of human beings, including, but not limited to severing the umbilical cord; 
(B) to deliver a human child or practice obstetrics; 
(C) to practice dentistry; 
(D) to practice optometry; 
(E) to use any drug or medicine included in materia medica; 
(F) to use a lithotripter; 
(G) to use ultrasound on a fetus for either diagnostic or treatment purposes; or 
(H) to perform a mammography.
(5) A duly licensed chiropractor may employ the use of vitamins, food supplements, foods for special dietary use, or proprietary medicines, if the above substances are also included in section 4057 of the Business and Professions Code, so long as such substances are not included in materia medica as defined in section 13 of the Business and Professions Code…
(6) Except as specifically provided in section 302(a)(4), a duly licensed chiropractor may make use of X-ray and thermography equipment for the purposes of diagnosis but not for the purposes of treatment. A duly licensed chiropractor may make use of diagnostic ultrasound equipment for the purposes of neuromuscular skeletal diagnosis. 
(7) A duly licensed chiropractor may only practice or attempt to practice or hold himself or herself out as practicing a system of chiropractic….A chiropractor may not hold himself or herself out as being licensed as anything other than a chiropractor or as holding any other healing arts license or as practicing physical therapy or use the term “physical therapy” in advertising unless he or she holds another such license.10
The Devil in the Details
Despite the specificity of such laws and regulations, there is a fair bit of ambiguity as to exactly who is allowed to do what, and state attorneys general and the courts are frequently called upon to interpret these laws. In some states, physicians have been held to be legally permitted to practice alternative therapies even without specific licenses in those approaches, under the general provisions of medical practice. Other states, however, have required physicians to be licensed in these approaches before offering them. And, of course, given the controversial nature of many CAM therapies, physicians run some risk of being sanction for “unprofessional conduct” by their state medical board for offering some unconventional therapies. 
In one well-known example, a North Carolina doctor was disciplined by the state medical board or administering homeopathic treatments. The board concluded that since homeopathy “does not conform to the standards of acceptable and prevailing medical practice,” using it constituted unprofessional conduct. After this sanction was reversed by two lower courts (one asserting there was not sufficient evidence to support the board’s conclusions about homeopathy, and the other arguing that it didn’t matter because homeopathy was harmless), the state supreme court upheld the board’s decision.11
The majority argued, quite sensibly, that “a general risk of endangering the public is inherent in any practices which fail to conform to the standards of ‘acceptable and prevailing’ medical practice” regardless of whether the specific treatment was directly harmful. The justices also recognized that “certain aspects of regulating the medical profession plainly require expertise beyond that of a layman” and that “while questions as to the efficacy of homeopathy….may be open to debate among members of the medical profession….the courts are not the proper forum for that debate.”12 
Unfortunately, the legislature of North Carolina took a different view, preferring to protect consumer choice and the autonomy of individual providers, and the law was subsequently amended to specifically protect physicians who offer treatments that are “experimental, nontraditional, or that [depart] from acceptable and prevailing medical practices” unless they can be clearly shown to be more harmful than conventional treatments.12
A variety of legal opinions and rulings also exist that clarify (or sometimes obscure) the limits of acceptable therapies licensed alternative practitioners can provide as well. For example, in some states chiropractors can legally provide colonic irrigation, perform pelvic and rectal exams, perform electrocardiograms, provide herbal remedies or nutritional supplements, or perform acupuncture under generous interpretations of the definition of chiropractic.13 However, other states have ruled it a violation of their scope of practice limitations for chiropractors to utilize herbal or nutritional substances in treating patients, perform pelvic exams, perform or order diagnostic blood or urine tests, and engage in other such practices deemed outside of their licensed activities.13 There are similar inconsistencies in the interpretation of what therapies are permissible for other licensed alternative providers as well.
Faith Healing and Secular Spiritual Practices
A particularly interesting area of medical jurisprudence is the relationship of licensing laws to spiritual and religious practices. The tension between individual liberty and freedom of economic activity on the one hand and the role of government in protecting the public health on the other is weak tea compared to the conflict between government police powers and the legal and cultural imperatives in the U.S. to protect religious freedom. Religion may be specifically excluded from medical regulation, as in the California code above or in states like Minnesota and Ohio, which specifically exempt Christian Science faith healing from the definition of medical practice for example.14 And even in the absence of specific exemptions for religious activity, medical regulations are often required to meet a very high standard of justification if they are perceived to interfere with religious practices. The decisions made by courts and state legislatures on such matters often hinge more on the issue of religious liberty versus state police powers than on the question of whether spiritual healing practices have any medical benefit.
This controversy also has implications for so-called “secular spiritual” approaches, such as the various energy therapies like Reiki, Thought Field Therapy, Healing Touch, some meditation or mind-body therapies, and so on. Are such methods the practice of medicine? Are they religious practices and so protected to some extent from regulation? Does it matter if they work? Or if they are harmless? These are questions that have been raised by advocates of these approaches and legal scholars but which have not often been directly or clearly addressed in law or judicial rulings.
In cases involving ostensibly religious healing practices, courts have both supported and overruled restrictions imposed by medical regulations. In one Florida case, a man who claimed to heal through prayer and laying on hands was accused of practicing medicine. He claimed his activity was protected under the provision indicating the state practice act did not apply to “the practice of the religious tenets of any church.” The state supreme court ruling in the defendant’s favor did point out that his actions did not “invade the province of the medical profession and assume the ability to diagnose diseases and prescribe drugs or other medical or surgical or mechanical means to restore the health” of his clients. However, the bulk of the opinion was concerned with the issue of religious liberty and with the apparent lack of any direct harm done by the healing practice, as well as the more general epistemological argument that science doesn’t know everything:
…from ancient times down to this modern and so called materialistic age, there have always been quite a large percentage of people who believed in the efficacy and availability of Divine power, not only to save the souls but also the bodies and lives of men and to heal all the ills that flesh is heir to….And if this class of people hear and believe that some person can and does invoke the power of Most High to heal people of their ills, or that in his own person such individual possesses some strange mental, magnetic or psychic power to banish disease from the human body….[they] will seek him out. And it is not the policy of our laws to prevent them; nor to punish those to whom they go, and who endeavor to heal the ills of men by such mental or spiritual means…
The reason for this policy is founded upon the liberty of the individual citizen under our bill of rights, and the fact that so long as these faith healers or spirit mediums rely upon their power, by prayer or faith, to invoke the exercise of the power of the Almighty, if indeed they fail to cure, they at least can do no harm…
Now this appellant testified that the power which he invoked was not his own, but that it was the power of God. And if some of the uncontradicted witnesses are to be believed, he was instrumental in accomplishing some remarkable cures….Now, to most of us, this matter of healing ‘by faith and the laying on of hands,’ ancient as it is, is still beyond us. But according to Shakespeare’s Hamlet, ‘There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.’ And in that magnificent speech of St. Paul’s before King Agrippa, he said to the king: ‘Why shuld it be thought a thing incredible with you, that God should raise the dead?’ So the legislature and the courts might well accord our citizens the liberty to decide such questions as these for themselves.”15
Other rulings on the question of whether religious practices are subject to the regulations that govern the practice of medicine have been more pragmatic and less prolix. A California case concerned a healer who imposed on people not only prayer and laying on of hands but strict fasting and dietary requirements and a prohibition on conventional medical diagnostics or treatment. He attempted to defend his practices as religious rather than medical, even after the death of one person and significant injury to others following his approach. Despite the state’s exemption of religious practices from the medical practice act, the court ruled that the methods used went well beyond protected religious activity and invaded the domain of secular medicine. 
There is no question that the described activities constitute the practice of medicine; that the Board has a substantial interest in preventing such activities, which are demonstrably harmful on this record; …[and] there is [no] serious argument made that the injunction infringes appellants’ constitutional rights of free exercise of religion under the First Amendment. Cases are legion which hold that freedom of religious belief may be absolute but freedom of action is not.[citations omitted] The state may legitimately regulate dangerous conduct regardless of religious content. It is therefore universally held that in the interest of protecting its citizens’ health, the state may regulate health treatments which are potentially dangerous to the patient….In reaching this decision we do not deem it necessary to question the bona fides of appellant Andrews’ religious faith; that fact is not relevant…16
Of course, there are salient differences in the facts in these cases, as well as the historical moments in which they were heard. The practical question of whether direct harm is done by a spiritual healing approach is weighed by the courts in adjudicating such cases. However, as is frequently the case, the reasoning that informs the courts’ decisions often fail to address the scientific question of the efficacy of such treatments or the potential indirect harm they may do in discouraging effective medical care. And the issues of individual and religious liberty are often given as much or more weight than the question of whether the interventions are demonstrably effective or not.
Is Medical Licensure Fair and Does It Protect the Public?
Medical licensure is widely accepted as a legitimate use of state authority to protect the public health by preventing people from being exposed to dangerous and ineffective therapies in an unrestrained medical market. Proponents of CAM, as well as opponents of government regulation generally, sometimes cast the promulgation of medical licensing laws as a straightforward protectionist campaign by “allopathic” doctors to wipe out the competition. While it would be disingenuous to suggest that professional organizations such as the AMA or the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) have no political or economic agendas beyond the protection of the public good, it is a convenient but inaccurate exaggeration to say that concerns for territory or income have been the prime motivators of efforts to license and regulate medicine. Concerns for the actual, verifiable scientific truth behind medical practices and the welfare of patients have always been a genuine and important reason for encouraging government to regulate healthcare. 
Even in the notorious antitrust case Wilk v. American Medical Association, in which chiropractors succeeded in using anti-trust laws and allegations of protectionism to weaken the ability of the AMA, and other professional organizations, to marginalize unscientific medical practices, the court was “persuaded that the dominant factor [in the AMA's efforts] was patient care and the AMA’s subjective belief that chiropractic was not in the best interests of patients.”17
Licensure and scope of practice limitations do leave enormous room for physicians and others to engage in ineffective and dangerous medical practices, and the spirit and letter of the law is subject to wide-ranging interpretations in different states and courts. And while licensing CAM professions arguably gives the state some ability to enforce reasonable standards of training and practice, there is an element of Tooth Fairy Regulation in this (with apologies to Dr. Hall). 
For example, the California law regulating acupuncturists requires a minimum of 2250 hours of clinical training and 1548 hours of theoretical and didactic training to apply for a license. Some of this, such as how to avoid transmitting infectious diseases with needles, is legitimate training that protects public health. But it is debatable how helpful it is to require many hours of study of Qi Gong, Traditional Oriental Medicine Theory, Moxibustion, Ear Acupuncture theory, and so on.
And, of course, licensure creates a perception of legitimacy and accuracy to the claims of CAM providers in the minds of the public, who generally don’t appreciate the extent to which decisions about medical regulation are made less on the basis of scientific facts than on the basis of political and philosophical issues. 
On balance, the regulation of conventional medical practice, and to a lesser extent alternative therapies, probably is reasonably effective in protecting the public. The popularity and availability of dangerous and clearly ineffective approaches is certainly less than it was during the age of medical anarchism, and such laws have doubtless played a role in this. 
Why We Should Understand Medical Licensing Laws
While we must always maintain our emphasis on verifiable scientific facts about the safety and efficacy of proposed therapeutic approaches, those of us dedicated to science-based medicine may also be able to play a role as a constituency in shaping the writing and interpretation of medical laws and regulation to better protect the public. And we must certainly be aware of what our own state’s laws are, and participate in seeing that they are properly executed. 
In researching this subject, for example, I became aware that the California veterinary practice act has very strict requirements for veterinary supervision of chiropractic applied to animals, and also a requirement that “the veterinarian shall obtain as part of the patient’s permanent record, a signed acknowledgment from the owner of the patient or his or her authorized representative that [musculoskeletal manipulation] is considered to be an alternative (nonstandard) veterinary therapy.”18 I am certain most of the vets I know who refer patients for chiropractic treatment do not comply with these guidelines, and if wider compliance can be achieved it would likely reduce the utilization and potential harm of this unproven, and possibly dangerous, therapeutic approach. 
A familiarity with the laws govern medical practice is an important element in advocating for good quality scientific medicine and discouraging unproven or unsafe interventions. Part of my goal in this series is to encourage such familiarity. The references I cite in these posts are a good starting point, though they have their limitations and biases. Most relevant state laws and regulations are easily accessible on the internet. 
Proponents of alternative therapies are aware of the importance of understanding and helping to shape medical laws and regulations, and they explicitly encourage CAM practitioners to be knowledgeable and involved (see, for example, these resources for acupuncturists, naturopaths, and chiropractors). Since professional organizations such as the AMA and AVMA are limited by political and legal considerations from aggressively working to shape legislation and public policies that discourage alternative therapies, those of us who would promote science-based medicine would do well to be as familiar with medical laws and the agendas that influence them as we try to be with the scientific facts concerning questionable medical practices. 
References
     1.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. Return to text.
     2.  Ramey DW, Rollin BE. Untested therapies and medical anarchism. In: Complementary and alternative veterinary medicine considered. Ames (IA), USA: Iowa State Press, 2004. p.168-9. Return to text.
     3.  Wilson JF, Rollin BE, Garbe, JAL. Law and ethics of the veterinary profession.Morrisville (PA), USA: Priority Press Ltd, 1993. Return to text.
     4.  N.Y. Educ. Law § 6521. Cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 36. Return to text.
     5.  Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 2052(a). Cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 36. Return to text.
     6.  Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 4826. Cited In: California Veterinary Medicine Practice Act. 2010 Ed. Charlottesville (VA), USA: LexisNexis, Matthew Bender & Company, Inc, 2010. p. 5-6. Return to text.
     7.  Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 2063. Retrieved Sept. 9, 2010 from California Law Website: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=bpc&group=02001-03000&file=2050-2079 Return to text.
     8.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p.56. Return to text.
     9.  Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 4026-4027. Retrieved Sept. 9, 2010 from California Law Website: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=bpc&group=04001-05000&file=4925-4934.2 Return to text.
     10.  Cal. Admin. Code tit. 16, § 302 Retrieved Sept. 9, 2010 from webite: http://weblinks.westlaw.com/result/default.aspx?cite=16CAADCS302&db=1000937&findtype=L&fn=%5Ftop&ifm=NotSet&pbc=4BF3FCBE&rlt=CLID%5FFQRLT2612239251299&rp=%2FSearch%2Fdefault%2Ewl&rs=WEBL10%2E08&service=Find&spa=CCR%2D1000&sr=TC&vr=2%2E0 Return to text.
     11.  Guess v. Board of Medical Examiners 393 S.E.2d 833 (1990). Cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 42-44. Return to text.
     12.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p.50. Return to text.
     13.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p.87-88. Return to text.
     14.  Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p.61-62. Return to text.
     15.  Curley v. State of Florida Supreme Court of Florida, en Bacn 16 So. 2d 440 (1943). Cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 58-60. Return to text.
     16.  Board of Medical Quality Assurance v. Arthur Andrews Court of Appeal, Sixth Distr., California 211 Cal. App. 3d 1346 (1989). Cited in Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 60-63. Return to text.
     17.  Wilk v. American Medical Association 671 F. Supp 1465 (N.D. Ill.) 1987. Cited in: Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 230-241. Return to text.
     18.  Cal. Code of Regulations § 2038. Cited In: California Veterinary Medicine Practice Act. 2010 Ed. Charlottesville (VA), USA: LexisNexis, Matthew Bender & Company, Inc, 2010. p173.

   CAM and the Law Part 4: Regulation of Supplements and Homeopathic Remedies
Brennen McKenzie
Link
Another major set of legal standards that apply to alternative medicine are the laws and regulations that govern the manufacturing and availability of homeopathic and herbal remedies and dietary supplements. Although there is less ambiguity in these standards than in some of the areas I’ve covered previously, there are certainly loopholes aplenty available to avoid the need for any truly scientific standards of evaluating safety and efficacy. This is perhaps the area in which the triumph of politics over science is most vivid.
Regulation of Homeopathic Remedies
The Food and Drug Administration was constituted as the agency responsible for regulating medicines and most foods by the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) of 1938. The FDCA has been updated and amended in various ways since then, but it is still the primary law governing the regulation of prescription and non-prescription substances used to treat illness. The law identifies substances acceptable for sale as medicines as those listed in its official compendia, the United States Pharmacopeia-National Formulary (USP-NF) and the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS). The HPUS was a list of homeopathic remedies first published by the American Institute of Homeopathy, a professional body for homeopaths, in 1897 and now published and maintained by the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States (HPCUS), an independent organization of homeopathic “experts.” The inclusion of homeopathic remedies as accepted drugs in the original legislation was primarily due to the efforts of Senator Royal Copeland, a physician trained in homeopathy and one of the principle authors of the FDCA.1
Most homeopathic remedies are available as over-the-counter products, though at least theoretically some homeopathic drugs do require a prescription. The distinction between ordinary drugs that can be sold over-the-counter and those available only by prescription is made by the FDA based on the history of use of the particular ingredients, the nature of the complaint for which they are used and, in the case of new OTC drugs, the scientific evidence concerning safety and efficacy. However, with respect to homeopathic products, the distinction seems to depend solely on the intended use of the remedy. If a complaint is expected to be easily recognized by a lay person and self-limiting or not life-threatening, then a homeopathic remedy for such a complaint can be sold without a prescription. However, remedies intended for use in conditions that are serious, not self-limiting, and not easily diagnosed by laypeople require a prescription. 
The HPCUS has promulgated detailed guidelines for approving new homeopathic drugs. According to one review:
The clinical benefits of the new drug must be established in one of the following ways: through clinical verification acceptable to HPCUS, after which there is a period of clinical verification; through published documentation that the substance was in use prior to 1962; through use established by at least two adequately controlled double-blind clinical studies using the drug as the single intervention; or through use established by data gathered from clinical experience encompassing the symptom picture before and after treatment, including subjective and any available objective symptoms.[citation omitted]
The criterion of clinical use prior to 1962 was used to grandfather many drugs during the 1970s and 1980s into acceptance. This criterion is now rarely, if ever, used, and HPCUS is rereviewing [sic] many monographs accepted under this approach. HPCUS reports that the criterion of clinical experience has never been used. Consequently, only the criteria of homeopathic drug “proving” and establishment by two adequate clinical studies are currently in actual use [citation omitted].1
This sounds very impressive and scientific if we ignore the fact that the vast majority of the “drugs” we are talking about are identical and contain nothing but water. It is a testament to the power of cognitive dissonance and faith that a complex set of laws and regulations as well as scores of dedicated professionals in government and the private sector are devoted to regulating the use of over 1200 differently labeled preparations of water. It is also a reminder that scientific facts are not as persuasive in the legal and political arenas as we might hope.
The FDA guidelines for marketing of homeopathic drugs specifies the labeling and manufacturing requirements for homeopathic remedies, but it is most interesting for the inclusion of a definition of Health Fraud:
The deceptive promotion, advertisement, distribution or sale of articles, intended for human or animal use, that are represented as being effective to diagnose, prevent, cure, treat, or mitigate disease (or other conditions), or provide a beneficial effect on health, but which have not been scientifically proven safe and effective for such purposes. Such practices may be deliberate, or done without adequate knowledge or understanding of the article.
The inclusion of this definition without any apparent acknowledgement of its clear application to the practice of homeopathy being regulated by the document is as fine an example of the disconnect between scientific and legal reasoning.
Regulation of Herbal Remedies and Other “Therapeutic” Dietary Supplements
Much has previously been written here at Science-Based Medicine on the subject of the Dietary Supplement and Health Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4), and I don’t have a great deal to add. In brief, the supplement industry and sympathetic lawmakers created this law to pretend to regulate herbal remedies and other dietary supplements while effectively stripping the FDA of the ability to control the sale of these products for the prevention or treatment of disease. This was accomplished by classifying all such products as foods and codifying the principle that they must be assumed to be safe unless the government can generate substantial evidence to the contrary. There are some restrictions on the medical claims manufacturers can make on the labels of these remedies, but they are routinely ignored and the resources and will behind enforcement of them are manifestly inadequate.
It is instructive to look at some of the judicial opinions that have been rendered in cases where the FDA did attempt to restrict the use of supplements that had clear potential to be harmful or to challenge unsupported label claims. When the FDA banned the sale of the supplement Ephedra in 2004, for example, due to strong evidence of adverse effects and deaths due to use of the supplement, the company sued and the district court ruled in the manufacturer’s favor. The argument made by the company, and accepted by the district court, was that “by injecting a risk-benefit analysis, the FDA required [the manufacturer] to make a showing of the benefits of its product.” This would be inappropriate because in passing DSHEA “Congress expressly placed the burden of proof on the government to determine whether a dietary supplement” is unsafe.2 
The Tenth Circuit court agreed with the interpretation that the law requires no burden of proof be placed on supplement manufacturers to demonstrate the safety or efficacy of their products. However, it upheld the FDA ban on the basis that because the agency gathered all the data and conducted the analysis at its own expense and without requiring the company to prove any benefit to justify the risks identified, no inappropriate burden was placed on the manufacturer.2 At the risk of injuring myself, I have tried to imagine the public reaction to such a one-sided, industry-friendly regulatory system applied to the pharmaceutical companies, but the image of the resulting rhetorical conflagration is simply too horrible to contemplate.
In another case, a supplement manufacturer was denied permission to market their products with certain health claims on the label, due to a lack of sufficient scientific evidence to support the claims. The company sued the FDA, and the court of appeals found that denying the claims violated the company’s First Amendment commercial speech rights because the alternative of allowing the unproven claims accompanied by a disclaimer was not offered. The court did not challenge, or even address, the quality of the evidence for or against the specific claims. It simply ruled that not allowing them to be made, with appropriate disclaimers indicating the weakness of the evidence or the lack of FDA approval, was unduly restrictive of the company’s speech rights and represented a “simplistic view of human nature or market behavior” that did not give adequate credit to the ability of consumers to judge the merit of such claims for themselves.3
These cases illustrate, yet again, the priorities and concerns of justices and lawmakers with regard to the use of alternative medicine, which are often quite different from those of scientists and healthcare providers.
Where Do We Go From Here?
This series has been a relatively superficial survey of a complex subject, but hopefully I have been able to illustrate a few key issues. First, the scientific facts of claims made about alternative therapies, and the importance of using appropriate and effective epistemological methods to establish those facts, must be the foundation of a rational public policy concerning these therapies. Whether an intervention helps or harms or both is vital to the process of determining how government should approach regulating that intervention. However, the lawmakers and justices who shape public policy towards medicine are seldom themselves experts in scientific methods and the information they generate. To effectively argue the case for science-based medicine, we must understand the way the processes and data of science appear to smart, educated non-scientists, and we must be effective in communicating about science to such people. 
While I don’t want to wade too far into the debates surrounding science communication, I would recommend looking at the work of Michael Nisbet, Randy Olson, and Chris Mooney, all somewhat controversial figures who make a variety of interesting arguments about the most effective ways to communicate about science to the general public. If nothing else, these arguments are good for stimulating a healthy debate about how to promote science and science-based medicine in a culture not as friendly to science as it once was.
In addition to not necessarily understanding the nuances of scientific evidence, policy makers also have other agendas and sometimes have to serve their constituencies even when that means promoting policies based on unscientific or even irrational foundations. There are legitimate philosophical questions about the rights of the individual versus the power of the government, the most effective way to organize and run healthcare delivery systems, and other issues that are not primarily scientific but which influence law and policy concerning science and medicine. In promoting science-based and rational policies, we must take these other issues into account. And the plain political reality remains that if enough people, or people with enough influence, support an idea, it is unlikely to be effectively combated through law and regulation even if it is inherently unscientific and not in the best interest of the public health. Such ideas are better addressed through education and lobbying to alter public opinion rather than through legal or regulatory avenues.
I’ve tried in these posts to provide a rudimentary familiarity with the basics of how the laws that govern medicine in this country relate to the practices of alternative medicine. Hopefully, this will be useful in informing our efforts to advocate for science-based medicine and further marginalize unsafe and ineffective medical approaches.
References
     1.  Borneman JP, Field RI. Regulation of homeopathic drug products. Amerian Journal of Health-System Pharmacy 2006;63:p. 86-91. 
     2.  Nutraceutical Corporation v Von Eschenbach, Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, 459 F.3d 1033 (2006). Cited in: Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 208-10. 
     3.  Pearson v. Donna Shalala, Secretary, United States Department of Health and Human Services United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia 164 F.3d 650 (1999). Cited in: Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 214-17. 

2026: State Legislatures as Vectors of Health Misinformation and Anti-Science
Anti-science health legislation doesn’t just reflect misinformation; it institutionalizes it, cementing false beliefs into population-level risks.
Scott Gavura on February 12, 2026
Link

For many years, Science-Based Medicine has documented the troubling trend of state legislatures increasingly substitute ideology for evidence in public health policy. This trend that accelerated during the COVID-19 pandemic. No one chronicled this more diligently than Jann Bellamy, who read the bills most of us did not, and showed how sometimes subtle legal changes could erode real-world protections against infectious disease and medical misinformation.
I wish Jann were still blogging. That work matters even more now. The volume of legislation targeting vaccines, public health authority, and other evidence-based safeguards has not slowed. It has accelerated. As recently reported by the Associated Press,
Trump administration officials are directing activists to push anti-science legislation in the states – where public health authority rests – with the ultimate goal of changing laws and minds nationally.
These actions are the next step of an anti-science agenda: Normalizing anti–public health beliefs by formally incorporating misinformation into law. And it is happening at a moment when the consequences are no longer theoretical. As measles surges and vaccination rates fall below critical thresholds in some communities, lawmakers are advancing bills that weaken school immunization requirements and constrain public health responses to outbreaks. These policies do not merely reflect a misunderstanding of science. They are designed to cement it, transforming false beliefs into laws that will produce population-level harm for years to come.

One of the most obvious examples is the renewed push to weaken or eliminate school immunization requirements. Bills introduced or advanced in multiple states in 2025 (350 of them in 43 states, by AP’s count) target vaccines in different ways: from expanding non-medical exemptions, removing or weakening mandates, instituting waiting periods, or even requiring blood banks to test for evidence of vaccinations. Two Minnesota bills even call mRNA vaccines “weapons of mass destruction”!
These laws are often positioned as protecting parental rights, but their public health effect is predictable: lower immunization rates, more unvaccinated children, and increased risk of outbreaks that inevitably affect those who did not opt out, including infants, immunocompromised individuals, and others in whom vaccines are less effective.
This is not a controversial point in science-based public health. Protection against measles and other communicable and contagious diseases depends on maintaining vaccination rates above a critical threshold, typically around 95 percent. When coverage drops, the risk of transmission rises sharply, particularly in communities where the under-vaccinated cluster, geographically or socially. (This is why outbreaks tend to begin in pockets of low vaccination and then spread outward.) School immunization requirements were designed precisely to prevent this – not to limit individual (or “parental”) autonomy, but to preserve a level of collective protection to a community that no individual decision is certain to provide on its own.
As the same column by the Associated Press noted, this anti-science push extends well beyond vaccination policy. In some jurisdictions, legislators have moved to eliminate community water fluoridation, despite decades of high-quality evidence showing substantial reductions in dental caries, particularly among children and lower-income populations. Elsewhere, bills have been introduced to make the sale of raw (unpasteurized) milk easier, increasing access to a product that carries a well-documented risk of serious foodborne illness without any demonstrated health benefit. Framed as protections against government overreach, these measures instead disable proven public health interventions and safeguards, or promote higher-risk alternatives, substituting belief and ideology for evidence with predictable consequences.
The invisibility of public health
Public health protections are often invisible when they work. Vaccination requirements, water fluoridation, and disease response authority don’t attract much attention until they are weakened or removed. The evidence supporting them is not new, or subject to serious scientific debate. These policies exist because they reduce harm at the population level, particularly for those who cannot protect themselves.
What we see now is a greater willingness of legislators to ignore evidence in favor of sentiment and belief. Well-organized lobbying is making it harder for legislators to ignore. The result we can expect is not increased freedom, but predictable, preventable harm. The most dangerous misinformation may not be the kind that people believe, but the kind that governments enforce.


Regulating Fringe Practitioners
Fringe professions like chiropractic and naturopaths are not adequately regulated. This needs to be fixed.
Steven Novella on January 2, 2019
Link

Licencing health professionals is one of the major ways in which healthcare is regulated. The primary goal of such regulation is to protect the public from fraud and quackery and to maintain high standards of practice and professionalism. But what happens when fringe practitioners, such as chiropractors or naturopaths, gain licensure?
Two recent incidents in Canada highlight the dilemma of regulating unscientific practitioners, and the menace this can potentially pose to the public. The first relates to the ability of naturopaths to call themselves “medically trained.” Scott Gavura wrote about this case in New Brunswick last week. Briefly, a naturopath claimed he went to “medical school” and was therefore medically trained. As Scott pointed out:
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of New Brunswick recently conducted an investigation and found that 41 per cent of the province’s naturopaths were using restricted terms like “physician” and “medical practitioner” in contravention of New Brunswick’s Medical Act.
But what happened when a complaint was filed with the naturopathic board that regulates naturopaths? They decided the saying he went to “medical school” was not misleading because his naturopathic college was also listed on the website. This, of course, is nonsense. Anything that blurs the lines between real medical training and the pseudoscientific farce that naturopaths engage in is inherently misleading. The public, in fact, is highly confused about the true nature of naturopaths. I have had people on multiple occasions argue that naturopaths are legitimate because they can call themselves “doctor” and they get “medical training,” etc.
I don’t see how there is any other way to interpret this other than as a deliberate attempt to portray themselves as legitimate doctors, to position their practices as primary medical care – and it’s essentially working. But the deeper problem here is that this is allowed to happen largely because the regulation of naturopaths is largely in the hands of other naturopaths.
This is the bait and switch that often happens when fringe practitioners push for licensure. They argue to politicians that it will regulate the profession, and thereby protect the public and raise standards. That is what regulation is supposed to do. But once they have licensure, the foxes are put in charge of the hen house. Regulation is used to protect the profession and practitioners – not the public.
Let’s turn to the second case, also in Canada, this time in Ontario and dealing with chiropractors. As reported in The Globe and Mail, regarding recent criticisms of how chiropractic is regulated:
The College of Chiropractors of Ontario (CCO), they contend, is putting members’ interests above those of the public and has allowed assertions, including the ability to prevent cancer, to go unchecked. Some believe that, for the sake of public health, CCO council members who hold “vitalistic” views should resign.
The criticism stems from a case in which an Ontario chiropractor, Brian Nantais, claimed in the advertising for a workshop, that nerve blockage:
weakens the body, weakens the cells, weakens the immune system, weakens the very things that fight cancer.
The obvious implication here is that chiropractic manipulation of the spine can help treat cancer, which is not science-based on any level. To make such a claim is nothing short of fraud. The CCO heard the complaint and determined that all that needed to be done was for Nantais to add the word “may” in front of these claims, because they found the claims plausible, if unproven.
Again – the deeper problem here is that there are four chiropractors on the CCO board who are vitalists, like Nantais. Chiropractic has its origins in the vitalistic notion that a life force (called innate) travels through through the nerves of the body, and blockages of nerves can impeded the flow of innate and cause illness. Unblocking this vital force unleashing unlimited healing power. A century of subsequent medical science has determined that such claims are without any basis.
Nantais continues making such claims. For example, he claims to be able to treat allergies:
An allergy is an adverse immune system raction [sic) to a substance that is normally considered harmless to the human body. Dr. Nantais’s approach is to evaluate your spine & Nervous System to determine if you have nerve interference. If nerve supply is diminished, the goal of Dr. Nantais is to restore your body to heal at 100%, and therefore decrease your allergy symptoms naturally. NO DRUGS!!!
And of course, if you believe this vitalistic premise, you can put any disease or illness in place of allergies and make the same claims.
The end result of licencing practitioners who are not science-based is that fraud and pseudoscience now has the imprimatur of legitimate medicine, the public is largely confused about the true status of these practitioners, and the regulatory process is used to promote rather than prevent harm to the public.
There are solutions, however. The “nuclear option” would be to simply end licensure of fringe professions that are not adequately based in reality. This is the option I advocate, and is the only true solution that adequately protects the public and promotes high standards of health care. But I also recognize that realizing this option is politically difficult.
It is also true that within chiropractic at least there are practitioners who at least advocate for evidence-based practice, and themselves are critical of vitalistic and non-evidence-based chiropractors. Among them is Dr. Ammendolia:
The early November story prompted what Dr. Ammendolia, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto and a chiropractor himself, called a “huge outcry in the profession that something needs to give and something needs to change.”
Both Dr. Ammendolia and Professor Joe Schwarcz, director of McGill University’s Office for Science and Society, have suggested what I also have advocated – that these professions should be regulated by an outside body that can hold them to objective science-based standards. This would mean disciplining practitioners who harm or deceive patients, and setting evidence- based standards of practice (not just claiming to for promotional purposes). It also allows for clear policing of the scope of practice.
Having objective science-based regulation would go a long way to mitigating the harm done by licensing fringe practitioners, and could force them to eliminate at least their most harmful practices. This should also include regulating what claims they are allowed to make, and this brings us to the second measure – making clear distinctions between real medical practitioners and “alternative” practitioners.
We already have a standard for medical training and practicing as a primary care physician. There is no reason to establish separate, and far weaker, standards. All this does is confuse the public and allow charlatans to pretend to be doctors.
You are a medical doctor if you have an MD. No other health practitioner should be allowed to call themselves a “doctor” or claim to have medical training, or claim to provide primary care. (As an aside, there are already regulations in place for nurse practitioners and similar allied professions, so that is a separate issue.)
Further, regulation should prevent scope of practice creep. Practitioners are tireless at lobbying for a greater scope of practice, like the ability to prescribe drugs or be reimbursed for annual physicals or general health maintenance. Finally, they should not be allowed to claim to treat or cure diseases.
Together these regulations would allow these professions to continue to exist, but protect the public to some degree against deception and fraudulent practice. Chiropractors can still provide symptomatic treatment for uncomplicated acute lower back strain – the only indication for which there is adequate evidence for efficacy. I’m honestly not sure what would be left if all the pseudoscience was stripped from naturopathic practice.
One thing is clear – at present these non-medical professions are generally poorly regulated, putting the government in the position of sanctioning and promoting health fraud and collaborating in making the public more vulnerable to deception and exploitation. This is the exact opposite of what health regulatory bodies should do. This needs to be fixed.

   Is “CAM” Fraud?
Published by Jann Bellamy
Link
During my continuing education about so-called “complementary and alternative” medicine one question presents itself in my mind over and over: Isn’t that fraud? Well, is it?
And by “CAM,” I mean …
The book Snake Oil Science, by R. Barker Bausell, defines “Complementary and Alternative” therapies as “physical, mental, chemical, or psychic interventions … practiced in the absence of both
    • scientific evidence proving their effectiveness and
    • a plausible biological explanation for why they should be effective,
and their practice continues unabated even after
    • …there is scientific evidence that they are ineffective and
    • …their biological basis is discredited.”
(Emphasis added.)
Science Based Medicine has given us an abundance of examples supporting Dr. Bausell’s definition: homeopathy, subluxation-based chiropractic , energy healing , acupuncture , and so on.
Fraudulent Misrepresentation
Unfortunately for ‘CAM” products and practitioners, there is no equivalent of “alternative medicine” in the law. “Conventional law” will have to do for our analysis. In “conventional law,” fraud can be a crime, a breach of contract or a tort. Here we will confine our analysis to fraud as a tort, that is, a private or civil wrong, independent of contract, and more particularly the tort of fraudulent misrepresentation.
Tort law varies from state to state, and a discussion of the law of fraudulent misrepresentation in all 50 states (plus assorted other U.S. jurisdictions) is beyond the scope of this post. However, the Restatement of Law 2d, Torts,1 [hereinafter, the Restatement] is widely regarded as the best compilation of current law on the subject. “The Restatements … are famous as an effort to bring analytical coherence into nonstatutory fields of law otherwise marked by a flood of discrete instances and judicial rationalizations of divergent results.”2 Where the law is in flux, they offer recommendations based on policy grounds. The Restatements of various areas of the law (Torts, Contracts, Agency, and so on) are highly respected and often cited in court opinions.
According to the Restatement, Sec. 525, if A
     1.  fraudulently makes a misrepresentation of fact, opinion, intention or law to B
     2.  for the purpose of inducing B to act (or refrain from acting),
     3.  A is liable to B for B’s monetary loss
     4.  caused by B’s justifiable reliance on the misrepresentation.
“Monetary loss” includes loss caused by physical harm in cases where there is a duty to disclose a fact. Restatement, Sec. 557A. “Misrepresentation,” as you might guess, means that the representation is “untrue,” “not in accordance with the facts.”3 Actions for fraudulent misrepresentation (as distinct from malpractice) have been successfully maintained against health care providers, including M.D.s, dentists and chiropractors.4
Let’s consider more closely that first element: under what conditions is a misrepresentation considered fraudulent? That is largely a question of intent (or “scienter”). But, contrary to what some may think, actual lying is not required to hold one accountable. According to the Restatement, Sec. 526,
A misrepresentation is fraudulent if the maker
     1.  knows or believes that the matter is not as he represents it to be,
     2.  does not have the confidence in the accuracy of his representation that he states or implies, or
     3.  knows that he does not have the basis for his representation that he states or implies.
Subsection (a.) describes what we colloquially call “lying.” But subsection (b.) and (c.) do not require actual knowledge that one’s statement is false to impose liability. According to the Restatement’s comments to Sec. 526, which further explain its meaning, A cannot state to B that X is a fact when A merely believes it is a fact but recognizes there is a good chance it is not true. This is sometimes referred to as making a statement “recklessly,” careless as to whether it is true or false. Nor can A tell B that he knows X to be a fact based on his personal knowledge or investigation, or imply that this is the case, when A actually has no personal knowledge or has not made an investigation, even where A is honestly convinced of the truth of his representation.
Misrepresenting Science
Lack of scientific evidence as misrepresentation\
To understand “CAM” in the context of fraudulent misrepresentation, let us first consider the sale of goods and services outside the “CAM” area. Will the lack of scientific evidence for a product’s or service’s claims support a cause of action for fraud?
The tobacco cases provide an excellent example of how one industry misrepresented the scientific evidence and got burned for its efforts. Here, we’ll look at just one of the many cases brought against a tobacco company for, among other things, fraudulent misrepresentation.
In Henley v. Philip Morris,5 the defendant tobacco company claimed on appeal that there was insufficient evidence to support the jury’s finding of liability on plaintiff’s claim of fraudulent misrepresentation. The court thoroughly rejected that argument:
Our review of the record satisfies us that there was substantial evidence that [defendant] engaged in a conscious, deliberate scheme to deceive the public, … about the health hazards and addictive effects of cigarette smoking. The jury could properly find that … defendant and other cigarette manufacturers acted both in concert and individually to issue innumerable false denials and assurances concerning the dangers of smoking, deliberately fostering a false impression by the public … that assertions of health risk were overblown … , that any real hazards had yet to be shown, and that the industry itself was acting and would act diligently to discover the scientific truth of the matter and promptly disclose its findings, good or bad. The jury could also find that plaintiff … was falsely led to believe, as defendant intended, that there was a legitimate ‘controversy’ about whether cigarettes actually caused cancer or carried any other serious health risks.
Does this remind anyone of another fairly recent controversy regarding the safety of a certain “CAM” procedure, discussed here, here
and here?
In addition, defendant argued that its statements were “opinions,” not statements of fact, and were therefore not actionable. That argument was equally unpersuasive to the court:
This argument relies on the general rule that statements of opinion will not support an action for fraud, while ignoring the exception … applicable to any statements of opinion: ‘[W]hen one of the parties possesses, or assumes to possess, superior knowledge or special information regarding the subject matter of the representation, and the other party is so situated that he may reasonably rely upon such supposed superior knowledge or special information, a representation … though it might be regarded as but the expression of an opinion if made by any other person, is not excused if it be false. … Further, if a statement of opinion ‘misrepresents the facts upon which it is based or implies the existence of facts which are nonexistent, it constitutes an actionable misrepresentation.’ … The jury here was entitled to find that insofar as any of defendant’s statements constituted opinions, they implied the existence of superior knowledge as well as a state of facts that did not exist.
In another example, a number of claims for fraud were brought against Amoco for false advertising arising out of Amoco’s assertions regarding its gasoline’s benefits.6 In one of these cases, plaintiff claimed that the following representations were “made without any competent and/or scientific substantiation”:
‘The clear color of Amoco Ultimate gasoline demonstrates the superior
engine performance and environmental benefits Amoco Ultimate provides compared to other premium brands of gasolines that are not clear in color;
A single tankful of Amoco Silver or Ultimate gasoline will make dirty or clogged fuel injectors clean … ’
Do you notice a certain similarity between Amoco’s second claim and those made for colonic irrigation?
Thus, the answer is yes, as common sense would indicate, lack of scientific evidence, or distortion of the actual evidence, for a product or service will support a cause of action for fraudulent misrepresentation. Even if the misstatement would otherwise qualify as an opinion, it is actionable fraud if the statements imply superior knowledge and are based on non-existent “facts.”
Implausibility as misrepresentation
It is difficult to find cases discussing the other element of Dr. Bausell’s “CAM” definition—lack of a plausible basis in science (as opposed to lack of scientific evidence for claims about the product or service). Of course, outside of ‘CAM,” what sort of product or service would fit that description? Levitation lessons? A perpetual motion machine? Man-capturing perfumes? In fact, yes, all of these have elicited the judicial equivalent of “you gotta be kidding!”
In Hendel v. World Plan Executive Council and Maharishi International University,7 plaintiff sued for fraud arising out of defendants’ claims that, according to her complaint, courses in Transcendental Meditation would allow her to “attain certain extraordinary powers, such as clairvoyance, ability to levitate, ability to fly, invisibility, and superhuman strength.” In addition, she “would ultimately become a ‘Master of Creation’ with the ability to manipulate the physical world and the laws of nature.”
The court did not reach the merits of her fraud claim, finding instead that her suit was barred by the statute of limitations. However, in reaching that conclusion, the court did remark that defendants’ representations were such that “any reasonable person would recognize as being contrary to common human experience and, indeed, to the laws of physics.” This meant plaintiff should have been on notice earlier that she was being defrauded.
Similarly, in Waterman v. Haumaier,8 the laws of physics prevented one party from claiming he could justifiably rely on representations in an agreement which “closely approach the concept of the perpetual motion machine … [S]uch machines … are impossible in light of the First Law of Thermodynamics,” citing Handbook of Chemistry and Physics (64th ed. Weast 1983).
Less specifically, but equally based on scientific implausibility, in Gottlieb v. Schaffer,9 the court found that various perfumes the seller claimed would allow the wearer to “control men” (“Desire” perfume), to make a man “stay close to you” (“Nirvana”), “make men obey you” (“Command”), and so on, were so “patently absurd” that no proof of their falsity or intent to deceive was necessary due to “the universality of scientific belief that [such] advertising representations are wholly unsupportable.” The Gottlieb case was decided in 1956, which makes me think the perfume seller was simply ahead of his time and could have marketed his product as a combination of aromatherapy and energy medicine in today’s market.
Thus, both the lack of a plausible basis in science and the lack of scientific evidence for claims made for products or services are well-recognized as “misrepresentations” which will support a cause of action for fraud. Now let’s apply the law of fraudulent misrepresentation to a few hypotheticals involving “CAM.”
B, the poor devil10
Acupuncture
Imagine that A is an M.D. practicing family medicine. His patient, B, has long complained of back pain, but has not found relief in any of the remedies A has prescribed. The doctor, being an “integrative” practitioner, suggests acupuncture, which he has learned to perform, might help B’s pain, adding that he has “seen it work” in other patients. B justifiably takes all of this to mean that acupuncture is an effective treatment for back pain, and relies on that representation. B undergoes a series of 12 treatments, which costs about $1,200. In fact, A is aware, from his undergraduate education in the sciences and his medical education and training, that the basic principles of acupuncture are highly implausible and, having reviewed the literature, knows there is no good evidence that it is effective. Thus, A knows that his express and implied representations of the effectiveness of acupuncture for back pain are “not as he represents [them] to be” within the meaning of Sec. 526(a). Therefore, all the elements of a cause of action for fraudulent misrepresentation under Sec. 525, are present.
Naturopathy/Homeopathy
Next, let’s suppose that A is an N.D. licensed to practice naturopathy in her state. B, her patient, has the flu, so A prescribes oscillococcinum, which she describes to B as a homeopathic flu remedy. A, having taken classes in chemistry and physics, has her doubts about homeopathy, but she does not express them to B. B justifiably relies on A’s advice because A is a licensed health care provider. B takes the homeopathic remedy, but continues to suffer because, as we know, homeopathic remedies cannot be, and have proven not to be, effective. As a result, B is out the cost of the remedy plus additional monetary losses due to the physical harm caused by ineffective treatment, which delays her seeking medical care for the flu, which progresses into pneumonia. A’s conduct has thus satisfied the definition of fraudulent misrepresentation under Sec. 526, subsection (b), as she knew when she prescribed oscillococcinum that homeopathy is inconsistent with the laws of chemistry and physics and therefore could not be confident that it was, in fact, an effective remedy. In other words, she did “not have the confidence in the accuracy of [her] representation that [she] states or implies.” All the elements of a cause of action under Sec. 525 are present.
Chiropractic
Assume A is a D.C. B visits his office for the first time, complaining of headaches. A explains to B that he is suffering from subluxation of a cervical vertebrae, the cause of his “cerviocogenic headache,” and that cervical manipulation will reduce the subluxation, thereby allowing the body’s self-healing ability to function properly. B asks A about the safety and effectiveness of this treatment. A responds that “the scientific evidence for the safety and effectiveness of chiropractic care is overwhelming.” He adds that “over the past twenty years, many controlled clinical research studies have shown that chiropractic care is safe and effective for back pain, neck pain and headaches.”11 B justifiably relies on these statements due to the chiropractor’s presumed superior knowledge on these subjects.
In fact, A has not reviewed the recent literature on the scientific validity of the chiropractic subluxation, which does not support its existence. Nor has he reviewed the recent literature on the safety and effectiveness of cervical manipulation for headaches, which does not support his unequivocal statement. He is simply repeating statements in a patient brochure he purchased in bulk for his office. Unfortunately, the cervical manipulation causes B to suffer a vertebral artery dissection and subsequent stroke, resulting in lifelong disability. A’s conduct satisfies the definition of fraudulent misrepresentation as he did not actually investigate the literature and therefore “knows that he does not have the basis for his representation that he states or implies.” This is so even though he “is honestly convinced of its truth from hearsay or other sources that he believes to be reliable.” Restatement, Sec. 526(c), and comment (f). All the elements of a cause of action for fraudulent misrepresentation under Sec. 525 of the Restatement are present.
Reiki
Finally, assume A, a licensed massage therapist in her state and a reiki practitioner, places an ad for her services in the newspaper, and is contacted by B, who asks for more information. A tells B that reiki is based on the idea that there is a universal, or source, energy that supports the body’s innate healing abilities. Practitioners seek to access this energy, allowing it to flow to the body and facilitate healing. A adds that people use reiki for relaxation, stress reduction, and symptom relief, in efforts to improve overall health and well-being and that reiki has been used by people with anxiety, chronic pain, HIV/AIDS, and other health conditions, as well as by people recovering from surgery or experiencing side effects from cancer treatments. A tells B that if it is inconvenient for her to come in, A can practice reiki from a distance, that is, when B is not physically present in the office. B tells A she suffers from chronic anxiety and pain and schedules an appointment. A tells B after her first session that the standard for treatment is at least four sessions of 30 to 90 minutes each.12 B ultimately ends up attending 10 sessions, and having reiki performed without her presence twice, which costs her $1,000 total.
In a departure from the previous hypotheticals, it is not certain that B can satisfy all the elements of proof to succeed on a claim of fraudulent misrepresentation against A. A’s description of reiki’s purported mechanism of action is clearly contrary to the laws of physics, so much so that one can argue the average person should be aware of its implausibility. Even if B can prove that A knew, or should have known this, reiki’s very implausibility might keep B from being able to prove she justifiably relied on A’s statements, as was the case in Waterman. Hendel, although decided on a different issue, points to the same result. However, for the purposes of our discussion below, let’s assume the facts in this hypothetical satisfy all the elements of a cause of action for fraudulent misrepresentation under Sec. 525.
A license to defraud?
I’ve concluded that all the elements of a cause of action for fraudulent misrepresentation are present in each hypothetical. However, that is not the same as concluding the plaintiff will succeed (assuming he or she can prove the allegations of the complaint) because in any suit the defendant can plead and prove an “affirmative defense” which defeats the plaintiff’s claim. By way of example, one common affirmative defense is failure to bring an action within the time provided by the statute of limitations, as was the case in Hendel, above. Ms. Hendel may have had a textbook claim of fraudulent misrepresentation against the defendants, but because she waited too long to bring her suit, the defendants won on their affirmative defense that her claim was barred by the statute of limitations.
So what affirmative defense might be raised to defeat claims of fraudulent misrepresentation brought by B against A?
Again we turn to the …
Restatement:
“Sec. 890 Privileges
“One who otherwise would be liable for a tort is not liable if he acts in pursuance of and within the limits of a privilege …”
Sec. 10 of the Restatement further describes the types of consent and how they are created. Some privileges are based on the consent of another. The most familiar of these to readers of SBM is likely consent to medical treatment, so that the person who cuts one open with a sharp object will not be liable for battery if that person is a surgeon and one has consented to the surgery. We are not talking about that kind of privilege here even if consents to treatment were obtained as consent induced by fraud is invalid.
Other privileges are nonconsensual, and they can be either conditional or absolute. These privileges allow the A’s of the world to adversely affect the legally protected interests of the B’s of the world without their consent and to avoid liability for doing so. Absolute privilege is not applicable here. It is the conditional privilege which may form the basis of an affirmative defense in our hypotheticals.
“A person ‘who otherwise would be liable for a tort is not liable if he acts in pursuance of and within the limits of a privilege.’ … The term ‘privilege’ denotes the existence of circumstances that justify, or excuse, conduct that would ordinarily subject the actor to liability… . Conduct that would otherwise be actionable is held to be privileged as a matter of law where, under the circumstances, it furthers an interest of social importance.” Schultz v. Elm Beverage Shoppe,13 quoting, Restatment, Sec. 890.
However, a person is liable for any acts that are in excess of those permitted by the privilege. Thus, if A acts in self-defense during an attack by B, the privilege of self-defense against attack by another would protect him from liability for injury to B. But if A uses excessive force he has exceeded the scope of his privilege and the privilege will not protect him from liability for injuries caused by his use of unnecessary force. Restatement, Sec. 890, comment e.
Privileges can be based on a constitutional or statutory provision protecting the alleged wrongdoer’s interests even where the creation of the privilege is not specifically mentioned.14 A familiar example is the privilege protecting the media from a claim of defamation where the defamatory statement was published without malice or reckless disregard of the truth (and a few other requirements). This privilege is recognized by the courts to protect First Amendment freedoms, although obviously you don’t find actual language to that effect in the First Amendment.
The defendants in our hypotheticals can raise the affirmative defense of conditional privilege. The M.D., N.D., D.C. and L.M.T. would all argue that because their practice acts incorporate a right to perform the procedures which the patients claim are fraudulent, the practice acts create a privilege. In other words, the state legislatures, by incorporating implausible and evidence-free practices into the law, are protecting these practitioners from liability even if their patients can prove their representations are untrue and were made with the requisite intent to deceive.
The D.C. and the N.D. appear to have the best case for defeating the patient’s claim of fraudulent misrepresentation, as their practice acts incorporate their science-and-evidence-free procedures. All state chiropractic acts either explicitly or implicitly allow chiropractors to detect and correct “subluxations.”15 However, any privilege afforded by the practice act obviously would not extend to statements regarding the safety of cervical manipulation as that subject is not specifically addressed in the act. Likewise, because the naturopathy practice acts allow the use of homeopathy, the N.D. can plead privilege as an affirmative defense, although it could be argued that she exceeded the scope of her privilege by not disclosing her doubts about homeopathy.
The L.M.T’s claim of privilege would depend on whether her state included reiki in the definition of massage practice. If it does, the court could find that the statute creates a privilege. If not, there would no statutory basis for it, although she might argue that by virtue of the state’s allowing practices “taught in massage schools” (as some do) the practice act implicitly affords a privilege if her massage school training included reiki.
The M.D. is on shakier ground. While some states have enacted statutes protecting physicians to a certain extent in using “CAM”16 it is unlikely those would protect an M.D. who believed in neither the plausibility nor effectiveness of the treatment but, at least impliedly, represented otherwise to the patient. In addition, some of these statutes protect a physician solely from disciplinary action for using CAM and arguably create no privilege in a civil action. Thus, even though the M.D.’s scope of practice is broad, it does not insulate physicians from knowingly making false claims about a therapy.
In response to claims of privilege, plaintiffs could argue that a nonconsensual privilege which defeats their right to recover damages for fraudulent misrepresentation should not be recognized unless it protects some important public interest. Restatement, Sec. 10, comment (d.); Sec. 890, comment (a.). Certainly there is no important public interest served by allowing health care practitioners to make demonstrably false representations to patients.
Conclusion
So, is ‘CAM’ fraud? According to the Snake Oil Science definition, it most certainly is misrepresentation. Whether it is fraudulent misrepresentation depends on whether one of the three elements required for establishing fraudulent intent can be proved: knowing misrepresentation, reckless misrepresentation, or stating (or implying) a basis for the misrepresentation that one does not actually have. As criticism of CAM for scientific implausibility grows and study after study fails to support claims of effectiveness, we may reach a point where it becomes impossible for the CAM practitioner to avoid knowing that CAM is based on misrepresentations, making it much harder to defeat claims of fraudulent misrepresentation. Key to this will be the courts’ refusal to interpret the state practice acts as creating a privilege which allows CAM practitioners to avoid liability for defrauding their patients.
References
     1.  Restatement of the Law 2d, Torts, American Law Institute (1979) Return to text
     2.  U.S. Nat. Bank of Oregon v. Fought, 630 P.2d 337, 352 (Or. 1982) (Linde, J., concurring). Return to text
     3.  Black’s Law Dictionary (4th Ed. 1968) Return to text
     4.  Ohlsson GL, Malpractice Considerations in Complementary Medicine, in Louisell & Williams, Medical Malpractice, Sec. 17D.04 (Matthew Bender 2010) Return to text
     5.  114 Cal. App. 4th 1429, 1465-66, 9 Cal. Rptr. 3d 29, 62 (Cal. App. 1st Dist. 2004), cert. den., 544 U.S. 92, 125 S. Ct. 1640 (2005) Return to text
     6.  Oliveira v. Amoco Oil Co., 776 N.E.2d 151, 156, n. 2 (Ill. 2002) Return to text
     7.  705 A.2d 656 (D.C. App. 1997) Return to text
     8.  222 B.R. 40, 1998 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 10124 (S.D.N.Y. 1998)141 F.Supp. 7 (S.D. N.Y. 1956) Return to text
     9.  Because B, through no fault of his own, is the second letter in the alphabet, he is constantly subjected to A’s actions, both devious and innocent, in the legal literature: A sells B real property A doesn’t own, rear ends B in traffic, shoots B in self-defense, fails to deliver goods B has purchased, and so on. Return to text
     10.  This is actually a direct quote taken from a video about the safety and effectiveness of chiropractic featuring Rick McMichael, D.C., described as the president of the American Chiropractic Association. The video appears on the Sharecare website. http://www.sharecare.com/question/chiropracticcareeffective According a Sharecare press release, the site was created by Dr. Mehmet Oz and Jeff Arnold. Return to text
     11.  http://static.sharecare.com/docs/SharecareLaunchRelease100710.pdf?v=47 Return to text
     12.  This description is taken almost verbatim from the NCCAM website. “Reiki: An Introduction,” http://nccam.nih.gov/health/reiki/introduction.htm. Return to text
     13.  40 Ohio St. 3d 326; 533 N.E.2d 349, 351 (1988) Return to text
     14.  See, e.g., New York Times v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254, 84 S.Ct. 710 (1964) Return to text
     15.  Bellamy JJ, Legislative Alchemy: the state chiropractic practice acts, Focus Alt & Comp Ther; 15: 214-222 Return to text
16. Cal Bus & Prof Code Sec. 2234.1 (2010); Fla.Stat. Sec. 456.41 (2010) Return to text

   “CAL”: a Medico-Legal Parable
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Preamble
From the fall of 2000 to the winter of 2002, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts convened a Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners. There were 12 members: 6 legislators, 3 MDs, a naturopath, a lawyer who represented the New England School of Acupuncture, and the chairman, who was also the Director of the Massachusetts Division of Professional Licensure. At the start of deliberations two things became apparent: first, the Commission would concern itself almost exclusively with the petition of “naturopathic physicians” to become licensed health care practitioners in the Commonwealth*; second, there were only two recognizable, medically-sophisticated skeptics among the members. They were Arnold “Bud” Relman, the emeritus editor of the New England Journal of Medicine (appointed by the Massachusetts Board of Registration in Medicine), and I (appointed by the Mass. Medical Society). We expected a third, an MD soon to be appointed by the Commissioner of Public Health, Dr. Howard Koh.
Within a few weeks it became clear that the third MD would not be a skeptic. Dr. Koh, apparently thinking he had found an expert, appointed as his representative David Eisenberg, Director of the Harvard Medical School (HMS) Division for Research and Education in Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies. Dr. Koh must not have known that in 1997 Dr. Eisenberg had called for
A national listing of licensed alternative medical providers (e.g., chiropractors, acupuncturists, massage therapists, naturopaths, and homeopaths) in each of the 50 states as well as a uniform credentialing process.
Commissioner Koh also must not have known that Dr. Eisenberg had received or was currently receiving funds from several sources committed to furthering the ambitions of ”CAM” practitioners in general or of “naturopathic physicians” in particular: the NCCAM, the Fetzer Institute, the New York Chiropractic College, Cambridge Muscular Therapy Institute, New England School of Acupuncture, American Specialty Health Plan, and the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine.
Dr. Eisenberg directed an annual conference that was funded by several of those institutions and that offered continuing education credits for acupuncturists, chiropractors, “massage therapists and bodyworkers,” and “naturopathic physicians.” He and his right-hand man Ted Kaptchuk had shown a substantial interest in the selling of “CAM,” not merely in its “Research and Education,” and in 1999 they had joined naturopaths from Bastyr, National College of Naturopathic Medicine, and University of Bridgeport College of Naturopathic Medicine at a conference on “Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Chronic Liver Disease,” co-sponsored by the NIH and the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians.
After Dr. Eisenberg’s appointment, it became clear that he would not be coming to most of the meetings. Instead he sent his “Director of Legal Programs,” attorney Michael Cohen. Mr. Cohen was also committed to the goals of naturopaths and other “CAM” practitioners, and at the time was on the Advisory Board of the American Association for Health Freedom—a lobbying organization of quacks. Neither Dr. Eisenberg nor Mr. Cohen disclosed their associations to members of the Commission or, I presume, to Dr. Koh. Dr. Relman and I were yet too green and too busy with other matters to discover them ourselves. When I finally began to dig, I reported several of my findings to Dr. Daniel Federman, the Dean of Alumni at HMS, whom I had formerly respected and trusted. That is a long, disappointing story, partially told here and here. Suffice it to say that it does not provide an exception to the rule that everyone has his price.
What Dr. Relman and I did recognize during the early deliberations of the Special Commission is that we were fighting an uphill battle for rational medicine. We also found that we would not be getting any help from Eisenberg, whom the other members presumed to be the expert on the topic. As we delved into naturopathic practices and claims, it was obvious to us that they were absurd and dangerous (see here and here for examples that we presented to the Commission), but our points were met with blank stares or worse.
During one meeting I attempted to get the Commission’s attention by citing a naturopathic recommendation for treating an acute asthma attack by placing the patient in a bath containing “a cup or so of 3% hydrogen peroxide in the water to bring extra oxygen to the entire surface of the skin, thus making the lungs somewhat less oxygen hungry.” Shortly thereafter, the chairman of the Commission, William Wood, pronounced that the differences of opinion between MDs and naturopaths amounted to nothing more than a “battle of the bands.”
That and similar experiences led me to try “alternative” arguments that I hoped might jar commission members to understand what had failed to impress them when presented in a direct way. If I could argue from legal concepts instead of from biological or medical ones, perhaps the several lawyers in the room would finally get it. Perhaps, for example, I could make them realize that naturopathic claims had the same validity for health and disease as “spectral evidence” had for jurisprudence. This seemed especially appealing to me, given the irony of our deliberating not far from the hallowed ground upon which Massachusetts Royal Governor William Phips had put a stop to the Salem Witch Trials a little more than 300 years before.
It didn’t work; I was met with more blank stares. To this day I don’t know whether the lawyers and legislators in the room knew little of an important chapter in the histories of their own profession and Commonwealth, or whether they understood exactly what I was saying but ignored it because the fix had been in from the start. Nevertheless, I later decided that it might be fun to turn the story of my experiences on the Special Commission and in investigating “naturopathic medicine” into a parable, similar to Steve Novella’s “Alternative Engineering” on Quackwatch. I wrote most of it a few years ago; it didn’t seem that good, and I forgot about it until Mark Crislip posted his “Alternative Flight” here on SBM in January. I hauled it out of the mothballs of my hard drive; it still isn’t that good, but what the heck? I decided that it would be useful for a week when I had little time or inclination to do the real digging, and I’ve been on vacation for a week, so here it is.
“CAL”: a Medico-Legal Parable
The Natural Law School (NatchL) was recently created. Its founders and professors state that it teaches the same basic subjects as “conventional” law schools, but also offers a curriculum that is complementary to stodgy old Conventional Law (ConLaw). It integrates modern legal theory with vis litigatrix naturae, “the legal power of nature.”[1] This refers to the body politic’s innate power to heal its own disputes. Natural Lawyers “treat the underlying causes of conflict, rather than merely eliminate or suppress social and interpersonal altercations.”[2] The school draws from the traditions of many indigenous legal systems around the world, because it recognizes that Western Law doesn’t have a monopoly on truth. Its students, the professors tell us, are taught the same rules of evidence that ConLaw students learn, and can pass an NLBEX (natural law bar exam) to prove it.[3,4] According to the NatchL website, its graduates’ “scope of practice includes all aspects of family law, and all natural legal modalities.”[5]
The school asserts that it teaches natural, gentle legal remedies, instead of the more arduous ones that are so prevalent in Conventional Law.[2] Conventional Lawyers haven’t bothered to read NatchL literature, so they aren’t sure what those gentle legal remedies might be. They know a little about alternative approaches to resolving disputes, however, and thus assume that NatchL must stress arbitration and mediation instead of litigation. Many Conventional Lawyers are impressed that the President of NatchL has been invited to serve on a White House Commission that will consider the new Complementary and Alternative Law (CAL), which, by all accounts, is sweeping the land.[6] NatchL faculty and graduates want to know why Natural Lawyers shouldn’t be admitted to the bar, eligible to become judges, and entitled to all the other privileges pursuant to Conventional legal training.
The State Bar Association appoints a Conventional Lawyer to a State Commission that will consider the petition of NatchL grads to be admitted to the bar.[7] Natural Lawyers have already been admitted in a few states, and several legislators and a few constituents feel that it is a no-brainer to admit them here, especially when there are other people offering natural legal advice and calling themselves Natural Lawyers, but who didn’t graduate from NatchL. Shouldn’t the public be protected from impostors?
The Conventional Lawyer takes his charge seriously and looks into the field of Natural Law in some detail. To his great surprise he discovers, by reading the Textbook of Natural Law,[8] the NatchL course catalog,[9] and other Natural Law literature widely available in the public domain, that while NatchL students take courses nominally pertaining to “conventional” rules of evidence, they are also taught that many “alternative” rules are equally valid. Among the latter are Spectral Evidence, Psychic Testimony, Intuitive Evidence, Past Lives Evidence, Alien Abduction Evidence, Recovered Memory Evidence, and Polygraphs.[10-15] Natural Law School even offers a course in Comparative Heart Weighing, which its catalog describes as
…the most comprehensive and one of the world’s oldest systems of jurisprudence. It encompasses physical, mental and spiritual aspects of human justice and is introduced in the light of its twentieth century revolutionary reformation and resynthesis, with brief history of its competitive existence, stature and staying power.[16]
The Conventional Lawyer finds numerous other departures from modern legal theory and practice, many that were discredited generations ago and others that are contrary to basic legal principles. One of them, Star Chamber Justice,[17] is said by NatchL faculty to have been suppressed in the 17th century “when Conventional Law first began to achieve hegemony as the dominant Western legal system,” but now has been rediscovered, and “even many Conventional Lawyers admit that its adjudications are not completely due to caprice.”[18] Another, the Rack and Screw, has been out of favor in the West for many years but has achieved a large following and a reputation for effectiveness in parts of the Middle East.
The Conventional Lawyer finds that there doesn’t seem to be an effort by the leaders of Natural Law to curb these practices; on the contrary, the leaders themselves advocate them. They are even formalized in the Position Papers of the American Association of Natural Lawyers (AANL).[19] Moreover, he finds no evidence that admission of Natural Lawyers to the bar in other states has protected the public, because all of these practices and more—including some not even taught at NatchL —are promulgated in continuing legal education courses listed by the few state Natural Law Bar Associations.[20]
The Conventional Lawyer concludes that he can’t support the petition of Natural Lawyers to be admitted to the bar, and writes the Commission’s report to the state legislature explaining why.[21] Oddly, this turns out to be the Commission’s “minority” report. The majority feels that the tenets of Natural Law are irrelevant to the Commission’s deliberations, because what really matter are schools, accreditations, standardized exams, a national organization, and other trappings of legitimacy.[22] After all, Natural Law is an “emerging profession” and therefore can’t be expected to have accumulated as many court opinions or law review articles as has Conventional Law.[23,24] Moreover, as the Chairman of the Commission himself observes, the differences between Natural and Conventional Law amount merely to a “battle of the bands,” with neither side having more claim to truth than the other.[25]
The Conventional Lawyer subsequently writes an article for the online LawScape General Law Review (GenLawRev) describing some of his findings.[26] He doesn’t discuss Conventional Law because that isn’t the article’s purpose. The article is read by Natural Lawyers, including the leaders of NatchL and AANL. They write letters to the editor of GenLawRev complaining that Natural Lawyers don’t actually do any of the things that the author has asserted, but that those practices are nevertheless supported by thousands of law review articles.[27-31]
Those correspondents and others, including some ConLawyers, write that the Conventional Lawyer who wrote the article shouldn’t talk, because look at how bad Conventional Law is. They say that it’s obvious from ConLaw’s failure to convict O.J. that CAL must have a lot to offer. Some write that the thousands of wrongfully convicted prisoners in the Conventional criminal justice system prove Natural Law’s validity. Apparently (they don’t actually say) these writers believe that if Spectral Evidence or Psychic Testimony had been admissible at those trials, justice would have prevailed.
A couple of Conventional Lawyers write particularly angry letters decrying the author’s statements and conclusions.[32,33] They say that he must be “flagrantly biased,” presumably because he used examples such as Past Lives Evidence, but they don’t say which of his statements are inaccurate. These two Conventional Lawyers haven’t investigated Natural Law literature themselves. They just know that the author is wrong because they are acquainted with a few Natural Lawyers and find them to be very nice people. One of the Conventional Lawyers suggests that the short time she has to spend with clients must mean that Natural Lawyers have something important to teach Conventional Lawyers, and she is ashamed that she did not learn this in law school.[32] The other Conventional Lawyer, who is the recipient of $1 million in public funds earmarked for sympathetic studies of CAL, cites Shakespeare to show the author the error of his ways.[33]
The author responds to these letters, imagining that some readers might be persuaded by reason.[34]
1. Inspired by: Bastyr University website. Information about Naturopathic Medicine. Accessed 1/04 at: http://www.bastyr.edu/academic/naturopath/
2. Inspired by: American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. Principles. Accessed 1/04 at: http://web.archive.org/web/20030818114817/http://www.naturopathic.org/about/principles_.html
3. Inspired by: Naturopathic physicians are rigorously trained. Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges website. Accessed 2/08 at: http://www.aanmc.org/nat_med/trained.php
4. Inspired by: North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners website. Accessed 2/08 at: http://www.nabne.org/
5. Inspired by: Bastyr University website. Information about Naturopathic Medicine. Accessed 1/04 at: http://www.bastyr.edu/academic/naturopath/
6. Inspired by: White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy. Commission Members. Joseph E. Pizzorno, Jr., N.D. Accessed 3/07 at: http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/whccamp/members/jep.html
7. Inspired by: Reports of the Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners. Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Division of Professional Licensure. Website. Last modified 12/11/02. Available at: http://web.archive.org/web/20030220062958/http://www.state.ma.us/reg/current/2002medp/
8. Inspired by: Pizzorno JE, Murray MT, eds. Textbook of Natural Medicine. 2nd ed. London, England: Churchill Livingstone; 1999.
9. Inspired by: Bastyr University Course Catalog. 2001. Accessed 3/08 at: http://web.archive.org/web/20010430174446/bastyr.edu/catalog/courses/
10. Wikipedia contributors. Spectral evidence. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. February 3, 2008, 22:19 UTC. Available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Spectral_evidence&oldid=188896279 . Accessed February 29, 2008.
11. Rowe WF. Psychic Detectives: A Critical Examination. Skeptical Inquirer. 1993;17(2):159-165
12. Bloomberg D. Can an Idiot Be Psychic? Book review of The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Being Psychic By Lynne Robinson and LaVonne Carlson-Finnerty Alpha Books, New York. 1999. ISBN 0-02-862904-3. Skeptical Inquirer Sept/Oct 1999. Available at: http://www.csicop.org/si/9909/book-review.html Accessed 1/04.
13. Blackmore S. Abduction by Aliens or Sleep Paralysis? Skeptic Inquirer May/June 1998. Available at: http://www.csicop.org/si/9805/abduction.html Accessed 1/04.
14. Canadian Psychological Association. Guidelines for Psychologists Addressing Recovered Memories. Approved by CPA, 1996 (updated 2001). Available at: http://web.archive.org/web/20050516202732/http://www.cpa.ca/recmem.pdf
15. Zelicoff AP. Polygraphs and the National Labs: Dangerous Ruse Undermines National Security. Skeptical Inquirer July/August 2001. Available at: http://www.csicop.org/si/2001-07/polygraph.html Accessed 1/04.
16. Inspired by: Bastyr University Catalog 2003-2004. NM9541 Yunani System of Health and Healing. (p.104). Accessed 1/04 at: http://www.bastyr.edu/ftp/Catalog03-04.pdf
17. Wikipedia contributors. Star Chamber. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. February 29, 2008, 01:45 UTC. Available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Star_Chamber&oldid=194802041 Accessed February 29, 2008.
18. Inspired by: Linde K, Clausius N, Ramirez G, et al. Are the clinical effects of homeopathy placebo effects? A meta-analysis of placebo-controlled trials. Lancet. 1997 Sep 20;350(9081):834-43. Abstract available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=9310601&dopt=Abstract
19. Inspired by: American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. Position Papers. Available at: http://web.archive.org/web/20031202204818/http://www.naturopathic.org/positions/positions_and_practice.html Accessed 5/08.
20. Inspired by: Oregon Board of Naturopathic Examiners. Continuing Education. Accessed 1/04 at: http://web.archive.org/web/20040213222559/http://www.obne.state.or.us/conted.htm
21. Inspired by: Atwood KC, Ryder WJ. Minority Report of the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners, In Opposition to the Licensure of Naturopaths. Reported to the state legislature January 2002. Available at: http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Naturopathy/minority.pdf Accessed December 2003.
22. Inspired by: Multiple authors. Majority Report of the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners, favoring the licensure of naturopaths. Reported to the state legislature January 2002. Available at: http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Naturopathy/majority.pdf
23. Inspired by: Hough HJ, Dower C, O’Neil EH. Profile of a Profession: Naturopathic Practice. The Center for the Health Professions, University of California, San Francisco. 2001. P. IX. Accessed 3/08 at: http://www.futurehealth.ucsf.edu/pdf_files/Naturo2.pdf
24. Inspired by: Testimony offered by Barbara Silbert, President of the Massachusetts Association of Naturopathic Physicians, at the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners (2000-2002), to explain the paucity of rigorous, peer-reviewed literature supporting naturopathic methods.
25. Inspired by: Personal communication with Bill Wood, Chairman of the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners and Director of the Massachusetts Division of Professional Licensure, regarding naturopathic claims vs. critiques based on human biology and modern medicine. June 2001.
26. Inspired by: Atwood KC. Naturopathy: a critical appraisal. Medscape General Medicine 5(4), 2003. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/465994 Accessed 1/04
27. Inspired by: Zeitlin KF. We are all doctors. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470692
28. Inspired by: Boggs ND, Mittman P. Naturopathic medicine is an emerging field in one of medicine’s most dynamic eras. Letter. MedGenMed. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470702
29. Inspired by: Gagnier JJ. Interventions employed by accredited naturopathic medical schools and their practitioners prove efficacious. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470711
30. Inspired by: Shepherd TC. Professional agendas and mechanisms for standardized licensure exams do exist in teaching naturopathic medicine. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470700
31. Inspired by: Bongiorno PB, LoGiudice P. Naturopathic medicine is indeed legitimate, effective, and wanted. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470701
32. Inspired by: Jacobson J. Working toward more patient-centered integrative care. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470709
33. Inspired by: Katz DL. Acting in defense of the medical literature. Letter. MedGenMed. Posted 03/24/2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/470713
34. Inspired by: Atwood KC. Naturopathy, Pseudoscience, and Medicine: myths and fallacies vs. truth. MedGenMed 6(1), 2004. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/471156

CAM practitioners as primary care providers under the Affordable Care Act: Part 1
Jann Bellamy on August 22, 2013
Link
Section 2706 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 300gg-5) of the Affordable Care Act (the “ACA” or “Obamacare”) prevents “discrimination” against any health care provider acting within the scope of his or her state license. The provision, supported by the American Chiropractic Association and other CAM practitioners, was inserted, without a hearing, under the leadership of Sen. Tom Harkin. Sec. 2706 is of concern to advocates of science-based medicine due to the broad scope of practice granted chiropractors, naturopaths, homeopaths, acupuncturists and direct-entry midwives under state law, as well as their over-confident view of themselves and their abilities. As we have previously discussed, for example, both naturopaths and chiropractors fancy themselves as primary care physicians able to differentially diagnose any patient with any disease or condition and, in many cases, treat or “co-manage” these patients.
As might be expected, a brouhaha is brewing over just what Section 2706 means. And there is one attempt to repeal it outright.
In all cases of statutory interpretation, the proper starting point is the statutory language itself.
SEC. 2706. NON-DISCRIMINATION IN HEALTH CARE.
(a) PROVIDERS.—A group health plan and a health insurance issuer offering group or individual health insurance coverage shall not discriminate with respect to participation under the plan or coverage against any health care provider who is acting within the scope of that provider’s license or certification under applicable State law. This section shall not require that a group health plan or health insurance issuer contract with any health care provider willing to abide by the terms and conditions for participation established by the plan or issuer. Nothing in this section shall be construed as preventing a group health plan, a health insurance issuer, or the Secretary [of Health and Human Services] from establishing varying reimbursement rates based on quality or performance measures.
In short, while broadly prohibiting discrimination, there are two important limitations. This is not an “any willing provider law” requiring an insurance company to contract with any provider agreeing to the insurer’s contract. And insurers can pay different rates to different providers as long as these rates are “based on quality or performance measures.”
Rep. Andy Harris (R-MD), a medical doctor, is sponsoring a bill (H.R. 2817) to repeal Section 2706 outright. Last month, seven medical specialty societies sent a letter to Rep. Harris in support of his efforts. In their view,
it would become illegal “discrimination” under federal law for private individual and group health plans, and state-based health insurers, to make qualification distinctions among varying groups of physicians and other health care professions . . . We are deeply concerned that for certain covered services in a number of states, [Section 2706] will be interpreted to provide that all health professional groups be considered as if their education, skills and training were equal even if the state-based medical and healthcare professional licenses or certifications are very different.
CAM tizzy
Short of actual repeal, a debate is developing about how Section 2706 will be interpreted and applied.
The three agencies charged with administering the ACA (the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and Treasury) issued what little guidance they are offering at the moment in a “FAQ” format. No, the Departments said in answer to a question, they will not be issuing regulations interpreting this provision.
Until any further guidance is issued, group health plans and health insurance issuers offering group or individual coverage are expected to implement the requirements of . . . section 2706(a) using a good faith, reasonable interpretation of the law. For this purpose, to the extent an item or service is a covered benefit under the plan or coverage, and consistent with reasonable medical management techniques specified under the plan with respect to the frequency, method, treatment or setting for an item or service, a plan or issuer shall not discriminate based on a provider’s license or certification, to the extent the provider is acting within the scope of the provider’s license or certification under applicable state law. This provision does not require plans or issuers to accept all types of providers into a network. This provision also does not govern provider reimbursement rates, which may be subject to quality, performance, or market standards and considerations.
This got Sen. Harkin and the pro-CAM crowd in a tizzy. In response, the following was inserted into a committee report accompanying the 2014 appropriations bill for the Departments of Labor, HHS, Education and “related agencies.” The Appropriations Committee “is concerned” that the Departments “FAQ” response
advises insurers that this nondiscrimination provision allows them to exclude from participation whole categories of providers operating under a State license or certification. In addition, the FAQ advises insurers that section 2706 allows discrimination in reimbursement rates based on broad ‘‘market considerations’’ rather than the more limited exception cited in the law for performance and quality measures. Section 2706 was intended to prohibit exactly these types of discrimination.
The Committee advised the Departments to work together and issue new guidance within 30 days of the appropriations bill being passed (which has yet to happen) and in time for insurers to understand their obligations before Section 2706 goes into effect in 2014.
This is alarming indeed and is contrary to the plain language of the statute. Even though Section 2706 states that no insurer is required to contract with any particular provider, it appears Sen. Harkin and his committee think that each insurer must have at least one provider of each type licensed under a particular state’s law. And likely more, because if all provider types must be included then having only one or two could give the appearance that tokenism is afoot. Will insurers have to include CAM providers in all geographical areas? Will this require quotas?
John Weeks over at the Huff Po/Integrator Blog was even more apoplectic. According to him (even though this didn’t seem to bother the Harkin committee):
It doesn’t take a legal expert to read this document as a declaration that the plans and states can use “reasonable medical management techniques” to essentially blow off the section.
So insurers should not control “the frequency, method, treatment or setting for an item or service” with “reasonable medical management techniques” even if they are, well, reasonable? Of course, I can see where these controls might upset CAM providers. After all, “frequency” limitations might prevent chiropractors from convincing patients they need weekly “adjustments.” “Method” and “treatment” limitations could practically wipe out naturopathic practice coverage – no more colonic irrigation, peat baths, green tea suppositories, live blood analysis, and the like. And it would eliminate anything a homeopath could do.
What do chiropractors want?
Which brings us to an interesting question: what do CAM providers think should be covered under the ACA in order for insurers to be in full compliance with Section 2706? Chiropractors have been the most vocal, and we’ll look at what they are saying in this and the next post. We’ll also take a look next time at the views of naturopaths, acupuncturists and direct-entry midwives. But the short answer is: they want to be primary care providers and they want insurance to pay for it.
As we have seen, it doesn’t seem like Congress had chiropractors and naturopaths in mind at all when it defined primary care provider. Unfortunately, that doesn’t necessarily mean insurers will be able to avoid reimbursing chiropractors when they provide certain services normally provided by PCPs. In fact, if there is one thing you can be sure of, it is that chiropractors and other CAM providers will be screaming “foul” if anything they do (no matter how they do it) isn’t paid for if MDs, DOs, or nurse practitioners are being paid for doing it.
The ACA requires insurers to cover certain “essential health benefits” (or “EHBs”):
     1.  Ambulatory patient services
     2.  Emergency services
     3.  Hospitalization
     4.  Maternity and newborn care
     5.  Mental health and substance use disorder services
     6.  Prescription drugs
     7.  Rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices
     8.  Laboratory services
     9.  Preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management
     10.  Pediatric services, including oral and vision care
An article just out from Chiropractic & Osteopathy focuses on how chiropractors might claim a slice of the insurance reimbursement pie by providing “evidence-based clinical preventive services.” (The ACA eliminated co-pays for those services rated A or B by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force [USPSTF].) According to the authors, except for recommendations on screening and counseling for infectious diseases, the following services are within the scope of chiropractic practice in most states:
Screening
    • Alcohol misuse
    • Colorectal cancer
    • Depression
    • Diabetes (type 2)
    • Hearing Loss
    • Hypertension
    • Iron deficiency anemia
    • Obesity
    • Osteoporosis
    • Tobacco use
    • Lipid disorders
    • Vision
Counseling/interventions
    • Alcohol misuse
    • Breastfeeding
    • Folic acid supplement
    • Iron deficiency anemia screening
    • Obesity weight management
    • Tobacco use intervention
Abdominal aortic aneurysm (ultrasound), breast cancer (mammography) and cervical cancer screening, and aspirin for CVD prevention, are noted as not within the chiropractic scope in most states, which implies that they are within the scope of practice in some. (Note that we are talking only about preventive services here, which is only a portion of the coverage chiropractors want. Should you wish to see what chiropractic treatment of diabetes might look like, you can read about it here.)
The authors admit, however, that even though the listed services are within the chiropractic scope of practice, “many chiropractic college faculty do not have specific training in clinical preventive services.” Instead of adding additional coursework to the DC curriculum, they recommend that basic science material like microbiology and biochemistry could be reduced in favor of more on health behavior and education.
Clinical education for the vast majority of chiropractic students takes place in small chiropractic college clinics as a requirement for the DC degree. (MD and DO primary care physicians must undergo an additional 3 years of clinical training in primary care after getting a medical or osteopathic degree.) Here’s how the authors propose to incorporate training into the DC curriculum:
it seems quite feasible to simply “get more mileage” out of existing standardized and actual patients. That is, rather than restricting the history and examination to vital signs, orthopedic, neurological, postural or palpatory findings, simply broaden them to include BMI assessment, health habits and other lifestyle factors. In fact, many and perhaps most chiropractic colleges already do include lifestyle in the history. The next step, not uniformly taken as yet, would be to require students to counsel patients on changing risky health behaviors. These patients may be presenting for musculoskeletal complaints, or like many patients in chiropractic teaching clinics, may be presenting for “wellness care.” These are opportunities to screen for health risks, particularly those which are extremely common, such physical inactivity and overweight/obesity, and to counsel patients when the risks are present. Thus, current patients (both standardized and actual) could provide opportunities for screening and counseling at the same time that they are being treated for symptoms/conditions.
The authors’ advice contains some stunning, and most certainly unintentional, admissions about deficiencies in chiropractic education and training that are at odds with any number of claims otherwise, a subject we’ll look at in more depth in the next post.
First, at this point, chiropractic schools aren’t educating and training students in preventive care. Second, chiropractic education and training is woefully inadequate to support chiropractic scope of practice. After all, the authors listed many screening and counseling/intervention services recommended by the USPSTF as within the scope of chiropractic practice. Yet, they admit these same services are not part of chiropractic education. Furthermore, in their recommendations for improving clinical education, I don’t see anything about, for example, how to screen for breast or colorectal cancer, lipid disorders, vision, or hearing loss. And breastfeeding? Well, chiropractic “pediatricians” do claim that “subluxations” in an infant’s spine can lead to breastfeeding difficulties. I suppose they may be learning that. Third, apparently practically all patients present with musculoskeletal complaints or for wellness care, not with the broad range of patient presentations typical of primary care clinical training and practice. This goes not only to their lack of training, but also demonstrates that the public doesn’t consider chiropractors as suited for preventive care even when they are using them for “wellness care.”
Wellness care?
If there is one so-called preventive health technique chiropractors are being trained for and are using, it is certainly “wellness care.” But it is nothing you will find in the USPSTF recommendations. Nonetheless, according to the 2012 chiropractic journal article Consensus Process to Develop a Best-Practice Document on the Role of Chiropractic Care in Health Promotion, Disease Prevention, and Wellness, wellness care is most certainly part of the DC primary care tool kit. But as it is with many aspects of chiropractic practice, the term “wellness care” means different things to different chiropractors.
To some it is synonymous with “maintenance care”, that is, periodic “adjustments” of “subluxations” to improve overall health and prevent disease and “for prevention of future musculoskeletal disorders.” This is ironic, considering their emphasis on USPSTF recommendations, because the Task Force has concluded “the evidence is insufficient to recommend for or against the routine use of interventions to prevent low back pain in adults in primary care settings.” And you can bet if there were some evidence in favor of interventions they wouldn’t include maintenance care. Other chiropractors use the term more broadly, meaning a combination of maintenance care along advice about such things as exercise. Still others don’t recommend maintenance care at all. According to these authors, there is currently no evidence to either support the “theory” underlying maintenance care or to reject it. An odd position considering there is no evidence subluxations exist.
Thus, the authors undertook what they describe as:
The first attempt at developing a comprehensive set of best-practice statements that address the issues of providing wellness care within the context of chiropractic practice. It is a synthesis of the best current evidence and collective expert opinion about a reasonable clinical approach to health promotion within chiropractic practice.
The first attempt? They’re just getting around to this in 2012?
So, based on “the best current evidence and collective expert opinion” is “maintenance care” an appropriate part of health promotion, disease prevention, and wellness in chiropractic practice? Yes, the only limitation being that chiropractors shouldn’t use it “without counseling on lifestyle and screening for risk factors.” Or, at least, they shouldn’t call it “wellness care” without this window dressing.
All of this raises some interesting questions regarding coverage of chiropractic services under the ACA. For example, will chiropractors be able to bundle an episode of “maintenance care” into a screening package and bill the insurance company for it? And if the medical specialty societies are correct and insurers won’t be able to take into account differences in education and training, must insurers cover, for example, breastfeeding advice and lipid screening by chiropractors, even when they have little, or no, training in these areas? Or use bogus methods? And if the chiropractor gets to the patient first and bills for an annual panel of screening tests and preventive care advice (no matter how poorly done), will the primary care physician have to eliminate those items from his billing, or do them for free? What if he sees that the chiropractor has botched the diabetes screening or sold the patient on a bunch of dietary supplements as “nutritional advice?”
Next time, we’ll look into what the chiropractic industry associations are saying about chiropractors and Obamacare coverage for primary care, as well how naturopaths, acupuncturists and direct-entry midwives see themselves as PCPs.

CAM practitioners as primary care providers under the Affordable Care Act: Part 2
Jann Bellamy on September 5, 2013
Link
In the last post, we took another look at Section 2607 of the Affordable Care Act, which prohibits “discrimination” against licensed CAM practitioners by insurers, and how chiropractors are continuing their PR campaign to rebrand themselves as primary care physicians. This time, we review a recent white paper by the Academic Consortium of Complementary and Alternative Healthcare, an organization that might be seen as CAM’s answer to the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine (CAHCIM). The Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care (ACCAHC) is a group of “complementary and alternative medicine” educational organizations representing chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists, homeopaths, ayurvedic practitioners, direct entry midwives and massage therapists. The executive director is John Weeks, a relentless promoter of “integrative medicine,” both on the Integrator Blog website and in the Huffington Post. The ACCAHC is dedicated to ensuring that its members and the practitioners they represent are included in all aspects of health care, such insurance reimbursement, financial resources for education and delivery models. ACCAHC’s stock-in-trade is its practitioners’ supposed expertise is being patient-centered, holistic, taking into account the whole person and such, as well as an alleged emphasis on healthy lifestyles, nutrition, well-being, and the like.
In fact, the stated vision of the ACCAHC is remarkably similar to that of the CAHCIM:
ACCAHC envisions a healthcare system that is multidisciplinary and enhances competence, mutual respect and collaboration across all healthcare disciplines. This system will deliver effective care that is patient centered, focused on health creation and healing, and readily accessible to all populations.
The CAHCIC’s vision is:
A comprehensive and compassionate health care system offering seamless integration of effective complementary and conventional approaches to promote healing and health in every individual and community.
Indeed, there is an overlap in governance of the two organizations. Benjamin Kligner, MD, Adam Perlman, MD, Mary Jo Kreitzer, PhD, RN, and Aviad Haramati, PhD, are all on the ACCAHC’s Board of Advisers, as well as being either current or former members of the CAHCIM’s Executive Committee. The Board of Advisers also includes other integrative medicine luminaries such as Brian Berman, MD, Wayne Jonas, MD, and David Katz, MD. The two organizations have worked together in several endeavors. One wonders why the they don’t just go ahead and merge. (Actually, one knows perfectly well why they don’t.)As might be imagined, actual evidence that CAM practitioners can deliver on the lofty generalities of its vision and mission is in short supply. That has not stopped the ACCAHC from several initiatives aimed at cheerleading its way into modern healthcare. In this it has attained some success, according to its website.
The ACCAHC has issued “Meeting the Nations Primary Care Needs: Current and Prospective Roles of Doctors of Chiropractic and Naturopathic Medicine, Practitioners of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, and Direct-Entry Midwives,” a white paper “developed through the Primary Care Project of the ACCAHC,” under the editorship of Michael S. Goldstein, PhD, of the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research and John Weeks, published in March, 2013.
The paper laments that, despite the shortage of MD/DO primary care physicians and the consideration of other health care providers as means of addressing this gap, such as nurse practitioners and physicians assistants,
workforce analyses and healthcare delivery practices have not to date engaged the potential contributions of chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists and direct-entry midwives as providers of primary care.
Thus,
the goal of this paper is to assist policy makers, regulators, third-party payers, delivery system administrators, practitioners, and other concerned parties as well as the disciplines themselves in considering the optimal use of these professions as part of the nation’s primary care matrix.
Toward this end, teams were chosen by the Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges, Association of Chiropractic Colleges, Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, and the Midwifery Education Accreditation Council to set forth how each field meets, or does not meet, “conventionally used definitions of primary care.” (The Midwifery Education Accreditation Council has jurisdiction over direct-entry midwives. These midwives do not have the equivalent education and training of nurse midwives. I will not cover their portion of the paper in this post.)
We should note here that, according to one of the “conventional” definitions of primary care referenced in the paper, primary care includes the ability to meet the health care needs of the “undifferentiated patient”, that is
persons with any undiagnosed sign, symptom, or health concern . . . not limited by problem origin (biological, behavioral, or social), organ system, or diagnosis.
(From the American Academy of Family Physicians [AAFP], 2010)
According to the same definition, primary care physicians must also be able to “treat acute and chronic illness in a variety of health care settings.” This is not all that they do, of course. The AAFP’s definition of primary care also includes health promotion, disease prevention, health maintenance, counseling, patient education, promotion and maintenance of wellness.
In supposedly answering the question posed, the paper provides a lot of platitudinous statements about wellness, health promotion, patient-centered care, the whole person, natural remedies, the body’s self-healing abilities, and so on. There is also a great deal of talk about being a “first contact” provider for patients, insurance coverage, what the scope of practice acts say, the fact that this or that provider is called a “physician” or “doctor,” what government programs include or do not include, accreditation by the U.S. Department of Education, what their patients think about them and other information not directly relevant to two key components of primary care practice if one is to practice independently, without supervision of an MD or DO. If these components are not part of the practitioner’s skill set, then he or she shouldn’t be claiming rights to the PCP title.
To determine whether these key components are present two questions must be answered: (1) does the chiropractor, naturopath, or acupuncturist have the education, training and ability to see the undifferentiated patient in his office and know what to do with her, that is, can he diagnose the undifferentiated patient, either deciding to treat her or refer her to another provider? And, (2) does he have the education and training to treat acute and chronic illness in a variety of health care settings?
Let’s see how this paper addresses these critical aspects of primary care because, if CAM practitioners can’t convincingly argue that they can do these things safely and effectively, they shouldn’t be considered for the job, credulous legislators aside.
“Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine Practitioners in Primary Care”
(Statement approved by Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine)
The acupuncturists admit that they do not have sufficient “biomedical training” (their term) to serve as primary care providers if one’s definition of primary care means that the practitioner meets all of the biomedical and health needs of the patient. Depending on which accreditation agency oversees a particular acupuncture school, students have between 450 and 588 hours of biomedical training, although the subject matter and quality of these courses is not addressed. They add that there have been no published studies examining AOM providers as primary care providers.
However, like chiropractors, there is a faction within acupuncture which supports the development of acupuncturists as primary care practitioners. This group formed the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, but the organization has not been recognized as an accrediting body by the U.S. Department of Education. The authors believe acupuncturists must reach a consensus that they want to be PCPs before this idea moves forward, but “the acupuncture terrain is rapidly changing and this situation could change within 3-5 years.”
Oddly, they say that
there has been an opinion within the CAM community that a one year primary care training program would prepare AOM practitioners to work within mainstream medicine, with training similar to that of a physician assistant (PA).
One year?
The authors note that there are three states (California, Florida and New Mexico) which define acupuncturists as “primary care physicians” in their practice acts. These statutes
imply that providers in these states provide comprehensive biomedical care commensurate with the training of a primary care biomedical provider. This issue has led to some providers within the profession to assume that they have the same primary care mandate as a medical doctor or nurse practitioner without the commensurate level of biomedical training and to push for an expanded role within primary care, even with the current level of training in the US.
On the other hand, the authors vigorously defend their ability to be a first contact health care provider seeing patients who have not been seen by a medical doctor, provide care for those who do not need “more intensive biomedical care” either initially or during the course of being under an acupuncturist’s care, and are trained to make both emergency and non-emergency referrals when necessary. No matter what their actual education and training, the authors point to studies that patients actually used acupuncturists for musculoskeletal complaints, anxiety, depression and other mood disorders, and other conditions including digestive disorders, respiratory disorders, urinary and reproductive disorders, infections conditions, autoimmune disorders, headaches, fatigue, stress, and allergies, among others.
“The Chiropractic Profession and Primary Care”
(Endorsed by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges)
The chiropractors claim, right off the bat, that they are primary care physicians. This is based on the Council on Chiropractic Education, the American Chiropractic Association, International Chiropractors’ Association and other chiropractic organizations saying that they are. The authors say that chiropractors can practice as a first-contact provider for patients of all ages and genders, assess a patient’s health status, formulate a clinical diagnosis, develop a case management plan that includes treatment, prognosis, and any necessary referrals. They can (according to the ACA) address “a large majority of personal health care needs.” The ICA says that the chiropractor can “provide all three levels of primary care interventions and therefore is a primary care provider, as are MDs and DOs.” The authors further claim that chiropractors “are trained to appropriately diagnose and manage the majority of healthcare issues that may present to their offices.”
If that is the case, it is certainly not proven in this document. Although studies and various surveys were cited, none supports the claim that DCs are capable of acting as primary care physicians nor do they support the assertions made by the CCE, the ACA or the ICA.
The chiropractor portion of the white paper ends by seeking to bifurcate primary care into two different types: primary medical care and primary health care. This allows the authors to hold forth on two of the CAM practitioners favorite subjects: how “holistic” they are and how bad medicine is.
The distinction aligns with the holistic biopsychosocial model of health as opposed to the biomedical focus on disease alone. . . Primary health care pays attention to both objective and subjective findings; it is truly patient-centered. Instead of medical specialists, the emphasis is on generalist health professionals who are trained and willing to work together. In this view, while primary medical care is dominated by medical physicians and internally focused on its own institutions and behaviors, primary health care explicitly seeks community participation and a wide range of professionals, always working the with patients as partners in the relationship.
However, in discussing barriers to chiropractors playing a greater role in primary care, the authors have (most certainly unintentionally) provide an unflattering picture of what chiropractic primary health care would look like. They note that some payers won’t “reimburse DCs for primary care services. An egregious example is that Medicare that pays for manipulative treatment but not for the diagnostic work that must precede it.” What they are referring to is the fact that Medicare pays for manual manipulation of the spine to correct a “subluxation” but does not reimburse for an x-ray to “detect” the subluxation. Of course, the chiropractic subluxation doesn’t exist and it can’t be detected at all, on an x-ray or otherwise. The “holistic biopsychosocial model” indeed.
“Naturopathic Physicians in Primary Care”
(Endorsed by the Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges)
Naturopaths, as did the chiropractors in their report, like the Institute of Medicine’s definition of primary care because of its appealing vagueness when plucked from the context in which it was created.
Primary care is the provision of integrated, accessible health care services by clinicians who are accountable for addressing a large majority of personal health care needs, developing a sustained partnership with patients, and practicing in the context of family and community.
The actual 1996 IOM report from which this definition is taken is 400-plus pages long. Nowhere in the report does it indicate that the IOM thinks medical education and residency should be chucked for PCPs or that chiropractors or naturopaths should be primary care physicians. (Quite the contrary – see chapter 7.) Yet naturopaths seem to think that declaring they can meet the IOM definition, without knowing what the IOM was talking about, is sufficient to claim the role:
By philosophy, training and practice, modern naturopathic primary care satisfies these criteria by providing individualized, comprehensive, patient-centered care for all conditions and demographics.
Does it? Let’s look at the evidence presented.
There is virtually nothing about naturopathic education and training in the report, much less any hard evidence that it is sufficient to support a PCP scope of practice. (Mark Crislip came to a similar conclusion in his review of an earlier attempt by naturopaths to convince us.) In attempting to address their lack of clinical education, they make the curious argument that, since most primary care occurs in community settings and in-patient care is provided by hospitalists, their lack of hospital-based training is not problematic. The authors apparently hold the misguided impression that training in a hospital is simply for learning about “hospital-managed pathology” (their term) and therefore unnecessary. (Of course, this also ignores the 3 additional years of clinical training an MD or DO primary care physician must undergo.)
As for research, the authors claim that naturopathic “principles are continually being reexamined in light of scientific advances.” But in the very next paragraph, they say that some naturopaths specialize, giving as an example the specialty of homeopathic medicine, a naturopathic principle that is most certainly not examined in the light of science at all, much less scientific advances. They then go on to claim:
Although the literature based on naturopathic outcomes in disease and health is limited, there is increasing evidence demonstrating effectiveness and cost-effectiveness.
Eleven studies (one of which was addressed by David Gorski here) are cited, but they don’t tell us what these studies actually concluded. There is also a reference to the Naturopathic Physician’s Research Institute but that is equally unimpressive. Some of this research is downright disturbing, such as “Safety and efficacy of oral DMSA therapy for children with autism spectrum disorders: part B – behavioral results.” This study, done at the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine,
investigated [DMSA’s] use for an off-label application, namely treating children with ASD who have evidence of significant heavy metal exposure (based on urinary excretion after DMSA challenge). DMSA preferentially binds to lead, but can also increase the excretion of several other toxic metals (including tin, bismuth, thallium, mercury, antimony, and tungsten) to a lesser extent. Another paper resulting from this study discusses the strong correlation of the initial severity of autism with the body burden of toxic metals.
The urine toxic metals test is a scam and the “theory” that the severity of autism is correlated with any “burden of toxic metals” is quackery.
Conclusion
What the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care white paper demonstrates more than anything is that the state practice acts for chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists give all of these practitioners a scope of practice that far exceeds their abilities. Acupuncture practice is more limited in most states but, as the acupuncturists themselves noted, they have a scope of practice in three states they are not properly educated or trained to assume. Even where they are not specifically defined by law as PCPs, they believe they can see the undifferentiated patient as an acupuncture and oriental medicine provider, while referring patients when they need “biomedical” care. Yet they fail to realize that without “biomedical” education, they cannot reliably determine when such care is required.
Chiropractors in all states can see any patient with any disease or condition, although there are a handful of diseases they are, by law, prevented from treating. The same is true for naturopaths in most states where they are licensed. But given the opportunity to present evidence that they can safely and effectively act as primary care physicians, that is, first contact providers who can diagnose and treat (or safely refer) all patients, they have fallen far short.
The ACCAHC has unwittingly provided an excellent resource for anyone lobbying for reform of the CAM provider practice acts. This is especially true in light of Section 2607 of the Affordable Care Act, which mandates reimbursement based on scope of practice allowed by the state, not the provider’s actual abilities.

Repealing Legislative Alchemy
We need to repeal federal and state laws that allow quackery and pseudoscience in healthcare.
Jann Bellamy on October 12, 2017
Link

Three decades ago, our elected representatives thought quackery a sufficient threat to physical, mental and financial health to warrant an exhaustive four-year study of its deleterious effects and a 250-page Congressional subcommittee report condemning the assault of pseudoscience on the American healthcare system. The report defined “quackery” as:
The promotion of medical remedies known to be false or which are unproven for a profit, usually by means of false representations that they will “cure” or aid in the cure of various diseases and problems. Quackery is pseudoscience at its best.
Acupuncture, subluxation-based chiropractic, Gerson therapy, fad diets, herbs, glandulars, hydrotherapy, and energy healing, among others, were condemned as pseudoscience harmful to the public. As a remedy, the report made several suggestions to alleviate victimization of the public by quacks: increased government enforcement efforts, increased criminal penalties, more consumer education, strengthening medical licensing statutes to make practice of medicine without a license a felony, and more patient protection when non-standard therapies are offered.
So much for that idea. Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, the last 30 years have seen Congress and the state legislatures weaken consumer protections against quackery and incorporate the very pseudoscience Congress itself warned against into state and federal law.
Even when legislators aren’t directly incorporating pseudoscience into the law, they fail to realize how other laws (such as the Medical Device Amendments, which we’ll get to in a moment) don’t include proper controls to prohibit their use by quacks for pseudoscientific diagnoses and treatment.
I’ve written about Legislative Alchemy many times on SBM. But individual instances cannot properly convey the magnitude of the problem. In this post, I attempt to collect the various laws which legalize pseudo-medicine, describe how they operate to the detriment of our health care system and patients, and offer solutions. Altogether, they paint a grim portrait of the extent to which pseudoscience is baked into our healthcare system by clueless legislators. (Feel free to add your own examples.)
Federal laws
Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA)
What it does: DSHEA was written by the dietary supplement industry and it shows. It allows vitamins, minerals, herbs, enzymes and desiccated animal organs (glandulars) to be sold based on vague claims of benefit to body “structure” and “function,” terms no one seems to understand but often misinterpreted as meaning supplements can prevent or treat disease. Sellers are supposed to have evidence to back up their claims but are not required share it with the FDA or the public. Premarket regulation is limited to minimal registration requirements, labeling standards and good manufacturing practices. The FDA must wait until it learns of contamination or adverse events before acting and burden is on the FDA to prove product is unsafe. The FDA has a $5 million budget and about two dozen staffers to police the entire industry.
What this means:Dietary supplements are a $41 billion a year industry in the U.S. Yet, supplements have failed to live up to the hype that they are effective in preventing or treating disease and some actually increase the risk of disease. Adulteration with undisclosed ingredients, including prescription drugs, poses health risks. In addition to over-the-counter sales, supplements serve as an economic engine for “integrative medicine” and “functional medicine” practitioners, naturopaths, and chiropractors, who prescribe them both for prevention and treatment of disease without adequate evidence of safety or effectiveness. These practitioners then sell the prescribed supplements to their patients at a profit.
What needs to happen: DSHEA should be scrapped and a new regulatory scheme put in place. Vitamins and minerals should be sold in reasonable doses with adequate evidence supplied to buyers of the need for dietary supplementation. Herbs and desiccated animal organs are simply unpurified drugs and should be required to meet pre-market safety and efficacy standards based on well-conducted clinical trials before health claims can be made. Good manufacturing standards and post-market surveillance should be beefed up.
Food, Drug, & Cosmetic Act of 1938: Homeopathic Drugs
What it does: All homeopathic products on the U.S. market today, whether over-the-counter (OTC) or prescription (most homeopathic remedies are OTC), fall within the definition of “drug” in the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act of 1938. Yet the FDA has, without statutory authority, exempted homeopathic drugs from the regulatory scheme mandated by federal law. Instead, both prescription and OTC homeopathic drugs have been manufactured and sold without FDA approval under enforcement policies set out in the FDA’s Compliance Policy Guide (CPG) 400.400, “Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed.”
What this means: The overwhelming scientific consensus is that homeopathy is highly implausible, unsupported by scientific evidence, ineffective in treating illness and, when relied upon instead of actual medicine, dangerous and even deadly. Yet homeopathic remedies are a $3 billion a year business in the U.S., sold widely in drugstores and other retail locations, online, and by naturopaths and other health care practitioners who prescribe them. (Homeopathy is an integral part of naturopathy.)
What needs to happen: This one is easy. The FDA should simply follow the law and require all homeopathic drugs to comply with the same statutes and regulations as all other OTC and prescription drugs. Two years ago, the FDA sought public comment on homeopathic remedy regulation but, so far, has done nothing. Fortunately, the FTC, on the other hand, has announced it will do its job and follow the law:
The FTC will hold efficacy and safety claims for OTC homeopathic drugs to the same standard as other products making similar claims. That is, companies must have competent and reliable scientific evidence for health-related claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions.
Medical Device Amendments of 1976 to the Food, Drug & Cosmetics Act: Laboratory-Developed Tests
What it does: The FDA regulates most in vitro diagnostic devices (IVDs) as medical devices. (A limited number are regulated as biological products, a topic we won’t get into here.) IVDs analyze human samples, such as blood, saliva, tissue and urine. However, in the past, the agency did not use its authority to regulate what are known as “laboratory-developed tests” (LDTs), tests developed and performed at a single laboratory, with all samples sent to that particular lab for testing. Instead, it focused on commercial tests kits, which are broadly marketed to laboratories or the public. The latter had to undergo the same pre-market approval process as other medical devices regulated by the FDA, including, in some cases, clinical studies demonstrating that the device is safe and effective for its intended use.
Historically, LDTs were developed by hospitals, researchers and academic medical centers for their own use. That is no longer true. In the past 15 years or so, there has been an explosion in the use of LDTs by commercial labs and biotechnology companies. The FDA now estimates that there are about 11,000 LDTs offered by 2,000 laboratories. A federal law, The Clinical Laboratories Improvement Act (CLIA), requires assessment of whether a lab can test according to instructions and detect what is intended to be detected, that is, the test’s analytical validity. However, a key element is missing in that evaluation: clinical validity. Does the test accurately diagnose or predict the risk of a particular clinical outcome? While the FDA announced its intent to revisit the issue of LDTs several years ago, it has not done so, although it issued draft guidance and a discussion paper on the subject. There is also a discussion draft of a bill circulating in Congress to address LDTs.
What this means:While the majority of LDTs are developed by legitimate, mainstream medical organizations, the lack of regulation has allowed the creation of bogus tests to detect supposed “nutritional deficiencies” and “chronic Lyme” among others. There’s also a problem with bastardizing legitimate tests for quack purposes, as has happened with MTHFR genetic testing. These tests are used by practitioners like naturopaths and “Lyme literate” doctors to sell patients dietary supplements and other unnecessary treatments.
What needs to happen:Whether a legislative solution is crafted by Congress or the FDA uses its existing authority to regulate LDTs, any test that is used to diagnose a disease or condition that is not supported by sufficient evidence that it actually exists (such as “nutritional deficiencies” that have no scientifically recognized effect on human health) or is not recognized as a valid medical diagnosis should require pre-market approval. This would eliminate at least some of the bogus testing used by pseudoscientific practitioners who prey on unsuspecting patients.
Compounded drug regulation
What it does: Compounded drugs are created by health care practitioners and pharmacists without going through the tough FDA pre-market approval process or having to meet the same good manufacturing practices as other pharmaceutical products. Their manufacture is regulated by a combination of federal drug law and state health care practitioner regulation. After a meningitis outbreak caused by a compounded medication, Congress beefed up the requirements for compounded drugs and the FDA issued draft guidance implementing the new law. This upset naturopaths and physicians who employ dubious compounded drugs in their practices and they are lobbying their representatives in Congress to weaken the law’s consumer protections.
What this means: While there are many legitimate uses of compounded drugs, naturopaths and some physicians abuse the process by concocting quack remedies, sometimes with tragic results. The new law and draft guidance are a step in the right direction, but naturopaths and their allies could be successful in weakening these improvements. Much of the problem, however, may be out of the federal government’s control as long as states continue to license practitioners of pseudoscience and fail to discipline physicians who use dubious compounded remedies.
What needs to happen:In addition to resisting efforts to weaken the new law or the FDA’s interpretation of it, see the recommended solutions for dealing with the naturopathic practice acts and physicians who practice pseudoscience under the so-called “health freedom” laws, below.
Affordable Care Act “non-discrimination” provision
What it does:Section 2706 of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (the “ACA” or “Obamacare”) prohibits “discrimination” by health insurers against state-regulated health care practitioners acting within their scope of practice as defined by state law.
What this means: Exactly what would constitute “discrimination” was never defined and the law seems to have done little (if anything) to assist naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists in gaining coverage for their practices, perhaps because health insurers are not prohibited from refusing to cover diagnoses and treatments they consider “experimental,” that is, lacking in evidence.
What needs to be happen: Health insurers should not be forced to cover practitioners who achieved their scope of practice through political means rather than appropriate education and training and adherence to evidence-based practices. Section 2706 should be repealed.
State laws
Chiropractic Practice Acts
What they do: All 50 states license chiropractors. All states permit chiropractors to claim that they can detect non-existent “subluxations” and that the correction of these phantom lesions improves health and can prevent or treat disease. State practice acts are not uniform and vary widely in scope of practice. All states allow chiropractors to perform or order diagnostic testing and give nutritional advice. In some states, chiropractors can, for example, perform physicals for school athletics and gynecological exams and administer oral and IV chelation therapy. Other states allow the term “chiropractic physician.”
Licensure is granted based on graduation from chiropractic college, where clinical education takes place in small school clinics offering a very limited range of experience and passing an examination, both of which are controlled entirely by chiropractors. In most states, boards made up of a majority of chiropractors regulate their practice, including discipline, continuing education requirements and specialty practice, such as “chiropractic neurology,” “chiropractic pediatrics,” and “chiropractic internist.” Specialty practice is permitted based on post-grad courses which may take place in hotel conference rooms and require no clinical experience. Practice expansion efforts have resulted in limited prescription privileges, the authority to give patients IV vitamin and mineral infusions, and to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients (also here).
What this means: Claiming a variety of health benefits, including (among many others) turning breach babies and improvements in asthma, allergies, bedwetting, ear infections, and “wellness,” chiropractors have been detecting “subluxations” for over a century without ever having shown that subluxations exist, that they have a deleterious effect on human health, that they can be detected, or that “subluxation correction” via “adjustments” is effective for anything. (These practices are to be distinguished from the evidence-based use of spinal manipulation for certain types of back pain, to which some chiropractors limit themselves, although they are hard to find.) Given the right to use diagnostic testing (both real and bogus) and give “nutritional advice,” which translates into prescribing and selling dietary supplements, allows chiropractors to practice an ersatz version of primary care. (The American Chiropractic Association, the largest chiropractic professional association, vigorously promotes “the DC as PCP.”) This includes a plethora of quack diagnoses and treatments.
What needs to happen: Detection and correction of subluxations should be eliminated from the chiropractic practice acts. (And not by creatively renaming subluxations.) Chiropractors should be limited to the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal problems, without prescription privileges. They should be prohibited from using bogus diagnostic tests and devices, although, as mentioned above, this needs to be addressed at the national level so that it applies to all health care practitioners. While they should be allowed to advise patients on proper diet, they should be prohibited from selling dietary supplements they prescribe to their patients, a huge conflict of interest. School physicals, pelvic exams, obstetrics and all the other practices for which they are inadequately educated and trained should be eliminated from the practice acts and, because of their anti-vaccination philosophy, they should be specifically prohibited from giving immunization advice as outside their scope of practice.
Naturopathic Practice Acts
What they do: Naturopathic “doctors,” those with degrees from naturopathic “medical” schools, are currently regulated (through licensing or registration) in 19 states and Washington, D.C., with scopes of practice varying widely from full-range primary care scope (although only Oregon does this) to practice acts which specifically refute the notion that naturopaths are capable of practicing as primary care doctors (as in Maryland and Rhode Island). Like chiropractors, naturopaths have set up their own educational and testing system, controlled completely by naturopaths and operating wholly outside the mainstream U.S. university system. States default to these “credentials” as sufficient to ensure public safety.
More than any other type of health care practitioner, the naturopathic practice acts legalize a wide range of quackery. These acts recognize vitalism as the source of naturopathic practice and allow naturopaths to treat patients with (depending on the state) homeopathy, colonic irrigation, herbs, and energy healing, and IV infusions of vitamins, and minerals, among many others. The authority to do diagnostic testing allows naturopaths to use the sort of unvalidated testing discussed earlier in the post. Most states give naturopaths their own regulatory board.
What this means:At best, naturopaths sell patients dubious remedies, like homeopathic drugs and dietary supplements, for self-limiting conditions that may well have gotten better on their own, or for made-up conditions like “chronic candidiasis.” At worst, they treat patients with dangerous remedies like IV hydrogen peroxide and IV curcumin, sometimes killing them. If you want a peek inside how they operate, read Britt Hermes blog, Naturopathic Diaries, David Gorski’s and Orac’s posts on “What naturopaths say when they think no one is listening” (actually, Orac titled his posts more colorfully) and Scott Gavura’s “Naturopathy vs. Science” series. To boot, naturopaths are also anti-vaccination.
What needs to happen:Repeal the naturopathic practice acts. There’s not a shred of reliable evidence that naturopathic practice benefits patients, and it has the potential to do great financial and physical harm.
Homeopathic Practice Acts
What they do: Only three states specifically license medical and osteopathic doctors as “homeopathic physicians,” although naturopaths, chiropractors, acupuncturists and unlicensed CAM practitioners can legally prescribe, administer and sell homeopathic remedies to patients in some states.
What this means:Physicians could possibly be prosecuted for falling below the medical standard of care for employing homeopathic remedies without specific authority to do so, since homeopathy is so obviously devoid of any scientific basis or evidence of effectiveness. Homeopathic practice acts eliminate that possibility.
What to do: This is another no-brainer. No MD or DO should be allowed by the state to prescribe bogus remedies. Homeopathic practice acts should be repealed.
Acupuncture, Traditional Chinese Medicine, East Asian Medicine and Oriental Medicine Practice Acts and Auricular Acupuncture
What they do: State acupuncture practice acts vary widely, with some, like Mississippi, allowing a very narrow scope of practice (in Mississippi’s case, requiring that the patient have been evaluated by a physician in most instances and limiting practitioners to needle acupuncture). Others are far more expansive, allowing the practice of what is variously called Traditional Chinese Medicine, East Asian Medicine and Oriental Medicine. Some, like Kansas, specifically incorporate a proposed mechanism of action unknown to science:
assessment, evaluation, prevention treatment or correction of any abnormal physiology or pain by means of controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy . . . and stimulating the body to restore itself.
These laws incorporate all manner of pseudoscientific diagnoses as well as treatments, such as moxibustion, herbalism, and cupping. Several states also permit the practice of auricular acupuncture for limited conditions, like substance abuse, by those without formal training in acupuncture. Like chiropractors and naturopaths, acupuncturists have created and control their own educational and testing system, to which the state legislatures default in licensing decisions. Most states give acupuncturists their own regulatory board.
What this means: Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo, leading some patients to believe that acupuncture “works.” In addition to ineffectiveness, acupuncture has its risks (also here), as does the use of herbs (or, unrefined drugs), which are too often contaminated. Even if one were to concede (and we don’t) that needle acupuncture is effective for a handful of conditions, the practice acts allow acupuncturists to diagnose and treat virtually any disease or condition with methods that are both biologically implausible and have no reliable evidence of safety or efficacy.
What needs to happen: At best, repeal the acupuncture practice acts. A less drastic solution would be to allow acupuncturists to see only those patients with a physician referral for a limited course of treatment, eliminating the authority to diagnose according to principles that are no better than magic tricks and treat with unproven remedies like herbs, cupping and moxibustion.
State “health freedom” laws: Quack version
What they do: While the provisions vary by state, and not all states have them, so-called “health freedom” laws (or, as I prefer, the “Quack Full Employment Acts“) allow people with no health care education or training to sell bogus treatments to the public without fear of being prosecuted for the unlicensed practice of a health care profession as long as certain minimal requirements are made. For example, in Nevada, practitioners of Gerson Therapy, reiki, reflexology, herbalism, “detoxification,” and iridology are protected from prosecution for the unlicensed practice of medicine, for which the penalty is reduced from a felony to a misdemeanor. Even then, the state must meet an almost impossible burden of proof in prosecuting them. In Colorado, unlicensed practitioners offering energy healing, dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies and colonic irrigation are shielded.
What this means: The state cannot prosecute even the most egregious quackery, in some cases even if it causes physical harm.
What needs to happen:This is another simple one: eliminate these unwarranted protections of quacks and repeal and restore the authorities’ ability to prosecute.
State “health freedom” laws: Physician version
What they do: Either via statute or regulation, some states have adopted a double standard for physicians using “complementary and alternative” diagnoses and treatments. The Federation of State Medical Boards has provided a template for implementing this double standard. Basically, these laws permit a physician to practice in a manner that would normally fall below the standard of care without fear of prosecution from the state medical board if certain requirements are met. (See, e.g., this Texas regulation and this Florida statute.) Provisions vary from state to state, but generally require that the diagnosis or treatment not pose an undue risk or actually cause harm.
What this means: Physicians are free to discard evidence-based medicine in favor of pseudoscience.
What needs to happen: Physicians should be held to a single standard of care, with no exceptions for pseudoscience, of all things. These statutes and regulations should be repealed.
Conclusion: We’re moving in the wrong direction
While changes (or, at least, proposed changes) in the regulation of laboratory-developed tests and compounded drugs are a step in the right direction, the legalization of quackery is actually expanding via the enactment, for example, of scope of practice liberalization for chiropractors and naturopathic practice acts. Over 30 years ago, a Congressional subcommittee concluded:
As this report details, quackery has traveled far from the day of the pitchman and covered wagon to emerge as big business. Those who orchestrate and profit from the sale and promotion of these useless and often harmful “health” products are no longer quaint and comical figures. They are well organized, sophisticated and persistent. [We estimate] the cost of quackery – the promotion and sale of useless remedies promising relief from chronic and critical health conditions – exceeds $10 billion a year [a figure that has greatly increased; dietary supplements alone are a $41 billion a year business.] The costs of quackery in human terms, measured in disillusion, pain, relief forsaken or postponed because of reliance on unproven methods, is more difficult to measure, but nonetheless real. All too frequently, the purchaser has paid with his life. While the impact of quackery on our lives has been increasing and growing in sophistication, public and private efforts designed to address and control this problem have diminished, been redirected or disbanded.
I would argue that a concerted public effort to protect consumers from quackery is virtually non-existent today. As far as I know, a legislative solution to the victimization of consumers is not even a topic of conversation in the halls of Congress or the state legislatures. It should be.

   Georgia on my mind
John Snyder
Link
My inaugural post was about vaccines, and I promised that I wouldn’t write exclusively on this topic. But something rotten is brewing in the state of Georgia and this story is just too important to ignore.
The first successful challenge to the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Compensation Act (NCVICA) has taken place in Georgia, and we all should be just a little bit worried. In Ferrari v. American Home Products Corp., the plaintiffs, Marcello and Carolyn Ferrari of Atlanta, have sued American Home Products Corp. (otherwise known as Wyeth) and the co-defendant GlaxoSmithKline, claiming that the vaccine preservative thimerosal led to their son’s autism. The consequences of this ruling could effect the health of the entire nation. To understand why, we need to delve a bit into what the NCVICA is exactly, and why it was created in the first place.
There have been “anti-vaccine movements” ever since Jenner tested the first smallpox vaccine in 1796. But what might be considered the big-bang of the contemporary anti-vaccine movement in this country occurred in 1982, when the documentary DPT: Vaccine Roulette aired on WRC TV. It was a devastating and graphically in-your-face documentary purporting to show the neurologically ravaged child victims of the original whole-cell DTP vaccine. Once this hour-long documentary was aired nationally, the entire country was “awakened” to the alleged dangers of vaccines. Although no good evidence ever surfaced attributing any serious complications to the old whole cell pertussis vaccine, the documentary created massive fear of this vaccine, and widespread mistrust of vaccines in general. A woman named Barbara Loe Fisher was so taken by this show, that she formed an organization, Dissatisfied Parents Together (which later became the National Vaccine Information Center, the largest and best-known repository of vaccine misinformation), whose mission was to lobby the federal government to enact legislation to compensate parents whose children had supposedly been injured by vaccines. In 1986, the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) was enacted by congress as part of the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Compensation Act. The most important purpose of the VICP was to safeguard the nation’s vaccine supply in the wake of a mounting torrent of lawsuits directed at vaccine manufacturers. These lawsuits were a major threat to the country’s vaccination program, as manufacturers faced potential jury awards that would be impossible to survive. In 1979 there was one DTP-related lawsuit. In 1986 there were 255. Between 1983 and 1984, costs related to these lawsuits climbed from $4.7 million to $9.9 million. In 1986 alone, over $3 billion in DTP injury claims were sought, which was 30 times greater than that year’s entire dollar value of DTP vaccine. Vaccine prices soared, and companies stopped making vaccines or went out of business entirely. In 1957 there were 26 vaccine manufacturers. In 1980 there were 17 companies making vaccines, and by 1986 there were only 3 (today there are only 5 major vaccine manufacturers in the world, and they are large pharmaceutical companies for which vaccines are only a small part of their product line).
The VICP effectively saved the nation’s vaccine program by moving these legal actions out of the traditional tort process, and creating a no-fault system whereby the vaccine manufacturers were saved from potential ruin. A special “vaccine court” was created to hear injury claims, presided over by Special Masters responsible for reviewing the evidence and quickly adjudicating cases on behalf of claimants. If a parent’s claim is deemed to fit a known vaccine complication, an award is usually given without significant reliance on the customary rules of evidence required by the traditional tort system. Compensation is drawn from a fund generated by a 75 cent excise tax on each vaccine component at the time a vaccine is administered (75 cents for a single vaccine like Hepatitis B, $2.25 for a three component vaccine like DTP).
While the VICP has been successful in providing timely compensation in cases of true (but rare) vaccine injury, the emphasis on streamlined proceedings, and the lack of rigor and evidence-base required of science (these are, after-all, legal not scientific hearings) has resulted in many rather dubious rulings. The special Omnibus Autism Proceedings, discussed previously on SBM, was established as an extension of the original vaccine court, and was designed to handle the over 5000 lawsuits clogging the system from parents claiming their children developed autism as a result of the MMR vaccine, the thimerosal preservative in other vaccines, or a combination of these factors. I’ll refrain from discussing the science behind this here, as it has been extensively covered elsewhere. Suffice it to say that the Special Masters poured over mountains of published evidence and listened to hundreds of hours of testimony on three test cases for these three theories. In a victory for science, they ruled strongly and unanimously against the claimants. This time, at least, the legal system respected the science and made it’s ruling accordingly.
Back to Georgia.
What’s brewing in the state of Georgia right now should bring a chill to the spine of anyone familiar with the history of the legal threats to our vaccine supply. For the first time since the creation of the VICP, and with complete disregard for the intent of Congress, a product-injury lawsuit against a vaccine manufacturer has been allowed to go forward.
In 2005, Marcelo and Carolyn Ferrari sued American Home Products Corp. (aka Wyeth) and GlaxoSmithKline claiming that thimerosal in the vaccines their son received caused his autism [it is interesting to note that they also sued the local power utility, claiming that their mercury emissions contributed to his autism as well]. A Georgia state court correctly ruled, just as all other courts have done previously, that the Ferrari claim was pre-empted by the congressionally enacted VICP. The Ferrari’s appealed, and won a reversal from the Georgia Court of Appeals in 2007. Incredibly, the appeals court ruling was upheld by the Georgia Supreme Court in 2008, effectively clearing the way for a return to the days when a flood of law suits threatened to undermine our Nation’s vaccine supply. The judge in the Georgia Supreme Court’s ruling interpreted the Vaccine Act by stating:
…a vaccine manufacturer cannot be held liable for defective design if it is determined, on a case-by-case basis, that the injurious side effects of the particular vaccine were unavoidable.
Forget the fact that autism has never been an “injurious side effect” of vaccines, whether they contained thimerosal or not. These are legal proceedings, having nothing to do with causation. [It does, however, make it difficult to follow from a rational, evidence-based perspective.]
The judge further held that,
…if such effects were avoidable by a feasible, alternative design, liability is not completely barred.
In the Ferrari case, the court thus found that the plaintiffs should be allowed to make a claim based on the presumption that their child’s injuries may have been avoidable with a different product design, and that that decision should be left to the trial courts to decide, congress be damned.
But the judicial precedent of state courts following the intent of congress is well established. In fact a recent ruling by the Third Circuit (regarding another vaccine liability case) specifically cited and rejected the Georgia Supreme Court’s ruling in the Ferrari case, stating that if we interpret the Vaccine Act
to allow case-by-case analysis of whether particular vaccine side effects are avoidable…every design defect claim is subject to evaluation by a court.” And “Each of the objectives extolled [in the Vaccine Act's legislative history] would be undermined.”
The Third Circuit court judge clarified the intent of congress by stating that the Vaccine Act pre-empts
all design defect claims, including those based in negligence.”
But the Georgia Supreme Court’s ruling in favor of the Ferrari’s flies in the face of Congress’ intent when it enacted the VICP.
The legal reasoning as to why this decision is not legitimate is more complex than I’ve laid it out to be here. The bottom line is if the decision is allowed to stand, the floodgates will once again be opened to a torrent of litigation that could cripple the vaccine industry, just as we saw occur in the mid 1980′s, potentially lowering vaccination rates and leading to a resurgence of vaccine preventable disease.
Last month the American Academy of Pediatrics filed an Amicus Brief with the U.S. Supreme Court, asking that it overturn the lower court’s ruling. The brief was co-authored by the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American Medical Association, the American Public Helath Association, Every Child By Two, the Immunization Action Coalition, the Infectious Diseases Society of America, the Pediatric Infectious Disease Society, the American College of Osteopathic Pediatricans, and the Vaccine Education Center of the Children’s Hospital of Phildelphia. In the brief, the AAP argues that vaccines have been one of the most important public health measures of the twentieth century. In it’s brief, the AAP goes on to elaborate about the dangerous precedent the Ferrari ruling makes, and reminds the court how vulnerable our vaccine supply is to an unregulated tort process. It points out how the Vaccine Act has not only allowed vaccine manufacturers to continue to make vaccines, but has allowed for the continued development of extremely important vaccine products. Despite this, we have not seen a rise in the number of companies in the business of making vaccines. Because of this, the current vaccine supply remains highly susceptible to a return to the old wild-west style of vaccine litigation that existed prior to the Vaccine Act. Currently, there are only two manufacturers of the DTaP vaccine in the United States. Only one company makes the MMR vaccine. A dramatic illustration of the vulnerability of our vaccine supply resulting from the difficult financial pressures on vaccine production can be found in our current shortage of Hib vaccine.
There are two US makers of the Haemophilus influenzae type b vaccine. Because of a quality control issue, one was forced to stop production of the vaccine while it retools it’s manufacturing facility. The remaining Hib manufacturer has been unable to keep pace with production, resulting in a nationwide shortage of the vaccine. This prompted the CDC to recommend a temporary change to the Hib vaccine schedule, holding the booster dose usually given at 15 months of age. This shortage, combined with an increasing prevalence of parental vaccine refusal due to the spreading wave of vaccine misinformation, has resulted in the frightening emergence of isolated Hib outbreaks. Four children have died.
The future of the vaccine supply is now in the hands of the US Supreme court. If the Ferrari lawsuit is allowed to proceed, vaccine manufacturers will once again be open to an onslaught of hungry trial lawyers and an enormous pool of misinformed parents eager for revenge. Our greatest weapon against childhood death and disease will fall prey, but our children will be the ultimate victims.

   A pox on your bank account: failure to vaccinate and its legal consequences
Jann Bellany
Link
Here’s a question anti-vaxers may want to consider:
Can the parents of an unvaccinated child be held liable if their child becomes infected with a vaccine-preventable disease which then spreads from their child to another child or children?
Yes, they can.
In fact, for over 125 years, courts in this country have recognized a cause of action for negligent transmission of an infectious disease. In the first reported case (New York, 1884) the defendant infected the plaintiff with whooping cough. Cases since then have run the gamut: smallpox, tuberculosis, unspecified “venereal disease,” typhoid fever, scarlet fever, diphtheria, hepatitis, herpes, gonorrhea, HIV. If your favorite infectious disease is not on this list, don’t worry. The disease may vary, but the legal principles remain the same.
You’ve got WHAT?
As the previous paragraph suggests, one need look no further than plain old negligence for an entrée to the courts — the same legal principle that forms the basis of actions arising out of automobile accidents and slip and fall cases.
Here’s how the Court of Appeals of Maryland described the basic law of negligence and its application to infectious diseases:
The traditional elements of a cause of action in negligence may be stated as:
     1.  A duty, or obligation, recognized by the law, requiring the person to conform to a certain standard of conduct, for the protection of others against unreasonable risks.
     2.  A failure on the person’s part to conform to the standard required: a breach of the duty ….
     3.  A reasonably close causal connection between the conduct and the resulting injury ….
     4.  Actual loss or damage resulting to the interests of another ….
The notion of duty is founded on the ‘responsibility each of us bears to exercise due care to avoid unreasonable risks of harm to others.’ … ‘When a reasonable person knows or should have known that certain types of conduct constitute an unreasonable risk of harm to another, he or she has the duty to refrain from that conduct.’ …
One who knows he or she has a highly infectious disease can readily foresee the danger that the disease may be communicated to others with whom the infected person comes into contact. As a consequence, the infected person has a duty to take reasonable precautions—whether by warning others or by avoiding contact with them—to avoid transmitting the disease. ‘[As an example] if defendant knew that he was afflicted with smallpox it then became and was his duty to keep away from other persons, or should other persons approach him to notify them of the fact so that they might protect themselves.’
B.N. v. K.K., 538 A.2d 1176 (Md. Ct. App. 1988)(citations omitted)(emphasis added).
In this case, K.K., a doctor, transmitted genital herpes to B.N., a nurse with whom he worked at Johns Hopkins Hospital. (Hence the discrete initials instead of the names of the parties, although that privilege is not always granted to the litigants in STD cases.) Dr. K.K. and Nurse B.N. had a sexual relationship of several months’ duration during which time Dr. K.K. — rather ungallantly — failed to tell Nurse B.N. about his infection, even though he knew his diagnosis and on at least one particular occasion knew that he had an active case.1
While the facts were unique to the case under consideration, the Maryland appellate court correctly stated the law of negligence generally applicable in the 50 states. Some courts have added that the duty to exercise due care not to infect others is also grounded in the state’s interest in the prevention and control of disease. (Caveat: each state’s courts have the jurisdiction to create variations on the law of negligence, so, as has been said on this blog before, your results may vary.)
But what if one doesn’t know he has a contagious disease?
Actual knowledge is not required, although it makes for easier proof. Courts have found that in certain circumstances the infected person should have known, or, as it is sometimes put, he had constructive knowledge of his disease. This can be established on the basis of symptoms alone, without a confirming medical diagnosis, particularly where symptoms of the disease are well publicized, such as is true of HIV/AIDS infection and genital herpes.
Note that a “reasonable person” is the standard — what a reasonable person knew or should have known. Thus, being merely unaware (in cases where the “reasonable person” would have known) or willfully ignorant of the disease is no excuse.
Once a duty to act with due care is established through actual or constructive knowledge of one’s disease, the infected person is charged with, at the least, warning those with whom he comes in contact that he has a communicable disease (allowing them to choose to stay away) or himself choosing not to engage in activity which would spread the disease to others. If he fails to do so, the second element of negligence — breach of his duty — is established.
A tougher problem might be to show that the diseased person’s conduct was the cause in fact of the plaintiff’s injury, the third element of proof in a negligence case. Even though she catches the same infectious disease as is suffered by the defendant, the plaintiff must still show the defendant was in fact the source of her disease. Depending on the disease, this can be accomplished through expert testimony concerning, for example, how contagious the disease is, the incubation period, and DNA testing of the disease strains.
Finally, there must be actual damages, and there usually are, in the form of medical expenses. (The collateral source rule prevents the offset of health insurance payments against the plaintiff’s recovery.) In cases where the defendant’s conduct was particularly egregious, punitive damages might be awarded. Other types of damages are discussed below.
No two negligence cases are exactly alike. There will always be factual variations to weigh in determining liability. In general, however, negligent transmission of infectious disease cases will turn on two issues: (1) Did the defendant know, or should he have known, he was contagious, and (2) Was he the cause in fact of plaintiff’s disease. Once those two are established, the defendant’s lack of due care will almost always be a given, as will at least some damages. Of course, in some cases the facts may show contributory negligence, or even consent, by the plaintiff.
While negligence is the most common, and easiest to prove, claim against a defendant who has transmitted an infectious disease, it’s not the only one. Actions for fraud, intentional infliction of emotional distress, the tort of battery, other forms of intentional tort, and actions based on premises liability (for failure to warn of a communicable disease on one’s property) have all been the subject of suits based on the contraction of an infectious disease.
Some states have a law making it a crime to intentionally transmit HIV to another through sexual contact. If that is not the case, the crimes of battery and reckless endangerment may offer the possibility of prosecution for any infectious disease transmission given the requisite proof of intentional or reckless conduct.
So sue me! 
So let’s apply these lessons to a perennial topic at SBM — parents who refuse to vaccinate their children because of unwarranted fears about vaccine safety. What part such children might be playing in the current pertussis epidemic is a question under investigation by public health authorities, as pointed out in a recent post by Dr. Steve Novella.
First, note that in the case of vaccine-preventable childhood diseases, it’s not the child who is calling the shots. (Sorry!) Children under a certain age (usually 18) are deemed legally incapable of making decisions about their health care. The parents make those decisions and it is the parents who are legally responsible for the consequences of their decisions.
Of course, as the standard for determining negligence is what a “reasonable person” in the same or similar circumstances would do, how could that standard ever be applied to children? The “reasonable toddler?” No such thing.
Second, it does not matter WHY the parent chose not to vaccinate in establishing liability. The parent may have exercised his statutory privilege of opting out for religious or philosophical reasons, but that’s not the equivalent of a “get out of jail free” card for all the consequences of that decision.
In fact, it can help the plaintiff establish liability by showing that the parent knew, or should have known, her child was vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases and that this, in turn, made it more likely that her child would transmit these diseases to unvaccinated, not fully vaccinated and even vaccinated children.
In one New England Journal of Medicine2 article the authors point out:
    • Children with non-medical exemptions are at a greatly increased risk for acquiring and transmitting vaccine-preventable diseases;
    • In one study, at least 11% of nonexempt children who acquired measles were infected through contact with an exempt child;
    • Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease often start among persons who refused vaccination, spread rapidly within unvaccinated populations, and then to other subpopulations, such as vaccinated children.
In cases where there is not a confirmed diagnosis, I would argue that reasonable parents should have been on high alert for symptoms, given their child’s increased susceptibility. While the parent of a vaccinated child could be excused for not thinking his child, broken out in little blisters, might have chicken pox, the argument can be made that the parent of an unvaccinated child shouldn’t be given that consideration.
As one treatise states:
The defendant’s membership in a group at high risk for development of a particular infectious or contagious disease, his or her involvement in patterns of behavior likely to result in contraction of a disease, and/or his or her exposure to a disease in circumstances likely to lead to contraction of the disease are additional factors which may assist the plaintiff in establishing constructive knowledge. If any combination of the factors stated above would put a reasonable person on notice of the need to inquire further, the defendant will be charged with constructive knowledge of any facts reasonable inquiry would have disclosed.
22 Causes of Action 1, at 18 (Westlaw, accessed June 4, 2010).
“Group at high risk?” “Behavior likely to result in contraction of a disease?” Sounds like a description of the unvaccinated child.
An insolent question
With all of this in mind, we turn to a hypothetical posed by Dr. David Gorski:
What would the liability be of the parents of a child who refused to vaccinate if their child infected other children, leading to serious harm (such as measles encephalitis). Let’s say the causation could be proven very strongly, for instance by the sequence of the measles virus in the unvaccinated child matching exactly the measles that infected and harmed other children. Say the children who were harmed were fully vaccinated against MMR (remember, MMR is not 100% effective).
Slam dunk, Dr. Gorski! With a few caveats.
Certainly, if the parents knew, or should have known from symptoms, that their child was infected with measles and then put him into a position where he might infect other children, and causation has been established as you suggest, then the parents would be liable to the injured children for their pain and suffering and to their parents for all medical and other expenses incurred in taking care of their ill children. If the encephalitis had lasting effects, the defendant parents would also be liable for the continuing care of the children, the children’s future wages, and the parents’ loss of their children’s help and support. If any of the children actually died, the amount of loss would depend on the wrongful death law of the state where this occurred as the method for calculating those losses varies from state to state. Then there is the possibility of punitive damages.
In other words, this could run into hundreds of thousands, even several million, dollars, depending on the number of children injured and the extent of their injuries.
But … factual variations might influence the outcome. If the parents of the unvaccinated child knew the other children were vaccinated, the finder of fact (either the jury or, if a bench trial, the judge) might determine they were not negligent. It would depend on whether a reasonable person should know the vaccine is not 100% effective. If the parents of the injured children knew or should have known the unvaccinated child had the measles, and the uncertain effectiveness of the vaccine, then their own negligence might reduce their recovery, but not that of the children. And so on.
“Chicken pox parties” present an interesting case. For the parent supplying the diseased child to the “party” the prospect of liability should be particularly troubling. She is not negligently spreading her child’s disease — she is intentionally spreading it. Intentional torts automatically subject the defendant to the possibility of punitive damages, which are usually based on the defendant’s net worth. The whole point is to make sure the defendant is financially punished for her actions — in other words, to take enough money that it hurts.
Punitive damages are on top of actual damages, such as medical bills, and pain and suffering. As in the above hypothetical, while the recovery of parents subjecting their children to the virus can be reduced — perhaps eliminated in this case — because of their actions, the award to the children cannot, and it is the children who are entitled to punitive damages. It could turn out to be a very expensive party.
And what about the physician? What role does he or she play? Well, possibly the role of “defendant.” Courts in a number of jurisdictions have found that in certain circumstances a physician is liable to a third party who contracts a contagious disease from the physician’s patient. One of these circumstances is the physician’s failure to inform the patient how to avoid the spread of the disease, such as by avoiding specific at-risk conduct. Another is giving the patient inadequate or incorrect information. The physician does not need to know that this third person even exists and the third person does not have to rely on the physician’s incorrect advice to hold the physician liable.
As one court in Pennsylvania said,
the duty of the physician treating a patient with a communicable disease is to prevent the spread of the disease, not for the benefit of the patient, whose health has already been compromised, but for the benefit of those third parties ‘within the foreseeable orbit of risk of harm.’
Troxel v. A.I. DuPont Institute, 450 Pa.Super. 71, 675 A.2d 314 (Pa. Super. 1996)(citations omitted).
I would argue that this duty to third parties requires a physician to warn the vaccine-refusing parent, and the parent who chooses the “alternative” vaccine schedule (a la Dr. Bob), of not only the heightened risks to her child resulting from vaccine refusal or delay, but also the risks to other persons to whom her child could spread disease. This information would include the symptoms of the preventable disease and how to avoid infecting others. Otherwise, beware of small third parties bearing service of process coming at you from “the foreseeable orbit of risk of harm.”
Closing argument
In sum, the state’s interest in preventing the spread of communicable diseases manifests itself not only in mandatory vaccine laws, but also in impressing a duty to avoid the spread of disease on those who are infected with, or who are at high risk for contraction of, a communicable disease. Where the diseased are children, the responsibility for fulfilling this duty falls on the parents. As well, physicians of high risk or infected patients must properly instruct patients in avoiding transmission of disease to others. Those who breach their duty to avoid the spread of communicable disease may be liable to those injured for damages.
Parents who refuse vaccination may be willing to forsake their children’s health for their religion or their philosophy, but once that choice adversely affects someone else’s child, they will have to pick up the tab.
Notes
1. I have no sympathy for Dr. K.K., but do note that it must be a huge bummer for one’s negligent transmission of genital herpes case go all the way to the state court of appeals and be immortalized in published case law. Future defendants in such cases might want to consider settlement.
2. Omer SB, Salmon DA, Orenstein WA, et al., Vaccine Refusal, Mandatory Immunization, and the Risks of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases, N Engl J Med 2009; 360:1981-1988.

   Supreme Court Saves Nation’s Immunization Program
John Snyder
Link
The Supreme Court of the United States made a ruling the other day that has profound implications for the health of millions of children. Since October 12, 2010, The Court has been quietly deliberating the case of Bruesewitz v. Wyeth, inc. The case centers on Russell and Robalee Bruesewitz’s allegation that their 18 year old daughter, Hannah, was irreversibly injured by a DTP vaccine she received when she was 6 months old. What is important about this case is not the allegation itself (I will discuss its merits, or lack thereof, in a moment), but the ramifications the ruling has for the future of childhood immunization in this country. The Supreme Court’s ruling against the Bruesewitz’s and in favor of the U.S. vaccination program was the right one, and safeguards our children from the irrationality of the anti-vaccine movement. Some important background is necessary here to understand why this is so.
Prior to the development of effective vaccines, diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis were common diseases, terrifyingly familiar to all parents. Death records from Massachusetts during the latter half of the 1800’s indicate that diphtheria caused 3-10% of all deaths. In the first part of the 20th century, these dreaded organisms still caused illness in hundreds of thousands of people each year in the United States. These are devastating diseases which, if not resulting in death, often produced severe and permanent damage to those afflicted. In the 1920’s, vaccines against each of these scourges were finally developed, and in the mid 1940’s the combined DTP vaccine was introduced. The vaccines were so effective that cases of these deadly infections were practically eliminated. Today, few parents know the terror once routinely wrought by these pathogens.
Despite the effectiveness of the original DTP vaccine, it did frequently produce reactions in the children who received it. Fever (and fever seizures in those genetically predisposed), irritability, and sometimes frightening hyporesponsive episodes were seen. The side effects of the DTP vaccine were attributable to its pertussis component. The vaccine was produced using the whole pertussis organism in an attenuated state so that it could not cause the disease itself. Utilizing the whole organism, however, exposed the child to a large number of proteins, some of which were responsible for the fever and other side effects the vaccine produced. These deleterious reactions certainly paled in comparison to the dangers of the diseases themselves. Nonetheless, as the diseases prevented by the vaccine disappeared, parents began to take more seriously these annoying and often frightening reactions. Because some of these reactions were so frightening, including febrile, or fever seizures, many people began to believe the vaccine was responsible for more serious side effects, including brain damage and even death. As outlined in an earlier SBM post, the side effects of the original “whole cell” DTP vaccine (DTwP) were not, however, life-threatening and produced no long-term problems in those receiving it. In 2006, a retrospective case-control cohort study of more than 2 million children concluded there was no increased risk of developing encephalopathy following administration of the original DTwP vaccine1. But when encephalopathy or a new onset seizure disorder occurred in temporal association with the receipt of the DTwP vaccine, causation was often ascribed to it.
It was the escalating, yet unfounded fears surrounding the original DTwP vaccine that led to the emergence of the modern-day anti-vaccine movement in this country. In 1982, the shockumentary “Vaccine Roulette” appeared on a local NBC TV affiliate. It purported to show the child victims of the DTwP vaccine, housed in a dark and dismal chronic care facility, damaged by doctors and forgotten by society. The show awakened the nation to the alleged dangers of this vaccine, and the fear quickly spread like wild fire. Fear of the DTwP vaccine and of vaccines in general enveloped the nation, and lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers over a host of alleged reactions rained down upon the courts. This torrent of legal action threatened the future of the vaccination program in this country. While in 1979 there was only 1 DTP-related lawsuit, by 1986 there were 255, with a total of over $3 billion sought by claimants. This clearly was not sustainable for the vaccine industry, and in fact manufacturers went out of business. In 1967 there were 26 US manufacturers of vaccines. By 1980 this number had dropped to 15, and by 1986 there were only 3 companies still making vaccines in this country. Vaccine prices skyrocketed, and manufacturers found it difficult to obtain liability insurance.
With the future of our vaccination program at risk, Congress passed the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA) in 1986 and established the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP). Funded by an excise tax on each vaccine component administered, the NVICP was designed as a no-fault, expedited process to compensate families who claim their child has suffered a vaccine-related injury. No proof of causation is necessary to be eligible for compensation. A child simply has to have a documented problem that occurred in the specified time frame following a vaccination, and that problem has to be on the table of problems recognized by the NVICP as potential vaccine adverse events. Cases are reviewed by a Special Master, who makes a determination based on minimal evidence, with the primary goal being a prompt resolution. If a claim is successful, compensation is granted for medical, rehabilitation, counseling, special education, and vocational training expenses, and $250,000 when the claimed outcome is death. Patients may accept the ruling or take their case through the usual tort process by suing the manufacturer. However, a major aspect of this process, and the one which saved the vaccine program from total collapse in the 1980s, is the significant liability protection granted to the vaccine manufacturers. Before suing a vaccine manufacturer, a claimant must first go through the NVICP process, or the so called “Vaccine Court”. But if a parent rejects an NVICP ruling and decides to sue in court, the vaccine manufacturer is immune from liability, assuming they have complied with all regulatory requirements and have not committed outright fraud or other crimes in the manufacture of the vaccine. Most importantly, the NCVIA stipulates that,
No vaccine manufacturer shall be liable in a civil action for damages arising from a vaccine-related injury or death associated with the administration of a vaccine after October 1, 1988, if the injury or death resulted from side effects that were unavoidable even though the vaccine was properly prepared and was accompanied by proper directions and warnings.
Setting aside for the moment the fact that there is no evidence the DTwP vaccine can cause any of the adverse events listed in the original table, the statement above gets to the heart of the Supreme Court’s ruling. Specifically, the ruling centered around the words “unavoidable” and “even though” in the above excerpt. In April 1992, when Hannah Bruesewitz received the vaccine that allegedly injured her, her diagnosis “residual seizure disorder” had just been removed from the NVICP vaccine injury table. Her claim was denied by the Special Master, although she was still awarded $127,000 for legal fees. The family rejected this decision, and instead brought the case against Wyeth (which had acquired Lederle) to Pennsylvania state court. The Breusewitz’s asserted that the vaccine was defective, that the manufacturer knew it could cause harm, and that they had knowledge of a safer vaccine but failed to develop or use it. The Pennsylvania court rejected this claim, citing that such design-defect claims were preempted by the Vaccine Act. The case then ended up in The Supreme Court which finally, this past Tuesday, upheld the intent of the NVICP to protect the vaccine supply by preventing lawsuits based on design-defect claims. The Supreme Court’s opinion, delivered by Justice Antonin Scalia, interpreted the word “unavoidable” as written in the Vaccine Act, to apply to the specific vaccine administered to a claimant, and not to other hypothetical, alternate vaccines that might or might not be more or less safe and effectve. Justice Scalia argued that the use of the words “even though” in the excerpt above implies that the unavoidability referred to in the Act applies to the specific vaccine that was administered, and not to some other potential vaccine. In other words, the Breusewitz’s claim that their daughter’s condition was avoidable because a safer alternative vaccine could have been given was ruled to be a misreading of the Vaccine Act’s intent. The Opinion asserts that exclusion of design defects from the Act was intentional. The fact that the NCVIA and the FDA spell out in detail the manufacturing method and the warnings and directions that must be provided by a vaccine manufacturer, while making no mention of vaccine design requirements is a clear indication that such an exclusion was intentional. It was the Court’s opinion that any other reading of The Act would require very difficult determinations of relative vaccine safety and efficacy. Justice Scalia points out that these determinations are rightly the domain of the FDA and National Vaccine Program experts, and not the courts.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in this case was a huge victory for the health and well-being of our Nation’s children, and the Court should be applauded for its good sense and clarity on the issue. Undoubtedly, those who eschew rationality and oppose vaccines will find fault with the ruling, and cling to the mantra of conspiracy and collusion. Sadly, the fear and misinformation spawned from the DTwP-era lives on today. As technology improved, a version of the vaccine containing an “acellular” pertussis component did eventually become feasible. The DTaP vaccine, as it was called, was introduced in 1996 and nearly eliminated reactions to the vaccine. But the damage was done. As the media and a splintered cadre of like-minded conspiracy and anti-establishment groups took up arms against vaccines in general, a new anti-vaccinationism took hold. We’ve since been through the Wakefield crisis, the thimerosal debacle, and many other dangerous vaccine myths, nourished along by the media and the anti-vaccine cartel. The consequence of this spreading fear is an increasing distrust of vaccines, and the development of pockets of underimmunization around the country. We are now seeing outbreaks of completely preventable childhood disease, and children have died as a result. This was an important ruling, but we have a long way to go before we can bring rationality to the public discussion and understanding of vaccines in this country.

   Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., vaccines, the EPA, and the interface with science-based medicine and public policy
David Gorski
Link
This blog is entitled Science-Based Medicine for a reason, and that’s because we here at SBM believe that the best method to result in the most efficacious treatments for the most people is through the application of science to the evaluation of the biology, pathophysiology, and treatment of disease and disorders.
I may (or may not) be departing a bit from the views of my co-bloggers with this belief, but for purposes of this blog I consider “medicine” to go far beyond what we as physicians do when we undertake to treat patients. In fact, in my view, the purview of science-based medicine should not be so limited but should include any area where decisions, actions, or policy have a direct impact on health. Thus, my definition of science-based medicine encompasses environmental policy, because of the profound effect on human health environmental pollution and toxins can have. Unfortunately for those of us who don’t like its messiness, such a view drives me even more directly into politics than previous issues I’ve taken on. Like Dr. Novella, I rarely write about politics, but when it directly impacts science-based medicine. Mostly, such discussions here on SBM have involved the regulation of the medical profession by government, as Dr. Atwood discussed recently (1, 2, 3) in the context of the difficulties medical boards have in preventing quackery to my discussion of how a quack like Dr. Rashid Buttar could continue to practice in North Carolina, despite his despicable preying upon desperate cancer patients and the parents of children with autism, not to mention the frequent criticisms of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. Dr. Sampson, on the other hand, was more than willing to examine a much more explicitly political issue, namely the number of Iraq War dead (1, 2), and that provoked a bit of disagreement with our commenters, not to mention me.
Recently, hot on the heels of the election of Barack Obama in the Presidential election last week, an issue relevant to several aspects of where science-based medicine intersects public policy popped up. Steve Novella has already commented on it on his own blog, as have numerous other medical bloggers, science bloggers, and political bloggers but I feel justified in commenting on it here, for the reasons that I’ve just mentioned. The controversy is that antivaccine activist and true believer in the scientifically discredited notion that mercury in the thimerosal preservative in vaccines causes autism, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., is being seriously considered by Barack Obama either to head the Environmental Protection Agency or even to be Secretary of the Interior. Like our fearless leader Steve, I believe that such a selection would be an unmitigated disaster for science policy in government.
I understand that politics is a dirty business. I also understand that to win frequently idealism has to be checked at the door. I understand that Obama came of age, politically, in the rough-and-tumble Chicago machine. Having lived in Chicago for three years back in the 1990s, I understand exactly what that means. I even understand that some measure of political payback is often necessary, or that Obama might think he needs to do something to mollify certain wings of his Party. As Politico put it:
The selection of Kennedy would be a shrewd early move for the new presidential team. Obama advisers said the nomination would please both Sen. Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.).
It also would raise the profile of the EPA, which would help endear Obama to liberals who may be disappointed on other issues important to the Democratic left because of budget restrictions.
Even so, I have a hard time imagining a quicker way for Obama to put the lie to his dedication to science-based policy than to appoint such a vocal and energetic booster of the pseudoscience that mercury in vaccines cause autism into such an influential post. It would be a horrific self-inflicted wound.
RFK, Jr. and antivaccine activism
RFK, Jr. first came to my attention when he published a screed simultaneously on Salon.com and Rolling Stone, entitled Deadly Immunity, which argued that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in vaccines. It was a screed that was so dishonest and full of misinformation and distortions that at the time bloggers labeled it the “biggest, steamingest, drippiest turd I’ve ever seen it [Salon.com] publish“; “RFK, Jr.’s completely dishonest thimerosal article“; as well as “lies, damned lies, and quote-mining.” Even liberal blogger Majikthise concluded that the actual transcript of the Simpsonwood Conference, described in such conspiratorial detail as a conference in which the CDC decided to cover up “smoking gun” data showing that thimerosal in vaccines causes autism didn’t come close to vindicating Kennedy’s grandiose claims and that “nothing said at Simpsonwood suggests an attempt to whitewash or cover up anything.” That didn’t stop RFK, Jr. from spewing one conspiracy theory after another about how the CDC and big pharma supposedly “covered up” a link between mercury in vaccines and autism, all the while misrepresenting the science.
For example, here he is on TV around the time of Deadly Immunity:
Note one particularly outrageous example of confusing correlation with causation as RFK, Jr. points out that thimerosal first started to be used in vaccines in the 1930s and “almost immediately” the syndrome of autism was noticed. Of course, autism was first described as a syndrome in 1943 by Leo Kanner; before that there was no condition generally recognized as autism; so this observation is completely spurious, especially since there is copious evidence that behavioral syndromes that were almost certainly autism have been with us for a very long time. They were simply called something different.
Since that “splash” in 2005, RFK, Jr. has stayed unrelentingly on message that mercury in the thimerosal in vaccines is a major cause of autism. He’s also continued to repeat his accusations that the CDC and big pharma are conspiring to keep the evidence that thimerosal-containing vaccines cause autism and all sorts of other horrific complications a secret, that the press is “too lazy” to research the link, and that scientists sympathetic to his point of view are being prevented from doing the research that would prove the connection or somehow otherwise “muzzled.” He has not retreated even one inch, even though numerous lines of evidence, including several very large epidemiological studies, have failed to find a link between mercury and autism or vaccines and autism. For example, he misrepresented a letter to the CDC by Smith-Kline-Beecham as being evidence of some dark conspiracy by the CDC to “discourage” the removal of mercury from vaccines when it was obviously nothing more than the CDC turning back an obvious attempt by SKB to profit from the then incipient thimerosal scare by securing an exclusive contract with the government to supply thimerosal-free vaccines. Meanwhile, RFK, Jr. has been launching histrionic attacks against anyone who dares to call him for his antivaccine winguttery, accusing them of “hating mothers,” all the while cherry-picking studies, conspiracy-mongering, and ignoring the great mass of evidence that does not support his viewpoint. As Mark Hoofnagle put it:
The conspiracy has landed! And it’s a doozy. The CDC, the IOM, the American Association of Pediatrics, and the Pharmaceutical companies are all in cohoots! And don’t forget those bureaucrats (said through clenched teeth), you know how they’re always on the side of evil. And the Pediatricians! If kids didn’t get sick, they’d be out of a job! Clearly they want autism to be pervasive.
Because to RFK, Jr., it’s always a conspiracy. Most recently, he gave a speech at the infamous “Green Our Vaccines” antivaccination rally, led by ex-Playmate, game show hostess, and gross-out comedienne turned “mother warrior” against vaccines, Jenny McCarthy:
See Kennedy praising reporter Dan Olmsted (who is known for his breathless and credulous reporting of any study or news that seems to support his view that vaccines cause autism), while claiming that he got “dragged into this issue” because “the truth became undeniable to me.” Never mind that three years after his infamous article, the evidence that there is no correlation between mercury in vaccines and autism has in fact only grown stronger, with each successive study failing to find a correlation between mercury-containing vaccines and autism building upon the next. Indeed, the very observation that autism incidence has not declined by now, seven years after the removal thimerosal from nearly every childhood vaccine is about as powerful an epidemiological experiment to test the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism as there could be. The hypothesis has clearly failed this test, as well as many others. On this issue, RFK, Jr. is, quite frankly, a crank, as he proclaims that he agrees with mothers who think that vaccines are are “destroying the health” of their children and making the “sickest generation of American children in the history of our country.” His speech, as expected, is thick with conspiracy theories and in the third part he attacks Dr. Paul Offit, whom he famously called a “biostitute.”
Why did RFK, Jr. become a true believer in the thimerosal myth?
A question that keeps coming up is an obvious one. RFK, Jr. is not a physician or scientist. He’s a lawyer and activist for environmentalist causes. So how on earth did he become arguably the second most famous antivaccine activist after Jenny McCarthy? Why?
If I may be so bold (or rash) to speculate, I believe that the reason is most likely that RFK, Jr. clearly likes to see himself as an advocate for the downtrodden, people victimized by corporations polluting their land and air, people without the means to fight back. Certainly there are such people, and arguably RFK, Jr. has championed their cause, sometimes against long odds. In the mercury militia, he found what he thought to be another such group. Indeed, if you watch the videos of his speech to the “Green Our Vaccines” rally, you’ll see that he makes a point of mentioning that several mothers who believed that mercury in vaccines cause autism had approached him with their ideas and that they had lamented to him how they couldn’t get any traction from the CDC and that no one believed them. My speculation (albeit, I think, a reasonable one) is that because RFK, Jr. correctly knew that too much environmental mercury is a bad thing that could result in health problems and because he is also clearly not too savvy about the science, he was easily seduced by the idea that mercury in vaccines was just like mercury in the environment and could cause autism and other neurological disorders. (Never mind that environmental mercury doesn’t cause autism, either.) Instead of dispassionately looking at the science to see if there was anything behind it, he looked at it from the point of view of an advocate. Not surprisingly, he was able to find evidence he wanted to support the conclusion he was predisposed to believe through his self-image and prior history of advocacy. Add to that RFK, Jr.’s well-documented tendency to see dark conspiracies everywhere between corporations and the government over the environment, throw in the false “conspiracy” over the Simpsonwood Conference, and–voilà!–he was an instant convert to the cult of the mercury militia. After all, few groups of cranks see as many dark conspiracies as the mercury militia and antivaccinationists in general.
Unfortunately, RFK, Jr. is apparently unable to distinguish between people who are indeed victims of the depradations of corporations and government and suffer health problems as a result (who do need a champion) and those who only think they are abused by corporations and the government but in fact are not (who need, more than anything else, a serious reality check more than a champion). His seeing himself as a champion of the abused predisposed him to believe the pseudoscience of the mercury militia, and he hasn’t looked back since he first made his splash in 2005. That RFK, Jr. does indeed view himself this way was demonstrated very well in a post he wrote for The Huffington Post last year, in which he defended Katie Wright and the quackery that is chelation therapy for autism:
The poisonous public attacks on Katie Wright this week–for revealing that her autistic son Christian (grandson of NBC Chair Bob Wright), has recovered significant function after chelation treatments to remove mercury — surprised many observers unfamiliar with the acrimonious debate over the mercury-based vaccine preservative Thimerosal. But the patronizing attacks on the mothers of autistic children who have organized to oppose this brain-killing poison is one of the most persistent tactics employed by those defending Thimerosal against the barrage of scientific evidence linking it to the epidemic of pediatric neurological disorders, including autism. Mothers of autistics are routinely dismissed as irrational, hysterical, or as a newspaper editor told me last week, “desperate to find the reason for their children’s illnesses,” and therefore, overwrought and disconnected.
And:
Many of them [mercury militia mothers] approached the link skeptically and only through dispassionate and diligent investigation became convinced that Thimerosal-laced vaccines destroyed their children’s brains. As a group they have sat through hundreds of meetings and scientific conferences, and studied research papers and medical tests. They have networked with each other at meetings and on the Web. Along the way they have stoically endured the abuse routinely heaped upon them by the vaccine industry and public health authorities and casual dismissal by reporters and editors too lazy to do their jobs.
And:
The CDC and IOM base their defense of Thimerosal on these flimsy studies, their own formidable reputations, and their faith that journalists won’t take the time to critically read the science. The bureaucrats are simultaneously using their influence, energies and clout to derail, defund and suppress any scientific study that may verify the link between Thimerosal and brain disorders…The federal agencies have refused to release the massive public health information accumulated in their Vaccine Safety Database (VSD) apparently to keep independent scientists from reviewing evidence that could prove the link. They are also muzzling or blackballing scientists who want to conduct such studies.
Get out the tinfoil hats, everyone! That’s right: Not only do those who argue for science hate mothers, but we’re either part of a vast conspiracy, too “lazy” to do our research, or “muzzled” by the CDC and big pharma. This is the world RFK, Jr. inhabits. Whatever good he may have done with his environmental advocacy, he is in grave danger of tipping the overall balance of good to evil that he’s done to the evil side by his persistent advocacy of antivaccine pseudoscience in the face of increasingly overwhelming evidence that there is no detectable correlation between either thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism or vaccines in general and autism.
Why RFK, Jr.’s antivaccine views matter
A common argument against concerns such as the ones I laid out above about RFK, Jr.’s advocacy of vaccine pseudoscience is that the EPA and Department of the Interior do not set vaccine policy. In other words, it is argued that, sure, RFK, Jr. is a total crank when it comes to vaccines, but he’s on the side of right and goodness when it comes to the environment. That argument seems reasonable enough, as far as it goes, but it looks at the question from far too narrow a viewpoint. The more appropriate viewpoint is what the appointement of RFK, Jr. to a major government agency responsible for turning environmental law and policy into regulations that impact the health of every citizen in the U.S would say about the commitment of the U.S. government not just to science-baesd medicine but science-based policy in general. What it would say would not be good; indeed, it would put the lie to President-Elect Obama’s previous promises to be a “pro-science” President. RFK, Jr. has demonstrated himself on this issue not only to be prone to dubious science, but to have become a true believer in one of the most outrageous and dangerous forms of pseudoscience out there: antivaccinationism, or vaccine rejectionism. If you’re trying to build an administration ostensibly devoted to using the best science as the basis for public policy, and the EPA is one agency where that is incredibly important, you do not want someone who is so prone to pseudoscience and promoting misinformation running that agency. Moreover, RFK, Jr’s tendency to play fast and loose with science goes beyond mercury in vaccines and into the very area where he claims expertise, the environment, where he blames Katrina on global warming, for instance (not even Al Gore does that). Apparently, any “science” is good to him, as long as it appears to support his agenda. Add to that his “not in my backyard” hypocrisy in opposing a proposal to build wind power turbines off of Martha’s Vineyard, and it’s hard for me to comprehend how Obama could consider him for a post even for a moment.
Also, his antivaccine pseudocience and advocacy of autism quackery like chelation therapy aside, let’s not forget also that RFK, Jr. is utterly unqualified to run a major government agency, his environmentalist activities notwithstanding. The EPA is a sprawling bureaucracy charged with converting environmental law into concrete regulations and then enforcing those regulations. It takes a strong managerial skill set to run such an organization. Is there any evidence that RFK, Jr. has the managerial chops to run a bureaucracy as large and complex as the EPA? None that I can see. Certainly he doesn’t have the temperament for such a task. He’s always seeing dark conspiracies everywhere and is prone to fly off the handle and conflate policy disagreements with evil in the form of Adolf Hitler. After all, he’s been quoted thusly about reporters who don’t report what he thinks they should report, “They should all drink poison Kool Aid and restore integrity to their profession.” The man is so prone to see conspiracies everywhere that I sincerely wonder if any time a mail order company fails to deliver its product on time to him he starts thinking that the government and his enemies conspired to intercept it before it arrived at his house. However, looking at his prior advocacy, I can now see how his love of standing up for “the people” against the powerful could have led him astray when it comes to thimerosal in vaccines. The problem is that not all groups claiming to be downtrodden are, in fact, downtrodden, and not all groups claiming a government conspiracy against them are, in fact, victims of a conspiracy. As hard as it is to believe, there are times when the government and corporations are not conspiring and are actually closer to the side of good science than “the people.” The case of antivaccine activists is just one such example.
Finally, not only would letting RFK, Jr. anywhere near Interior or the EPA allow him to insinuate his pseudoscience into government policy, RFK, Jr. would be a profound embarrassment to the embryonic Obama Administration right from the start. His temperament, his tendency towards conspiracy-mongering and calling his opponents “Nazis” or “traitors,” and his credulity towards pseudoscience that allows him to cast himself as the Great Defender Of The Underdog would provide endless ammunition for Republicans to use against the Obama Administration. Worse, in most cases Obama’s opponents would be right: RFK, Jr. could be expected to politicize science and medicine every bit as much as the Bush Administration was accused of doing, just from a different political viewpoint. If the Bush Administration’s politicization of science was so bad, why should it be any more acceptable from Democrats?
Fortunately, one week after the first reports surfaced, I’m heartened that the reaction to the suggestion that RFK, Jr. was under serious consideration for a government post dealing with science-based policy has been quite negative, other than from the more radical edges of the Democratic Party and, of course, antivaccinationists such as those inhabiting the forums of Mothering.com, Age of Autism, and antivaccine blogs. Campaigns to contact the Obama transition team to protest the appointment of RFK, Jr. have been suggested, and the most recent speculation (as of Friday) about President-Elect Obama’s appointments contain nary a whisper of RFK, Jr for the EPA or Department of the Interior. Indeed, his name disappeared so quickly, that I now suspect that its mention in the first place was one of two things. First, it may have been a trial balloon. I doubt this first possibility, however, as reports that RFK, Jr. was being considered for Interior surfaced the day before the election, which is rather curious, not to mention that he was then mentioned the day after the election as a potential nominee to run the EPA. These observations make me now strongly suspect a second explanation: That the source of these reports was either RFK, Jr. himself through is supporters or his supporters acting on their own to create a buzz in support of his nomination to one of these two spots. This suspicion is stoked by an interview with RFK, Jr. reported on The Huffington Post in which he said, “If asked, I will serve.” As Howard Dean famously pointed out last week, anyone willing to talk about his chances to be appointed to the Obama Administration probably has no chance. I sincerely hope that this is the case with RFK, Jr.
It is my belief that policy that deals with public health and medicine should be based on the best available science. While it is true that politics is a matter of value judgments and that different people can look at the evidence and come to different conclusions based on the evidence and what they value, what we should all agree on, I hope, is that the evidence itself upon which such political value judgments are based should be of the highest quality and based on the strongest science. Morever, such policies should be reconsidered and possibly modified according to the latest science. RFK, Jr., through his stubborn clinging to the myth that mercury in vaccines causes autism and other neurological conditions, has demonstrated that not only is he anathema to science-based medicine but to science-based policy in general. I like to think that his staunch advocacy of a failed and pseudocientific notion about vaccines causing autism has finally come home to roost and bitten him in the proverbial posterior.
Now, let’s hope that President-Elect Obama appoints people dedicated to science-based medicine and science-based policy to the appropriate posts: FDA, the Department of Health and Human Services, EPA, National Science Foundation, Department of the Interior, and numerous others. After an Administration with a distressing tendency to politicize science based on conservative politics (stem cell research, anyone?), I would very much hate to see one doing the same thing based on liberal politics. Fortunately, I don’t think President-Elect Obama will fall into that trap, but that doesn’t mean I’m not keeping an eye on him for signs that he will.

Attacking vaccines through the misunderstanding of medical ethics
Since becoming HHS Secretary, RFK Jr. has been deceptively weaponizing principles of evidence-based medicine against vaccines. Will weaponizing research ethics be next? It might if the ideas of one of his advisors, James Lyons-Weiler, are any indication.
David Gorski on May 19, 2025
Link

Ever since antivax activist turned presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. bent the knee to Donald Trump in exchange for a high-ranking position related to health in the Trump administration under the false banner of “make America healthy again” (MAHA), I’ve been warning what a threat he is to the federal government’s public health and science programs, warnings that, in retrospect, turned out to have been, if anything, not dire enough. The most dire threat, of course, is to public health in general and vaccines in particular, and, although he hasn’t tried this yet, I think I’ve found yet another way that RFK Jr. will try to undermine vaccines by co-opting a narrative that they are all “experimental.”
First, however, let’s go through a bit of background. The other day, I was on social media warning people about Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and vaccines. Specifically, I warned them pointedly not to underestimate RFK Jr.’s determination to eliminate all vaccines in the US. and that, every time he’s claimed that he doesn’t want to take away anyone’s vaccines, he was lying through his teeth. Indeed, RFK Jr. will find ways to eliminate as many vaccines as he can before 2029. First, as I have been predicting ever since RFK Jr. was nominated to be HHS Secretary, he will try to delicense specific vaccines, starting with COVID-19 vaccines. (The Wall Street Journal reported last week that HHS plans to bypass the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices and stop recommending routine COVID-19 vaccination for children and pregnant people, almost certainly just the first step in this process.) Next, most likely he will move on to more vaccines, probably starting first with the human papilloma virus and hepatitis B vaccines, both long hated by antivaxxers in general and fundamentalist Christians in particular.
He will wait a while to move against the MMR vaccine, if only because it looks bad to attack the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine during a large measles outbreak. He’s probably counting on high case numbers of meals to become normalized before he does anything on MMR, even as he tries his best to deemphasize the importance of getting children vaccinated with MMR whenever asked about the measles outbreaks. Basically, count on RFK Jr. to find creative ways to take various vaccines off the CDC-recommended schedule, so that insurance doesn’t have to cover them anymore, and also find ways to prevent Medicare and Medicaid covering them. Failing that, RFK Jr. will cherry pick bad science in order to “discover” that vaccines cause horrible side effects and/or cause autism and then use those “findings” to to put black box warnings on the label for vaccines. Such warnings would greatly discourage their use.
RFK Jr. has also made official HHS policy deceptive antivax narratives designed to weaponize informed consent into what I like to call “misinformed refusal” in order to discourage people from vaccinating and to use methodolatry with respect to the evidence-based medicine model to falsely claim that the childhood vaccination schedule has never been adequately tested in randomized controlled clinical trials because most of them haven’t been tested against his preferred comparator, saline, and is therefore dangerous. Of course, as I have explained time and time again, first generation vaccines for diseases that don’t have approved vaccines are tested against an inert placebo, usually saline, but, once there is a vaccine against a disease, it is highly unethical to test a new second generation vaccine against that disease because that would require subjecting the control group to a placebo that doesn’t protect them against the disease; i.e., one that is less than the standard of care. In the case of second generation vaccines, the only ethical comparator to use for the control group is the first generation vaccine, to test if the new vaccine is better than the old, or at least not inferior.
Look to antivaxxers to try to do a Pee-wee Herman—”I know you are, but what am I?”—and try to accuse the current vaccination program of violating medical ethics. It’s an old tactic, but I can see it being added to the “no saline placebo gambit” fairly easily. I was thinking about these issues three weeks ago when I came across a Substack post by antivax activist James Lyons-Weiler entitled Uncontrolled Trials: Modern Vaccine Policy Violates Core Principles of Medical Ethics — and How to Build an Ethical Alternative. Yes, you read that right. An antivaxxer is trying to make an argument from medical ethics to attack the current vaccination program. Longtime readers, I suspect, will find some of this familiar, just wrapped in pseudo-ethical and pseudomedical language.
Let’s dive in.
The vaccination program is experimental?
James Lyons-Weiler (henceforth JLW) is a longtime antivaxxer who happens to be one of the rare ones with an actual scientific background, not that it stopped him from weaving among the very first “lab leak” conspiracy theories shortly after the publication of the nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 had just been published. Using his super-duper molecular biology skills, JLW claimed to have found evidence of “engineering” in the form of plasmid sequences in the newly published sequence, but it was all nonsense. Before that, JLW would lose his mind over studies that concluded that autism was mostly genetic in nature, all while publishing utter dreck claiming to link vaccines to autism, the most recent of which has been promoted by RFK Jr. and others. Most recently, JLW’s Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge (IPAK)—that’s it’s real name, I kid you not—has started a journal, Science, Public Health Policy and the Law, that appears to me to be nothing more than a WordPress blog with an “editorial board” full of antivax pseudoscientists designed to publish bad antivax “science” and launder antivax studies that were retracted from actual journals that had made the mistake of publishing them.
But let’s get to JLW’s Substack, where he proclaims:
There was a time when vaccines symbolized the triumph of science — a rare point of agreement between medicine and ethics. Today, that symbolism is being dangerously eroded.
Oooh. How is that “symbolism” being eroded, pray tell:
Behind the sanitized language of “routine care” and “wellness check visits” lies a truth that is harder and harder to ignore: modern pediatric vaccine programs are systematically violating the foundational principles of medical ethics — and the very laws designed to protect human subjects.
This article will expose how financial incentives, regulatory capture, and structural coercion have hollowed out informed consent. But we will not stop at diagnosis: we will outline a path forward — a vision of what a truly ethical vaccine program would look like, anchored in the enduring principles of Nuremberg, Belmont, and the Common Rule.
Oh, goody. Remember the antivax narrative of Nuremberg 2.0? It looks as though we’re going there again. I will give credit to JLW for realizing that the ethics of medical research involving human subjects has evolved since the Nuremberg Code was first published in 1947 after the Nuremberg Medical Trials, where Nazi physicians were put on trial for crimes against humanity based on their deadly and highly unethical medical experiments carried out on prisoners in their concentration and death camps. As I explained back then, the Nuremberg Code was a start, but far from complete. It was built upon through the Belmont Report, which forms the basis for the Common Rule (which is the HHS regulatory framework governing human subjects research). Oddly enough, JLW doesn’t mention what is arguably the most comprehensive statement of ethical principles governing human subjects research, the Declaration of Helsinki, which has been periodically updated since it was first published in 1964.
One thing you must remember about these ethical principles is that they govern only human subjects research. That means more than just randomized clinical trials. It means preliminary trials, observational studies, or any study in which the experimentation might cause significant harm to research subjects. Again, though, it does not mean medical practice. It does not mean standard-of-care medical interventions, like approved vaccines. Does that stop JLW? Of course not. It just motivates him to find a way to misrepresent the vaccination program as experimental. Again, longtime readers will not find this to be surprising. Antivaxxers have been misrepresenting the childhood vaccination program as “experimental” almost as long as I’ve been paying attention.
Let’s see how JLW tries to do this:
In theory, pediatric vaccination programs are public health interventions.
In reality, they have become massive, ongoing, post-market safety studies — involving human subjects without proper informed consent.
Violation 1: Coercion and Penalty for Refusal
Parents who decline vaccines for their children face a cascade of penalties: expulsion from pediatric practices, exclusion from schools, and social vilification.
This is textbook coercion, forbidden under both the Nuremberg Code and 45 CFR 46.
Violation 2: Failure to Disclose Experimental Status
Parents are not told that many vaccines continue to be monitored under post-marketing surveillance (“pharmacovigilance”), meaning safety and efficacy are still under study.
Pregnant women are routinely advised to take vaccines without disclosure that many vaccines were never tested in pregnant populations before licensure.
Violation 3: Inadequate Protections for Vulnerable Populations
The Common Rule demands extra protections for fetuses, infants, and children.
Instead, these groups are pushed into vaccine programs without the disclosure, protections, or opt-out options that ethical standards require.
Violation 4: Financial Incentives Over Health Outcomes
Physicians and practices are rewarded financially based on vaccination rates, not patient-centered outcomes.
Quantity, not quality, defines success — directly violating the principle of Beneficence.
As you can see, Violations 1-4 only make sense if you accept the deceptive and false premise that vaccines are all experimental. To try to convince you of this, note how JLW tries to claim that, because there are postmarketing vaccine safety surveillance programs, a.k.a. pharmacovigilance, then vaccines are still “experimental.”
There are also some other doozies in there. For example, Violation 4 is the classic half-truth. Yes, many primary care practices, particularly pediatrics practices, are rewarded by health insurers for maintaining certain metrics with respect to evidence-based health interventions. One of those is, of course, vaccine uptake of recommended vaccines, because those recommended vaccines are evidence-based standard of care, no matter how much JLW tries to mislabel them as “experimental.” Nor are vaccines the only metric. Practices can receive incentives for rates of cancer screening (adult). Here’s an example from just one health insurance program. Physician practices can receive incentives for:
    • Breast Cancer Screening
    • Care for Older Adults – Pain Assessment
    • Care for Older Adults – Medication Review
    • Colorectal Cancer Screening
    • Controlling High Blood Pressure
    • Diabetes Care – Blood Sugar Controlled (A1c<9)
    • Diabetes Care – Retinal Eye Exam
    • Medication Adherence for Cholesterol (Statins)
    • Medication Adherence for Diabetes Medications
    • Medication Adherence for Hypertension
    • Medication Reconciliation Post-Discharge
    • Statin Therapy for Patients with Cardiovascular Disease
    • Statin Use in Persons with Diabetes
My reaction?
The horror…the horror.
Note that many of these are patient-centered outcomes (e.g., control of blood sugar in diabetes, blood pressure control), contrary to what JLW claims. Moreover, some health insurers work with physicians collaboratively to come up with patient-centered metrics. Don’t get me wrong. I’m painfully aware that most health insurers are for-profit entities—and often rapaciously so, at that—and I am not defending them. (Any physician who’s ever had to deal with insurance company preauthorizations would never defend insurance companies.) I’m just pointing out that, as rapaciously for-profit entities, insurance companies wouldn’t spend money on something that wouldn’t improve their bottom line by preventing disease and complications based on the rationale that it is almost always much less expensive to prevent than it is to treat. In other words, sometimes being rapaciously for-profit can provide incentives for investing relatively small amounts of money in order to prevent or decrease payouts that would cost far more money.
Going back to the rest of the “Violations” claimed by JLW, again, the vaccination program is not human experimentation; so the Common Rule doesn’t apply, making JLW’s further characterization completely misleading:
Modern pediatric vaccination programs function as large-scale, uncontrolled clinical trials — but without the oversight, consent, and protections required of real research.
    • There is no independent IRB monitoring the administration of vaccines in general pediatric practice.
    • There is no opt-out mechanism that respects voluntariness without penalty.
    • There is no routine, transparent, long-term tracking of health outcomes comparing vaccinated to unvaccinated children.
In any other context — a university clinical trial, a pharmaceutical company study — these conditions would result in massive regulatory penalties.
In vaccine policy, they are normalized, rationalized, and even celebrated.
It is not alarmist to say: we have legalized what Nuremberg condemned.
No, we have not “legalized what Nuremberg condemned.” Again, the childhood vaccination program is not human experimentation, making the proposed requirement that an institutional review board oversee the administration vaccines in general pediatric practice utter nonsense. Moreover, does JLW even think about what accepting his false premise that, because there are pharmacovigilance programs examining postlicensure safety and efficacy of vaccines, might mean. If you claim that vaccines are experimental because there is postmarketing surveillance for adverse events, then by that “logic” (such as it is) all drugs and medical devices, even after having been approved by the FDA, must also be experimental, because pharmacovigilance applies to more than just vaccines. So why isn’t JLW demanding the same standard for all drugs and medical devices?
Inquiring minds want to know. Inquiring minds also want to know where JLW is going with this.
Weaponizing EBM? That’s for amateurs. This is weaponizing medical ethics
Looking back at how RFK Jr. is proposing to weaponize methodolatry in the EBM paradigm by demanding saline placebos as The One True Comparator and the only control allowed in studies of vaccines, no matter how unethical it would be to use saline placebos for second generation vaccines, I realize that JLW is simply suggesting weaponizing the structure of medical ethics with respect to human subject experimentation codified at Nuremberg and built upon in the nearly 80 years since by classifying all vaccines as experimental, no matter how long they’ve been used safely and effectively.
Let’s review the steps of experimentation that lead to an intervention, like a vaccine, being first accepted as safe and effective based on science and then being approved by the FDA for marketing for a given indication. This is a much simplified version; friend of the blog Skeptical Raptor has listed a more detailed version of vaccine approval. Basically, these are the steps in evidence.
     1.  Preclinical (basic science). The vaccine is developed and refined, with the antigen to be used carefully selected, along with the delivery mechanism. In vitro cell culture studies and animal studies are done in order to develop evidence that the vaccine will be effective and safe in humans.
     2.  Clinical trials. These start with phase I trials (“first in human”), which are designed to evaluate the safety and tolerability of the intervention (in this case, a vaccine), as well as to determine the appropriate dosage and administration schedule. These generally involve small numbers of human subjects (less than 100, often less than 30), and in particular look for severe toxicities. Next are phase II trials, which are somewhat larger trials, usually randomized placebo-controlled (unless using an inert placebo would be unethical) designed to test for a signal of efficacy and to identify adverse reaction. Finally, phase III trials are much larger randomized controlled trials, double blind with appropriate comparator (inert placebo or previous intervention) designed to test efficacy and safety. The number of subjects can be in the tens of thousands, depending on how many are needed based on analyses of statistical power.
     3.  Approval and post approval. Assuming the results of the phase III trials demonstrate efficacy and sufficient safety, the FDA will grant licensure to the vaccine to be marketed. However, that’s not the end of the process, mainly because even large RCTs can miss rare adverse events. Consequently, as the vaccine goes on to be used by millions, pharmacovigilance programs monitor for safety. In the US, the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS, a passive reporting system) and the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD, an active monitoring system) are the two main systems used.
Basically, after successful phase III RCTs, the scientific community will no longer consider an intervention “experimental,” and, from a regulatory standpoint, it is no longer experimental either, regardless of what JLW says. None of this stops him from arguing:
Post-market surveillance of vaccines — the ongoing collection of safety data after approval — would be treated with the seriousness it demands. Every vaccination would be part of a formally monitored, IRB-approved research system, just as any other drug undergoing study would require. Parents would be told explicitly that participation contributes to ongoing safety assessment, and they would retain the right to withdraw at any time. Adverse event tracking would be mandatory, rigorous, and publicly transparent.
And:
Today, pediatric vaccine policy has wandered dangerously far from those ethical moorings. The lure of expediency — the desire to maximize compliance, minimize resistance, and achieve statistical targets — has led to a profound disregard for the dignity, autonomy, and rights of individuals. It has created a system where human subjects are enrolled in ongoing experiments without their knowledge, where refusal is punished, and where profit too often eclipses principle.
Everything JLW says here is wrong, except that postmarketing surveillance of vaccines could be better. I’ve even argued that myself, mainly because the FDA has long been underfunded and therefore had inadequate resources to be as detailed and rigorous as some might argue that it should be. Unsurprisingly, Aaron Siri (who has worked with RFK Jr. on antivax legal actions) has twisted the words of vaccine pioneer Stanley Plotkin when he suggested that there should be more funding for FDA postauthorization monitoring programs to falsely suggest that Plotkin was “admitting” that vaccines aren’t adequately studied. As I pointed out at the time, this was a reasonable policy debate about how, how much, and whether more money should be appropriated for postlicensure vaccine safety monitoring; it does not, however, indicate that vaccines are unsafe or “experimental.”
Then there’s this from JLW:
Financial incentives would be restructured from the ground up. Pediatricians would not be rewarded based on the sheer number of vaccinations administered. Instead, they would be compensated for spending time educating patients, fostering informed decision-making, and promoting genuine preventive health — across the full range of strategies, not merely immunization. Quality of communication, integrity of care, and health outcomes over time would matter far more than throughput metrics.
“Full range of strategies, not merely immunization”? In other words, JLW is turning medical ethics on its head by proposing incentivizing physicians to lie to patients. For most vaccine-preventable diseases, there aren’t a good “full range of strategies.” There tend to be no good treatments for such diseases, no matter how much, for example, RFK Jr. might claim that steroids or castor oil can treat measles. That’s why physicians and scientists went through the time and expense to develop vaccines against those diseases in the first place!
Reading JLW’s post, I couldn’t help but keep thinking back to this post on X by him:
I got to know @RobertKennedyJr during the fight across 20 states to save families' rights to exemptions, 2016-2019. I knew he was the right man to fight for those who are less able to stand up for themselves. I don't see him through the lens of "Kennedy". I see the… pic.twitter.com/AFB6rkGaA8
— James Lyons-Weiler (@lifebiomedguru) June 19, 2024
JLW considers Secretary Kennedy to be his “friend” and has been one of RFK Jr.’s advisors. Given that background knowledge, I can’t help but wonder whether JLW’s ideas with respect to treating all vaccines as experimental might ultimately inform HHS policy. This would not be an easy set of policies to change, although, given how this administration has thus far sidestepped the usual public comment and bureaucratic process to make major changes in policy (e.g., such as mass-canceling NIH grants), I could see a “tweak” such as saddling vaccines with a label of “experimental” until some onerous postlicensure process had occurred might be the next step in the dismantling of the US federal vaccination program.
Make no mistake. That is the endgame here, no matter how much RFK Jr. lies when he says he doesn’t want to take vaccines away from anyone who wants them.


   Pitfalls in Regulating Physicians. Part 1
Kimball Atwood
Link
I had intended today’s posting to be a summary of a real case faced by a state medical board. It is a case of licensed physicians treating patients with a substandard, dangerous, and unequivocally illegal method. My intent was to use it as an illustration of how difficult it can be for medical boards to discipline such practitioners, even when the treatment involved is obviously, blatantly bad. Only yesterday, I was informed by the pertinent board that because this case has yet to be resolved, I may not discuss it. So be it: I’ll save the specifics for another time. Instead I’ll offer a general example of a dubious treatment as a prelude to Part 2 of this series,† which will attempt to discover some of the reasons that medical boards might, under such circumstances, be ineffectual.
Intravenous Hydrogen Peroxide
Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a highly reactive compound that is caustic to living tissues. It spontaneously decomposes to water and oxygen, a reaction that is greatly accelerated in the presence of peroxidases (mainly catalase), which are ubiquitous in human blood and tissues. It has been used as a disinfectant for superficial skin wounds and in the mouth, and also for fabric and medical equipment. It has been used as a bleaching agent for teeth and hair. When used as an irrigant in surgical fields, in other large wounds, or consumed in any form (including intravenously), however, it has resulted in predictable, catastrophic complications: arterial and venous gas emboli, emphysema, respiratory arrest, strokes, multiple cerebral infarcts, seizures, colonic ulcers, intestinal gangrene, acute hemolytic crises, shock, cardiac arrest, and death.[1-7]
Hydrogen peroxide is also made in minute quantities by most eukaryotic cells, including those in humans. It is one of the “reactive oxygen species” involved in redox reactions, most importantly lipid metabolism. It is also involved in the destruction of microorganisms by phagocytic cells. In order to protect against toxicity, our cells sequester H2O2 in special organelles (peroxisomes) and tightly regulate both its synthesis and its decomposition.[8] When such regulation fails, endogenous hydrogen peroxide contributes to disease states, including hepatic necrosis and adult respiratory distress syndrome—probably because when it leaks from damaged cells it destroys the lipid cell membranes of other cells, leading to a vicious cycle of inflammation and cell destruction.[9]
IV H2O2 is “Fraudulent, Dangerous, and Illegal”
According to Thompson Micromedex, an authoritative drug information database, intravenous hydrogen peroxide is fraudulent, dangerous, and illegal:
GENERAL INFORMATION: Thirty-five percent hydrogen peroxide (“35% Food Grade Hydrogen Peroxide”) to be diluted and used in “Hyper-oxygenation Therapy” for AIDS, CANCERS and more than 60 other conditions (acne, gum disease, athlete’s foot, colic, headache, varicose veins) is fraudulent, dangerous, and illegal, and distributors have been actively restrained by US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) action since 1985. The liquid has been purchased in bulk from chemical plants in Texas and Mexico and repackaged into smaller containers by distributors. Stored in home refrigerators according to the manufacturers instructions, the corrosive chemical has been mistaken for water and consumed. The products – sometimes called “Biowater” and “H2O2” – are promoted as an “alternative medicine” by mail-order distributors. Materials promoting the product often include printed pages resembling magazine articles along with alleged testimonials that blend various medical facts with fictitious claims and offer the view that hydrogen peroxide’s benefits are suppressed by the medical establishment and the government. FDA is not aware of any medical benefits from consuming hydrogen peroxide in any form; no information or applications have been submitted to the agency to support any drug claims for taking this chemical internally (Anon, 1989).
Anon: FDA Mailgram. April 14, 1989.
Enter the Fringe, eh?
In spite of such dangers, for the past 25 years a fringe group of practitioners has advocated the use of intravenous hydrogen peroxide for a multitude of indications.[2] The champion of this method was the late Charles H. Farr, MD, PhD (1927-1998), the self-styled “father of oxidative medicine.” (“Oxidative medicine” or “oxidative therapy” includes the use of hydrogen peroxide, ozone, and other substances). Farr claimed to have discovered “a positive metabolic effect to intravenous infusions of hydrogen peroxide”[10], but never published an article on the subject in a peer-reviewed journal. Instead, he founded the International Bio-Oxidative Medicine Foundation (IBOMF) and the International Oxidative Medicine Association (IOMA) to promote this and other dubious methods through courses, brochures, and highly questionable “studies.”[11]
Of the 87 IBOMF/IOMA members listed in 1999, at least 27 have been subject to medical board or legal actions. The FDA effectively shut down the IBOMF Institutional Review Board (IRB) in 1997, after an inspector found that it was a sham. Recently, the IBOMF/IOMA appears to have been absorbed by the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), the major advocacy group for another dangerous and substandard treatment, “chelation therapy.”
Farr claimed safety and near-panacea effects for IV H2O2. His organization, the IBOMF, issued a brochure for patients that states, in part:
Oxidation administered through hydrogen peroxide therapy regulates tissue repair, cellular respiration, growth, immune functions, the energy system, most hormone systems, and the production of cytokines (chemical messengers that are involved in the regulation of almost every system in the body). Oxidation can also work as a defense system, directly destroying invading bacteria, viruses, yeast, and parasites.
Hydrogen peroxide is used for a variety of health problems, including AIDS, arthritis, cancer, candidiasis, chronic fatigue syndrome, depression, lupus erythematosus,…emphysema, multiple sclerosis, varicose veins, and fractures.
There are few, if any, side effects with hydrogen peroxide therapy.
The evidence for these claims is not credible.[11] The language, moreover, appears to constitute illegal “misbranding” of IV H2O2 for the purposes of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. The IBOMF also issued a model consent form, including in part:
I understand that despite the history of use of intravenous hydrogen peroxide, it may considered experimental [sic]. Because it is not standard therapy yet in the United States, you cannot and do not offer this procedure to me except upon the condition that I release you from any legal responsibility resulting from the administration of intravenous hydrogen peroxide in my case and/or any medical treatment that may be necessary as a result thereof.
Such exculpatory language is considered unethical by major human studies treatises and is expressly prohibited, for human trials, by the Code of Federal Regulations.
Dilution is not the Solution
Advocates claim that the risks of intravenous hydrogen peroxide are non-existent at the concentration that they recommend, which is less than 0.1%. Nevertheless, no safe dose of H2O2 has been established.[1,12] A recent death in South Carolina was judged by the coroner to have been caused by a single infusion of H2O2. The drug had reportedly been given according to the “well-established protocols” of the International Oxidative Medicine Association.[7]
Earn CMEs while Learning Quackery!
How, then, can this dangerous and illegal method be so openly advocated? Googling “hydrogen peroxide” yields countless hits, almost all of them promotional. The ACAM, which refers to itself as “the voice of integrative medicine,” offers regular courses in IV H2O2, chelation, and other dubious treatments, for which physicians receive Continuing Medical Education credits. Here is its pitch for a course a couple of weeks from now in Las Vegas:
Statement of Need:
We are in a time of increasing toxicity, weakened immune systems, rising infections, and circulatory impairment. Therapies of little toxicity are desperately needed to address these conditions. Oxidation therapy provides solutions to these challenges by stimulating the body to correct imbalances and restore its physiology with virtually no toxicity.
Target audience:
All physicians searching for therapies of great efficacy and little if any toxicity for the disorders of modern times.
Course Learning objectives:
At the conclusion of this educational activity, participants will be able to:
1. Describe basic oxidation therapy with the four available modalities: hydrogen peroxide, ozone, UBI and IV-C.
2. Employ hydrogen peroxide therapy, IV-C, and basic UBI therapy, with a strong understanding of ozone therapy.
3. Summarize the basic science of intravenous vitamin C as an additional oxidation therapy.
4. Utilize the theory, mechanisms of action, biochemistry, clinical research and applications of oxidation therapy for routine clinical setting in integrative practice.
Hmmm. According to the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME),
Continuing medical education consists of educational activities which serve to maintain, develop, or increase the knowledge, skills, and professional performance and relationships that a physician uses to provide services for patients, the public, or the profession. The content of CME is that body of knowledge and skills generally recognized and accepted by the profession as within the basic medical sciences, the discipline of clinical medicine, and the provision of health care to the public.
How can the ACAM, an organization that portrays itself as “selecting the most valid and reliable evidence for the topic being addressed” make such brazenly ridiculous statements as those in its pitch for “oxidation therapy”? In two weeks, I’ll offer a few possible explanations.
References:
Anon. Hydrogen Peroxide. In: Klasco RK (Ed): DRUGDEX® System (electronic version). Thomson Micromedex, Greenwood Village, Colorado, USA. Accessed 10/05 at: http://www.thomsonhc.com
Green S. Oxygenation Therapy: Unproven Treatments for Cancer and AIDS. Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine 1998;2,1:6-12. Available at: http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Cancer/oxygen.html 
Jordan KS, Mackey D, Garvey E. A 39-year-old man with acute hemolytic crisis secondary to intravenous injection of hydrogen peroxide. J Emerg Nurs. 1991 Feb;17(1):8-10.
Before the North Carolina State Medical Board. In re: John Carl Pittman, MD. Notice of Charges and Allegations, 05/15/2002. Available at: http://glsuite.ncmedboard.org/DataTier/Documents/Repository/LegacyImages/00/00/81/00008149.tif
Hirschtick RE, et al. Death from an unconventional therapy for AIDS. Ann Intern Med 1994; 120: 694
Gordon SM, et al. Hemolysis associated with hydrogen peroxide at a pediatric dialysis center. Am J Nephrol 1990; 10: 123-7
Breed AG, Associated Press. Peroxide therapy leads to a patient’s death in South Carolina. The Barre Montpelier Times Argus. Jan. 2, 2005. Available at: http://www.timesargus.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050102/NEWS/501020313/1014
Devlin TM (ed.). Textbook of Biochemistry with Clinical Correlations. 5th Edition. New York, Wiley-Liss. 2002. P.22
Traub SJ, Nelson LS. Chemical Principles: Reactive Oxygen Species. In: Goldfrank LR (ed.). Toxicologic Emergencies. 7th Edition. New York, McGraw-Hill. 2002. pp. 190-192
Farr CH. Workbook on Free Radical Chemistry and Hydrogen Peroxide Metabolism. Including Protocol for the Intravenous Administration of Hydrogen Peroxide. “Common Law Copyright, 1989-1996, IBOM Foundation, P.O. Box 891954 Oklahoma City, OK 73189.”
Atwood KC. Charles H. Farr and the Purported Scientific and Medical Rationale for Intravenous Hydrogen Peroxide. Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine. In press.
U.S. Congress, Office of Technology Assessment. Oxygen Treatments. In: Unconventional Cancer Treatments. OTA-H-405 (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, September 1990). P. 114. Available at: http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/OTA/ota05.html

   Pitfalls in Regulating Physicians. Part 2. The Games Scoundrels Play
Kimball Atwood
Link
A Few Things that No Doctor Should Do
When a physician is accused of DUI, “substance abuse,” being too loose with narcotic prescriptions, throwing scalpels in the OR, or diddling patients, the response of a state medical board† tends to be swift and definitive. Shoot first, ask questions later. After all, the first responsibility of the board is to the public’s safety, not to preserving the physician’s livelihood. One might therefore expect that a physician accused of using dangerous, substandard treatments would face a similar predicament. As you’ve undoubtedly guessed, such is not the case.
Here on Science-Based Medicine I’ve discussed at least 4 risky and implausible treatments: Laetrile, the “Gonzalez Regimen,” Na2EDTA “chelation therapy,” and intravenous hydrogen peroxide. Any medical board worth its salt ought to recognize each of those as dangerous and sub-standard, and therefore ought quickly to impose serious disciplinary measures upon any licensed physician found using them. Sometimes that is the case, but all too often it isn’t.
Rothstein Redux
We saw an example last week. Binyamin Rothstein, who accused me of “stopping” the NIH chelation trial (if only I had that much power!), was initially charged with substandard practice in July, 1995. In March, 1996, having documented numerous examples of such practices including failure to diagnose life-threatening conditions such as meningitis, pneumonia, and congestive heart failure, and using treatments such as intravenous hydrogen peroxide, Na2EDTA, and colchicine, the Maryland medical board suspended Rothstein’s license for 3 years—only to ”stay” the suspension after 90 days on the condition that he consent to remedial training, oversight of his practice, and 3 years’ probation. The board also ordered Rothstein to ”devise Board Approved Consent Forms apprising patients of the concept of alternative medicine and the risks thereof.”
Features of Rothstein’s case are common to many investigations of quacks: the board usually finds an arsenal of quack treatments rather than one or two; basic medical care is found to be substandard and poorly documented; the board, even after documenting such appalling practices, tends to be lenient at first; and the board often reveals a naiveté about misleading language, appearing unconcerned that quackery has somehow become “alternative medicine,” with its implication that an accommodation ought to be made (in Rothstein’s case, the language about informed consent) .
Another feature of Rothstein’s case common to others is that his consent order was ineffectual. Only 3 years later he was found to have been practicing in the same manner as before. The board determined that he had violated his probation, but granted him another reprieve: 3 more years of probation, now with the stipulation that he must “terminate his practice of ‘alternative’ or ‘complementary’ medicine and shall practice only ‘traditional,’ ‘conventional,’ or osteopathic medicine for the entire period of probation.”
‘Twas not to be. In 2005, again finding that nothing had changed, the Maryland board revoked Rothstein’s medical license. The revocation order expressed the board’s frustration at having bent over backward to help him keep his job:
The Board has attempted to work with Dr. Rothstein for a decade. In the first Consent Order, every effort was made to accommodate his desire to practice alternative medicine, as long as he provided his patients with informed consent, did his patients no harm and did not neglect their conditions that required traditional medical evaluation or treatment. The first Consent Order was not effective in protecting the public health, because he continued to neglect his patients’ serious medical symptoms and conditions. Despite this failure, the Board once more entered into a consent order, Consent Order II, with Dr. Rothstein. This second time, however, the Board attempted to alleviate any danger to the public by prohibiting him from practicing alternative medicine and requiring that he practice competent conventional medicine. He was also ordered to “cooperate fully with the Board at all times” in the Board’s oversight of his practice.
Dr. Rothstein did not cooperate with the Board…
Thus it took a full decade, once the Maryland board caught wind of Rothstein’s mischief, to get him off the streets. Even then, as mentioned last week, he continued to market his brand of pseudomedicine through a shady business and an even shadier claim of “clerical privilege.” 
And That was One of the Better Outcomes!
Dear Reader: before you begin making inevitable comparisons to repeat DUI offenders in the pre-MADD era, consider that the Maryland board, as medical boards go, did a pretty good job. There are numerous physician quacks (although they probably constitute a very small percentage of all MDs and DOs) who have either evaded regulatory scrutiny altogether or have faced it but managed to quack again and again. I invite you to peruse the many cases linked from the website of CIRCARE (Citizens for Responsible Care and Research), whose President, the classicist Liz Woeckner, is one of our co-authors on the TACT article; and linked from Casewatch (one of the affiliated sites of Quackwatch), operated by Stephen Barrett and another of our TACT co-authors, Robert Baratz.
On the CIRCARE website there is also a wealth of information about nearly 100 unfit TACT investigators, which we posted as a reference for the article. Of those, fewer than 20 have been subjected to state medical board actions, and a few more to federal or criminal actions (including 2 fraud convictions—good judgment by the NIH and IRBs to approve them as investigators, no?). Yet all of them peddle quack treatments.
Does It Take One to Know One?
Let’s look at another ploy common to such cases: quacks frequently claim that there is a solid scientific basis for their methods, but that “conventional” physicians are unaware of it. A corollary is that “conventional” physicians are held to be unqualified to judge quack methods (now called “CAM” or “integrative medicine”). In a case decided in 1998, the Iowa state medical board suspended the license of V. Thomas Riley, MD, a board-certified ENT surgeon who had been treating patients with “chelation therapy,” IV hydrogen peroxide, and IV vitamin C, and advising them that their dental amalgams were posing a risk of mercury poisoning. He told a patient who had had a root canal that the tooth in question was ” ‘like a dead fetus’ in her body and had to be removed.”
To support such drivel, Riley produced 3 “experts.” One was Charles H. Farr, the “father of oxidative medicine” discussed here 2 weeks ago. For Riley’s case, Farr claimed expertise in “chelation therapy” and IV hydrogen peroxide. Another was Roy E. Kerry, a fellow ear, nose, and throat surgeon who styled himself as an authority on “heavy metal toxicity,” especially from mercury. Kerry later became famous after injecting the chelating agent Na2EDTA (the same drug used in the TACT) into a 5-y.o. autistic boy in Pennsylvania, who died minutes later.
Riley also offered several chelation “studies” to support his case; we reviewed each of them for our recent article, and found them to be at best worthless, but more likely fraudulent.
Fortunately, the Iowa board was having none of it, thanks in part to the testimony of its own expert on quackery, the late John Renner. A federal case in 1993 provided a precedent for courts rejecting the assertion that “expert witnesses” must be limited to those who have used the methods in question. The US Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit, affirmed a district court’s finding that the manufacture and distribution of a hydrogen peroxide-containing “gel” for oral ingestion violated several articles of the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.* The court rejected the defendants’ claim that the government’s expert testimony should be disqualified merely because its author, Gloria Troendle, MD, “had no formal training in hydrogen peroxide therapy.” The court observed: “Requiring a physician to be trained in the very field whose legitimacy he questions would be unreasonable.” Regarding the defendants’ response to Dr. Troendle’s affidavit, the court opined:
The defendants have not rebutted this affidavit with any competent testimony from their own experts, choosing instead to impeach Dr. Troendle’s methods and to rely upon articles written by proponents of hydrogen peroxide therapy. Dr. Troendle has admitted that she has not tested or observed the effects of hydrogen peroxide, has not published articles concerning the drugs at issue, and has not interviewed doctors or patients who have used hydrogen peroxide therapy. However, she had no responsibility to do these studies; she gave her opinion based upon the information made available to her.†
Together, the last two cited cases seem to argue for optimism, regarding the role of science and reason in disciplining quack physicians and other purveyors of dubious methods. There is cause for optimism, but there have been many exceptions and setbacks, some of which might be considered systematic or part of an unfortunate societal trend. I’ll discuss some of those in two weeks.
Is Quackery an Addiction?
Let’s revisit some of the statements made at the beginning of this post. A lawyer friend of mine describes substance abuse, ‘boundary violations,’ and other infractions of the sort mentioned in the first paragraph as “low hanging fruit” for medical boards. They’re easy—not always easy to prove, but easy to despise. But what about the contradiction between the “shoot first” mentality of boards plucking low hanging fruit and the give’em another chance mentality of the same boards when faced with the like of Binyamin Rothstein? Is there a role for boards repeatedly giving “the benefit of the doubt” in the latter cases? I don’t think so. A good argument can be made that quacks are at least as dangerous to patients and at least as entrenched in their practices as are drug addicts.
Consider Rothstein’s view of his troubles with the Maryland board:
My penchant for healing has always gone beyond the confines of Western medicine and two things occurred: I had a very high success rate in treating patients, and I evoked the ire of the Maryland Board of Physicians. As a result of these two events, the Maryland Board of Physicians elected to revoke my license, not because anyone was injured, complained, or failed to respond to treatment but because my patients all did well. For full details of my case, please log onto www.binyaminrothstein.com. You be the judge.
The attitude that quackery works so well that it irks, or embarrasses, or threatens other physicians is another common feature of such cases and of quacks themselves. It’s hard to imagine that Rothstein didn’t already hold those views at the time of his first brush with the board.
I believe that opinions such as Rothstein’s are every bit as compelling to those who hold them as heroin is to a junkie or, more to the point, as the next bet is to a compulsive gambler. Imagine a gambler who doesn’t merely believe he’ll win his next bet, but who almost always does win it, and you’ll begin to sense how it must feel to be a quack physician. The unfortunate reality is that practicing pseudomedicine is not only far easier—intellectually, ethically, and in hours spent—than is practicing real primary care medicine, but it is also considerably more lucrative. Here is a passage from our chelation article (please refer to the original for references):
Chelation Goes Private: “A Big Cash Cow”
Nevertheless, a tiny group of advocates continued to practice “chelation therapy,” usually in the office. Then as now, it consisted of an initial series of IV infusions of disodium EDTA, magnesium, vitamins, and minerals, followed by monthly “maintenance” infusions. At first, chelationists called the treatment a “chemical Roto-Rooter” or a “chemical endarterectomy,” but eventually promoted it as a near-panacea for conditions as disparate as multiple sclerosis, schizophrenia, autism, cancer, peptic ulcer, back pain, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.[34,56,57] According to a recent article reprinted on the Web site of the ACAM, the most conspicuous organization of chelationists, “heart patients undergoing chelation typically receive 30 to 40 weekly treatments, then are scheduled for lifelong monthly sessions to keep the arteries free of plaque.[58]” The article quoted the price of a single chelation treatment – the ingredients of which cost a few dollars[59] – to be $120–$125. In addition, according to the Trial Chelation Consultant for the TACT,[4] there are “nutritional supplements in the range of $20 to $200 per month [and] diagnostic study costs and professional fees…ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars.[57]”
The article on the ACAM Web site reported that TACT co-investigator and “prominent expert[4]” Allan Magaziner “said his center [was] treating 400 to 500 heart patients with chelation.[58]” L. Terry Chappell, another “prominent expert” and co-investigator, told a government hearing in 1999 that he had treated “at least 2500 to 3000 patients with chelation therapy” over a period of about 18 years, but that this represented “only 20–25% of [his] medical practice.[41]” Former ACAM president and convicted extortionist Ted Rozema,[60] also a TACT co-investigator, testified at the same hearing that in 16 years he had treated “over 2000 patients [with] over 80,000 infusions of EDTA.[41]” The 2001 TACT protocol states that Trial Chelation Consultant, prominent expert, and TACT co-investigator Dr. Martin Dayton, who was convicted of conspiracy and mail fraud in 1986,[61] “has clinical experience with over 75,000 chelation infusions.[4]” The late H. Ray Evers, a convicted felon revered by chelationists as a “pioneer of chelation therapy,” reportedly claimed to treat, during the 1970s, 1000 patients per year at $3000 each.[62,63] According to a former practitioner, “chelation is a big cash cow.[59]”
Another TACT investigator, Rashid Buttar, has shown that cancer quackery is also a big cash cow. And so on.
Quack physicians are Con Men extraordinaires. They combine the psychology of religious fanaticism with the positive behavioral feedback of the norm of reciprocity and substantial monetary gain. They are successful because they have the imprimatur of the state and face little competition. They are members of a tiny, state-protected oligopoly, comprising individuals who combine a license to practice medicine with a compulsion to practice pseudomedicine.
* United States v. Vital Health Products, 786 F.Supp. 761 (E.D. Wis. 1992); affirmed as U.S. v. LeBeau, 985 F.2d 563 (7th Cir. 1993)

   How State Medical Boards Shoot Themselves (and You) in the Foot
Kimball Atwood
Link
This is almost the final entry (for now) in a series of posts about the pitfalls of regulating physicians who peddle quackery.† In previous entries we’ve seen how quacks have portrayed an illegal and pseudoscientific treatment, intravenous hydrogen peroxide, as legitimate; how a physician who practiced that and other dubious methods eluded definitive regulatory sanctions for years; examples of quacks banding together to form pseudomedical pseudoprofessional organizations (PPOs) and bogus board-certification schemes to establish the appearance of professional legitimacy, for protection from regulatory scrutiny, to garner political clout, to attract funds from interested businesses, to dupe the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education into granting continuing medical education credits (CMEs) for pseudoscientific conferences, and more.
Now we’ll look at several examples of how state medical boards in the U.S. have abdicated their responsibility to protect the public from such practitioners. A few caveats: first, in most cases I can only guess why that has happened. Some of it has probably been due to naiveté, or to political or legal pressures. To some extent it has probably been due to faddism and its close relative, misleading language. Next, the examples given here are by no means exhaustive. Next, a state medical board can only be as effective as the language in the state’s medical practice act allows it to be, and that is determined by legislators (politics), not board members. Finally, state medical boards have not uniformly made the wrong choices regarding quack practices and practitioners.
The Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) Succumbs to “Academic CAM” Pressure
Let’s start with the organization that advises all state medical boards. In 2000, after several years of sincere efforts to curb quackery, the FSMB abruptly did an about-face, establishing a “Special Committee for the Study of Unconventional Health Care Practices (Complementary and Alternative Medicine).” Consultants to the committee were Russell Greenfield, an early graduate of Andrew Weil’s “Program in Integrative Medicine” at the University of Arizona, and two more pals of Weil, Kenneth Pelletier and David Eisenberg. This resulted in Model Guidelines for the Use of Complementary and Alternative Therapies in Medical Practice, published in 2002 and subsequently accepted by several state medical boards. I’ve discussed this previously on SBM, but here will add a few comments.
In 2001, Tim Gorski (no relation to our David) who, along with the late John Renner, had advised the FSMB’s now defunct “Special Committee on Questionable and Deceptive Health Care Practices,” sent this email:
As you saw, the committee report issued when John and I were consulting was really quite good. But compare/contrast what will come if E [Eisenberg] and RG [Greenfield] get their way:
1997 report: “committee recognized that the primary responsibility of state medical boards is to protect the public from the incompetent, unprofessional, improper, and unlawful practice of medicine”
E & RG: (looking into my crystal ball!): “recognized that half of all Americans are already visiting CAM practitioners and, in order to protect the public, guidelines need to be established for licensed physicians to co-manage their patients”
Likewise, the 1997 report’s sections entitled “evaluation and investigation,” “education,” and “collaboration” will take on whole new meanings …
Tim had a pretty good crystal ball. Here’s what the 2002 report says:
Because of the increasing interest in and use of complementary and alternative therapies in medical practices (CAM), state medical boards have a responsibility to assure that licensees utilize CAM in a manner consistent with safe and responsible medicine. On behalf of the Federation of State Medical Boards and its continued commitment to assist state medical boards in protecting the public and improving the quality of health care in the United States, the Special Committee for the Study of Unconventional Health Care Practices (Complementary and Alternative Medicine), undertook an initiative in April 2000 to develop model guidelines for state medical boards to use in educating and regulating (1) physicians who use CAM in their practices, and/or (2) those who co-manage patients with licensed or otherwise stateregulated CAM providers.
The 2002 report makes much of the notion that “conventional medicine” and “CAM” ought to be judged according to the same standards and “ethical guidelines”:
This initiative focuses on encouraging the medical community to adopt consistent standards, ensuring the public health and safety by facilitating the proper and effective use of both conventional and CAM treatments, while educating physicians on the adequate safeguards needed to assure these services are provided within the bounds of acceptable professional practice. The Committee believes adoption of guidelines based on this model will protect legitimate medical uses of CAM while avoiding unacceptable risk.
The intention of the Committee is to provide guidelines that are clinically responsible and ethically appropriate. These guidelines are designed to be consistent with what state medical boards generally consider to be within the boundaries of professional practice and accepted standard of care.
That shouldn’t be hard, right? Just do what you’ve always done! That oughtta deal with the other ‘sections’ mentioned by Tim, but the devil, of course, is in the details: the elusive natures of “CAM,” its definition, and its champions. Regarding “evaluation and investigation,” “education,” and “collaboration,” the committee treated them like so many bulls at the mercy of its faena:
CAM is a fluid concept that has been defined differently by various organizations and groups. For the purposes of these guidelines, the Committee has chosen to use the term CAM as defined by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) (see Definitions). The Committee acknowledges that some therapies deemed CAM today may eventually be recognized as conventional, based on evidence over time…
Inasmuch as the (name of board) is obligated under the laws of the state of (name of state) to protect the public’s health, safety and welfare and recognizes that the standards used in evaluating health care practices should be consistent, whether such practices are regarded as conventional or CAM, the Board recognizes that a licensed physician shall not be found guilty of unprofessional conduct for failure to practice medicine in an acceptable manner solely on the basis of utilizing CAM…
CAM refers to a broad range of healing philosophies (schools of thought), approaches and therapies that mainstream Western (conventional) medicine does not commonly use, accept, study, understand, or make available. A few of the many CAM practices include the use of acupuncture, herbs, homeopathy, therapeutic massage, and traditional Oriental medicine to promote well-being or treat health conditions. People use CAM treatments and therapies in a variety of ways. Therapies may be used alone, as an alternative to conventional therapies, or in addition to conventional, mainstream therapies, in what is referred to as a complementary or an integrative approach. Many CAM therapies are called holistic, which generally means they consider the whole person, including physical, mental, emotional and spiritual aspects.
And so, in one fell swoop, the organization that had just finished advising every state medical board to take a stand against questionable and deceptive health care practices issued a breezy “Never Mind.” As long as the practice is not “proven to be ineffective or unsafe through controlled trials or documented evidence or as measured by a risk/benefit assessment,” anything goes!
A few months after Tim Gorski sent his email, by the way, he became the target of a dirty trick played by Rep. Dan Burton (R-IN), “organized quackery’s best friend in Congress.” Dr. Gorski used the opportunity to whip off a rebuttal that is jam-packed with still-useful information for those interested in our government’s role in promoting quackery to its citizens.
(Timothy! Where on earth did you go?)
Language Specific to State Medical Boards: Often Incoherent or Self-Defeating
What follows are a couple of arbitrary examples of how state medical boards attempt to deal with “CAM.”
Illinois
Among the credits in the FSMB’s 2002 report was this:
“Illinois Department of Professional Regulation Medical Disciplinary Board (MDB). Board Policy Statement: Complementary and Alternative Therapies. November 1999″
I can’t find that anywhere on line (perhaps it is obsolete), but thanks to Tim Gorski I have a paper copy. It is a maze of internal and external contradictions. On the one hand:
The various offerings of alternative medicine fall into one of three categories:
1) Invalidated: interventions that are “invalidated” because they have neither a proven nor a scientific basis for any health benefit. Invalidated remedies include any therapy that
a) is implausible on a priori grounds (because its implied mechanisms or putative effects contradict well established laws, principles, or empirical findings in physics, chemistry, or biology):
b) lacks a sufficiently acceptable rationale of its own;
c) has insufficient supporting evidence derived from adequately controlled outcome research; and
d) has failed in well-controlled studies done by impartial evaluations [sic] and has been unable to rule out competing explanations for why it might seem to work in uncontrolled settings.
2) Nonvalidated (plausible but not yet proven): [etc.]
3) Validated (proven to be efficacious).
………………..
The MDB feels physicians and providers should never accede to invalidated treatments. The Board does believe physicians may incorporate nonvalidated treatments if research results are very promising, if the physician believes a particular patient may benefit, if the risk of harm is very low, and if the physician adheres to the conventions that govern the doctrine of informed consent for nonvalidated treatment.
Wow. That could almost have been written by an SBM blogger: homeopathy is clearly out, as are chiropractic, naturopathy, Ayurveda, TCM, and almost all the rest of “CAM” other than biologically-active molecules, right? Prepare to bonk yourself in the forehead, then, as you read the sentence that immediately precedes the one first quoted above:
The State of Illinois recognizes allopathic and chiropractic medicine as the medically dominant health systems.
Or a sentence in the paragraph that immediately precedes the one last quoted:
Abusive criticism of alternative practitioners and threats to their licensure solely because they offer their patients an integrated practice will not be tolerated.
Finally, consider that in Illinois, chiropractors are subject to the same practice act that regulates MDs, and as such may (and do) hold themselves out to the public as “primary care physicians.”
Such contradictions aren’t really surprising, coming from a Medical Practice Act that issues this dire warning:
Where a physician has been found, upon complaint and investigation of the Department, and after hearing, to have performed an abortion procedure in a wilful and wanton manner upon a woman who was not pregnant at the time such abortion procedure was performed, the Department shall automatically revoke the license of such physician to practice medicine in Illinois.
Are you reeling yet? Let’s go next door to…
Missouri
Many SBM readers are aware of “chelation therapy,” a major health fraud in the US for about 40 years. Although its proponents originally thought that disodium EDTA could leech calcium from atherosclerotic plaques, for more than 20 years they’ve claimed that it works by treating “heavy metal toxicity.” This has served them quite well: it provides a rationale for using the treatment not for merely one or two, but for approximately 70 “indications,” and it approximates the formal indication for another EDTA salt, calcium-disodium EDTA. Such sleight-of-hand has duped more than one state medical board, mainly due to the efforts of a PPO discussed 2 weeks ago, the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM). Here is an example (numbered references in the original):
In 2001 the Missouri Code of State Regulations added language about chelation. It begins with a promising statement:
…the board declares the use of ethylinediaminetetracetic acid (EDTA) chelation on a patient is of no medical or osteopathic value except for those uses approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) by federal regulation.[120]
Notwithstanding that preamble:
The board shall not seek disciplinary action against a licensee based solely upon a non-approved use of EDTA chelation if the licensee has the patient sign the Informed Consent for EDTA Chelation Therapy form, included herein….[120]
The consent form warns that chelation “may be harmful” and “has been authoritatively demonstrated to be ineffective in the treatment of vascular diseases,” (emphasis in the original) but also includes these statements:
My physician has explained to me and I fully understand:
(a) that the use of ethylenediaminetetracetic [sic] acid (EDTA) has been approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) only for the use of removing heavy metals from the body;
(b) that the FDA has not approved the drug EDTA for treatment of diseases or conditions other than heavy metals poisoning;
…(i) that the Missouri State Board of Registration for the Healing Arts strongly recommends that Missouri citizens not undergo EDTA chelation therapy for the treatment of any human disease, illness, malady, or physical condition other than heavy metals poisoning;
Notwithstanding having read and understood the above, I hereby elect to undergo treatment with EDTA chelation therapy under the protocol recommended by the American College for the Advancement in Medicine (ACAM) [sic].[120]
It seems odd that the Missouri Board would warn citizens to avoid chelation, which it deems dangerous and ineffective, but declines to discipline licensees who push it. The Board appears to have been unaware, when it wrote that rule, that the statements about heavy metals undermine the statements urging citizens to refuse chelation, and are also quite false: The EDTA salt recommended by the ACAM protocol,[33] Na2EDTA, is not approved by the FDA for removing heavy metals. Even the somewhat safer CaEDTA is approved for the removal of only 1 heavy metal (lead), not heavy metals. Because there is nothing in the Missouri rule requiring a proper diagnosis of “heavy metals poisoning,” chelationists can conform to the letter of the law by doing exactly what they’ve been doing for years: prescribing chelation ostensibly to remove heavy metals, no matter what may or may not ail the patient.
Several other state medical boards or practice acts have language addressing unapproved uses of EDTA or chelation.[121] They vary in the extent to which they tolerate or condemn the practice, but most appear to have been misled by the heavy metals gambit. Tennessee is a laudable exception.[122,123]
Recently, the FDA did the job that had eluded state medical boards for years: it withdrew its approval for Na2EDTA, thus making it, for practical purposes, illegal for a physician to prescribe or administer it to a patient. Nevertheless, the problem won’t easily go away: hydrogen peroxide has never been approved for internal administration, and is thus similarly illegal when given intravenously. As we’ve seen, that hasn’t stopped our quack colleagues from doing exactly that.
“Health Freedom” States
Several states now have language in their medical practice acts or board regulations that mimic the FSMB language quoted above. Here’s how a proponent website introduces them:
Health Freedom States


The following states have laws that protect patient access to alternative therapies from licensed physicians:
Alaska | Colorado | Georgia | Indiana | Massachusetts | New York
North Carolina | Ohio | Oklahoma | Oregon | Texas | Washington
The following has law that protects patient access to alternative therapies from all licensed health care professionals:
Florida
The following states have regulations that protect patient access to alternative therapies from licensed physicians: Louisiana | Nevada | Texas
The following states have enacted laws that protect patient access to EDTA Chelation, specifically, from licensed physicians:
Oklahoma | South Dakota | Louisiana
The following states license homeopathic practice for physicians already licensed in any state:
Arizona | Connecticut | Nevada. 
Notice that the index doesn’t include variations such as those in Illinois and Missouri. It is also somewhat dated; it is on the website of a PPO, the Foundation for the Advancement of Innovative Medicine (FAIM), that seems to be petering out—possibly because of the death, in 2003, of its founder and former president, diet guru Robert Atkins. A more general resource for laws relating to the selling of implausible medical claims is the Georgetown Law Library “CAM Research Guide.”
Arizona: Pleasure Island for Quacks
For about 25 years, the Arizona Board of Homeopathic Medical Examiners has offered a safe haven for dangerous misfits with MD or DO degrees. It is entirely distinct from the Arizona Medical Board and the Arizona Osteopathic Board, and has even allowed a couple of docs to practice who’d had their licenses revoked by those boards. Notwithstanding the word “homeopathic,” a license granted by the Homeopathy Board confers upon its holder a broad scope of practice, including general medicine, minor surgery, and…quackery: the pertinent Statutes and Rules explicitly or implicitly allow licensees to practice “classical homeopathy,” “complex homeopathy,” “chelation therapy,” “oxidative therapy,” “electro-diagnosis,” “EAV,” “diagnosis and treatment of ailments according to the systematic principles of traditional Asian medicine,” “orthomolecular therapy,” “neuromuscular integration,” “bio-terrain analysis,” “live blood analysis,” “magnetic therapy,” and more. On October 1, 2008, to (ahem) more accurately reflect this broad scope, the name of the board was officially changed to the “Board of Homeopathic and Integrated Medicine Examiners.”
It’s not surprising that scoundrels from other states have found sanctuary in Arizona. In 2005, investigative reporter Robbie Sherwood of the Arizona Republic documented examples of the homeopathy board granting licenses to felons and other physicians who’d been disciplined elsewhere for substandard practices and fraud, among other charges. Interviews with board members made it clear that this was no accident:
Members of the homeopathic board say they have welcomed doctors to Arizona who have been disciplined unfairly in other states and whose skills could benefit patients seeking alternative remedies. Until recently, a Web page operated by the Arizona Homeopathic and Integrative Medical Association urged homeopathic doctors to come to Arizona if they have been “oppressed” by medical boards elsewhere.
“There are doctors that have been enlightened as far as natural cures that have been around for hundreds of years, and their medical boards take them up on charges,” said Dr. Bruce Shelton, former Arizona homeopathic board chairman. “Those doctors are welcomed here to practice integrative medicine.”
Come in Rangoon!
“Natural cures” weren’t the only reasons that such émigrés had been “oppressed by medical boards elsewhere”:
Troubled physicians licensed by the board include Dr. Charles Crosby, who obtained his Arizona homeopathic license in May 2004 despite revealing to the board that he had been ordered to have counseling for a “perceived loss of social inhibition” in his home state of Florida. It later became known that Crosby had been accused of fondling patients and of having a breast fetish. A report on the case in Florida said Crosby had developed “a special technique of manipulating women’s breasts to treat pain in other areas of their body.”
The suspension of Crosby’s license in Florida triggered a inquiry before the Arizona homeopathic board in July. At the meeting, Schwengel, the board president, said he did not find any specific examples that showed Crosby had acted unprofessionally, according to meeting minutes.
The Arizona Republic stories are no longer available online without paying a fee, but at the time were posted by several skeptics’ sites, including that of physical therapist Paul Lee (here and here).
At some point you had to wonder how the Arizona Homeopathy Board had responded to the bad press, which it certainly must have noticed. Its website has minutes of its meetings, and there just had to be references to the articles in the Republic. Well, the meeting of Nov. 15, 2005, which would have been the first to follow the articles’ publication, was cancelled for unstated reasons. The following meeting, on Dec. 6, gave almost no indication that the Board had noticed the criticism. On Jan. 10, 2006, however, the Board offered this discussion:
General discussion: function and duty of Board members
Dr. Schwengel began the discussion by noting that a board member’s duty was to protect the public and license qualified doctors. He explained that the homeopathic physician represented a considerable expansion of medical skills and offered the public greater choice of healthcare. The special training needed to qualify for the homeopathic license is not limited to homeopathic medicine but also encompasses other modalities defined in ARS §32-2901(22) including acupuncture, nutrition, chelation therapy, orthomolecular medicine and osteopathic manipulation.
He indicated that the board provides recourse for the public to file complaints and the Office of the Attorney General serves as the legal advocate to the Board. The confidentiality of patient records is maintained during deliberations and executive sessions offer the board the opportunity to receive legal advice from its legal advocate, their assistant attorney general. He explained that during an executive session the board can not deliberate matters or make personal comments but can only seek legal advice.
In closing Dr. Schwengel noted that the sunset review process is an opportunity to make changes and address procedures that would make it more responsive to the needs of the citizens of Arizona. In as much as an audit of the board has not been performed in twenty years, the board welcomes the audit process and believes the processes examined by the auditors will benefit from the scrutiny and ultimately, the citizens of Arizona will be better served.
At this point, Dr. Schwengel opened the floor to board members.
Mr. Farris commented that in his opinion the public does not fully understand what the roll of the board is. As a public member, his job is to protect the public by applying the laws governing the board to the processes of licensing and complaint reviews. He noted his personal experience in the value of homeopathic medicine through the effectiveness of treatments received by his own family members.
Dr. Rowe thanked the Office of the Attorney General for their assistance to the Board and for providing clarity in their interpretation of the laws governing the board.
Dr. Gordon stated that there was a national crisis relative to the public’s access to affordable healthcare and to choices in the type of care available. The board serves an important roll in regulating alternative healthcare providers.
Once again, please pass the potentized Ipecac. It turns out that there was, subsequently, an audit of the Arizona Homeopathy Board (although you’d be hard-pressed to discover that fact by looking on the Board’s website). The auditors, in spite of being barraged by conflicting opinions that they may not have been capable of evaluating, made some good points, albeit in the understated language common to such efforts. To wit: ”The Legislature should consider whether there is a need to continue the Board.”
Alas, it appears to have continued.
Colorado and the Unlawful Practice of Medicine
Some state medical practice acts require medical boards not only to discipline their licensees, but to identify and trigger actions against non-licensees whose activities constitute the unlawful practice of medicine. Colorado is one such state. Three years ago, rational health care activists Linda Rosa and Larry Sarner of Loveland discovered numerous examples of such unlawful practices. They gathered the evidence and presented it to the Board of Medical Examiners, as stipulated by the Colorado Medical Practice Act. Rosemary McCool, the director of the Division of Registrations, responded that “we are not in a position to accept and process your complaints,” citing the following:
. . . you have not included specific patient-care allegations regarding these individuals. In fact, it does not appear that you have personally interacted with these naturopaths and have no direct knowledge of the services that they provide. . . . it appears that your primary objection is to the fact that these individuals provide some type of health-care service.
Ms. Rosa and Mr. Sarner had been corresponding with others interested in the issue, including Dr. Carl Bartecchi at the University of Colorado School of Medicine and yers truly (previously mentioned on SBM here). Needless to say, Ms. McCool’s response rankled, enough to inspire us to write an op-ed piece for the Rocky Mountain News. That piece also now appears to be available only for a price, but thanks again to Paul Lee you can read it here for free. It doesn’t seem to have had any tangible effect, but it sure felt good.
Sometimes this anti-health-fraud stuff feels like bein’ in the Folk Song Army (the part about Franco, that is).

   The North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners, Dr. Rashid Buttar, and protecting the public from practitioners of non-science-based medicine
David Gorski
Link
One of the most contentious and difficult aspects of trying to improve medical care in this country is enforcing a minimal “standard of care.” Optimally, this standard of care should be based on science- and evidence-based medicine and act swiftly when a practitioner practices medicine that doesn’t meet even a minimal requirement for scientific studies and clinical trials to support it. At the same time, going too far in the other direction risks stifling innovation and the ability to individualize treatments to a patient’s unique situation–or even to use treatments that have only scientific plausibility going for them as a last-ditch effort to help a patient. Also, areas of medicine that are still unsettled and controversial could be especially difficult to adjudicate. Unfortunately, with medicine being regulated at the state level, there are 50 state medical boards, each with different laws governing licensure requirements and standards for disciplining wayward physicians, our current system doesn’t even do a very good job of protecting the public from physicians who practice obvious quackery. The reasons are myriad. Most medical boards are overburdened and underfunded. Consequently, until complaints are made and there is actual evidence of patient harm, they are often slow to act. Also, in my experience, they tend to prefer to go after physicians who misbehave in particularly egregious ways: alcoholic physicians or physicians suffering from other forms of substance abuse; physicians who sexually abuse patients; or physicians who are “prescription mills” for narcotics. These sorts of cases are often much more clear-cut, but most importantly they don’t force boards to make value judgments on the competence and practice of physicians to nearly the extent that prosecuting purveyors of unscientific medicine does.
Dr. Rashid Buttar: Autism and cancer
The reason I’ve been thinking about this issue again is because last Friday it was announced that one of the most dubious of dubious physicians of which I have ever become aware, Dr. Rashid Buttar of North Carolina, was, after many years of practice, finally disciplined by the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners. Basically, the Board restricted his practice so that he could no longer treat children or cancer patients (more on why those two particular restrictions were imposed below). Once hailed as a hero by antivaccinationists and even once having testified to the Subcommittee on Wellness & Human Rights on autism issues, he is now disgraced.
Dr. Buttar runs a clinic called the Center for Advanced Medicine and Clinical Research, which features on its front page this quote:
“All truth passes through 3 phases: First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed, and Third, it is accepted as self-evident.”- Arthur Schopenhauer, 1788-1860.
I can’t resist mentioning that any time I see this particular quote, I know that I’m almost certainly dealing with someone who is far on the fringe, because what one first has to realize about the quote is that non-”truth” never makes it past phase one or two–and rightly so. Right off the bat, we can see that Dr. Buttar has a greatly inflated view of his own importance.
I first became aware of Dr. Buttar around three years ago in the context of his “transdermal” chelation therapy for autism. Regular readers may be aware that the whole concept of “chelation” therapy for autism is based on the scientifically discredited notion that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in childhood vaccines until the end of 2001 is a major cause of autism. Based on this highly dubious concept, all manner of methods to “detoxify” these children of the mercury (and other heavy metals) that, according to antivaccinationists, are the cause of autism, have been used on autistic children. Chelation therapy involves using chemicals that can bind to the metal ions and allow them to be excreted by the kidneys, and indeed this is standard therapy for certain types of acute heavy metal poisoning. However, when it is used for coronary artery disease or autism, on a strictly stoichiometric and pharmacological basis, it is extremely implausible. Moreover, it is not without potential complications, including renal damage and cardiac arrhythmias due to sudden drops in calcium levels. Such arrhythmias can and have led to deaths (more later). Despite this extreme implausibility, randomized controlled studies showing that chelation is no better than placebo for cardiovascular disease, and no evidence at all that it does anything at all for symptoms of autism, a veritable cottage industry of chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease and autism has sprung up. With most regimens costing $100 to $150 a treatment and “requiring” 30 to 40 doses, it’s a tidy little profit center for “alternative” physicians.
Dr. Buttar made his name in the autism community by coming up with a form of chelation therapy that did not involve intravenous medication, which led him to be lionized by boosters of the “mercury causes autism” such as Generation Rescue. He took an accepted chelator used for acute heavy metal poisoinging, including mercury, called DMPS, formulated it as a paste or cream, and dubbed it “transdermal” DMPS or TD-DMPS, or, as some wags have dubbed it, “Buttar’s butter.” His main claim is that it’s safer. Of that there is little doubt, but that’s because Dr. Buttar has either utterly refused or been unable to provide even the barest modicum of evidence to suggest that the DMPS is absorbed through the skin and into the bloodstream. That is the most basic question that any science-based physician would ask about any transdermal medicine, and Dr. Buttar’s reactions to such questions is very telling. For instance, Prometheus quotes him:
In answer to questions of whether he has tested to see if his transdermal DMPS (TD-DMPS) drops are, in fact, absorbed through the skin -
No, we haven’t done that. Why would I waste my time proving something that I already know is working innately?
And, in response to being challenged on this point, Dr. Buttar wrote in an e-mail exchange with a supporter of his named Pat Sullivan:
My purpose is not to prove that TD-DMPS is getting through the skin Patrick. I don’t care if it is a placebo, which obviously it isn’t….and our lancet paper
It is a “SAFETY” issue I’m talking about….I don’t care to prove a damn thing to those people that you have been dueling it out with.
In a later e-mail, Dr. Buttar wrote:
You see, first, you would have to actually have to have some type of test developed to actually detect the DMPS in it’s altered form as it is absorbed. That takes money, effort and time. As my friend says, why do it? Let someone who wants to establish biokenetics and half life do that. It is not necessary to do this from a clinical efficacy standpoint. It would be nice to know how it works, but it is irrelevant. It works based on empirical evidence.
So it’s absorption is not an issue for me or for anyone who is a true scientist because the empirical evidence is abundant. Only a pseduo scientist is going to get caught up with levels in serum, which it may not even show, since DMPS is highly neurophillic and may be possibly taken up by the nerves or distributed through the lymphatics…I don’t know and I frankly don’t care since it has no relevance to the clinical side of the house. But you see how absurd it is to simply assume it has to get into the serum? It most likely does, but it may not. The point is, it gets in and it works….and it works better than anything else out there.
Yes, Dr. Buttar “knows” his treatment works, based on his “clinical experience.” He don’t need no steekin’ science, like bothering to show that his drug actually gets absorbed through the skin into the bloodstream. (Never mind that Dr. Buttar has been promising a study since 2004.) This seems quite odd, given that it would in fact be pretty straightforward to document whether the DMPS is getting into the bloodstream and if it is actually chelating heavy metals. Why on earth would he not want to do it? Of course, as we know, the plural of “anecdotes” is not “data,” as Steve Novella has pointed out, and, as Prometheus has pointed out, autism is a syndrome of developmental delay, not developmental stasis, which is why randomized studies with a placebo-control group are so critical. Particularly telling is Dr. Buttar’s statement that he “doesn’t care if it’s a placebo.” Little more needs to be said about his attitude about science, but that hasn’t stopped him from promoting this unproven and dubious therapy for autism for several years now.
More recently, Dr. Buttar developed a new “protocol” for treating autism that involved more than just chelation therapy. It is described here by a parent who saw him for a consultation a couple of years ago:
Every 2 weeks our son will get IV EDTA and ozone (which will be infused in his blood and given via IV) and on the second day he will get minerals. The reason given for ozone is to reduce persistent organics in his system. There is no test being recommended to determine if the child will be a good candidate for ozone. Apparently, some children are seeing good results and Dr Buttar is trying this treatment on older children (greater than 7). Dr Buttar’s office has provided some research on ozone done by a MD researcher in NY whom we spoke with. The immediate reaction of this researcher was that there has not been any study with children while ozone therapy is safe and has been used on millions of people in Europe. The researcher was not aware of Dr Buttar or his protocol on children and said that one needs to establish first if ozone therapy is needed.
There is no biologic plausibility or evidence to support the use of such a regimen. But Dr. Buttar has reportedly gone even beyond this level of dubiousness. As reported by Kevin Leitch, parents on a Yahoo! discussion group about chelation therapy for autism were reporting in 2006 that Dr. Buttar was recommending, well, let Kevin describe it. First, a parent asks:
Have any of your tried, or even heard anything about, doing urine shots to help the immune system? I don’t know much about it yet, but I know you use your child’s own urine, and filter it with special filters, before injecting it into their hip. I’ve heard really good things about it from a friend who tried it.
Here are some answers:
    • “This was recommended by Dr. Buttar’s office for my NT son who has tons of allergies. I believe Dr. Imam in NY does it. It sounded too “out there” for us so we are currently sticking with justchelation for him.”
    • “My grandson went through this beginning in October. It was a once a week treatment for 10 weeks. Before he began, he had lots of allergy problems that would often advance into sinus infection and ear infections. It’s almost April and he has not had one problem since. The only thing that I see is an occasional stuffy nose that lasts only a very short time.”
    • “I only know this was described to me to be a procedure used by Dr. Buttar about a year ago when my son was his patient, but the nurse said it would require an extended stay near the clinic and we live in Texas. We never tried it and moved on to another doctor.”
As Kevin puts it:
Just in case you think you read it wrong, you didn’t. Rashid Buttar and others recommend taking some of the childs urine, filtering it and then injecting it back into them. This is apparently good for the immune system. Yummy.
Yummy, indeed.
Arguably even more egregious is Dr. Buttar’s treatments for cancer patients. Let’s see what Dr. Buttar says on his own website about how he treats cancer:
The standard method of treating cancer is comprised of a combination of chemotherapy, radiation and surgery. However, according to the conventional, traditional medical literature, 75 to 95 percent of all cancers are related to some type of toxicity which results in damage to the immune system. Also, 42 percent of all cancer patients die of malnutrition. Yet, how many doctors treating cancer address nutrition or help repair the immune system? Learn the 5 step treatment approach Dr. Buttar uses in repairing the immune system in conditions such as cancer and AIDS. Then reach your own conclusion.
None of Dr. Buttar’s treatments have been subjected to science or to randomized clinical trials. That doesn’t stop Dr. Buttar from being unbelievably cocky and making totally unrealistic claims to patients with incurable cancer:
Medical board documents don’t name the four patients whose cases are cited. But Stephanie Kenny, a Charlotte mother of three, told The Charlotte Observer she is one of those who complained, on behalf of her husband, Jeffrey Kenny.
After learning that his adrenal cell cancer had returned following surgery, Jeffrey Kenny sought help from Buttar in early 2004. “He said it didn’t matter what kind of cancer anybody had, he could cure it,” Stephanie Kenny said. “He kept reiterating he had a 100 percent success rate.”
And:
Jerry Messina, of Los Angeles, told The Charlotte Observer he also complained to the medical board on behalf of his aunt, Lori Kostin. He said she went to Buttar after three rounds of chemotherapy failed to cure ovarian cancer. The medical board said Kostin paid $10,000 of a $30,000 bill for two months of treatment with IV infusions.
Messina, who did not meet Buttar, said his aunt told him the doctor “treated every type of cancer the same” and bragged about his 100 percent success rate. Two weeks before she died, in November 2004 at age 52, “she just flat out told me `I wish I’d never gone to this Dr. Buttar,’” Messina said. “She felt that her cancer got a lot worse.”
It should be noted that Dr. Buttar claims that he has patients sign a form that “no claim to cure cancer with these therapies has been made.” Be that as it may, anyone, doctor or not, who claims that he or she has a 100% success rate in curing cancers like the ones described above is either deluded or a liar. Period. Not even cancers for which there is a good prognosis and for which we have very effective treatments are cured 100% of the time. Moreover, it is incredibly unethical to make such a claim and then accept tens of thousands of dollars for these treatments. Even worse, like the Gonzalez regimen, Dr. Buttar’s cancer regimen is very onerous for cancer patients to follow. Indeed, one of Dr. Buttar’s patients, a man with prostate cancer who has posted under the pseudonym Cajun Cowboy, summarized his regimen, and it’s incredible. It turns out that Cajun Cowboy was at first a big fan and happy patient of Dr. Buttar, but now he says:
All the information about Dr. Buttar is still on this site but I no longer am one of his patients and I do not recommend him to any one for any reason. If you go to him for treatment BEWARE, BEWARE and read Roger Mason’s books first and go to QuackWatch.org first!
His description of Dr. Buttar’s billing practices is heartbreaking, and Dr. Buttar has been known to go after patients’ estates for uncollected bills. Meanwhile, one of the Board recognized a cardinal sign of questionable medicine:
“Doesn’t it strike you as a little strange that every patient that comes through your door has heavy metal toxicity?” Dr. Art McCulloch, a Charlotte anesthesiologist, asked Buttar’s nurse practitioner, Jane Garcia.
I assume the question was rhetorical, as anyone who has taken the time to study such practitioners knows that giving the same diagnosis and treatment to every patient is practically pathognomonic of quackery.
The reason I’ve gone on so long about Dr. Buttar is first simply to show just how outside of the standard of care Dr. Buttar’s practice of medicine has been. Kathleen Seidel has documented all of the complaints leveled by the NC Board against him, and I encourage everyone to read it. My second purpose is to point out just how powerless the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners seems to have been for so long. Yes, it is taking action now and has specifically restricted Dr. Buttar’s practice to exclude cancer patients and children (the latter of which should stop his treating autistic children), but Dr. Buttar practiced this way for several years and continued to do so in the many months during which the Board’s proceedings against him ground along. Moreover, it’s by no means clear that the Board’s recommendation against him will stand. Dr. Buttar has deep pockets and can indeed afford to fight this action all the way to the North Carolina Supreme Court. I have no doubt that he will try to do just that. Even worse, even if he loses, his license is not being taken away. He will still be able to practice, just not on cancer patients or children. There’s nothing in the Board’s recommendation that would prevent him from treating patients with cardiovascular disease with his TD-DMPS.
Other practitioners of dubious therapies
If Dr. Buttar were just one example of an “alternative” practitioner who manages to get away with practicing non-science-based medicine that does not help patients and arguably harms them, one might dismiss him as nothing more than an anomaly. However, just in the realm of autism alone, he is not alone. Dr. Roy Kerry, for instance, is an otolaryngologist near Pittsburgh who apparently has given up head and neck surgery and devoted himself to dubious allergy treatments and various “alternative” medical modalities, who killed an autistic child in 2005 with chelation therapy. Yet, despite this, the CDC got it wrong about why this happened, and it took nearly two and a half years before any substantive action was taken. I will give proper credit to the State of Pennsylvania, though, that Dr. Kerry will soon stand trial for negligent homicide, although I can’t resist pointing out that Dr. Kerry still has a license to practice medicine and has continued to see patients since 2005. I have no doubt that if the autistic boy Abubakar Tariq Nadama had not died, Dr. Kerry would still be happily chelating autistic children with no inteference from the government.
If Dr. Buttar and Dr. Kerry are two who actually are being brought to justice for their offenses against medicine, however, more are like the case of Dr. Mark Geier, who has served as an expert witness in numerous lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers. He has had, as far as I know, no actions taken against him by the Maryland Board of Physicians. Describing in detail the number of questionable and unscientific practices that Dr. Geier inflicts on autistic children would be the topic for another blog post entirely, but I can summarize them with a short list of links:
    • Advocating a combination of chelation therapy and androgen blockade with Lupron (the same drug used for chemical castration) for autistic children (also here)
    • Diagnosing most autistic children with “precocious puberty” without proper diagnostic tests (an example bordering on diagnosing all autistic children with the same condition)
    • Subjecting children to excessive blood draws for no good reason
    • Running a front “institute” that allows them to constitute an IRB packed with cronies and friends to supervise his “clinical trials” (more here). As a clinical researcher, it boggles my mind that anyone can get away with such an unethical arrangement.
Kathleen Seidel has done an in-depth series about Dr. Geier, as well.
Reform is needed
Advocates for science-based medicine cannot help but be appalled at how easily physicians practicing modalities that are clearly far outside the standard of care can continue to do so with little or no interference by state medical boards. In essence, it takes particularly egregious offenses to motivate a board to act, be it substance abuse, non-science-based treatments resulting in the death or severe injury of a patient, or blatantly illegal behavior. Part of the problem is that the attitude among doctors seems to be that a medical license is a right, not an incredible privilege bestowed upon us by society that takes an equally incredible commitment and skill to be allowed to keep. Physicians who are on these boards are also often unpaid and reluctant (as they see it) to strip a fellow doctor of the means of his or her livelihood. There’s also a cultural tendency among physicians to stick together. We understand the difficulty of making decisions that can have profound consequences in our patients’ lives, and we tend to want to bend over backwards to give fellow doctors the benefit of the doubt. Our patients deserve better. The vast majority of physicians are competent and try their best to deliver the best evidence-based care they can to their patients. However, doctors who consistently do not practice according to the standard of care, be it because they are incompetent, dishonest, impaired by substance abuse, or because they have come to believe in blatantly unscientific treatments that do not help and not infrequently harm patients, do not deserve to be physicians. Examples such as Drs. Buttar, Kerry, and Geier show that our system is broken. If we as a profession do not find a way to do better, I fear that legislators will do it for us.

Physicians and “CAM”
Jann Bellamy on September 20, 2012
Link
In the last 20 or so years, the popularity of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” began to lure physicians (M.D.s and D.O.s) into employing CAM treatments, or what is now rebranded as “integrative medicine.” Of course, CAM use by a physician necessarily requires some deviation from the “conventional” standard of care. Because deviation from the standard of care can be grounds for discipline by the state medical board, state legislatures and medical boards in the United States have had to grapple with just how much medical practice acts and regulations should accommodate CAM use by physicians.
As it turns out, less than you might think.

Disclaimer!
Allow me to jump in early on with some qualifiers. This is not a law review article and I did not exhaustively research all 50 states statutes and regulations. Nor am I saying that if you are a physician and have practiced or recommended CAM you violated your state’s medical practice act or regulations. And, of course, no one practicing medicine (actually, no one period) should rely on a blog post for legal advice. If you want to know the appropriate parameters for practicing CAM, or integrative medicine, or whatever you might wish to call diagnostic methods and treatments that have no plausible basis in science, call your lawyer and your state medical board.
Limitations on CAM use
That said, I did find several states with specific laws or regulations governing CAM practice by licensed physicians. I was pleasantly surprised to learn there are, in my opinion, some significant restrictions on use of CAM. Usually these laws say something to the effect that a physician cannot be disciplined by the medical board for use of “alternative,” “complementary,” “integrative” or “nonconventional” (the terminology varies) diagnostic methods and/or treatments if certain conditions are met. The most common limitation on CAM use, one which might not immediately strike the eye of the casual reader, is found in this New York statute (NY C.L.S. Educ. Sec. 6527), which provides this exception to conduct prohibited by the medical practice act:
The physician’s use of whatever medical care, conventional or non-conventional, which effectively treats human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition.
Did you notice that the statute requires non-conventional treatment to be effective?
In fact, other states have similar restrictions on CAM use by physicians:
North Carolina (N.C. Gen. Stat. Sec. 90-14):
Medical Board cannot discipline a licensee solely because he used a therapy that is “experimental, nontraditional, or that departs from acceptable and prevailing medical practices unless, by competent evidence Board can establish that the treatment has a safety risk greater than the prevailing treatment or that the treatment is generally not effective.”
Oregon (O.R.S. Sec. 677.190):
Use of an “alternative medical treatment” does not constitute unprofessional conduct if “the physician . . . based on the physician’s professional experience has an objective basis to believe [it] has a reasonable probability for effectiveness in its intended use . . . and poses no greater risk . . . than the generally recognized or standard treatment.”
California (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 2234.1):
Physician not subject to discipline if use of “alternative or complementary medicine” provides “a reasonable potential for therapeutic gain in a patient’s medical condition that is not outweighed by the risk . . .”
Colorado (C.R.S. Sec. 12-36-117):
Physician not subject to discipline if use of “alternative medicine” provides “a reasonable potential for therapeutic gain in a patient’s medical condition that is not outweighed by the risk . . . ”
Ohio (O.R.C. Ann. Sec. 4731.227)
Physicians may use alternative treatments if it is “reasonable when the benefits and risks of the alternative medical treatment and the conventional medical care are compared.”
In other states, similar provisions are contained in the medical board’s regulations:
Louisiana (28 L.R. 1589):
Integrative or complementary medicine can be used “provided there exists a reasonable probability for diagnostic or therapeutic effectiveness in its intended use.”
Texas (22 T.A.C. Sec. 200.3):
The Texas regulation is somewhat confusing. On the one had it says that a physician cannot be disciplined for use of complementary or alternative medicine, “unless it can be demonstrated that such method has a safety risk for the patient that is unreasonably greater than the conventional treatment . . .” Yet, in another section, it states that a treatment must “be based upon a reasonable expectation that it will result in a favorable patient outcome, including preventive practices” and the treatment must offer a greater benefit than can be expected with no treatment.
If we look at the true CAM treatments typically employed or recommended by physicians, such as acupuncture, reiki, and therapeutic touch, I am not aware of a single one that is “effective” or provides “a reasonable potential for therapeutic gain” or is more beneficial than a conventional medical treatment. (I say “true” to distinguish therapies incorrectly rebranded as CAM, such as exercise and nutrition.) One wonders, then, how physicians using CAM in these states can avoid potential trouble with the state medical board.
Unreasonable risk
Other states have a lower standard for CAM use.
Indiana (Burns Ind. Code Ann. Sec. 25-22.5-1-2.1)
“[N]o reasonable basis to conclude that [the treatment] poses an unreasonable and significant risk of danger . . . ”
Georgia (O.C.G.A. Sec. 43-34-38):
Uses the same standard as Indiana, but only for “any illness or disease which is potentially life threatening or chronically disabling.”
Alaska (Alaska Stat. Sec. 08.64.326):
Board cannot “base finding of professional incompetence solely on the basis that a licensee’s practice is unconventional or experimental in the absence of demonstrable physical harm to the patient.” This is true even though other reasons for determining professional incompetence (e.g.,violation of Board’s code of ethics or false advertising) do not require “demonstrable physical harm.”
However, the requirement that an alternative treatment pose an “unreasonable risk” before the imposition of discipline may not be the safe harbor it at first appears. In one case, a Washington physician used a galvanic skin response device to detect and treat allergies. The medical board disciplined him even though state law provided that “the use of nontraditional treatment by itself” is not unprofessional conduct as long as it does not “create an unreasonable risk that a patient might be harmed.” The Washington Supreme Court held that leading patients to believe that the device could diagnose and treat allergies, when in fact it could not, placed patients at a risk of harm. Thus, the court essentially grafted an effectiveness requirement onto the statute by finding that lack of effectiveness itself creates risk.
Patient protection
As noted, Louisiana and Texas require a reasonable probability of effectiveness. Even if a treatment could squeak by that one, these states have a fairly elaborate regulatory scheme for a physician’s use of CAM.
In Louisiana, the physician must have a treatment plan “by which progress or success can be evaluated.” (One wonders how the “success” of, say, reiki could be “evaluated.”) The patient must be seen by the physician at intervals to assess the “efficacy” of the treatment. Lack of progress or worsening of symptoms “shall indicate the need to revise the treatment plan.” In addition the patient must have an actual medical diagnosis, which would presumably exclude something like imbalanced qi. The physician must tell the patient a treatment is unconventional or unproven and its benefits and risks.
Texas’s regulations are even more stringent. In addition to requirements similar to Louisiana’s, the Texas physician must give the patient
a description of the underlying therapeutic basis or mechanism of action of the proposed treatment purporting to have a reasonable potential for therapeutic gain that is written in a manner understandable to the patient.
I’d like to see the “underlying therapeutic basis or mechanism of action” for homeopathy or acupuncture written out in an “understandable” way.
And:
All physicians must be able to demonstrate the medical, scientific or other theoretical principles connected with any healthcare method offered and provided to patients.
We have to presume that demonstration of CAM methods would necessarily fall under the “other theoretical principles” category.
As unfortunate as it is that Texas, and other states, allow physicians to use CAM, don’t we all wish that these same regulations would cover all CAM providers? Even if the regulation of nonsense results in nonsense, it would be nice to impose some actual patient protection on the process. (This as opposed to faux patient protection, like education and training in CAM.)
Federation of State Medical Boards
Louisiana and Texas apparently based their CAM regulations on the Federal of State Medical Boards (FSMB) 2002 “Model Guidelines for the Use of Complementary and Alternative Therapies in Medical Practice,” which are to be used by state medical boards in formulating policy. (Other state medical boards may have done the same.) The Model Guidelines are interesting in that they reflect the sort of uninformed enthusiasm for CAM’s potential that I think has been tamped down somewhat by 10 years of unproductive research into CAM treatments. The Introduction speaks of “legitimate medical uses of CAM” and the Guidelines being “consistent with . . . [the] accepted standard of care.” The Guidelines themselves speak of the appropriateness of using CAM as based in part on the question of whether it has “adequate scientific evidence of efficacy.” Based on what we know 10 years later, no CAM treatment to date can meet these standards.
In April of this year the FSMB House of Delegates adopted a new “Essentials of a State Medical and Osteopathic Practice Act.” These documents (this is the 13th) are designed to “serve as a guide to those states that may adopt new medical practice acts or may amend existing laws.” Notably, while the Model Guidelines on CAM are still recommended (or, at least, they haven’t been taken down from the FSMB’s website), the model practice act does not contain any specific reference to CAM, nor does it contain any exception for CAM use to the list of conduct requiring “disciplinary or remedial action.” The Essentials do provide, however, the following grounds for discipline:
making a false or misleading statement regarding his or her skill or the efficacy or value of the medicine, treatment or remedy prescribed by him or her or at his or her direction in the treatment of any disease or other condition of the body or mind.
It would seem, then, that in any state adopting the model practice act, a physician would have to tell the truth about the efficacy of any CAM treatment he offered or recommended and not do it in a way that misleads the patient into thinking that the treatment is efficacious when in fact it is not. Again, I am not sure what CAM treatment could meet this standard based on the current evidence.
Two odd states
This brings me to my home state, Florida, which takes a unique approach. Although I can’t imagine that the legislature meant what it said when it passed this statute governing “Complementary or alternative health care treatments,”(Fla. Stat. Sec. 456.41) this is what the law actually says:
It is the intent of the legislature that health care practitioners be able to offer complementary and alternative health care treatments with the same requirements, provisions, and liabilities as those associated with the prevailing or conventional treatment methods.
Which sounds to me like under Florida law the CAM treatments must at least have some plausible basis in science and a reasonable expectation that they will actually work.
This is confirmed by the definition of CAM treatments:
any treatment that is designed to provide patients with an effective option to the prevailing or conventional treatment methods associated with the services provided by a health care practitioner.
But that’s not the reason I think the legislature didn’t realize what it was doing. (It happens.) It is perfectly reasonable for a state to require that CAM treatments be effective if they are to be used. Here’s the odd thing, though. Florida’s statute applies to all licensed health care professionals. So, in addition to M.D.s, D.O.s, dentists, nurses, and other science-based professionals, it also covers chiropractors and acupuncturists. Frankly, I don’t see how a subluxation-based chiropractor or an acupuncturist could practice at all.
Maybe they could wiggle out from under these provisions with the phrase “prevailing . . . methods associated with the services provided by a health care practitioner” by claiming it means that if a method is “prevailing” in chiropractic or acupuncture, they can use it. Thus, they could argue that detection of subluxations or rebalancing qi with needle sticks is exempted. On the other hand, the only time this argument would likely come up is when a patient claims the practitioner violated the statute by offering an ineffective CAM treatment. Normally, the defense would be that the treatment is, in fact, effective. But in this case the CAM practitioner would be put in the decidedly uncomfortable position of arguing that because the statute exempts “prevailing” treatments in his field effectiveness is not required.
And speaking of odd, we’ll close with a Massachusetts statute (A.L.M. G.L. ch. 112, Sec. 7) I discovered, which doesn’t really deal with physician CAM use but is too good to pass up. Massachusetts exempts the following from the commonwealth’s medical practice act:
clairvoyants or persons practicing hypnotism, magnetic healing, mind cure, massage, Christian Science or cosmopathic method of healing.
Cosmopathic healing? When I googled “cosmopathic” I was asked “Do you mean ‘sociopathic?'” but I did find this video on YouTube.
When cosmopathic healing becomes a licensed health care profession in the U.S., remember, you heard about it here first.


Is (Conversion) Therapy Speech?
Steven Novella on October 15, 2025
Link
The US Supreme Court recently heard a case that could have devastating effects on the standard of care in medicine, and the indicators of where the justices fall are not good. The case is Chiles v Salazar, in which a licensed therapist is arguing that a Colorado law banning conversion therapy for gay and trans clients violates her free speech. So the question is – is therapy given by a licensed professional speech, medical treatment, or some combination?
Let me first establish an important premise – conversion therapy, which is an attempt to alter someone’s sexual orientation or gender identity, has been studied for decades and found to be not only ineffective but actively harmful, increasing the risk of depression, anxiety, and suicidality. For this reason the practice has been condemned by many (here is a list of 53) healthcare organizations.
Of course, there are always complexities and nuances. I think it is very clear conversion therapy does not work. That data on harms, however, is mostly observational, although there is a consistent effect. There is one single researcher and paper which is an outlier opinion, arguing that conversion therapy does not increase suicidality, and this paper has been criticized for methodological flaws.
What all of this means is that there is a very clear standard of care, which rejects conversion therapy (also called reparative therapy, and technically “sexual orientation change efforts” or SOCE). Standards change over time as they evolve with new evidence, available interventions, and perspectives. But that does not mean there is no standard, or that the current standard cannot or should not be upheld.
There are also various ways in which the standard of care is maintained. The first line, and always the preferred method, is simply training – teaching professionals what the standard of care is and why, what the evidence base is, and then confirming their knowledge and expertise through testing, certification, licensing, and continuing education. That is, arguably, what professional licensing in health care is – a social contract in which the licensed individual demonstrates they understand the standard of care, have the knowledge and skills to implement it, and promise to do so faithfully.
But there also needs to be methods of policing the standard of care, and making corrections when it is violated. Institutions, like hospitals and groups practices, are expected to police their own, maintaining standards through privileges and affiliations. Professional organizations can also maintain standards by publishing guidelines, and also giving certification to those who demonstrate expertise, and then revoking it if members repeatedly and willfully violate standards of care. In the US, states regulate medical licenses, and any practitioner can have complaints brought against them and can have their license acted against if they violate the standard of care. This can involve censure, just telling the practitioner to stop the substandard practice, suspending their license, or even revoking their license.
There is also a fairly draconian method when all else fails – suing the practitioner for malpractice. This requires the demonstration of either neglect or substandard practice (not just a bad outcome).
And then there is the method at issue here – governments (usually states) outright banning practices for being substandard and/or harmful. I am not a fan of this method, but I acknowledge in some rare cases it is necessary. The problem with using government legislatures to determine and enforce the standard of care in this way is that such bodies are not capable of nimbly keeping up with the scientific literature. It is not their job to micromanage the scientific evidence and interpret it all to determine what the standard should be. This is why they wisely leave it up to professionals and professional organizations. They enforce the standard of care, but they do not determine what it is – the experts do that.
Typically when legislatures get involved in determining the standard of care it is for political reasons. Their interference also can cut both ways – banning certain practices, but also exempting others from the standard of care. I have been highly critical, for example, of my home state’s (CT) law exempting IV therapy for chronic Lyme disease from the standard of care. This is bad law and bad medicine. But I cannot deny that states have the legal right to do this.
With regard to conversion therapy there is a strong case to be made for simply banning the practice. The fact that it is ineffective is not enough, and even the fact that it is potentially harmful is also not sufficient, in my opinion. Many practices are ineffective and harmful, and they do not all need to be specifically banned – just let the system determine and maintain the standard of care. But in this case there is a particularly vulnerable population being targeted for therapy – minors who are also in a vulnerable social minority and who are often the target of oppressive social, parental, or religious pressure to comply (which casts doubt on their consent). Further, there are practitioners who (for apparent ideological or religious reasons) reject the standard of care. In this specific case a ban is perhaps the most effective way to enforce a very reasonable standard of care that has been long established. You could reasonably put conversion therapy in the same category as other treatments, like frontal lobotomy, where banning is appropriate.
So what’s the issue? The issue is that Chiles’ lawyers are arguing that her conversion therapy is protected free speech, and the conservative justices on the court seem sympathetic to this argument. They have not yet formally decided this case, and I hope that better judgements prevail, but it’s not looking good. This issue goes well beyond conversion therapy – it goes to the very heart of the standard of care in medicine. I would say there are two important issues here with such broad implications. The first is whether free speech trumps professional standards. The second is, is counseling therapy by a licensed professional medical treatment? I think the answers are and should be obvious – no and yes respectively.
On the second count, it has been pointed out (by some of the justices) that the Supreme Court upheld states banning of gender affirming care – which makes it seem like states can ban care the majority of justices don’t like but cannot ban care they do like. I reject any argument that therapy is not real healthcare, so this seems like a blatant double-standard.
The free speech argument is all we are left with, and I also think it is pretty clear here. Therapy is not pure speech. In the context of therapy, speech is professional conduct. It can be regulated in order to uphold the standard of care. Justice Sotomayor, I think, got it exactly right when she asked the question: “If a dietitian decides to help anorexics starve themselves, can the government stop them?”
Any therapist that believes in conversion therapy can make their case to their profession, they can state their opinion in opinion pieces, and advocate for whatever position they want. But when treating a client, the state absolutely has the right and a legitimate legal interest in what they say as part of that therapy. The state gives them a license to practice – and that license gives the therapist responsibilities and also explicitly gives the state the legal right to regulate their professional practice.
I will say, it would be optimal for state departments of health to have the resources and inclination to do their job far more robustly than they typically do. It would not be necessary for states to ban substandard practices if health departments acted swiftly and decisively to uphold the standard of care. But this is not the world we live in. In some specific cases it is simply more efficient to ban a practice.
Perhaps we need a third option – a way to strongly enforce the standard of care but with the backing of recognized experts and the ability to nimbly adapt to evolving evidence. Laws are too rigid, political, and slow. Health departments lack the power and resources to be effective. The easiest solution might just be to give health departments the power and resources they need to be more effective.


SCOTUS conversion therapy decision “opens a dangerous can of worms”
“We are on a slippery slope now: For the first time, the Supreme Court has interpreted the First Amendment to bless a risk of therapeutic harm to children by limiting the State’s ability to regulate medical providers who treat patients with speech.” Justice Jackson, dissenting
Jann Bellamy on April 21, 2026
Link

In Chiles v. Salazar, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) recently held that a Colorado law banning conversion therapy, a discredited and harmful treatment for same-sex orientation and gender dysphoria, was a “presumptively unconstitutional” infringement on a mental health counselor’s First Amendment free speech rights. The case was sent back to the lower courts to decide whether Colorado can prove its law “is narrowly tailored to serve compelling state interests”, a standard that is, in the Supreme Court’s own estimation, extremely difficult to meet.
In its ruling, the Court essentially bifurcated the standard of care for treatment based on whether the care is spoken, as in talk therapy, or conduct, as in surgery. If the treatment is spoken, any government regulation banning substandard care must meet a First Amendment test so strict (hence the name, “strict scrutiny”) that “it is ‘rare that a regulation . . . will ever be permissible’”. If the treatment is administered via conduct, the First Amendment is not implicated. Thus, the state can still rely on the consensus of medical experts as to the effectiveness and safety of the treatment in regulating healthcare practices.
And what of healthcare that arguably combines speech and conduct, like a discussion with one’s doctor concerning whether or not to have surgery? The Court gave no clear answer.
As Justice Jackson, the lone dissenter, put it, the decision
opens a dangerous can of worms.
I agree.
Today, we’ll look at the facts of the case and the majority’s opinion, written by Justice Gorsuch, joined by Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Thomas, Alito, Kavanaugh, and Barrett. Justice Kagan, joined by Justice Sotomayor, filed a concurring opinion, which we’ll touch on briefly.
Then we’ll see how Justice Jackson effectively exposes the real-world consequences of the majority’s decision and offers a more sensible constitutional framework for evaluating healthcare practitioner speech.
Along the way, we’ll encounter some familiar characters who have a vested interest in establishing a constitutional right to promote pseudoscience.
[The mental health counselor challenging the conversion therapy ban specifically advertised herself as being a Christian faith-based counselor, bringing to her defense, in “friend of the court” briefs, a number of religious organizations seeking to protect that counseling approach. Because the First Amendment’s religious freedom protections were not at issue in the case, that aspect will not be further discussed.]
Conversion therapy law
In 2019, Colorado (joining 25 other states) passed a law prohibiting licensed mental health counselors from providing “conversion therapy” to minors, forbidding (quoting the Court’s decision):
‘any practice or treatment . . . that attempts to change an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity’ . . . as well as any ‘effor[t] to change behaviors or gender expressions or to eliminate or reduce sexual or romantic attraction or feelings toward individuals of the same sex.’
However (again quoting the Court),
the law explicitly allows counselors to engage in ‘practices’ that provide ‘[a]cceptance, support, and understanding for the facilitation of an individual’s . . . exploration and development.’
As noted in Justice Jackson’s dissent, the Colorado legislature crafted this law “after crediting witness testimony and the professional consensus about conversion therapy—namely, that it is harmful, and that the preferred treatment for minors . . . is affirming care”.
Kaley Chiles, a Colorado-licensed mental health counselor, challenged the law. She claimed it violated her First Amendment right to freedom of speech and sought an injunction against the state’s enforcement of the ban.
She lost in the district (trial) court and the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, both courts finding that, because the law regulated professional conduct, and only incidentally regulated speech, the appropriate First Amendment test was whether Colorado had a “rational basis” for its ban. Because the state legislature had determined that conversion therapy for minors was harmful, the rational basis test was satisfied and the injunction denied.
“Viewpoint discrimination”
The Supreme Court reversed the decision, finding that Colorado had engaged in “viewpoint discrimination” by banning talk therapy that facilitated repression of same-sex orientation or gender identity, while at the same time allowing talk therapy that supported such orientation or identity. In doing so, the Court applied a straight-up First Amendment speech analysis, treating Chiles as if she were a random lay speaker expressing her thoughts on, say, a hot-button political issue, not a state-licensed health care practitioner providing treatment.
In doing so, the Court did not dispute the conclusions of experts on which the Colorado legislature based the law: that conversion therapy was harmful to minors, “associated with increased depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts, and suicide attempts.” Nor did it take issue with the state’s ban on the use of harmful physical conversion therapy techniques.
Thus, per the Court, a state is free to decide, based on the evidence, that a therapy is harmful to minors. But it can ban only physical manifestations of the harmful therapy. If the harmful therapy is delivered in words, the state will face a virtually impenetrable First Amendment barrier, and practitioners will be free to impose that harmful therapy on minors.
Disturbingly, the opinion was downright dismissive of the idea that the state’s authority to protect the public’s health, safety, and welfare through regulation of healthcare practitioners cut the state any First Amendment slack. Justice Gorsuch called any such attempt, when directed to spoken therapies, “state-imposed orthodoxies” and derided what he, and the majority, saw as a move to “censor almost any speech they consider ‘substandard care’”. The opinion decried what were seen as attempts to “silence”
any professional speech that deviates from ‘current beliefs about the safety and efficacy of various medical treatments’
The quacks are surely thrilled with that one.
And:
A prevailing standard of care may reflect what most practitioners believe today, but it cannot mark the outer boundary of what they may say tomorrow.
Right. Science constantly evolves, so there’s no sense in making any rules against substandard care because, who knows? I’m surprised the opinion didn’t add that quack shibboleth “science doesn’t know everything”.
The Court steadfastly refused to analogize spoken health care treatments to other situations where limitations on harmful speech pass constitutional muster, such as defamation, fraud, and “fighting words”. It also refused to see talk therapy as analogous to the regulation of commercial speech, which can constitutionally be limited to “factual” information.
Nor did it agree with the lower courts’ decisions that Colorado’s regulation of speech was only “incidental to” state regulation of conduct, which the Court has recognized in previous cases as requiring a less-demanding level of First Amendment scrutiny. According to the majority opinion, those precedents don’t apply to the facts here because those cases focused on
two entirely different questions: whether the law in question restricts speech only because it is integrally related to unlawful conduct—or whether the law restricts expressive conduct only for reasons unrelated to its content.
So, healthcare that includes both speech and conduct (which I assume is a good portion of all medical care) could get by the First Amendment if it meets one of these tests. Good luck with figuring that out. Only time, and perhaps a lot of expensive litigation, will tell us how the courts might try to untangle this Gordian knot. Or, as one health law professor put it,
If I tell you to eat steak and that cholesterol is fake, is that pure speech . . . ?
Concurrence
Justice Kagan, joined by Justice Sotomayor, wrote a concurring opinion. Unfortunately, it also ignored the expert consensus that conversion therapy is both ineffective and harmful, treating it as but one side of a “debate” and endorsing a “both sides” approach to legislation.
Once again, because the State has suppressed one side of a debate, while aiding the other, the constitutional issue is straightforward.
A law that was “viewpoint neutral” might be constitutional, the concurrence said, because such a law “raises no real concern that the government is censoring disfavored ideas”.
One constitutional scholar aptly summed up the majority opinion, which
continues a pattern of inconsistent decisions concerning the ability of the government to regulate speech by professionals. . . . If the court follows its approach in Chiles v. Salazar, it will make it more difficult to regulate professionals and to hold them liable to protect their patients and clients. [emphasis added] But there also is a strong sense that, at least for some of the justices, the case is less about a principle, but, like other professional speech cases, much more about the court’s feelings about this law.
Of course, the Court’s decision cuts both ways. Legislation imposing what some would consider inappropriate ideology on the medical profession—such as requiring doctors to recommend quackery for pain or preventing pediatricians from inquiring about guns in the home—can also fail under a “strict scrutiny” test.
Can of worms
As regular SBM readers are undoubtedly aware, I am deeply concerned about the deleterious effect of ignoring science in government regulation of health care practices and the imposition of ideology in place of evidence. Usually, this comes in the form of legislation that incorporates pseudoscience into the law. Now, even when states attempt to impose a science-based standard, at least as far as spoken treatments are concerned, their efforts could be subject to a First Amendment challenge.
In my opinion, the majority’s pure “free speech” test is neither workable nor is it constitutionally required. Justice Jackson agrees, and explained why in her 35-page dissent, which she read from the bench, indicating her strong disagreement with the majority. In Justice Jackson’s view, the majority failed to credit the context—the licensing and regulation of health care practitioners—in which Colorado’s ban on conversion therapy operates:
[It] restricts treatment-related speech uttered by medical professionals only as a part of a larger regulatory scheme aimed at ensuring that providers tender high-quality medical care to patients.
In such cases, she argues, the state is not restricting a practitioner’s speech “as speech”, that is, trying to suppress ideas or expressive content. Rather, it is regulating medical treatment that just happens to be in spoken form. A speech v. conduct distinction is “irrational” in this context:
[F]or purposes of the State’s regulation of harmful professional conduct, treatments administered through words versus treatments administered through acts are not meaningfully different. [emphasis in original]
She freely concedes that, in establishing a standard of care, one “viewpoint” is chosen over others, and finds the majority’s concern about this “puzzling”:
Within the confines of the professional-patient relationship, treatment-related ’truths’ are a given—they are set by licensing and malpractice standards, . . . Taking a position as to how . . . providers should handle a medical issue is the very essence of standard-setting . . . [A] standards-based healthcare scheme cannot function unless its regulators are permitted to choose sides.
Perhaps agreeing with the constitutional scholar’s observation about the personal ideologies of her colleagues, she remarks that
No one would bat an eye if a state required its doctors to discourage, but not encourage, smoking tobacco.
Restricting spoken conversion therapy as a function of setting healthcare standards does not, Justice Jackson notes, restrict practitioners from expressing their support for conversion therapy in other contexts, such as speaking in its favor at conferences or writing journal articles supporting it, activities she believes are protected by the First Amendment.
In summary, she warns that
the Court could be ushering in an era of unprofessional and unsafe medical care administered by effectively unsupervised healthcare providers.
Sadly, Justice Jackson, we’re already there. As I said, this decision will only worsen the existing epidemic of pseudoscientific healthcare practices.
Friends of pseudoscience
Chiles v. Salazar is already being cited by the anti-vaccine organization Children’s Health Defense in First Amendment-based suits against the California and Washington state medical boards over actions targeting doctors who spread COVID misinformation. Its attorney expects a “quick win”.
Speaking of COVID misinformation, a “friend of the court” brief supporting Chiles’s challenge to the conversion therapy ban was filed by America’s Frontline Doctors and Simone Gold, M.D., J.D., who represented the organization before the Court. As you may recall, this group, with Dr. Gold participating, held a rally in D.C. in 2020, where they claimed that hydroxychloroquine, zinc, and Zithromax were “cures” for COVID. Dr. Gold has also said that the COVID vaccine is actually an “experimental biological agent deceptively named a vaccine.” Her brief reiterates these themes, claiming that she and her group were “targeted” by the government for promoting the benefits of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine for COVID even though they proved to be “completely correct”. (No, they’re not.)
Another friend of the court brief supporting Chiles was filed by that friend of pseudoscience, the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), which says it has “strong interests in defending and restoring freedom of speech in the medical profession.” No doubt, as it leaves AAPS members free to promote false information, like claiming links between vaccines and both autism and SIDS, and between abortion and breast cancer.
If I’m being optimistic, on remand to the Court of Appeals, which will almost certainly send the case back to the trial court, I’m not convinced that Colorado couldn’t successfully defend its conversion therapy ban as “narrowly tailored to serve compelling state interests”, given the overwhelming professional consensus (summarized by Justice Jackson in her dissent) that, in addition to the harms mentioned,
the medical community has determined that efforts to change a patient’s sexual orientation or gender identity will necessarily be ineffective. The American Psychological Association . . . has found ‘no empirical evidence that providing any type of therapy in childhood can alter adult same-sex orientation.’ . . . And ‘[n]o research published in the peer-reviewed literature that demonstrates the efficacy of conversion therapy efforts with gender minority youth, nor any benefits of such interventions to children and their families.’
I am hard pressed to imagine, then, why a state wouldn’t have a “compelling interest” in banning conversion therapy, although I admit that the “narrowly tailored” requirement might make some tinkering with the language of the ban necessary. We’ll see what happens.


Idaho allows faith-based medical neglect to kill children
Idaho parents are shielded from criminal prosecution if they choose “prayer or spiritual means” over effective medical care for their children, even as their children keep dying.
Jann Bellamy on October 6, 2026
Link

In Idaho, as in other states, medical neglect of a child is a crime. However, if an Idaho parent (or guardian)
chooses for his child treatment by prayer or spiritual means alone
and the child suffers, even if he dies, the parent is exempt from criminal prosecution.
Not only does Idaho law shield the neglectful parents from prosecution, it prevents law enforcement and social workers from stepping in to protect a dead child’s siblings from suffering a similar fate.
Preventable deaths
The consequences of these barbaric laws were recently laid out in three maddening, heart-wrenching articles by the independent, non-profit newsroom, ProPublica. ProPublica reporters assembled law enforcement and death records involving children born into a faith-healing sect called Followers of Christ, a group we’ve covered before on SBM. The sect believes
that God heals the faithful and that life and death must be left to God’s divine will.
The news organization had medical experts review those records to determine whether the deaths would have been preventable with appropriate medical care. The review found that at least 15 babies and children died between 2015 and 2025 from illnesses that could have been successfully treated which, they concluded, was “almost certainly an undercount.”
Six deaths could not be evaluated due to incomplete or unavailable records. In four cases, experts could not say with confidence that medical care would have changed the outcome. (Although, I would think, almost certainly palliative medicine could have eased the children’s suffering.)
As well, experts identified numerous preventable losses of babies who died during birth or in utero very close to their due dates, cases labeled by the coroners as stillbirths.
The details of these deaths are horrific, gathered both from witness testimony and the conclusions of the medical experts about what the child would have experienced prior to death. These accounts are difficult to read but, unfortunately, in the torrent of news about human suffering being wrought by depraved governmental forces and medical bad actors, I felt these recent stories were not getting the attention they deserve; hence this post.
(ProPublica has also been at the forefront of digging out sundry other malfeasance, both health-related [raw milk, abortion bans, dismantling of USAID] and not, such as this recent blockbuster scoop involving a certain wedding.)
Faith-based medical neglect
A summary of some of ProPublica’s findings:
    • A newborn whose condition meant that he would have been gasping for air and turning blue due to lack of oxygen before dying from pneumonia. Thirteen months later, his newborn younger brother died of the same condition, which experts suspect was from a birth-related strep infection that expectant mothers in the U.S. are routinely screened for and is entirely treatable with antibiotics.
    • A 16-year-old “the size of a third grader” (62 pounds, just under 4 feet tall), whose death experts traced to a benign, treatable pituitary tumor that should have been discovered due to her stunted growth earlier in childhood. She suffered from many ailments during her brief life, her tumor sending “her body into a hormonal tailspin that destroyed her organs.”
    • At least three children who died from sepsis caused by common infections that could easily have been treated with antibiotics. One boy was born “happy and alert” but, over the next couple of days, grew “darker in color, coughing up phlegm and clenching his limbs in convulsions” before dying.
    • A two-year-old boy who was sick for six weeks with an untreated bacterial infection that settled in his heart and destroyed it. He had “fevers, abdominal pain, vomiting and swelling”.
    • A 16-month-old who died from an intestinal condition that can be fixed with a routine, minimally invasive surgery. Left untreated, the autopsy determined, the boy’s bowels had compressed his lungs and heart, which stopped beating; his lungs were so cramped they stayed the size of a newborn’s.
    • Four young children from the same family died from what appears to be untreated diabetes. They suffered from uncontrolled vomiting prior to passing away.
    • Two newborns from the same family died after aspirating meconium, an extremely rare occurrence in the U.S. A healthcare provider attending a birth is trained to detect meconium aspiration and to prevent illness and death of the infant with established protocols, including prescribing antibiotics.
In fact, records show at least five sets of parents have lost multiple children.
One of the sect’s “patriarchs” defended the Followers of Christ’s thusly:
Children and babies can’t make their own decision to rely on faith healing. [He] said their parents must keep them away from the doctor to set an example, so the young ones won’t be cursed later in life by turning to medicine.
Sect members who go to the doctor are shunned by their communities to reinforce its beliefs and, in the patriarch’s words, make sure they don’t go again. Family and neighbors form a protective shield around parents whose children die from neglect, trying to isolate them from law enforcement when the deaths are investigated, according to deputies who’ve been sent to follow up when a death is reported.
“Beyond comprehension”
Not everyone in Idaho agrees with shielding parents from the consequences of their neglect. Canyon County Sheriff Kieran Donahue, one of the most vocal opponents of the state’s faith-healing laws, has sent deputies to follow up on the deaths of at least 10 Followers’ children and infants since he took office in 2013.
‘This is needless,’ Donahue said. ‘This shouldn’t be happening.’
Retired pediatrician Dr. David Peterman, who reviewed the deaths of 18 infants and children, agrees. He finds it beyond comprehension that state legislators won’t change the law.
‘How is this tolerable?’ he said. ‘I don’t understand how there could be an exception in Idaho law that allows for these children to die.’
It’s hard to imagine any rational person disagreeing, but Idaho legislators have so far resisted changing the 1971 faith-healing legislation. In fact, the state legislature, in 1976, added a law that kept children from being placed in foster care solely for lack of medical attention.
According to ProPublica,
Since 2014, [state legislators] have rejected repeated efforts to dial back Idaho’s faith-healing exemption, instead crafting legislation to further limit the role of anyone but a parent when it comes to children’s health and safety. The state has codified ‘parental rights,‘ banned vaccine requirements in schools and childcare centers, and made parental consent a prerequisite for medical care of minors. Legislators also have tried to narrow the definition of ‘medical neglect’ for all families to only the most life-threatening situations, but those attempts have failed.
Next door, in Oregon, the rollback of similar laws protecting faith-based medical neglect has resulted in prosecutions of parents who put their children at risk. This provides a “powerful incentive for parents to seek medical care” and gives the state “legal leverage to order medical care for surviving and future children”, according to ProPublica’s reporting.
Given the current political support for ill-informed medical decision-making by parents and disregard for the resulting suffering it causes, I am not optimistic that Idaho’s laws will be revised in the near term. Unfortunately, we can be certain more children will suffer and die until that happens.


Naturopathy

   Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 1
Kimball Atwood
Link
Minnesota has recently become the 15th state in the U.S. to formally endorse the claims of a tiny group of naturopaths who portray themselves as physicians.* The bill , like the popular-media “CAM” reports that Steve Novella criticized on Wednesday, merely parrots what these naturopaths claim about themselves. It reveals no attempt to investigate or to judge the tenets of the field. The following excerpts present false assertions as though they were facts. I’ve underlined some of the more obvious examples:
“Naturopathic medicine” means a system of primary health care for the prevention, assessment, and treatment of human health conditions, injuries, and diseases…
“Naturopathic physical medicine” includes, but is not limited to, the therapeutic use of the physical agents of air, water, heat, cold, sound, light, and electromagnetic nonionizing radiation and the physical modalities of electrotherapy, diathermy, ultraviolet light, hydrotherapy, massage, stretching, colon hydrotherapy, frequency specific microcurrent, electrical muscle stimulation, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, and therapeutic exercise.
The practice of naturopathic medicine includes, but is not limited to, the following services: (1) ordering, administering, prescribing, or dispensing for preventive and therapeutic purposes: food, extracts of food, nutraceuticals, vitamins, minerals, amino acids, enzymes, botanicals and their extracts, botanical medicines, herbal remedies, homeopathic medicines, dietary supplements and nonprescription drugs as defined by the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, glandulars, protomorphogens, lifestyle counseling, hypnotherapy, biofeedback, dietary therapy, electrotherapy, galvanic therapy, oxygen, therapeutic devices, barrier devices for contraception, and minor office procedures, including obtaining specimens to assess and treat disease…
Unlike the Minnesota leglislators, I have substantial knowledge of the tenets and practices of “naturopathic physicians,” and I am capable of judging those tenets according to standards of reason, science, and modern, science-based medicine. Beginning with my stint on the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners 6-8 years ago, I have spent years listening to “NDs,” reading their literature, and writing about them. I described a bit of my experience on that Commission in a post on Science-Based Medicine several weeks ago. I have continued to observe NDs’ cult-like behavior since then, and have seen no indication that they have begun to awaken from their collective, pseudoscientific stupor.
I won’t reiterate most of what I’ve written elsewhere. I’ll also try not to reiterate material about the Minnesota decision that has already been posted on other worthy blogs (including, and with references to the rest, here). Suffice it to say that I’ve heard every argument favoring licensure or registration of “educated” naturopaths—that is, of graduates of the now 6, on-campus, 4-year schools in North America. I’ve heard every argument claiming that these NDs are “scientifically” trained and that they are qualified to act as “primary care doctors,” which purportedly distinguishes them from “traditional” naturopaths (the matchbook crowd). I’ve heard every argument that they are capable of self-regulation, that their methods are “gentle” and “natural,” that they are experts in “nutrition” and “prevention,” that they “treat the cause, rather than the symptoms,” that they are experts in “natural remedies,” that their methods are supported by “10,000 citations to peer-reviewed literature providing standards of practice for natural medicine,” that their schools have responsible research programs, that they can be expected to make responsible recommendations about immunizations, that they attend responsible continuing education courses, that public demand for them is substantial and can only be satisfied by formal state recognition, and every other argument, ad nauseam. Each of these arguments is specious, as shown in excruciating detail here, here, here, here, here, here , here, and here, among other places.
For now I’ll make a few comments pertinent to the Minnesota bill and discuss a few points that are not likely to be apparent to most people. I’ll also add some information not easily found in the public domain: descriptions of 4-5 catastrophes in the past few years, attributable to “licensed naturopathic physicians” practicing according to their own standards of care; an annotated bibliography of responsible references and of a few irresponsible references; rigorous evidence that NDs are not the experts in “natural remedies” that they claim to be. It will require 2-3 postings to cover the material.
The Minnesota Bill: the Devil’s in the Details
To the uninitiated—including many medical doctors—the practices quoted above from the Minnesota bill probably sound bland and relatively benign, if a little kooky. Even if that were the extent of it, it wouldn’t do for the state to endorse such practices, because they can’t replace effective treatments for real diseases. What isn’t readily apparent are the real meanings of many of the listed methods. References to various “electrical” entities appear several times, for example. To find out what these might be and be used for, it’s necessary to dig a little. The following passage is quoted from a naturopathic treatise on cancer of the prostate. It was written by Thomas Kruzel, the the “former Dean of Clinical Education and Chief Medical Officer at the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine in Phoenix, Arizona”:
Electrical current in the form of positive galvanism, applied transrectally, has been used in the treatment of CAP [cancer of the prostate] as well as BPH [benign prostatic hypertrophy]. A steady current of 1 to 5 milliamps for 10 to 15 minutes creates an acidic environment within the prostate gland, oxygenating the tissues and increasing the white blood cell count. This treatment must be coupled with anticoagulant and antioxidant therapy. During and following a series of treatments, protomorphogen therapy helps the growth of healthy prostate tissue.
With natural treatment for CAP it is important to remember that the therapy will have its ups and downs…
Kruzel, according to his biography on the website of the Arizona Naturopathic Medical Association, ”is also the past president of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and was selected as Physician of the Year by the AANP in 2000.”
Another application to the body, electric, favored by NDs is “electrodiagnostic testing,” also known as “electroacupuncture according to Voll” (EAV), “electrodermal screening” (EDS), “bioelectric functions diagnosis” (BFD), “bio resonance therapy” (BRT), VegaTest, Bio-Path, “bio-energy regulatory technique” (BER), and more. The claims for this method, which consists of using a galvanometer to measure the skin’s (varying) resistance to a tiny electric current, are illustrated in the following listings from the AANP’s “Equipment for Sale” webpage from 2001 (the AANP no longer makes this public):
Clinic Closing, EAV Screening Device for Sale, A Listen System. Almost new. Complete with manuals, video, and text book. Increase your revenue while better serving your clients. Test for parasites, food and environmental sensitivities, candida, nutritional deficiencies and much more. Call 416-530-5956 for Samantha for more information. Asking $15,000 or best offer.
Biopath Listen System using electrodermal screening. A great way to test for allergies of all kinds. Excellent practice builder- $2500.
Vega Machine For Sale. VegaTest II complete with carrying case, extra hand electrode, instruction manual (Short Manual of Vega Test), test kits and 114 food vials. $2,000 for the whole kit and kaboodle. Remember, Vega units are no longer available in the United States. Save yourself the expense and hassle of importing a Vega unit (and avoid the possibility of having the unit confiscated at the border). Contact: Michele Goodwin, N.D. 555 Soquel Ave., Suite 260-H, Santa Cruz, CA 95062; (408) 459-9206 email: doctorg@cruzio.com
Are you interested in purchasing a relativley new AVITAR EAV diagnostic unit? This machine is state of the art EAV testing and is a good adjunctive source of revenue to a medical practice (We typically charge $100.00 per session). The machine is easy to use and office staff can be trained to use the machine effectively, while the doctor is seeing other patients. We are looking for someone to take over our lease. The monthly payments are about $260.00 (buy out cost is about $11000) We aleady have some equity invested. Contact Geoff at (425)820-4148
The reason that a naturopath might decide to ”avoid the possibility of having the unit confiscated at the border” is that the FDA has, for practical purposes, declared such devices illegal.
“Hydrotherapy” sounds harmless and possibly soothing, until you discover some of its uses:
…if you or a family member already has suffered from one or more strokes, a simple hydrotherapy technique may provide relief, and even minimize long term sequelae…One technique is to lower your body temperature, with a cold bath for example, as much as possible without inducing shivering as soon as possible after a stroke has occurred, or is suspected to have occured. The idea here is that if the stroke is ischemic (temporary restriction of oxygenated blood) the body naturally and preferentially preserves blood flow to the brain, so cooling the rest of the body will cause the blood to shunt rapidly to the brain. However, if the stroke is hemorrhagic, cooling the body rapidly will cause vasoconstriction, thereby helping to control the bleed. Another hydrotherapy technique with a similar rationale is to soak the feet in a hot foot bath, as soon as possible after the stroke has occurred, while applying a cold compress to the neck, face and scalp. If this technique can be applied as a stroke is happening, it may even abort the stroke. Make sure the ice-cold compress touches the skin over the carotid arteries under the jaw bone. Mustard paste or powder may be added to the foot bath to increase the heating effect. Make sure to continue this treatment for at least 20 minutes and keep adding hot water to the foot bath and make sure the cold compress stays really cold. Or, you may take a neutral bath that is neither freezing cold, nor warm. Immersion in water of neutral temperature is extremely soothing to the central nervous system.
It is now possible to genuinely abort some ischemic strokes if they are diagnosed and treated promptly. All strokes are potentially life-threatening, and are considered to be medical emergencies that require prompt and expert evaluation and supportive care. The treatments described above will do nothing to improve the outcomes of strokes, but are certain to delay competent diagnosis and treatment. They are recommended by “a graduate of Bastyr University in Seattle (class of 1992)…[who is]…the former senior editor of the Journal of Naturopathic Medicine (1989-96), the scientific, peer-reviewed journal of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians” (AANP: the national organization of “educated” naturopaths).
Hydrotherapy, garlic, and a version of oxygen, another seemingly benign substance listed in the Minnesota bill, are bases for the following asthma treatments, also recommended by the former senior editor of the Journal of Naturopathic Medicine:
Another useful Physical Medicine technique is that of Hydrotherapy…Placing a hot, wrung out towel over the chest can relax the breathing muscles and restore normal breathing. For an acute asthma attack try a steam inhalation (draping a towel over your head and a bowl of hot water) with a few drops of eucalyptus oil in the water. Be careful that the water is not so hot that the steam burns your face. Some doctors recommend taking baths with a cup or so of 3% hydrogen peroxide in the water to bring extra oxygen to the entire surface of the skin, thus making the lungs somewhat less oxygen hungry. This method can be performed preventively. Another technique for an acute attack is to drink some hot water with the juice of one clove of garlic.
That passage was written by a practitioner held in high esteem by her entire “profession,” and was promoted by the AANP in its “articles written by Naturopathic Physicians for the general public.” Those facts illustrate that NDs are neither scientifically trained nor competent to practice medicine: The amount of oxygen that can be absorbed through the skin is negligible, as anyone with even a passing knowledge of chemistry and physiology ought to know. Asthma is a serious disease, and an acute attack can be life-threatening. A delay caused by such nonsense would be foolish and dangerous. A real-death example, as I’ll discuss, has already occurred.
Another, more lucrative form of oxygen “therapy” has recently become popular among advocates of Implausible Health Claims (IMC): hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT). It is a slippery form of quackery, because there are a few legitimate uses for the method, and most advocates of illegitimate uses hide behind those. As is true for almost any IMC, HBOT is becoming popular among NDs.
“Amino acids” sound benign and nutritious, to denizens of health food stores and veterans of high school biology classes. There is no value in taking them as “medicines,” however, unless one suffers from a frank deficiency, and guess what the term conceals? According to a recent press release from the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), the most conspicuous organization advocating “chelation therapy,”
Chelation therapy is a process in which a synthetic or man-made amino acid called EDTA is delivered intravenously.
By “EDTA,” the ACAM means disodium ethylenediamine-tetra-acetic acid (Na2EDTA), a dangerous drug that has no place in modern medical therapeutics. Naturopaths at the highest levels recommend “chelation therapy.” In 2003 the Oregon Board of Naturopathic Examiners listed an approved continuing education course taught by the ACAM entitled “Heavy Metal Detoxification,” a euphemism for chelation. The Oregon Naturopathic Formulary Compendium includes “EDTA.” At least one death has resulted, as will be discussed.
“Vitamins” are another category that would make most people yawn, unless they are aware of one of the euphemisms for Laetrile, the greatest health fraud in American history: “vitamin B17.” When I was on the Massachusetts Special Commission, the ND who was president of the Mass. Assoc. of Naturopathic Physicians stated, with an air of accomplishment, that she had worked at the Contreras Clinic in Mexico. She did not add that the clinic is a notorious Laetrile mill.
There is much more hidden agenda in the excerpts from the Minnesota bill, but I trust that the point has been made. I’ll offer a final couple of examples to introduce the next topic. If a doctor ever offers you “glandulars” or “protomorphogens” please turn around and run. Only when you’re safely away should you drop a dime to the state medical board…unless, of course, the “doctor” is a naturopath, because in that case the board will recognize the practice as a standard of care for “naturopathic medicine”—thus demonstrating exactly why there can’t be useful regulation of an irrational “health profession.”
Self-Regulation by Tiny Groups of Sectarians
Almost all trades and professions that are typically regulated—electricians, plumbers, nurses, MDs, etc.—are self-regulated. By that is meant that there is a regulatory board whose members are predominantly members of the relevant profession. If that initially sounds self-defeating, it is also inevitable: who, besides civil engineers, for example, would be qualified to comment on the standards of civil engineering? The Minnesota naturopathy bill is typical in that sense:
REGISTERED NATUROPATHIC DOCTOR ADVISORY COUNCIL.
Subdivision 1. Membership. The board shall appoint a seven-member Registered Naturopathic Doctor Advisory Council consisting of one public member as defined in section 214.02, five registered naturopathic doctors who are residents of the state, and one licensed physician or osteopath with expertise in natural medicine.
The most obvious problem with such a scheme, and what mainly distinguishes it from civil engineering and other boards, is that there can be no objective standards for fields that lack objective data to support their methods. Where are the state boards of astrologers or psychics? Next week I’ll present examples of ND-associated catastrophes that failed to elicit appropriate responses from regulatory boards.
A less-appreciated problem is that of self-regulation of a tiny group. In Minnesota there are barely 25 NDs who qualify for registration, and the state expects 5 of them to pass judgment upon the rest. There’s a good chance that any complaint sent to the Advisory Council will involve an ND that the council members already know, since they are all members of a tiny organization that, until now, was primarily concerned with political activism. How can they avoid conflicting interests? The other reason that self-regulating professions are at least somewhat capable of acting objectively, in addition to the existence of objective standards, is that most are large enough to guarantee independence in their board deliberations. In Massachusetts, for example, there are 30,000 MDs.
Title Protection and Government Handouts
A state board for a tiny group presents a tangential problem that the Minnesota electorate might have overlooked: who pays for it? Most professions pay for their own regulation through licensing fees. How will 25 NDs in Minnesota, each paying $200 for initial registration and $150 for annual renewal, support their board? They won’t, of course:
Sec. 13. APPROPRIATIONS.
(a) $8,000 in fiscal year 2009 is appropriated from the state government special revenue fund to the Board of Medical Practice for the registration of naturopathic doctors under Minnesota Statutes, chapter 147E.
(b) $25,000 in fiscal year 2009 is appropriated from the state government special revenue fund to the commissioner of health for the naturopathy work group. This is a onetime appropriation.
This bill, which is primarily a “title protection” bill (explaining why it has pissed off “traditional naturopaths“), is a real-life example of a government hand-out to a tiny, “special interest” group. What is the alternative? My opinion:
There will always be fanciful health claims that range from the relatively innocuous to the outright dangerous. Most of these will inevitably fall through the regulatory cracks, in spite of the best intentions of government. It would be impossible to regulate all of them, and unwise to try. Existing laws governing consumer fraud, assault, and the illegitimate practice of medicine should be invoked when necessary. Licensure and registration schemes, however well intentioned, tend to encourage illegitimate health practices, rather than to limit them.
The best way for government to help citizens make sense of nonstandard health claims, while respecting freedom of choice, is through education. We recommend that the legislature direct the Department of Public Health and the Office of Consumer Affairs to collaborate on an educational program. We recommend that in doing so, these agencies seek counsel not from advocates, but from experts. There are numerous experts in [Minnesota], covering every medical field, who could help with such a project. There are also organizations of experts who are familiar with nonstandard claims and have already applied scientific scrutiny to many of them…

   Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 2
Kimball Atwood
Link
The “Safety of Naturopathic Treatment”
In their nationwide effort to convince lawmakers to pronounce them primary care physicians, “educated” naturopaths have repeatedly claimed that their “natural” treatments are “safer and gentler” than those offered by medical doctors. The Alliance Legislative Workbook, a website that for several years provided strategies and “talking points” for ND-activists seeking state licensure, made this assertion in 2001:
Malpractice insurance rates [for licensed NDs] are generally less than $4000.00 per year, indicating the safety of naturopathic treatment as assessed by insurance companies. Master Insurance Trust reports that of the naturopathic physicians for whom MIT provides liability insurance, there have been only four incidents reported to the company for follow-up. However, nothing has been paid in either settlements or judgements on any of these items. “While this pooling of physicians is much too small to base actuarial considerations, this claims experience is clearly superior.” (Jeffrey D. Brunken, Program Manager, MIT, Letter dated May 21, 1990.)
Jury Verdicts Northwest, a legal database which records court cases in Washington and Oregon, the area of the country with the largest number of naturopathic physicians, shows no judgments for malpractice against N.D.s since the database was started in 1983. One in five M.D.s is sued each year in the US (AMA).
Why is malpractice so much lower among naturopathic physicians?
Naturopathic methods are less likely to cause injury than orthodox methods. Prudent dietary and lifestyle changes, for instance, are unlikely to cause harm. Naturopathic physicians by philosophy and training use the least invasive means to treat and prevent disease. This results in less injury to patients. Naturopathic physicians also have excellent diagnostic and referral skills. There is no significant history of complaints against naturopathic physicians resulting from a missed diagnoses, the most common cause for suits in a general practice. From insurance data, it appears that naturopathic physicians as a group know the limits of their methods and refer patients to other practitioners or specialists when appropriate.
The Colorado DORA “Sunrise Review”
Malpractice premiums, claims, and judgments are notoriously poor measures of either the presence or absence of harm. Nevertheless, NDs have continued to make political hay by claiming that their methods are particularly safe. Linda Rosa and Larry Sarner of the National Council Against Health Fraud have been active in opposing the ND licensing push in Colorado. A couple of years ago they asked if I knew of examples of licensed NDs having harmed patients. They had been communicating with the Colorado Dept. of Regulatory Agencies (DORA) as it prepared a “Sunrise Report” on “Naturopathic Physicians,” its second in 8 years. According to Mr. Sarner,
They apparently have all the evidence they need for the “traditional” [naturopaths], which has helped make the case for “protecting the public” against them by excluding them from practice. But as was told to us, they don’t have a single example of an “educated” naturopath being harmful, much less a number that would convincingly make the case that formal naturopathic training and knowledge makes no difference. Yesterday’s article (“Death by Natural Causes”) was timely, but when we sent it to DORA, they said the case only involved allegations of wrongdoing at this point, though they were glad to see the information and requested we feed them more of same.
My answer was, more or less, as follows (I sent a copy of it to DORA, apparently to no avail). I’ve added some new information that wasn’t then available. If some of this is duplicated from what I’ve written elsewhere, I apologize.
It is true that it’s difficult to find many cases of “educated” naturopaths harming patients. In my opinion the reasons are several:
1. There are few “educated” NDs to begin with. There are approximately 2500 throughout the US, or an average of 50 per state. By comparison, there are more than 12,000 MDs in Colorado alone. “Traditional” naturopaths claim that their numbers are many times those of “naturopathic physicians,” but there are no objective data to support this claim.
2. Self-regulating boards and malpractice suits will not expose such cases, because they will typically judge them to meet the “standard of care” for NDs, as is illustrated by the cases below. Thus in states with licensure, regulation does exactly the opposite of its intended effect: rather than protect the public, it shields NDs and their practices from regulatory and civil court scrutiny.
3. Most patients who seek medical care from naturopaths are unaware that virtually all naturopathic practices are unacceptable, and discover this only if a disaster occurs. For every disaster there are likely to be multiple near-disasters that no one, including patients and NDs, recognizes.
4. Most patients who have sought care from naturopaths are aware that they have chosen to venture outside of the mainstream, and are therefore likely to have a higher than usual level of cognitive dissonance even if they are capable of recognizing some dubious practices. What this means is that they are more reluctant to acknowledge or report such practices, because doing so would amount to an admission of bad judgment.
5. Most naturopathic practices are inert and thus not physically dangerous (although some are, as in the cases below). Harm by NDs is therefore more likely to be due to errors of omission (by diverting patients from effective treatment) than to errors of commission. Such “opportunity cost” harm is less likely to be reported by patients, who may be unaware of it. Nevertheless, it is just as dangerous as frank physical injury, and in all cases it amounts to fraud. That such omissions are real, contradicting the assertion that ”naturopathic physicians as a group know the limits of their methods,” is evidenced by a passage on p. 19 of a booklet entitled Naturopathy: Recommended for Licensure in Massachusetts, offered to the Massachusetts Special Commission by Barbara S. Silbert, DC, ND, “representing the Massachusetts Society of Naturopathic Physicians”:
CONDITIONS TREATED BY NATUROPATHIC PHYSICIANS
Naturopathic Physicians treat most conditions which out-patient family practice medicine can treat.
The type of patients who come to see Naturopathic Physicians include those:
who are successfully treated but having side effects from the medication
who are “successfully” treated but would like to eliminate the condition rather than continue on maintenance medication (depression, arthritis, hypertension, recurrent ear infections, irritable bowel, migraines, reflux, etc.).
who want to avoid the recommended conventional treatments (infertility, depression, arthritis, synthetic cholesterol lowering agents).
who want to prevent recurrences of problems (abnormal PAPs, chronic sinusitis, menstrual pain).
who want to enhance the effectiveness or reduce side effects of conventional treatments (cancer, heart disease, pain relief).
who have a condition for which there is no conventional diagnosis an/or [sic] conventional treatment.
who are interested in natural treatments as a first choice.
….
The goals of naturopathic treatment are:
To cure the disease, to make all medications unnecessary.
6. Some harm that is exclusively psychological or emotional is unlikely to be recognized by those who lack medical sophistication. Here is an example: naturopaths tell parents that many common childhood problems, including ear infections and attention deficit disorder (ADD), are wholly or in part caused by multiple food allergies. This is almost always false. The child who is given this erroneous “diagnosis” is unnecessarily sentenced to years or even a lifetime of cumbersome, distasteful, and socially awkward dietary constraints. Anyone who has gluten-sensitive enteropathy, for example, knows what a project it is to avoid the offending substances. Imagine a ruse in which many people are falsely led to believe, by licensed “primary care doctors,” that they have intolerances to molecules that are nearly ubiquitous in packaged foods and foods served in commercial eateries.
7. Many patients have a reasonably good sense of when to seek real, as opposed to fanciful, care. Thus NDs are unwittingly saved from themselves by patients and MDs. The frequency with which this occurs is unknown.
“You can’t hold a naturopathic doctor to a medical doctor standard of care…”
There have been, however, deaths and serious injuries either directly caused by NDs or resulting from state endorsement of NDs as “doctors.” Several examples follow. The NDs were either known or almost certain to be licensed, as the case reports demonstrate.
Case I: Unnecessary death of a woman given “chelation therapy”
In 2003, a 53 year-old woman in Oregon died from acute hypocalcemia (rapid lowering of blood calcium) caused by intravenous Na2EDTA “chelation therapy,” which a licensed naturopath had given her to “remove heavy metals.” The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) reported: “The Oregon State Naturopath Licensing Board is conducting an investigation to determine whether Na2EDTA or CaEDTA was administered to this patient.” The Oregon Naturopathic Board found that the naturopath “was medically negligent in performing a chelation procedure,” but the order does not name the chelating drug, nor does it comment on the infusion rate—the most important predictor of hypocalcemia.
The order also makes no comment on the purported “indication” for the treatment, and there is no reason to believe that it viewed that as negligent: the Oregon naturopathic formulary lists “EDTA” without a cation, adding, “Board approved certification required before therapeutic IV chelation is allowed.” In 2003 such certification was likely to have come from the American College for the Advancement of Medicine [ACAM], which recommends Na2EDTA—not CaEDTA—for numerous fraudulent purposes: the Oregon Naturopathic Board included, on its list of approved continuing education courses, an ACAM course titled “Heavy Metal Detoxification.” Thus it is virtually certain that Na2EDTA was the drug that killed the woman, and “therapeutic IV chelation” is a state-sanctioned oxymoron in Oregon. The ND himself is an ACAM member.
Such baseless, dangerous treatment is among the worst that quackery has to offer, as explained at length elsewhere. The case illustrates the folly of a state conferring self-regulatory power on “health” practitioners whose tenets are irrational: the Oregon State Naturopath Licensing Board had encouraged the very practice that killed the woman! From a medical ethical standpoint, it mattered not at all which of the two chelating agents she received for the bogus purpose of “removing heavy metals.” They are equally unethical when given for fraudulent reasons, even if one [Na2EDTA] is more dangerous than the other. The Oregon Naturopathic Board placed the practitioner on probation—he had also practiced recklessly in several other respects—but it will allow him to resume administering Na2EDTA after 3 years if he “completes all qualifying educational requirements as provided in the Board’s administrative rules.” Back to square one.
Case II: Unnecessary death of a teenage girl with an asthma attack
This is the case referred to above, “Death by Natural Causes.” In summary, in 2001 a 16-year-old girl in Washington state, suffering from an asthma attack, was taken by her mother to the family’s “primary care doctor”: a licensed ND. The ND couldn’t see the patient immediately, and in the meantime arranged for her to undergo acupuncture elswhere in the office. Twenty or thirty minutes later the ND emerged and gave the child vitamin B12 and an “herbal tincture.” The child went home, got worse, and died within a few hours—in the family car as her father was pulling up to an emergency room.
There is disagreement between the parents and the ND over what actually happened: the ND adamantly claims that she advised the parents to take the child to the hospital right away; the parents, just as adamantly, claim that the ND did not do that. There is no question that the ND failed to use any of several standard clinical tools to determine the severity of the girl’s asthma attack. There is also no question, among those familiar with physiology, pharmacology, and modern medicine, that the ministrations offered by the ND are useless for the treatment of asthma.
As Larry Sarner reported above, DORA apparently did not consider this case to be particularly telling because it “only involved allegations of wrongdoing at this point.” From a purely legal standpoint that may be correct, not only because of the disputed facts, but also because of the state-sponsored ambiguity of the ND’s role as a “physician.” Regardless of the disputed facts, however, the case illustrates why a state should not license practitioners who claim to be “primary care providers” but who have not been trained to practice modern medicine. As a consultant to the reporter who wrote the article for Seattle Weekly, I had the opportunity to read several of the depositions from the civil case. What they show is the folly of the State of Washington having granted licensure to NDs.
The plaintiffs argued that the treatment of acute asthma is not within the scope of practice of NDs. But NDs themselves list asthma as the 5th most common reason for patient visits, and their legal status in Washington had suggested to the mother that the ND could competently treat asthma: the ND is called a “physician”; her own website states that “NDs have the same training as a general practice MD”; the Boeing Corporation’s health insurance covered the ND as the family’s “primary care provider”; ND literature (easily available online and elsewhere) is replete with “expert” treatises on asthma and other common and uncommon medical problems.
Washington formally relies on NDs to determine their own standards of care, even though such standards conflict with medical facts. The Naturopathy Program Advisory Committee of the Washington State Department of Health consists of three NDs and two public members. A statute quoted in one of the depositions for this case stipulates that “health care providers…exercise that degree of care, skill, and learning expected of a reasonably prudent health care provider…in the profession or class to which he belongs…” ((RCW 7.70.030(1)(1)); emphasis added). This statute, in all probability, originally applied to allied health professionals such as nurses, physical therapists, nutritionists, etc. It almost certainly was not intended to provide a safe haven for physician-impersonators, but by licensing NDs the state of Washington has made it appear to do exactly that.
Thus the state, the ND, the field of “naturopathic medicine,” the Boeing Corporation, and the health insurance company all conspired to send an erroneous and, as it turned out, deadly message to the girl’s family: that the ND is a real doctor who is competent to treat a child’s asthma. The expert witnesses were correct that there can be only one standard of care, but the state, by imposing more than one standard when it licensed naturopaths, declared otherwise. Is it surprising that this would confuse and endanger health consumers? Isn’t the state of Washington, by dint of its decision to license NDs, the real culprit here?
Finally, the article is replete with opinions by NDs who judged the care given the child to have been perfectly acceptable. According to a Washington ND
who helped write the state law regulating naturopaths, ‘you can’t hold a naturopathic doctor to a medical doctor standard of care…’
The naturopathic board in Arizona, in which the ND defendant was also licensed, reportedly exonerated her upon receiving her report of the case. Thus both the influential Washington ND and the Arizona Board upheld care that included a shoddy diagnostic workup and useless treatments of acupuncture, vitamin B12, and “herbal tinctures” for a teenager who would die of a treatable disease within hours. The Washington State Dept. of Health also appears, so far, not to have found reason to discipline the ND.
If the child had been brought to the emergency room only an hour earlier, she would almost certainly have been saved. Neither her parents nor the naturopath would have known how close she had come to dying. How many such “near-misses” occur on a regular basis?
Case III: Nasal septum fracture caused by “NeuroCranial Restructuring”
“NeuroCranial Restructuring” is the absurd practice of inflating balloons in the nasal passages to effect a “controlled release of the connective tissue tension to unwind the body and return it toward its original design.” It was “created” and is taught by Dean Howell, ND, a Bastyr graduate who, according to his website, is licensed in the state of Washington. In 2003 the Archives of Otolaryngology reported that an ND in Washington had fractured a patient’s nasal septum while performing this technique. NeuroCranial Restructuring is a variant of “bilateral nasal specifics,” which was offered in the Bastyr course catalog at least as recently as 2001 (Bastyr University, in Kenmore, WA, is the flagship of naturopathic “medical” schools).
In 1983 an Alberta naturopath killed a 20-month-old girl using the same technique. A judge called it “outright quackery” but sentenced the naturopath to only a $1000 fine and one day in jail.* This suggests that the naturopath’s status as a “health care provider” had shielded him from more fitting punishment. We don’t know who the ND was who caused the nasal septum fracture in Washington, but there is a good chance that it was either Howell himself or someone taught by Howell. He or she was almost certainly licensed. The Oregon Board of Naturopathic Examiners lists “craniosacral therapy” (another nonsensical method, from which “NeuroCranial Restructuring” was derived), among its continuing education courses for NDs. Such a listing further illustrates the folly of licensing “educated” naturopaths.
Case IV: The Death of Debbie Benson
The following report was posted a few years ago on Quackwatch:
My good friend Debbie Benson died July 15, 1997, at age fifty-five. I had known her for thirty years. Her official diagnosis was breast cancer, but she was really a victim of quackery. Conventional treatment might have saved her, but she rejected the advice of her oncologist and went to “natural healers.”
Debbie was a registered nurse at the Kaiser hospital in Portland, Oregon, but she had a deep distrust of standard medical practice. She didn’t have a mammogram for nine years, and when she did — in March 1996 — it showed a cancerous lump in her breast. She had the lump removed, but she refused the additional treatment her doctor recommended. Instead she went to a naturopath who gave her — among other things — some “Pesticide Removal Tinctures.”
Soon after that, lymph nodes swelled in Debbie’s armpit. The naturopath said that this was merely the effect of the herbal remedies he was giving her and not to worry. Belatedly, she returned to her oncologist at Kaiser hospital, where the lymph nodes were biopsied and found to be cancerous. Once again, she refused the recommended treatment. Unfortunately, the cancer was spreading throughout her body.
Debbie continued to patronize “alternative healers” in the Portland area. One even claimed to diagnose her with a pendulum! She found another lump in her breast, but the cancer had invaded her liver and was no longer treatable by standard methods.
During the last weeks of her life, another naturopath gave Debbie a skin preparation that was supposed to draw the tumor out of her. This stuff caused an ugly open sore on her breast. By this time, her liver was failing and she felt awful. The naturopath told Debbie she was feeling bad as a result of this medicine, and to get more sleep. When Debbie became too weak to get out of bed and the imminence of her death was obvious, the naturopath blamed Debbie’s turn for the worse on “giving up.”
I have reported Debbie’s mistreatment to state regulatory agencies, and they are investigating.
During my research for the Massachusetts Special Commission, I wrote the author, Kenneth Spiker, wondering if anything had come of the case. He replied:
Had I been a Portland resident I would have done a more thorough investigation. I don’t know how much chance a lawsuit would have had in Oregon, even if a person had documentary evidence such as cancelled checks, medicine bottles, left over herbs, etc. If naturopaths are allowed to practice, then who’s to say that the standard of care wasn’t followed? Another naturopath?
Debbie was always a counterculture type of person. We used to go to peyote meetings in the 60′s at the Native American Church. She had her baby in a tipi on a commune in New Mexico. There’s still a whole counterculture out here, often associated with hobbit communities in Berkeley, Portland and Mendocino (where I live), where flaky alternative medical advice is passed around and there’s not a critical thought in a carload. I met a fellow at a party just last week who declared that he had come down with some kind of flu or crud, and bravely asserted, “I healed myself!” “How do you know that God didn’t heal you?” I asked. Evidently he had gone to some sort of alternative healer and he’d been instructed to “Put his disbelief on a shelf.” This fellow wasn’t an ignorant peasant, but a retired lawyer.
This stuff is rampant. If Debbie had been persuaded by her friends to try some herb or incantation, I wouldn’t be so angry about it, that’s her choice. But she went to a fake healer who was sanctioned by the State of Oregon and was persuaded to shell out a large amount of money for worthless cures. She made her choices and who’s to say for sure that even pursuing conventional medicine she would have lived? But I don’t like to see exploiters and cheats get away with their crimes.
The story of Debbie Benson and the response of her friend, a reasonable citizen-observer, further demonstrate why state governments should not appear to endorse nonsensical health claims—even though a few citizens may be ardent believers in those claims. I wasn’t able to find out who the naturopaths in the case were, but it’s likely that they were licensed, given Mr. Spiker’s statement and the fact that such licensing exists in Oregon.
Case V: “Adult Female Patient Instructed to Cease Taking Thyroid Medicine”
This case, ironically, was provided by DORA itself:
In July 2004, a Colorado woman visited a naturopathic physician who is licensed as a naturopathic physician in Montana, and as an acupuncturist in Colorado. The practitioner held himself out to the public as having extensive clinical experience in proctology, homeopathy, minor surgery, hemorrhoid treatment, spinal manipulation, and laboratory diagnostics. The patient informed the practitioner of her under active thyroid that had been persistent for the previous eight years. The patient alleged that the naturopathic physician sold the patient “USP” Armour thyroid medicine (pig gland), for which prescribing authority (medical license) is required in Colorado. Within a month, the patient suffered from hot flashes, hair loss, fluid retention, weight gain, and fatigue. A blood test was performed at the office of the endocrinologist, who reported that the results indicated a very low thyroid level. The endocrinologist indicated that the implications for not taking prescription thyroid medication in the long-term could be fluid retention, weight gain, sluggishness, rise in cholesterol levels, myxedema, and heart attacks. An injunction by the Colorado Board of Medical Examiners was imposed on the naturopathic physician for engaging in the unlicensed practice of medicine.
The final disposition (September 1, 2005) of this case between the Colorado State Board of Medical Examiners and the naturopathic physician (defendant) included the following terms: (1) the defendant will not engage in the practice of medicine as defined in section 12-36-106, et seq., C.R.S., (2) the defendant will not perform any kind of surgical operation (as defined in the permanent injunction) upon a human being, and (3) the defendant agreed not to practice proctology, surgery, the writing of or dispensing of prescriptions for prescription drugs, intravenous therapy, vitamin and mineral injections, topical anesthesia injections, and obstetrics.
The irony is that the ND in this case was, apparently, an “educated” naturopath. Each of the claims and methods attributed to him are typical for the cult as a whole, and only got him into trouble because Colorado did not have licensure for NDs. Thus it is a near certainty that the sanctions meted out by the Colorado Medical Board, appropriate though they were, would not have been issued by a hypothetical Colorado naturopathic board. Yet DORA contends that NDs should become licensed in Colorado.
Cases VI-VIII: Unnecessary deaths from colchicine overdoses
Last year 3 more deaths occurred in Oregon and Washington, each caused by overdoses of the highly toxic drug colchicine. It had been administered intravenously as a treatment for back pain, which should make any modern physician cringe. I don’t have time to discuss these cases in detail, but newspaper reports here, here, here, and indexed here showed that they involved NDs, at least one MD, and a shady compounding pharmacy that had mispackaged the drug in a concentration 8x that indicated on its label. Many readers of the linked stories concluded that the compounding pharmacy was entirely culpable, but I disagree. The NDs and the MD strike me as exuberant children left alone in a room with with nothing but matches and a pile of newspapers to play with. Another match in the box was undoubtedly Na2EDTA, as evidenced by one of the letters referring to treatments for “heavy metals.” My view is that of this letter-writer:
Re: Fatal doses leave doctor with questions
This use of colchicine is outrageous. In the medical profession, IV colchicine is never recommended even for gout because of the potential harmful adverse reactions. Oral dosing is safe because patients stop at appropriate levels because of GI side effects. IV does not have this built in safety feature. That is a major reason it is never given IV. Even oral can cause neuropathy (damage to nerves in arms and legs) if used for a long period of time. This is NOT a benign medication. This is yet another reason that Evidence-Based Medical Care should be the norm.
“Appalled MD”
That IV colchicine for back pain is not some rare outlier among the practices of NDs and quack MDs is shown by this paragraph, quoted from p. 69 of the same booklet cited above, offered by NDs as evidence favoring their licensure in Massachusetts:
Colchicine is a drug derived from the autumn crocus plant. It is used in conventional medicine to treat gout. Alternative physicians also give colchicine intravenously to treat herniated discs. The success rate is said to be 90%. Widespread use of colchicine could substantially reduce the number of people who require disc surgery, saving billions of dollars per year.
Those words had been written by Alan Gaby, MD, a quack who was “Professor of Therapeutic Nutrition and a member of the Clinical staff at Bastyr University from 1995 to 2002.” So much for “natural and gentle,” and so much for “the least invasive means to treat and prevent disease.”
No, I won’t get dragged into the “medicine is the 3rd leading cause of death” BS
I am aware, because I’ve gone through the exercise so many times, that apologists for “naturopathic medicine” will respond to this blog with a tired, tu quoque fallacy: how can I talk when “conventional” medicine is so bad? I’ve answered this on numerous occasions and I don’t plan to do it again here. If anyone would like to peruse those discussions, they are among the articles linked from Part 1 of this series. I would consider, in another setting, debunking the “3rd leading cause” myth, but I suspect that Harriet will be doing that soon. That some MDs are also quacks is certainly true—that’s what most SBM blogs are about—but no excuse for NDs; two wrongs don’t make a right.
The difference, which I hope remains so, is that quacks constitute a tiny, fringe group among MDs. They are the absolute, unquestioned Standard Bearers of “naturopathic medicine.”
A final look at DORA: how Bureaucrats Think
The 2005 DORA report, flawed as it is, offers on pp. 36-7 an “answer” to the fundamental question raised last week: why would bureaucrats attempt to “regulate” a field that lacks objective standards? I’d like to think that the following quotation refers to a voluminous opinion, however misapprehended, offered to DORA by yours truly. Maybe it does, but DORA never sent me even an acknowledgment of receipt:
An argument raised in opposition to the Applicant’s proposal [for licensure of NDs] is a broad assault upon the efficacy of naturopathic practice. This opposition makes little or no distinction between groups or philosophies lumping all naturopathy into the realm of quackery. Many of these arguments are not compelling, but the most sophisticated of them holds that naturopathic practices are not proven effective by medical standards for testing, and, consequently, naturopathic doctors or physicians are not medical doctors.
This review concurs with those premises but differs in the conclusion drawn from them. To dispense with the easiest case, naturopathic doctors are not medical doctors and the application for regulation does not assert that they are, or should be construed as such.
This review concurs with the opponent’s position that naturopathic practice may not satisfy the requirement of allopathic medical research standards. This standard, however rigorous and time-tested, is not the standard for regulation of a profession. Colorado currently regulates acupuncture and chiropractic, modalities that may be or once were subject to the same criticisms. The regulatory test for government intervention in consumer choices, and barring clear evidence of fraud, or other compounding factors, is to determine the proper level of education, experience, examination, and subsequent scope of practice. This, coupled with disciplinary authority over practitioners who violate the state’s standards constitutes the proper role of government. Ultimately, given a safe market place in which to choose, consumers will make the appropriate decisions more efficiently than will government.
This review therefore is not convinced by the arguments of opponents who believe that naturopathy should not be regulated because of the lack of efficacy of the practice itself.
Wow. There are so many contradictions, misconceptions, and begged questions there that it boggles the mind. Maybe someday I’ll take it apart sentence by sentence, but right now I’m plain tuckered out.
Next week: are NDs truly experts in nutrition and “natural remedies”?
(Naaahhhh!)
Reference
*Butler K. A Consumer’s Guide to Alternative Medicine. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books; 1992:82

   Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is “Naturopathic Medicine.” Part 3
Kimball Atwood
Link
The “Science” and Ethics of “Natural Medicines”
This and the next entry in the current “Naturopathic Medicine” series* deal with the cult’s claim of expertise in “natural medicines” or “natural remedies.” These include herbs (“botanicals”), glandular extracts, vitamins, and minerals. A large fraction of the Textbook of Natural Medicine (TNM), “the most thoroughly researched and carefully referenced text on natural medicine,” is devoted to these agents.[1] They are keys to the practice of naturopathy and to a core claim of “naturopathic physicians” that legislators tend to swallow: that NDs offer something that most MDs do not.
During the deliberations of the Massachusetts Special Commission, NDs produced Dr. Alan Trachtenberg, a fresh-faced ingenue who had briefly been Acting Director of the federal Office of Alternative Medicine, to testify on their behalf. He suggested to the Commission that naturopaths could be the “learned intermediaries” that the public needed to help make sense of the myriad “natural remedies” that became freely available in the wake of the Dietary and Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA). This is from his written testimony:
Another advantage of state licensure, is that the holder of a professional license who provides or recommends a product, then becomes responsible for the quality and safety of a product. In an unregulated marketplace, such a learned intermediary can be invaluable to the consumer. Since naturopaths do often provide dietary supplements and herbal products directly to their patients, it is vital that they have an enforceable code of professional ethics. Such a code of ethics becomes enforceable with State licensure.
It is also beneficial for the patient to have a practitioner who knows enough about biochemistry, physiology, pharmacology, and physical diagnosis to adequately assess a patient’s clinical response to a product. These products are essentially complicated but unregulated drug mixtures. My understanding is that licensable naturopathic doctors have all taken these courses during their four years of training and passed standardized exams that test their mastery. There is no such quality assurance for the other kind of naturopathic practitioner.
Instead of relying on Dr. Trachtenberg’s “understanding,” let’s submit his two assertions—that of a “code of ethics” and that of “mastery” of the topic of “natural medicines”—to real scrutiny. In doing so I confess that I have plagiarized, to some extent, pieces that I’ve written elsewhere.
The Ethics of “Naturopathic Physicians” Selling Drugs
Shortly before the Special Commission was convened, a “supplements” company called MotherNature.com issued the following press release (emphasis added):
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Aliza Schlifkin Sharon Rice
Ruder Finn MotherNature.com
212-583-2732 978-929-2008
schlifkina@ruderfinn.com sharon.rice@mothernature.com
MOTHERNATURE.COM ANNOUNCES STRATEGIC ALLIANCES
WITH TWO HEALTHCARE ORGANIZATIONS
Agreements with Landmark Healthcare and the AANP Offer Marketing of
MotherNature.com Products & Information to Millions of Patients
CONCORD FARMS, MA (January 6, 2000) – MotherNature.com (Nasdaq: MTHR), a leading online information source and e-tailer of vitamins, supplements, minerals, and other natural and healthy living products, today announced partnerships with two leading alternative care health organizations to provide natural health products and information to their members. The agreements with Landmark Healthcare and the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) will promote MotherNature.com to millions of patients and healthcare practitioners of the two organizations.
…
AANP
The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians is the leading organization for Naturopaths, representing about 650 active physicians. A licensed naturopathic physician (N.D.) attends a four-year graduate-level naturopathic medical school and is educated in all of the same basic sciences as an M.D. but also studies holistic and nontoxic approaches to therapy with a strong emphasis on disease prevention and optimizing wellness.
With this new alliance, an AANP doctor can set up a personal dispensary on MotherNature.com and become part of MotherNature.com’s Wellness Advisor Network, an online, interactive forum to improve patient care and extend the relationship between patient and practitioner beyond the office walls. The N.D. can then send a patient to their personal site to learn about and purchase the natural products they find efficacious in treatment.
“It is an excellent added value for our N.D.’s to provide their patients with easy access to a trustworthy source for the broad array of natural health products and information they recommend every day in clinical practice,” added Sheila Quinn, Executive Director of the AANP. “We look forward to growing this partnership with MotherNature.com and finding new and innovative ways to work together.”
About MotherNature.com, Inc.
MotherNature.com, Inc. (Nasdaq: MTHR) established an Internet site in 1995. It is a leading online retailer of a vast array of vitamins, supplements, minerals, and other natural and healthy living products. MotherNature.com is also a leading provider of health information on the Internet, with contributions from a panel of health and medical professionals. The company maintains its corporate office in Concord, MA, a distribution center in Springfield, MA, and a customer support center in Acton, MA.
This profit-seeking arrangement was entirely consistent with the AANP’s “Sales of Medications by Physicians” position paper:
SALE OF MEDICATIONS BY PHYSICIANS
I. The AANP is a strong proponent of Preventive Medicine and considers adequate nutrition to be of primary importance in the maintenance of health and the prevention of disease.
II. There are numerous references in the medical literature that document the existence of subclinical disease and the fact that the chances of anyone consuming a diet that meets the RDA for all nutrients is extremely unlikely.
III. There are numerous citations in the medical literature about the efficacy of homeopathic, botanical and other natural substances as medications to be used in the treatment of disease. It is common knowledge that many of the medications prescribed by Naturopathic Physicians (such as homeopathic and botanical medications as well as certain nutrient supplements) are not available elsewhere.
IV. Certain medications, although available through retailers, exist in these markets as different formulations than the physician determines most effective for his patients. These “optimal formulations” may only be available through companies that sell exclusively to physicians.
V. Certain formulations are classified as “legend drugs” (even through they may be natural origin). These medications may be obtainable via a prescription yet are not readily available through retail pharmacies.
VI. In general, the companies that supply products to physicians are under strict scrutiny by the FDA. This ensures certain standards of quality control. While true for the majority of companies that supply health food stores, certain companies may avoid FDA regulation.
VII. Any selling of medications within a doctor’s office must be based on addressing the needs of the patient. The making of profit is always viewed as a secondary consideration. This is an extension of the code of ethics of the state and national associations governing the conduct of Naturopathic Physicians.
VIII. While the retail selling of medications could be construed as a conflict of interest on the part of the physician; as long as the underlying intention remains the patient’s best interest and not to make profit, and no other source for the formulation and quality of the medication that the physician feels is adequate exists, this remains a legitimate and viable service.
IX. The AANP expects that its members act conscientiously and within accepted codes of ethics concerning these and all professional matters. Any breach of this should be reported to the AANP if writing as identified.
Principal Authors: Martin Milner, ND, Konrad Kail, ND
Adopted at the 1990 Annual Convention.
Regarding the AANP and MotherNature.com, here was the deal:
1. Can I keep my in-office dispensary and benefit from MotherNature.com’s Wellness Advisor Network? Yes. You can maintain business as usual, using the Wellness Advisor Network to order professional line products at wholesale for your dispensary.
5. How does the AANP benefit when I join the Wellness Advisor Network? The AANP receives 1% of all the retail transactions made by your patients through your Web site. By integrating the Wellness Advisor Network into your practice, you generate revenues that will help maintain and build our organization.
6. What is the benefit to AANP members? The AANP has negotiated a 24% referral fee structure for our members – 4% more than the 20% received by other providers. The referral fee is paid on the retail sales from your patients through your website.
That pact was not surprising for organized “naturopathic medicine.” Consider the means by which it achieved licensure in Utah in 1996, as reported by the National Council Against Health Fraud (NCAHF):
HEALTH FOODS INDUSTRY GROUP GETS
NATUROPATHIC PRACTICE ACT IN UTAH
The sweetheart relationship between naturopaths and the health food industry became more transparent with the passage of a naturopathic licensure act in Utah. Health Forum, the lobbying organization that pulled off the action, was led by Rae Howard, President of the National Nutritional Foods Association (NNFA), and President of Good Earth Natural Foods at Orem, Utah. In NNFA Today (5/96, p.9) Howard boasts that: “every state legislator received a visit by representatives from Health Forum and other constituents. Grassroots meetings and training sessions were held throughout the state beginning last September, to explain the bill to consumers, train them in the political process and organize support.”
Such boosting has continued. Here is a partial list of Corporate Sponsors of the recently successful ND licensing effort in California:
CANP is the California Association of Naturopathic Physicians. California ANP Sponsors are generously helping in the licensing effort in California.
California Association of Naturopathic Physicians 2002-2003 Natural Partners Program
The CANP wishes to thank the following companies for their generous financial support in 2002-2003:
CANP Corporate Leader
Metagenics
CANP Corporate Partner
American Specialty Health Plans
CANP Corporate Donor
Thorne
CANP Corporate Sponsor
Biogenesis
Capsugel
Douglas Labs
Integrative Therapeutics Incorporated
New Hope Natural Media
Pure Encapsulations
Specturm Organic
Whole Foods Market
The AANP itself touts its sponsorship by a host of “supplement” companies, dubious “laboratories,” and other companies making a buck off of organized quackery.
The naturopathic “medical schools,” which one might expect to be pristine, are not immune to the same temptation. This item appeared in the 1995 summer edition of the NCAHF news:
HEALTH FOODS INDUSTRY INFLUENCES
NATUROPATHIC EDUCATION
Bastyr University, a naturopathic college in Seattle, has added several board members who are associated with the natural products industry. Included are Past President of the National Nutritional Foods Association Martie Whittekin, Sandy Gooch, founder of Mrs. Gooch’s Natural Foods Markets, Michael Murray, ND, Director of Research and Product Development at Enzymatic Therapy, and Jerry Schlesser, ND,DC, President and CEO of IsoChem Corporation. [Natural Health Advocate Winter, 1995 (a publication of Bastyr University as "an update for the natural products industry.")]
Comment: The symbiotic relationship between naturopathic education and the health food industry (natural foods, herbal remedies, dietary supplements, and homeopathic remedies) is scandalous. If drug companies were wielding comparable influence on a medical school there would be a national outcry. It makes naturopathic education appear to be a conspiracy between the health food industry and pseudomedicine.
No kidding. In 1988 Bastyr had been the happy recipient of $20,000 worth of money and equipment from American Biologics, the major Laetrile pusher. That was at a time when Bastyr was poor and $20,000 was real money.
And finally:
ENZYMATIC THERAPY, INC.
Ira Milner, RD, reports (Nutrition Forum, Nov-Dec, 1990) on his experience of attending a New Jersey seminar along with “more than 100 retailers and a few chiropractors” put on by Enzymatic Therapy, Inc. of Green Bay, Wisconsin. Before the program began, participants were asked to sign a “guarantee” that they were not agents of the FDA, Better Business Bureau, or any other consumer protection agency; and, that they would not tape the seminar for use against the company by any government agency. The seminar lasted from 9 am to 6 pm, and featured company president Terence J. Lemerond, ND, BS, CNC, Kenneth R. Daub, DC, and Michael T. Murray, ND, who practices naturopathy in Bellevue, Washington and teaches “therapeutic nutrition” at John Bastyr College, a naturopathic school in Seattle. Milner details how these promoters work to circumvent the law in the promotion of unapproved drugs disguised as nutritional products. Milner says, “rather than seek FDA approval, Lemerond and his associates have been using subterfuge to ‘distance’ illegal claims from their product labels. The fact that this effort has prospered is not the result of its cleverness but of FDA sluggishness. As should be obvious from this report, evidence of wrongdoing is not difficult to obtain.”
Does Michael T. Murray sound familiar? He’s the co-author/co-editor of the Textbook of Natural Medicine and a member of the Board of Regents of Bastyr University, the most conspicuous of naturopathic “medical schools.” Murray continues to capitalize on his apparent academic stature by shilling for such enterprises as “Natural Factors,” a purveyor of herbs and vitamins, and “BodyBalance,” a company that hawks dubious laboratory tests directly to unwary consumers.
So much for a “code of ethics.”

Bastyr University’s MPH and MPH/ND programs should not be accredited
Bastyr University’s application for accreditation of MPH and MPH/ND programs should be denied. Bastyr’s curriculum is filled with pseudoscience and incompatible with the science of public health. Naturopathy is a poor fit for an MPH program, especially considering its opposition to immunization.
Jann Bellamy on January 14, 2021
Link

The motto of the American Public Health Association is “For science. For action. For health.” Accreditation of a Master of Public Health (MPH) and a combined Master of Public Health/Naturopathic Doctor (MPH/ND) program at Bastyr University would make a mockery of that axiom.
Bastyr University’s application for accreditation of its MPH and MPH/ND programs has been accepted by the Council on Education for Public Health (CEPH), the accrediting agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education for public health education schools and programs. (The CEPH is the successor to the American Public Health Association’s original accreditation program.) A site visit is scheduled on January 6, 2022, and the anticipated decision date on the application is “TBD 2022”, per the CEPH website.
According to my recent telephone conversation with a CEPH rep, the scheduling of a site visit means that CEPH is fairly confident that accreditation will be granted and the sooner public comments on the application are submitted, the better, so the CEPH can take them into account when making a final decision. (I did not mention a particular school in my inquiry.)
In my opinion, granting accreditation to a Bastyr MPH or MPH/ND program would give undue luster to a school that specializes in the teaching of pseudoscience and concomitantly dilute the value of an MPH degree from an accredited school. After all, if a school teaching, say, that humans are channeled with “meridians” funneling “energy” about their bodies can have an accredited MPH program, what does that say about the validity of accreditation everywhere?
Before we go further, however, a word about accreditation of schools in the U.S., which, unlike quality-control schema in other countries, is not actually run by the government. The Department of Education has basically farmed that task out to private accreditation agencies which, if not managed in the public interest, can create a fox-guarding-the-henhouse situation.
Most importantly for our purposes here, in granting authority to these private agencies, one criteria wholly absent from the qualifications is that education be science-based. This means that, once an accrediting agency is approved, the schools it oversees are free to teach all the pseudoscience they want as long as their accrediting agency is simpatico.
Nothing in the CEPH guidelines, of course, suggests the agency is tolerant of pseudoscience. In fact, its accreditation criteria requires that programs ensure its graduates “are grounded in public health knowledge” and “can discuss the science of . . . prevention in population health”, among other science-related criteria. The same cannot be said, however, of Bastyr’s accreditation by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education or the Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine. Thus, to the extent CEPH is relying on accreditation by those agencies to ensure that MPH students would find themselves in a suitably science-based institution, it shouldn’t.
Nor should the fact that naturopathic doctors are licensed in some states be treated as an indication of their scientific legitimacy. Legislation is all-too-often political, not evidence-based, as demonstrated by legislative attempts to mandate the teaching of creationism and to require doctors to perform medically unnecessary procedures prior to performing abortions. Such is the case with naturopathic licensing.
Bastyr rejects science and evidence
With that, let’s turn back to the reasons for denying accreditation to Bastyr’s MPH and MPH/ND programs.
Bastyr University is a private alternative medicine school in Washington offering degrees in naturopathy, acupuncture and Chinese medicine, among others. Bastyr’s curriculum is not entirely evidence-based and, in some cases, not even compatible with basic scientific principles, including chemistry and physics. This matters because, in my view, the public health profession cannot stand with one foot in science and one foot in pseudoscience without its credibility being destroyed. Public health must be grounded wholly in the acceptance of the scientific method and its fruits, and an institution that rejects the scientific method cannot remain true to the principles underlying public health.
A few examples from Bastyr’s curriculum should suffice to illustrate the school’s rejection of science and evidence.
Bastyr’s acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine programs purport to draw on “both traditional Chinese medicine and biomedical concepts” incorporating “Eastern and Western healing traditions”. In other words, the body of scientific knowledge underlying medicine is reduced to just another “concept” or “healing tradition” which can be accepted or rejected in favor of the pseudoscience of acupuncture and TCM.
Bastyr’s acupuncture and TCM course descriptions illustrate the extent to which so-called “Western medicine” is put on equal footing with the pseudoscientific concepts. Thus, in anatomy, students are taught “Western anatomy and acupuncture energetic anatomy”, which are “bridged in this course”, and “anatomical connections to acupuncture point location” (Course BC4102). Students learn, as factual, that the body contains meridian channels and 365 acupoints (AM5100), “tongue and pulse” diagnosis (AM 7402), and the “TCM empirical model of pathophysiology of health disharmonies according to Zang Fu and [“meridian”] channel theories” and the “etiology, signs and symptoms, and patterns that create disease” per TCM. (AM5203). It is worth noting that the photos on Bastyr’s website illustrating its acupuncture program show needles being inserted without regard to basic sterile technique (i.e., the use of gloves).
Bastyr also offers courses (and, formerly, a Masters Program and certificate) in ayurvedic “science”. Ayurveda is a pre-scientific belief system originating in India based on concepts of human functioning and claims of health benefit that are unsupported by basic science or evidence of effectiveness. Yet, according to a paper presented by the head of the ayurvedic program at Bastyr (and posted on Bastyr’s website), ayurveda will “cure and remove illness and disease of Ill people” and will “prevent disease”.
The rejection of science at Bastyr is further illustrated by its naturopathy curriculum, which, for example, includes five separate homeopathy courses as well as clinical education in homeopathy. (The homeopathy department is headed by a ND who holds an appointment as an associate dean at Bastyr.)
Homeopathy is quackery. The overwhelming scientific consensus is that homeopathy is highly implausible, unsupported by scientific evidence, ineffective in treating illness and, when relied upon instead of actual medicine, dangerous and even deadly. The FDA has acknowledged that all homeopathic remedies on the market today are there in violation of the FD&C Act because they lack the legally required FDA pre-market review for safety and efficacy. (At the present time, the FDA is exercising its enforcement discretion and targeting only homeopathic remedies raising certain safety concerns.)
Thus, Bastyr is currently teaching students a thoroughly discredited method of diagnosis and treatment using a product that is illegal under federal law.
Over half of Bastyr’s faculty have degrees in “alternative medicine”, such as naturopathy, acupuncture, and chiropractic. Only a handful have PhD, MD, or MPH degrees. Bastyr’s Research Institute reports only three currently ongoing studies and only two published studies in the last decade.
There is no critic of Bastyr more informed than Britt Hermes, a former licensed ND who graduated from Bastyr in 2011. Britt left naturopathic practice when she caught another ND using an illegal cancer drug on patients and
began scrutinizing my education and training at Bastyr University. What I learned is frightening.
Since then, Britt has become a whistleblower whose writing (including her own blog and posts on SBM) and media appearances have exposed the bogus claims made by alternative medicine practitioners and the dangerous therapies used by naturopathic doctors, including those to treat cancer. For this, she won the John Maddox Prize, a joint initiative of the charity Sense about Science and the journal Nature, recognizing her championing of science in the face of hostility and legal threats. (One legal threat came from Bastyr University itself, apparently upset regarding her revelations about her education there.) She is currently a PhD student in evolutionary biology at the University of Kiel.
Britt describes naturopathic education as
riddled with pseudoscience, debunked medical theories, and experimental medical practices. . . . After breaking down the clinical training hours and assessing the quality of the medical training, I believe the quantity and quality of the training provided by Bastyr University is scant, lacks the application of medical standards of care, and includes pseudoscientific diagnostic methods and treatments of real and fake diseases. . . . To the best of my memory [in clinical training at Bastyr], I was rarely asked about the medical standard of care for a diagnosis and treatment plan. The treatments offered to patients were usually abundant and seemed like a toss-up. . . . Of the hours that Bastyr provided to me and my classmates in purported primary care training (748 hours), one quarter of this time was spent in case preview and review. The remaining 75% (561 hours) contained dubious diagnostics and experimental treatments that were so embedded within a pseudo-scientific and pseudo-medical practice that the student clinician loses the ability to assess what is truth and what is make-believe. When homeopathic remedies are presented on the same level as antibiotic treatment, the naturopathic student is lost, and I don’t blame them.
She adds, in another post:
Pre-clinical coursework at accredited naturopathic programs is also not so rigorous or science-based, though on paper ND credit hours match an MD or DO program. Indeed, naturopathic programs teach classes with the same titles as those in medical schools. Naturopathic classes, including basic sciences courses, are almost entirely taught by other naturopaths or other practitioners of alternative medicine, such as doctors of naprapathy. The pediatrics courses assign reading from anti-vaccine authors, like Bob Sears, and overall the reading load seems quite low for what would be expected from MD and DO students.
The accredited naturopathic curriculum also includes a large amount of pure pseudoscience, with the most glaring examples being three quarters spent on homeopathy . . .
In addressing students who ask her whether they should go to naturopathic school (The answer? No.) Britt tells them:
Accredited naturopathic schools are disguising the naturopathic education of nonsense as a distinct, and better, form of primary care medicine. Sadly, these schools are getting away with what I consider to be education fraud. The truth is that naturopathic education is riddled with pseudoscience, debunked theories, and experimental medical practices.
Given immunization’s vital role in public health and the concern about vaccine hesitancy, Britt’s experiences in “the fatally flawed pediatric training that NDs receive in their accredited programs” are particularly concerning. In her elective pediatrics clinical shift:
I didn’t see any newborns. We talked to parents about what supplements to take in order to “boost the immune system.” We counseled about alternative vaccine schedules and didn’t actually give out vaccines. What kind of primary care training is this? . . .
It should be appalling for anyone to see Dana Ullman’s Homeopathy for Children and Infants and Dr. Bob Sears’s The Vaccine Book, not once, but twice in the [pediatrics course reading] list! All of my syllabi for the Bastyr pediatrics courses included these texts.
While the pediatrics courses discussed vaccines and official immunization schedules, this was always in the context of stirring controversy. Take, for example, the following class note I made about counseling parents on alternative vaccine schedules:
When discussing vaccination with parents these questions need to be discussed separately: Which ones to give? When to give chosen immunizations? How many doses are recommended? Advise parents to ask the following questions in order to assist them in making the choice to vaccinate or to refuse to vaccinate: What is the seriousness of the disease? What is the risk of getting the disease? How easy is the disease to treat? What is the risk of vaccinating for the disease? How do vaccines affect our immune systems? How does exposure to childhood disease affect our immune systems? What is the general health of my child? What will my child be exposed to? If my child were to get sick because we didn’t vaccinate him how would we feel? If my child were to get sick from a vaccine how would we feel?
Naturopathic students are essentially trained in alternative vaccines schedules, which lead parents to not vaccinate. If this isn’t smoking gun proof that naturopaths are anti-vaccine to the core, then what is? I noticed that missing from my notes are discussions about how to advocate for the official vaccination schedule and alleviate parental fear of toxins, for example.
An archived page from Bastyr’s teaching clinic website falsely claims that influenza vaccines weaken the immune system and that the vaccine isn’t recommended if you are healthy. Included among the many homeopathic remedies listed on an archived page from the clinic’s dispensary are fake homeopathic vaccines (including a fake “MMR” vaccine) and homeopathic nosodes like Influenzinum.
Specifically regarding homeopathy, Britt reveals:
When I was in school at Bastyr University, my naturopathic instructors would often tell students stories about the miraculous healing powers of homeopathy, even in life and death situations. There were presented cases of severely depressed patients taking Aurum, a remedy made from gold, who were cured of their suicidal ideations. I remember stories using homeopathy to treat acute asthma attacks as students, we were also taught keep our own homeopathic first-aid kits at home, and Bastyr in June 2017, wrote “Homeopathy could be a great solution for your natural first aid kit for summer.”
Naturopathy is not compatible with public health
In addition to an accredited MPH program, Bastyr is seeking accreditation of a combined MPH/ND program. Given naturopathy’s hostility to vaccination and science-based practice, there exists an inherent tension between it and public health. In my view, this would require either that naturopathy unqualifiedly reject its foundation in pseudoscience (highly unlikely) or that public health accommodate naturopathy’s junk science (hopefully unlikely) for the two to co-exist in one program.
To augment the disturbing information about naturopathy specific to Bastyr already exposed in this post, a few additional observations about naturopathic practice in general are in order.
First, naturopathy’s antipathy to vaccination is well documented. Studies of naturopathic students indicate that their support for vaccination decreases with each year of education. Naturopathic care is associated with fewer vaccinations and increased likelihood of vaccine-preventable disease: in one Ontario naturopathic practice just under 9% of the pediatric patients were unvaccinated and, in a survey of Massachusetts homeopaths and naturopaths, most did not recommend vaccination. Naturopathic anti-vaccination rhetoric was more recently documented in this journal article.
NDs’ use of unconventional therapies, including lightly-regulated compounded drugs, can be dangerous, especially when they venture into serious diseases like cancer. In 2019, the FDA issued a proposed rule rejecting eleven substances nominated by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP, the ND equivalent of the AMA) for use in drug compounding, including curcumin and cesium chloride. Curcumin was the active ingredient in an intravenous infusion that killed the patient of a California-licensed naturopathic doctor and Bastyr graduate, who administered it to his patient for eczema. Cesium chloride is a dangerous and ineffective naturopathic cancer treatment, previously the subject of an FDA safety alert. If finalized, which seems highly likely considering the solid science behind it, the rule will, thankfully, prohibit the use of these and other substances in compounded drugs. Yet, the AANP is fighting the FDA’s decision with a Citizen’s Petition and, potentially, a lawsuit, despite the fact that the evidence it presented in support of its nominations was soundly rejected by the FDA’s panel of experts.
Most recently, NDs have been taken to task for their unproven COVID-19 nostrums. Both the AANP and the California Association of Naturopathic Doctors have been promoting the unproven COVID-19 therapeutic, IV Vitamin C, despite the Australian Government’s recent safety alert finding “no robust scientific evidence to support the usage of this vitamin in the management of COVID-19”.
Because applications for accreditation are not available to the general public, I have no idea what representations Bastyr University made in its application, although I doubt the information in this post is included. The CEPH normally works with applicant programs that are part of the mainstream American college and university system and it is understandably unfamiliar with the alternative universe of schools with alternative medicine programs. It should proceed very cautiously in this arena and do its own research. In the end, I hope the CEPH will agree that an educational institution that won’t commit to science and evidence cannot co-exist with a profession whose commitment to science and evidence is at the heart of its protection of public health.
I will be submitting a comment to the CEPH and hope those of you who are concerned about public health will do the same. As well, if you know others who might be interested, especially those who are in the public health field or hold public health degrees, it would be valuable to pass this information on and ask that they consider commenting as well. According to my telephone conversion with the CEPH, comments can be submitted by email to [email protected].
The mailing address is: Council on Education for Public Health, 1010 Wayne Ave., Suite 220, Silver Spring, MD 20910.
For further information on submitting comments, the CEPH telephone number is (202) 789-1050. (There is a “Complaint Procedure” that covers both accredited and applicant schools, but based on the information I got by telephone, and on reading the complaint procedure, it does not appear to apply to general comments of this nature on a school’s application.)

What naturopaths really want
Naturopaths want the same scope of practice as MDs and DOs, allowing them to make important medico-legal judgments that put life, liberty and property at risk.
Jann Bellamy on June 8, 2017
Link

Mark Crislip, MD, SBM’s own infectious diseases expert, recently observed that he was increasingly seeing patients whose very real diseases are being managed with bogus naturopathic therapies, as opposed to his experience earlier in his career, where naturopathic treatment was more commonly in addition to medical management.
What to do when the patient has the ND not as a supplement to the real doctor, but the ND IS their doctor? I do not want to be complicit in approving ND care, but I may be the only ID doctor the patient can see and I want the patient to see a real doctor (me) so I can’t say no. But it is an awkward ethical position, participating in care that I know is bogus yet legal. I tend to feel a little weaselly with these cases, mostly ignoring the steaming pile of ND care in the room and focus on making sure the patient gets the best medical diagnosis and treatment I can provide. If asked about the ND care, I give an honest answer, but I do not go out of my way to discuss it. It is, I think, the lesser the two evils, but it leaves me feeling dirty.
He is not the first physician frustrated by dubious naturopathic diagnoses and treatments foisted on his patients. (See here, here and here.) As he observed, the problem is likely to get worse “as pseudo-medical providers increase their presence in health care.”
His observation has proved tragically prescient. Aided by the Oregon Legislature, and barring a veto by the Governor, the “steaming pile of ND care” is about to get a lot bigger and he and his fellow physicians (the real ones: MDs and DOs) are going to be wading in it big time.
Oregon already grants naturopathic doctors the same scope of practice as MD and DO primary care physicians, the most liberal among the 19 states that give naturopathy some form of legal recognition. But NDs weren’t satisfied with merely being able to practice primary care while at the same time skipping the rigorous requirements of medical school (entrance exams, high undergrad GPAs, tough science-based courses, meaningful clinical experience), validated testing of their knowledge, and thousands of hours of post-grad residency.
What was the source of this dissatisfaction? As in every state, Oregon’s laws have requirements that, when certain medico-legal issues arise, competent medical judgments must be made by those appropriately educated and trained to make them. For example, many states permit people to make what are often called “living wills,” directing their end-of-life care in case they are not able to communicate their wishes. Typically, living wills describe the circumstances under which a person no longer wants to receive further medical treatment, nutrition and hydration, even if it hastens death. To protect the patient, state law will require a physician to make the medical judgments necessary to determine key issues, such as whether the patient lacks the capacity to make decisions on his own, whether he has a terminal illness from which he is unlikely to recover and whether further treatment would be of any benefit. Other medico-legal issues include mental capacity in guardianship proceedings, eligibility for government services (such as special education) based on disability, and determinations of whether crimes such as sexual assault and child abuse have occurred.
Oregon NDs were miffed that they were being cut out of the decision-making and other benefits (such as eligibility for state employment as “physicians” and fees for some services) because state laws referred only to “physicians” or to physicians licensed as MDs and DOs, but not “naturopathic physicians,” making it unclear whether they were included. So, as they often do, the NDs went running to their friends in the state legislature. Having combed through the entire Oregon Revised Statutes and picked out the offending sections, they managed to get introduced a 79-page bill (Senate Bill 856) inserting “naturopathic physician” in all the relevant state laws. That bill just passed in the Oregon House and Senate and is on its way to the Governor for consideration. Having won primary care physician status via Legislative Alchemy, they are now bootstrapping themselves into every nook and cranny of the Oregon health care system. (SB 856 is but one of several naturopath-friendly bills pending in Oregon.)
The Oregon Association of Naturopathic Physicians (OANP) argued that this was not a scope of practice expansion, although both the (woefully inadequate) House and the Senate staff analyses appear to disagree. According to the OANP, even though NDs are “now recognized as primary care physicians,” the statutes “have not evolved to reflect the procedures and services that naturopathic physicians now provide.”
Before turning to these “procedures and services” NDs will now be able to legally provide (again, barring veto by the Governor), it is important to keep in mind a few points about naturopathic doctors:
    • No independent professional evaluation of the adequacy of ND education and training to practice as primary care physicians (or as anything, for that matter) has ever been carried out. There is, however, considerable evidence that it is wholly inadequate to the task.
    • There is not a shred of evidence that NDs can safely and effectively deliver primary healthcare services. There is, however, evidence that their care is substandard. (Also, here.)
    • NDs have no discernible standard of care, reject evidence-based medicine, and, by all accounts, offer the public a plethora of dubious diagnoses and pseudoscientific treatments.
    • Each of the privileges SB 856 grants to naturopathic physicians can be carried out by a graduate of a four-year naturopathic “medical” education program, one of which is conducted in a building located in an office park, a graduate who is highly unlikely to have ever seen a patient with many of the diseases and conditions she will face in making the momentous medico-legal decisions Oregon law would allow. She may have had zero training in any mainstream health care facility, such as a hospital, specialty care clinic or nursing home.
Life, liberty and property
With that, let’s turn to SB 856 and just what NDs will be allowed to do if the Governor signs on:
     1.  Withdraw medical treatment, hydration and nutrition from a patient when the ND has determined that the patient has a terminal condition and would not likely benefit from further medical care or is at an advanced stage of illness and unlikely to improve, even in the absence of a patient’s having previously expressed his wishes on these issues. OANP’s summary of SB 856’s provisions for legislators and the public completely misrepresents the sweeping nature of this change by describing it as “Adds NDs to providers who can sign Advanced Directives.”
     2.  Order physical or chemical restraint, or psychotropic medication, for elderly and disabled persons.
     3.  Sign Physicians Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment (POLST). A POLST is a standing medical order directing or withholding specific medical treatment (for example, an order not to resuscitate the patient) designed for seriously ill or frail patients whose health care professional believes may die within a year. POLSTs should be executed by the health care professional only after a discussion with the patient concerning his wishes for end-of-life care.
     4.  Determine that a patient is not competent to give informed consent to mental health treatment, as well as consent to that treatment for the patient, including convulsive treatment, psychoactive medication, psychosurgery, and retention in a mental health care facility.
     5.  Conduct medical examinations of sexual assault and child abuse victims; allows courts to order treatment of child abuse victim by an ND.
     6.  Review state correctional facility medical plans, provide medical care to prisoners and juvenile detainees, train non-medical facility personnel in administering medications and order special diets for prisoners. (Considering the whacko diets favored by naturopaths, this one could prove a real challenge to Oregon’s budget.)
     7.  Give disability ratings to veterans.
     8.  Authorize administration of medication at school to students.
     9.  Perform the medical exam necessary for a child to receive special education services.
     10.  Receive fees for providing care to cystic fibrosis patients.
     11.  Treat those convicted of sex crimes enrolled in a medical treatment program.
     12.  Make diagnostic evaluations of persons alleged to have mental illness or developmental disability who are candidates for court-ordered commitment to a care facility, and provide medical care, including prescription medications, for mentally and developmentally disabled patients committed to care facilities.
     13.  Participate in Oregon Health Authority (OHA) drug treatment programs, including treatment with synthetic opiates.
     14.  Recommend voluntary sterilization or abortion.
     15.  Give orders for patients of home health agencies, nursing home facilities and hospice and determine eligibility for hospice care.
     16.  (Dr. Crislip will love this one.) Perform exams of food handlers suspected of having infectious or contagious disease and issue health certificates to food handlers suspected of having communicable diseases.
     17.  Give orders for respiratory therapy.
     18.  Enter into clinical pharmacy agreements with pharmacists, meaning clinical pharmacists can provide direct patient care to the ND’s patients under the ND’s supervision.
     19.  Provide health care services at Oregon Health and Science University with protection from liability for malpractice.
     20.  Allows the OHA to refer patients to NDs for “consultation, examination, medical treatment and prescription” for contraception.
     21.  Expands the use of NDs in state-funded medical care programs.
     22.  Forces insurers to cover the services of “naturopathic physicians specializing in women’s health” if a female insured wants to designate same as her PCP. (Escharotic treatment of cervical dysplasia, anyone?)
I could not find that the Oregon Medical Association took a position on SB 856, although two MDs did show up at a committee hearing and testified against it, pointing out the inadequacy of naturopathic education and training, naturopathic belief in homeopathy, naturopathic opposition to vaccination, their rejection of evidence-based medicine, and criticism of the NPLEX for failure to meet national licensing standards. As one said:
Graduate MDs are held to a standard of residency training and so should naturopaths if they want to hold the title “physician” with these same privileges. To ensure fairness, graduate MDs should be allowed to take the NPLEX exam to practice in the state of Oregon without a residency; or vice versa, naturopaths should take the USMLE and obtain a standardized medical residency.
Exactly.
In sum, the Oregon Legislature has made it clear that naturopathic “physicians” will be able to make life and death decisions for seriously ill patients and provide medical care for vulnerable populations like the mentally ill, developmentally disabled, prisoners, addicts, juvenile detainees, the poor, crime victims and hospice patients. NDs will be able to weigh in on whether people should be deprived of their liberty through involuntary commitment and of the right to control their own property through determinations of competency. They will make the call on whether the public is at risk for the spread of communicable diseases. Those are weighty matters to put into the hands of folks who think water has magical properties. Life, liberty and property are in jeopardy when outcomes are based on incompetent medical judgments.
Naturopaths want to have it both ways. They like to portray themselves as purveyors of “natural” treatments that “stimulate the body’s self-healing ability” and as experts at prevention and management of chronic diseases. But what they really want is exactly the same broad-scope privileges as MDs and DOs, from pre-natal care right down to pulling the plug on the terminally ill, and this bill proves it. State legislators should be reminded of this as naturopaths seek licensing and practice expansion: naturopaths will return to the statehouse again and again until they reach full equivalency with MDs and DOs.
There may be a silver lining of sorts here: as their inclusion in the mainstream healthcare system expands, their incompetency will be increasingly exposed. Perhaps their greedy grab for power will prove their undoing.
If you would like to contact Oregon Gov. Kate Brown and ask her to veto Senate Bill 856, click here.

Legislative Alchemy I: Naturopathy
Jann Bellamy
Link
Via the magic of “legislative alchemy,” state legislatures transform implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments into perfectly legal health care practices.[1] Without the benefit of legislative alchemy, chiropractors, naturopaths, homeopaths, acupuncturists and other assorted putative healers would be vulnerable to charges of practicing medicine without a license and consumer fraud. Thus, they must seek either their own licensing system or exemption from licensing altogether.
Licensing bestows an undeserved air of legitimacy on “alternative” practitioners. Because a state’s authority to regulate health care lies in its inherent power to protect the public health, safety and welfare, the public understandably assumes licensing actually accomplishes this purpose. In fact, the opposite occurs. Any attempt to impose a science-based standard of health care becomes impossible when vitalism and similarly debunked notions of human functioning are enshrined into law.
Initial licensing is just a beginning. Once the beach head is established other benefits can follow, such as expansion of the scope of practice. If not granted in the initial legislation, “alternative” practitioners can return, seeking more goodies like self-regulation and mandatory insurance coverage.
Each year brings a fresh round of eager petitioners to the state house doors hoping to transform their base ideas into licensing gold through legislative alchemy. In this post, we look at how the naturopaths are faring. We’ll leave chiropractors, acupuncturists and the rest to a later post.
Naturopathy 101
Three years ago, Dr. Kimball Atwood wrote an excellent series of SBM posts on naturopathy, including efforts to license naturopaths in several states (In four parts: 1, 2, 3, 4)[2] Since then, naturopathy has fairly regularly appeared on SBM, its pseudoscientific practices and threats to public health offering plenty of grist (gluten-free or not) for the scientific mill in posts by Drs. Gorski (also this one), Lipson, and Kroll.
All posts are highly recommended, but if you’re pressed for time, here’s Dr. Gorski’s description of naturopathy:
…a hodge-podge of mostly unscientific treatment modalities based on vitalism and other prescientific notions of disease. As a result, typical naturopaths are more than happy in essence to ‘pick one from column A and one from column B’ when it comes to pseudoscience, mixing and matching treatments including traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, herbalism, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophical medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine.
As well, according to a recent article in Maternal and Child Health Journal “published reports suggest that only a minority of naturopathic physicians actively support full vaccination.”[3] This should surprise no one, as it fully accords with naturopathy’s long standing opposition to vaccination (see also QuackWatch).
A review of Washington state insurance records reported in the article showed that children were significantly less likely to receive each of four recommended vaccinations (measles/mumps/rubella, chickenpox, diphtheria/tetanus/pertussis, and H. influenzae type B) if they saw a naturopathic physician. It would naturally follow then that pediatric use of naturopathy was associated with significantly more diagnoses of vaccine-preventable disease.
The Scorecard
In the first half of 2011 alone, bills to license naturopaths were pending before ten state legislatures. To date, only one has been successful, in North Dakota. Licensing bills failed in four states because they never made it out of committee. They remain pending in committee in five states.
Of the 15 states already licensing naturopaths, bills to expand the scope of practice (including expansion via self-regulation) were introduced in seven. These bills remain pending in two states, passed in two states, and failed in three states, again because they never made it out of committee. (A bill to expand naturopathic scope of practice is also pending in Washington, D.C.) Legislation mandating public and/or private health insurance coverage for naturopathic services is pending in one state, and failed to make it out of committee in two.
Licensing happens
In July, 2008, Dr. Atwood began the first of his four-part series, “Another State Promotes the Pseudoscientific Cult that is ‘Naturopathic Medicine,’” with the observation that Minnesota had just become the 15th state to license naturopaths. In July, 2011, North Dakota became the 16th state.[4]
North Dakota departs from those states giving naturopaths their own governing authority by establishing a State Board of Integrative Health Care. “Integrative health care,” that ever shape-shifting term, is not defined in the statute, but the Board appears to be a place to park things the state otherwise doesn’t know exactly what to do with. For starters, the Board will license and regulate both naturopaths and music therapists, but the barn door is left open for other “integrative” health care practitioners to apply for regulation.
The new Board must have at least five members, including one member of each profession (such as they are) regulated. One member must be an M.D. or D.O., although if no medical or osteopathic doctor is willing to serve the governor can appoint an advanced practice registered nurse (APRN) instead. Perhaps this indicates the level of enthusiasm for board service the legislature anticipates. The governor must also appoint a pharmacist, an APRN and a layperson, although no provision is made if none of them want to do this either.
The new law contains the typical boilerplate found in other naturopath licensing bills (discussed further below) although this one is unusually short on details and leaves it to the State Board of Integrative Health Care to sort out the specifics. The law does say that NDs cannot prescribe or administer drugs or ionizing radioactive substances or perform surgery. And even though the statute describes naturopathy as “a system of primary health care … for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of human health conditions, injury, and disease” a licensed naturopath “may not hold out to the public that the naturopath is a primary care provider.”
The law has two laudable provisions. First, naturopaths are prohibited from “the making of false or misleading statements about the licensee’s skill or the efficacy of any medicine, treatment, or remedy.” (Emphasis mine.) That last phrase is going to make it pretty quiet around the N.D. office. After all, if you can’t misrepresent the efficacy of, for example, homeopathic preparations or herbal supplements it’s going to be hard to come up with an explanation of exactly why you’re prescribing (or selling) them.
Second, another provision prohibits “the representation to a patient that a manifestly incurable condition, sickness, disease, or injury can be cured.” Too late for Hulda Clark, but at least the legislature had the good sense to take care that end on the bell curve of charlatanism.
Pending licensing legislation
Naturopathic licensing bills are now before the legislatures of Massachusetts (House Bill 2367, Senate Bill 1158), North Carolina (House Bill 847, Senate Bill 467) Illinois (House Bill 3350), Pennsylvania (House Bill 1717), and New York (Assembly Bills 1937 and 3057, Senate Bill 1803).
As with all naturopathic licensing legislation, these bills are based on three unproven notions: that the general public wants access to naturopaths, that naturopathic licensing protects the public from substandard health care practices, and that “educated” naturopaths are the answer to quality of care issues.
And as is true of other bills pending in 2011, both successful and not, these proposals to license naturopaths buy into the same false premise set forth in Massachusetts House Bill No. 02367:
Naturopathic health care [is] a system of health care practices for the prevention, diagnosis, evaluation and treatment of illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body through the use of education, nutrition, natural medicines and therapies and other modalities which are designed to support, stimulate or supplement the human body’s own natural self-healing processes.
Yes, it’s those famous “self-healing processes,” which, if we can only hit them with the right plant, or animal part, or mineral, or electric current, or needle, or pressure, or thrust, or energy field, they will spring forth and do their job. They’re just being stubborn, you see, lurking there in the body, refusing to heal. Like little gods, they must be appeased with food and other amusements. And they like theirs natural.
Pennsylvania in particular wants to go after the body’s self-healing processes full bore. Its proposed licensing act would allow naturopaths to practice “behavioral medicine,” including cognitive therapy. As well, they could employ “naturopathic musculokeletal therapy” on, among other things, scar tissue and visceral organs, and “reposition … displaced body tissues and organs.” Then there’s electromagnetic energy, colon hydrotherapy, electrotherapy, magnetic therapy, low-level laser light, neural therapy, diathermy, dietary supplements and “bio-identical” hormones.
And what naturopathy licensing act would be complete without homeopathy, now with a new, improved statutory definition in Pennsylvania: “a system of employing substances of animal, vegetable or mineral origin which are given in microdosage in the prevention and treatment of disease.” “Microdosage”? How about “nonexistentdosage”?
One means of poking the body’s “self-healing processes” not available under any state’s proposed legislation is acupuncture. It is specifically prohibited except under one version of New York’s licensing bill, where it is not mentioned either as part of the permissible scope of practice or as a prohibition.
A Learner’s Permit to Practice Medicine?
One version of a New York Assembly licensing bill (A01937) and a Senate bill would prohibit the practice of naturopathy except under the supervision of a physician. (Assembly bill A03057 does not include this prohibition, and further allows “naturopathic childbirth.”)
Neither North Carolina’s Senate or House bill require actual physician supervision, but applicants for licensure must provide the North Carolina Naturopathic Doctors Licensing Board with a list of physicians from at least four specialty areas who have “agreed to work with … and accept referrals from the applicant.” The Senate bill would create an “Advisory Council” to “foster coordination and collaboration” between N.D.s, M.D.s and other health professionals “for the purpose of providing appropriate care for patients.” Naturopaths could not prescribe drugs in N.C.
In Pennsylvania, naturopaths would be regulated by the Board of Medicine. A “Naturopathic Formulary Committee” must include two physicians, a pharmacist, and someone with an advanced degree in pharmacology or pharmacognosy. Massachusetts establishes a naturopathic board which includes physicians and a pharmacologist. It does not give naturopaths prescribing privileges.
On the other hand, in Illinois, naturopaths would have their own board, which has no M.D. or D.O. physician members. However, both physicians and pharmacists must be on the “Naturopathic Formulary Council,” which would establish a formulary that can include prescription drugs.
The Illinois House licensing bill establishes a “Naturopathic Childbirth Attendance Advisory Committee” (which must include an M.D. obstetrician and a certified nurse midwife) to look into naturopathic education and training, then make recommendations regarding naturopathic childbirth attendance, which the Department of Financial and Professional Regulation must adopt as rules. The N.D. must pass the North American Registry of Midwives examination to practice “naturopathic childbirth attendance.”
All of these proposals indicate to me that the state legislatures don’t quite trust naturopaths. Naturopathy, as defined by naturopaths, is a free-standing health care philosophy (if you will) perfectly capable of operating without supervision from “mainstream” medicine. But the states aren’t buying it. While they are willing to consider licensing, it’s clear the state legislatures are not willing to unleash naturopaths on the public without some version of physician oversight. This is especially obvious regarding childbirth and prescription drugs. After all, for example, if one believes naturopaths are “real doctors” then why do they need to pass a midwifery exam to deliver babies?
This is an unfortunate half-baked approach. If the states don’t believe the education and training of naturopaths is up to par, then they shouldn’t license them at all. Instead naturopaths are given learner’s permits to practice medicine – they can be doctors, but only with adult supervision.
And now, for the good news
Naturopathic licensing bills failed in four states in 2011: Maryland, Virginia, Colorado, and Iowa. In Colorado it failed for the eighth time, largely due to the indefatigable Linda Rosa, RN, Larry Sarner and Mark Johnson, MD. In the past, the Colorado Medical Society has failed science-based medicine by supporting naturopathic licensing. This time around, according to Ms. Rosa, the Colorado Medical Society leadership stuck to their deal with the naturopaths to allow registration in exchange for naturopaths not using the term “physician” and limiting some of their scope of practice.
You can’t always get what you want…
But you can always go back and ask again, which is what’s happening in states already licensing naturopaths.
New laws in Washington and Arizona expand the scope of naturopathic practice. Arizona now allows IV administration of “nutrients.” The Arizona Naturopathic Medical Association requested “parenteral” administration authority but that word was changed to “intravenous” in committee.
In Washington, naturopaths will now be governed by their very own Board of Naturopathy, free of the meddling influence of M.D.s, D.O.s or pharmacists – the Board is composed of five N.D.s and two public members. In addition, naturopaths may now give orders to respiratory therapists and prescribe contraceptive drugs. A limitation on the use of “physical modalities” to those that are “non-invasive” was lifted.
Other bills failed to make it out of committee before the legislatures adjourned:
Alaska: would create a Naturopathic Medical Board for purpose of expanding allowed practices and procedures, including limited prescriptive authority.
Idaho: attempt to establish something called a “registered naturopathic practitioner,” which required no formal education if one had “practiced as a doctor of naturopathy” for 20 years.
Kansas: would expand the scope of naturopathic prescribing authority to include intramuscular, subcutaneous or intravenous administration of vitamins, minerals and homeopathic preparations, as well as prescription and administration of, among other things, whole gland thyroid. (If I may be permitted a comment: EEWWWW!)
Hawaii: would allow naturopaths to prescribe controlled substances.
New Hampshire and Oregon: would mandate insurance coverage of naturopathic services.
Still pending are bills in California to expand drug prescribing authority and in Hawaii to mandate insurance coverage for naturopathic services.
Hawaii law, very sensibly, requires the state auditor to submit a report assessing “both the social and financial effects of proposed mandated coverage.” In what I personally consider a new low in legislative drafting sleaziness, the Hawaii Senate’s concurrent resolution requesting the auditor’s study states:
WHEREAS, according to the American Cancer Society, naturopathy is ‘a complete alternative care system that uses a wide range of approaches such as nutrition, herbs, manipulation of the body, exercise, stress, and acupuncture … .’
Here’s a more, um, holistic view of the American Cancer Society’s statements on naturopathy for the state auditor’s consideration:
Available scientific evidence does not support claims that naturopathic medicine can cure cancer or any other disease, since virtually no studies on naturopathy as a whole have been published.
Available scientific evidence does not support claims that naturopathic medicine is effective for most health problems. Most of the claims of effectiveness are based on individual cases, medical records, and summaries of practitioners’ clinical experiences.
Excessive fasting, dietary restrictions, or use of enemas, which are sometimes components of naturopathic treatment, may be dangerous. Naturopathic treatment may involve taking unregulated herbs, some of which may have harmful effects.
As if that weren’t enough, the Hawaii Senate’s resolution adds:
WHEREAS, naturopathic medicine has become recognized as a therapy that is comparable in its effectiveness to more traditional medical and surgical practices for many types of illnesses…
Gosh, I looked and looked on PubMed and couldn’t find a single thing to support that statement. Maybe the state auditor’s research will turn up something.
By the way…
It would cost a whole lot of money – I don’t know how much, but a whole lot for sure – to draft and introduce licensing legislation and shepherd it through the legislative process in any one state. To do this in ten states in one year must cost an astronomical amount, especially in states the size of New York, Pennsylvania and Illinois. Who’s paying for this?
Conclusion
No person should be subjected to scientifically implausible diagnostic methods and treatments. States should be working to eliminate such practices, not giving out licenses to perpetuate them.
Passage of naturopathic licensing bills in the five states where legislation is pending would substantially increase the population subject to this conglomeration of pseudoscientific practices. But even one more licensing law in one state is one too many. Supporters of science-based medicine should actively oppose the “legislative alchemy” that is naturopathic licensing and, where licensing is already entrenched, oppose expansion of scope of practice and insurance mandates.
In fact, it is possible to eliminate existing licensing of naturopaths altogether, as Florida has done.
Notes
     1.  See, Bellamy J., Legislative Alchemy: the US state chiropractic practice acts, Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies (2010)15(3): 214–222.
     2.  For an excellent primer on naturopathy, see also, Atwood K., Naturopathy: A Critical Appraisal, Medscape, General Medicine. (2003);5(4). http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/465994
     3.  Downey L, et al, Pediatric Vaccination and Vaccine-Preventable Disease Acquisition: Associations with Care by Complementary and Alternative Medicine Providers, Matern Child Health J (2010) 14: 922-930.
N.D. Cent. Code Ch. 43-58 (2011).

Licensing Naturopaths: the triumph of politics over science
Jann Bellamy on October 10, 2013
Link
Naturopaths shouldn’t get too excited about having a special week in their honor. The U.S. House of Representatives gave watermelons a whole month. As between naturopathy and watermelons for my good health, I’ll go with the watermelons any day. You’ll soon understand why.
Today is not my usual blogging day. But when David Gorksi announced SBM’s celebration of Naturopathic Medicine Week, I volunteered an extra post to answer the question I am sure is on everyone’s mind: How in the heck do they get away with this stuff?
The answer lies in the creation of Naturopathic Medicine Week itself: politics. Just as Sen. Barbara Mikulski turned her credulous acceptance of naturopathy into a Senate Resolution and slipped it by her Senate colleagues, clueless legislators around the country are sponsoring bills to license naturopaths, in some cases as primary care physicians. And it’s not as if these legislators don’t know they are incorporating quackery into primary care. Practices such as naturopathic “organ repositioning” (an anatomical impossibility) and Mark Crislip noted, what little data there is suggests that naturopathic primary care is associated with worse outcomes. But evidence is not necessary in the political realm. And now the political process has given naturopaths an additional incentive for licensure. They argue that the Affordable Care Act mandates reimbursement for their services. 
Naturopaths are far short of their goal even though licensing bills have been introduced repeatedly in many states, only to fail. Naturopaths are licensed in 17 states, but have full prescription rights in only two, Oregon and Washington. Florida, my home state, is still on their wish list but no bill was introduced this year. (Florida actually rescinded naturopathic licensing in the 1950s.) Inquiries were made, but either they couldn’t find a sponsor or backed down for other reasons. Perhaps they were deterred by the specter of their previous attempt, which resulted in a Florida House Committee report concluding that “the proposed licensure of naturopathic physicians would likely increase the risk of harm to the public.”
In 2013, licensing bills were introduced in 10 states. So far, the naturopaths are one and four.
Licensing bills failed in Arkansas, Maryland, Rhode Island and North Carolina, but are pending in six others, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania. Bills passed in the New York Senate and Pennsylvania House and are now pending in the other chamber. Key legislation expanding scope of practice or insurance coverage failed in Oregon, Alaska, Montana and Hawaii. In addition, the Alaska Department of Commerce, Community and Economic Development recently took away their authority to use “prescriptive nutrients.”
Colorado: “I’ll be back!”
After numerous failed attempts over two decades, the Colorado legislature passed a naturopathic registration (but not licensing) bill. The naturopathic lobbyists weren’t exactly straight with the legislators in this process. Naturopaths handed out a chart purporting to demonstrate that their education is at least equal to that of medical doctors. As you can see, the chart is based on the false assumption that somehow hours of education equates with quality of education. (On this same basis, I can make the argument that high school and college are equivalent.) Even assuming that is a proper basis for comparison, the chart totally misrepresents medical education and training by leaving off the additional three years of residency family practice and internal medicine physicians must undergo before they can practice.
Actually, what this chart convincingly demonstrates is that a good part of naturopathic education is eaten up with topics like homeopathy (110 hours), botanical medicine (herbs and dietary supplements, 110 hours), and Chinese medicine (160 hours). This is most interesting considering advice just out from the American College of Medical Toxicology and the American Academy of Clinical Toxicology (“Physicians Specializing in the Care of Poisoned Patients”).
Don’t use homeopathic medications, non-vitamin dietary supplements or herbal supplements as treatments for disease or preventive health measures.
When two groups whose collective motto is “Physicians Specializing in the Care of Poisoned Patients” tell us not to take something I think we all should listen, don’t you? Unfortunately for naturopaths, this pretty much wipes out the standard naturopathic formulary. Not that it will have any effect whatsoever on actual naturopathic practice, as they eschew evidence-based medicine.
But having granted them the privilege of practicing naturopathic medicine, the Colorado legislature had to go back and pepper the bill with all sorts of limitations in an attempt to satisfy the objections of those who think NDs present a danger to public health. This resulted in a scope of practice that falls far short of that accorded MD primary care physicians:
    • naturopaths are not licensed to practice, they are simply registered
    • must advise patients they are not medical doctors
    • cannot describe themselves as “physicians,” naturopathy not described as “primary care”
    • no prescription drugs and no telling patients to discontinue their medications
    • no treatment of children under two without an elaborate process in place to ensure they are also seeing a pediatrician and get the recommended vaccinations
    • must advise patients to have a medical doctor and attempt to coordinate care with same
    • no obstetrics
    • no independent supervisory board, advisory board only consisting of 3 NDs, 3 MDs, one pharmacist and 2 public members
Thus, while NDs may think they are primary care physicians, the State of Colorado most certainly does not agree. Now, you’d think the average person might pause to wonder: if naturopaths are telling the truth about their education and practice, why all the restrictions? Maybe that should tell Coloradans something. They vow to return to expand their scope of practice, a cautionary tale for states wishing to test the waters by giving NDs a limited scope of practice.
Still, there is plenty of room for mischief and the Colorado NDs seem to be making the most of it, even though full implementation of the law was delayed until June, 2014. They are, despite all evidence that they shouldn’t, busy selling patients on the idea that homeopathy and dietary supplements are beneficial.
And they are testing, testing, testing to find illusory problems they can treat. They’re using provoked urine tests to identify the ubiquitous toxins NDs claim permeate our bodies so that they can treat this imagined toxic overload with chelating agents. Here’s what the “Physicians Specializing in the Care of Poisoned Patients” have to say on that subject:
Don’t administer a chelating agent prior to testing urine for metals, a practice referred to as “provoked” urine testing.
Don’t order heavy metal screening tests to assess non-specific symptoms in the absence of excessive exposure to metals.
Don’t recommend chelation except for documented metal intoxication which has been diagnosed using validated tests in appropriate biological samples.
Why?
Chelating drugs may have significant side effects, including dehydration, hypocalcaemia, kidney injury, liver enzyme elevations, hypotension, allergic reactions and essential mineral deficiencies. Inappropriate chelation, which may cost hundreds to thousands of dollars, risks these harms, as well as neurodevelopmental toxicity, teratogenicity and death.
Seems like a high price to pay for a problem that doesn’t exist.
But that’s not all. Colorado NDs are testing blood and saliva so they can diagnose and treat “adrenal fatigue,” another imaginary condition (as explained here by the Mayo Clinic) with dietary supplements and strict dietary regimens. They are testing for “food toxicity” because “if you have one or more these symptoms, there is a 95% probability you’ll benefit from a food toxicity test.” This is followed by an impressive list of symptoms that makes one wonder what wouldn’t be a symptom of “food toxicity.” They is “genomic testing to determine genetic need for specific nutrients,” another dubious test debunked by Quackwatch. They are testing blood to measure IgG response to a wide selection of foods which, in the alternative reality of alternative medicine, raises the possibility of digestive problems. (Scott Gavura: “These tests lack both a sound scientific rationale and evidence of effectiveness.”)
The Quack Full Employment Act
We can’t leave Colorado and head east without mentioning the Natural Health Care Consumer Protection Act, or, as I prefer to call it, the Quack Full Employment Act, which also made it through the legislature and was signed into law by the governor. Apparently, this was a sop thrown to the traditional naturopaths in exchange for their not opposing the naturopathic doctors getting their registration act passed. It allows traditional naturopaths to continue practicing without fear of being charged with practicing naturopathy without a license. Although they use many of the same methods, traditional naturopaths don’t make any claim they are able to practice primary care medicine.
The Quack Full Employment Act is another one of those “health freedom” laws designed to allow anyone to practice medicine. All you have to do is avoid claiming you are practicing medicine and using medical terms. You can use made-up terms, though, and made-up treatments. Here is my take on the bill before its unfortunate transformation into actual law:
Let’s put this all together and see just what would happen should this bill become law. Virtually anyone can set up shop without any education or training in health care whatsoever, or a worthless on-line certificate if they prefer, and practice complementary and alternative “health care and healing arts therapies and methods.” They can see anyone who walks in the door, no matter how sick. They can provide any unconventional disease diagnosis they want, including making up diseases and conditions that don’t exist. CAM practitioners can then proceed to practice virtually any “healing arts therapies and methods” they can dream up, including recommending various nostrums that they then sell to the consumer. They have no duty to provide informed consent, no education and training in recognizing the need to refer to a physician and no duty to refer to a physician. And even if the CAM practitioner is injuring his “clients” right and left, the medical board must sit on its hands and do nothing as long as the CAM practitioner complies with a few rules. The board has no authority whatsoever to step in and stop it. Unlike every licensed health care professional in Colorado, who must answer to a regulatory authority, the unlicensed practitioner answers to no one.
Now the takeover of Colorado by quackery is complete.
Organ repositioning: an update
Let’s zip across the country to Pennsylvania, where a bill to license naturopaths as primary care physicians passed the House and is now waiting to be assigned to a Senate committee. I covered the bill’s provisions in “Naturopathic Organ Repositioning Coming Soon to Pennsylvania?”
One thing not mentioned in that post was the bill’s sponsor Rep. Mark Mustio’s statement touting the fact that Cancer Treatment Centers of America employs naturopaths, a subject David Gorski thoroughly explored on Monday. Someone might wish to point out to Rep. Mustio that what CTCA permits its NDs to do is far narrower than what this bill would allow. CTCA NDs are under the supervision of medical doctors and allowed a very limited input into patient care. Even the ND-friendly CTCA doesn’t allow them to see patients on their own and certainly not in the capacity of a primary care practitioner. In fact, they don’t even refer to them as “doctors” or “physicians” in their naturopathic medicine section. They are “naturopathic clinicians” who are part of “your overall care team.” And I don’t see any reference to CTCA’s offering organ repositioning, fasting, detoxification, magnetic therapy, and any number of other naturopathic treatments NDs would be licensed to use if this bill passes.
As was true in Colorado before their registration act was passed, Pennsylvania naturopaths are already practicing naturopathy even without a license to do so. Their websites offer a window on what naturopathic practice would be like if they are licensed, likely multiplied by many more naturopaths attracted to one of the few states where they can legally practice. And a bill licensing them as primary care practitioners would surely expand the liberties they are already taking with their, shall we say, questionable practices.
Here we find ourselves in familiar territory. Pennsylvania naturopaths are advising patients to take dietary supplements, botanicals, and homeopathic remedies for their medical conditions despite overwhelming evidence that this is inappropriate. They are also “detoxifying” patients with fasts, as well as colon hydrotherapy and detox foot bath. They offer “flower essences to “energetically address emotional and mental issues.” One Pennsylvania naturopath claims to treat almost 50 different diseases and conditions on her website, including cancer, endometriosis, glaucoma, thyroid disease and HIV/AIDS. (I am not sure how one gets away with this without a license to practice a health care profession.) Another purports to have expertise in advising parents about childhood vaccinations, including holding this “workshop” for parents, even though naturopaths cannot legally administer vaccinations and naturopathic care is associated with lower vaccination rates and greater incidence of certain vaccine-preventable diseases.
A recent graduate of Bastyr, a naturopathic “medical school,” is a certified BioEnergetic Medicine Practitioner, an honor bestowed by a company selling homeopathic remedies and dietary supplements. A BioEnergetic Assessment is described as “one of the most exciting tools in the field of integrative health care because of its flexibility in identifying a specific and wide range of energetic imbalances.” From the company’s substantial offering of homeopathic remedies, nutritionals (glandulars, herbal cleanse formulas, enzymes and such), and botannicals (e.g., “spagyrically processed Chinese botanical blends”), I offer these examples of what a BioEnergetic Medicine Practitioner might use, after a properly conducted BioEnergetic Assessment, one assumes.
Circulopath: a complex blend of homeopathic remedies specifically designed to target the increase of circulatory flow (blood, lymph and interstitial fluid) in the tissue, organs and systems of the body.
And:
Adaptopath: an essential homeopathic remedy for boosting underpowered healing strategies by enhancing the body’s ability to adapt to stress.
As well, this naturopath employs a “Cellular Expansion Practitioner” whose clients “receive gentle and nurturing energy to address a wide array of health issues, including chronic pain, headaches, depression, weight loss, anxiety and infertility.” I’m no biologist, but “cellular expansion” doesn’t sound like a good idea at all. What if the cells expand too much?
Keep all of this in mind as you contemplate the Pennsylvania licensing bill’s definition of “naturopathic medicine:”
A system of primary health care practiced by doctors of naturopathic medicine for the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of human health conditions, injuries and diseases.
In other words, these naturopaths would become “primary care” doctors whose scope of practice covers the diagnosis and treatment of all patients, no matter what age and no matter their disease or condition. Can you imagine someone who thinks a BioEnergetic Assessment is a proper diagnostic tool and homeopathic remedies can treat cardiovascular disease seeing a patient as his primary care doctor?
And a few more things . . .
During my almost year-long monitoring of naturopathic licensing bills it has become increasingly clear that legislators are willing to unleash healthcare practitioners on the public who have no business seeing patients on their own, if they have any business seeing patients at all. This appears to be caused by two things.
One, they don’t have sufficient understanding of even basic science, which would otherwise make them instantly suspicious of any bill that included, for example, “magnetic therapy” or “organ repositioning” as a treatment. After all, one doesn’t need to be an organic chemist to understand why homeopathy cannot and does not work. Heck, I never even took chemistry and I understand it.
Two, they haven’t done the least bit of independent research to determine whether licensing naturopaths is in the best interest of the public health, safety and welfare. These bills are obviously written by naturopathic lobbyists and reasons for their adoption, if any are given at all, simply parrot the party line about naturopaths attending “accredited four year graduate medical programs,” their supposed ability to practice primary care, their use of “natural” therapies to support the “body’s intrinsic healing abilities,” and so on. Their constituents deserve better.

Naturopaths push for licensing in Massachusetts (again)
Jann Bellamy on January 17, 2013
Link
I have some good news and some bad news about a Massachusetts naturopathy practitioner licensing bill.
First the bad news: the bill passed both the Massachusetts House and Senate in December of last year.
Now, I am certainly no expert in the arcane workings of the Massachusetts legislature, but after doing a bit of research I’ve come to wonder if the way the bill passed was entirely above board. I’ll spare you most of the details, but here’s what I found out. See if you don’t agree with me that the whole thing smells a bit fishy.
What’s that smell?
(Please feel free to skip this part and move on to the good news section if you care only about what happened, but not how it happened.)
According to the Massachusetts Bar Association’s explanation of the legislative process, all legislative business of the 2011-2012 session had to be finished by July 31, 2012. The Senate passed a naturopathy licensing bill before the deadline. The Senate bill then went to the House for consideration. (In Massachusetts, they call it “registration,” but I am going to call it “licensing” because it is that is what most states would call it.) As of July 31, the House had amended the Senate’s version of the bill and had proceeded in its deliberations to a point two steps shy of passage. Had the House had enough time to complete this process and the bill had passed, the Senate would have to consider the bill again because of the House’s amendment. Thus, as of July 31, the bill, in its final form, had not been passed in either the House or the Senate. By law, neither legislative branch could meet again in formal session and the bill was dead. Or so we all thought. In fact, the Massachusetts Medical Society reported that the bill did not pass on its website.
Although prohibited from meeting in formal session after July 31, the House and Senate can meet in informal session until December 31. According to the Massachusetts Secretary of State, these informal sessions are designed for consideration of “non-controversial” matters only. Under the Senate’s Rules,
In the case of an informal session, only reports of committees and matters not giving rise to formal motion or debate shall be considered.
(Emphasis in original.) The House has a similar rule.
But a very odd thing happened on December 27. The House, in an informal session, went through the next-to-the-last step required to pass its amended version of the bill. On December 31, the House actually enacted the naturopathy licensing legislation, again in informal session. Also on December 31, the Senate took up and concurred in the House’s amendment to the bill and enacted it, both done in informal session.
I don’t know what the Massachusetts legislature’s definition of “non-controversial” is, but apparently it does not include a matter that has been taken up and defeated in 11 previous legislative sessions, thanks in no small part to the efforts of our own Kimball Atwood. M.D., whose fight against licensing is chronicled on SBM. If this is “non-controversial,” I’d like to see what might fit their definition of “controversial.”
By law, debate on the bill was possible at any of these four events taking place at the end of December. Presumably, had debate actually occurred (which, remember, is forbidden in an informal session) those who opposed the bill could have convinced others not to vote in favor of it and it could have been defeated. And I have to wonder whether a quorum was present at any of these sessions, occurring as they did two days after Christmas and on New Year’s Eve.
Like I said, a bit fishy.
And now for the good news
Fortunately, this ploy didn’t work. Gov. Deval Patrick had the good sense to veto the legislation. But the naturopaths will be back. They always are.
It is worth a look at the failed legislation because it demonstrates a typical naturopathic licensing bill in what many people would likely consider its most benign form because it purports to limit their scope of practice in several ways I describe below. But, as we shall soon see, there is still plenty of room for mischief.
First, by way of background, a little bit about the two types of naturopaths. Traditional naturopaths (those without “N.D.” degrees) usually do not operate under the pretense that they practice medicine or can diagnose or treat disease. Some states allow them to do their thing and some don’t. Whether they should be allowed to practice at all is a subject for another day.
The naturopaths pushing for state licensing are those with “naturopathic doctor” degrees. By falling for the unproven assertion that having a “doctorate” in “naturopathic medicine” affords N.D.s the education and training to operate as real doctors, N.D. licensing bills give N.D.s a broad scope of practice. Some states, such as Oregon, permit N.D.s to practice as primary care physicians. (PCPs) Other states permit them a more limited scope of practice. Practice as PCPs is their goal in all 50 states, but they will take what they can get and later return for more. Requiring an N.D. degree prevents traditional naturopaths from practicing at all, which makes for an interesting turf war between the two groups. A big incentive for licensing in more states is the Affordable Care Act, which prohibits insurer discrimination against any licensed health care provider.
Under the Massachusetts bill, N.D.s can’t refer to themselves as “physicians” or claim to provide “primary care,” although I imagine those distinctions are lost on a majority of the public. It also includes the usual requirements of a degree from an accredited naturopathic school, passing a licensing exam, continuing education, and a board to oversee the practice of naturopathy, all false assurances of public protection. As Edzard Ernst, M.D., says, “the most meticulous regulation of nonsense must still result in nonsense.”
In an apparent attempt to address naturopathic opposition to vaccination, the Massachusetts bill requires:
mandatory tracking and documentation of the immunization status of a patient under 18 . . . and the required referral of such patients to a primary care or collaborative care physician where evidence exists that the individual has not been immunized.
You would think the necessity of this sort of language would raise a big red flag in the minds of legislators. After all, wouldn’t a thinking person wonder why a group wanting to be licensed as “doctors” would oppose one of the most successful public health measures of all time? Wouldn’t opposition to vaccination of children and the avoidance of vaccine-preventable disease imply a certain deficiency in the education and training of a health care provider? And wouldn’t that raise the further thought: “I wonder what else about the prevention and treatment of disease does this person not understand”?
Apparently not.
The bill prohibits naturopaths from prescribing, dispensing or administering drugs, which prevents their using some of their favorite treatments, such as IV vitamins and minerals and chelation therapy. While we’re on this subject let’s take a brief look at the unfortunate results of allowing naturopaths the privilege of giving IV infusions.
IV nutrient bags: a brief digression
In Arizona, licensed naturopathic doctors, who must have a degree from a naturopathic college, can administer intravenous nutrients, vitamins and minerals. (They can also prescribe and administer some drugs.) Last week, the Phoenix CBS affiliate ran a story about a naturopathic doctor, Carol Spooner, who is offering IV “nutrient bags” of vitamins and minerals for flu prevention. Because these nutrients go straight to the bloodstream the benefits are almost immediate, according to the story. Spooner explains that
These vitamins and minerals are the hammers and nails the body understands to put back, put itself back together again. . . For anybody, regardless of whether they’ve had flu shots or not, these IV nutrients work very well.
At a hefty price too. The nutrient bags are $100 to $200 a pop and take up to an hour to administer. Spooner says that one bag carries a healthy person through the flu season while “others may need a few more.”
Remember, folks, these are the people who want to be licensed as primary care physicians in all 50 states, according to the National Association of Naturopathic Physicians.
Back to Massachusetts
Despite attempts to limit naturopathic practice and make them toe the line on vaccinations, this bill nevertheless buys into pseudoscientific concepts and unproven treatments typical of naturopaths. Unfortunately, the bill also gives naturopaths plenty of opportunity to employ them even though the pretense that they are PCPs has been taken away.
The purpose of “naturopathic health care” is, according to the bill,
to support, stimulate or supplement the human body’s own natural self-healing processes.
Having accepted the pleasant-sounding but essentially meaningless concept that the body has a “natural self-healing process” which requires support, stimulation or supplementation, the bill fastens onto the equally nonsensical corollary that there are means available to accomplish this very task and that naturopaths are just the persons to provide them. How? Through “the use of education, nutrition, natural medicines and therapies and other modalities.”
I don’t know about you, but “other modalities” seems disconcertingly unlimited to me. This unbridled discretion is reinforced by a definition of “naturopathic health care” that “include[s]” but is not “limited to:”
dispensing, administering, ordering and prescribing natural medicines of mineral, animal or botanical origin, including food products or extracts, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, digestive aids, natural hormones, plant substances, homeopathic preparations, natural antibiotics and topical medicines and nonprescription drugs, therapeutic devices and barrier contraceptives to prevent or treat illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body [and] the use of manual mechanical manipulation of body structures or tissues [and] the use of naturopathic physical medicine to restore normal physiological functioning the human body.
So, if it comes from a plant, an animal or a mineral and it’s not a prescription drug, with manipulation and physical medicine thrown in for good measure, it’s o.k. Effectiveness and safety be damned.
The bill defines “naturopathic health care” as:
a system of health care practices for the prevention, evaluation and treatment of illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body . . . .
Thus, while the means N.D.s can use may be curtailed in this bill, the ability to diagnose and treat any condition or disease is not. The danger here is that their education and training is nothing like that of an M.D. primary care physician and does not prepare them for the wide range of undifferentiated symptoms they will encounter in the population of patients they will see. For one thing, M.D. primary care physicians spend at least three years after graduation caring for patients with a variety of illnesses, some of them gravely ill, supervised and in a hospital setting. N.D.s do not. They may very well be prevented from claiming they practice primary care medicine or calling themselves a physician. This does nothing to prevent patients with conditions N.D.s have no business diagnosing and treating from coming to see them.
This illusion of diagnostic ability is furthered by a provision in the bill including in “the practice of naturopathic health care”:
the use of physical examinations and the ordering of clinical, laboratory and radiological diagnostic procedures from licensed clinics or laboratories to evaluate injuries, illnesses and conditions in the human body.
I will leave it to others to evaluate naturopaths’ level of understanding of conventional lab tests and x-rays. But it is worth noting that the Textbook of Natural Medicine (2013), the foundational text of naturopathic education and practice, has an entire section (Section 2) titled “Supplementary Diagnostic Procedures.” I take “supplementary” to mean “not used in convential medicine, at least not in this way.” The twenty-two chapters include several tests for detection of the ubiquitous “toxins” naturopaths believe are causing ill health in us all. Other tests address “functional nutritional analysis,” a standard of “functional medicine,” and “immune function assessment,” because, as we know, naturopathy is all about “boosting the immune system,” another fuzzy and essentially meaningless term they use. In addition to being unnecessary themselves, the results of these tests can lead to all sorts of unnecessary treatments, such as vitamins, minerals and “detoxification.”
Naturopathic treatments
I’ve already mentioned nutrient bags for flu prevention. While the Massachusetts bill would not allow IV administration of vitamins, minerals and such, there is, as I said, plenty of opportunity for mischief. Let’s look at just a couple of the nonsensical and potentially dangerous treatments currently being used by naturopaths, both of which would have been within their scope of practice had this legislation not been vetoed by Gov. Patrick.
Fresh from the website of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, in honor of Cervical Health Awareness Month, is this advice on “Management of Cervical Dysplasia and Human Papillomavirus.” The article starts innocently enough with standard advice on the subject from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and another medical group. It then goes off the rails with advice on “natural” treatment of HPV and cervical dysplasia. Interestingly, while it discusses prevention, the article wholly fails to mention the HPV vaccine.
Here I’ll focus on just two of the treatments promoted in this article. In addition to recommendations citing evidence for other treatments which no responsible physician would regard as sufficient, “green tea suppositories” are touted as “effective for cervical dysplasia and HPV.” And the evidence? One study. As the article itself admits, this study used two chemical components of green tea, not green tea suppositories, and looked at its effect on cells. Not humans, cells in a laboratory. Nevertheless green tea suppositories are “effective for cervical dysplasia and HPV.”
Another recommended treatment: vaginal depletion packs. These packs are made up of vitamins, minerals and several oils derived from plants. The evidence of their effectiveness for “mild dysplasia and/or high risk HPV,” their intended use? None cited. However, they “have been used since the 1800s,” which is, of course, an excellent reason to continue their use despite not having any evidence of safety or effectiveness. Another reason is that some of the ingredients are “effective against many microbial pathogens.” Not necessarily these microbial pathogens, but “many.”
The article ends with this observation:
Critics of natural medicine say there is no published evidence that these options work or are backed in [sic] science. There are several recent published articles explaining the science and patient outcomes. One can be found at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19679625.
One? Where are the others? In any event, if you click on the reference you find a single case study. As all regular SBM readers know, a case study is an anecdote, a single report about a single patient. It is not evidence of anything and it certainly doesn’t support the notion that “these options work or are backed in science.”
“Backed in science”?
As I have mentioned before, I have absolutely no training in science. I took one biology and one general science course in high school. I took geology in college. That’s it. Yet I can figure out that the naturopathic treatment recommendations in this article don’t have sufficient evidence of safety and effectiveness. Why can’t they?
Whether naturopaths are already licensed in your state or it’s just a possibility, your state legislators need to know the facts about naturopathic practice. They won’t unless you take the time to tell them.

Here we go again: A bill licensing naturopaths rears its ugly head in Michigan
The goal of organized naturopathy is to achieve licensure for naturopaths in all 50 states. Unfortunately, that means they have to come through Michigan, which is my state. This means the naturopaths, having failed to pass a licensure bill last year, are back to try again. They’re a lot like the Terminator that way. They never, ever give up.
David Gorski on February 4, 2013
Link
If I’ve pointed it out once, I’ve pointed it out a thousand times. Naturopathy is a cornucopia of almost every quackery you can think of. Be it homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophical medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine, it’s hard to think of a single form of pseudoscientific medicine and quackery that naturopathy doesn’t embrace or at least tolerate. Indeed, as I’ve retorted before to apologists for naturopathy who claim that it is scientific, naturopathy can never be scientific as long as you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy and naturopaths embrace homeopathy. Unfortunately, naturopaths have over the years been having some success in persuading state legislatures to license naturopaths, in some cases even giving them the privilege of being considered primary care practitioners. It’s part of an organized effort, too, and I don’t expect that effort to let up. True, the governor of Massachusetts did veto a naturopathic licensing bill that came across his desk recently, but no one following this issue expects the naturopaths to let up. As Jann Bellamy put it, the naturopaths will be back. They always are.
Indeed, in the wake of the failure to pass a naturopathic licensing bill in Massachusetts, Michael Cronin, the president of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) lamented:
This brings up many thoughts and emotions for me. I feel disappointment over a legislative process that seems slow and unfair. And there is anger at a process that placates the desires of the Massachusetts Medical Society over serving the health needs of the public and the desire of the Commonwealth.
But he also brags:
There are currently licensing laws in 16 states (up from 5 in 1978), the District of Columbia, the United States territories of Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, and 5 Canadian provinces. We have 7 healthy, accredited North American colleges and there are now 43 state associations.
And urges his fellow naturopaths:
I send the highest kudos to our ND brothers and sisters in Massachusetts. May you heal your wounds and come out fighting.
In the meantime, unfortunately, they seem to be coming out fighting in my home state of Michigan. I just learned from Jann Bellamy over the weekend that a naturopathic licensing bill has been introduced for consideration by the Michigan legislature. I’m referring to Michigan House Bill 4152 (2013), which is now in the House Committee on Health Policy. Apparently it was introduced on January 31 by Representative Lisa Posthumus Lyons, who is the Assistant Floor Majority Leader and represents District 86, which encompasses a rural area the Lower Peninsula east of Grand Rapids. I couldn’t find anything about her bill on her House website, but I did find a Facebook post by her congratulating Kelly Hassberger for opening her new Naturopathic Health Clinic in Grand Rapids. One notes that this particular news story notes that Hassberger focuses on “homeopathic medicine,” which shows just how far Lyon’s acceptance and even promotion of quackery goes.
There is, however, a rather interesting bit of information in this story:
While naturopathic doctors are licensed practitioners in the state of Arizona, they are not in Michigan.
Hassberger is working with The Michigan Association of Naturopathic Physicians and state legislators to get practitioners who graduated from accredited doctorate programs in naturopathic medicine to practice as primary care physicians in the state.
State Reps. Lisa Posthumus, Ellen Lipton and Joseph Haveman introduced House Bill 5594 to the House in May 2012.
The proposed bill outlines what would be required to be a licensed naturopathic physician in Michigan, including defining what an accredited naturopathic medical program entails, creating a naturopathic medical medical board, as well as defining the scope of practice for naturopathic physicians in Michigan.
“It would give us back the ability to use the skills we are trained in, including IV therapy among others, as well as give us the right to accept insurance, run lab testing, diagnose and prescribe prescription drugs when needed,” Hassberger said. “I want to give the public an understanding of the differences between my training and other programs in Michigan. My goal is to be here and develop awareness and help to get that bill through.”
So this is not the first bite at the apple that Lyons has taken. Notice how Hassberger refers to “IV therapy.” Naturopaths shouldn’t be let anywhere near an intravenous line, much less IV therapy, because in the hands of naturopaths IV therapy usually means quackery like high dose intravenous vitamin C or chelation therapy.
Sadly, this is a bipartisan effort, with Lyons being the Republican half of the not-so-dynamic duo of legislators, and Ellen Cogen Lipton being the Democratic half, representing the Michigan 27th House district, which represents Detroit suburbs such as Ferndale, Royal Oak Township, Oak Park, Huntington Woods, and Hazel Park. I know some of these towns. For instance, Ferndale is known as one of the “hipper” cities in the Detroit metropolitan area; it’s not surprising to me that a Representative whose district encompasses Ferndale would be sympathetic to naturopathy to the point of being willing to make repeated attempts to pass a bill that would license naturopaths.
Let’s take a look at MI HB 4152.
The bill defines “naturopathy” and “naturopathic physicians” thusly:
(3) “NATUROPATHIC MEDICINE” MEANS A SYSTEM OF PRACTICE THAT IS BASED ON THE NATURAL HEALING CAPACITY OF INDIVIDUALS FOR THE DIAGNOSIS, TREATMENT, AND PREVENTION OF DISEASES
(4) “NATUROPATHIC PHYSICIAN” MEANS AN INDIVIDUAL WHO ENGAGES IN THE PRACTICE OF NATUROPATHIC MEDICINE AND WHO IS REQUIRED TO BE LICENSED OR OTHERWISE AUTHORIZED UNDER THIS PART TO ENGAGE IN THAT PRACTICE.
The wag in me can’t help but point out how stupid this definition is. Let me just put it this way. Science-based medicine relies on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of diseases. Think about it. Setting broken bones would be useless if the body weren’t able to heal itself naturally. Surgery itself relies on the ability of the body to heal itself; otherwise cutting into the body to rearrange its anatomy for therapeutic intent would be the gravest of folly. The very definition of naturopathy is a false dichotomy between conventional medicine and “natural healing.”
So what does this law authorize “naturopathic physicians” to do? The list is disturbing:
(A) ORDER AND PERFORM PHYSICAL AND LABORATORY EXAMINATIONS FOR DIAGNOSTICPURPOSES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PHLEBOTOMY, CLINICAL LABORATORY TESTS,ORIFICIAL EXAMINATIONS, OR PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION TESTS.(B) ORDER DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING STUDIES.(C) DISPENSE, ADMINISTER, ORDER, OR PRESCRIBE OR PERFORM ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:
(I) FOOD, EXTRACTS OF FOOD, NUTRACEUTICALS, VITAMINS, AMINO ACIDS, MINERALS,ENZYMES, BOTANICALS AND THEIR EXTRACTS, BOTANICAL MEDICINES, HOMEOPATHICMEDICINES, ALL DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS, OR NONPRESCRIPTION DRUGS AS DEFINED BY THEFEDERAL FOOD, DRUG, AND COSMETIC ACT, 21 USC 301 TO 399D.(II) PRESCRIPTION OR NONPRESCRIPTION MEDICINES AS DESIGNATED BY THENATUROPATHIC FORMULARY COUNCIL.(III) HOT OR COLD HYDROTHERAPY; NATUROPATHIC PHYSICAL MEDICINE;ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY; OR THERAPEUTIC EXERCISE.(IV) DEVICES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THERAPEUTIC DEVICES, BARRIERCONTRACEPTION, OR DURABLE MEDICAL EQUIPMENT.(V) HEALTH EDUCATION OR HEALTH COUNSELING.(VI) REPAIR AND CARE INCIDENTAL TO SUPERFICIAL LACERATIONS OR ABRASIONS.(VII) MUSCULOSKELETAL MANIPULATION.(D) UTILIZE ROUTES OF ADMINISTRATION THAT INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, ORAL,NASAL, AURICULAR, OCULAR, RECTAL, VAGINAL, TRANSDERMAL, INTRADERMAL,SUBCUTANEOUS, INTRAVENOUS, OR INTRAMUSCULAR CONSISTENT WITH HIS OR HERNATUROPATHIC EDUCATION AND TRAINING.(E) OTHER NATUROPATHIC THERAPIES AS APPROVED BY THE BOARD.
I suppose I should be relieved that the law would not allow naturopaths (I refuse to use the term “naturopathic physician”) to prescribe controlled substances. administer ionizing radioactive substances, perform chiropractic adjustments, do acupuncture, or perform very minor surgical procedures, or to do anything encompassed in the scope of practice of physicians.
Not surprisingly, the Michigan Association of Naturopathic Physicians is very much behind this effort. Hilariously, the MANP frames their effort as being driven by a concern protecting patients, arguing that “Without licensure, it is difficult for health consumers to discern between natural health consultants and naturopathic doctors. State licensure is the only way to protect the public by providing regulation to verify the credentials of their naturopathic physicians.” Never mind that those credentials are fairy dust, what Harriet Hall so aptly described as “tooth fairy science.” Seriously, on its blog, the MANP is referencing articles on Mike Adams’ NaturalNews.com, which is about as good a sign that it is not science-based as I can think of. Be that as it may, the MANP also argues that if the Michigan legislature doesn’t pass a naturopathic licensing law, then Michigan residents seeking “natural healing” will go across state lines to get it.
Funny, they say that as if it were a bad thing.
It would appear that there’s a situation here that is in desperate need of monitoring and action in my state, and I plan on doing just that. Here’s hoping that in 2013 the fate of this bill is the same as it was in 2012: Oblivion.

Nobody licenses quacks in my state! HB 4531 and the licensing of naturopaths in Michigan
David Gorski on May 16, 2016
Link


Over the years, I’ve taken care of women with locally advanced breast cancer so advanced that it’s eroded through the skin, forming huge, nasty ulcers filled with stinky dead cancer tissue that’s outgrown its blood supply, leaving the patient in chronic pain. If the patient is fortunate, her cancer has not metastasized beyond her axillary lymph nodes (the lymph nodes under her arm), and her life might still be saved by a combination of chemotherapy, radical surgery, and radiation. If the patient is not fortunate, either the cancer has metastasized and she is doomed or hasn’t metastasized yet, but it’s invaded into the chest wall and the nerves in her axilla (the structures under the arm), making it impossible to remove surgically but not likely to kill her any time soon. In the latter case, chronic pain, infection, and blood loss is what the patient will look forward to until the cancer either metastasizes or invades a vital structure. Fortunately, I’ve only seen a handfull of these patients over the last 20 years. Fortunately, the number of such patients I’ve seen and taken care of has been small.
I fear that, before long, I’m going to bee seeing a lot more of them. Leave it to Jann Bellamy to wake me up to that possibility.
I’m referring, of course, to her post last week about yet another attempt by naturopaths to expand their scope of practice. Worse, this is happening in my state through Michigan House Bill 4531, which has been approved by the Michigan Committee on Health Policy and referred to the full House for consideration. Yes, of these patients I’ve seen with horrific neglected breast cancers, at least half of them had relied on naturopaths before they came to the attention of real oncologists and surgeons. The last time I wrote about naturopaths trying to expand their scope of practice in my state was in 2013 in the form of a bill that was not as broad as HB 4531, namely HB 4152. Fortunately, it went nowhere and, in contrast to HB 4531, didn’t even make it out of the Committee on Health Policy.
Although Jann has already ably discussed the bill and occasional Science-Based Medicine (SBM) contributor Peter Lipson has referred to naturopaths as fake doctors in white coats (which is true), as well as why naturopathy is unscientific and how he as a primary care internist not infrequently has to clean up the messes left when local naturopaths treat patients incompetently, this is my state, and I can’t help but chime in myself. What I will try to do is to predict what the potential consequences will be if HB 4531 passes and expands the scope of practice to be nearly as broad as that of MDs practicing primary care medicine. I will do that by looking at real world examples of naturopathic shenanigans and disasters both within our very own state, because these are the people with whom the reins of primary care will be shared if HB 4531 were to pass.
Naturopathy: The pseudoscience that is “natural medicine”
We at SBM have written extensively about naturopathy in the past. Perhaps the definitive explanation of why naturopathy is pseudoscience and quackery was written 13 years ago by Kimball Atwood (who, alas, no longer blogs for SBM) for Medscape and entitled “Naturopathy: A Critical Appraisal.” You can also find much more about naturopathy from this very blog.
Naturopaths like to represent naturopathy as “natural medicine.” In reality, naturopathy is the modern day iteration of the 19th century “natural living” movement in Germany. Early naturopaths objected to contemporary science-based medicine, particularly germ theory and vaccinations, instead advocating the “water cure,” fasting, herbs, homeopathy (or, as I like to call it, The One Quackery To Rule Them All), colonic “detoxification,” and other popular methods of the era. Unfortunately, little has changed in naturopathic practice in 150 years, although naturopaths are much better at cloaking their quackery in scientific-seeming trappings, and some of them have embraced laboratory tests in a big way as part of their embrace of the dubious specialty of functional medicine.
Despite the efforts of modern naturopaths to argue that their profession is scientific, in reality naturopathy is now, as it was in the 19th century, rooted in prescientific vitalism. Basically, naturopathy is based on a belief in the “healing power of nature“:
The body has an inherent ability to establish, maintain, and restore health. The healing process is ordered and intelligent; nature heals through the response of the life force. The physician’s role is to facilitate this process, to identify and remove obstacles to health and recovery, and to establish or restore a healthy internal and external environment.
For those of you who aren’t familiar with the lingo, any time you hear someone refer to the “life force,” you’re looking at vitalism, the idea that there is some sort of mysterious, yes, “life force” that is present in living matter and makes it alive. In essence, vitalism is the philosophical doctrine that states that life has a quality (the “life force,” “vital force,” or any of a number of other terms such as “life energy”) independent of physical and chemical laws, such as an immaterial soul. Many forms of alternative medicine are based on vitalism. For instance, chiropractic posits an “innate intelligence” whose properties are very similar to the “vital force.” This “innate intelligence” flows from the central nervous system but can be blocked by subluxations, which chiropractors claim to relieve. Acupuncture claims that sticking needles into “meridians” through which qi (the life energy or force) flows will redirect the flow and relieve symptoms and/or cure disease. Reiki practitioners claim that they can direct life energy from the “universal source” into patients for healing effect, which is why I like to say that if you replace the term “universal source” with “God” you have faith healing. Basically all “energy medicine” claims that its practitioners can somehow manipulate “life energy” to healing effect. Not surprisingly, naturopathy embraces pretty much all of these modalities, and more.
Particularly popular among naturopaths is a belief that disease is caused by “toxins.” These toxins are seldom validated by science. In many cases, they aren’t even identified. Yet, “detoxification” is a major theme in naturopathic treatments, with unscientific and sometimes dangerous treatments, such as chelation therapy (to “detoxify” heavy metal overload) and colon cleanses, including the infamous coffee enemas, being advocated to help patients “detoxify.”
Basically, if you peruse some of the links above (and, as you will see as I examine what naturopaths really advertise on their websites), you will learn that naturopathy is nothing more than a hodge-podge of mostly unscientific treatment modalities based on vitalism and other prescientific notions of disease. As a result, typical naturopaths are more than happy in essence to “pick one from column A and one from column B” when it comes to pseudoscience, mixing and matching treatments including traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, herbalism, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophic medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine.
Within naturopathy, there are two types of practitioners, traditional naturopaths and “naturopathic physicians.” In reality, from my perspective there is little difference between the two, other than that “naturopathic physicians” have graduated from “accredited” schools of naturopathic medicine and hold the “ND” degree for “naturopathic doctor” (or, as I like to call it, “not a doctor”). Both naturopaths and NDs embrace a wide variety of quackery, which they mix with some sensible lifestyle and diet advice, which is “rebranded” as somehow being unique to naturopathy. In a way, NDs are worse in that they are much better than traditional naturopaths at cloaking their activities under the mantle of science and have added to their armamentarium a wide variety of unproven or disproven diagnoses and treatments that sound medical, such as treatments for “adrenal fatigue” and “chronic yeast overgrowth“.
Despite their affinity for non-science-based medical systems, naturopaths crave the imprimatur of science. As a result, they desperately try to represent what they do as being science-based, and they’ve even set up research institutes, much like the departments, divisions, and institutes devoted to “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) that have cropped up on the campuses of legitimate (and prestigious) medical schools, academic medical centers, and even community hospitals, like so many weeds poking through the cracks in the edifice of science-based medicine. Naturopaths also really, really don’t like it when they encounter criticism that their “discipline” is not science-based. I discovered this a year and a half ago when I managed to get a review article on the pseudoscience of “integrative oncology” published in a high profile journal.
This incident was particularly instructive, as well, because a lot of the criticism came from physicians who have become advocates of integrative oncology, who particularly objected to my criticism of homeopathy as pseudoscience. Their responses boiled down to, “Oh, no, we would never approve of the use of homeopathy. We know it’s total pseudoscience.” I responded by pointing out that naturopaths (one of whom co-authored the Society for Integrative Oncology’s (SIO) “evidence-based” guidelines for breast cancer care) learn homeopathy as an integral part of their training and that, indeed, they are tested on it as part of the NPLEX, the naturopathic licensing examination. I further responded by pointing out that one of the co-authors of their guidelines (Dugald Seely) was the principal investigator for an N-of-1 study of homeopathic treatment of fatigue in patients receiving chemotherapy. Basically, real, honest-to-goodness MDs, who have fallen under the spell of “integrative medicine” and are happy to collaborate with naturopaths, don’t even know what naturopathy is or what naturopaths really do.
Oddly enough, I haven’t seen a retort from the SIO yet. Maybe they need to speak with Britt Marie Hermes, a real naturopathic doctor who realized how full of quackery naturopathy is and left it behind.
Unfortunately, because of the lack of knowledge most people (and physicians) have about what naturopathy really is and how naturopaths really practice, videos like this Indiegogo campaign for the Michigan Association of Naturopathic Physicians (MANP) are effective:
As you will see, the shiny happy video above is a massive distortion of what naturopaths are and do.
What HB 4531 does
Before you can understand why those of us in Michigan who support SBM are alarmed by this bill, it’s necessary to take a look at it. Unfortunately, naturopathy is a licensed medical profession in 17 states, the District of Columbia, and the United States territories of Puerto Rico and the United States Virgin Islands. Jann explained that, if passed, SB 4531 would give naturopaths in Michigan one of the broadest scopes of practice in the US, essentially equaling that of a family practice MD or DO.
As Jann recounted, HB 4531 defines “naturopathic medicine” as:
…a system of practice that is based on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease.
And I can’t help but recount and revise my retort to that definition, which is simple. The invocation of “natural healing capacity” as something that naturopaths uniquely utilize to treat disease is nonsense. Think of it this way. Science-based medicine relies on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of diseases. Setting broken bones would be pointless if the body weren’t able to heal itself naturally and knit the two bone ends together. Surgery itself (my specialty) relies on the ability of the body to heal itself; otherwise cutting into the body to rearrange its anatomy for therapeutic intent would be the gravest of folly. The very definition of naturopathy is a false dichotomy between conventional medicine and “natural healing.” Of course, as I discussed above, what naturopaths mean by “the natural healing capacity” is a mystical vitalism that is based in prescientific religious belief systems about life and disease.
That being said, HB 4531 would amend 1978 PA 368, entitled “Public health code,” (MCL 333.1101 to 333.25211) by adding section 16348a and part 186 to create a board of naturopathic medicine to license and regulate naturopaths. In doing so, HB 4531 would also grant naturopaths who have graduated from an “accredited” naturopathy school (like, for instance, Bastyr University), attained the degree of “doctor of naturopathic medicine” or “doctor of naturopathy,” and have passed the NPLEX the authority to diagnose, treat and prevent disease in any patient, of any age, with any disease or condition. Here is the key passage:
SEC. 18615. A NATUROPATHIC PHYSICIAN MAY DO ANY OF THE FOLLOWING, CONSISTENT WITH HIS OR HER NATUROPATHIC EDUCATION AND TRAINING:
(A) ORDER AND PERFORM PHYSICAL AND LABORATORY EXAMINATIONS FOR DIAGNOSTIC PURPOSES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PHLEBOTOMY, CLINICAL LABORATORY TESTS, ORIFICIAL EXAMINATIONS, OR PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION TESTS.
(B) ORDER DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING STUDIES.
(C) DISPENSE, ADMINISTER, ORDER, OR PRESCRIBE OR PERFORM ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:(i) FOOD, EXTRACTS OF FOOD, NUTRACEUTICALS, VITAMINS, AMINO ACIDS, MINERALS, ENZYMES, BOTANICALS AND THEIR EXTRACTS, BOTANICAL MEDICINES, HOMEOPATHIC MEDICINES, ALL DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS, OR NONPRESCRIPTION DRUGS AS DEFINED BY THE FEDERAL FOOD, DRUG, AND COSMETIC ACT, 21 USC 301 TO 399D.(ii) PRESCRIPTION OR NONPRESCRIPTION MEDICINES AS DESIGNATED BY THE NATUROPATHIC FORMULARY COUNCIL.(iii) HOT OR COLD HYDROTHERAPY; NATUROPATHIC PHYSICAL MEDICINE; ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY; OR THERAPEUTIC EXERCISE.(iv) DEVICES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THERAPEUTIC DEVICES, BARRIER CONTRACEPTION, OR DURABLE MEDICAL EQUIPMENT.(v) HEALTH EDUCATION OR HEALTH COUNSELING.(vi) REPAIR AND CARE INCIDENTAL TO SUPERFICIAL LACERATIONS OR ABRASIONS.(vii) MUSCULOSKELETAL MANIPULATION.
(D) UTILIZE ROUTES OF ADMINISTRATION THAT INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, ORAL, NASAL, AURICULAR, OCULAR, RECTAL, VAGINAL, TRANSDERMAL, INTRADERMAL, SUBCUTANEOUS, INTRAVENOUS, OR INTRAMUSCULAR CONSISTENT WITH HIS OR HER NATUROPATHIC EDUCATION AND TRAINING
(E) OTHER NATUROPATHIC THERAPIES AS APPROVED BY THE BOARD.
Basically, the only things NDs couldn’t do that MDs can if HB 4531 were to pass would be to prescribe controlled substances; do surgical procedures other than office procedures as described elsewhere in the bill (such as suturing small lacerations or doing punch biopsies of the skin); administer general or spinal anesthetics; use laser devices or ionizing radiation therapeutically; perform surgical procedures involving the eye, ear, tendons, nerves, veins, or arteries; and, of course, chiropractic manipulation (which would intrude on the turf of licensed chiropractors). Basically, in practice, with the exception of the power to prescribe controlled substances, HB 4531 would grant naturopaths roughly the same scope of practice as primary care physicians have.
As Jann pointed out, the naturopathic board proposed in the bill would consist of three naturopaths, two licensed MDs or DOs, and two public members who have never been licensed health care professionals and do not have any financial or legal interest in “naturopathic education, business, or practice.” Jann is correct to be concerned that the naturopaths on the board outnumber real physicians and that the governor could potentially easily be influenced to appoint as members from the general public people who are sympathetic to alternative medicine.
How naturopaths in Michigan actually practice
In her post, Jann pointed out how naturopaths practice, but only briefly looked at Michigan naturopaths. Since I live in the actual state, I really wanted to look more closely at naturopaths whose patients I might see or who might see my patients with breast cancer. Having over the years seen women with locally advanced, neglected cancers who had been relying on naturopaths to treat their disease until it started ulcerating through the skin to produce a painful, bleeding, stinking mess, I am very concerned with the legitimization of quackery that Michigan HB 4531 would produce. So I perused the MANP website to find NDs in Michigan, and then I perused their websites to see what they advertise. Of course, I included NDs that I have already discussed before, in particular Doug Cutler, who runs the largest naturopathic practice I know of in the state, Cutler Integrative Medicine.
Let’s take a look at a few naturopathic practices in Michigan, in alphabetic order, and see the sorts of practitioners whose scope of practice would be widened to treat pretty much anyone as a primary care provider:
Cutler Integrative Medicine, Bingham Farms. Doug Cutler is the granddaddy of Michigan naturopaths and runs what is, to my knowledge (and I could be mistaken, but there’s no doubt that Cutler is very successful), the largest naturopathic practice in the Detroit area, if not in the state. He is well-known nationally among naturopaths and was a major contributor to the discussions within the NatChat naturopathic discussion group whose contents were leaked on two occasions. He is very, very antivaccine (in my opinion), and, if you have any doubt that this is true, please go and read some of his comments in NatChat about “toxins” and a variant of the “too many, too soon” trope. Of course, the vast majority of naturopaths are antivaccine, with very few exceptions, and some of those exceptions still flirt with being antivaccine.
He offers constitutional and colon hydrotherapy; applied kinesiology; The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy); Nambudripad Allergy Elimination Technique (NAET); and, of course, TrueRife Technology. I had never heard of NAET before; so I looked it up. Nambudripad’s Allergy Elimination Technique is described as a “non-invasive, drug free, natural solution to alleviate allergies of all types and intensities using a blend of selective energy balancing, testing and treatment procedures from acupuncture/acupressure, allopathy, chiropractic, nutritional, and kinesiological disciplines of medicine.” In other words, NAET is clearly nonsense. As for TrueRife, Rife is a form of electricity quackery whose proponents use to treat a variety of diseases, including cancer, with electromagnetic impulses at different frequencies. There is no compelling scientific evidence that it is efficacious for treating any disease or condition, including cancer.
Healing Paths Naturopathic Care, Flint. This is the practice of Michelle Hoppe, ND. She offers (of course) clinical nutrition, even repeating “Let thy food be thy medicine and thy medicine be thy food”; botanical medicine; traditional Chinese medicine, particularly acupuncture; The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy); and NAET as well.
Holistic Care Approach, Grand Rapids. This practice includes several practitioners, but the naturopath there is AnnAlisa Behling, ND. Behling touts her training in homeopathy, hydrotherapy, oriental medicine, naturopathic manipulation, low level laser therapy, physical medicine, botanical medicine, as well as psychological and lifestyle counseling. She treats, among other conditions. She also treats “parasites” and, of course, candida, both of which represent favorite fake diseases in naturopathy, just like adrenal fatigue.
Huron Valley Naturopathic Clinic, Ann Arbor. This is the practice of Michelle Loewe, ND. Sadly, Loewe is apparently employed at nearby Madonna University, “where she teaches workshops to teachers on integrating nutrition and movement into the curriculum to enhance student wellness and academic achievement.” She offers the usual services, such as “nutrition”; herbal medicines; “detoxification” and fasting; The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy); and hydrotherapy, among others.
Naturopathic Health Services, Clarkston, MI. This is the practice of Nancy Caruso, ND. She offers a typical roster of naturopathic therapies, first and foremost being nutrition. Of course, when a naturopath talks about using “nutrition” to treat disease, she doesn’t mean what a physician does. She means using “personalized diets, vitamin and mineral supplements, and enzyme therapies are implemented in each treatment plan.” Caruso also offers homeopathy (again, The One Quackery To Rule Them All); biotherapeutic drainage to ‘restore normal physiology through detoxification and re-education of organs to bring the body back homeostatic balance’; hydrotherapy; and aromatherapy. She also offers something I’ve never heard of before, Ortho-Bionomy, which is basically a form of musculoskeletal manipulation that sounds a lot like a lot of the other forms of musculoskeletal manipulations out there. Of course, anyone who offers homeopathy cannot be considered a science-based practitioner.
Sleeping Bear Natural Health, Traverse City, MI. The naturopath here is Abigail Ellsworth, ND, who offers: The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy, along with the other usual naturopathic nonsense. What is interesting about Ellsworth is that she takes pains to point out that she is “unable to legally practice medicine and/or offer services to the full scope of: her training and that she does not “provide Primary Care, diagnose or treat disease or prescribe medications.” Imagine if HB 4531 passes and naturopaths like her become able to provide primary care.
Troy Naturopathic, Troy. This is the practice of Dimpi Patel, ND, who offers botanical medicine; The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy); supplements; hydrotherapy; and traditional Chinese medicine.
I could go on, but you get the idea. Wait. I should mention one more: William Beaumont Hospital, a very large private hospital system in the Detroit area, which added naturopaths to its staff in 2008 and offers naturopathy to this day, complete with The One Quackery To Rule Them All, which is described on Beaumont’s site thusly:
Homeopathy is based on the understanding that natural substances, prepared in very diluted doses, can prompt the body to self correct. Symptoms that may respond well to homeopathy include auto-immune conditions, allergies, trauma recovery and conditions that don’t fit into a clear conventional diagnosis.
Yes, this is the website of a respected hospital touting homeopathy as something that is pure quackery. Seriously, go and read the Beaumont Hospital webpage on naturopathy. It might as well have been written by one of the private naturopaths in Michigan. Oh, wait, it probably was. Worse, a representative for Beaumont Health System testified in favor of HB 4531.
Certain recurring themes are apparent in these practices around the state. The first is that nearly all of them offer The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy) plus a selection of other pseudoscientific and mystical therapies, such as acupuncture, other traditional Chinese medicine, detoxification, “personalized” diet advice, and others. The second recurring theme is that many of these naturopaths are unhappy that they cannot practice to the “full extent” of their “educations.” Personally, I’m glad that that is true, and remain amazed that any of them, in any state, can do so. Like Peter Lipson, who deals with the fallout from naturopathic mismanagement of patients far more than I ever have, I truly fear what might come to pass for my patients and other patients at my cancer center if HB 4531 were to pass.
Who wants HB 4531 to pass?
How has this effort to license naturopaths with a very expansive scope of practice has somehow been resurrected, this time to the point of actually making it out of the House Committee on Health Policy to the full House for consideration? Obviously, the MANP has been pushing for licensure and an expanded scope of practice all along, but that’s to be expected. Also not unexpected is who introduced this bill: Representative Lisa Posthumus Lyons, who represents District 86, which encompasses a rural area in the western Lower Peninsula. As was the case last time with HB 4152, the predecessor of HB 4531, I perused her Facebook and House page and was unable to find any mention of HB 4531, even though she seems to tout everything else she does there. One might almost think she’s ashamed of having sponsored HB 4531.
In any case, this time around, instead of just one co-sponsor, Rep. Lyons (R-Alto) has persuaded four additional Representatives to co-sponsor HB 4531 with her, a bipartisan group: Andy Schor (D-Lansing), George Darany (D-Dearborn and co-chair of the Committee on Health Policy), Jeff Irwin (D-Ann Arbor), Brandon Dillon (D-Grand Rapids), and Kathy Crawford (R-Novi). One notes that Brandon Dillon resigned late last year to become the Chairman of the Michigan Democratic Party. The interesting thing here is that searching for all of these Representatives plus either “naturopathy” or “HB 4531” turned up a whole lot of nothing. Not only did I fail to find much in the way of any of them bragging about introducing this legislation (as most legislators do when they introduce anything), finding news stories on HB 4531 that mention much beyond some very basic facts is almost impossible. Also odd is that this bill was introduced more than a year ago, as a naturopath named Kelly Hassberger exulted on Facebook:
Now, I realize that the wheels of government grind slowly. But what happened recently, a year after HB 4531 was introduced, to push it through the Committee on Health Policy to the floor of the House? The video I cited above mentions that the MANP hired a lobbyist to push HB 4531 through the legislature. MANP also lists various sponsors at various levels, such as Platinum ($5,000 a year), Gold ($2,500 a year), Silver ($1,00 a year), and Bronze ($500 a year). Donors include Commonwealth Labs, the manufacturer of a breath test for “Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth,” or “SIBO” (Platinum Sponsor); Designs for Health, a supplement manufacturer (Gold Sponsor); Viotron International, LLC, another supplement manufacturer (Silver Sponsor); and Integrative Therapeutics, yet another supplement manufacturer (Bronze Sponsor). So supplement manufacturers and the maker of a test for a questionable condition are supporting MANP’s campaign? Color me surprised.
So are Madelon and Kurt Hassberger. Remember that there is some sort of link between the Hassbergers and Rep. Lyons. Kelly Hassberger, who appears to be Madelon and Kurt Hassberger’s daughter, owns Grand Rapids Natural Health. Whatever’s going on, the forces pushing for naturopathic licensure in Michigan have gotten further than they ever have before. To figure out why, perhaps we should look at the other side of the equation.
Who opposes HB 4531?
HB 4531 is a danger to patients in the state of Michigan. Of that there is no doubt. Licensing naturopaths would add nothing to the quality of health care in Michigan, but would under the Affordable Care Act possibly force insurance companies to reimburse for the services of naturopaths and at the same time legitimize a whole lot of quackery. So you’d think that our major medical societies in the state would be very much against HB 4531, wouldn’t you? So are they? I don’t know. Certainly, it’s very hard to find any mention of this bill at all. For example, the Michigan Health & Hospital Association lists various pending bills and its positions on the bills, ranging from support to neutral to oppose to no position. What does the MHHA say about HB 4531? It says, “To Be Determined.” Come on, MHHA! You’ve had a year to figure out whether you oppose or support this bill. In contrast, it sure does oppose a bill that would require the development of an acuity system and staffing plan for nurses!
What about the Michigan State Medical Society? One notes that a search on its website for “naturopath” or “HB 4531” reveals exactly zero mentions of either. Now, I’ve taken MSMS to task before for its intractable opposition to a bill that would expand the scope of practice of advanced practice nurses (a.k.a. nurse practitioners) to be in line with their training. I’ve called out MSMS for this being nothing more than an example of turf protection by physicians. I note that MSMS appears to have taken down its videos and material opposing this bill since then, but I’d be willing to bet that’s just because the bill being opposed was successfully scuttled. In contrast, I note that the MSMS did not testify against HB 4531 or even offer a statement opposing it when it was debated before the Committee on Health Policy on May 3, 2016. At the very same meeting, an MSMS representative did submit written testimony opposing HB 5587, a bill that would allow a pharmacist to refuse to dispense a prescription for a controlled substance if there is reason to believe the prescription was not written in good faith or would not be used for legitimate medical purposes.
I note that MSMS stated unequivocally that every “discussion in Lansing about health care and health policy should start and end with what is best for Michigan patients.” Its silence in the face of HB 4531 is directly the opposite of that nobly expressed sentiment. I can only concluded that its silence is because MSMS is either ignorant of the contents of HB 4531 (a charitable interpretation), ignorant of what naturopaths actually do (another charitable interpretation), or doesn’t view naturopaths as a threat to its turf (the cynical interpretation). Take your pick of one or more. It’s hard for me not to take the cynical interpretation, though, given how much effort and expense MSMS plowed into opposing Senate Bill 2, which would have expanded the scope of practice of nurse practitioners to be appropriate to their training, compared to its silence on HB 4531.
It’s not all bad news, though. Other Michigan medical societies did better than MSMS. For example, during that aforementioned May 3 meeting of the Committee on Health Policy, the Michigan Academy of Family Physicians, the Michigan Osteopathic Association, and the Michigan Orthopedic Society each submitted a testimony card in opposition to HB 4531. At an earlier meeting of the committee on April 19, the Michigan Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics testified in opposition to the bill. Unfortunately, they did so for the wrong reason:
Yes, it was turf protection. Note how the Academy stated that it is “not opposed to the licensure of naturopaths, we feel Michiganders should have the freedom and ability to keep receiving the great care they are getting from their trusted health care practitioners.” Ugh.
What next?
If there’s one thing I’ve learned about Michigan politics, it’s that our legislature is very good at passing bills “under the radar.” For instance, I had no idea that our “right-to-try” law had passed until two weeks after, when Governor Snyder signed it into law, this despite having had Google Alerts set up and checking local news sites on a near-daily basis. I fear the same thing happening with HB 4531, which has received very close to zero news coverage even in local newspapers and other news outlets.
The answer is sunlight. When light is shed on bills like HB 4531, good things can happen. This is true not just in Michigan, but anywhere naturopaths try to expand their scope of practice. For physicians, that means pressuring your state medical societies, particularly ones to which you belong, to put their full muscle behind opposing bills like HB 4531. For lay people and physicians both, it means contacting your legislators and letting them know that you don’t want practitioners of unscientific, prescientific, and pseudoscientific medicine to be legitimized by state licensure. Remember that these efforts by naturopaths are not going away. Naturopaths play the long game. When they fail, they wait until the time is right and try again, as they are doing now in Michigan.
If we advocates of science-based medicine don’t mobilize, the state of Michigan could well be licensing fake doctors soon.

Legislative Alchemy: Michigan House Bill 4531 gives naturopaths a broad scope of practice
Jann Bellamy on May 12, 2016
Link

Michigan House Bill 4531, if passed, would give naturopaths one of the broadest scopes of practice in the U.S., essentially equaling that of a family practice MD or DO. The bill made it through all the necessary House committees and is now before the House for an initial vote determining whether it will proceed further in that body. If it passes there, it will move to the Senate and its committee process.
Most naturopathic licensing bills fail, even in those states where attempts are made year after year. Michigan is no exception. Both David Gorski (a Michigan resident) and I discussed the previous licensing attempts there. In the two states where naturopathic licensing or registration has succeeded in the last few years, they have been able to get only a much more limited scope of practice than the full primary care scope they desire. For example, in Colorado, there are severe limitations on naturopaths’ seeing pediatric patients. They must disclose they are not physicians, recommend to parents that their children have a relationship with a licensed pediatric practitioner, and give parents the CDC-recommended vaccination schedule. All this is to thwart their efforts to talk parents out of vaccinating their children by giving them “balanced” information that is actually full of anti-vaccination dog whistles.
In Maryland, where naturopaths are regulated by the Maryland Board of Physicians, they cannot call themselves physicians or claim to practice primary care. They must have a collaboration and consultation agreement with an MD or DO and attest to the Board that the ND will “refer patients to and consult with physicians and other health care providers.” NDs must also have patients sign a consent form stating that the ND’s practice is limited to the scope of practice allowed by law. They cannot deviate from what is termed “safe care of patients” whether or not actual injury to a patient is established.
If passed, HB 4531 would be a radical departure from that trend. This newfound success in moving the ball forward may be due to an influx of funds from Emerson Ecologics, a company that sells dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies to naturopaths for resale to their patients. The company also sells the sort of dubious diagnostic tests used by naturopaths in their practice. For example, they offer a test for “adrenal stress” (to discover, not just “adrenal fatigue,” but actual “exhaustion”) and a saliva test for hormone levels as an indicator of the need for “bio-identical hormones.” (Neither the test nor “bio-identical hormones,” which is actually a marketing, and not medical term, are recommended in evidence-based medical practice.) In March, Emerson Ecologics announced a “grant” to the Michigan Association of Naturopathic Physicians (MANP) of $10,000 to support the effort to obtain full licensure for naturopathic doctors in Michigan.
The MANP is no stranger to corporate funding from companies that would benefit from their licensing. It is indeed odd, and hypocritical, that we at SBM, who accept no money from pharmaceutical companies, are referred to as “Big Pharma shills,” but no one hears a peep about the conflict of interest when naturopaths openly accept contributions from companies with whom they share a symbiotic relationship.
We’ve catalogued naturopathic pseudoscience here on SBM many times. Here, for example, is David Gorski’s excellent description of naturopathic practice:
naturopathy is a hodge-podge of mostly unscientific treatment modalities based on vitalism and other prescientific notions of disease. As a result, typical naturopaths are more than happy in essence to “pick one from column A and one from column B” when it comes to pseudoscience, mixing and matching treatments including traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, herbalism, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophical medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine.
If you want to dig further, there’s Scott Gavura’s meticulous analysis of naturopathic practices in his wonderful Naturopathy vs. Science series, Britt Hermes’s Naturopathic Diaries blog, the information on the Oppose Naturopathic Licensing website, as well as numerous entries on Quackwatch and its affiliated website, Naturowatch.
First, I’ll summarize HB 4531. Then, in contrast to the dog-and-pony show naturopaths are no doubt putting on for Michigan legislators, we’ll look at what the good folks in Michigan can actually expect from their licensed naturopaths if this bill becomes law, as revealed by naturopaths who are now practicing in other areas of the country as well as in Michigan.
House Bill 4531
“Naturopathic medicine” is defined in HB 4531 as
a system of practice that is based on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease.
As David said in his post on the previous bill,
The wag in me can’t help but point out how stupid this definition is. Let me just put it this way. Science-based medicine relies on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of diseases. Think about it. Setting broken bones would be useless if the body weren’t able to heal itself naturally. Surgery itself relies on the ability of the body to heal itself; otherwise cutting into the body to rearrange its anatomy for therapeutic intent would be the gravest of folly. The very definition of naturopathy is a false dichotomy between conventional medicine and “natural healing.”
Actually, they likely mean the kind of “natural healing capacity” that is vitalism, a prescientific concept at the core of naturopathic philosophy. The idea behind vitalism is that there is some incorporeal healing force inside our bodies acting independently of the real natural processes actually doing the work, like chemistry and biology. This was debunked long ago.
In any event, HB 4531 gives naturopaths the authority to diagnose, treat and prevent disease in any patient, of any age, with any disease or condition. This is a frightening concept, considering how ill-prepared they are by their education and training. Fortunately, we now know far more about that subject, thanks to the inside scoop provided by Britt Hermes, who went through the whole process herself and has been brave enough to tell what she knows. In addition to coursework devoted, in part, to nonsensical subjects like homeopathy, she breaks down their clinical training to reveal its gross inadequacy.
As Britt notes, the only clinical training naturopaths get prior to going into practice has to fit into their four years of naturopathic “medical” school, leaving them a mere 15,000+ hours short of the training family practice physicians must undergo. Here, they have cleverly left out of HB 4531 any claim they are capable of providing primary care (a claim that they cannot support with any objective evidence) perhaps to thwart efforts to make this sort of revealing comparison, while helping themselves to the same scope of practice anyway. Their lack of pharmacology education and training is particularly concerning in states where naturopaths (as here) lobby for prescribing privileges.
Yet HB 4531 falls for the false notion that naturopathic education is sufficient for this broad scope of practice, even though the whole system is a closed-loop of naturopaths teaching naturopaths in naturopathic schools accredited by an organization totally run by naturopaths, a system that operates wholly outside mainstream American higher education. Following that, they sit for an exam created and graded by naturopaths – an exam that has never been reviewed by anyone outside the closed loop. (Validating it for having content that actually reflects what naturopaths were taught doesn’t solve this problem. We need to know what they are actually tested on.) Then, they go straight into practice, no residency required.
Despite these deficiencies, HB 4531 would allow naturopaths to call themselves “physicians” and to
    • Order and perform lab exams for diagnostic purposes
    • Order diagnostic imaging studies
    • Prescribe (and, of course, sell) dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies
    • Use hot or cold hydrotherapy (including colon hydrotherapy)
    • Use “electromagnetic energy”
    • Perform minor office surgery, including “obtaining specimens to diagnose, assess, and treat disease” (such as an excisional biopsy, another scary thought)
    • Other naturopathic therapies approved by the Board
They will also be able to prescribe drugs, including controlled substances, if the drugs are on a naturopathic formulary. This formulary would be devised by a Formulary Council on which, fortunately, in addition to two naturopaths there will be two pharmacists and one MD or DO physician.
They will be able to use all routes of administration, including rectal, vaginal, transdermal, intramuscular, and intravenous. (Especially disturbing in light of their willingness to pump patients full of things like Myers cocktails.)
Naturopaths will be regulated by both the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs and a Board of Naturopathic Medicine. The Board would be composed of three naturopaths, two MDs or DOs, and two public members, leaving open the unfortunate possibility that they will engineer the appointment (by the Governor) of sympathetic public members and outflank the MDs/DOs. Michigan would be foolish to rely on a naturopathic board to assist in regulating naturopathic practitioners. Naturopathic Boards in Arizona and California have endorsed the most egregious quackery in service of the naturopaths they are charged with regulating.
How naturopaths really practice
I trust the naturopaths sold Michigan legislators on the idea that licensing would allow them to provide preventive healthcare and treat disease “naturally.” That’s always a selling point and a pretense to engage in the sort of awful quackery they actually specialize in. Since there is no standard of care in naturopathy, patients are at the mercy of whatever diagnoses and treatments the naturopath pulls out of his or her bag of tricks. If you don’t believe me, you should “listen in” on conversations among naturopaths about their patients, as David Gorski was able to do, which, as he said, “revealed just how quacky they are.”
All one need do to see how all of this plays out in actual practice is to look at the websites of naturopaths who practice all over the U.S., even in states where they aren’t licensed.
In Massachusetts, we find naturopaths who advertise ozone and light therapy, alternative cancer treatments, biotherapeutic drainage, bogus lab tests, and electro-dermal screening. And in New York there’s “Dr. Doni,” who offers bogus MTHFR genetic testing, designed to scare patients into thinking they have a greater chance of developing particular diseases. This is used as a pretense for selling patients an expensive program of naturopathic treatments.
And here are a few who practice in Colorado. As I catalogued in a previous post:
They’re using provoked urine tests to identify the ubiquitous toxins NDs claim permeate our bodies so that they can treat this imagined toxic overload with chelating agents. . . . But that’s not all. Colorado NDs are testing blood and saliva so they can diagnose and treat “adrenal fatigue,” another imaginary condition . . . with dietary supplements and strict dietary regimens. They are testing for “food toxicity” because “if you have one or more these symptoms, there is a 95% probability you’ll benefit from a food toxicity test.” This is followed by an impressive list of symptoms that makes one wonder what wouldn’t be a symptom of “food toxicity.” There is “genomic testing to determine genetic need for specific nutrients,” another dubious test debunked by Quackwatch. They are testing blood to measure IgG response to a wide selection of foods which, in the alternative reality of alternative medicine, raises the possibility of digestive problems. (Scott Gavura: “These tests lack both a sound scientific rationale and evidence of effectiveness.”)
But wait – that’s not all! More Colorado naturopathic practices were discussed in an earlier post, including bio-identical hormones, craniosacral therapy, reiki, chelation and visceral manipulation.
The Society for Science-Based Medicine, in its report on licensing naturopaths in Maryland, made an extensive list of the nonsensical diagnostic methods and treatments being offered by naturopaths there, complete with references debunking them, including alkaline diets, MELISA testing, autonomic response testing, and far-infrared saunas.
Mark Crislip also looked at naturopathic websites of practitioners in the Northwest U.S., and found many of the same practices, as did those who investigated naturopathic websites in Canada, where a licensed naturopath’s recommendation of tincture of Echinacea for a toddler suffering from meningitis, who died shortly thereafter, was discussed here on SBM and in the American and Canadian press. In sum, as the authors of “Supported by Science: What Canadian Naturopaths Advertise to the Public” concluded:
A review of the therapies advertised on the websites of clinics offering naturopathic treatments does not support the proposition that naturopathic medicine is a science and evidence-based practice.
Of course, as in other states where they are not licensed, Michigan naturopaths appear undaunted by the fact that they cannot practice legally. For example, under “Treatments,” Dimpi Patel, ND, says she treats all sorts of problems with menstruation, hormonal “imbalance,” uterine fibroids, polycystic ovary syndrome, peri-menopause, endometriosis , vaginal infection and inflammation, ADD/ADHD, panic and anxiety disorders, depression, OCD and bi-polar I and II disorder. As a matter of fact, only certain licensed health care practitioners (such as MDs) are legally authorized to treat disease.
You’ll find all the usual bread-and butter-naturopathic practices offered in Michigan, such as elimination of toxins via colon hydrotherapy (Cutler Integrative Medicine), “leaky gut” (Michelle Crowder, ND), mistletoe therapy for cancer (Jen Green, ND), chronic candidiasis, which apparently has a new name: “candidiasis syndrome,” (Ellen Kahn, ND), NAET (Healing Paths) and (of course!) cleansing and detoxification (Grand Rapids Natural Health).
I hope this tour of what naturopaths actually do, as opposed to what they claim they do, will dissuade Michigan legislators from voting to license them. Not only that, I hope they’ll investigate and take steps to stop these harmful practices.

Maryland legislature passes naturopathic licensing bill, but with damage control
Jann Bellamy on April 3, 2014
Link


It looks like Maryland is about to become the 18th state licensing (or registering) naturopaths unless the governor vetoes this legislation. That is unlikely to happen because the licensing bills passed overwhelmingly in the House and Senate. But becoming licensed in Maryland may turn out to be something of a pyrrhic victory.
The companion House (HB 402) and Senate (SB 314) bills moved through the General Assembly with lightning speed, suggesting the legislative wheels were well-greased behind the scenes. The lubricant was compromise by all parties: the NDs, the Maryland Board of Physicians, and Med Chi, the state’s medical association. The result seems to be the product of the legislature giving everyone some of what they want, but no one got it all. The baby got split, and that is never good for the baby’s health.
The warhorse parade
The bills originally introduced were obviously drafted by the naturopaths. It gave them their own governing board. They would be able to perform minor office procedures, use colon hydrotherapy, dispense therapeutic devices for barrier contraception, and durable medical equipment. They could administer homeopathic remedies, nutritional “medicine,” vitamins, minerals and so forth via intradermal, subcutaneous and intravenous routes. And they could practice independently, free of any supervision by a physician. Basically, they would be primary care physicians, which is what they claim they are.
Fortunately, all of that is gone in the version that passed. Unfortunately, there is still plenty to be concerned about. We’ll get to those features in a minute.
I listened to recordings of a couple of hours of testimony before two committees, one House, one Senate. (You’re welcome.) But the groundwork for licensing was laid last year, with a report from the Maryland Board of Physicians based on “Practitioner Workgroup” meetings that included representatives from state government and medical, chiropractic, acupuncture, occupational therapy, naturopathic and “chain drug store” (go figure) organizations, a law/lobbying firm (can’t tell who they represented), and Dr. Linda Lee, the Director of the Center for Integrative Medicine at Johns Hopkins. These “stakeholders” decided to try to iron out their differences rather than duke out all the issues in front of the legislature.
During the Workgroup meetings (of which there were only 3) the Maryland Association of Naturopathic Physicians trotted out the usual naturopathic warhorses, such as (with my comments in parentheses):
    • NDs are “natural medicine experts” (One cannot claim both to be an “expert” and at the same time ignore the lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness for many of the herbs and dietary supplements they recommend. And the use of homeopathy instantly disqualifies one from claiming “expertise” in anything, even the basic sciences.)
    • “Many patients visit NDs who would not otherwise seek healthcare and NDs assist those patients in entering the system.” (As far as I can tell, there is zero evidence for this position.)
    • NDs “search for the underlying causes of disease.” (True, to the extent diet and exercise may play a role in disease. False, if the underlying cause is something that doesn’t exist, such as “leaky gut,” “chronic yeast overgrowth,” or “adrenal fatigue.”)
    • The pre-med pre-requisites for ND school are the same as applicants for med school. (Except for the small matter that there is no entrance exam for ND school, while med school applicants must take the MCAT.)
    • A med school – naturopathic school “Comparative Curricula” chart showing, among other things that students at the University of Wisconsin Medical School have only 67 more hours in “clerkships and allopathic therapeutics” than ND students in the National College of Natural Medicine’s program. (As is typical, NDs completely ignore the 3-7 additional years of training medical residency requires. And we’d all love to see how they define “allopathic therapeutics” or why they combined this with clerkship hours. What’s the rationale there?)
    • “Significant data exists and continues to increase” for naturopathic practice. (I’ll let one their own examples speak for itself: “Herbs (ex: ‘tumeric’ or ‘curcumin’ into [sic] PubMed) yields 5780 citations.” Query: what information is missing from this example?)
All in all, the NDs presented themselves to both the Workgroup and the legislative committees as educated and trained to the same standards as MDs and DOs, able to fill an unmet need for “health promotion, wellness, disease prevention, and disease management” which they, to the exclusion of other health care providers, could provide in a safe, evidence-based, and cost-effective manner. Their licensure would, in addition, protect the public from poorly trained naturopaths, with their “on-line degrees.” As far as I can see from their presentation to the Workgroup and at the legislative hearings, the evidence they presented in support of their claims is between none and middling. (There is a 400-plus page “compendium” they put together for the legislature. I am attempting to get a copy.)
The Board of Physicians and Med Chi objected to the proposed scope of practice for NDs but not to licensure itself. Both emphasized groups that naturopaths’ unscientific education and training renders them unqualified to diagnose, order and interpret tests, or do anything else beyond use noninvasive “natural” remedies. The Board was adamant that they did not want anything to do with supervising NDs, and who could blame them? Instead they wanted them under the jurisdiction of their own Board (which is, of course, what the NDs wanted). Another possibility they floated was a newly-created Alternative and Complementary Medicine Board, which would also have jurisdiction over chiropractors and acupuncturists, a non-starter as the chiropractors and acupuncturists weren’t about to give up their autonomous boards. Med Chi wanted NDs firmly in the sights of the physicians board, a no-compromise position necessary for their support. Both the Board and Med Chi also objected to NDs using the term “physician.”
(I did not see any mention of the fact that Section 2607 of the Affordable Care Act would prevent insurers from “discriminating” against licensed naturopaths, although apparently Health and Human Services has told insurers they do not need to include naturopaths in their networks.)
As best I can tell, there was not a single skeptical or patient protection group involved. This left opponents from other professions open to the attack that it was all about turf protection. And that is exactly what happened at subsequent legislative hearings. After the chiropractors and acupuncturists were neutralized with provisions in the bill protecting their turfs, the MDs and DOs were left to defend the citadel with pointed questions about why they were always before the Maryland General Assembly trying to limit other health care professions’ scope of practice.
By the time the legislation was drafted and made it to legislative committee hearings, the big battleground turned out to be scope of practice. And it is here that the legislators split the baby, or rather divided the baby up among the various “stakeholders,” as they like to say.
A few MDs testified or wrote letters in support of licensure (integrative medicine’s collateral damage at work), as did a few patients. One patient’s testimony was particularly telling. She has been diagnosed with smoldering myeloma and her oncologist had suggested a watchful waiting to see how things developed. If the disease progressed further, she would go on a regimen of chemotherapy, which is standard practice.
Although smoldering myeloma has a greater risk of progressing to active multiple myeloma, some patients with smoldering myeloma do not make this transition and smolder for many years. Therefore, the current International Myeloma Working Group recommendation is that smoldering myeloma should be observed off treatment outside the setting of a clinical trial. There is at least one small clinical trial that has suggested better outcomes for early intervention, and larger studies are underway to confirm this finding.
So she went to a “naturopathic oncologist,” who prescribed a regimen of dietary supplements and curcumin, which, she pointed out, is being studied at the MD Anderson Cancer Center. This is true, but for lymphoma. Two trials have been terminated and no results are posted. According to the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, curcumin is possibly effective for dyspepsia and osteoarthritis. Apparently, there is some very preliminary research about its use in treating cancer, and the internet chatter is taking that one to the bank. She also ascribed the fact that she had not developed full blown myeloma, and therefore the need for chemotherapy, to her naturopath’s treatment.
To the uninitiated, this might sound impressive, and apparently the NDs thought it so or they wouldn’t have asked her to testify. Yet, what she said was actually troubling: an ND claiming a specialty in oncology prescribed dietary supplements, including curcumin, which has insufficient evidence of safety and effectiveness for cancer and none for smoldering myeloma. And she was attributing lack of progression of her disease to this treatment – was the ND fostering this confusion between correlation and causation?
In fact, each of the patients testifying in favor of licensing attributed improvement to ND treatments (including cranial sacral therapy for a concussion), when in fact the improvement could just have easily been the result of the natural progression of the condition or other treatments the patients were using.
And the results are . . .
The NDs got the scope of practice they wanted in terms of what and who they can treat. This includes:
the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of human health conditions, injury, and disease . . .
In other words, they can diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition. They can order and perform physical and lab exams, including phlebotomy, clinical lab tests, and order and interpret the reports of diagnostic imaging studies.
And here’s the interesting thing: other than the testimony about the time spent in clinical training (or lack thereof) there was no testimony or documentation, at least publicly available, demonstrating that NDs come out of school capable of diagnosing and treating the broad range of disease and conditions presented by a potential patient population, which includes basically everyone who can walk in off the street and present themselves to the ND. This is a point the DOs and MDs addressed and the NDs never really responded to. Virtually all of the ND testimony consisted of emphasis on their supposed ability to collaborate with other health care providers by serving as the experts in CAM, especially dietary supplements. Well, that’s just marvelous if all your patients happen to present with the limited number of diseases and conditions you’ve seen in your training or know how to recognize. And you can say all day that you will refer when necessary. But you can’t refer if you don’t see the problem in the first place.
Treatments will be limited to:
patient education and naturopathic therapies and therapeutic substances recognized by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education.
Thus, the State of Maryland will default to the CNME to decide what “naturopathic therapies and therapeutic substances” are appropriate. I looked on the CNME website and could not find any information about what substances and therapies they do and do not recognize, nor do I see any evidence that they regard making such a list as part of their duties. In fact, the CNME’s standards for what is taught in ND school (if this is what is meant by being “recognized” by the CNME) is remarkably vague. And the bar for what treatments are recognized must be awfully low, considering the fact that ND schools teach homeopathy, acupuncture, Unani (that is, humoral medicine), Ayurvedic medicine, cranial sacral therapy, and a host of other dubious treatments.
After granting NDs the right to diagnose and treat, legislators turned around and piled on a whole bunch of restrictions and safeguards, some of which the NDs agreed to in order to get their feet in the door. Of course, as we know, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians is gunning for full primary care physician scope of practice, including prescription privileges, in all 50 states. However, they are amenable to an incremental strategy, getting what they can initially and then returning to the legislature year after year. This strategy is playing out in Colorado right now, where, having gained registration rights just last year, they’ve already managed to get bills filed removing restrictions on their practice, some of which are similar to the ones imposed in Maryland.
Maryland NDs won’t be able to perform minor office procedures or any type of surgery, use transdermal, subcutaneous or IV routes of administration (eliminating their shooting patients up with vitamin and mineral “cocktails”) or colonic irrigation, or prescribe drugs. Nor claim they are “physicians.”
And, best of all, but much to the chagrin of the Board, they will be under the jurisdiction of the Board of Physicians, with a naturopathic advisory committee (2 NDs, 2 MDs or DOs, one consumer).
This advisory committee will be able to
    • Evaluate the content of any clinical, practice or residency requirement for licensure;
    • Develop and recommend to the Board exam standards for licensure, a code of ethics, and continuing education requirements.
Interestingly, one of the duties of the Board will be to collect licensing fees, which were estimated by legislative staff to be as much as $5,100 biennially, making it, by a factor of about 4, the biggest health care practitioner licensing fee in the state. This is because there are only about 25 NDs in Maryland. Fewer licensees means fewer people to share the administrative costs of regulating them. Of course, Maryland can expect to become a magnet for un- or under- employed NDs. According to their figures, there are about 4,750 licensees in the U.S. While some NDs practice in Canada, that number exceeds the number of graduates from ND schools, apparently by a large factor. According to one person who testified at a legislative hearing, the ND schools are graduating 500 NDs per year, although I couldn’t verify that.
As well, all NDs must have a “collaboration and consultation agreement” with an MD or DO, and attest to the Board that the ND will “refer patients to and consult with physicians and other health care providers.” NDs must also have patients sign a consent form stating that the ND’s practice is limited to the scope of practice identified in the statute. (I have to assume here that the ND must actually tell the patient what that is and not just refer to the section of the state statutes where the scope appears. Let’s hope so.)
NDs are prohibited from using “false, deceptive, or misleading advertising.” These prohibitions are typical in health care practitioner licensing statutes. But, while a naturopathic board might not find it problematic for a naturopath to claim, for example, that “toxins” have invaded a patient’s body and therefore “detoxification” is in order, a Board composed of physicians might take a decidedly different view. NDs can’t do anything that doesn’t meet “generally accepted standards of practice of naturopathic medicine.” One wonders what that might be, considering standardization of treatment doesn’t appear to fit into the naturopathic paradigm and their rejection of evidence-based medicine.
However, in addition, they cannot deviate from what is termed “safe care of patients” whether or not actual injury to a patient is established. This is important, for it gives the Board the opportunity to discipline a naturopath for conduct that may well be within the naturopathic standard but is nevertheless unsafe, and without having to show actual injury. Some possibilities: the prescription of dietary supplements where there is insufficient evidence of safety and effectiveness (especially for children, for whom there is virtually no research on dietary supplements), discouraging vaccination by giving parents misleading information about their safety and efficacy, and using naturopathic treatments without advising patients there are more effective medical treatments, or diagnosing and treating one of their non-existent diseases (e.g., food “sensitivities”). They also can’t offer to treat a disease by “a secret method, treatment or medicine,” or promote the sale of goods or services to a patient “so as to exploit the patient for financial gain.”
The bill creates a workgroup to study the development of a naturopathic formulary and make recommendations regarding a formulary, including the types of drugs, medicines and devices to be included and their routes of delivery. But they can’t actually establish a formulary without the legislature giving the green light.
Some disinfectant sunshine
If the Board takes its responsibilities seriously and wants to put in the time and effort, there are some real possibilities to both inform the public about, and protect the public from, naturopathic practice. Here are a few ideas in keeping with the authority granted them by this legislation:
    • Require informed consent, including an accurate (scientifically accurate, not accurate according to “naturopathic principles”) statement of the risks and benefits of any treatment. For example, make them tell patients that homeopathic remedies are water with no evidence of efficacy. Make them accurately state the evidence for any particular dietary supplement. Do not allow them to tell patients they need “detoxification” by falsely stating their bodies are full of “toxins.”
    • Do not accept at face value the ND’s version of their education, training and testing (the NPLEX). There is specific authority to look into it and NDs aren’t telling the straight story. (Why believe an ND who represents his education and training as the same as an MD and qualifies him to diagnose all comers?) Look at the CNME’s accreditation requirements and ask for documentary evidence of what they are taught and details of their training. And beef up the standards where you can.
    • There is no specific prohibition against their selling dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, and the like to patients, but there is also nothing to prevent the Board from enacting an ethical rule saying they can’t. After all, not selling drugs to patients is already a well-established ethical principle in medicine.
    • Make their continuing education requirements rigorous, and be sure to include the safety and efficacy of vaccination as one of your first required courses.
Finally, I hope Maryland physicians, PAs and nurse practitioners won’t be shy about calling them out on their diagnoses and treatments. Actually, all health care practitioners are required by this legislation to report NDs who are in violation of the statute or the Board’s rules.
The NDs got their licensing statute and most of the scope of practice they wanted. But they did so at the cost of submitting themselves to closer scrutiny (but not actual supervision) via having an MD or DO watching what they are doing. As well, other physicians, PAs, and nurse practitioners will be made aware of how they operate. They had to give up their claim of being PCPs and must tell patients about their limitations. And, if the Board does its job, the public will have an opportunity to examine their education, training, and practice in a way that hasn’t been done before. What comes of this remains to be seen.

Naturopathic organ repositioning coming soon to Pennsylvania?
Jann Bellamy on May 30, 2013
Link
Pennsylvania legislators need to know only one thing about House Bill 612 (licensure of naturopathic “doctors”) to vote against it: As a means of “naturopathic musculoskeletal therapy” the bill would allow naturopaths to “reposition body tissues and organs.”
This is impossible. You cannot “reposition” tissues and organs of the human body by external manipulation.
Why does this tell us everything we need to know about these naturopathic doctors and why they shouldn’t be licensed in Pennsylvania? For one thing, this is no mistake a bill draftsman made in understanding what naturopathic practice includes. House Bill 612 was obviously drafted by naturopaths. That means naturopathic doctors actually believe they can “reposition” your body’s tissues and organs. And that speaks to their poor education and training. They don’t even understand basic anatomy.
For another, it tells us naturopathic doctors reject evidence-based medicine as a standard of practice. There is no evidence that this “repositioning” of organs and tissues is beneficial for any condition or disease, even if they could do it in the first place, which they can’t.
And for yet another, this certainly calls into question their understanding of the disease process and their diagnostic skills. One has to wonder exactly what health problems they think these purportedly out-of-place organs are causing. And how do they go about determining which organs are out of place and where they should go? Or when they have been successfully returned to their proper position? Again, this should raise alarming questions in the legislators’ minds about their education and training.
Yet, if this bill passes, naturopathic doctors will become state-licensed providers of primary care. Yes, primary care providers. It says so right there in the definition of “naturopathic medicine.” (Mark Crislip thoroughly debunked the notion of naturopaths as primary care doctors in a post deconstructing a naturopathic white paper on the subject.) This will allow naturopaths to “reposition” the organs and tissues of unsuspecting Pennsylvania citizens, possibly claiming a right to insurance reimbursement for the privilege, another problem with this bill we’ll get to later.
Of course, this fantasy treatment could be excised from the bill. But that would do nothing to resolve the substantial questions about their education, training, and abilities to perform the most basic tasks of primary care, or any other form of evidence-based healthcare, or even reality-based health care for that matter. And there are plenty more naturopathic fantasy treatments allowed by House Bill 612 even if you get rid of this one. We’ll get to a few more in a minute.
This affinity for fantasy treatments among naturopathic doctors is explained in the first part of the bill, Section 103, which defines “naturopathic medicine” as:
a system of primary health care practiced by doctors of naturopathic medicine for the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of human health conditions, injuries and diseases and that uses education, natural medicines and therapies to support and stimulate the individual’s intrinsic self-healing processes.
This is the central fallacy of naturopathic practice, one that sounds appealing but is at its core meaningless. “Intrinsic self-healing processes” is simply another way of referring to vitalism, a long-discredited, pre-scientific notion that bodily function is controlled by some incorporeal force unknown to science or medicine. As Steve Novella pointed out, vitalism was a placeholder, used to explain bodily functioning until biology, chemistry, physiology and anatomy developed science-based explanations for these functions. Except for naturopaths, who’ve remained stuck in vitalism.
Naturopaths have tried to backfill a scientific explanation into the pre-conceived notion of an “intrinsic self-healing process.” When they can convince a group of respectable physiologists (say, those holding faculty appointments at major research universities or medical schools) that their explanation is credible, I’ll believe it too. Until then, I won’t and no one else should either.
Of course, when you start from the premise that the body is governed by this non-existent life force pretty much anything that you can fit into that paradigm will fly, and naturopaths have used this to their full advantage in devising diagnoses and treatments no responsible medical doctor would agree with. Hence organ repositioning.
More nonsense
Other implausible and unproven treatments either mentioned specifically in the bill or permitted under its broadly defined categories, such as “naturopathic physical medicine,” include all those mentioned in David Gorski’s summary of naturopathic practice:
If I’ve pointed it out once, I’ve pointed it out a thousand times. Naturopathy is a cornucopia of almost every quackery you can think of. Be it homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophical medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine, it’s hard to think of a single form of pseudoscientific medicine and quackery that naturopathy doesn’t embrace or at least tolerate.
This bill will also allow naturopathic doctors to pump patients full of unnecessary vitamins and minerals intravenously, and use other favorite and potentially dangerous treatments such as peat baths, colonic irrigation (which the Journal of Family Practice warned against in this 2011 article), fasting and severely restricted diets, and recommendation of dietary supplements of unknown safety and effectiveness, to name a few. Naturopaths will be able to diagnose diseases they’ve invented, such as chronic yeast overgrowth, ubiquitous toxins (that no one else seems to be able to find), and food “sensitivities” (again, that no one else seems to be able to detect).
In addition to what we might politely refer to as their “unique” diagnoses and therapies, N.D.s will also be able to use some conventional diagnostic means such as mammography, X-rays, and lab tests. They will be able to perform physical exams, including well baby checkups and vaginal and proctologic exams. But permitting naturopaths to do these things and their knowing what they are doing are two entirely different things.
Naturopathic education, such as it is
I trust no one could get to this point in reading and think that naturopathic doctors have sufficient education and training to diagnose and treat patients. Unfortunately, all naturopathic licensing bills make the mistake of assuming their education and training is somehow the equivalent of, or at least close to, that of a medical doctor.
House Bill 612 makes this same unfounded assumption. An applicant to practice as a naturopathic doctor must have “completed a doctorate-level naturopathic medical program” accredited by an accreditation agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education and must pass an examination administered by the North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners (The “NPLEX”). Let’s see what this education, accreditation and examination are really like. This is ground we have covered before at SBM, but it bears repeating because I have never seen a shred of evidence that the sponsors of this bill, or any state naturopathic licensing bill, have ever set foot on the campus of a naturopathic school and critically evaluated its programs, or looked at one of these licensing exams or researched the requirements for becoming an accrediting agency. All the bills I’ve read simply parrot language obviously supplied by naturopaths.
So here’s what’s actually going on: These naturopathic “medical” schools have simply appropriated the word “medical” and pasted into the school’s name. There are five of these schools in the U.S. and two in Canada. Unlike medical schools, where students must score well on the grueling MCAT to be accepted, there is no entrance exam. All are private and none are part of a mainstream public or private university or college. Unlike real medical schools and science departments at other colleges and universities, their faculty members have published little and do virtually no research.
The Council on Naturopathic Medical Education has been approved by the U.S. Department of Education to accredit naturopathy schools. While naturopaths pushing licensing seem to want to use this as a sort of federal government seal of approval, it is nothing of the sort. The goal of the Department is to ensure that accredited schools meet certain financial, disclosure and similar requirements in order to protect prospective and current students from such problems as financially unsound institutions or schools that are dishonest about post-graduation job opportunities. It is also designed to determine which schools can take advantage of student loan programs. The accreditation program is not designed to protect the public health by ensuring these schools instruct their students in the use of safe and evidence based healthcare. It does not mean that graduates are capable of practicing primary care, nor of providing health care at all. The Department does not vet course content. That is simply not the function of the accreditation programs.
Nor does passing the NPLEX exam guarantee the delivery of quality healthcare by naturopaths. This somewhat mysterious document seems to be carefully protected by naturopaths. No one outside of naturopathy appears to have seen a copy or reviewed its contents. In fact, even when Kimball Atwood asked for a copy as part of a state-appointed commission reviewing naturopathy licensure for Massachusetts in 2002 he couldn’t get one. (Naturopaths are still not licensed in Massachusetts, even after trying numerous times. I think they are up to a dozen attempts, maybe more.) No person voting on House Bill 612 should miss reading Dr. Atwood’s series on naturopathy, which you can find referenced here. It would be unconscionable to vote without this information.
Let’s also look at a huge gap in their training, which we’ll discuss in the context of their claims to being “primary care” providers.
Primary Care Practice?
As mentioned, this bill will allow naturopaths to practice primary care. N.D.s would have the same scope of practice as an M.D. or D.O. primary care physician but be limited in some of the therapies they could offer. (For example, they could not prescribe controlled substances.) They will be able to see, and treat, any patient of any age with any disease or condition, no matter how serious.
Full scope of practice as a primary care physician, including all prescription drugs, is actually the goal of the American Association of Naturopaths. Naturopaths are willing to accept a more narrow scope, as is apparently the case in Pennsylvania, and then return for increased scope once entrenched. They have achieved this in Washington state, including mandatory insurance coverage, with interesting results. Two reviews of insurance claims for naturopathic care revealed that less than 2% of the insured adult and pediatric population made such claims, indicating an extremely low use of licensed naturopathic doctors for health care even where they are fully licensed and covered by insurance.
In defining what a primary care physician does, I turn again to an American Association of Family Physicians definition:
Primary care is that care provided by physicians specifically trained for and skilled in comprehensive first contact and continuing care for persons with any undiagnosed sign, symptom, or health concern (the “undifferentiated” patient) not limited by problem origin (biological, behavioral, or social), organ system, or diagnosis.
Primary care includes health promotion, disease prevention, health maintenance, counseling, patient education, diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic illnesses in a variety of health care settings (e.g., office, inpatient, critical care, long-term care, home care, day care, etc.). Primary care is performed and managed by a personal physician often collaborating with other health professionals, and utilizing consultation or referral as appropriate.
Note specifically that this bill would allow the N.D. to see and treat the “undifferentiated patient” straight out of N.D. school, with 1200 hours of clinical training. This training is usually done in naturopathy school clinics where the students typically see patients who have a variety of mild, self-limiting conditions, such as colds and musculoskeletal pain. Compare this to the clinical training medical students must have before they can become board certified in family practice, general internal medicine or pediatrics (the three primary care specialties in medicine). During med school, in the third and fourth year, students see patients in a variety of settings (hospital, office, emergency room) in clinical rotations among a variety of specialists (pediatrics, surgery, oncology, obstetrics etc.). After graduation they also spend an additional three years, at about 80 hours per week, in clinical training. For an idea of what they do during that residency, you can find a broad outline of the curriculum for a three-year family practice residency at Penn Medicine on its website. Again, naturopathic doctors do not have this training.
Naturopathic treatment of pediatric patients is especially troubling because of naturopathic opposition to vaccination. Studies have found:
    • A negative influence of naturopaths on mothers’ decision to vaccinate children.
    • Consultation with a naturopath significantly decreased the likelihood of receiving a flu shot among women in contact with young children.
    • Children in Washington state were significantly less likely to receive recommended vaccinations if they saw a naturopathic doctor, and significantly more likely to be diagnosed with a vaccine-preventable disease if they received naturopathic care.
Forced insurance reimbursement? And other problems.
To add insult to injury, the Affordable Care Act’s non-discrimination provision may require reimbursement of naturopathic health care if naturopathic doctors are licensed. That is certainly what they are aiming for. And they aren’t shy about making a huge fuss when they aren’t included in physician practice groups because they don’t practice evidence-based medicine.
House bill 612 will require naturopathic doctors to refer a patient to a physician “when the patient is presenting a contraindication to the practice of naturopathic medicine.” I am not even sure what that means. (Based on what we know about naturopathic practice one might argue that pretty much all patients present with a “contraindication to the practice of naturopathic medicine.”) In any case, note that it will be the N.D. who makes the call here. That presents two problems. First, N.D.s already think they are capable of practicing as primary care physicians. Given this overblown view of their abilities, abilities I feel fairly sure I’ve just demonstrated they do not possess, might one not be concerned that they will fail to realize their shortcomings when a patient needs a referral? Second, given their lack of training in diagnosing patients, who could be confident that they will be able to recognize a disease or condition requiring referral in the first place?
Nor should Pennsylvania legislators take comfort in the fact that naturopaths would be regulated by the state medical board. The board can only regulate within the confines of the scope of naturopathic practice granted by this bill. It will have no authority to prevent naturopaths from doing anything the legislature says they can do. In fact, regulation by the medical board will create quite a quandary. How will the board determine, for example, whether a naturopath’s repositioning of an organ fell below the standard of care? How about an injection of vitamins and minerals for “flu prevention”? Or a prescription for homeopathy?
If I were Rep. Mark Mustio, the bill’s main sponsor, or any of the other legislators who signed on as sponsors, I would be furious with the naturopaths for putting me in this position, subject to ridicule for sponsoring such bill. Rep. Mustio can redeem himself, and save his colleagues a lot of embarrassment, by quietly withdrawing House Bill 612 from consideration before it even comes up for a vote before the House Professional Licensure Committee on June 5th.

Night of the living naturopaths
Jann Nellamy on January 26, 2012
Link
Colorado’s “degreed” naturopaths (NDs) are nothing if not persistent. Starting in 1994 they have tried seven times to convince legislators that the Colorado’s public needs protection from what “traditional” naturopaths (traditionals) do, and that the best way of providing that protection, they claim, is to bestow licensure on the guys with the college degrees. The irony in this is that the NDs could well be the more dangerous practitioners.
Legislators have been largely sympathetic to the concerns of the more numerous traditionals who fear the loss of their right to work as naturopaths. The NDs have tried neutralize these opponents by reassuring them they could continue to practice naturopathy, but the traditionals don’t buy that. And they won’t easily forfeit the title of “naturopath” to which they believe to have more claim.
So what we have here in Colorado is near 20-year turf war between two types of naturopaths: the NDs who seek legislation to transform naturopathy into a protected guild, and the traditionals who are happy with the status quo. There is no love lost between these groups. Legislators repeatedly advise them to resolve their differences before asking for licensure again, but they haven’t gotten close to détente.
Colorado NDs have made no secret of their economic motivations. Before the 2011 legislative session, the Colorado Association of Naturopathic Doctors (CAND) was reinvigorated by the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act which has this “non-discrimination” provision:
(a) Providers– A group health plan and a health insurance issuer offering group or individual health insurance coverage shall not discriminate with respect to participation under the plan or coverage against any health care provider who is acting within the scope of that provider’s license or certification under applicable State law. This section shall not require that a group health plan or health insurance issuer contract with any health care provider willing to abide by the terms and conditions for participation established by the plan or issuer. Nothing in this section shall be construed as preventing a group health plan, a health insurance issuer, or the Secretary from establishing varying reimbursement rates based on quality or performance measures. [Sec. 2706]
CAND cited this provision in their Spring 2010 newsletter, adding:
There has never been a more important time for states to realize the positive impact of state licensing laws that dictate a full scope of practice for qualified naturopathic doctors….In short, naturopathic doctors in licensed states will now be a part of major insurance offerings.
With the lure of mandated reimbursements, we can predict NDs not only in Colorado, but around the country, to be making a renewed push for licensure.
What Gets Lost
In all the years that naturopath licensure has been considered, it is maddening that the most fundamental questions are rarely, if ever, considered by Colorado policymakers: What do NDs offer the public that is unique and effective healthcare? Do NDs have a scope of practice and objective standards to inform regulation?
Over the years, the Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA) has been responsible for providing legislators with a factual background reports on naturopathy and making recommendations regarding licensure. In their “sunrise” report, there is considerable evidence that DORA puts a heavy thumb on the scales in the favor of the NDs. DORA has dismissed criticism of naturopathy with the assertion that regulation is solely about protecting the public and that regulators have no duty to determine if a profession’s practices are efficacious or validated by science. Alas, many legislators follow DORA’s lead on this.
In the last sunrise review, DORA calls naturopathy a “philosophy” which is “not tied to any particular therapy or modality.” So it’s not surprising that the operational definitions regarding naturopathy in the legislation have been vague to the point of being almost meaningless. Bill language itself has made naturopathy sound so chicken-soup-innocuous that one might think the legislators would question the need to regulate naturopathy at all. Here, from the 2011 bill:
“NATUROPATHIC MEDICINE” MEANS A SYSTEM OF HEALTH CARE PRACTICES FOR THE PREVENTION, DIAGNOSIS, EVALUATION, AND TREATMENT OF INJURIES, DISEASES, AND CONDITIONS OF THE HUMAN BODY THROUGH THE USE OF EDUCATION, NUTRITION, NATURAL MEDICINES AND THERAPIES, AND OTHER MODALITIES THAT ARE DESIGNED TO SUPPORT, STIMULATE, OR SUPPLEMENT THE HUMAN BODY’S OWN NATURAL SELF-HEALING PROCESSES.
“NATUROPATHIC MEDICINE” INCLUDES NATUROPATHIC PHYSICAL MEDICINE, WHICH CONSISTS OF THE THERAPEUTIC USE OF THE PHYSICAL AGENTS OF AIR, WATER, HEAT, COLD, SOUND, LIGHT, TOUCH, AND ELECTROMAGNETIC NONIONIZING RADIATION AND THE PHYSICAL MODALITIES OF ELECTROTHERAPY, DIATHERMY, ULTRAVIOLET LIGHT, ULTRASOUND, HYDROTHERAPY, AND EXERCISE.
In sunrise reviews, DORA devoted only half a page to describing ND practices: a summary of the “remedy” homeopathy and a characterization of “hydrotherapy” as the use of water “in any of its forms” at “various temperatures” for its “revitalizing properties.”
At a legislative hearing in 2011, my testimony was shut down when I started describing a few other ND practices. It apparently was not relevant to deliberations. But with the prospect of facing yet another ND licensing bill this year, I thought it might be useful for legislators to see what Colorado NDs actually practice.
So in Nov/Dec 2011, I surveyed 88 NDs in Colorado advertising their services on the Internet, almost entirely through their business websites. I tallied up the practices they offer in Table 1:
Modality	Count	Pct
Clinical nutrition	73	83%
Herbal/botanical Medicine	73	83%
Homeopathy	71	81%
Supplements	45	51%
Detoxing/fasting	39	43%
Hydrotherapy	30	34%
Food & other allergy testing	27	31%
Lifestyle counseling	27	31%
Mental health counseling*	26	30%
Acupuncture**	24	27%
Traditional Chinese medicine	24	27%
ND manipulation & mobilization	23	26%
Bio-identical hormones	22	25%
Cancer support and/or therapy	20	23%
GYN/infertility services	19	22%
Heavy metal testing	19	22%
Craniosacral therapy	18	20%
IV & IM nutrition	18	20%
Cold & Flu treatment	16	18%
Saliva and/or hair testing	14	16%
Applied kinesiology	12	14%
Functional medicine	12	14%
Qi gong, TT, Reiki, or Energy Medicine	12	14%
Environmental medicine	11	12%
Anti-aging medicine	10	11%
Massage	10	11%
Childbirth/OB	9	10%
Mind-body medicine	9	10%
Weight loss program	9	10%
Candida Treatment	8	9%
Chelation	8	9%
Specialty labs	7	8%
Visceral manipulation	7	8%
Ayurvedic medicine	6	6%
Body work	5	6%
Intuition or insight to diagnose	5	6%
Parasite testing	5	6%
Prolotherapy	5	6%
* None of the NDs who offer mental health services have any type of mental health licensure, even though it’s extremely easy to become a “registered psychotherapist” in Colorado.
** 19 NDs are currently licensed as acupuncturists; an additional five NDs without acupuncture licenses offer acupuncture.
Practices publicly offered by four or fewer NDs are: acupuncture injections (1), aromatherapy (1), Brain Chemistry Balancing (2), colonics (3), colostrum for children (1), Crossinology (1), DAN (4), Drum Circle & Capoeira (1), equine massage (2), minor surgery (1), Orthobionomy (1), Peat Moss Therapy (2), Plant Stem Cell Therapy (3), probiotics (3), sweat lodge for children (1), testosterone replacement (4), trigger point injections (1), and unpasteurized products (2). A few additional practices will be discussed below.
Without valid diagnostic methods, the issue of ND treatments almost becomes a moot question. So it is notable that one-fourth of the NDs reveal that they favor unreliable diagnostic methods, i.e. “specialty labs” (such as Great Smokies), applied kinesiology, NAET, and intuition.
Twenty-eight NDs posted their fees on their websites, so I gather that information, as well in Table 2:
	Initial consult	Subsequent visits
Adults	$200
Range: $100-$375	$99
Range: $55-$155
Children	$145	$84
This strikes me as a pretty scary list of diagnostic and treatment practices, and they ain’t cheap. Some are clearly practices to avoid at any price, such as visceral manipulation, IV chelation, and home birth. But in reading the ND websites, I found that even the more innocuous-sounding practices (such as homeopathy and hydrotherapy) – unfettered as they are by any standards – can take on dangerous and sadistic forms. A few examples:
Cowboy homeopathy?
“Snake Bite Kit…$89.00…Crotalus hordius [30C], a homeopath remedy derived from the rattlesnake venom, has shown benefits with doses at 15 minute intervals.
Kids would much rather just get a shot for the flu
Wet Socks Treatment… great for relieving – and even preventing… colds, flu … [The icy socks will be dried by the body’s circulating blood… Soak cotton socks in ice cold water (or keep a pair in the freezer)… Also consider wet tee-shirts and underwear when treating the chest and pelvic areas.
You get yourself an infrared heat lamp, put it in a big box, and voila’!
The Life Vessel is…one of the newest technologies in the emerging fields of natural healthcare paradigms in the 21st century….[It] works to eliminate the source of chronic disease…
LactoHerbalism?
Once the child is born and is nursing if any problems arise with the infant I treat the mother. This is an effective and efficient way to treat a nursing child since I can give herbs/nutrients to the mother (that I could not give directly to the infant) which the child will receive through the breast milk.
“Clinical nutrition”? How bad could that be?
The most common practices of Natural Therapy in Cancer Care are: Alternative Medicine – Therapies are used in place of standard medical treatments, for example a special diet to “treat” cancer in lieu of an oncologist’s suggested treatment plan….
Routine IV infusions
If caught at first sign of symptoms, a nutritional IV can be a perfect way to ward off cold and flu… A nutritional IV takes about an hour to infuse, however for a super quick boost for the immune system, a Wellness injection is the perfect solution! …a combination of B12 and specific immune boosting homeopathics…
Many nutrients …are needed in much higher doses then the government recommended dosing schedule (R.D.A) which is only necessary to prevent overt disease, not to maintain health. IV therapy is a safe and fast way to supply the body with adequate levels of minerals and vitamins…
IV hydrogen peroxide? Holy gas embolism!
Using IV route of administration of nutrients allows for maximum concentration of nutrients to reach tissues that need it the most….What are some of the nutrients used? There are a lot of options but the most used are B- vitamins like B1, B2, B3, B5, B6, Vitamin C, Calcium, Magnesium, Hydrogen Peroxide, Glutithione, and many others….Cells now have enough energy to eliminate accumulated toxins. This process may lead to a detoxification reaction, bringing about symptoms of fatigue, nausea, headache and bowel changes.
Good ol’ fear-mongering
26 vaccine doses in the 1st year of life and over 50 doses total before kindergarten!!! That’s a lot… this study in Germany shows a 2-5 Time Increase in Diseases and Disorders in Vaccinated Children over Non-Vaccinated. Make sure you do your homework parents! [sic]
Why cleanse? …Our water supply is contaminated with heavy metals, fluoride, parasites and non-soluble minerals.
They learn this in “college”?
When you are flying, homeopathic remedies should be carried on your person, walking through the metal detector will NOT harm them. Putting them in your luggage or carry-on results in them getting X-rayed and losing their potency. [E] is a general practitioner who enjoys integrating the wisdom of vitalistic medicine with the latest research of modern medicine…
[T]he detoxiﬁcation process is a great starting place for most…Once food allergies and sensitivities are removed, it is easier to establish what symptoms remain and need to be dealt with.
Homeopathy…[Dr. B] has never heard a really convincing explanation for how this mysterious system of medicine really works. She suspects it is a quantum physics thing, which isn’t her field!
Far-Infrared Sauna… The heat produces an artificial “fever” and urges every organ of the body into action. While outwardly relaxed, your inner organs are as active as though you were jogging or mowing the lawn.
And an offer for you and three of your most toxic friends
It is our pleasure to offer you a free colon hydrotherapy session after three of your friends visit us. Refer three, get one free!
“We’re Physicians…”
Arguably, the most dangerous thing about NDs may be their inflated view of their own abilities, equating themselves with “physicians.” As many Colorado NDs are licensed as naturopathic physicians in another state, they can mention this fact in advertising and possibly circumvent their licensing law’s proscription against using the protected title of “physician.” A similar dodge is possible by mentioning their membership in the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. They use many other misleading terms in describing their practices:
“family medicine” (12)“pediatric” (30)“primary care physician”* (3)“sports medicine” (9)“naturopathic obstetrics” (1)“medical school” (5)“naturopathic medical school” (6)
Here are representative statements made by Colorado NDs about their qualifications:
Licensed naturopathic physicians have attended a 4-year graduate level program at accredited institutions where they receive the same basic science education as their counterparts in regular medical school. Naturopathic doctors also participate in a clinical program which spans over two years. Naturopath’s are distinctively situated to be primary care doctors due to their intensive training in both western medical sciences and traditional healing forms.
“We’re Physicians…Only Better”
NDs tell legislators that licensure would allow them to work closely with healthcare professionals, but a number of their statements suggest an implacable animosity towards the medical profession:
[W]hen it comes to chronic care, conventional healthcare is far from superior and often does not have the tools needed to truly get people healthy.
The current, mainstream model of medicine ignores the real causes of disease and illness…Chances are, the answer to your health problems is NOT another prescription.
I utilize traditional and functional lab tests as part of the diagnostic process. These are tests that not every doctor orders, much less understands.
Only in Colorado
Colorado has some fairly high-profile NDs practicing without licensure. Two teach at Metropolitan State College’s Integrated Therapeutic Practices department, a program that includes a “Pre-ND Club.” A chain of three Boulder pharmacies has had roaming NDs giving advice to customers. One Boulder ND is on the faculty of Bastyr and the College of Homeopathy in London. Another ND gives her address as the US Air Force Academy.
The Tim Tebow of Colorado NDs was not included in the survey because I could find no evidence that he currently sees patients, but he now publishes his own magazine, does TV spots, and works with a large grocery chain promoting his “Optimum Wellness” program.
Conclusion
Colorado’s NDs market a laundry list of pre-scientific vitalistic practices to the public. Though not the subject of my survey, it appears that some of the more popular practices, such as “clinical nutrition,” may be significantly different from one ND to another.
It is notable that homeopathy, which has been so thoroughly invalidated by science, is still an ubiquitous offering by Colorado NDs. I find this to be a measure of their devotion to vitalism and how far removed they are from having a scientific temperament.
It appears that predicting what any one ND will prescribe for any particular condition is not possible. Colorado NDs appear to each have their own pet practices, even when they are a husband-wife couple working together. How can there be meaningful regulation of a “profession” with no operational definition of substandard practice?
At one legislative hearing, Mark Johnson, MD, Director of the Jefferson County Health Department (and President of the Institute for Science in Medicine), aptly characterized naturopathy as “this squishy thing that you can’t get your hands around.”
DORA may not be interested in efficacy, but if protecting the public from harm is its responsibility, this agency should be be looking very closely at ND practices. In particular, evidence of ND opposition to childhood vaccination and other public health measures should be made available to legislators.
Unless there is a profound change in political environment, Colorado NDs are going to get their licenses to practice medicine and the mandatory third-party reimbursements that go with them. And like in horror movies, these remanent 19th century practitioners who prey on the vulnerable will be even harder to stop. Truly scary.
Recommended Reading
AMA Scope of Practice Data Series: Naturopaths, American Medical Association, Sep 2009.

Legislative alchemy (briefly) revisited: Naturopathy in Vermont and colloidal silver
David Gorski on January 23, 2012
Tweet
A couple of weeks ago, Jann Bellamy wrote about “legislative alchemy” in the new year, in which CAM mischief works its way into state legislatures. Specifically, she mentioned the case of legislators in Vermont trying to declare in law that naturopaths are primary care physicians, who can serve as a patient’s medical home without supervision by real doctors.
Rosemary Jacobs, whose life was altered irrevocably when she developed agyria due to colloidal silver noticed another aspect of this new proposed law:
I recently learned that Vermont licenses naturopaths, NDs, as physicians and that they have a state sanctioned formulary, a list of drugs they can prescribe and administer to patients. To my horror, the 2009 formulary includes “colloidal silver preparations” to treat eye infections and “silver” which they can administer intravenously.http://www.vtprofessionals.org/opr1/naturopaths/info/Naturopathic Physician Formulary 20091211.pdf [pdf download]
I was horrified because of the danger this poses to patients, the incredible ignorance it shows on the part of naturopaths, and because NDs had, without my knowledge, been licensed in Vermont to administer prescription drugs and other strange substances like silver and tin, do physical exams and order the same diagnostic tests that MDs order.
How had this happened without my knowledge? I have been following alternative medicine for 15 years and warning people about the danger of ingesting silver, an alternative “remedy”, because I don’t want anyone else disfigured by it like I was over 50 years ago.
Silver drugs were used by medical doctors before the advent of antibiotics. Although they didn’t work, they permanently turned many people blue and gray. The condition is called argyria. It was formerly common, and is well documented and understood by scientists.
If NDs had known as much about medicine as I, an educated consumer, do, they would have searched the medical literature before including anything in their formulary. If they had done that, they would have seen that: there are no studies showing that ingesting silver in any form or amount offers benefits; colloidal silver does not treat eye infections; taking silver internally or putting it in your eye can result in permanent discoloration.
Colloidal silver is nonsense. There’s no evidence that it is good for anything. Rosemary also revealed to me something I didn’t know before, namely that there’s another woo-friendly Senator that I didn’t really know about: Bernie Sanders, who, according to her, helped naturopaths become players in the medical marketplace.

Legislative Alchemy: The New Year
Jann Bellamy on January 12, 2012
Link
A new year brings new opportunities for practicing the magic of legislative alchemy, the process by which state legislatures transform implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments into perfectly legal health care practices, such as naturopathy, chiropractic and acupuncture. Different states have different legislative calendars, but many begin a new session soon after the first of the year. This gives “complementary and alternative medicine” providers a fresh opportunity to increase their scope of practice, insurance coverage and influence.
The state house doors have barely opened but CAM-friendly bills are already being docketed and sent on to health care and other committees for analysis. Unfortunately, legislators seem less than adept at critical thinking when it comes to perusing CAM legislation. To this point, I’ll start with an example from 2011: “Vertebral Subluxation Awareness Month” in Pennsylvania.
Pennsylvania honors the subluxation
Just a few months ago, the Pennsylvania Senate adopted Resolution 195, which I deliver to you unedited (with apologies for the length of the quotation) because there is no better way to convey the sheer foolishness of their action:
WHEREAS, Optimum performance and health of the human body depends on the unfettered, free transmission of mental impulses, or nerve impulses between the brain and all cells, tissues and organs; and
WHEREAS, The flow of mental impulses between the brain and the body passes through the vertebrae of the spinal column; and
WHEREAS, Blockages of mental impulses, called vertebral subluxations, occur when a vertebra misaligns, occludes an opening, impinges on a nerve or otherwise interferes with neurotransmission; and
WHEREAS, A vertebral subluxation can occur regardless of the presence or absence of symptoms; and
WHEREAS, Doctors of chiropractic are the licensed professionals uniquely trained to locate, analyze and correct vertebral subluxations that compromise a person’s health and well-being; therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Senate commend the Chiropractic Fellowship of Pennsylvania for its efforts in educating the public about the importance of having spinal checks for vertebral subluxations; and be it further
RESOLVED, That the Senate recognize the month of September 2011 as “Vertebral Subluxation Awareness Month” in Pennsylvania.
Whereas, I suppose we can be thankful that the Pennsylvania Senate limited “Vertebral Subluxation Awareness Month” to a single month in a single year and hope this does not become an annual event.
While Resolution 195 gave chiropractors something to frame and hang in their waiting rooms, it does not give chiropractors any authority they don’t already possess to foist implausible and unproven health care practices onto the unsuspecting public. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said of other CAM matters currently (or soon to be) pending before state legislatures.
Wisconsin woo
During its 2011–2012 regular session, the Wisconsin Legislature has the opportunity to follow in the footsteps of New Mexico, Minnesota and Rhode Island, and become another state where anyone can practice medicine. Senate Bill 280 would allow anyone to provide a complementary and alternative health service (“CAHS”), which is broadly defined as
any health care practice or method or healing therapy or modality that is not prohibited under [a certain section of the proposed bill, described below] and that is provided by an individual who is not a health care provider or who is a health care provider but is not acting under his or her certificate, permit, or license as a health care provider.
The bill removes the prohibition against the unlawful practice of medicine and surgery, nursing, dentistry, respiratory care, physical therapy, podiatry, psychology, pharmacy, and 18 other professions and occupations for which a license, certificate or permit is required by law, as long as the CAHS provider does not do any of the following:
    • Puncture the skin, except by pricking a finger for purposes of blood screening.
    • Prescribe or administer X-ray services.
    • Prescribe, directly apply, deliver, or dispense prescription drugs or devices that can be used legally only by a health care provider.
    • Perform chiropractic adjustment or manipulation.
    • Recommend to the person receiving the CAHS (at least they don’t call him or her a “patient”) that he or she discontinue treatment prescribed by a health care provider.
    • “Make a specific diagnosis using a medical term that is commonly used and understood in conventional western medicine.”
That last one makes me wonder why CAHS providers are allowed to prick the finger for blood screening. What’s the purpose of blood screening if not a conventional western medicine diagnosis? But making sense is not this bill’s strong suit.
If a person suffers an injury as the result of a CAHS provider’s doing any of the prohibited acts enumerated above, he can sue to recover treble damages along with costs and attorneys fees. Which is cold comfort considering there is no malpractice or other insurance required (and no insurance company would likely write such policies even if it were required). Unless the CAHS provider just happens to be independently wealthy, no attorney is going to take the case anyway. Even multi-million-dollar judgment is worthless if you can’t collect on it.
Note that the right to sue is provided only if one is injured by the CAHS provider performing one of the acts prohibited by statute, but not if the poor person is injured by the hocus-pocus treatment itself. Thus, if the CAHS provider fries you with an X-ray, luckily you can sue for treble damages. But say he invents a non-conventional-western-medicine diagnosis and treats you with hocus-pocus. If it turns out you actually have a conventional-western-medicine-diagnosed cancer and your conventional-western-medicine treatment is delayed due to the course of hocus-pocus treatment, too bad! And what would you sue the CAHS provider for anyway? It’s not malpractice because there is no “practice,” no standard of care.
The drafters of this bill make it clear that CAHS providers are not prohibited from “use of medical terminology or common words to describe a health condition.” Let’s just pray they use the correct medical terminology and don’t get all confused by their lack of education and training in said terminology and what it means.
As well, CAHS providers can give “advice that the individual should consult a health care provider in order to rule out a diagnosable condition,” even though no education and training in recognizing any “diagnosable condition” is required, so how would the CAHS provider know that it needed to be ruled out? One just has to hope that perhaps the CAHS provider, or maybe a friend or relative, had the same “diagnosable condition” that you do and he remembers a few symptoms and connects them to the right “diagnosable condition” and suggests you see a real doctor. (And here I assume they mean “diagnosable conditions” of the conventional western medicine sort.)
This could prove to be a handy feature for the licensed health care provider who steps out of his role as such and into the role of a CAHS provider, free of the strictures of his professional education and training. This is actually permissible under the proposed legislation. Say, for example, an M.D. has chosen to add CAHS to his practice. If, in acting as a CAHS provider, he discovers a “diagnosable condition” needs to be ruled out, he can — viola! — switch back into a M.D. and proceed to employ his western medical diagnostic skills. At which point I assume he can either stay in M.D. mode and prescribe some western medical treatment or — Transformer-like — switch back into a CAHS provider and prescribe CAHS.
Another safety feature: the CAHS provider can legally tell you that your “symptoms may be indicative of or consistent with a specific medical condition,” even though he must leave you up in the air on this one because he can’t legally diagnose your “specific medical condition.” Of course, nothing prevents him from proceeding to treat you with his special brand of hocus-pocus for your “specific medical condition,” whether or not he has in fact stumbled upon a correct diagnosis of said condition, which he can’t tell you anyway. Or, he could possibly be completely wrong about your “specific medical condition,” in which case he would presumably be using the wrong hocus-pocus on you.
One small comfort in this proposed legislation: the CAHS provider must tell you, in writing, that he is about to defraud you and you must acknowledge that he has your permission to do so, also in writing. That is, he must tell you he is not a licensed health care provider, unless he is and is in CAHS provider mode, in which case the proposed legislation is unclear about what to do. He must also provide “a description of the complementary and alternative health service to be provided,” and his “education or other qualifications that relate to the service that is to be provided.” Note that he doesn’t have to have any actual education or “other qualifications,” but if he has them you get to know about it ahead of time.
It will be hard to top Wisconsin Senate Bill 280 for nonsense, but the year is young. To be complete, although they are not quite as full of it as SB 280, here are a few other proposals which may become law during 2012. Let’s hope not.
Vermont “Obamacare”
During 2012, as the mandatory health insurance coverage provisions of the federal Affordable Health Care Act come into play, complementary and alternative providers will be attempting to wrest a piece of the insurance dollar pie from M.D.s, D.O.s, nurse practitioners and other health care providers via state legislation.
In Vermont, Senate Bill 209 seeks to accomplish this by declaiming that naturopaths are primary care physicians. Primary care is currently defined by Vermont law as
health services provided by health care professionals specifically trained for and skilled in first-contact and continuing care for individuals with signs, symptoms, or health concerns, not limited by problem origin, organ system, or diagnosis, and shall include prenatal care and the treatment of mental illness.
Apparently the bill’s sponsors are aware that naturopathy would not necessarily meet this definition, broad as it may appear, so the bill specifically tacks on the phrase “and services provided by a naturopathic physician” at the end.
Just to make it clear, the bill also provides that “to the extent permitted under federal law” licensed naturopaths “may serve as a patient’s medical home” and that they “shall be authorized to work independently and shall not require supervision by any other health care professional.” And, for good measure, the bill requires the state to apply for funds to provide grants and loans to naturopaths for establishing electronic health records systems.
Florida’s big headache
Here in the Sunshine State, chiropractors are trying to add a bit of polish to their tarnished image by inserting themselves into new safety measures for young athletes suspected of suffering a concussion during play.
There are several versions of this proposed legislation circulating. All would require that young athletes be removed from play if suspected of having sustained a concussion and prevent their return to play without clearance by a physician. However, Senate Bill 948 is unique in including chiropractors among the type of physician who can clear the athlete for return to play. The bill also rather grandly establishes a “Sports Medicine Advisory Committee” including three M.D.s, three D.O.s, and, of course, three chiropractors. This is an effort to insinuate chiropractors among the medical professionals who cover youth athletics, with its attendant implication that chiropractors are qualified to be “sports medicine” experts.
The thought of a chiropractor diagnosing, treating, and then returning to play a young athlete suffering a concussion frankly gives me a headache. I suppose, given their belief that just about anything can cause the non-existent “vertebral subluxation” (or joint dysfunction, or manipulable lesion, or one of the many other names they call this putative condition), subluxations are an inevitable by-product of any trauma sufficient to cause a concussion. Thus, the subluxation detection and correction possibilities for the concussed youth are both numerous and guaranteed.
Arizona health care providers busted
Finally, although not exclusively concerned with CAM providers, Arizona House Bill 2035 deserves a mention. Apparently, the Arizona Legislature wants to sniff out exactly who has been inappropriately recommending medical marijuana to patients. Toward this end, the bill would require the boards governing medical and osteopathic practice, as well “The Naturopathic Physicians Medical Board” and “The Board of Homeopathic and Integrated Medicine Examiners” to submit an annual report informing the governor and various other officials of the number of unprofessional conduct complaints about, and investigations conducted of, “suspected unprofessional conduct that relate[s] to medical marijuana recommendations” made by health care providers. If this bill passes, I’ll be keeping tabs on the annual report to see just which type of health care provider is (per capita) getting the most patients stoned. Stay tuned.
Petitioning for redress of your grievances
Unfortunately, there is too often no organized opposition to legislative alchemy. Sometimes the state medical societies will get involved but they cannot be relied upon to oppose every attempt to spread CAM. This leaves the door open to a few proponents leading an entire legislature in creating new laws making nonsense legal.
I urge SBM readers to become part of the solution by keeping up with proposed CAM legislation in your state and letting your state representatives know of your opposition. The cynical among you will protest that this is futile, but don’t be so sure. Linda Rosa, RN and Larry Sarner in Colorado, Rosemary Jacobs in Vermont, and Rita Swan in many states, have virtually single-handedly prevented the spread of legislative alchemy, or are at work doing so now. SBM’s own Kimball Atwood, M.D., has held off the naturopaths in Massachusetts though his dogged efforts. (See here for references to his collected works on naturopathy.) You don’t have to be involved on this scale, but you can at least write a letter, send an e-mail or make a phone call. And to get you started, here’s a website with links to your state’s legislature’s website. From there, you can figure out if legislative alchemy is brewing in your area and do something about it.

Legislative Alchemy: 2012.5
Jann Bellamy on June 14, 2012
Link
Legislative alchemy, as faithful SBM readers know, is the process by which state legislatures and Congress take scientifically implausible and unproven treatments and diagnostic methods and turn them into licensed health care practices and legally sold products. Previous posts have explored this phenomenon in naturopathy, chiropractic and acupuncture.
Our last report on the legislative efforts of CAM providers appeared almost six months ago, the beginning of the legislative year for many states. Now, most legislatures have shuttered the statehouse doors and gone home. So let’s see how the CAM practitioners are doing this year.
Naturopathy
A goal of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) is “full scope of practice” in all 50 U.S. states. They’ve got a ways to go. Naturopaths are currently licensed to practice in only 17 states and the District of Columbia. Bills to expand licensure failed to make it out of committee again during the 2012 legislative sessions of two states, Iowa and Maryland. In Colorado and Virginia, where licensing bills failed to pass in previous years, no new legislation was introduced to license naturopaths in 2012. Bills to license naturopaths are still pending before legislative committees in Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, New York and Pennsylvania. However, in North Carolina and Pennsylvania these bills have been languishing in committee since 2011, making passage appear less likely This is especially true in North Carolina, where the legislative session ends soon.
Another strategy of the AANP is “progressive legislation.” This means that while some compromise in initial licensing legislation may be necessary to get a licensing bill passed, successive attempts can cure any initial disappointments through expansion of scope of practice and insurance coverage, for example. Nowhere was this strategy more successful in 2012 than in Vermont, where “naturopathic physicians” (as the Vermont Legislature calls them) were officially defined as “primary care providers” (PCPs) for the purpose of health insurance coverage. The new law means that naturopathic physician practices can qualify as patient “medical homes” under the state’s Blueprint for Health and that they may practice as such independently and without supervision.

As conceived by Vermont’s Blueprint for Health, all citizens are expected to have a PCP, who heads the patient’s “patient-centered medical home” (PCMH) and who coordinates all of his medical care, including mental health, social work, physical therapy and specialty care. Thus, the law designating naturopathic physicians as PCPs clarifies that a naturopath, if she otherwise meets the state’s PCMH’s requirements, will be in complete charge of the healthcare of any patient who chooses the naturopath’s practice as his PCMH.
One snag in the naturopaths’ Vermont plan was the state’s reliance on the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA) to score PCP practices to see if they qualify as PCMHs. (The NCQA is a non-profit organization that accredits health plans, medical homes, and other components of the health care system nationwide.) However, the NCQA didn’t accept N.D.s as PCMH applicants. (I wonder why.) So the state of Vermont went to bat for naturopaths and now the NCQA has agreed to assess N.D.s for eligibility as PCMHs in Vermont.
Unfortunately, a much-needed counterweight to Vermont’s expansion of naturopathic practice did not make it out of committee. A bill would have required a state pharmacologist to approve the naturopathic formulary. Alarmingly, the current formulary includes colloidal silver preparations, to treat eye infections, and silver, which can be administered intravenously, both dangerous substances which no physician in his right mind would ever use as a treatment. Silver can cause argyria, permanently turning the skin blue or grey, as detailed in this report by Rosemary Jacobs, an argyria sufferer who supported the bill. In addition, the bill would have required N.D.s to clearly state that they are not M.D.s in all promotional materials.
New York’s naturopath licensing bill is wending its way through the Senate and Assembly committee system. However, if passed, naturopathic practice will be quite different than in Vermont.
Both the N.Y. Senate and Assembly versions of the bill begin with the usual false premises of CAM practitioner licensing – that regulation is necessary to protect the public health and welfare and that one way to accomplish this is to require naturopaths to be formally educated in naturopathic schools. Unlike Vermont, though, naturopaths won’t be primary care practitioners as they would be able to practice only under the supervision of a physician. The scope of practice is limited to
Application of non-pharmaceutical and non-surgical treatments, which complement medical treatment, . . . to encourage and facilitate the body’s self healing process.”
In other words, they can practice their vitalism but only if it “complements” a medical treatment. Treatments are limited to
the application of the following healing systems of physical, nutritional or natural agent regiments, dietary changes; vitamins, minerals and other dietary supplements and over-the-counter herbal medicine; counseling and education on lifestyle changes; homeopathy; hydrotherapy, manipulation and mobilization; exercise therapy and mind body therapies such as yoga and meditation.
Naturopaths would be prohibited from using invasive procedures, including surgery, lasers, injections, ionizing radiation, therapeutic ultrasound, and electromyography, among others. As well, they could not use anesthesia, provide obstetrical or psychology services, or interpret x-rays, MRIs, or diagnostic tests. Interestingly, beginning in 2015, naturopaths would be required to complete a one-year “residency” under the supervision of another naturopath.
If this legislation passes, I’ll make two predictions. One, this is simply part of a progressive legislation strategy on the part of naturopaths and they’ll be back before the N.Y. legislature again and again trying to expand their scope of practice and get out from under physician supervision. Two, many naturopaths will be employed by or in partnership with “integrative” physicians, who will use them as a marketing tool and, in an employment relationship, profit center. Just imagine the cachet having a naturopath in the office would add to the integrative brand.
Chiropractic
Chiropractic is already licensed in all 50 states so proposed legislation tends to fall into the progressive legislation category. Over the last few years there have been attempts to expand the scope of chiropractic practice by “updating” a state’s chiropractic practice act, supposedly to reflect chiropractors’ current education and training. This is apparently part of a larger goal of rebranding the chiropractor as a primary care physician with a scope of practice roughly equivalent to a family practice M.D. or D.O., a subject both Harriet Hall and I have addressed in previous posts.
Fortunately, one such attempt failed to get out of committee in the 2011-2012 Minnesota legislative session, but expect more efforts along these lines in the future. Minnesota currently defines “chiropractic” as
the science of adjusting any abnormal articulations of the human body, especially those of the spinal column, for the purpose of giving freedom of action to impinged nerves that may cause pain or deranged function.
Regular SBM readers will be able to translate this as “the detection and correction of the chiropractic subluxation,” which, as regular SBM readers also know, does not exist.
The new, improved definition would have defined “chiropractic” as
the health care discipline that emphasizes the inherent recuperative power of the body to heal itself without the use of drugs or surgery. Chiropractic focuses on the relationship between structure, primarily the spine, and function, as coordinated by the nervous system, and how that relationship affects the preservation and restoration of health.
This meaningless nonsense is taken from the Association of Chiropractic College’s 1996 “consensus” definition of chiropractic, which simply restated basic subluxation “theory.”
The gibberish continued along these lines by giving chiropractors the authority to manipulate “abnormal articulations,” defined to include subluxations and “other pathology that results in . . . disturbances within the nervous system.” This, of course, is simply reworded traditional chiropractic philosophy, which holds that disturbances in “nerve flow” between the brain and bodily organs can cause disease.
The bill also threw in the right to use acupuncture as
a modality of treating abnormal physical conditions by stimulating various points of the body or interruption of the cutaneous integrity by needle insertion to secure a reflex relief of the symptoms by nerve stimulation as used as an adjunct to chiropractic adjustment.
In other words, more gibberish.
But the most alarming language in the bill concerned the broad diagnostic authority given to chiropractors:
‘Diagnostic services’ means clinical, physical, laboratory, and other diagnostic measures, including all types of diagnostic imaging that may be necessary to determine the presence or absence of a condition, deficiency, deformity, abnormality, or disease as a basis for evaluation of a health concern, diagnosis, differential diagnosis, treatment, further examination, or referral.
And look at this definition of “therapeutic services” within the scope of practice:
Rehabilitative therapy, acupuncture, and all of the therapeutic, rehabilitative, and preventive sciences and procedures for which the licensee was subject to examination under section 148.06, including, but not limited to, physical examinations, healthy screenings, and counseling regarding health lifestyles and behavior modification.
The reference to “examination under section 148.06” essentially means that any subject the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners chooses to include in its exams would be automatically included within the scope of chiropractic practice in Minnesota.
A new legislative priority of chiropractors appears to be a law which permits chiropractors not licensed in a particular state to come in and treat patients during “state emergencies declared by the Governor.” I suppose there is nothing like a state emergency to bring out the “subluxations” in a body. A bill with this provision passed in Oklahoma only to be vetoed by the Governor. In South Carolina the same language was included in a bill which died in committee.
In a rare piece of proposed legislation that restricts, rather than expands, the scope of chiropractic practice, the California Senate passed a bill prohibiting chiropractic treatment for hypersensitivity to foods, medications, environmental allergens, or venoms. Unfortunately, this indicates there are enough of these treatments being done by California chiropractors to warrant preventive legislation.
The majority of chiropractic legislation concerned efforts to mandate insurance coverage of chiropractic and indicates just how busy chiropractic lobbyists are. For example, a bill in Oklahoma would have prohibited a greater copayment for chiropractic services than that imposed for a primary care physician for the same or similar diagnosed condition even if “different nomenclature” is used to describe a condition. Presumably, this would mean that if two patients were diagnosed with acute low back pain, and one was treated by a chiropractor, who decided that the cause was “vertebral subluxation complex” and “adjusted” the subluxations, and the other by a family physician M.D., who prescribed a conventional medical treatment, the patient’s copayment for the chiropractor’s service could not be greater than that for the M.D. Fortunately, this bill was voted “do not pass” by a Senate insurance committee and Oklahoma legislature has adjourned.
A few more examples of insurance or coverage related bills and their status:
    • Connecticut: mandates coverage of chiropractic services under state employee health care plans; died in committee.
    • Connecticut: mandates coverage of chiropractic treatment in Medicaid services; died in committee.
    • Indiana: rolls back reduction in Medicaid reimbursement for chiropractic services; died in committee.
    • Iowa: requires that co-payment for chiropractic services be no greater than co-payment for medical services for the same or similar diagnosed condition; died in committee.
    • Kentucky: makes it an unfair trade practice to impose requirements in a provider contract with a chiropractor that restrict, reduce or negate benefits that are otherwise provided to the insured under a health benefit plan, although insurer is not prevented from conducting a utilization review; passed and signed into law by governor.
    • Missouri: requires chiropractors to be reimbursed by Missouri HealthNet Program if services are otherwise covered by program and are within scope of chiropractic practice; voted “do pass” by House health insurance committee but did not pass before the legislature adjourned.
    • New Jersey: requires chiropractors to be reimbursed at the same rate as other health care providers; in committee.
    • New York: includes chiropractic services within the definition of “comprehensive health services” for purposes of health maintenance organizations; in committee.
Acupuncture
An attempt to increase the number of states licensing acupuncturists failed when the Alabama legislature adjourned without taking up an acupuncture practice act.
California, where acupuncturists are licensed, has a number of acupuncture-related bills pending. One, now in committee, requires the state agency overseeing worker’s compensation to determine whether acupuncturists are qualified to conduct disability determinations and, if not, what additional training might bring them up to par. The bill does not specify whether the disability would be based on a conventional Western medical diagnosis or upon traditional acupuncture diagnoses, such as running piglet disorder.
Another California bill establishes a new health care practice, “Traditional Chinese Medicine Traumatology,” which
includes a range of treatments to address both acute and chronic musculoskeletal conditions, as well as many nonmusculoskeletal conditions. Techniques include, but are not limited to, brushing, kneading, rolling, pressing, and rubbing the areas between each of the joints to open the body’s defensive chi and stimulate the energy movement in both meridians.
The Traumatologists will be governed by a non-profit organization, the Traditional Chinese Medicine Traumatology Council, may work only under the supervision of an orthopedic surgeon and must be at least 18 years of age. The bill has passed the California Senate and is now before the Asssembly. Integrative orthopedic surgery, anyone?
To protect consumers from being misled by the use of the title “doctor,” a bill passed by the Senate and now before an Assembly committee would prevent the use of that title by an acupuncturist unless he or she holds an actual doctorate in acupuncture, oriental medicine, or biological science, or something “otherwise related” to the practice of acupuncture. So, apparently, if you have a doctoral degree in, say, zoology, and are an acupuncturist, you can call yourself “Dr.” ?
In Mississippi, acupuncturists were unsuccessful in deleting the statutory requirement that acupuncture patients must have a written referral from a physician and that acupuncture procedures be performed under the general supervision of the referring physician. A bill requiring insurance coverage for acupuncture when it was deemed medically necessary by a physician also died in committee.
Ohio already licenses acupuncturists. A bill passed in the Ohio House and now in the Senate would add “oriental medicine” as a licensed health care practice, defined as “a form of health care in which acupuncture is performed with or without the use of herbal therapy.” Herbal therapy is “the use of foods, herbs, vitamins, minerals, organ extracts, and homeopathy.” Acupuncture practice would be expanded to include
the use of general nonmedical nutritional information, traditional and modern oriental therapeutics, heat therapy, moxibustion, acupressure and other forms of Chinese massage and educational information regarding lifestyle modifications.
A bill mandating insurance coverage for acupuncture diagnosis (including “the use of observation, listening, smelling, inquiring, palpation, pulses, tongue, physiognomy, 5 element correspondences, ryodoraku, German electro-acupuncture, and thermography”) and treatment has been set aside for study in a Massachusetts legislative committee. Similarly, New York is considering including acupuncture treatments in the worker’s compensation insurance program. Both states would benefit from a look at Florida’s expensive experience with acupuncture in no-fault automobile accident insurance coverage.
Utah added homeopathy to the list of permissible acupuncturists’ treatments in a bill signed into law by the governor. Added as well is a strange provision permitting acupuncture, moxibustion and other methods of diagnosis and treatment based on traditional oriental medicine “and modern research,” a term which is undefined in the new statute. I suppose if you held acupuncturists to the literal terms of the statute they couldn’t practice, as none of their diagnostic methods and treatments are based on “modern research,” but I feel confident that an acupuncturist’s definition of “modern research” is far too liberal for that result.
Updates
Legislation discussed in previous posts has reached a resolution, fortunately with good results.
I am happy to report that an extremely ill-conceived Wisconsin bill, which would have resulted in pretty much anyone being able to practice medicine, failed to pass. As I detailed in a previous post, the bill would have removed the prohibition against the unlawful practice of medicine and surgery, nursing, dentistry, physical therapy, psychology, pharmacy and over 20 other health care professions and occupations for which some form of licensing is required by law, as long as the so-called “complementary and alternative healthcare service” provider stayed away from, for example, surgery, x-rays, prescribing drugs, and “conventional western medicine” diagnosis. Of all the ill-advised and dangerous CAM legislation ever proposed, this, in my view, takes top prize.
I am also relieved to report two positive results in my own state, Florida. First, a bill requiring that youth athletes who have suffered a concussion be cleared by a physician before returning to play did not include chiropractors among those authorized to make this evaluation. Chiropractic lobbyists pushed to include chiropractors, representing to the legislature that chiropractors were qualified to manage youth athletes with concussions. This included a boast that there were over 100 “chiropractic neurologists” in Florida. Fortunately, the bill simply requires that a physician trained in the diagnosis and management of concussions do the job, and punts the decision as to who might qualify to a Sports Medicine committee consisting of, among others, eight M.D. or D.O. physicians and one chiropractor, making the chances of chiropractors being included pretty much nil.
The Florida legislature also curtailed some of the abuses of personal injury protection (PIP) no-fault auto insurance medical claims, discussed in a previous post, by limiting the full $10,000 benefit to emergency medical conditions. (Otherwise, there is a $2,500 cap.) The new law also eliminates massage therapy and acupuncture, which accounted for thousands of dollars per claim, from eligibility for PIP benefits.
Conclusion: Legislative alchemy still threatens our health
Congratulations to you if you made it through this morass of legislation and are still awake. I trust that you are suitably alarmed by the continued efforts of CAM practitioners to ply their trades and to be paid for it with your money. And suitably alarmed enough to do something about it. Here’s a website linking to all state legislative websites so you can let your legislators how you feel when CAM legislation threatens in your state.

2013 Legislative Review: placenta take out
Jann Bellamy on January 9, 2014
Link

It’s official in Oregon now. You can take your placenta, along with your new baby, home from the hospital. This was already a practice among the CAM set but apparently new mothers were running afoul of laws designed to protect us from bio-hazards. New legislation exempts “the removal from a health care facility . . . of a placenta by a postpartum mother.”
Now, why would anyone want a placenta? Well, SBM is nothing if not your complete source of all things CAM and Harriet Hall has already covered the subject. The short answer is that in Traditional Chinese Medicine placenta-eating is thought to confer all sorts of health benefits on the new mother. I learned of this new law from USA Today, which explains that “some experts say” it has positive health benefits. Well, thank goodness for that. Wouldn’t want a new law passed without “experts” weighing in.
But if handling a placenta makes you squeamish, not to worry. The Placenta Power Wellness Service in Portland (among others) will steam, dehydrate and encapsulate it into a handy pill form for about $150-$250. (Each placenta will make 80-120 capsules, according to the website). If you wish, you can get raw placenta encapsulation instead. Placenta tincture, placenta salve and a print of your placenta (sort of like those newborn footprints) are available for extra. That would be a real conversation starter, sitting there on the mantel.
According to Placenta Power Wellness Service, anecdotal evidence shows women experience an increase in energy, mood enhancement, milk supply and feelings of elation. Plus, it’s been used in Traditional Chinese Medicine “for centuries.”
And folks, that is all you need to get a statute passed adding practices or products to the legally-available health care armamentarium: anecdotes, sometimes relayed by “experts.” Traditional use is icing on the cake. (Or maybe the placenta.) It’s the reason for the DSHEA, the chiropractic, acupuncture and naturopathic practice acts, “health freedom” laws, and getting the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia dumped in toto into federal law, with updates courtesy of the homeopathic industry. “I’ve seen it work!” “It worked for me!” Depending on the method, the evidence for the astounding variety of practices and products legally permitted by these laws generally ranges between none and some, with, I’d wager, most hovering in the “it can’t work” to the “we don’t know if it works” range. Not to mention the evidence of safety, or lack thereof.
This past year was no exception. Although 2013 wasn’t an outstanding year for pro-CAM legislation, CAM proponents did manage to gain a bit of ground in the states, especially in Colorado. Of course, one might argue that they have been so successful in legalizing CAM in the past that a saturation point of sorts has been reached and there really isn’t that much more to do except perhaps expand naturopathic licensing.
Chiropractic
Chiropractors have been spectacularly successful in the legislative arena. For example, all states permit the detection and correction of the non-existent subluxation. Insurers, however, are not as generous as the government and policies typically exclude unproven diagnostic and treatment methods they employ as well as limit the number of treatments they can give. Chiropractors must then resort to their friends in the legislature for help.
But whether it is because they think the non-discrimination provision of the Affordable Care Act will take care of this alleged “discrimination” against chiropractors, whether states are afraid of paying for mandates themselves (as the ACA may require in some cases), or whether legislators are beginning to wise up, I don’t know. My Lexis search turned up almost 30 bills that in some way attempted to expand payment for chiropractic services. These included coverage of chiropractic services by Medicaid, worker’s compensation and private insurance, lifting limitations on treatments, and requiring that chiropractors be paid the same reimbursement as medical doctors. None of these bills passed in 2013. This doesn’t mean they won’t pass in states that have not completed their legislative sessions, but only a handful of states have sessions that extend from 2013 into this year.
Chiropractors did enjoy some legislative successes although a couple of them were merely cosmetic. The Pennsylvania legislature adopted Senate Resolution 192, once again recognizing September as “Vertebral Subluxation Awareness Month.” The resolution, which could have been drafted by Daniel David Palmer himself, begins:
Optimum performance and health of the human body depends on the unfettered, free transmission of mental impulses, or nerve impulses, between the brain and all cells, tissues and organs of the body. . .
It goes on to warn of the deleterious effects of “blockages of mental impulses,” which “can occur regardless of the presence or absence of symptoms” and “compromise a person’s health and well-being.” And so on, ending with a commendation of the Chiropractic Fellowship of Pennsylvania “for educating the public about the importance of having spinal checks for vertebral subluxations.” Small wonder, then, that the Pennsylvania House was willing to pass naturopathic licensing legislation which includes “organ repositioning” as a mode of naturopathic treatment. (A naturopathic licensing bill is still pending before the Senate.)
In Rhode Island, the legislature passed a “Joint Resolution Prohibiting Discrimination Against Chiropractic Physicians in Rhode Island.” It affirmed that:
chiropractic physicians are entitled to the same rights and privileges as all other allopathic and osteopathic physicians, consistent with . . . the Federal Affordable Care Act prohibiting discrimination against chiropractic physicians.
I suppose this bit of political theater is meant to boost chiropractors’ arguments that they are primary care physicians under the ACA. It conveniently avoids the messy prospect of actually having to get the legislature to amend their Rhode Island practice act to give them the same scope of practice as a PCP. It just gives them a piece of paper to wave around and declare that’s what the legislature intended.
A number of legislative efforts were directed toward permitting chiropractors to perform physicals. (Harriet Hall has explained why they should not be permitted to perform sports physicals.) An added bonus will no doubt be another pretext upon which to argue they are PCPs.
Nevada added a requirement this year that taxi drivers obtain a certificate from a medical examiner that they meet certain health requirements. “Medical examiner” is defined to include medical doctors and chiropractors. In California, chiropractors were added to the list of health care providers who can perform physicals on school bus and farm labor vehicle drivers.
A new statute in Delaware unintentionally reveals a disturbing aspect of chiropractic practice in that state. Delaware law requires the presence of a parent or guardian, or an adult staff member of the same sex, during examination and treatment of minors who are disrobed. Chiropractors are now required to abide by the law when providing treatment to a minor who is undressed or during an exam “involving the breasts, genitalia or rectum.” I suppose this is both good news and bad news. It is good that chiropractors must now have a guardian or staff member present. The bad news is that any chiropractor would examine the breasts, genitalia or rectum of anyone. Exactly what within a chiropractor’s scope of practice would require such an examination? In Delaware, chiropractors are limited to “manipulation/adjustment of the spine and other skeletal structures and the use of adjunctive procedures not otherwise prohibited.” They are specifically prohibited from obstetrical or gynecological exams or treatment.
Chiropractors see physical therapists as an economic threat to their livelihood. They have been successful in getting legislation passed in a number of states prohibiting physical therapists from performing spinal manipulation even though there is no evidence supporting their position.
In Indiana, a new law contains a limitation (although not a complete ban) on PT use of spinal manipulation. While PTs were able to get a limited right to direct access by patients (that is, without a referral), spinal manipulation was specifically excluded. We can all guess who was among those responsible for that exception. PTs still cannot perform spinal manipulation without a referral from a doctor or chiropractor who has examined the patient before referral.
But PTs are fighting back. A 2014 bill has been filed in Washington State specifically allowing PTs to perform spinal manipulation. It will be considered this year and I hope it passes.
While this post focuses on legislation enacted in 2013, one chiropractic bill still pending before the New York legislature bears mentioning. (Legislation pending in 2013 carries over to 2014 in New York.) Current law requires the director of school health services to conduct scoliosis screenings as designated by regulation. The necessity of scoliosis screening of asymptomatic adolescents is debatable but fortunately administrative regulations can adapt to changes in evidence for or against the screenings more easily than any schedule imposed by statute. (Whether NY regulations actually abide by current recommendations, I do not know.) Assembly Bill 6998, however, mandates that:
a scoliosis screening shall be performed by a chiropractor during child’s third, sixth and ninth year of school. [Emphasis added.]
Considering that New York is the fourth most populous state in the U.S., that is a lot of mandatory screenings. What a boon for chiropractic income! And a great way to get the word out that chiropractors treat childhood scoliosis, as this New York chiropractor’s website tells us:
Who Else Wants to Reverse Scoliosis Without Ugly Braces Or Painful Surgery?
The Scoliosis CLEAR treatment system [“adjustments” of “subluxations” included] that helped thousands of Scoliosis sufferers reverse their conditions and take back control of their lives.
Naturopaths, acupuncturists and assorted others
Colorado became the 17th state to license naturopaths. Licensing bills failed in 4 states and but were carried over to this year in 5 states, where they remain pending. (Another bill, in New Jersey, has until January 14th, making passage unlikely.) A couple of attempts to force insurance coverage and one to expand their prescription privileges failed.
The New Mexico legislature passed a bill to exempt “expanded practice doctors of Oriental medicine” from the requirement of getting a state medical imaging certificate to perform “diagnostic ultrasound or ultrasound procedure guidance.” This intrigued me in two ways. One, learning that there was an “expanded practice” version of the Oriental medicine doctor, and two, that any state would think of permitting them to use these procedures at all. Of course, New Mexico is the birthplace of the “advance practice” chiropractor, whose battles over expanded prescription privileges and other accoutrements of primary care practice are well documented on SBM. We should not be surprised to learn, then, that New Mexico also licenses Oriental medicine practitioners as primary care providers with prescription privileges that echo those of chiropractors in that state. Fortunately, the New Mexico governor had the good sense to “pocket veto” this exemption legislation.
Colorado (them again!) expanded the scope of acupuncture practice. Formerly, acupuncture was defined as being based on “traditional oriental medical concepts.” It now includes “traditional and modern oriental medical concepts,” whatever that means. Actually, it probably means pretty much anything they want it to mean.
Colorado law was also amended to authorize “aricular acudetox by trained mental health professionals.” Aricular acudetox is defined as:
The subcutaneous insertion of sterile, disposable acupuncture needles in the following five consistent, predetermined bilateral locations: (I) Sympathetic; (II) Shen Men; (III) Kidney; (IV) Liver; and (V) Lung.
The mental health professional must:
successfully complete a training program in auricular acudetox for the treatment of alcoholism, substance abuse or chemical dependency that meets or exceeds standards of training established by the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association [NADA] or another organization approved [by the state].
NADA presents this summary, dated 2013, of the evidence for auricular acupuncture on its website. Interestingly, not mentioned is a Cochrane review, published on-line in 2008, finding no evidence that auricular acupuncture is effective for cocaine addiction.
Of course, there is absolutely no reason to believe that sticking needles in the ear, or elsewhere, at the “liver” location or otherwise, will affect substance abuse and one could predict that no well-conducted study would show any effect beyond placebo. Fortunately, the legislatures of Alabama and Wyoming showed better judgment than Colorado (admittedly a low bar) and rejected licensing for acupuncturists altogether.
Colorado also enacted the Quack Full Employment Act, officially known as the Colorado Natural Health Care Consumer Protection Act, which, in fact, substantially weakened consumer protections in that state. Fortunately, it is the only state to pass one of these “health freedom” acts last year, perhaps because the so-called health freedom movement has its hands full trying to stop GMOs, or at least get them labeled.
Must we put up with this?
In case you haven’t heard, the Society for Science-Based Medicine is a new organization formed, in part, in response to you readers who wanted a group to represent their interests in the promotion of science-based medicine. I am proud to be a member, and a Board Member, and you can join too. Too often, legislators hear only the pro-CAM side of proposed laws. Opposition generally comes from medical groups, who can easily be painted (fairly or not) as “protecting their turf.” Sensible citizens who support science-based solutions to health care are rarely heard from. But we can change that. Part of my duties will be to keep you abreast of new pro-CAM legislation pending in Congress and the states or, in the rare case, legislation that actually curbs CAM abuses. We’ll include contact information for your state and federal representatives. My plan is to update the list weekly. (You won’t need to join to access the information, but please do anyway.)

Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathy 2013
Jann Bellamy on February 7, 2013
Link
A fresh season of state legislative sessions is upon us and with it comes the ubiquitous attempts by purveyors of so called “complementary and alternative medicine” (or “CAM”) to join the health care provider fraternity. Via the magic of legislative alchemy, state legislatures transform pseudoscientific diagnoses (e.g., “chronic yeast overgrowth”) and treatments (e.g., homeopathy) into faux, but legal, health care. Once the imprimatur of legitimacy is bestowed by the state in the form of a health care practice act tailored to their special brand of quackery, these newly licensed health care providers are free to foist their practices onto an unsuspecting public and charge them for the privilege. All of this is done under the false assumption that such legislation is necessary to protect the public health, safety and welfare.
We might well want to consider how far this whole thing is going. Will practitioners of CAM split into an ever-expanding number of CAM provider guilds, all with their own practice acts? First, chiropractors were the only CAM practitioners who managed to get themselves licensed in all 50 states. Then along came acupuncturists, who are now licensed to practice in over 40 states. A few states license homeopaths. Some states licensed naturopaths early on. Now the naturopaths, licensed in 16 states, are in a full court press to catch up and legitimize themselves with licenses to practice “naturopathic medicine.”
Why? Because, according to Lorilee Schoenback, ND, a Vermont practitioner and American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) Board member:
If the law [the Affordable Care Act, or ACA] is implemented as intended NDs in 16 states will immediately be covered by insurance.
“Implemented as intended” refers to Section 2706 of the ACA, which prohibits “discrimination” in insurance coverage of services provided by any state licensed health care provider. According to the AANP (per Schoenback) this
suggest[s] that if insurers cover a health condition, they must pay any providers are licensed to treat that condition. If the insurer covers a service provided by medical doctors . . ., for example, it must also cover that service when provided by another legal provider, such as NDs, acupuncturists or chiropractors.
Schoenback continues,
it’s a change our nation needs. Our health care system needs prevention-oriented, low-cost primary care that’s effective for chronic illness. There’s no profession that does that better than us.
It is just this sort of evidence-free delusion about their competency that makes further licensure of naturopaths such a disturbing prospect.
One true and many false assumptions
So let’s turn to their current efforts to become licensed primary care providers. The AANP announced licensure in 11 more states as its goal for 2013, and licensing legislation has been introduced to date in six: Arkansas, Colorado (for the umpteenth time), Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts (also for the umpteenth time) and Michigan. David Gorski discussed the Michigan bill in his Monday post, but we’ll analyze it further here.
[I have copies of the bills introduced in all states except Maryland. The office of its sponsor promised to fax me a copy, but I never got it. My discussion will exclude Maryland except for what little information I can get from a summary of the bill, provided courtesy of the Maryland Association of Naturopathic Physicians.]
All bills share certain common assumptions, one of which is true. The others, both express and implied, are made without any evidence and are, in my opinion, false. These assumptions (in italics) and my comments follow.
First, the true assumption: There are naturopaths already practicing in the state even though they aren’t licensed.
Why are they allowed to practice? This is an incongruous state of affairs that no one seems to question. Apparently the way a group of CAM providers bootstraps its way into legality is to practice medicine in some form illegally until the state says it’s o.k. and gives them a license to do so. Why aren’t they being prosecuted for the unlicensed practice of medicine prior to their being licensed? And doesn’t this reward breaking the law?
And now for the false assumptions.
There is a demand for naturopathic health care.
This is stated in the findings of the Arkansas legislature as the raison d’etre for licensing:
A significant number of the citizens of this state are turning to naturopathic practitioners for their healthcare needs.
Other than the self-serving statements of naturopaths and perhaps a few of their patients, how do they know that there is any need or even desire for naturopaths? Specifically to Arkansas, a “significant number” should be, well, a “number” that is “significant.” Unquantified citizens cannot, by definition, be a “number,” and obviously cannot be “significant.”
So what is the evidence that such citizens exist? They don’t cite any. But I happen to have some stats. According to the Centers for Disease Control’s 2007 survey of complementary and alternative health care use, a miniscule three tenths of one percent of American adults saw a naturopath in 2007, up a mere one tenth of a percent from 2002. (National Health Statistics Report No. 12) Even in Washington State, where health insurance coverage of naturopathic services is mandated per state law, a study revealed that only one percent of a large sampling of insured pediatric patients (age birth-17 years) made a claim for naturopathic care in 2002, while 97.5 percent made a claim for a visit to a conventional medical provider. Of 600,000 insured persons (all ages) in Washington, another study found that only 1.6 percent made an insurance claim for naturopathic services in 2002. If giving NDs licenses to practice as primary care physicians and having insurance pay for their services doesn’t bring them in, what will?
Because there is a fictional market for naturopaths, the state must license them as health care providers. Among other presumed reasons, which are not stated, the public has “freedom of choice in health care.” Illinois and Arkansas specifically mention this “freedom” as a mandate for licensing.
Assuming, for the purposes of argument, that citizens desire licensing of naturopaths, let’s address the proposition that state licensing must necessarily follow. This means that licensing of health care providers is basically a popularity contest and equally available to all comers who profess they are such and can chum up enough legislators to agree with them. Whether these self-appointed health care providers actually provide safe and effective health care apparently is not open to question. If they say they do, then, ipso facto, they do. Otherwise, states obviously would not have licensed chiropractors, acupuncturists, homeopaths and naturopaths.
Having dispensed with the notion that safety and effectiveness are relevant to the issue, let’s move on to “freedom of choice.” Outside the inventive minds of naturopaths and other CAM providers, I know of no state or federal constitutional provision specifically guaranteeing a “freedom of choice” in healthcare which would translate into a state mandate that naturopaths be licensed. Apparently this is like those terms that CAM devotees use to sound “science-y.” “Freedom of choice” in health care sounds “legal-y” so they use it without defining what it means or citing the source of this allegedly guaranteed “freedom.”
Regulation of naturopathic practice is necessary to the health, welfare and safety of the state’s citizens.
This is necessarily an assumption behind all health care licensing because it is the constitutional basis of the state’s authority to regulate health care. But as we’ve demonstrated at SBM over and over, licensing naturopaths is anathema to the very notion of health, safety or welfare. One need only read Kimball Atwood’s informative series on naturopathy to thoroughly debunk that notion. Or Mark Crislip’s deconstruction of a naturopathic white paper, which discusses many of their pseudoscientific diagnostic methods and treatments as well as their opposition to vaccination.
And as David Gorski said just this past Monday:
If I’ve pointed it out once, I’ve pointed it out a thousand times. Naturopathy is a cornucopia of almost every quackery you can think of. Be it homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, applied kinesiology, anthroposophical medicine, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine, it’s hard to think of a single form of pseudoscientific medicine and quackery that naturopathy doesn’t embrace or at least tolerate.
Obtaining a “naturopathic doctor” degree from a school accredited by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education, which is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education as the accrediting agency for naturopathic medicine, and passing an exam administered by the North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners qualifies one to practice primary care medicine. (As we’ll see below, this is essentially the scope of practice allowed by the pending bills.)
First, as we know, the Department of Education does not care one whit about course content in general or its scientific validity in particular, and it has said as much. The Department looks only at administrative issues, like record keeping, conflicts of interest and financial stability. Department recognition of an accrediting agency says virtually nothing about the quality of education received at an accredited institution. This leaves a private agency created by and for naturopaths at the controls of naturopathic education.
And it shows. While naturopathic schools have misappropriated the term “medical” and pasted it onto their names, what they teach is nothing like a real medical school. Outside of naturopathy, little is known about the actual content of these courses – the only information available to the outside world are course names and brief descriptions. However, the Textbook of Natural Medicine (2013), the foundational text of naturopathy, provides some insight.
As we’ve previously seen, this text includes a chapter on humoral medicine, the ancient Greek system based on the presumed control over bodily function by the “four humors,” and not just as a matter of historical interest. The Textbook also includes chapters on Ayurveda (ancient Hindu medicine), fasting, glandular therapy, virtually universal food “sensitivities,” chronic candidiasis, functional toxicology and vaginal depletion packs. No responsible physician would use of these therapies or employ these diagnoses in the manner suggested by the Textbook. In addition, the Textbook suggests the use of dietary supplements for illnesses in cases which there is insufficient, or no, evidence of safety or effectiveness.
To add insult to injury, none of the licensing statutes has any residency requirement. Once they’ve graduated from medical or osteopathy school, real primary care physicians must go through residency training, an additional three years of hospital based training caring for the most vulnerable and sick patients.
After ND school, ND graduates head, sans residency, straight for the NPLEX exam, which, again, is created by naturopaths, for naturopaths. No one outside the naturopathic fraternity appears to know what is on this exam or whether it has any relevancy whatsoever to the actual practice of primary care. If anyone knows anything about this mysterious document, please advise. We are all anxious for information.
Apparently, none of this makes the slightest difference to the credulous legislators who introduce and vote for naturopathic licensure.
The naturopathic licensing bills
Now let’s look at what these legislators — based on the false assumptions they’ve made about naturopathic licensing — are going to let NDs do.
Scope of practice:
In all six states an ND can “diagnose” or “evaluate” any human condition, illness or disease in any patient, including children. In other words, they are licensed as primary care physicians, which, as noted earlier, is what they want. In other words, they are limited only by the methods they can use to diagnose and treat, but there is no limitation on what they can diagnose and treat. Here is what they should be able to do, according to one definition of primary care provided by the American Association of Family Physicians (emphasis added):
Primary care is that care provided by physicians specifically trained for and skilled in comprehensive first contact and continuing care for persons with any undiagnosed sign, symptom, or health concern (the “undifferentiated” patient) not limited by problem origin (biological, behavioral, or social), organ system, or diagnosis.
Primary care includes health promotion, disease prevention, health maintenance, counseling, patient education, diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic illnesses in a variety of health care settings (e.g., office, inpatient, critical care, long-term care, home care, day care, etc.). Primary care is performed and managed by a personal physician often collaborating with other health professionals, and utilizing consultation or referral as appropriate.
Primary care provides patient advocacy in the health care system to accomplish cost-effective care by coordination of health care services. Primary care promotes effective communication with patients and encourages the role of the patient as a partner in health care.
Other than providing some routine, non-controversial advice about exercise and diet (widely available from other sources, often at no cost) NDs are not properly educated and trained to practice the necessary elements of primary care, nor should they be allowed to until they can provide adequate evidence – not self-serving conclusory statements – that they have the appropriate skills and training.
The only limitation on their treatment of any condition or disease is in the Colorado bill. When a patient seeks treatment for cancer from an ND, the ND must
“recommend . . . that the patient consult with a licensed physician specializing in oncology.”
Note the disturbing implication here: that an ND is qualified to treat cancer.
“Natural” Treatments and OTC drugs:
All states allow use of some form of “natural substances,” including dietary supplements and homeopathy, which, as David Gorski correctly surmised:
Homeopathy is the perfect quackery. The reason that homeopathy is so perfect as a form of quackery is because it is quite literally nothing.
Most bills specifically include OTC drugs. Some bills also allow amino acids, enzymes, “natural” antibiotics, bioidentical or “natural” hormones and barrier contraceptives and NDs can sell at least some of these products to their patients in all states. By the way, according to the highly regarded publication, The Medical Letter, bioidentical hormones can have the same adverse effects as conventional hormone prescriptions. It concludes:
There is no acceptable evidence that ‘bioidentical’ hormones are safe or effective. Patients should be discouraged from taking them.
Prescription drugs:
These are permitted, including controlled substances, if on the naturopathic formulary, in Michigan (with additional training) and Colorado. “Some pharmaceutical drugs” are permitted in Maryland if on their formulary. As Mark Crislip said:
I will pause here to point out that if a provider believes that homeopathy is a reasonable therapeutic intervention, they cannot be trusted to understand modern pharmacology. . . If I were Pfizer I would be turning my sales force loose on the 800 plus ND’s in Oregon [who can prescribe drugs]: they have no background to understand the truth of what they are told, they have no critical thinking skills, they are used to accepting authority over evidence, they have no issues with being subsidized by industry, and crave respectability. Perfect fodder for the drug rep. They don’t have a chance. And neither do their patients.
Other treatments:
This generally includes some combination of manual therapy, electrotherapy, diathermy, ultraviolet light, ultrasound and hydrotherapy. All of these have legitimate uses, but some have the potential to become quackery in the hands of naturopaths. For example, “hydrotherapy” includes colonic irrigation to remove “toxins,” alternating hot and cold footbaths, and wrapping patients in wet towels. “Electrotherapy” includes “electroacupuncture” and “manual medicine” includes craniosacral therapy.
Surgery:NDs can perform “minor office procedures” in all states but only with additional training in Arkansas and Michigan. (Maryland unknown.) Surgery is not specifically included or excluded in Illinois (best I can tell).
Diagnostic methods:NDs can employ lab testing, physical exam and radiological studies in Massachusetts, Michigan and Colorado, and in Arkansas if permitted by rule. Michigan allows use of “minor office procedures” to diagnose, so presumably can do tissue biopsies. (Not specifically mentioned in Illinois; Maryland unknown.)
As I pointed out in the previous post on last year’s ND licensing bill in Massachusetts:
I will leave it to others to evaluate naturopaths’ level of understanding of conventional lab tests and x-rays. But it is worth noting that the Textbook of Natural Medicine (2013), the foundational text of naturopathic education and practice, has an entire section (Section 2) titled “Supplementary Diagnostic Procedures.” I take “supplementary” to mean “not used in conventional medicine, at least not in this way.” The twenty-two chapters include several tests for detection of the ubiquitous “toxins” naturopaths believe are causing ill health in us all. Other tests address “functional nutritional analysis,” a standard of “functional medicine,” and “immune function assessment,” because, as we know, naturopathy is all about “boosting the immune system,” another fuzzy and essentially meaningless term they use. In addition to being unnecessary themselves, the results of these tests can lead to all sorts of unnecessary treatments, such as vitamins, minerals and “detoxification.”
Governance and oversight:Board of Naturopathy (i.e., self-governance) in Colorado and Massachusetts; Board of Medicine or a state licensing department, with advice from naturopathy advisory board, in Michigan, Arkansas and Maryland (which puts one ND on medical board); Board of Medicine, to which an ND will be appointed, in Illinois.
Specialty practice:Yes, if allowed by rule enacted by governing board, in Massachusetts and Arkansas.
Licensure by endorsement:In other words, NDs can practice in the state if licensed in another state and if they meet certain minimum requirements. Licensure by endorsement is permitted in Illinois, Michigan, Arkansas and Colorado. (Maryland unknown.) This is important because underemployed and unemployed NDs will likely want to move to other states where there is more work. The four ND schools in the U.S. graduate more students than is currently necessary to meet demand, which is negligible.
Other bills
In states where NDs are already licensed, the following legislation is proposed:
Hawaii:Bills filed in the Senate and House makes the legislative finding that “naturopathic physicians [who apparently don’t subscribe to The Medical Letter] are known for their expertise in bio-identical hormones.” Thus, if passed, Hawaii would allow NDs to prescribe bio-identical testosterone, a controlled substance in that state.
Oregon:I previously posted about NDs not getting included in coordinated care organizations (CCOs), which are designed to reduce Medicaid costs, because they don’t practice evidence-based medicine, a statutory requirement for CCO care. As noted in that post, they went crying to their friends in state government to make the mean old CCOs let them participate. This effort has come to fruition in the form of House Bill 2522, which forces CCOs to provide members with access to chiropractic and naturopathic services as primary care and access to acupuncturists and massage therapists for specialty care. The CCOs must pay these providers for their services at the same reimbursement rate they pay to all providers without regard to the license or certification of the provider. So even though the law requires the practice of evidence-based medicine it will also require the inclusion of practitioners who don’t practice evidence-based medicine. Go figure.
Senate Bill 108 attempts to tighten up the regulation of NDs by the Naturopathic Medicine board. According to an article in the Portland Business Journal dated January 30, 2013 (which is no longer available online), the most common complaints “involve personal boundary issues between the caregiver and the patient, as well as the writing of prescriptions for chronic pain management.” Complaints are directed at 4 per cent of licensed NDs (n = about 1,000) but that doesn’t indicate how many are actually practicing, which is likely a lower number.
On the other hand, Senate Bill 302 abolishes the Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine (and the State Board of Chiropractic Examiners, along with other regulatory boards) and transfers all of their duties, including discipline and rulemaking, to a single entity, the Oregon Health Licensing Agency. Whether this will provide some reasonable regulation and oversight remains to be seen.
Help is on the way
Other than the glimmer of hope offered by the possibility of abolishing the Oregon ND Board, these bills continue to demonstrate a remarkable lack of critical thinking on the part of state legislators. So, as you will see in Fighting Back, above, I decided to help them out.
UPDATE
I just learned that a naturopathic licensing bill was introduced in Pennsylvania on February 6. The text of House Bill 612 is not available yet, but a summary provided by its sponsor, Rep. Mark Mustio, contains many of the evidence-free assumptions discussed above:
Licensure of Naturopathic Doctors will help to fill the medical void in many communities lacking general practice doctors. Naturopathic Doctors complete a four-year, graduate level medical school program and pass medical boards. These Doctors are highly trained specialists in the areas of nutrition, herbal medicine, homeopathy, and are the only group of medical providers trained in herb-drug and herb-nutraceutical interactions. . . . Licensure of Naturopathic Doctors will help patients who are seeking naturopathic medical care select qualified and accredited practitioners. . . .Licensure of Naturopathic Doctors would give Pennsylvania residents a choice in their health care and provide for an integrative model of healthcare. The patients of Pennsylvania Naturopathic Doctors deserve access to the care their doctors can provide and the State of Pennsylvania needs quality care providers who will reduce the burden of chronic disease.

Legislative Alchemy: Acupuncture and Homeopathy 2013
Jann Bellamy on March 7, 2013
Link
Acupuncture, or more broadly, Oriental or Traditional Chinese Medicine, is a
weird medley of philosophy, religion, superstition, magic, alchemy, astrology, feng shui, divination, sorcery, demonology and quackery.
And via the particular form of magic known as legislative alchemy, acupuncture is a licensed health care profession in 44 states and the District of Columbia.
A growing body of evidence demonstrates acupuncture is simply an elaborate placebo. Even the CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, says
Although millions of Americans use acupuncture each year, often for chronic pain, there has been considerable controversy surrounding its value as a therapy and whether it is anything more than placebo.
Someone should tell the state legislatures.
During the current state legislative sessions, some 30 bills affecting the practice of acupuncture have been filed. In Wyoming, where acupuncture and Oriental Medicine are not licensed, a bill to do so died in committee. So far, there are no other bills to expand licensed acupuncture practice to the few states where no licensing laws exist. (Note that medical doctors, and in some states chiropractors and naturopaths, can practice acupuncture within the scope of their current practice acts, whether acupuncturists are separately licensed or not.)
In Mississippi, acupuncturists can practice only under the supervision of a physician, with some fairly stringent requirements. First, a physician must perform a diagnostic exam. If a referral to an acupuncturist is made, the physician must specify how the ailment or condition diagnosed is to be treated, the intervals at which the acupuncturist must provide progress reports to the physician, and any conditions or restrictions placed on the course of treatment. The physician must be available for consultation with the acupuncture practitioner at a location not more than 60 minutes away.
Needless to say, Mississippi acupuncturists are not happy with this and got a bill introduced in the current session getting them out from under physician supervision. That provision got dropped in an amendment to the bill, but at that point the acupuncturists were able to add an amendment which would have prevented physical therapists from using “trigger point dry needling or intramuscular manual therapy.” (I guess they wanted something, anything.) Unfortunately for them, that also got dropped by further amendment and all they really got was extension of their practice act until 2017 (or 2016 if a House Bill wins out over the Senate version).
“Wellness promotion”
Odd companion bills have been filed with the Massachusetts House and Senate establishing a “Commission on Acupuncture and Wellness” within the Department of Public Health. The Commission is charged with making
an investigation and comprehensive study of the potential for better integrated use of acupuncture services to expand access, reduce health care costs, and provide improved quality of care to Massachusetts residents.
A report must be presented in six months and annually thereafter. The report will include suggestions for any necessary legislation to implement recommendations.
It appears to be a foregone conclusion that acupuncture can “reduce health care costs” and “improve quality of care,” because the bill forces insurers and other groups, such as health maintenance organizations, to cover acupuncture for pain management, post-traumatic stress disorder, substance abuse treatment and nausea.
The bill doesn’t force coverage for “wellness promotion” via the use of acupuncture, although the Commission on Acupuncture and Wellness is charged, as the name might imply, with “consider[ing] strategies to evaluate and implement effective integration of acupuncture” for that too. I don’t know what “wellness promotion” is or how acupuncture might promote said wellness. Maybe it’s something like chiropractic maintenance treatments, but instead of getting your spine adjusted to remove nerve flow interference you’d be stuck with needles to unblock your chi, whether you need it or not.
Despite all of this, the composition of the Commission on Acupuncture and Wellness does present some tantalizing possibilities. In addition to acupuncturists, the Committee must include members from the public health field, insurance industry and (listen up, Kimball Atwood, M.D.) medical profession. Suppose these dominate the Committee and its report concludes that acupuncture is nothing more than magical thinking which induces a placebo effect and is not effective for anything, including “wellness promotion.” What then?
In Pennsylvania, the acupuncture practice act allows an acupuncturist to
treat a person’s condition without the condition being diagnosed by a licensed physician, dentist or podiatrist for 60 calendar days.
One wonders how the person or the acupuncturist knows there is a “condition” to treat without any diagnosis. In any event, the condition may not be treated beyond 60 days without getting a diagnosis from one of the specified professionals. A bill proposes an amendment to the practice act adding that these limitations do not apply
if a person does not present any symptoms of a condition.
Which brings me to the question: then why is the person being treated? Perhaps this is a veiled attempt to allow the sort of “wellness promotion” the Massachusetts legislation contemplates.
Before we move on to the ever-popular subject of health insurance, one more bill bears mentioning. An Oregon bill addressing several acupuncture topics eliminates “traditional and modern techniques of diagnosis and evaluation” from the acupuncture practice act but does not replace it with any other provision authorizing diagnosis. If this weren’t Oregon, I’d think of this as a step in the right direction but it is probably just a mistake. Or maybe just another sneaky attempt to allow “wellness promotion” by eliminating the need for a diagnosis.
As promised: Insurance
Staying with Oregon for a moment, as I mentioned before regarding naturopaths and chiropractors, a bill would require coordinated care organizations to include acupuncturists as health care providers. They would be paid at the same rate as other specialty care providers. As I said previously, this upends the entire purpose of these organizations, which is to provide better care for Medicaid beneficiaries at a lower cost by mandating that all providers practice evidence-based medicine.
In Vermont, a bill would mandate coverage of acupuncture by Green Mountain Care, the state’s single payer insurance program covering all state residents. In New York, several bills mandate inclusion of acupuncture under worker’s compensation insurance. The New York legislature might want to review Florida’s experience with including acupuncture under the state’s no-fault personal injury protection auto insurance law. When a report showed acupuncture charges per patient were greater than for medical care the legislature wisely removed acupuncture coverage.
“Certified homeopaths”
Homeopathy, as David Gorski rightly says, is the perfect quackery.
Anyone who is any sort of a scientist or has an understanding of science, when confronted with these simple, well-established physical laws, might—just might—start to rethink his belief in something that is so utterly implausible from a scientific standpoint. Indeed, homeopathy is about as close to impossible as anything I can imagine, because for it to “work” multiple well-established laws of physics and chemistry would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong.
Although Connecticut licenses “homeopathic physicians,” who must be medical doctors, there are only 10 of them in the entire state. One can well imagine why, as the cognitive dissonance must be excruciating. Other licensed health care providers practice homeopathy as well, primarily naturopaths, who spend a good deal of time studying it in naturopathy school, where conflict with basic scientific principles apparently is less troubling.
This year a bill has been introduced in the Connecticut legislature to remedy a perceived lack of access to homeopathy practitioners via state certification of “classical homeopaths,” that is, those who have passed the certification requirements established by the Council for Homeopathic Certification but who are not medical doctors.
Hmmm . . . I wonder why all of a sudden classical homeopaths want the imprimatur of state certification? Could it be Section 2607 of the Affordable Care Act?
SEC. 2706. NON-DISCRIMINATION IN HEALTH CARE.
(a) PROVIDERS.—A group health plan and a health insurance issuer offering group or individual health insurance coverage shall not discriminate with respect to participation under the plan or coverage against any health care provider who is acting within the scope of that provider’s license or certification under applicable State law. . . .
I don’t know but you can bet we’ll find out soon enough if this bill passes. If Section 2607 is the motivation classical homeopaths will waste no time in making their demands for coverage, including any plan covering Connecticut state employees falling within the definition of “group health plan” or “health insurance issuer.” Perhaps this knowledge might temper the legislature’s desire for certified classical homeopaths in Connecticut.
The rationale for certification is set forth in a 2011 memorandum addressed to the Connecticut Department of Public Health from “Homeopathy for Connecticut” (HFC), an organization pushing the idea. According to the memo:
The risk of harm to the public is negligible since homeopathy is not a medical practice, homeopaths do not diagnose or treat disease or perform invasive procedures, and homeopathic remedies are available over the counter. Homeopaths indicate homeopathic remedies to assist in a person’s natural ability to restore health. A homeopathic remedy works on an energetic level by stimulating the body to heal itself. Consequently, in the U.S. there are very low rates of consumer complaints, malpractice claims or investigations regarding any type of homeopathic provider. In Connecticut, there have been no malpractice decisions made against homeopaths.
I have to concede the point that few people are actually physically harmed by homeopathy unless they use it as a substitute for real medical care. After all, water and sugar pills are pretty safe. But the HFC apparently is unaware of the several class actions against manufacturers of homeopathic products pending around the country alleging another type of injury — consumer fraud.
I do quarrel with the proposition that homeopaths “do not diagnose or treat disease.” They do, they just don’t call it that. This is clear from a fascinating document on the website of the Council for Homeopathic Certification, the organization whose certification will permit homeopaths to become state certified if this bill passes. According to the HFC, the Council
provides rigorous standards and a national exam that assesses competency in the skills required for professional practice of homeopathy.
The exam includes several case presentations. The Council’s guidelines on presentations provides clear evidence that, whatever they call it, homeopaths do diagnose and treat disease, or at least their version of disease. After all, if a homeopath is going to recommend a homeopathic product it obviously has to be based on some assessment of the patient’s problem and some idea of why a particular product might be beneficial for this problem. (The guidelines also use Anna Karenina as template for successful presentation but I’m not even going to go there. Let’s just say it’s quite a stretch from Tolstoy to homeopathic case presentation and leave it at that.)
But that is not what makes the guidelines fascinating. No, it is getting inside the head of a homeopath during his thought process of determining what is wrong with a patient and how to address it with homeopathic remedies. Or, as we would say, diagnosing and treating the patient. I can’t begin to describe it. You really must read it for yourself. (From the Home page, click on “Case Submission Guidelines” under the “Popular Downloads” heading. See “Acceptable Case (1),” starting on page 6, although the preceding pages are quite interesting too.)
Fighting back
This post, as well as earlier legislative alchemy posts, demonstrates that CAM providers will introduce legislation friendly to their interests, if not in the public interest, each year. And they will keep trying until they get their way. Too often, the only groups opposing this legislation are other health care providers, such as medical societies. This leaves valid concerns subject to dismissal on the charge that there is simply a turf war going on. (Unfortunately, instead of fighting implausible and unproven therapies, some medical doctors and medical institutions give unwarranted credibility to CAM treatments like acupuncture by promoting it as a valid therapy for a number of conditions.)
Unless citizens become more proactive in fighting these initiatives, CAM providers will enjoy an ever-increasing scope of practice and insurance coverage. Several comments have requested more concrete information on how to fight back. We’ll address this important topic in a post soon.

Legislative Alchemy 2014 (so far)
Jann Bellamy on May 15, 2014
Link
Legislative Alchemy is the process by which credulous state legislators turn practitioners of pseudoscience into state-licensed health care professionals. In addition to unleashing quackery such as homeopathy, colonic irrigation, moxibustion, reiki, cranial sacral therapy and the detection and correction of subluxations on the public, these practice acts typically give chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists the freedom of being governed by their own regulatory boards, to which the practitioners themselves are appointed. The boards, in turn, write the administrative rules governing practitioners and handle public complaints about their services. In the worst cases, legislatures simply hand out the privilege of practicing medicine to pretty much anyone.
State practice acts also establish the education and training standards for practitioners by requiring graduation from their accredited schools. Here the federal government lends a hand, by turning accreditation over to private agencies run by the practitioners themselves. The federal government also supports the schools by giving them taxpayer-funded student loans and research money.
If the legislature doesn’t give CAM practitioners everything they want the first time around, they return year after year until fully satisfied. The brass ring is full primary care practitioner status with full health care insurance coverage.
Over half of the state legislatures have either shut down for the year or didn’t have a session in the first place. CAM practitioners haven’t been particularly successful in 2014 but there is still plenty of mischief to be done in the statehouses. Let’s look at how they’ve fared so far.
Chiropractic
Chiropractors are licensed in all 50 states and all of their practice acts include the detection and correction of subluxations. What more could they want? Well, prescription privileges, for one thing, and turf protection for another.
It would be nice if those chiropractors who want to see their profession move toward evidence-based practice would begin with reform of the chiropractic practice acts, but there is no evidence they are taking this route. Perhaps they can get their act together and begin with next year’s legislative sessions.
For now, in what I see as a glimmer of hope that legislators are beginning to “get it,” chiropractors are seeing some pushback. For years, chiropractors have, via protective legislation, successfully blocked physical therapists from performing spinal manipulation, making the argument that PTs aren’t sufficiently educated and trained, which compromised safety. There is no credible evidence to support this position. There is yet another these attempt at turf protection pending in California right now.
But Washington State’s governor just signed a bill into law permitting PTs to perform spinal manipulation, although the requirements for getting the necessary “spinal manipulation endorsement” from the state are somewhat onerous. PTs still can’t legally advertise that they perform chiropractic “adjustment, spinal adjustment, maintenance or wellness manipulation, or chiropractic care of any kind.” Of course, why would they want to?
Chiropractors suffered another defeat in Washington as well. A bill allowing them to perform physicals for school sports and commercial driver’s licenses failed to pass.
Two attempts to expand chiropractic practice, one obvious and one a bit sneakier, also didn’t make it. In Hawaii, chiropractors are limited to the diagnosis and treatment of neuromusculoskeletal conditions related to the spine. A bill would have permitted chiropractors to call themselves “physicians” and to diagnose and treat any patient with any disease or condition by any physical, chemical, electrical or thermal method (including dietary supplements), using diagnostic imaging, ordering lab tests, or using any other method of diagnosis or treatment taught by chiropractic schools and approved by the state chiropractic board. In other words, as long as a chiropractic school taught it and the chiropractic board approved it, you can do it, no matter how ludicrous or dangerous.
In New Mexico, the festively-named Sen. Cisco McSorley once again went to bat for chiropractors and once again struck out. New Mexico is the closest chiropractors have gotten to being full-fledged PCPs, and even at that they have a ways to go. (Despite continued efforts, as Harriet Hall and I have discussed.) As of now, with a little additional training, “advanced practice” chiropractors have limited prescription privileges. Sen. McSorley’s bill would have substantially expanded their ability to prescribe and administer drugs.
In response to SBM posts on chiropractic’s dedication to the subluxation, DCs post comments that we are out of date, that chiropractic schools don’t teach the subluxation any more except as a historical concept, and that only the old-timers still believe in it. Tell that to the Minnesota legislature, where Senate Bill 1665 and House Bill 1850 are pending, redefining chiropractic as:
The health care discipline that recognizes the innate recuperative power of the body to heal itself without the use of drugs or surgery by identifying and caring for vertebral subluxations and other abnormal articulations by emphasizing the relationship between structure and function as coordinated by the nervous system and how that relationship affects the preservation and restoration of health.
Sure sounds like the old subluxation to me. The bills would also allow detection of these non-existent subluxations by CAT and PET scans and MRI.
Chiropractors have long denied the risk of stroke from chiropractic neck manipulation. In Wisconsin, Senate Bill 518 is now before the House Public Health Committee. It would create a Task Force on Neck Manipulation to:
examine risks, benefits, and alternatives to procedures associated with manual and manipulative treatment of the cervical spine. The task force shall also determine the necessity of informing patients of possible side effects resulting from treatments of the cervical spine.
The Task Force would consist of three chiropractic representatives, plus on MD, one DO and one PT, as well as legislative members, giving science a fighting chance.
Naturopathy
In the last two years, naturopaths added Colorado and Maryland to the list of states where they can legally diagnose and treat patients, for a total of 18. In those states where they aren’t licensed or registered they can still offer advice as long as they don’t claim the ability to actually diagnose and treat patients, a limitation that appears to be honored mainly in the breach. The goal of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians is full primary care physician status in all 50 states. Naturopaths fell short of that goal in their latest efforts, with both Colorado and Maryland putting substantial limitations on their scope of practice.
As the AANP promised, the naturopaths will come back year after year and try for more until they get what they want. True to their word, they were back before the Colorado legislature this year in an attempt to expand their scope of practice. Currently, NDs cannot see patients who are under two years of age at all. If the patient is between two and eight, they must give the parents a list of CDC-recommended vaccinations and urge that the child have a relationship with a licensed pediatric health care provider. (A fortunate provision, considering yet another survey demonstrates that ND students are anti-vaccination.) They must also disclose to patients that they are not physicians. Fortunately, a bill to do away with these limitations was defeated. The bill would also have lifted similar restrictions on practitioners of “complementary and alternative medicine,” which, in Colorado, means pretty much anyone who wants to set up shop as a CAM provider. A bill to expand the ND scope of practice also failed in Alaska.
In Hawaii, naturopaths have limited prescription privileges. A Hawaiian physician-legislator introduced a great bill that would have made it a requirement that naturopaths have the same education and training and MDs and DOs to obtain these privileges. Unfortunately, what actually passed, and is now on the Governor’s desk, simply requires beefed up continuing education in pharmacology and prescribing.
A bill to license naturopaths (Iowa) and a bill to implement a 2005 licensing law (Idaho) did not pass. ND licensing bills are still pending in Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey, Rhode Island, New York (passed in Senate, Assembly bill still under consideration), and Pennsylvania (Passed in House, now before Senate). While they vary in specifics, all of these bills would allow NDs to see any patient with any disease or condition, use pseudoscientific treatments like colonic irrigation and functional medicine, prescribe and sell homeopathic remedies and dietary supplements, diagnose and treat nonexistent diseases like chronic yeast overgrowth and adrenal fatigue, and order lab and other diagnostic tests, such as “live blood analysis.” Some would permit limited prescription privileges, like IV administration of “natural” substances. All would allow self-regulation and default to naturopathic organizations to determine who could practice.
Acupuncture
Bills favorable to acupuncturists aren’t doing so well in the Deep South. Acupuncture is not licensed in Alabama, and things don’t look too promising. A bill to license and regulate practitioners of acupuncture and Oriental Medicine is stuck in the Senate Committee on Health with the legislature scheduled to adjourn on May 19th. Next door, in Mississippi, a bill to get acupuncturists out from under the requirement that the patient obtain a physician’s referral failed again this year. And next door to them, in Louisiana, another state that doesn’t license acupuncturists, a bill to create a commission to study whether the state should license them is still pending.
A bill pending in Arizona expands the scope of practice of auricular acupuncture to include treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder, although it limits treatments to five needles per ear, as if that matters. In California, a bill to certify Traditional Chinese Medicine Traumatologists passed in the Senate and is now before the Assembly. TCM traumatology is defined as a system of treatment of musculoskeletal conditions by stimulation of “acupressure points” to “open the body’s defensive chi and stimulate energy movement in the meridians.”
Other CAM-friendly legislation
I’ve saved one of the worst for last. A “chronic Lyme disease” bill passed in the Vermont legislature and is now on the governor’s desk. In an indication of just how strong the Chronic Lyme lobby is, the bill had 31 co-sponsors in the Vermont House.
Not only does it buy into the fictitious disease itself, it includes diagnosis and treatment of multiple systemic infectious disease syndrome. Although the bill doesn’t call it by that name, the syndrome (discussed by Harriet Hall here) is described in its provisions.
The bill notes “a range of opinions in the medical community regarding proper treatment of Lyme disease.” Actually, the “medical community” is confident that CLD is an inappropriate diagnosis and that long-term antibiotic therapy is unwarranted and potentially dangerous. Only outliers, who have created an equally fictitious specialty, Lyme-Literate Medical Doctors (LLMDs), believe CLD is a reality. Naturopaths, on the other hand, don’t seem to have a problem with the widespread condemnation of health care professionals who exploit patients by telling them they have CLD, and why would they? Fortunately for them, NDs, who have a broad scope of practice in Vermont, including prescribing privileges, are included among those who can diagnose and treat CLD.
Apparently because CLD is more of a collection of symptoms looking for a label, diagnosis need not include an actual lab test showing an infection. It can include:
a clinical diagnosis . . . that does not meet the [CDC’s] surveillance criteria but presents other acute and chronic signs or symptoms of Lyme disease as determined by a physician [including NDs]. The clinical diagnosis shall be based on knowledge obtained through medical history and physical examination alone or in conjunction with testing that provides supportive data for the clinical diagnosis.
Naturally, physicians who diagnose and treat CLD do so under the threat of being disciplined for substandard practice. The bill eliminates that possibility. Long-term antibiotic therapy “for the purpose of eliminating or controlling a patient’s infection or symptoms” is permitted and physicians cannot be subject to discipline for prescribing long-term antibiotics as long as the patient is monitored and certain medical record requirements are met. Health insurance will have to cover long-term antibiotic treatment, eliminating cost to the patient as a factor in treatment decisions.
And now, a pitch
The Society for Science-Based Medicine keeps a running tab of CAM-friendly (and the occasional not-so-friendly) bills in the state legislatures. We can’t track all of them, nor can we track every move every bill makes as it wends its way through various legislative committees and onto the floor of legislative chambers and then to the governors’ desks for signing or veto. However, you can keep up with bills in your state and, by going to your state’s legislative website, track them yourself. If you don’t like what you see, contact your legislators and let them know. If you do, let them know that too. There are plenty of posts on SBM with plenty of reasons to support or oppose (depending on what the legislation is trying to do) legislation. Over on the Oppose Naturopathic Licensing! website, I also keep up with naturopathic licensing bills, as well as other bills affecting naturopaths. Plus, you’ll find lots of information on why naturopaths should not become licensed health care practitioners. Even if all you can do is send a link, please do it.
You can bet the chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists, and their lobbyists, are wandering the statehouse halls, even as you read this. Unfortunately, science-based medicine doesn’t have a lobbyist.

2014: Chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists lose in state legislatures
Jann Bellamy onJ anuary 8, 2015
Link


I am happy to report some good news: chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists and assorted other practitioners of pseudo-medicine didn’t fare too well in the 2013-2014 state legislative sessions.
We’ve been following their legislative efforts all year over at the Society for Science-Based Medicine. Some state legislatures meet in yearly sessions. At the end of the year, pending bills die with the session. Some meet only every other year. Others meet in two-year sessions and, in some of these, legislation introduced in one year carries over to the next year. All states with two-year sessions ended these sessions at the close of 2014, except New Jersey and Virginia. If you want to see how your state operates, several websites can help you: MultiState Associates, National Conference of State Legislatures and StateScape.
Chiropractors
Chiropractors are already licensed in all 50 states and all of their practice acts permit the detection and correction of the non-existent subluxation. Having achieved that goal, the focus of chiropractic legislative efforts is to expand their scope of practice (the holy grail, for some, being primary care physician status), turf protection and mandates requiring insurance reimbursement or their inclusion in various activities, such as sports physicals, concussion treatment, and scoliosis detection programs.
The most interesting chiropractic bill, one from Oklahoma, didn’t fall into any of those categories:
Chiropractic physicians in this state shall obtain informed, written consent from a patient prior to performing any procedure that involves treatment of the patient’s cervical spine and such informed consent shall include the risks and possible side effects of such treatment including the risk of chiropractic stroke.
The Oklahoma Chiropractors’ Association thinks informed consent legislation is “dangerous.” According to Chris Wadell, President of the Oklahoma Board of Chiropractic Examiners, informed consent “isn’t needed”:
“We don’t hide from this but it just hasn’t been necessary to do it,” Wadell said. He insists that chiropractors are helping people and are being unfairly blamed for strokes after a patient’s neck is adjusted.
The bill was watered down to a “Task Force on Neck Manipulation.” It passed in the House but not the Senate.
Fortunately, a bill passed and was signed into law by the governor in Wisconsin requiring chiropractors (who already had a duty to obtain informed consent) to inform patients of reasonable treatment alternatives and the risks and benefits of those alternatives. It does not require disclosure of “extremely remote possibilities that might unduly alarm the patient.” The standard for determining what must be disclosed is that of a “reasonable chiropractor,” not what a “reasonable patient” would want to know. We’ll have to see whether chiropractors will inform patients of the risk of cervical manipulation from now on, since the official position seems to be that chiropractic cervical manipulation is not a cause of stroke at all.
Bills in New Mexico and Hawaii sought to expand the chiropractic scope of practice, but both failed. In New Mexico, which I’ve discussed before, chiropractors wanted to get their hands on even more drugs than their limited formulary already allows, which includes injection of “nutritional medicine,” bioidentical hormones and glandulars, among other substances. (They must have all of 90 additional hours of training for this privilege.) This time, they wanted to expand their formulary to include all drugs, including “dangerous drugs” (other than Schedule I and II) used in primary care practice. They’d need a “post-graduate degree in a clinical specialty” (not otherwise defined) for this, plus 650 hours in a supervised “clinical rotation” (again, not otherwise defined).
Both the New Mexico and Hawaii bills contained language which would essentially allow the decision regarding chiropractic scope of practice to default to the chiropractic schools and boards. Of course, the bills don’t say that specifically. What they do say is that chiropractors could diagnose and treat any disease or condition for which they are “educated and trained” (New Mexico) or diagnose and treat with methods taught by chiropractic schools and approved by the state chiropractic board (Hawaii). Even though these bills didn’t pass, I think we are going to see more of this type introduced in the future, pressed by the “DC as PCP” faction. Like naturopathic schools, chiropractic schools could claim they train DCs to be primary care physicians, and thus they would – voila! – become PCPs under state law.
Chiropractors are threatened by physical therapists because PTs are educated and trained to use manual manipulation, but without all the mumbo-jumbo. In California, a bill failed that would have prevented PTs from performing joint manipulations, while in Washington, the governor signed a law that specifically allows PTs to perform spinal manipulations. The law has a comical provision that prevents PTs from using exactly the sort of mumbo-jumbo they avoid in the first place — “adjustments” and “maintenance or wellness manipulation.”
Finally, and thankfully, chiropractors won’t be performing mandated scoliosis screening in New York or sports physicals and commercial driver’s license exams in Washington. Those bills failed as well.
Naturopathy
During 2013-2014, 10 naturopathic licensing bills were introduced, all of which attempted to give naturopaths a broad scope of practice. Treatments specifically permitted in some bills include colonic irrigation and prescription of “natural” medicines, vitamins, minerals and homeopathic substances, including administration by injection or IV. Pennsylvania would allow “visceral manipulation.” An interesting feature of many licensing bills is a provision allowing naturopaths to perform or order diagnostic testing, such as x-rays or those “commonly used” by MD PCPs, as long as it is “consistent with naturopathic education and training.” This is the same sort of open-ended permission we are seeing in chiropractic bills, defaulting to the schools to determine the scope of practice.
Eight of these naturopathic licensing bills were rejected (New York, Massachusetts, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Iowa, Idaho, Rhode Island) leaving naturopaths licensed or registered in only 17 states and D.C. One bill, in New Jersey, is still pending because NJ is one of the two states to carry 2014 legislation over to 2015.
Only one licensing bill, in Maryland, passed, albeit with a scope far short of what they wanted. Maryland will not permit naturopaths to call themselves primary care physicians (or even “physicians,” for that matter). Nor will it allow them to prescribe drugs, use colon hydrotherapy or practice under the jurisdiction of their own board. Instead, they will be under the jurisdiction of the Maryland Board of Physicians, which is currently working on regulations, a subject I covered in a previous post.
Naturopaths also fought to have restrictions on their practice removed in Colorado. In 2013, after numerous attempts by naturopaths (also here), the legislature finally passed a registration (but not licensing) bill. The law prevents them from seeing patients under 2 years of age at all, and places severe limitations on their ability to treat patients between 2 and 8: they must disclose they are not physicians, recommend that the child have a relationship with a licensed pediatric practitioner, and give parents the CDC-recommended vaccination schedule. One of the main purposes of these restrictions was to thwart their efforts to dissuade parents from vaccinating their children. Fortunately, the bill watering down patient protections did not pass and those restrictions remain in place. On the other hand, a Colorado bill to eliminate their ability to prescribe drugs in their formulary and perform minor office procedures did not pass.
Another bill designed to protect patients was passed in Hawaii but only after having been defanged as it moved through the legislature. What began as a bill requiring that naturopaths who wanted to prescribe drugs have the same education as an MD or DO ended up as a law requiring more continuing education.
Naturopaths did get an expansion of their scope of practice in 3 states, but it was significant only in Connecticut, a topic I covered in an earlier post. (A humorous aside: There is a slide presentation, “About Naturopathic Medicine,” on the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians’ website comparing naturopathic “medical” school education to that of the Yale School of Medicine. You’re in good hands, Connecticut!) They can now practice “telemedicine” in Arizona and perform minor office procedures in Utah. A practice expansion bill in Alaska failed.
Insurance coverage
CAM providers crave coverage of their services by public and private health insurance. This can be a mixed blessing, since private insurers generally won’t cover diagnoses and treatments with insufficient evidence to support their use, such as many diagnostic and treatment methods used by chiropractors. This leads CAM practitioners to call on their friends in the legislature to force insurers to cover their services. (State mandates become more problematic under the Affordable Care Act, although the ACA has its own troublesome non-discrimination provision.)
Because bills mandating coverage are so numerous, we don’t follow them on SFSBM. One bill bears mentioning, though, because it is a good example of how CAM providers try to force themselves on health insurance programs via state legislatures.
Oregon created “coordinated care organizations” to provide health care services to Medicaid patients. Obviously, the state gets more value for the taxpayer dollar when ineffective treatments are excluded. So that is what the state did, by requiring that all CCO providers practice evidence-based medicine. Naturopaths, naturally, balked at this.
Not to worry, though. Legislators came to the rescue with a bill that required CCOs to include all state-licensed healthcare providers in sufficient numbers and geographical distribution to give all patients reasonable access. This would include:
Reasonable access to chiropractic physicians [and] naturopathic physicians . . . for all primary care services that are within the scope of the provider’s license . . .
Acupuncturists would have to be included as specialty care providers.
The CCO would have to pay:
. . . the same reimbursement rate for a service to all providers who are acting within the scope of their license . . . and may not vary reimbursement rates solely on the basis of a provider’s license . . .
Fortunately, this bill didn’t pass. Of course, CCOs can choose to include naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists in their provider panels, they just won’t be forced to by the state. Nor would they have to pay the same rate they pay MD or DO physicians.
Acupuncture, TCM and oriental medicine
Acupuncturists really struck out. Of the 7 acupuncture bills proposed, only one passed, and it wasn’t much. Pennsylvania acupuncturists must refer a patient to a physician if they treat a “condition” beyond 60 days. Now they can avoid referring if the patient doesn’t present with a “condition.” This is mystifying, because I can’t imagine why a patient would be getting acupuncture treatments at all if he didn’t have a “condition” that needed treating. The Pennsylvania House also passed a resolution making Oct. 24, 2014, “Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine Day,” because those modalities have been:
used for thousands of years to diagnose and treat illness, prevent disease and improve well-being.
“Used,” maybe. Effective, no.
On a brighter note for consumers, the Pennsylvania acupuncturists must now carry $1 million in liability insurance, which will be enough to attract a personal injury attorney to take a plaintiff’s case should matters go south with the acupuncturist.
Speaking of going south, things did exactly that for acupuncturists in the Deep South. A licensing bill failed in Alabama, Louisiana wouldn’t even create a committee to look into licensing, and Mississippi refused to ditch a requirement that patients have a physician’s referral to see an acupuncturist.
Arizona didn’t pass a bill expanding the scope of “auricular acupuncture” to include PTSD treatment. A bill to create a “Traditional Chinese Medicine Traumatologist” certification passed the California Senate but not the House. If it had become law, these practitioners could treat musculoskeletal conditions by stimulation of “acupressure points” to:
open the body’s defensive chi and stimulate energy movement in the meridians.
“Alternative Health Care Practitioners”
“Alternative Health Care Practitioners” are pretty much anyone who wants to hang out a shingle and advertise himself as such. The Colorado legislature passed a law in 2013, which I call “the Quack Full Employment Act,” allowing folks to do exactly that, but put the same sort of restrictions on their treating children as it did on naturopaths. (Not very flattering for the naturopaths, if you think about it.) A bill tried to remove those restrictions, but failed.
All in all, the 2013-2014 legislative session (or sessions, depending on where you live) were a bust for chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists and assorted other practitioners of pseudo-medicine. Let’s keep it that way for 2015-2016. We’ll be following CAM bills over at SFSBM. These are target-rich subjects, making it inevitable that SBM bloggers will “review” them from time to time as well.
Even better, we at SFSBM aren’t stopping with the Maryland naturopaths in our efforts to give science and consumers a voice when CAM practitioners go for licensing or try to expand their scope of practice. You can help by keeping up with what is going on in your state using the vast amount of information on SFSBM and SBM to educate your legislators. Looks like they could use some help.

Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathic licensing and practice expansion 2015
Jann Bellamy on April 30, 2015
Link


Naturopathy is chock-full of quackery. No doubt about it. Here at SBM and elsewhere, the seemingly limitless nonsense that can be incorporated into naturopathic practice has been documented time and again: detoxification, food “sensitivities,” anti-vaccination ideology, fake diseases (chronic yeast overgrowth, adrenal fatigue, chronic Lyme disease), bogus tests (also here), homeopathy, chelation therapy, assorted other odd-ball treatments, lack of ethical standards, and just general wackiness.
So, let’s give naturopaths licenses to practice primary care! What a good idea.
This affinity for nonsense is perfectly understandable, given their pseudoscience-filled education and foundation in vitalism. Once the scientific method is chucked in favor of “philosophy,” what’s to stop them from simply making things up? As far as I can tell, nothing. But why inflict this on the public under the guise of promoting health, safety and welfare?
To be fair, naturopaths aren’t the only ones who incorporate quackery into their practices. There are chiropractors, acupuncturists, reiki masters, doctors of Oriental Medicine, and “integrative medicine” practitioners. But what sets naturopaths apart, in my mind, is the sheer range of pseudoscience they will accommodate without the slightest hint of doubt in its efficacy or safety and their unwavering belief in their ability to diagnose and treat patients with the expertise and skill of medical doctors. “Delusional” is not too strong a word to describe their utter lack of awareness of their ignorance or the danger to patients they may pose.
We “self-proclaimed guardians of the true definition of evidence-based medicine” are not the only ones to notice this. From the Florida House Committee on Health Care Interim Project Report, January, 2004:
. . . the proposed licensure of naturopathic physicians would likely increase the risk of harm to the public . . .
The American Cancer Society:
Available scientific evidence does not support claims that naturopathic medicine is effective for most health problems.
. . .
Excessive fasting, dietary restrictions, or use of enemas [colonic irrigation], which are sometimes components of naturopathic treatment, may be dangerous. Naturopathic treatment may involve taking unregulated herbs, some of which may have harmful effects. . . .
The Immunization Action Coalition:
Naturopathy and homeopathy are totally ineffective in preventing vaccine-preventable diseases.
Even the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine (although, hypocritically, NCCIM helps keep naturopathic schools afloat by giving them research funds):
. . . little scientific evidence is currently available on overall effectiveness [of naturopathy].
Some beliefs and approaches of naturopathic practitioners are not consistent with conventional medicine. . . and their safety may not be supported by scientific evidence. For example, some practitioners may not recommend childhood vaccinations. The benefits of vaccination in preventing illness and death have been repeated proven and greatly outweigh the risks.
Timothy Caulfield, Professor, Faculty of Law and the School of Public Health, University of Alberta; Comment: “Don’t legitimize the witch doctors,” National Post (Canada):
. . . many naturopathic practices are based on a semi-spiritual theory (the healing power of nature), and have no foundation in science. They reside largely in the realm of pseudoscience.
Not exactly a bunch of wild-eyed, Big Pharma-shill bloggers, are they?
So, why is it that state legislators are, once again, willing to introduce naturopathic licensing and expansion of practice bills? One reason I’ve discovered is that the “naturopathic doctors” will flat out fabricate “facts” in support of these bills, both in the form of the bills they draft (and make no mistake, it is the naturopaths who are drafting these bills) and in the information they give legislators.
(And, speaking of Big Pharma shills, naturopaths are hiring lobbyists to promote their interests in the state legislatures. In at least one Massachusetts legislative session, their state association was given $25,000 to pay for lobbying. Imagine the outcry if, say, Nurse Practitioners were given thousands of dollars by Merck to lobby for increased prescription privileges.)
For example, in (the unfortunately successful) lobbying for licensing in Maryland last year, the Maryland Association of Naturopathic Physicians (now the Maryland Naturoapthic Doctors Association, because they are prohibited from calling themselves “physicians”) represented to the legislature that:
Research confirms that naturopathic medicine is effective in reducing chronic disease, and provides important cost savings.
Where is this “research?” As far as I can tell, it doesn’t exist. In fact naturopathic care is associated with poorer outcomes.
[A] study . . . found that the addition of naturopathic care to conventional medical care reduced incidence of metabolic syndrome and the risk of a cardiovascular event (such as a stroke or heart attack) by a third.
Not true, as David Gorski demonstrated in his deconstruction of this study.
NDs complete . . . over 1,500 hours of direct clinical patient care.
Again, not true, as we know from Britt Deegan Hermes’s revelatory post. (That this is a fiction is more extensively documented on her blog, Naturopathic Diaries.)
12 states . . . have naturopathic licensure legislation pending.
No, they didn’t. And, in fact, of the states where naturopathic licensing bills were pending, all were rejected except in Maryland.
Carnegie Commission of Higher Ed: Naturopathic Medicine Programs reviewed and designated as “Doctors Degree – professional practice” [and] included in this category [are]: MD, DO, DDS, DVM.
No it doesn’t.
New fictions
I must admit, however, that even I was surprised by the “Legislative Intent” section of New York’s latest bills to license naturopaths, fresh off the presses and recently introduced in the Senate and Assembly.
Here we learn of yet another amazing (and totally fabricated) naturopathic ability: their superior understanding of human physiology allows them to anticipate, and therefore avoid, iatrogenic consequences of conventional medical care, the latter due to conventional medicine’s failure to intervene earlier and treat the human body as “a whole living system.” At least, I think that is what they are saying. Sometime their word salads are hard to follow. Take a look for yourself:
The legislature recognizes that in the practice of naturopathic medicine the healing power of nature principle is viewed as being an inherent property in a living organism to heal itself, and is an acknowledgment that synergy results from the coordination of the many chemical and physical reactions of the living system through varied and circuitous feedback pathways making the whole function as more than the sum of its parts.
Let’s pause here to contemplate that this may well be the reason naturopaths are so sure homeopathy works, while the rest of the scientific world remains convinced that it’s nonsense. Must be all that synergy and circuitous feedback pathways only they know about.
Earlier in the bill, we learn that the American healthcare system excels at triage and responding to emergent conditions, but there is an epidemic of chronic disease and “unacceptable degree” of iatrogenic disease. Thus, we must leave the medical doctors to their triage and emergent conditions, because the naturopaths have a better idea of how to handle things:
The number of reactions and resulting complexity and synergy is viewed in the profession of naturopathic medicine as being why treatment of a given physiological process may result in unforeseen nonlocal consequences, including iatrogenic disease; and is why naturopathic doctors investigate and treat the patient as a whole living system, find and remove the cause, and prefer less invasive therapies and substances with fewer side effects. It is also why the naturopathic doctor prefers to intervene early to prevent the occurrence of disease.
So, they no longer claim that they are educated and trained to practice primary care equal to that of MDs and DOs, they are actually better at it.
Maybe this is their secret:
The naturopathic doctor . . . relies on the scientific method in implementing vitalistic, functional, and evidence-based strategies for assessing and treating patients.
I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but there is no way you can rely on the scientific method to implement vitalistic strategies. The scientific method would, in fact, negate every last one of your vitalistic strategies.
As I sometimes do (and here) when blogging about state naturopathic legislation, I have a look around the internet to see what area naturopaths are up to even before they are licensed. This usually ends up looking a lot like what naturopaths in licensed states are doing, making one wonder why they want to bother with licensing in the first place. (Actually, we do know: a veneer of legitimacy and insurance reimbursement.)
In my New York-based browse, I came upon yet another surprise from naturopaths. There’s a whole new naturopathic specialty of which I was previously unaware: the naturopathic geneticist. Let’s take a look at “Dr. Doni’s” website.
Dr. Doni, a graduate of Bastyr, is a former Board member of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and former Executive Director and President of the New York Society of Naturopathic Physicians. In other words, she’s firmly rooted in the mainstream of naturopathic medicine. In addition to the usual naturopathic folderol (leaky gut, adrenal fatigue, the “Hampton Cleanse,” food “sensitivities”) we find that Dr. Doni purports to be an expert in genetics.
As we learn from her website:
Many conventional doctors are not looking at your genetics when you present certain symptoms. Fewer still know how to identify and address genetic mutations. Of those, even fewer will treat your condition naturopathically.
I don’t doubt that “conventional” doctors don’t normally look at your genetics when you present with certain symptoms, probably because those symptoms have nothing to do with genetic mutations. And I have even less doubt that they treat the patient “naturopathically” when genetic mutations are an issue. But Dr. Doni, of course, knows better.
Everyone is different, but most patients with MTHFR or other genetic abnormalities will exhibit with one or more of these symptoms.
And what are these symptoms?
    • Chronic/recurring headaches or migraines
    • Chronic fatigue
    • Miscarriage(s)
    • Abnormal pap smear
    • Infertility
    • Hormonal imbalances (thyroid, ovarian, adrenal, pancreatic, etc.)
    • Auto-immune issues
    • Chronic digestive issues
    • Anxiety and/or depression
    • Brain fog
    • Irritability
    • Sleep issues
    • Aches and pains (including fibromyalgia or arthritis)
    • Difficulty focusing and/or difficulty with memory
Ah, the one true cause of disease (again)! And here Mayo Medical Laboratories was thinking MTHFR testing should be reserved for patients with coronary artery disease, acute myocardial infarction, peripheral vascular artery disease, stroke, or venous thromboembolism who have increased basal homocysteine levels or an abnormal methionine-load test.
Dr. Doni is particularly focused on this MTHFR mutation. Hmmm. Where else have we heard about this from a questionable source of medical information? Oh yes, here, in Steve Novella’s post on “functional medicine” guru Dr. Mark Hyman’s “personalized medicine” for dementia. And in Orac’s take on Hyman.
Dr. Doni will, for a mere $3,000 (4 months; dietary supplements not included), shepherd you through genetic testing, help you understand your genetic mutations and formulate a “natural remedy plan” that will not only reduce or eliminate your symptoms, but also avoid “serious illness” and it’s attendant medications and surgeries. And you can do all of this without ever setting foot in her office. Yes, you can enjoy the benefits of “Dr. Doni’s MTHFR and Genetic Profiling Solutions Package” via Skype!
See what I mean: naturopaths can totally make stuff up and sell it. Of course, to be fair, so can Dr. Hyman. Then again, he’s not a former member of the AMA Board or former president of the Medical Society of the State of New York.
Now, for some good news (and bad)
Ready for some good news about naturopathy? I thought so. Not news naturopaths would consider good, but good news to those of us who take offense at the infliction of nonsense on unsuspecting patients via the licensing of faux doctors.
Idaho actually repealed licensing naturopathic doctors this year! They were licensed in Idaho in 2005, but because of difficulties with implementation, licensing never really got off the ground. A bill was introduced that not only solved that problem, but gave naturopaths an expansive scope of practice: it defined naturopathy as “primary health care,” gave them their own regulatory board and prescription privileges, and allowed their board to approve naturopathic “specialty” practices. (Genetics, perhaps?) Only “gross negligence,” as opposed to negligence (the normal standard for malpractice), could be disciplined.
The whole thing blew up in their faces. Not only did the bill fail, but another passed repealing naturopathic licensing altogether and declared all current licenses “null and void.”
Another licensing bill failed in Mississippi and it appears an Iowa licensing bill will fail as well. Bills to expand naturopathic scope of practice, including varying degrees the authority to prescribe, didn’t pass in Montana, Washington and North Dakota. The North Dakota bill looked as if it might succeed until the legislature heard from Britt Hermes, who gave them the low down on the lack of naturopathic education and training in pharmacology. In Hawaii, naturopaths were unable to get a bill passed allowing them to corner the market in colon hydrotherapy by excluding others from using it.
Unfortunately, a number of licensing bills have been introduced (again) and are still pending: Illinois (for the 6th time); Massachusetts (10 times), Nevada, New Jersey, New York (8), North Carolina (7), Pennsylvania (7), Rhode Island (5). All of these would give naturopaths a broad scope of practice similar to that of a primary care physician, although they vary in details.
For example, Pennsylvania’s bill would allow “visceral manipulation,” a term chosen perhaps to avoid the laughable “reposition body tissues and organs” used in a previous bill, although no more plausible. But it’s no laughing matter that the Pennsylvania bill actually passed in the House and has now moved to the Senate for consideration.
Colorado, a state that appears to have an endless tolerance for quackery, has increased the naturopathic scope of practice just two years after initially allowing them to register (but not become licensed) with the state. This time, naturopaths wanted to overthrow the ban on their seeing patients under two years of age. That ban has now been removed, but with supposed protections for these patients, including providing the parent with the recommended vaccination schedule, more continuing education and recommending the child have a relationship with a licensed health care provider. Naturopaths must have a collaborative agreement with a pediatrician or family practice doctor to “ensure safety” of children under two. Of course, if oversight by a real doctor is necessary for safety, the logical corollary is that naturopathic practice is unsafe. But simple logic seems to escape Colorado legislators.
After the deadline for bill introduction passed, yet another bill was introduced, this time allowing naturopaths expanded prescription privileges. This was courtesy of the Colorado legislative leadership, which has discretion to allow such things for pet legislation. So far, the bill made it to the House floor.
California is contemplating a major expansion of naturopathic prescription privileges, sponsored by Sen. Marty Block. Sen. Block is also a co-sponsor of a bill that would eliminate California’s personal belief exemption. Perhaps someone should tell Sen. Block about naturopath’s anti-vaccination ideology and their ability to grant exemptions under California law.
Connecticut “modernized” its naturopathic scope of practice this year. As they promised, they’re back trying to get prescription privileges, or at least a committee to report to the legislature on expanded privileges, an effort blessed by Dr. David Katz. (Maryland, per last year’s licensing legislation, has a similar “Formulary Workgroup,” which will issue its report to the legislature later this year.) Finally, Oregon is considering a bill allowing naturopaths to choose whether they are “primary care” or “specialty” practitioners under health insurance policies.
We don’t have thousands of dollars to oppose naturopathic bills, but we do have thousands if readers. Go to the Society for Science-Based Medicine’s “Legislative Updates,” find out what’s pending, and contact your legislators.

Legislative Alchemy 2015: Another losing season for CAM practitioners
Jann Bellamy on January 7, 2016
Link

One of the main, but perhaps underappreciated, reasons quackery thrives in the United States is that the states legalize it by licensing practitioners of pseudoscience as health care providers. These practitioners are placed under the regulatory jurisdiction of, well, themselves. I call the whole deplorable process Legislative Alchemy, and you can see all posts on the topic here. It gives practitioners an underserved imprimatur of state authority and leaves public protection from harmful practices to the oversight of those who are themselves engaging in the very same conduct. Each year, dozens of bills are brought before the state legislatures to establish initial licensure or, once that goal is achieved, scope of practice expansion.
Most attempts fail, but CAM practitioners are a dogged bunch, and they will come back each year until they get what they want. It took chiropractors about 60 years to become licensed in all 50 states. Acupuncturists are almost there. Naturopaths lag far behind, but are slowly gaining ground each year, even if it is only via practice expansion in states where they are already licensed. 2015 was a losing season for all, but not without advancement toward larger goals.
Naturopaths
In 2015, naturopaths didn’t come any closer to their goal of licensing as primary care physicians in all 50 states. In fact, in what was undoubtedly a major embarrassment, they lost ground when naturopaths were delicensed in one state, Idaho. And this on the heels of a licensing bill’s failure in that same state. In other words, Idaho said, “not only no, but hell no” to naturopathy.
Elsewhere, licensing bills failed in Iowa, Mississippi, Nevada (a state that otherwise wholeheartedly embraced quackery in 2015), North Carolina, and Rhode Island. While, technically, the 2-year legislature doesn’t adjourn in New Jersey until January 11, naturopathic licensing bills there never even made it to committee hearing, guaranteeing their failure at this point. All told, naturopaths failed in their attempt to gain licensure in 7 states.
Licensing bills are still pending in 5 states, all carryovers from the 2015 sessions of a two-year legislature in Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York and Pennsylvania. (Britt Hermes has a post on the Massachusetts bill on her blog, Naturopathic Diaries.) In Pennsylvania, a bill passed in the House and is now before the Senate Committee on Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure. During 2013-14, bills came perilously close to becoming law in Massachusetts and New York. Gov. Deval Patrick vetoed a bill that passed both houses (under dubious circumstances) in Massachusetts and a New York bill passed in the Senate, only to fail in the House.
Naturopathy: Licensing inadequacy
Reading these licensing bills always presents a frightening prospect: naturopaths, despite their woefully inadequate education and training, are regularly given the authority to diagnose and treat any patient with any disease or condition. This leaves patients open to the possibility that they will be diagnosed with fake diseases like adrenal fatigue, chronic Lyme, and chronic candidiasis, and imaginary malfunctioning thyroids. They can order diagnostic testing and prescribe and sell dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies; sometimes with the ability to administer these substances by IV. In addition to homeopathy, other quackery is specifically permitted in some bills, such as visceral manipulation, hair analysis, colonic hydrotherapy, and “electromagnetic energy” treatments. They often seek the right to refer to themselves as “physicians” and define naturopathy as a form of “primary care.”
When they don’t get their desired scope of practice initially, naturopaths will return to the state legislatures year after year pushing for expansion. 2015 was no exception.
These efforts failed in Connecticut, where they couldn’t even get the legislature to order the Department of Health to look into the matter of giving them prescription privileges; in Hawaii, where they wanted to corner the market on colon hydrotherapy by banning other practitioners from using it; and in Montana, where naturopaths went all out by seeking the essentially the same prescription privileges as MDs.
North Dakota was a particular victory for science-based medicine and a real nail-biter to boot. A bill would have permitted naturopaths to prescribe from a formulary established by a Board of “Integrative Medicine,” perform minor office surgeries, and practice naturopathic childbirth attendance. In February, the bill failed in the Senate by a vote of 22 yeas to 25 nays. The very next day, it was reconsidered and passed, 25-22. It then went to the House, where it was voted out of committee with a “do pass” recommendation. But, when it went to the House Floor, the bill failed by a wide margin, 35-56.
What happened to turn things around? Former naturopathic doctor Britt Hermes told the truth. She’s recounted her written testimony before the North Dakota Legislature on her blog, Naturopathic Diaries. There, she exposes the misrepresentations naturopaths make to the state legislatures: the subjects they actually study (homeopathy, botanicals), their medically useless textbooks and the lack of clinical training. She’s done her homework too: a chart compares the pharmacology training of naturopaths versus that of Physician Assistants and Nurse Practitioners, who must practice under the supervision of a physician, and convincingly demonstrates how naturopathic education pales in comparison.
Unfortunately, two practice expansion bills passed in Colorado. One allows naturopaths to inject vitamins and non-prescription drugs. The other is a textbook example (along with a California bill we’ll get to next) of the confusion and ambivalence legislators display over just how far they should go in letting naturopaths play real doctor. It’s as if they know they shouldn’t trust the song-and-dance they’re getting from the naturopaths, but aren’t quite sure what to do about it. (They appear especially concerned about naturopathic anti-vaccine ideology, and for good reason.) This usually results in the expansion (or initial scope of practice) granted in a bill’s original draft being chipped away until arriving at a suitable mishmash of naturopathic privileges and patient safeguards. It never seems to occur to legislators that, if a barricade of patient safety measures must be erected around naturopathic practice, perhaps they shouldn’t be allowed to practice in the first place.
Colorado passed a naturopathic registration (but not licensing) act in 2013, but with provisions protecting children by placing restrictions on naturopathic treatment of pediatric “clients,” including a complete ban on seeing clients under 2 years of age. (Those who see registered naturopaths are referred to as “clients,” not patients.) Naturopaths tried to get rid of these restrictions in 2014, but failed. In 2015, instead of lifting the restrictions altogether, they supported a bill that would allow them to see children under 2 with the same restrictions as apply to clients between 2 and 8 years old: providing parents with the recommended vaccination schedule, requiring 3 hours of yearly pediatric continuing education, informing parents that the naturopath is not a licensed physician, recommending that the child have a relationship with a licensed health care provider, and referring a child to a physician if no such relationship exits.
The bill passed and was signed by the Governor, but with even further limitations added along the way during the legislative process: more hours of training, including recognizing a sick infant (imagine that!) and when to refer an infant for more intensive care, and requiring a collaborative agreement with a licensed physician to “ensure safety” of clients under 2.
See what I mean? Another example, as promised, comes to us from California.
Via Senate Bill 538, California naturopaths wanted to remove MD/DO oversight of their prescribing Schedule III – V drugs, including routes of administration and patient-specific protocols in certain cases. They also wanted the right to use parenteral therapy, to perform minor surgical procedures and to perform, review and interpret results of diagnostic procedures, including venipuncture, lab tests, electrocardiograms, diagnostic imaging and biopsies. Disappointingly, the AARP supports the bill.
This major practice expansion was trimmed considerably as the bill moved through the Senate, where it passed. It was then voted down in the Assembly Appropriations Committee, only to be resurrected when reconsideration was granted, and there the bill sits. Even then, Assembly committees pulled back even further on the proposed expansion. In its current form, naturopaths must still have MD/DO oversight for Schedule III- IV controlled substances prescribing. Pharmacists insisted on a provision allowing them to see a standardized protocol when “there is uncertainty about the naturopathic doctor furnishing the order.” Parenteral therapy and minor surgeries and biopsies are out, as well as performing and interpreting diagnostic imaging, although they can order these.
The California Naturopathic Doctors Association (CNDA) is worried that the bill’s chances might be endangered by naturopaths practicing outside their legal scope of practice. In a recent email, the CNDA warned that naturopathic websites with the terms homeopathic, ozone therapy, ultraviolet radiation therapy, alternative cancer care, biotherapeutic drainage, and electrodermal screening are “being targeted.” It urged members to review their websites to ensure that what they offer is within their legal scope of practice. Not to make sure that what they offer is safe and effective, only legal.
This vigilance was prompted by a complaint filed against a Vermont naturopath for using ozone therapy and auto-hemotherapy combined with UV light treatment, a quack procedure involving taking a few ounces of blood and mixing it to ozone gas, then injecting it back into the body via an IV drip, exposing it to UV light on the return trip. According to one naturopath:
Now your blood has been cleansed of UV-sensitive pathogens. If you give that blood a clean slate, and your body can now “see” the antigen structure of those organisms. It knows that those organisms are there, but the organisms happen to be dead, so they’re not going to hurt you. Your body can then see those organisms and mount a much more efficient immune response.
The CNDA noted that, while Vermont naturopaths enjoy a broad scope of practice, ozone therapy is in a “gray area.” According to the FDA, ozone has no useful medical purpose, but when that did that ever stop a naturopath? The CNDA expressed no concern whatsoever that ozone therapy is total nonsense. In fact, it offers its own course in the subject, although an ad for the course was taken down after the Vermont ozone kerfuffle became known. (Fortunately, we have a screen shot here.) Now that’s the kind of unimpeachable ethics and keen knowledge of pharmacology you want in a regulatory board supervising poorly educated and trained people who prescribe drugs.
A Washington bill authorized naturopaths to prescribe and administer legend (prescription) drugs, hydrocodone products contained in Schedule II of the controlled substances act, as well as all controlled substances in Schedules III – V. That bill failed but naturopaths were not deterred for long. A new bill was recently filed that would do essentially the same thing. No additional education or training would be required for these expanded privileges, nor would any regulatory supervision be provided other than the usual oversight of the Washington State Board of Naturopathy. (If you’d like to see this particular Board’s scientific IQ in action, take a look at my SFSBM post on its approval of two quack blood tests. I have to say, given these antics on the part of the California and Washington naturopathic boards, naturopathic education must be sorely lacking in hematology.)
Much to the chagrin of my SBM and SFSBM colleague, Mark Crislip, a new Oregon law forces insurers to allow naturopathic “physicians” to choose whether they’d like to be credentialed as a primary care provider or specialty provider (they are currently limited to the latter). Naturopathy is redefined as “primary care” under state law.
But don’t lose hope!
I see a potential silver lining here. It will be interesting to find out how many naturopaths take advantage of this new option and, of those who do, how many patients use them as PCPs. And, as Dr. Crislip himself recently discovered, the integration of naturopaths into the health care system will provide an opportunity to see what they are up to via the magic of EHRs (electronic health records). As Dr. Crislip recounts, another Oregon doctor was reviewing the EHR of a patient who had seen a naturopath. All that was in the patient’s assessment and plan was “Phelgm Misting Orifice.” (I’ll let him tell you the rest of the story.)
Chiropractors
Because chiropractors are already licensed in all 50 states, their legislative efforts are directed at expanding their scope of practice and increasing insurance coverage of their services.
One practice-expansion tactic they use is getting a bill passed defining their scope by reference to what they are taught in chiropractic school. For example, in Hawaii, chiropractic practice is limited to “adjustments” of the spine, with some exceptions allowing them to treat certain extra-spinal neuromuscular conditions. A bill was introduced eliminating those restrictions and allowing chiropractors to diagnose and treat any disease or condition (except through the use of legend drugs or surgery) as long as the diagnostic methods and treatments were taught by an accredited chiropractic college. Fortunately, the bill failed.
Now you can see why the intra-fraternal wars over the Council on Chiropractic Education and its accreditation standards aren’t just academic. It’s all part of a strategy to refashion chiropractors into primary care physicians, or at least substantially increase their income potential by allowing chiropractors do to more types of procedures. If the states default to the schools to decide the chiropractic scope of practice, and the CCE controls school curricula, what the CCE says the schools must teach becomes very, very important.
New Mexico gives chiropractors the most liberal scope of practice in the country, including the right to prescribe certain drugs if they have 90 hours of additional training, making them “advanced practice” chiropractors. A bill was introduced to expand that scope even further by allowing chiropractors to diagnose and treat any condition for which they have been “educated and trained.” Another “advanced practice” chiropractic tier was added (“Level Two”), allowing the prescription, injection, and dispensing of all dangerous drugs (as defined by state law) except Schedule I and II controlled substances, as long as they are drugs used in standard primary care practice. The chiropractic board was given the authority to add other drugs to the formulary “in consultation with” (but not approval of) the pharmacy board. The pharmacy board had gotten in the way of the chiropractic board’s previous efforts to expand the formulary, thus the need to neutralize its ability to interfere. Fortunately, this expansion effort didn’t pass.
A more modest attempt to add limited prescription rights to chiropractic scope of practice failed in Arizona as well, as did a bill establishing a certification in “animal chiropractic.” In Ohio, chiropractors want to recommend, distribute, administer, and sell non-prescription drugs, vitamins, minerals, antioxidents, other dietary supplements, homeopathic products, glandulars, and medical equipment. All real money-makers, especially where bogus tests for “deficiencies” will reliably detect a need for these products. That bill is still in committee.
In Mississippi and Louisiana, bills were introduced to remove restrictions on chiropractors’ use of diagnostic tests and imaging. Those didn’t pass either. Chiropractors in Texas were unsuccessful with a bill that would have enlarged their scope from analyzing and treating a “biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system” by adding the phrase “or the condition of another system of the human body that is affected by the musculoskeletal system.” One can well imagine that a creative interpretation of this additional phrase would have made their scope practically limitless.
A different sort of prescription issue remains pending in Michigan, where chiropractors want the authority to prescribe physical therapy. PTs, as well as MDs and insurance and business interests, oppose the bill. Under state law, patients have direct access to PTs in limited cases. PTs take the position that chiropractors can already refer patients who are eligible for this direct access. However, for more complicated cases, only an MD, DO, DPM, or DDS/DMD is properly educated and trained to fully assess the patient’s biomedical issues and determine whether physical therapy, drugs, surgery or some other treatment is appropriate. Chiropractors have neither the education nor scope of practice to properly assess all of these treatment options.
Another money maker is the authority to perform physical and eye exams. Attempts to gain both in Nebraska and the right to perform commercial driver’s license exams in Virginia didn’t pass. Finally, Wyoming chiropractors wanted to call themselves “chiropractic physicians.” That one didn’t make it either.
In case you weren’t counting, all told there were a dozen attempts to improve the chiropractic lot in 2015 via the state legislatures. All failed except the two, in Ohio and Michigan. Those remain pending during the 2016 session.
Acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine and oriental medicine
Acupuncturists fared somewhat better in 2015 than their fellow practitioners of pseudoscience. North Dakota passed an acupuncture practice act, although their scope of practice is fairly narrow. It includes botanical medicine and needle acupuncture, but without “electronic stimulation.” Rhode Island added the practice of “oriental medicine” to its acupuncture practice act, defined quite broadly as a form of “primary health care” using Chinese medical and acupuncture diagnosis, including “newer scientific models” for “assessment, treatment, prevention and cure of any disease.”
In Colorado, acupuncturists were successful in expanding their scope of practice to include injection therapy: the injection of sterile herbs, vitamins, minerals, homeopathic substances, sarapin, saline, glucose, procaine, and lidocaine into (the imaginary) acupuncture points. Amazing how the rationale for acupuncture and Oriental medicine – that it’s been used for “thousands of years” – conveniently falls by the wayside when they want to expand their practice.
Not all efforts were rewarded. In Iowa, acupuncturists tried unsuccessfully for a substantial practice expansion via adding oriental medicine, but Iowan oriental medicine is apparently different than Rhode Islander oriental medicine. The Iowa version would have included reflexology, magnets, dietary supplements, and “mind-body techniques,” among others. In Oklahoma, their effort to pass an initial licensing act failed, as it did in Wyoming. In Wyoming, acupuncturists wanted their practice to include stimulating “points on the body” with lancets. In other words, they wanted to bleed their patients. Not just metaphorically, via the wallet. They wanted real thing.
In Mississippi, acupuncturists again tried to get rid of the requirement that a patient have a physician referral for acupuncture treatment. They were again unsuccessful. Maine’s governor vetoed a bill that would have established a pilot project for treatment of substance abuse disorders with auricular acupuncture, a method that miniaturizes all the pseudoscience of whole body acupuncture and imposes it on the ear. A bill to expand the practice of acupuncturists in New York remains pending.
And here’s where you come in
Over on SFSBM, we follow the trail of Legislative Alchemy through all 50 state legislatures year-round. Many of the 2015 bills have been resolved, but 2016 is just getting underway. If you are wondering how to stem the tide of quackery, here’s an opportunity. Follow what is happening in your state and, when you see a bill you don’t like, contact your state legislator and tell him/her about it. Between SFSBM and SBM, you have plenty of raw material to compose a killer letter or, for those who want to try out their lobbying chops, in-person presentation. Check your state legislature’s website; some, like Washington, will take online comments on a particular bill from state residents. All will tell you how to contact your legislators.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Naturopaths push licensing and practice expansion while in damage control over IV turmeric death
Naturopaths are in damage control mode over the death of a naturopathic patient due to turmeric infusion, even as they lobby state legislatures for licensing and practice expansion.
Jann Bellamy on April 13, 2017
Link

Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, U.S. naturopaths are again seeking legitimization of their quack practices via licensing and practice expansion bills filed in the state legislatures, over half of which are now in session. Naturopaths are looking for licensing or expansion in at least 16 states this year, with over two dozen bills filed. (This doesn’t even include bills mandating insurance coverage of naturopathic services.) In Oregon alone, where the legislature has already declared, ipso facto, that naturopaths are primary care physicians, six pro-naturopath bills have been filed. Today, we’ll take a closer look at pending bills, with an emphasis on practice expansion.
The recent death of 30-year-old patient Jade Erick at the hands of a licensed California naturopath and Bastyr grad is already having an impact on legislative deliberations. (And this on the heels of the highly publicized death of a Canadian toddler from meningitis last year after his parents purchased a herbal remedy from a naturopathic doctor’s office.) As Steve Novella explained yesterday, Erick died after receiving an IV infusion of curcumin, an ingredient in the spice turmeric, from licensed California naturopathic doctor Kim Kelly, who prescribed it for her eczema. Former naturopath and SBM guest blogger Britt Hermes reported on the Forbes blog that the San Diego medical examiner ruled her death was caused by
severe anoxic brain injury secondary to cardiopulmonary arrest, most likely due to turmeric infusion.
Typical of naturopathic practice, which rejects evidence-based medicine, the fatal infusion was prescribed despite the lack of evidence that curcumin is effective for, well, anything, after having been extensively studied. Nevertheless, it is touted as a near cure-all by naturopaths.
This tragedy is the direct result of Legislative Alchemy, the California legislature having foolishly decided, in 2013, to add IV administration to the naturopathic scope of practice. All that’s required is a paltry 25 classroom hours in IV administration, including a whopping 10 IV setups, and getting a 70% on a 50-question exam. Approved course providers include none other than Kelly’s alma mater, Bastyr, where naturopath Paul Anderson, a proselytizer for curcumin infusions and campaigner against recent FDA efforts to improve the safety of compounded drugs, teaches courses on IV infusions. As both Britt Hermes and our good friend Orac reported, Anderson and the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians have been busy with damage control, including the obligatory digs at “conventional” medicine.
Obviously mindful that California’s naturopathic licensing act is about to sunset, David Field, the head of the California Naturopathic Medicine Committee, which will be charged with investigating any complaint filed against Kelly, was busy with his own tu quoque efforts. Orac uncovered this SOS from Field:
I am in great need of statistics, with references/citations if possible, regarding iatrogenic harm from MDs/DOs, DCs, LAcs, etc. As SOON as POSSIBLE please! ANY and ALL types!
That he needed this information it in his official capacity was made clear by the way he signed off:
David Field, ND, LAcChair, Naturopathic Medical Committee (i.e. Board) of CaliforniaSanta Rosa, CA
(Note to Field: No, the Committee is a Committee, not a Board. It operates under the auspices of the California Osteopathic Medicine Board.)
Field might want to reconsider his strategy of comparing the relative safety of “conventional” and naturopathic medicine in light of a revealing statistic from the 2016 Annual Report of the California Department of Consumer Affairs. California’s physicians and surgeons perform far riskier procedures on a far greater number of far sicker patients than naturopaths, yet the percentage of complaints received against medical doctors relative to their numbers was actually slightly lower than complaints against naturopaths (5.8% vs. 6.3%).
California law currently provides that the Naturopathic Doctors Act, which legalizes naturopathic practice, permits licensing of naturopaths, and establishes the Naturopathic Medicine Committee within the Osteopathic Medical Board, is repealed on January 1, 2018, and subjects the Committee to “review by the appropriate policy committees of the Legislature.” Senate Bill 796, now pending in the California legislature, simply kicks the can down the road for five years by changing the date for review and repeal to 2022. The bill is set for a hearing before the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee on April 24, about a month after Erick’s tragic death. And this after a bruising legislative battle last year when naturopaths unsuccessfully tried to get rid of physician supervision over their prescribing drugs.
There’s also a bill pending to allow naturopaths and chiropractors to perform physicals required for participation in school athletics.
For its part, rather than protecting the public from naturopaths, California Naturopathic Medicine Committee is proposing a scope of practice expansion along the lines of the bill defeated last year, including controlled substances in the scope of practice and removing physician supervision over prescribing. No bill based on this proposal has been introduced.
I’ve argued that the California legislature should allow the Act to sunset and stop further licensing of naturopaths altogether, reluctantly allowing the 600 or so naturopaths currently licensed to keep practicing due to the political difficulties of total delicensing. (Although Idaho did just that in 2015.) This is the approach taken by Florida when it delicensed naturopaths in the 1950s.
The NPLEX Pharmacology Exam debuts
Last year, the North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners (NABNE), which administers the NPLEX exam, admitted that naturopathic education and training was insufficient for prescribing privileges, claims to the contrary made by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians notwithstanding. The NPLEX, according to the NABNE, tested only a naturopath’s knowledge of drugs commonly prescribed by other practitioners, not whether the naturopath herself could safely and effectively prescribe drugs. No word on whether the NABNE went back to the states that already allowed prescribing privileges with this startling news and warned them to amend their practice acts accordingly. Somehow, I doubt it.
Now, the NABNE has quietly debuted the new NPLEX Elective Pharmacology Examination “comprised of 75 stand-alone items” to be completed in 90 minutes. Presumably, this new exam is meant to be the PR tool the NABNE envisioned:
a legitimate way to test pharmacological knowledge will give further credibility to the profession, and may make legislators more likely to consider expanded scope of practice.
Legitimate? Here’s how a representative of the NABNE described the process for creating the exam in an email:
NPLEX has completed the practice analysis to determine which drugs NDs are most likely to encounter in practice. The focus of the examination will be on the knowledge an ND needs to have about those drugs to be able to take their patients off drugs (which is a common patient request) or to safely prescribe drugs when pharmacotherapeutics are warranted.
In other words, they did this back ass-ward. First, they did a practice analysis to determine what drugs naturopaths already encounter in practice. Then they made up a test to see if naturopaths knew what they were doing when they advised a patient to stop using a drug his physician had prescribed or prescribed a drug themselves. (Know what they are doing in theory, at least. Only the naturopaths are privy to the actual exam contents, although you can find some information here.)
One state has already taken the bait via administrative action. A few years ago, Vermont passed a law allowing naturopaths to prescribe drugs (not just substances on their formulary) if they passed a pharmacology exam. The legislature left it up to the Director of the Office of Professional Regulation (OPR) to establish the rules and make up the exam. Those rules require naturopaths to take the National Board of Medical Examiners subject matter exam in pharmacology, the exam given in the Medical Pharmacology course taught through the Department of Pharmacology at the University of Vermont College of Medicine, “or a substantially equivalent” exam approved by the Director. However, without ever amending the rules (that I can find) the Director has decided to replace the real pharmacology exams with the NPLEX pharmacology exam. I have never been able to determine whether a single Vermont naturopath was able to pass the medical pharmacology exams (I’ve asked the OPR twice), giving rise to a suspicion that a new, easier exam had to be substituted if any Vermont naturopaths were going to gain independent prescription rights.
In any event, in spite of the NABNE’s admission, bills seeking expanded prescription privileges are pending in seven states. Two of these have already failed.
Except for a few items listed on their formulary (hormones, for example), Maine naturopaths cannot prescribe drugs. House Bill 393 would have allowed naturopaths to prescribe “certain naturally occurring medications.” Like curcumin and turmeric, perhaps? Fortunately, the Maine Medical Association, unlike some other state medical groups, did its job, showed up at a hearing on the bill and testified against it. The first committee to hear the bill listened and quite sensibly voted it down.
No fewer than three separate bills were filed in Connecticut expanding naturopathic prescribing privileges. (Senate Bills 125 and 314; House Bill 6250). All failed to meet the deadline for further consideration. Connecticut naturopaths lobbied for prescription privileges in 2014, when the state “modernized” their scope of practice, but didn’t get them. Their attempts are no doubt weighed down by a 2014 report from the state’s Department of Public Health, which found their education and training insufficient.
Prescription privileges are at the heart of a battle between the Colorado Senate and House over Senate Bill 106. Colorado’s naturopathic registration law, passed in 2013, required a sunset review by the state’s Department of Regulatory Affairs (DORA) last year. DORA issued a report consisting solely of boilerplate about the review process and regurgitation of naturopathic talking points, reaching the conclusion that “the laws that govern naturopathic doctors ensure competent and qualified practitioners” and, with minor amendments adding naturopaths as mandatory reporters of abuse and requiring reporting of information on malpractice claims, recommended the naturopathic registration law be continued until 2022.
DORA’s report completely ignored the criticisms of naturopathy (insufficient education and training, quack practices, anti-vaccination ideology, for starters) made during a conference call with DORA set up by the Colorado Citizens for Science in Medicine and featuring noted ethicist Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., immunization expert Paul Offit, M.D., and former naturopath Britt Hermes, among others, whose well-founded complaints fell on deaf bureaucratic ears.
So SB 106 was filed, dutifully extending the next sunset date and making the minor modifications to the statute DORA recommended, except that 2 years were shaved off by the Senate, sunsetting the law in 2020. The Senate also amended the bill to clarify that naturopaths are only registered, not licensed (DORA’s report explains the difference). Once the bill got to the House, egged on by naturopaths, the bill turned into something quite different: a major practice expansion, adding, among other substances, chelating agents and hormones to the naturopathic formulary, both of which could be administered IV. (According to DORA’s report, naturopaths lust after hormones: 75% said prescribing hormones was “very important” or “important” to their practice, outranking antibiotics, antivirals, antifungals, and nutrients.) Sunset was bumped back up to 2022 and the registration/licensing clarification unclarified. The Senate refused to concur in the House’s amendments and the bill went to the Conference Committee. The significance of Erick’s death was not lost on Colorado Sen. Irene Aguilar, a physician, who mentioned it in Monday’s Conference Committee hearing. Unfortunately, it appears the House version of SB 106 won the most votes in the Committee, although its fate at this point is uncertain.
Bills adding or expanding prescription privileges are also pending in Hawaii (hormones again), Minnesota (Senate Bill 1514, House Bill 1138, which also include, among other privileges, the right to perform minor surgery), North Dakota (along with office surgery and “natural childbirth attendance”) and Washington (all Schedule III, IV and V controlled substances).
Leave it to the Beaver State
Oregon has declared that naturopaths are primary care physicians and given them privileges to match. Apparently unsatisfied with this state of affairs, naturopaths have managed to get six bills introduced in the legislature further insinuating themselves into Oregon healthcare.
Senate Bill 217; House Bill 2390: Allows naturopathic “physicians” and chiropractic “physicians” to return student athletes to play after a concussion. Sort of like punishing the entire class when a few misbehave, the bill was amended to make all healthcare providers obtain a certificate before they will be allowed to sign off on a return to play. Even a pediatric neurologist would have to get a certificate, just to make sure DCs and NDs learn the basics.
Senate Bill 22: Repeals peer review of naturopaths.
Senate Bill 23: Current law allows naturopaths to do minor office surgery like repair of superficial lacerations. This bill would allow any surgery “that poses little risk to the life of the patient and can be safely performed in an office setting” according to rules set by the Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine, a group of naturopaths who’ve likely never done a single one of the procedures they’re going to authorize.
Senate Bill 856: Amends a variety of state laws, adding naturopathic “physicians” to various protections afforded to, and privileges allowed, MD and DO physicians and other health care providers. Most frightening, it adds naturopaths to health care practitioners who can participate in the state’s POLST (physician orders for life-sustaining treatment) registry.
House Bill 3400: Oregon forces insurers to cover naturopaths as primary care physicians. To protect themselves and their insureds from substandard naturopathic education and training, some insurers have imposed additional credentialing requirements on naturopaths. Like their previous attempt to quash an insurer’s requirement that they practice (gasp!) evidence-based medicine, the naturopaths are attacking the credentialing rules via their friends in the legislature. This bill would prevent insurers from imposing any requirement not also imposed on MDs or DOs.
The legislature would do well to heed the advice of Hawaii insurer University Health Alliance which actually reviewed three years of clinical documents associated with every claim for naturopathic services (Hawaii has an insurance mandate pending; UHA’s testimony starts on page 9 of the linked document):
UHA’s coders and physicians have studied the claims and clinical records and worked to reconcile these with standard CPT manual criteria and the Hawaii statutory definition of medical necessity. In addition, appropriate use criteria from a variety of sources have been used in determining whether tests or treatments have been safe, timely, efficient, patient centered, effective and equitable.
The result of UHA’s exhaustive review?
In general, our experience with Naturopaths has not been clinically favorable. . . In view of our three years’ worth of evaluation, UHA does not believe that this is safe or effective care and, therefore, does not favor legislation which will serve to embed naturopathic medicine in a standard health insurance plan.
Healthcare giant Kaiser Permanente also opposes Hawaii’s naturopathic insurance mandate bill.
Licensing and practice expansion: What you can do about it
Naturopaths are currently licensed or registered in 17 states and D.C., with practice acts that vary widely. Because of bills passed last year, they will be allowed to register in Massachusetts in September. They will not be allowed to practice primary care or call themselves “physicians” and must refer patients who are not fully vaccinated to a physician. However, they will be regulated by their own board and allowed to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition. In Pennsylvania, they will simply be allowed to register on January 1, 2018. No scope of practice is specified and they will be regulated by the state medical board, which will enact regulations governing their practice.
This year, initial naturopathic licensing or registration bills have been introduced in Illinois, Indiana, Mississippi, New York (for the ninth consecutive time), North Carolina (for the eighth time), and Rhode Island. A New Jersey bill is still pending from 2016. The Mississippi bill has already failed. You can find out more information on these bills, plus the practice expansion bills, including links to state legislative websites, over on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website, under Legislative Updates, which is refreshed weekly.
Commenters to previous posts on naturopathic legislation have asked if there is some ready reference they could use in opposing naturopathic licensing and practice expansion. Thanks to the indefatigable Britt Hermes, now there is. She has both a page on Naturopathic Diaries devoted to legislative action and a handy pdf you can print out or link and send to your state legislators. To find out more about when your state legislature is in session and how to contact your representatives, SFSBM also has an Advocacy FAQs page. For you Oregonians, who, let’s face it, could really use some help in fighting quackery, there’s also Oregonians for Science-Based Medicine.
Now, get on it.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Naturopathy
Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, naturopathic “doctors” gained state licensure and practice expansion, but also suffered major defeats, in 2017.
Jann Bellamy on December 21, 2017
Link

Legislative Alchemy, the process by which the state and federal governments transform quackery and pseudoscience into legal health care practices, continued apace in 2017. Today we look at state bills (some of which I previewed earlier this year) bestowing undeserved legitimacy on naturopathic “doctors” (NDs) who have degrees from naturopathic “medical” schools, by making them licensed or registered health care professionals. We also look at bills that attempted to expand naturopathic scope of practice, including two hard-fought instances where an attempted power grab backfired spectacularly.
NDs advertise themselves to legislators as being all about health promotion and disease prevention, skilled at treating chronic disease, and capable of addressing the shortage of primary care physicians. Their efforts are boosted by dietary supplement companies, which fund their lobbying.
Unfortunately, these talking points are sometimes parroted in legislation, like pending New York Senate Bill 4297 and Assembly Bill 5913 (read the laughable “Legislative intent” here and here), which would license naturopaths and give them an extremely broad scope of practice. In fact, naturopathic education and training is far inferior to that of primary care physicians (also here) and their patients receive substandard care. Their practices are filled with dubious modalities like homeopathy, unvalidated diagnostic tests, high-dose vitamin and herbal injections, detoxification, and ozone gas therapies. They get away with this because credulous legislators allow it.
With that sobering reminder of the lack of scientific acumen among our state legislators, let’s turn to the 2017 bills and see how they fared.
Step 1: Licensing, Registration or Certification
Bills legalizing naturopathic practice were introduced in six states in 2017: Illinois, Indiana, Mississippi, New York, North Carolina and Rhode Island. A bill carried over from 2016 remains pending in New Jersey. Bills in Indiana and Mississippi failed and, with New Jersey’s current legislative session adjourning in early January, it appears unlikely naturopaths will succeed in that state either.
NDs were successful in gaining licensure in Rhode Island but the legislature significantly narrowed their desired scope of practice. As originally introduced, bills would have allowed NDs to call themselves naturopathic “physicians,” prescribe drugs according to a formulary, perform minor office surgery, order diagnostic imaging studies, prescribe and dispense medical devices (including therapeutic devices, barrier contraception, and durable medical equipment), and use all routes of administration for the substances they can prescribe (e.g., minerals, vitamins, homeopathic remedies and prescription drugs on their formulary), including intramuscular and intravenous injections. Fortunately, none of those provisions survived.
The legislation that did pass makes it abundantly clear that, claims to the contrary notwithstanding, NDs are not primary care physicians. They cannot:
. . . practice or claim to practice as a medical doctor or physician, . . . a primary care doctor, a primary care practitioner, a primary care provider [or] a primary care naturopath . . .
In addition, Rhode Island NDs must have a written collaboration and consultation agreement with a licensed physician. Patients must read and sign a consent form that includes this information:
    • Rhode Island does not recognize doctors of naturopathy as primary care providers and a doctor of naturopathy is not responsible for the overall medical care of any patient.
    • Naturopathic care is intended only as an adjunct to, and not a substitute for, medical care . . . and doctors of naturopathy shall coordinate patient care with physicians and other health care providers.
    • Patients are urged to have a primary care provider and to have all specialty care provided by a properly credentialed physician specialist.
    • All questions regarding prescription medications should be directed to the prescriber or the patient’s primary care provider or licensed registered pharmacist.
Because vaccines are prescription drugs, the last provision should prevent NDs from misinforming patients with their anti-vaccination rhetoric or advising them to forego prescription hormone therapy in favor of desiccated animal glands.
The bad news is that they will still be able to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition using quack tests and “natural” remedies like colon hydrotherapy, homeopathy, and dietary supplements. And they will be under the jurisdiction of a Board of Naturopathy, not the state medical board.
Interestingly, acts deemed “unprofessional conduct” for Rhode Island physicians are not listed in the new law as unprofessional for NDs: They are not prohibited from taking kickbacks, falsifying records, performing unnecessary procedures, refusing to turn over medical records, deceptive advertising, or offering to treat a disease with a secret method (a red flag for quackery).
Licensing bills will remain pending in Illinois and New York (for the ninth consecutive legislative session) in 2018 because these states have two-year legislative sessions. In North Carolina (Senate Bill 258, House Bill 692), perhaps to make the idea of naturopaths practicing medicine more palatable to opponents, a bill will carry over to 2018 that would allow “certification” of NDs. No one should be fooled, however. As in other states, North Carolina NDs would be able to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition, no matter how complex. They could order and perform diagnostic testing, dispense (i.e., sell to patents) “natural” remedies like dietary supplements, “neutraceuticals” and homeopathic remedies, using, among others, rectal and vaginal routes of administration. They would be regulated by a Naturopathic Doctors Certification Board and NDs would comprise a majority on the Board.
As an insurance policy against failing to gain recognition for the eighth consecutive legislative session, N.C. House Bill 277 would create a work group to study “the appropriate oversight and regulation” of naturopathic practice in that state. The bill seems rigged to guarantee a specific outcome. The work group would consist of one public member, two naturopathic “physicians” appointed by the North Carolina Association of Naturopathic Physicians, and two (real) physicians, one of whom must have experience working with naturopaths, a typical requirement in pro-naturopathy bills designed to tip the scales in favor of an “integrative”-type physician sympathetic to pseudoscience. The work group is to “identify an approved study of naturopathic medicine” but defines this phrase so that only one outcome can be reached: The current system of naturopathic education created and run by and for naturopaths.
Step 2: Come back for more
Once they are licensed or registered in a state, naturopaths always come back for more. In 2017, NDs sought practice expansion in 11 states: Alaska, California (2 bills), Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Minnesota, North Dakota, Oregon (5 bills), Pennsylvania, and Washington.
In the 2015-2016 legislative session, NDs fought a bruising, and losing, battle in California to greatly expand their scope of practice. Their original bill removed state-required physician supervision over naturopathic prescribing and allowed NDs to conduct and interpret diagnostic studies, perform biopsies, and administer parenteral therapy, among other liberalizations. Fortunately, the bill didn’t pass.
This year, they had an even bigger fight over the right to practice at all, resulting in a bill (Senate Bill 796) that went through a whopping 8 versions, as competing interests duked it out in the halls of the California Senate and Assembly.
State law automatically repealed the naturopathic practice act in 2018 unless the legislature acted. (I argued, unsuccessfully, that this would be the perfect opportunity for California to rid itself of naturopaths.) Not content with merely sustaining their right to be licensed health care professionals, naturopaths with degrees from naturopathic “medical” schools used the opportunity to try to kill off traditional naturopaths by making their practice illegal. Although they managed to kick the can for further review of their own practice act down the road (until 2022), they not only failed to rid themselves of competition from traditional naturopaths (who can still practice under California’s “health freedom” law), the legislature added new requirements aimed at preventing conflict of interest in continuing education (CE) courses. CE must also:
provide balance, independence, objectivity and scientific rigor,
although this standard is watered down by a provision requiring patient care recommendations in CE courses:
be based on evidence accepted by naturopathic doctors,
an extremely low bar.
Another California bill attempting a practice expansion, in the form of NDs and chiropractors being allowed to perform school physicals for athletic participation, appears dead, having missed a legislative deadline for further consideration, although the legislature’s website reports the bill is “active.”
Like California, Colorado’s naturopathic registration act would automatically “sunset” in September of this year without legislative action. And, like their brethren in California, Colorado’s registered NDs exploited the opportunity presented by legislative review to attempt a vast scope-of-practice expansion. The resulting imbroglio, including a nasty attack on one Senator by the former head of the Colorado Association of Naturopathic Doctors (CAND), ended in a major defeat for Colorado naturopaths.
We’ll begin at the beginning, because the fight over practice expansion in Colorado is a perfect exemplar of the way the naturopathic lobbying machine pumps unsuspecting legislators with misinformation, naturopathic allies in state government turn a blind eye to evidence of naturopathic misdeeds, and allowing NDs into the regulated health professions fold simply legitimizes their harmful practices.
As required by law, in 2016 the Colorado Department of Regulatory Affairs (DORA) issued its Sunset Review of the Naturopathic Doctor Act (passed in 2013). As part of the review process, Colorado Citizens for Science in Medicine arranged a conference call with a DORA representative to present concerns about naturopathic practice. I, on behalf of the Society for Science-Based Medicine, participated in the call, along with former licensed naturopath Britt Hermes, pediatric infectious disease physician Paul Offit, MD, noted biomedical expert Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., as well as a Colorado physician and a pharmacist who is an expert on nonprescription products, including dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies. We presented testimony, supported by studies and other documentation provided to DORA, that:
    • Naturopathy is not based on scientific principles, but rather on tradition and pseudoscience, and lacks evidence of safety and efficacy.
    • Some naturopathic practices (like homeopathic nosodes as a substitute for vaccination and quirky diets for cancer treatment) are dangerous, yet are part of the naturopathic school curriculum.
    • Naturopathic education and training are insufficient for competent diagnosis and treatment and are filled with pseudoscience.
    • Naturopathic practices, like selling supplements to patients and misrepresenting the efficacy of therapies, are unethical under well-established biomedical ethics principles.
    • Seeing an ND can incur unnecessary expense and delay in effective treatment.
DORA, without explanation, failed to address our concerns, and its Review simply parroted naturopathic talking points, such as:
Naturopathic doctors treat acute and chronic conditions, but the emphasis of naturopathy is to prevent disease.
(DORA cites the University of Maryland’s wholly uncritical description of naturopathy for this proposition, one more example of how quackademic medicine promotes pseudoscience to the public’s detriment.)
As Britt Hermes pointed out,
By omitting our critique, DORA prevented lawmakers from learning that naturopathic doctors are trained to use treatments with extremely poor evidence for safety and effectiveness and can lead patients to delay or avoid credible medical care.
DORA recommended that the state continue naturopathic registration with a few minor changes in the statute because:
The laws that govern naturopathic doctors ensure competent and qualified practitioners.
Which DORA could confidently assert only by ignoring both the Colorado Science for Citizens in Medicine and other available evidence that registered Colorado NDs are freely using quack treatments with no interference from the state.
A bill was filed and passed in the Colorado Senate (SB 106), which extended the sunset date until 2020 (when there will be another review), and, following DORA’s recommendations, made minor changes, such as making registered NDs mandatory reporters of child and elder abuse.
But when SB 106 arrived in the House, NDs and their allies radically amended it. It morphed from the drafters’ original intent – to implement DORA’s recommendations – into a giant practice expansion bill, allowing NDs to prescribe hormones and IV vitamins, minerals, chelating agents and amino acids. The House version stripped the bill of a requirement that NDs used the initials “R.N.D.” (Registered Naturopathic Doctor) to avoid public confusion as to their status.
Why hormones? NDs love to prescribe hormones. DORA’s Review revealed that, in a survey of Colorado registered naturopaths, being able to prescribe hormones was “important” to “very important” to 75% of them. This far outranked the importance of being able to prescribe antibacterial, antifungal and antiviral meds.
The CAND was worried that the Senate wouldn’t buy the House’s overhaul of SB 106, so they sent out an SOS asking proponents to contact their Senators with this propaganda:
Naturopathic doctors are well trained on the use of hormone therapy and its dangers. I would like greater choice in my health care provider and the option of using natural hormone therapy if I would ever need it. Intravenous, nutritional therapy has many health benefits, including helping those with a compromised digestive system and those with chronic and acute infections. A recent article showed that IV Vitamin C performed better than IV antibiotics in treating sepsis, a life-threatening illness, and another showed its potential benefits in treating cancer alongside chemotherapy. NDs teach the use of IV Nutritional therapy and are well trained on its efficacy and risks. Since few MDs and DOs offer this therapy in Colorado [I wonder why?] it would be a significant public health benefit for NDs to be able to provide it.
None of these assertions about health benefits and safety of naturopathic practices is true, except the part about there being an article touting the use IV vitamin C in treating sepsis, which was exposed as vastly overhyped and viewed with skepticism by responsible medical authorities, including SBM’s own Mark Crislip, MD. (Not that a naturopath should be allowed anywhere near a patient with sepsis.)
When the House version of SB 106 returned to the Senate, Senators refused to play along. The bill (which went through 7 versions) was stripped of the House’s practice expansion and the original provisions restored. Thankfully, NDs suffered a major defeat, but it wasn’t for lack of effort, which included Denise Clark, former head of the CAND, calling one of the bill’s Senate sponsors a liar, a move that probably didn’t help their cause.
Unfortunately, the Oregon legislature did not follow California’s and Colorado’s lead in pushing back against naturopathic overreach. A new state law will allow naturopathic “physicians,” as they can call themselves in Oregon, to put the life, liberty and health of patients at risk through vastly expanded powers previously reserved for MDs and DOs. Among other powers (which I covered more extensively in this post) NDs will be allowed to:
    • Withdraw medical treatment, hydration and nutrition from a patient when the ND has determined that the patient has a terminal condition and would not likely benefit from further medical care or is at an advanced stage of illness and unlikely to improve, even in the absence of a patient’s having previously expressed his wishes on these issues.
    • Order physical or chemical restraint, or psychotropic medication, for elderly and disabled persons.
    • Sign standing medical orders directing or withholding specific medical treatment (for example, an order not to resuscitate the patient) for seriously ill or frail patients.
    • Determine that a patient is not competent to give informed consent to mental health treatment, as well as consent to that treatment for the patient, including convulsive treatment, psychoactive medication, psychosurgery, and retention in a mental health care facility.
    • Conduct medical examinations of sexual assault and child abuse victims; allows courts to order treatment of child abuse victim by an ND.
    • Make diagnostic evaluations of persons alleged to have mental illness or developmental disability who are candidates for court-ordered commitment to a care facility, and provide medical care, including prescription medications, for mentally and developmentally disabled patients committed to care facilities.
As I said in the previous post:
Those are weighty matters to put into the hands of folks who think water has magical properties.
Naturopathic “physicians” weren’t as fortunate with other practice-expansion efforts in Oregon. Bills failed that would have allowed them (along with chiropractors) to return student athletes to play following a concussion and expanding NDs’ office surgery privileges. Efforts to expand prescribing privileges in North Dakota (again), Connecticut (also again) and Maine failed as well.
Again, because several states have two-year legislative sessions, practice expansion bills that didn’t pass this year an opportunity to get to the governor’s desk in 2018.
No sooner had Pennsylvania passed a naturopathic registration act last session than the NDs were back for more. The new Pennsylvania law did not specify a scope of practice or much of anything else, dumping the whole matter into the lap of the state medical board, which is charged with enacting rules governing their practice. (If you’d like to give the board your two cents worth, you can email the board at [email protected] and asked be added to the list of stakeholders who wish to be kept informed regarding the rule-making process and opportunities for public comment.) Apparently concerned that the medical board might not be as generous as they wished, naturopathic proponents engineered the introduction of a new licensing (as opposed to registration) act (Senate Bill 834) granting NDs a broad scope of practice. That bill remains pending.
Practice expansions are also pending in Alaska (prescription privileges, office surgery, order and perform diagnostic testing), Hawaii (authority to prescribe testosterone), Minnesota (companion bills in House and Senate grant authority to prescribe drugs, minor office surgery, perform speculum and orificial exams), and Washington (expands authority to prescribe controlled substances).
The naturopathic modus operandi is to convince legislators they are all about health and wellness, buoyed with a few anecdotes of supposedly successful treatments delivered via patient testimonials. That’s all your legislators will hear unless science-minded citizens like you show up armed with the facts. Fortunately, Britt Hermes has done the heavy lifting for you by creating a page on her blog, Naturopathic Diaries, devoted to legislative action, and a handy pdf you can print out or link and send to your legislators. You can follow naturopathic bills in your state over on SfSBM’s website. To find out how to contact your state legislators, StateScape provides links to all state legislative websites and member contact information.

Legislative Alchemy 2018: naturopathic licensing and practice expansion shutout?
Naturopathic doctors pushed for licensing and practice expansion in 16 states in 2018. Looks like they are in for a complete shutout.
Jann Bellamy on December 6, 2018
Link

Each year, in a disheartening display of scientific ignorance, state legislators foolishly introduce bills designed to incorporate pseudoscience into the practice of health care, a process I’ve named “Legislative Alchemy.” Nowhere are these efforts more successful than when naturopaths become licensed healthcare professionals via state practice acts, bestowing the imprimatur of government legitimacy on pseudo-scientifically educated and woefully undertrained graduates of naturopathic “medical” schools. Legally permitted to call themselves “doctors” and, in some instances, claim they practice primary care, naturopaths can then go about diagnosing fake diseases and treating real ones with unproven, and sometimes lethal, remedies.
As 2018 draws to a close, we take a look today at how naturopathic “doctors” (or “NDs”, translated as “not-a-doctor” by critics) fared in the state legislative arena during the past year. Fortunately, despite the backing of the multi-billion-dollar dietary supplement industry, their results were decidedly anemic.
With scopes of practice and regulatory schemes varying widely, NDs are currently permitted to practice in 20 states. Naturopathy is illegal or has been abolished in six states. In 2018, eight additional states saw bills introduced to legalize naturopathic practice: Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Mississippi, New York, North Carolina, Oklahoma, and Wyoming. (Some of these bills were holdovers from 2017 in states with two-year legislative sessions.) So far, their efforts failed in Indiana, Mississippi, Oklahoma, and Wyoming. Given the fact that legislatures are about to adjourn in the four remaining states, it appears highly unlikely that licensing legislation will get to any governor’s desk. In fact, with the exception of Michigan, most bills, as we shall see, came to a halt early in the legislative process. (Although, never say never, as we learned in Massachusetts.)
Michigan, the home of SBM’s own David Gorski, MD, PhD, had a close call indeed. For the second time in as many legislative sessions, a naturopathic licensing bill was introduced giving NDs one of the broadest scopes of practice in the country. Senate Bill 826 passed in the Senate and is now before the House Committee on Health Policy, where it appears it will not be taken up before the legislature adjourns.
Whew! Had the bill passed and been signed by the Governor, naturopaths who graduated from accredited naturopathic “medical” schools (unlike MDs and DOs, residency is not required) would be allowed to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition and call themselves “physicians”. They would be regulated by a naturopathic board consisting of six NDs, one MD or DO, one chiropractor, one pharmacist, and two public members. In addition to bogus remedies like dietary supplements and homeopathy (which they could sell to patients), they could prescribe drugs on a naturopathic formulary devised by the naturopathic board. They would be allowed to perform minor office surgery, including biopsies, and could order and perform lab tests (including the bogus testing favored by naturopaths) as well as order diagnostic testing. They could employ almost all routes of administration, including IV, allowing them to inject patients with worthless and potentially dangerous vitamin, mineral and herbal “cocktails”. The naturopathic board would be given the unfettered authority to add “other naturopathic therapies” to the scope of practice if the board thought naturopathic education and training is sufficient. To head off opposition from traditional naturopaths whose practice might otherwise become illegal if a licensing bill passed, the bill did not prohibit practice of traditional naturopathy.
It is interesting that state legislatures continue to include homeopathy as a staple in naturopathic licensing bills even after the FDA has put everyone on notice that no homeopathic remedy has been approved by the FDA, as required by federal law, thus making all of them “subject to FDA enforcement action at any time.” (Although the FDA, for now, is only selectively enforcing the law.) In other words, state legislatures are attempting to authorize the prescription and sale of illegal drugs.
Similarly broad scopes of practice are, or were, on the table in other states.
In Indiana, House Bill 1427 was assigned to the House Health Committee, where it sat without further consideration until the legislature adjourned. A Senate Resolution full of unsupported claims about the putative benefits of naturopathy also failed.
That’s fortunate for the health of Hoosiers, as HB 1427 would have given NDs a scope of practice similar to that of a primary care physician, limited only in the diagnostic methods and treatments they could employ. Allowed treatments included manipulation, colon hydrotherapy, botanicals, homeopathy, dietary supplements, “nutraceuticals”, and nonprescription drugs, using routes of administration that include vaginal, rectal and intramuscular.
If approved by a Board of Naturopathic Medicine (consisting of five naturopaths and two public members), Indiana NDs would have been allowed to prescribe drugs, including controlled substances, and could administer these prescription drugs via intradermal, subcutaneous or intravenous routes of administration. (It is a testament to the audacity of naturopaths that they continue to push for drug prescription privileges when their own Board of Examiners has admitted that their education and training is insufficient to prescribe drugs.) They could order and perform diagnostic testing, including phlebotomy and electrocardiograms, and order and interpret the reports of diagnostic imaging studies.
Despite repeated efforts, naturopathic licensing has not made much headway in the southern U.S. This year was no exception. Bills allowing NDs to call themselves “physicians,” describing naturopathy as “primary health care”, and allowing NDs to treat any patient with any disease or condition, were introduced in Mississippi and Oklahoma. Bills in both states would have allowed NDs to prescribe drugs, perform minor office surgery, and order diagnostic testing, in addition to their usual menu of dietary supplements, colonics, and homeopathic remedies. Mississippi would have allowed NDs to use virtually all routes of administration, including IVs, and practice “naturopathic childbirth attendance“. Fortunately, neither the Oklahoma nor the Mississippi bills ever made it out of committee.
For the eighth consecutive legislative session, bills regulating the practice of naturopathy were introduced in North Carolina, where the session is scheduled to end today. [Update: Statescape now shows the session ending on December 31st. Unlike most states, there is no N.C. constitutional or statutory provision in mandating when a legislative session must end.] Instead of licensing, Senate Bill 258 and House Bill 692 create a “certification” (not licensing) for NDs, but otherwise give them a starter scope of practice (treat any patient with any problem, prescribe and sell dietary supplements and other unproven remedies, diagnostic testing) they could live with until they can come back to the legislature asking for more, as they inevitably do. A Naturopathic Doctors Certification Board, with a naturopathic majority, would regulate their practice. Interestingly, while “gross negligence” is sanctionable, mere malpractice (that is, falling below the standard of care, or ordinary negligence) is not mentioned, further reinforcing the conclusion that there is simply no standard of care in naturopathy.
As of this writing, both the House and Senate bills are sitting in the committee to which they were initially assigned, virtually assuring they won’t pass. Unfortunately, what did pass with lightning speed, rushing through the House and Senate in a couple of days, was House Bill 277, which was signed into law by the Governor. While purporting to establish a work group to study “the appropriate oversight and regulation” of naturopathic practice in North Carolina, the game seems rigged in favor of licensing. The work group is tasked with identifying “an approved study of naturopathy medicine” for licensing purposes, but defines that “approved study” so that only one outcome is possible: the current system of self-regulated naturopathic “medical” schools, which produces NDs whose brief clinical training, for the most part, concerns itself with the care of the worried well. The work group consists of two naturopaths appointed by the North Carolina Association of Naturopathic “Physicians,” two MDs, one of whom must have experience working with naturopaths (in my view, designed to insure a naturopathy-friendly MD), and one designee of the state Secretary of Health.
North Carolina is surpassed by New York in naturopathic licensing bids, this being the ninth session in which a bill legalizing naturopathic practice has been introduced in that state. Both bills are still sitting in the committee to which they were originally assigned. The New York State Legislature adjourns on January 2, 2019, and is in recess until December 31st. Keep your fingers crossed.
Senate Bill 4297 and Assembly Bill 5913 give naturopaths the typical broad scope of practice “to address the shortage of primary care physicians,” based on the fiction that naturopaths can stimulate the “inherent property in a living organism to heal itself,” i.e., vitalism. In addition to homeopathic remedies, dietary supplements, and herbs, they could prescribe thyroid hormones, estrogen, progesterone, and DHEA, all of which they would be able to administer by the usual routes (vaginal, rectal, oral) and, if registered with the state, by injection, including IV administration. This would permit them to concoct dubious remedies like Myers cocktails, high dose vitamin C, and other substances and administer them intravenously. They could order diagnostic imaging, including MRIs and thermography, and perform cryotherapy, ligation, fulguration, other minor office procedures and colonics. They would be regulated by a naturopathic board consisting of six naturopaths, two public members and one MD or DO. After two years naturopaths would have to have completed a one-year “residency” to become licensed.
Finally, in Wyoming, yet another broad-scope-of-practice, naturopathy-as-“primary care” bill didn’t make it. That bill got as far as being assigned a number (House Bill 151), but no further, ignominiously failing to warrant even a committee assignment. Wyoming naturopaths itching for the authority to inject patients with bogus vitamin and mineral “cocktails” and practice obstetrics, both granted by the bill, will have to wait. And in Illinois, similar to legislation introduced in prior years, bills licensing NDs (House Bill 2530 and Senate Bill 708) but otherwise not defining their scope of practice failed to meet legislative deadlines for further consideration.
NDs are not fit to practice primary care
As noted, many licensing bills are based on the notion that naturopathic “doctors” are capable of practicing “primary care”. Before we move on to practice expansion bills, let’s pause briefly to consider the meaning of that term. Here are excerpts from definitions from the American Academy of Family Physicians, focusing on the nature of the services primary care doctors provide to patients:
Primary care is that care provided by physicians specifically trained for and skilled in comprehensive first contact and continuing care for persons with any undiagnosed sign, symptom, or health concern (the “undifferentiated” patient) not limited by problem origin (biological, behavioral, or social), organ system, or diagnosis.
Primary care practices are organized to meet the needs of patients with undifferentiated problems, with the vast majority of patient concerns and needs being cared for in the primary care practice itself.
The style of primary care practice is such that the personal primary care physician serves as the entry point for substantially all of the patient’s medical and health care needs – not limited by problem origin, organ system, or diagnosis. Primary care physicians are advocates for the patient in coordinating the use of the entire health care system to benefit the patient.
When advocating against legalizing naturopathic practice, it is important to emphasize the obvious quackery, the ethical impropriety of their self-dealing, in the form of routinely selling remedies they prescribe to patients, and their lack of standards for care. Equally important, in my view, although perhaps under-appreciated, is calling out the insanity of allowing naturopathic “doctors” to practice primary care. The idea that someone with four years of education and training, a large portion of which is taken up by learning herbs and homeopathy and tending to the worried well, can competently serve as the “first contact and continuing care for persons with any undiagnosed sign, symptom, or health concern . . . not limited by problem origin (biological, behavioral, or social), organ system, or diagnosis” with “the vast majority of patient concerns and needs being cared for” is dangerously naïve. Equally absurd is the belief that NDs can be effective “advocates for the patient in coordinating the use of the entire health care system to benefit the patient,” when their appallingly inadequate training occurs almost exclusively outside of this health care system. Either legislators have no idea what the term “primary care” means or they are credulously swallowing naturopathic talking points without any independent investigation of their claims.
Practice expansion shutout
Even when a licensing bill passes, naturopaths often do not get the scope of practice they desire. However, having successfully stuck their noses under the tent, they will return to the statehouse door year after year, seeking practice expansion. Eight states saw practice expansion bills this year (again, some were holdovers from 2017). All failed.
Pennsylvania is an excellent example of this strategy. Last legislative session (2015-16), Pennsylvania passed a naturopathic registration act, allowing NDs to register with the state but without defining a scope of practice and leaving the details of regulation to the state medical board, under whose jurisdiction they will practice. Before the medical board could even begin its task of writing the rules, a licensing bill was introduced in the 2017-18 session allowing NDs to see, diagnose (with the authority to perform testing and order diagnostic imaging) and treat the undifferentiated patient with dietary supplements, herbs, homeopathy and like nostrums. The bill failed.
(The Society for Science-Based Medicine submitted comments [SFSBM Comment on Naturopathic Registration in Pennsylvania PDF] to the Pennsylvania State Board of Medicine discussing appropriate regulations. The Board appears to have listened. Proposed regulations require informed consent, including “notification to the client that the naturopathic doctor is not a physician and is not authorized to practice medicine”. Financial exploitation of patients is prohibited. Also included are restraints on misrepresentation, deception and untruthfulness in advertising that make one wonder whether they will be able to successfully advertise their practices at all.)
But wait, that’s not all! These bills also failed:
    • Alaska Senate Bill 120 and House Bill 326: Would have enlarged the fairly narrow scope of practice to include drug prescriptions, minor office surgery, and performing and ordering diagnostic testing.
    • Arizona Senate Bill 1085: Defined NDs as primary care practitioners under the state’s Medicaid system.
    • California Senate Bill 746: As originally drafted, would have allowed NDs (and chiropractors) to perform school athletics physicals, but bill provisions were changed to a totally different subject.
    • Connecticut House Bill 5294: In 2017, the Connecticut Department of Public Health issued an unfavorable report on giving NDs prescription privileges, including a discussion of their lack of education and training in pharmacology. Despite this, a bill was introduced giving NDs the right to prescribe drugs, leaving it to the Public Health Department, in consultation with the State Board of Naturopathic Examiners (but without input from medical or pharmacological groups) to establish additional requirements and a formulary.
    • Hawaii House Bill 1949 and Senate Bill 2299: A perennial attempt to get the authority to prescribe testosterone, describing naturopaths as “experts” in bio-identical hormones, which are not recommended by responsible medical authorities.
    • Minnesota Senate Bill 1514 and House Bill 1138: Another try at adding prescription privileges, as well as authority to perform minor office surgery and biopsies, do speculum exams, phlebotomy, and call themselves “naturopathic physicians.” Neither bill was considered in committee.
    • Washington Senate Bill 5369: Would have expanded existing prescription privileges to include controlled substances as well as perform minor office surgery per naturopathic board rules. Would also allow NDs to sign “guardianships, powers of attorney, disability determinations, and similar legal documents.” (As an attorney, I am aghast at the thought.) The bill was never considered in committee.
The only, and minor, legislative success was in Colorado, and that wasn’t a practice expansion. NDs there were required to identify themselves as “registered naturopathic doctor” (RND). The NDs don’t like this, so they got House Bill 1433 passed eliminating that requirement. They still cannot call themselves “physicians” (a prohibition that was being honored in the breach until someone started filing complaints with the state) but can advertise that they are members of naturopathic organizations that refer to naturopaths as “physicians,” unless it is misleading or deceptive to do so.
Because all of the state legislatures covered in this post were in one-year sessions, or two-year sessions ending in 2018, none of the bills will carry over to 2019. Assuming the current situation holds, naturopaths suffered a shutout in 2018 in licensing and practice expansion. But naturopaths will be back – they always are. According to the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, naturopaths have their sights set on licensing in 2019 in New Mexico, Texas, Mississippi, Georgia, Wisconsin, Ohio, New Jersey, and my state, Florida, as well as the Canadian Northwest Territories. Wherever they pop up, we’ll be following them on Legislative Updates.
Thanks to all of you SBM fans who contacted your state legislators to oppose naturopathic licensing and practice expansion. A special shout-out to the Center for Inquiry Michigan for its work in educating legislators about why naturopaths should not be licensed as health care professionals. Keep up the good work, everyone!

Legislative Alchemy: Naturopathic licensing bill now before Wisconsin Senate Committee
Naturopaths are pushing for licensing in Wisconsin with a bill allowing them to practice as primary care doctors, prescribe drugs, and employ quack diagnostic testing and remedies. A powerful regulatory board controlled by naturopaths could expand their scope of practice at will.
Jann Bellamy on October 21, 2021
Link

Senate Bill (SB) 532, which would license naturopathic “doctors” (NDs) as “primary care” providers, was recently heard before a Wisconsin Senate Committee. As usual, the naturopaths put on a dog-and-pony show, with carefully curated patient anecdotes, misrepresentation of their education and training, support from credulous physicians (and chiropractors), and cherry-picked studies supposedly showing that they are capable of practicing as primary care doctors. The committee has not voted but the bill has plenty of time to find its way into the statute books given that the Wisconsin Legislature is year-round and the current session does not officially conclude until January of 2023. A companion bill, AB 529, has been introduced in the Wisconsin Assembly.
This is yet another example of the continuing scourge known as Legislative Alchemy, the incorporation of pseudoscience into law (especially health care practitioner licensing) by state legislatures and Congress. So far, naturopaths have succeeded in gaining licensure or some other form of legal recognition in 23 states and D.C., with varying scopes of practice. Once licensed, naturopaths return to the state legislatures year after year seeking to expand their scope of practice, the Holy Grail being (despite all the rhetoric about “natural” remedies) full prescription privileges, a goal they’ve met in only one state: Oregon.
SBM has covered naturopathy extensively, but (quoting myself) here are a few main points to remember about naturopaths as you read this post:
     1.  Although they call themselves “doctors” and “physicians” and claim expertise as primary care providers, their education and training takes place in naturopathic “medical schools” that operate outside the mainstream American higher education system. These schools reject science and evidence-based medicine. Unlike conventional medicine, only a handful of residencies are available to graduates, and most go directly into practice after school. Or, as Dr. Mark Crislip put it: “Next time you see a naturopath, remember it is the same as seeing an unsupervised medical student”.
     2.  Licensed naturopaths are only nominally regulated by the states in which they practice, with naturopaths themselves controlling licensing standards (like exams), continuing education, and the standard of care, the latter of which apparently does not exist. In many states, they control the boards that are supposed to regulate them.
     3.  Naturopaths do not practice evidence-based medicine, which they reject in favor of folk remedies and pseudoscience. Many are anti-vaccination. Their practices include dubious diagnostic methods, like hair analysis for “toxicities” (used as a pretext for “detoxification“), and unproven treatments, like herbs, supplements, homeopathy, and colonic irrigation, many of which carry risks, including death, but provide no proven benefit. While they claim otherwise, there is no compelling evidence that “naturopathic medicine” improves health, prevents disease, or saves money. In fact, “what little data there is suggests that utilizing a naturopath for primary care is associated with worse care . . .”
SB 532 licenses naturopaths who’ve graduated from accredited naturopathic “medical” schools, passed a licensing exam created, and graded, by North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners, and passed a “pharmacology examination” approved by a Naturopathic Medicine Examining Board, which would regulate the practice of naturopathy in Wisconsin. (There is also a “limited scope naturopathic doctor license” for long-time practitioners who did not graduate from accredited schools.)
Per the bill, licensed naturopaths would be allowed to practice “primary health care for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of human health conditions, injury, and disease” without limitation as to the patient’s age or health status. In other words, licensed naturopaths could diagnose and treat, for example, both severely ill children and complex geriatric patients suffering from multiple conditions like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and cancer.
Their scope of practice would include:
    • “[S]upport and stimulation of a patient’s inherent self-healing processes”, meaning vitalism, the amorphous pre-scientific notion that an “invisible, intangible, unique form of energy is responsible for all the activities of living organisms”.
    • Ordering and performing physical and lab exams for diagnostic purposes “consistent with naturopathic education and training” including, but not limited to, diagnostic sonography and electrocardiography, as well as ordering diagnostic imaging studies.
    • Dispensing (in other words, selling) and administering nutraceuticals, vitamins, botanical medicines (e.g., herbs) and dietary supplements (none of which must be proven safe or effective), homeopathic remedies (pure quackery), and hydrotherapy (e.g., “colon cleansing“).
    • The prescription of any drug except those listed in Schedule I and Schedule II, and certain Schedule III narcotics. In other words, naturopaths would be prevented from prescribing only those drugs with a high degree of potential for abuse, but could prescribe many other pharmaceuticals like anabolic steroids, testosterone and other hormones, anti-depressants, and stimulants. They could also prescribe compounded drugs, or compound the drugs themselves, using any substance not prohibited by the FDA. (Naturopaths’ liberal use of dubious ingredients in compounded drugs, like the now-banned quack cancer treatment cesium chloride, has only recently been curbed by more stringent FDA oversight.)
    • Use of almost all routes of administration for substances like vitamins, minerals, homeopathic remedies, as well as prescription drugs, including intravenous, vaginal, auricular, and ocular.
    • Minor office procedures, including minor surgery.
    • “Any other diagnostic, therapeutic, or other procedure” approved by the Board.
As suggested by that last quote, the Naturopathic Medical Examining Board would be incredibly powerful, able to expand naturopathic practice to include anything not expressly prohibited by the licensing law (like surgery or therapeutic use of ionizing radiation). In case that was not explicit enough, the bill also provides, in another section:
The board may promulgate rules to do any of the following . . . (a) Further define the scope of practice of naturopathic medicine. The board may expressly authorize diagnostic, therapeutic, or other practices that may be used by naturopathic doctors.
In addition to expanding the scope of practice, the Board would write the rules governing standards of practice, ethics, continuing education requirements, and standards for licensure and discipline, and would have jurisdiction over disciplinary actions against naturopaths. The Board would consist of four naturopathic doctors, one MD or DO physician practicing primary care who has worked with a naturopath (a requirement aimed at getting a “naturopath-friendly” physician on the Board), and two public members, all appointed by the Governor. This composition virtually guarantees that there will be no real oversight of the Board’s rule-making and other activities and, given the fact that there is apparently no naturopathic standard of care, naturopaths would be left free to practice their many forms of quackery with little fear of discipline.
Of particular concern, this Board would approve the pharmacology exam required for practice. This would almost certainly mean adoption the North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners NPLEX Elective Pharmacology Examination, about which little is known except that it “is comprised of 75 stand-alone items” and is not “case-based”, must be completed in 90 minutes, requires a score of 60-70% (a specific figure was not given) and, as best I can tell, can be taken an unlimited number of times. This exam was created “in house” presumably to stave off any attempt by outside entities to determine whether naturopathic education and training is actually sufficient for prescribing privileges. All available indications are that this is most certainly not the case.
The Senate Committee on Insurance, Licensing and Forestry held its hearing on SB 532 on September 29, 2021. (There is no official recording or transcript but you can read the documents submitted online.) The Wisconsin Medical Society, the Medical College of Wisconsin, the Wisconsin Academy of Family Physicians and several other medical specialty groups, and the Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin, have all indicated opposition to the bill, although not all groups oppose all of the bill’s provisions.
The American Academy of Family Physicians opposes naturopathic licensing altogether and written testimony from the Wisconsin Academy did a good job of objecting to the conflation between medical doctors and naturopathic “doctors” and designating naturopaths as “primary care” providers. The Academy also provided data undermining the naturopaths’ claims of equivalency between medical and naturopathic education and training, especially regarding pharmacology and the lack of a residency requirement.
In addition to naturopaths and their organizations, who are hardly objective, naturopathic patients submitted anecdotes of their favorable experiences with naturopaths. Three immediate problems with this sort of testimony come to mind: (1) anecdotes are not evidence; (2) no medical records are submitted to verify patient’s claims of successful treatment; and (3) there was no attempt (that I could find) to solicit testimonials from those who had bad experiences with naturopathic care (or their families, for those killed by naturopathic treatment). In other words, the fact that some patients are satisfied with naturopathic treatment is no reason to license naturopaths as primary care providers with prescription privileges and give them free rein to expand their scope of practice as they see fit.
Other than information submitted by medical groups challenging naturopaths’ claims about their education and practices, there was no objective analysis of naturopathy. To me, it is absolutely stunning that legislative bodies basically depend on naturopaths to evaluate their own fitness for practice, and decide the scope thereof, and almost never employ any outside, disinterested evaluators to assess their claims. It is the equivalent of creating a whole new class of licensed health care practitioners based on Google reviews.
The most accurate evidence of the way Wisconsin naturopaths would actually practice, as opposed to their lofty claims of competence and effectiveness, can perhaps best be gleaned from the way they are already practicing, apparently unimpeded by the lack of licensing. Here’s a sampling from naturopaths who testified in favor of SB 532 and their practices.
Allison Baker, ND:
    • Claims that wet socks, worn overnight, will “bring warm blood to the feet, creating a pumping mechanism in the blood vessels that stimulates circulation and promotes release of congestion in the head and upper respiratory passages. In turn, this invigorates the immune system to fend off acute illness” and will relieve congestion. This is nonsense.
    • Uses homeopathy (which is, by definition, ineffective for anything) to treat acute infections.
Lakeside Natural Medicine:
    • Uses unvalidated salivary hormone tests to diagnose “adrenal fatigue”, a fake disease.
    • Claims that physicians treating your hypothyroidism with thyroid replacement medication are treating “lab tests, not YOU” and are failing to address the underlying “cause”, which may include gluten, which can “destroy” your thyroid.
    • Recommends a “toxic exposure and heavy metal assessment” and “detoxification support” to address fertility issues. Convincing patients they are infested with “toxins” and “heavy metals”, discovered through bogus testing, and “detoxifying” them are favorite naturopathic schemes.
Family Clinic of Natural Medicine:
    • Offers “IV Nutritional Therapy” to “help the body detoxify . . . enhance our immune system, decrease inflammation, support the liver, help combat chronic infections like Lyme disease and cold viruses”. These claims lack evidence.
Jill Crista, ND:
    • Recommends that tick bites be treated with homeopathy.
    • Sells genetic testing and dietary supplements based on naturopath Ben Lynch’s MTHFR quackery.
    • Sells Czech “peat therapy”, claiming that “a half hour in this mud bath saves your internal organs months of hard work trying to detox mold toxins.”
All of this is consistent with what we’ve learned about naturopathic practice from former naturopathic doctor Britt Hermes and surveys of naturopathic websites. As the authors of one of these surveys concluded:
A review of the therapies advertised on the websites of clinics offering naturopathic treatments does not support the proposition that naturopathic medicine is a science and evidence-based practice.
        ◦ That being the case, they should not be licensed as health care practitioners in Wisconsin, and certainly not as providers of primary care with prescription authority, allowed to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition.

Legislative Alchemy 2019: Naturopaths gain licensure in two states, try for authority to grant vaccination medical exemptions
Thanks to the magic of Legislative Alchemy, Idaho and New Mexico licensed naturopaths as primary care doctors in 2019. Naturopaths are also seeking the authority to grant medical exemptions to vaccination and prescribe drugs in several states.
Jann Bellamy on January 16, 2020
Link

Science and evidence-based medicine took a hit in 2019 with new laws passed licensing naturopathic “doctors” in New Mexico and Idaho, making naturopathy a regulated health care profession in almost half of the U.S. states. Licensing gives naturopathy an undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy and fools the public into thinking regulation will protect it from unproven and unsafe practices.
In states where they are already regulated, naturopaths came back to the legislatures asking for even more privileges in 2019. Most disturbingly, this includes giving naturopaths the authority to grant medical exemptions to vaccination in two states, a topic we’ll return to in a moment.
All of this is yet another example of the continuing scourge known as Legislative Alchemy, the incorporation of pseudoscience into law (especially health care practitioner licensing) by state legislatures and Congress.
SBM has covered naturopathy extensively, but here are a few main points to remember about naturopaths as you read this post:
     1.  Although they call themselves “doctors” and “physicians” and claim expertise as primary care providers, their education and training takes place in naturopathic “medical schools” that operate outside the mainstream American higher education system. These schools reject science and evidence-based medicine. Unlike conventional medicine, only a handful of residencies are available to graduates, and most go directly into practice after school. Or, as Dr. Mark Crislip put it: “Next time you see a naturopath, remember it is the same as seeing an unsupervised medical student”.
     2.  Licensed naturopaths are only nominally regulated by the states in which they practice, with naturopaths themselves controlling licensing standards (like exams), continuing education, and the standard of care, the latter of which apparently does not exist. In many states, they control the boards that are supposed to regulate them.
     3.  Naturopaths do not practice evidence-based medicine, which they reject in favor of folk remedies and pseudoscience. Many are anti-vaccination. Their practices include dubious diagnostic methods, like hair analysis for “toxicities” (used as a pretext for “detoxification“), and unproven treatments, like herbs, supplements, homeopathy, and colonic irrigation, many of which carry risks, including death, but provide no proven benefit. While they claim otherwise, there is no compelling evidence that “naturopathic medicine” improves health, prevents disease, or saves money. In fact, “what little data there is suggests that utilizing a naturopath for primary care is associated with worse care . . .”
Unfortunately, the new naturopathic practice acts in both New Mexico and Idaho will allow naturopaths to practice primary care and will give them the authority to treat the undifferentiated patient, that is, any person of any age with any disease or condition, within the primary care scope of practice. Patients will be depending on these licensed naturopaths to perform a competent differential diagnosis and provide safe and effective treatment or refer appropriately, skills their woefully inadequate education and clinical training call into question.
New Mexico
In New Mexico, licensed naturopaths, as primary care practitioners, will be able to, “in alignment with naturopathic medical education” (an undefined term without direction as to who will decide what, if any, limitations this actually imposes):
    • Perform physical exams, including orifical exams and physiological function tests
    • Order and interpret lab tests, including venipuncture and obtaining samples of human tissues
    • Order diagnostic imaging studies and “take action” based on the radiologist’s report
    • Prescribe, administer and dispense legend drugs (as used in New Mexico, this means unscheduled drugs that require a prescription), testosterone products, and Schedule III, IV, and V controlled substances (excluding benzodiazepines, opioids and opioid derivatives) after passing an exam authorized by the Medical Board
    • Use intramuscular, intravenous, subcutaneous, intra-articular and intradermal injections
    • Use oral, nasal, auricular, ocular, rectal, vaginal and other routes of administration
    • Perform minor office procedures, including “minor surgical care” but excluding surgical care to treat a lesion suspected of malignancy
    • Perform hypnosis
    • Perform allergy testing and treat allergies (presumably for both real and fake allergies)
    • Use colon hydrotherapy and electromagnetism
    • Use barrier contraception, intrauterine devices, hormonal and pharmaceutical contraception and durable medical equipment
    • Use the title “naturopathic doctor”, ND, and NMD, but not “physician”
In addition to the broad authority to prescribe drugs, particularly disturbing is authority to use “therapeutic substances”, administered via the extremely generous list of methods noted above, including vitamins, minerals, nutraceuticals, botanical medicines, oxygen, homeopathic medicine (defined as being “based on the use of infinitesimal doses of substances capable of producing symptoms similar to those of the disease treated”, which is pure, unadulterated quackery), hormones, hormonal or pharmaceutical contraceptive devices, and “other physiological substance[s]”, whatever that means. (If administered by injection, they are legally prescription drugs, presumably compounded.) These “therapeutic substances” seem to be (it’s not entirely clear) limited to those “exemplified in a standard naturopathic medical text, journal or pharmacopeia”. I’m not sure what that means either, but it presumably includes the Textbook of Natural Medicine, which Dr. Harriet Hall’s review aptly described as
mix[ing] good science with bad science, pseudoscience, outright errors of fact, vitalism, philosophy, ancient history, superstition, gullibility, misrepresentations, metaphysics, religion, hearsay, opinion and anecdotes.
Here, for example, is Dr. Hall’s comment on the Textbook‘s discussion of intravenous magnesium (which naturopaths can legally administer in New Mexico as a “therapeutic substance”) in the treatment of asthma:
The Textbook recognizes [that asthma attacks can kill], but it gives dangerous advice. It says, “If intravenous magnesium cannot be administered, the patient should be referred to an emergency department immediately”. Intravenous magnesium is used in treating an acute asthma attack only as an adjunct to conventional treatment. Treating the patient with IV magnesium before or instead of referral to an ED could have fatal results.
While “therapeutic substances” “exemplified” in naturopathy textbooks may offer practitioners a cornucopia of quack treatments, journals could guarantee a virtually unlimited supply of “exemplified” “therapeutic substances” for future use. As I read the law, all one need do is get an article published in one of the many CAM-friendly journals (Medical Hypotheses comes to mind) touting this or that “therapeutic substance” (a “physiological substance” perhaps) and, voila, it’s in the naturopathic scope of practice in New Mexico. What could be easier?
There are two potentially significant limitations on naturopathic practitioners in New Mexico. First, licensed naturopaths will be regulated by the New Mexico Medical Board, although a naturopathic advisory committee (which can consist solely of naturopaths and a public member) will recommend rules and licensing requirements, including the amount of malpractice insurance naturopaths must carry. The legislature has already specified that licensees must graduate from an accredited naturopathic school and pass the NPLEX exam, created and administered by the North American Board of Naturopathic Medical Examiners (NABNE). (Lest you think this imposes any sort of reasonable standard on their education and competency testing, former licensed naturopathic doctor Britt Hermes will easily disabuse you of that notion.)
The Board is specifically authorized to define “primary care” and decide which “screening or test[s]” naturopaths can perform outside those already permitted by the new law, and create pharmacy and state jurisprudence exams.
I could not determine whether the New Mexico Medical Board had enacted naturopathic practice rules yet, or even proposed rules, or that the advisory committee had recommended rules to the Board. Therefore, I do not know how the New Mexico Association of Naturopathic Physicians is claiming that naturopaths must pass the NPLEX Clinical Elective Examinations on Pharmacology (created after the NABNE admitted naturopathic education in pharmacology was insufficient, which is absolutely correct) and Minor Surgery. I hope the Board will not adopt these tests as a demonstration of proficiency in either prescribing drugs or minor office procedures. (It will undoubtedly be the recommendation of the naturopathic advisory committee.)
Per the NABNE, the minor surgery exam is “case-based, i.e., 15-20 brief clinical summaries are presented and several questions are asked about each case”. The pharmacology exam is “comprised of 75 stand-alone items” to be completed in 90 minutes. Given the lack of clinical training in minor surgery and prescribing drugs (remember, no residencies), this seems a remarkably inadequate measure of the competency of naturopaths to safety and effectively perform these essential components of primary care, especially prescribing. To quote the inimitable Dr. Crislip:
If I were Pfizer I would be turning my sales force loose on the 800 plus ND’s in Oregon: they have no background to understand the truth of what they are told, they have no critical thinking skills, they are used to accepting authority over evidence, they have no issues with being subsidized by industry, and crave respectability. Perfect fodder for the drug rep.
The second limitation on naturopaths is the requirement that they practice in collaboration with a licensed medical or osteopathic doctor, although I am not confident that this is a meaningful curb on their pseudoscientific practices. “Collaboration” is defined as
the process by which a licensed physician and a naturopathic doctor jointly contribute to the health care and medical treatment of patients [in which] each collaborator performs actions that the collaborator is licensed or otherwise authorized to perform; and [is not] construed to require the physical presence of the licensed physician . . .
Thus, the physician has no authority to prevent the naturopath from doing anything harmful, or just plain stupid for that matter. Query what sort of physician would want to take this on.
Idaho
Idaho at one time licensed naturopaths, “de-licensed” them in 2015, and has now turned around and, once again, passed a “naturopathic medicine” licensing act. Like New Mexico, naturopathic “doctors” (who are not allowed to call themselves physicians) are given the authority to provide primary care but, unlike New Mexico, no collaboration with a physician is required. They, too, will be regulated by the state’s medical board, advised by a naturopathic medical board, which, like New Mexico’s advisory committee, has no authority to require the enactment of its suggestions. The Idaho Board of Medicine has the exclusive authority to adopt rules governing naturopathic practice, including licensure requirements, “ethical standards of practice”, and disciplinary proceedings, although the Idaho legislature, again like New Mexico, has already defaulted to the naturopath-controlled naturopathic “medical” schools and the NABNE-controlled NPLEX exam as licensing standards for education and examination.
Naturopaths will also be able to prescribe drugs per a formulary devised by the Medical Board, which can include “legend medications excluding scheduled controlled substances except for testosterone”. (Naturopaths apparently find testosterone an absolute necessity. They’ve been trying to get the authority to prescribe testosterone in Hawaii for years.)
The new Idaho law is short on details, but naturopaths will also be able to employ diagnostic physical and lab exams and perform diagnostic and imaging tests “consistent with naturopathic medical education”, although no particular person or agency is assigned the task of defining just what this limitation entails. They can also perform minor office procedures.
And the other states
The news is not all bad: Licensing efforts failed in Indiana, Wyoming, and Mississippi. Unfortunately, licensing bills have been introduced in the 2020 legislative session, or carry over from the 2019 session, in New York, Illinois, Michigan, North Carolina and Virginia. The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians says it is “aiming to” file licensing bills in 2020-2021 in Wyoming, Texas, Oklahoma, Mississippi, Tennessee (where naturopathy is currently illegal), Iowa, Wisconsin, Ohio, Georgia, Florida, and New Jersey.
Naturopaths attempted practice expansions in seven states in 2019. They failed in five, while bills remain pending in two states. Those of are of particular concern as they allow naturopaths to exempt patients from vaccination requirements.
In Hawaii, House Bill 1182, with talking points straight out of the anti-vaccination playbook about vaccine package inserts, vaccine ingredients, and adverse reactions, adds a “conscientious belief” exemption to vaccination and waters down the requirement for claiming a religious exemption. It also allows naturopathic “physicians” to exempt patients from vaccination and changes the standard for exemption from a certificate stating that “because of a stated cause the health of the person would be endangered by the vaccination or immunization” to a letter claiming that “the person shall not be subject to immunization requirements because the vaccine could pose undue risks to their health”. The bill eliminates the requirement that a copy of the exemption document be filed with the state department of health.
A bill to permit licensed naturopaths to certify that patients with debilitating medical conditions need access to cannabis is also pending in Hawaii. (Senate Bill 1430) As Britt Hermes has described, pot certifications are a big money maker for naturopaths, many of whom are burdened with student debt but have few job opportunities.
Although I have not been able to locate the actual bill, according to LexisNexis, a Maine “Legislative Reference Bill 2845” has been filed, described as “an act to authorize naturopathic doctors to provide medical exemptions from the laws governing immunization requirements”.
Failed scope of expansion efforts mostly sought adding, or increasing, the authority to prescribe drugs. In Connecticut, a bill to add drug prescription privileges to the naturopathic scope of practice failed, as did an attempt to expand prescription privileges in Maryland. Bills permitting licensed naturopaths to certify that patients with debilitating medical conditions need access to cannabis failed in Oregon. Adding prescription drugs, minor office procedures, and diagnostic imaging to the scope of practice in Alaska didn’t pass either. In an unusual attempt to contract naturopathic practice, an Oregon bill removing naturopaths from the list of medical practitioners who conduct medical evaluations for child abuse cases failed.
What to do?
If you live in a state where a naturopathic bill is pending, please go to your legislature’s website and read the bill and any committee reports or staff analyses (which too often simply regurgitate naturopathic talking points). Contact your state senators and representatives to oppose licensing, registration, and practice expansion. Or, in the rare case of practice contraction, to support a bill. Many legislative websites will allow you to sign up for notifications about bills on specified subjects. You can use this feature to learn of new bills or follow pending ones. In too many cases, naturopathic bills get passed without significant opposition, even from the medical community. Naturopaths are very good at presenting themselves to lawmakers as well-qualified primary care practitioners. It is up to us to tell legislators the truth.

Legislative Alchemy: Undaunted by rejection in 2020, naturopaths return to state legislatures seeking licensing and practice expansion
States largely rejected naturopathic licensing and practice expansion efforts in 2020. As ever, naturopaths are back again in 2021, imploring state legislators to legitimize them with licensing and greater scopes of practice, especially the authority to prescribe drugs.
Jann Bellamy on February 11, 2021
Link

Each year, naturopaths who, via their closed-circuit educational and testing system, fancy themselves as primary care physicians on equal footing with MDs and DOs (they’re not), attempt to legitimize their self-regard by becoming state-regulated health care professionals, preferably via licensing. So far, thanks to the magic of Legislative Alchemy (the incorporation of pseudoscience into law by state legislatures), they’ve succeeded in 22 states and D.C. Once licensed, naturopaths return to the state legislatures year after year seeking to expand their scope of practice, the Holy Grail being (despite all the rhetoric about “natural” remedies) full prescription privileges, a goal they’ve met in only one state: Oregon.
2020 was no exception to this scheme, although their efforts were largely a failure. True to form, naturopaths are back in 2021, lobbying state legislators to perform that old legislative magic again.
Before we take a look at the 2020 and 2021 legislation, let’s briefly review why state licensing of naturopathic “doctors” or “physicians” is a terrible idea.
    • Although they call themselves “doctors” and “physicians” and claim expertise as primary care providers, their education and training takes place in naturopathic “medical schools” that operate outside the mainstream American higher education system. These schools reject science and evidence-based medicine. Unlike conventional medicine, only a handful of residencies are available to graduates, and most go directly into practice after school. Or, as Dr. Mark Crislip put it: “Next time you see a naturopath, remember it is the same as seeing an unsupervised medical student”. (I’d argue its worse, given the fact that at least the medical student has been taught reality-based medicine.)
    • Licensed naturopaths are only nominally regulated by the states in which they practice, with naturopaths themselves controlling licensing standards (like exams), continuing education, and the standard of care, the latter of which apparently does not exist. In many states, they control the boards that are supposed to regulate them.
    • Naturopaths do not practice evidence-based medicine, which they reject in favor of folk remedies and pseudoscience. Many are anti-vaccination. Their practices include dubious diagnostic methods, like hair analysis for “toxicities” (used as a pretext for “detoxification“), and unproven treatments, like herbs, supplements, homeopathy, and colonic irrigation, many of which carry risks, including death, but provide no proven benefit. While they claim otherwise, there is no compelling evidence that “naturopathic medicine” improves health, prevents disease, or saves money. In fact, “what little data there is suggests that utilizing a naturopath for primary care is associated with worse care . . .”
2020
When we last reviewed naturopathic legislative efforts on SBM a year ago, covering 2019, a couple of bills introduced that year remained pending in 2020. (Some states have two-year legislative sessions.) In Hawaii, a bill sought to allow naturopathic “physicians” to exempt patients from vaccination. With talking points straight out of the anti-vaccination playbook about vaccine package inserts, vaccine ingredients, and adverse reactions, the same bill added a “conscientious belief” exemption to vaccination, watered down the requirements for claiming a religious exemption, and loosened the standard for exemption certificates.
Another bill in Hawaii would have permitted naturopathic “physicians” to certify that patients with debilitating medical conditions needed access to cannabis. (As Britt Hermes has described, pot certifications are a big money-maker for naturopaths, many of whom are burdened with student debt but have few job opportunities.)
Fortunately, neither bill passed.
Other failures in 2020 legislative sessions (or 2019-2020 sessions in some states) include licensing bills in Illinois, Wisconsin, Wyoming, Michigan, Oklahoma, North Carolina, and New York.
In what we might call a “bait-and-switch” strategy, after accepting a limited scope of practice in exchange for legitimization via state licensing or registration, naturopaths will return to the legislatures year after year to add either initial or expanded prescription privileges.
A few years ago, in an attempt to burnish naturopathic prescribing credentials, the North American Board of Naturopathic Examiners (NABNE) created an optional pharmacology examination, apparently in hopes that the states, as they do with other naturopathic educational qualifications, would farm out a determination of competency to prescribe to the NABNE. The entire exam consists of 75 multiple-choice questions to be completed in 90 minutes. This effort has been partially successful, including the two states most recently licensing naturopaths, New Mexico and Idaho, both of which accept the NABNE’s pharmacology exam as a prerequisite for prescribing privileges. Unfortunately, that is pretty much the entire sum of our knowledge about the exam because, as far as I know, no one outside naturopathy has ever seen one and its validity has never been determined by any outside authority.
Which brings me, incidentally, to one of my favorite quotes from the inimitable Dr. Mark Crislip:
If I were Pfizer I would be turning my sales force loose on the 800 plus ND’s in Oregon: they have no background to understand the truth of what they are told, they have no critical thinking skills, they are used to accepting authority over evidence, they have no issues with being subsidized by industry, and crave respectability. Perfect fodder for the drug rep.
Perhaps legislators in some states agree. Attempts to initiate or expand naturopathic prescribing privileges failed in Washington, Massachusetts, and Maryland. In Rhode Island, a bill to add IV therapy, the authority to counsel patients on “their use of prescription drugs” prescribed by their (real) physician, and phlebotomy, to the naturopathic scope of practice failed as well.
I was particularly impressed with the opposition to Maryland’s bill by the state affiliate of the American College of Nurse-Midwives, the Maryland Nurses Association, and the Secular Coalition of Maryland, whose written testimony served as a demonstration to the legislature that the issue is not just a “turf war” between physicians and other practitioners, as is sometimes falsely claimed. (The state medical society, MedChi, also testified in opposition.) As the Nurses Association succinctly pointed out:
This opposition is based on a lack of clarity about whether the education and experience of naturopathic doctors aligns with the provisions of the bill. The bill grants broad prescriptive authority for naturopathic doctors to prescribe any medication, excluding controlled dangerous substances, on a formulary determined by an advisory committee.
Our questions include:
    • What is the content of naturopathic education?
    • Does naturopathic education include training on pharmacology beyond naturally derived medications?; and
    • Is naturopathic education on pharmacology standard or do programs differ?
We think these basic questions should be addressed before considering this legislation.
So do we! Of course, these are the very questions naturopaths would prefer not to answer.
Other practice expansion bills met a similar fate. In Arizona, an attempt to give naturopathic “physicians” some privileges reserved to (real) physicians and other health care professionals, such as writing standard orders for epi pens and limitations on liability related to the delivery of infants, failed. Kansas practice expansion bills, including expanded prescription and diagnostic procedure authority, failed as well.
2021
With that, we’ll turn to 2021. Some of this will sound familiar.
At the beginning of this year, a licensing effort in Virginia, carried over from 2020, was tabled in a Senate Committee and voted down in a House Committee. As the Virginia General Assembly adjourns today, licensing is presumably dead in that state for this session. The scope of practice was fairly broad, including IV administration of “botanical medicines” and “homeopathic medicines”, although prescription drugs weren’t authorized. It contained some interesting limitations as well: no psychological testing or treatment for moderate or severe mental illness, no diagnosis and treatment of the eyes, and no diagnosis and treatment of minors without a parent’s signed consent attesting that the minor is also a patient of a physician.
Bills giving “naturopathic doctors” title protection (that is, it prevented those without degrees from naturopathic “medical” schools from using that title) didn’t pass either.
Licensing bills are pending in New Jersey (not for the first time) and Arkansas.
In New Jersey, the bill, which has yet to be heard in committee, defines “naturopathic medicine” as primary care and gives “naturopathic doctors” a broad scope of practice, including the authority to diagnose and treat any injury, disease, or condition in patients of any age. They would be regulated by a Board of Naturopathic Examiners, consisting of six naturopaths, two consumers, and a state executive.
Naturopaths could prescribe and, in certain cases, dispense, drugs “consistent with” naturopathic education and training (apparently a decision up to the individual naturopath), along with the usual dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies. They could also administer drugs and other “natural” remedies via an IV, among other methods of administration (ocular, vaginal, oral, etc.). Without limitation, they could order and perform physical and lab exams and order diagnostic imaging studies (e.g., MRIs), although not perform them or read the results. The Board would establish qualifications for “naturopathic childbirth attendance”.
The Arkansas bill would license “naturopathic physicians” and put them under the jurisdiction of the state medical board, which would enact regulations governing their practice. The bill does not specify much about their scope of practice, although it is quite broad, giving naturopaths the authority to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any condition, including the use of “drugs”. This bill is before the House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee.
According to the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP), licensing bills are now pending in several states where I could find no record of a bill on either LegiScan or Bill Track 50 — Wisconsin, Michigan, New York, and North Carolina — although bills could be introduced later in the year. This list also includes states where the filing deadline has passed without a bill having been introduced: Wyoming, Oklahoma, and Illinois.
Bills have been introduced in Maryland (prescription privileges), Hawaii (cannabis), and Arizona (epi-pen, etc.) to revive efforts that failed last year. Although no specific bill language is yet available, a Connecticut bill has been filed to give naturopaths prescription privileges. Several previous attempts (here, here, here, here, and here) have rebuffed by the Connecticut legislature and, in 2017, the state Department of Public Health issued an unfavorable report on naturopathic prescribing privileges.
A North Dakota bill would have given naturopaths the authority to prescribe (and dispense in some circumstances) any legend (that is, prescription) drug, including DEA Schedule II-V drugs. However, after a recent hearing, a committee amended the bill to include only testosterone (a naturopathic favorite) and non-scheduled legend drugs. It then recommended that its own version not pass the legislature, presumably reducing its chances of becoming law.
One person submitting testimony at the committee hearing was the wonderful Britt Hermes who, as she had done with a previous North Dakota bill seeking prescription privileges, set out forcefully and cogently for the committee why naturopaths are not qualified to prescribe drugs. With her Bastyr transcript submitted as evidence, she demonstrated that a measly 55 hours in one course amounted to her entire classroom education in pharmacology, with “minimal, if any additional pharmacology training provided in clinical training hours”. (Her letter is well worth reading and filing away for use in opposing naturopathic licensing and practice expansion.)
Under the guise of addressing the primary care provider shortage (a favorite chestnut with naturopaths), a bill in Washington grants expanded prescription privileges to include “legend drugs and controlled substances contained in Schedules III through V.” As is the case currently, the state Board of Naturopathy (5 naturopaths, 2 public members) establishes the education and training necessary for these privileges.
Finally, another Washington bill would allow naturopaths to corner the market on colon hydrotherapy by requiring all colon hydrotherapists to get a certificate from the Board of Naturopathy and allowing them to perform colon hydrotherapy only if affiliated with a naturopath, with a referral from a naturopath, and pursuant to a plan of care devised by a naturopath (such as for “detoxification”, one presumes). The bill made it through its first Senate committee, Health & Long Term Care.
However naturopaths may fare in 2021, the AANP claims it has big plans for 2022, where “advocacy initiatives are planned” for Texas, Iowa, Tennessee, Mississippi, Indiana, Ohio, Georgia, and Florida. We’ll be watching.
What to do?
If you live in a state where a naturopathic bill is pending, please go to your legislature’s website and read the bill and any committee reports or staff analyses (which too often simply regurgitate naturopathic talking points). Contact your state senators and representatives to oppose licensing, registration, and practice expansion. Or, in the rare case of practice contraction, to support a bill. Many legislative websites will allow you to sign up for notifications about bills on specified subjects. You can use this feature to learn of new bills or follow pending ones. In too many cases, naturopathic bills get passed without significant opposition, even from the medical community. Naturopaths are very good at presenting themselves to lawmakers as well-qualified primary care practitioners. It is up to us to tell legislators the truth.
Addendum: Idaho licensed “naturopathic medical doctors” in 2019. In one of the stranger licensing bills I’ve come across, on February 15th, a bill was introduced in the Idaho legislature which apparently would license two more types of “naturopathic practitioners”, the “doctor of natural health” and the “licensed naturopathic doctor”. The former must have an “approved naturopathic doctoral degree” as determined by a new regulatory board, the Board of Naturopathic Health Care, which “shall use the national naturopathic board of examiners, as the resource for accreditation”. (The currently licensed “naturopathic medical doctors” are regulated by the state board of medicine in coordination with a naturopathic advisory committee.) The “licensed naturopathic doctor”, on the other hand, is
an individual who has graduated from an accredited doctoral program in the medical sciences, including but not limited to MD, DO, DPM, ND, DC, DMD, PA, NP, DNP, and PharmD and who has obtained an approved naturopathic doctoral degree, as set forth in rule [presumably promulgated by the newly-created Board of Naturopathic Health Care].
It’s not clear to me why any MD or DO would want to go to the trouble of obtaining an “approved naturopathic doctoral degree” when they can already do anything within the licensed naturopathic doctor’s scope of practice. Or why an ND would want to get an additional naturopathic degree.
The licensed naturopathic doctor has a broader scope of practice than the “doctor of natural health”, although the bill leaves many details up to the new Board (which consists of a public member, a doctor of natural health, and three people who have a degree from one of the “accredited doctoral programs” listed in the above quote) in deciding who can do what.
Some explanation for this mish-mash can be found in the bill’s “Statement of Purpose“, which says that the Naturopathic Physicians Association of Idaho agreed not to oppose licensing of naturopathic medical doctors in 2019
providing that a naturopathic license be formed to license graduates of their schools [presumably those not accredited by the Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges] and that a licensing board would be established to license “The Other Naturopaths of Idaho.”

Legislative Alchemy: “Naturopathic Doctor” licensing is bad medicine for Florida
Bad medicine, bad laws, bad choice
Jann Bellamy on March 3, 2026
Link

Florida banned naturopathic practice in 1959, and despite numerous attempts over the years to pass a licensing law, with varying scopes of practice proposed, all bills have ended in defeat.
Will 2026 be different? Sadly, I think this is their year.
Bills licensing “naturopathic doctors” are making their way through the current Florida legislative session. Given an armamentarium of unvalidated testing, pseudoscientific diagnoses, and quack remedies, naturopathic practitioners would be allowed to call themselves “doctors”, with the authority to diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or health condition, all without consultation with the patient’s physician.
Bad laws
But first: Hello, again. Good to be here. As some of you may recall, I was a regular SBM contributor from 2010 to 2022. As an attorney, I was particularly disturbed by the incorporation of rank pseudoscience into the law, a phenomenon I dubbed “Legislative Alchemy”, the subject of many of my posts.
A distinctly insidious form of Legislative Alchemy is healthcare practitioner licensing. Grounded in the states’ constitutional authority to protect the public’s health, safety, and welfare, at their best licensing laws set education and training standards, define scope of practice, and impose a regulatory framework to protect the public from harmful practices.
Unfortunately, licensing laws have been co-opted by practitioners of pseudoscience, like chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopaths. Diagnoses and treatments based on fabricated human physiology unknown to medical science (chiropractic subluxations, acupuncture points, naturopathic vitalism) are given the imprimatur of legitimacy. Patients fill the waiting rooms of these state-licensed practitioners, deceived by the credentials their legislators have carelessly bestowed. Perversely, licensing becomes a vector for harm.
I had been thinking recently of returning to blogging. The dogged determination of a couple of legislators to impose “naturopathic medicine” on the good citizens of Florida, and my alarm as I watched this unfold, finally lit the fire that led me back to SBM, where I’ll post monthly (and maybe more).
Bad bills
There’s no better exemplar of Legislative Alchemy than the naturopathic licensing bills threatening to become law in my home state.
Senate Bill 688 and House Bill 223 would give naturopathic doctors the authority to call themselves, well, “doctor”, “ND”, or “NMD” (naturopathic medical doctor), along with a broad scope of practice: the authority to diagnose and treat any patient of any age (including children) for “any deformity, disease, pain, or other physical or mental condition”. This is almost exactly the same language used to describe a medical doctor’s scope of practice in Florida law, the only difference being that MDs can do surgery and have full prescription privileges.
Their practice would be based on “Principles of naturopathic medicine”, an amorphous list that includes vitalism, rebranded here as “the healing power of nature”.
Self-regulated system
Like other health care licensing legislation, the bills default to a self-regulated system to establish credentials for practice, including education and testing. In the case of naturopathic licensing standards, the nomenclature of medical doctor licensing has been brilliantly co-opted, just without the rigor required for the real thing.
The proposed legislation would allow naturopaths who’ve graduated from an “accredited naturopathic medical school” and passed the Naturopathic Physicians Licensing Examinations (NPLEX) to practice. That all sounds nice, unless you know some background.
NDs are educated in small, private schools that operate outside the mainstream American university system. Unlike real medical school, there is no entrance exam and the acceptance rate for U.S. schools is 65%-100% (2015 analysis).
These schools are accredited by an agency run by naturopaths. Unfortunately, while the U.S. Department of Education imposes administrative and financial standards in approving accreditation agencies, it does not require a science-based education, making the Department yet another vector for the introduction of pseudoscience into the healthcare system.
Pseudoscientific curriculum and inadequate clinical training
Their curriculum includes pseudoscience, like homeopathy. Clinical training takes place, for the most part, in small, school-based clinics where they see patients with a limited range of health problems. Upon passing the NPLEX, the rigor and scientific basis of which have never been fully evaluated, they can go straight into practice.
No residency is required. The three to seven years of additional clinical training that medical doctors undergo before practice (plus additional exams) is simply whitewashed away.
Thus, according to the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP):
the scope and quality of naturopathic education do not prepare the practitioner to properly and accurately diagnose illness or provide appropriate treatment. Government endorsement of naturopaths through licensure will jeopardize the health and safety of patients.
Their inadequate education and training obviously show in their practice, which is, again according to the AAFP:
not based upon the body of basic knowledge related to health, disease, and health care that has been accepted widely by the scientific community.
Bad practices
Yet, despite these deficiencies, Florida would give NDs the authority to order any and all lab tests (some of which are poorly regulated) and diagnostic imaging, including unnecessary pediatric labs and scam tests like IgG testing for food “sensitivities”, hair testing for “toxicities”, and secretory IgA testing, which “are often accompanied by extensive clinical interpretations which may recommend, or be used to justify, unnecessary or harmful treatments.”
If what we know about naturopathic practice in other areas holds true in Florida, and we have no reason to expect otherwise, NDs, fresh from graduation, will be able to diagnose fake diseases, like adrenal fatigue and run “detox” scams or treat real health issues with bogus remedies, like treating cervical dysplasia with escharotics or HPV with “immune boosting” herbs.
In fact, they can treat any health condition with dietary supplements and herbs which (except for true vitamin or mineral deficiency) for the most part have a poor record of safety and effectiveness. They could employ “environmental medicine” and “natural substances”, neither of which is defined.
(For a more complete discussion of bogus diagnoses, misuse of testing, and other dangers of naturopathic practice, see Scott Gavura’s “Naturopathy v. Science” series and Naturopathic Diaries.)
Homeopathic remedies
They can also treat any disease or condition (again, real or imagined) with homeopathic remedies, which is both medically and legally problematic. Medically, homeopathic remedies can’t, and don’t work, for anything, unless you’re maybe looking to induce the placebo effect. (Here’s one example of how their use by a licensed naturopathic doctor resulted in tragedy.)
Legally, federal law requires all homeopathic remedies to have FDA approval before going on the market. But, as the FDA itself has said, none of them (that’s right, none) has ever met this requirement. So, it’s not legal to sell them. Unfortunately, however, the FDA (apparently due to a lack of resources) is turning a blind eye to the whole mess. For its part, the Federal Trade Commission has warned that, if you’re going to claim a homeopathic remedy is effective for anything, you basically have to tell consumers it doesn’t work right there on the label.
And where will patients get these nostrums? From the ND who prescribed them. So convenient! As ex-naturopathic doctor Britt Hermes points out, sales of dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, and the like to patients are a significant source of ND income. (We would go ballistic if MDs routinely wrote prescriptions for drugs, then sold those drugs to their patients.)
Prescribing “substances”
As for prescription drug privileges, last year’s failed licensing bill included a naturopathic formulary (a list of drugs they could prescribe). This year (solely as a matter of political expediency, in my view) there’s a more modest ask. NDs would be able to prescribe “natural, non-pharmacologic substances”, another term that is undefined.
Whatever that means, I believe it’s there so they have the legal authority to inject these “substances”. (Drug law is complicated, but a substance that is a dietary supplement in oral form, e.g., a vitamin, can become, legally, a prescription drug when injected, requiring prescription privileges.)
This could lead to a whole lot of mischief, such as IV infusions of vitamin mixtures (including high-dose Vitamin C for cancer). Or, prior to the FDA telling the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians they couldn’t do it anymore, infused compounds of substances like cesium chloride (also for cancer) or curcumin.
Self-regulating
NDs could do all of this without any obligation to consult with the patient’s MD. And without access to the patient’s medical records, unless the state plans to force the entire health care system (hospitals, doctors, ARNPs, and the rest) to let NDs access their EHRs. (There’s no such provision in the bills.)
A Board of Naturopathic Medicine will regulate their practice, consisting of four naturopathic doctors, two medical doctors, and a layperson. In other words, the foxes will guard the henhouse, applying a naturopathic, not a medical, standard of care.
Most of the rest of the bills’ verbiage consists of impressive-looking boilerplate incorporating “naturopathic doctors” into the vast web of laws governing health care in Florida, firmly embedding them in the system like malware.
And who will pay for this? Medicare and most health insurance policies (unless forced to by a state) don’t cover naturopathic doctors and, even when they do, they don’t pay for fake diagnoses and ineffective treatments. This will leave Floridians to pay hundreds, perhaps thousands, of dollars out of pocket.
Bad choice
You’d think all of this would give the legislators pause, but you’d be wrong. I testified against naturopathic licensing in four committee meetings, raising the same concerns I catalog here. Not one legislator asked a follow-up question. The Florida Medical Association opposed the bills but waived appearance before some committees. At others, including the one I attended yesterday, they didn’t even bother. I was the sole person to actually appear in opposition before any House or Senate committee. (Fun Fact: For some unknown reason, Americans for Prosperity, the Koch brothers-funded libertarian/conservative advocacy group, is also behind naturopathic licensing in Florida.)
HB 223’s sponsor, Rep. David Smith, a central Florida Republican, has told his colleagues that naturopathic doctors will practice “lifestyle medicine”, giving examples like treating allergies, high or low blood pressure, skin problems, and “ED”. He’s said that they won’t treat cancer and that having two medical doctors on the naturopathic board will provide “medical supervision”.
This is baloney! Let me be clear: There is absolutely nothing in these bills that would limit naturopaths to “lifestyle medicine” (not that they should be doing that anyway). Once again, they will have the authority to diagnose and treat any disease or health condition.
Cancer is most certainly a “disease” and there is the so-called “specialty” of “naturopathic oncology”, which, most disturbingly, includes “pediatric naturopathic oncology”.
And about that “medical supervision”? There are four naturopathic doctors and two medical doctors on the Board, each with one vote. You do the math.
The head of the Florida Naturopathic Physicians Association testified yesterday that there were “hundreds”, which he amended to “thousands”, of articles in the medical literature attesting to the safety and effectiveness of naturopathic care. (That name should give you a hint of their real intentions: full physician scope of practice, just like an MD.) Actually, there aren’t.
Sen. Ana Maria Rodriguez, a Miami-Dade Republican, the sponsor of SB 688, for her part, simply repeats the naturopathic talking points and defends her bill as giving Floridians “choices” in her committee appearances.
Yep, it’s a choice alright. A really bad choice. And very likely to become law.

Naturopaths cannot call themselves “Medically Trained” in New Brunswick
A judge in the Canadian province of New Brunswick has ruled that alternative-to-medicine practitioners knows as naturopaths cannot claim that they are “medically trained” or that they offer “family practice”.
Scott Gavura on December 27, 2018
Link


Naturopaths are alternative medicine practitioners who claim to provide primary care, like medical doctors. This is despite that fact that they use a hodgpodge of unproven or disproven therapies, sometimes alongside conventional medical treatments. Among naturopathy’s advocates, it’s repeatedly claimed that naturopathy offers something that “conventional” medicine does not: naturopaths are described as “doctors plus”, using unconventional approaches to coax the body to “heal itself” with methods that are claimed to be safer and more effective than conventional drugs and medical interventions.
Naturopathy, as a profession, seeks the same legislative credentials and status as medical doctors. And as Jann Bellamy has pointed out, they have been fairly successful in both Canada and the United States in obtaining legislative credentialling that implies scientific legitimacy to this practice. In what looks like a modest pushback, one Canadian province has declared that naturopaths cannot position themselves as medical doctors or claim that they are “medically trained”.
In November, a column at CBC news from Dr. Michelle Cohen, a family doctor, noted:
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of New Brunswick recently conducted an investigation and found that 41 per cent of the province’s naturopaths were using restricted terms like “physician” and “medical practitioner” in contravention of New Brunswick’s Medical Act.
She continued,
To be sure, naturopathic education does involve basic science and clinical skills, but it’s unquestionably false advertising to claim that this represents “medical training.” Many health professionals complete multi-year programs where students memorize anatomy, see patients in supervised settings and get tested on clinical skills. That’s not “medical” training — it’s the essential background for almost everyone in health care. And just like “dentistry” and “nursing” are clear and unambiguous ways to describe one’s background, so too should “naturopathy” be a sufficient descriptor. The only reason to start throwing the term “medical” around is to deliberately sow confusion about your education.
Five provinces (B.C. Manitoba, Alberta, Saskatchewan and Ontario) have naturopathic colleges that regulate the profession and are mandated to protect the public. This past summer, Alberta surgeon Dr. Carrie Kollias contacted the College of Naturopathic Doctors of Alberta about a naturopath claiming to have “recently graduated from medical school.” They replied that this was “not in any way misleading” because his website listed the naturopathic school he attended. But patients shouldn’t be required to fact check their provider’s background. Using the terms “naturopathic” and “medical” as if they are interchangeable is a bait and switch designed to confuse. Condoning this behaviour as a regulator is a dereliction of duty.
As ex-naturopath Britt Marie Hermes has pointed out out her excellent blog Naturopathic Diaries, positioning naturopathy as a form of “medical” or “primary” care is very common:
Naturopathic medicine is marketed as a “distinct form of primary health care.” This phrase is ubiquitous: it appears on the websites of naturopathic medical schools, on materials published by practicing naturopaths, and on lobbying documents to promote the unfettered licensure of naturopaths and to expand eligibility for federal loan repayment programs. Based on my educational and professional experience as an accomplished member of the naturopathic community, I can say that naturopathic medicine might be a distinct form of something, but it is not any form of primary health care. I am saddened to report that not only was I misled, but so were hundreds of legislators, thousands of students, and tens of thousands of patients.
The reality is that naturopathic education is profoundly unscientific and isn’t comparable to a medical education. So when naturopaths make claims that could be misleading, it’s not surprising that they will be called out.
New Brunswick physicians sought an injunction
Earlier this month, a New Brunswick judge issued an injunction prohibiting naturopaths (who are unlicensed in that province) from making specific claims about their credentials:
Naturopaths are not medical practitioners and naturopaths are not allowed to use words to suggest that they are.
– Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Hugh McLellan
The CBC noted:
In an oral decision, Justice Hugh McLellan said the justification for naturopaths using terms such as “doctor” and “family physician” are based on the assumption that “people are attuned to the meaning of words like “naturopathy.”
Many patients might read a website or a Facebook ad out of context, he said, and fail to pick up on the difference between “a doctor listing his or her qualifications as ‘Dr. So-and-So, B.Sc., MD,’ as opposed to the listing that might include ‘B.Sc., ND [naturopathic practitioner].'”
“I see a risk here,” McLellan said, “that the words … could, in fact, imply or be designed to lead the public to believe these various naturopaths are entitled to practise medicine.”
ND = Not a Doctor
In an unrelated but also related story, a newly elected city councillor in British Columbia is also being criticized for misrepresenting her naturopathic background during the election campaign.
Coun. Allison Patton, who was voted in last month as part of Mayor Doug McCallum’s Safe Surrey Coalition slate, used her profession as a selling point during the campaign. Patton described herself as “a community physician for over 17 years” in the biography on her campaign website, without noting that she is a naturopath. She also referenced her “medical practice” in a campaign video, but did not mention that she practices naturopathy.
The story notes:
A member of the public filed a complaint on Thursday with the College of Naturopathic Physicians of B.C., alleging that Patton’s campaign materials breached the college’s advertising policy. College policy says naturopaths can describe themselves as physicians or doctors, but “the designation naturopathic physician must be used each time.” According to the policy, “Physician, as a stand alone term, could imply another type of physician, for example an MD, even in a naturopathic setting.”
Seeking primary care? Check credentials
Naturopaths lack the qualifications of medical doctors, yet may position themselves as “medically trained” and capable of providing primary care. These claims are not backed by convincing evidence. While naturopaths can offer reasonable, science-based advice, naturopaths may also offer health advice that can be at odds with medical evidence and sometimes even basic laws of physics. To date, there have been few attempts worldwide to hold naturopaths to any particular objective standard of care. Given the variety of practices that encompass “naturopathy”, some of which may have disasterous consequences, this remains a practice where the consumer must be very cautious. If you’re seeking primary care grounded in science and evidence, there’s really only one provider you should be seriously considering: a medical doctor.

Legislative Alchemy: Michigan naturopathic licensing bill passes Senate
A bill granting naturopathic doctors one of the broadest scopes of practice in the country passed in the Michigan Senate. If enacted, the egregious quackery already being practiced by Michigan naturopaths will bear the imprimatur of state approval and rectifying harm to consumers will become much harder.
Jann Bellamy on May 24, 2018
Link


A bill granting naturopathic doctors one of the broadest scopes of practice in the country passed in the Michigan Senate and is now before the House Committee on Health Policy. Funded by dietary supplement companies, the Michigan Association of Naturopathic Physicians hired a lobbyist this year to push their bill. (Just imagine the outcry if, say, nurse practitioners seeking prescription privileges got money from Big Pharma.) If enacted, Senate Bill 826 will put the imprimatur of state approval on the egregious quackery already being practiced by Michigan naturopathic doctors (or “NDs”, terms I will use in this post to distinguish them from traditional naturopaths) and, by legalizing these practices, will make holding them accountable all but impossible.
This is not the ND’s first attempt to legalize “naturopathic medicine” in Michigan, although the websites of practicing naturopaths in the state indicate they are not dissuaded by current law banning the unlicensed practice of medicine from claiming they can treat a wide range of conditions with their “natural” methods, as myself, Michigan resident David Gorski (also here), and our good friend Orac (also here), have previously discussed. (Orac covered SB 826 yesterday.)
Unfortunately, the Michigan State Medical Society appears to be asleep at the wheel on this one. They are “monitoring” the bill, with no “for” or “against” position taken. This is a shame, if only for their own protection: MDs whose patients see NDs will spend extra time cleaning up the deleterious effects (also here) of their substandard practices and battling the quack notions put into their patients’ heads, not to mention naturopathic anti-vaccination ideology. The good news is that the Michigan Academy of Family Physicians is actively opposing the bill and has some great information on why NDs should not be licensed.
Short on science and 15,000+ hours of training, but no matter
As a demonstration of just how radical this bill is, let’s briefly compare “conventional” medical education to naturopathic “medical” education and training in the context of the scope of practice NDs would attain if SB 826 passes.
As it now stands in Michigan, only medical doctors (MDs) and doctors of osteopathy (DOs) have the legal authority to diagnose and treat, without limitation, the undifferentiated patient, that is, any person with any disease or condition. For this privilege, they go through a highly selective process (mean GPA of 3.56; mean Medical College Admissions Test score of 504; 7% acceptance rate). Four years of medical school, which includes about 9,000 hours of classroom and clinical education, is followed by three or more years of residency, consisting of tens of thousands of hours taking care of patients in a variety of clinical settings, including outpatient and hospital facilities. During medical school and residency, MDs and DOs must also pass the 3-part U.S. Medical Licensing Examination. The entire process of education, training and testing, is part of the traditional university-based educational system and detailed information is available to the public and policy makers.
SB 826 would introduce a new category of practitioner who has the authority to diagnose and treat any patient of any age – neonate to senior citizen – with any disease or condition: naturopathic doctors, who, like MDs and DOs, would be allowed to call themselves “physicians.”
The naturopathic doctor will begin practice at a distinct disadvantage in education and training compared to his supposed peers in conventional medicine. Unlike conventional medical schools, naturopathic medicine is taught in small, independent schools that operate outside the traditional university system and are accredited by an agency run by naturopaths. Although their accrediting agency has been approved by the U.S. Department of Education, the Department focuses on administrative and financial issues and does not vet curricula for their scientific accuracy or rigor. There is no admission test (not even the GRE) for naturopathic medical schools and almost everyone is accepted due to low admission standards.
While the naturopathic curriculum includes conventional scientific subjects, they are entry-level courses, not as rigorous as the advanced courses taught in conventional medical schools. And time that would be devoted to scientific subjects in medical school, like pharmacology, are crowded out by hours spent learning disproven treatments like homeopathy and energy healing, botanical drugs that have never been tested for safety and efficacy in humans, and dangerous modalities like ozone therapy.
Naturopaths have also created their own licensing exam, the NPLEX, which is shrouded in secrecy and has never been independently reviewed to determine whether it adequately vets naturopathic graduates for safe and effective practice. (While SB 826 doesn’t mention the NPLEX, it’s clear the NPLEX is intended.)
But the biggest difference in preparation for practice is in naturopathic clinical training: no residency is required for becoming licensed as a naturopathic doctor in Michigan. (In fact, there are few naturopathic residencies available anyway and even those last only one year.) Their only experience actually diagnosing and treating patients is in the 1,200 hours of clinical training, not all of which involves patient care, required during naturopathic school. This takes place, for the most part, in school clinics, where naturopathic students see patients with a very limited range of diseases and conditions. When no patient with a condition required to complete their training presents himself, naturopathic students simply practice on each other or give a presentation on the condition.
The American Academy of Family Physicians has put a number on that difference in training, and it’s huge: a family practice physician will have a whopping 15,000+ hours more experience diagnosing and treating a broad range of patients than a naturopathic doctor. Yet the state of Michigan will allow naturopathic doctors, 42% of whom typically go into solo practice, to act not only as primary care physicians, but specialists as well, a topic we’ll return to in a moment.
In allowing naturopathic doctors to see, without supervision, the undifferentiated patient, Michigan legislators seriously underestimate the importance of diagnostic skills. A basic fallacy underlying all naturopathic licensing is that, because they are supposedly using “natural” treatments to boost the “body’s self-healing ability,” diagnostic skill doesn’t matter. This ignores the fact that effective treatment depends on accurate diagnosis. There are thousands of diseases and conditions. As noted by the National Academies of Science et al. in Improving Diagnostics in Health Care (2015):
At the outset, it can be very difficult to determine which particular diagnosis is indicated by a particular combination of symptoms, especially if symptoms are nonspecific, such as fatigue. Diseases may also present atypically, with an unusual and unexpected constellation of symptoms.
The most frequently cited diagnostic errors are cancers, heart disease, cardiovascular disease, infections and stroke. Obviously, naturopathic doctors who have seen only a handful of these cases (if any) in clinical training are going to be woefully unequipped to appropriately diagnose them. The adequacy of current medical education in teaching diagnostic skills is itself under review; receiving a small fraction of clinical training that current medical education requires does not improve the situation. NDs often say they will collaborate with MDs and refer when necessary, but that misses the point. You can’t collaborate on a disease you don’t have the skills to diagnose or refer to a specialist when you don’t recognize the condition requiring specialty care. These are the “unknown unknowns,” as Donald Rumsfeld put it.
Adding to the dangers of naturopathic diagnosis is the tendency of NDs to fabricate conditions that don’t exist. Constellations of vague symptoms like fatigue, dizziness, headaches and nausea are turned into Wilson’s Temperature Syndrome, adrenal fatigue, “chronic” Lyme, “chronic” candidiasis, and the alternative medicine version of thyroid disease. Any of these could be a misdiagnosis of a very real disease or, alternatively, putting a label on benign symptoms and treating them unnecessarily.
Unfortunately, these diagnostic misadventures are aided, in SB 826, by the authority to order and perform laboratory testing and order diagnostic imaging. This presents two problems. The first is lack of training in ordering an appropriate test, a task that can stump even MDs and DOs:
The task of selecting the appropriate diagnostic testing is challenging for clinicians, in part because of the sheer volume of choices. For example, Hickner and colleagues (2014) found that primary care clinicians report uncertainty in ordering laboratory medicine tests in approximately 15 percent of diagnostic encounters.
SB 826 limits NDs to diagnostic testing “consistent with his or her naturopathic education and training” (the bill doesn’t say who gets to make that call), implicitly recognizing the problem this bill creates: NDs will have far less “education and training” in diagnostic testing, necessarily limiting their testing choices, but aren’t limited in the diseases they can diagnose and treat. How is that going to work?
Under the category of “minor office surgery,” NDs would also be allowed to obtain “specimens to diagnose, assess, and treat disease.” Presumably, this would include needle, aspiration, and skin biopsies.
And that’s only the valid tests. The second problem is that naturopathy is steeped in the use of clinically unvalidated tests (unfortunately, because of lack of FDA oversight these are widely available) which they use to justify all manner of unwarranted treatments. These include dubious MTHFR genetic testing, IgG food intolerance testing, “provoked” testing for heavy metals, hair mineral analysis (“a cardinal sign of quackery”), live blood analysis, and applied kinesiology, to name a few.
In sum, NDs, with their inadequate command of valid diagnostic tools, aren’t up to the task of diagnosing the unlimited range of patients this Michigan bill would allow them to see, although they do have an impressive grasp of bogus testing modalities.
Dubious naturopathic treatments
Having diagnosed that problem, let’s turn to the treatments SB 826 would allow. Here again we find a combination of conventional medicine (without the conventional training) and pseudoscience.
Their scope of practice would include prescription of dietary supplements and botanical medicine (the vast majority of which are untested in humans for safety and efficacy) and homeopathic medicines (all of which, the FDA recently admitted, are on the market illegally because they’re not FDA-approved). In addition to colonics (see below), massive doses of dietary supplements are a key ingredient in naturopathic “detox” scams. NDs, oblivious to ethical concerns about conflicts of interest, make a good bit of their income selling dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, and the other nostrums they prescribe to patients.
They would also be able to prescribe drugs (except controlled substances) and medical devices and non-prescription drugs listed on a formulary approved by the Board of Naturopathic Medicine, a body we’ll return to shortly. Routes of administration include oral, nasal, auricular, ocular, rectal, vaginal, transdermal, intradermal, subcutaneous, intravenous, or intramuscular. As you will soon see, we have every reason to believe the formulary will include the makings of discredited and potentially dangerous naturopathic favorites like Myers cocktails, turmeric infusions, escharotic treatment of cervical dysplasia (also here), compounded chelators (administered IV), high-dose Vitamin C, and intravenous peroxide for chronic infections.
Other modalities in their scope of practice include:
    • Hydrotherapy, the umbrella under which “colon cleanses” reside, used by naturopaths for bogus “detoxification.”
    • Health education and health counseling and use of food in treatment. This will allow NDs to legally prescribe their kooky diets and fasting, which can be dangerous.
    • Repair and care incidental to superficial lacerations or abrasions, therapeutic devices, electromagnetic energy and barrier contraceptives.
NDs would be regulated by a Board of Naturopathic Medicine, consisting of six “naturopathic physicians,” one MD or DO physician, one pharmacist, one chiropractor and two public members. The Board will regulate all aspects of naturopathic practice, including enacting rules, approving continuing education courses, discipline and, as mentioned, crafting the naturopathic formulary. Given the fact that there is no standard of care in naturopathy, it will be virtually impossible to discipline NDs for malpractice, no matter how egregious the harm or outlandish the quackery, especially with naturopaths holding a majority on the Board. This will also guarantee that the formulary’s list of drugs they prescribe will be long. The well-documented fact that NDs do not have (once again) adequate education and training to prescribe drugs will undoubtedly fall on deaf ears. (For Connecticut’s analysis of why NDs shouldn’t be allowed to prescribe, see here, and click on “Special Act 16-3 Committee on the Practice of Naturopathy.)
It will be interesting to see if the formulary includes vaccines. Naturopathy is notoriously anti-vaccination, and seeing a naturopathic is associated with both not being up-to-date on vaccinations and acquisition of vaccine-preventable diseases. In fact, the longer they are in school, the more anti-vaccination they become.
And no telling what will come of this provision, rounding out their scope of practice:
Other naturopathic therapies approved by the Board.
In a fascinating deviation from other licensing bills, SB 826 does not define naturopathic medicine as “primary care.” Rather, it says:
“Naturopathic medicine” means a system of practice that is based on the natural healing capacity of individuals for the diagnoses, treatment, and prevention of disease.
“Natural healing capacity of individuals” is, of course, vitalism, a long-discredited notion of how the human body functions. That aside, I suspect the omission of “primary care” is intentional and meant to expand their scope of practice beyond primary care. According to the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) NDs also practice as specialists, and nothing in this bill would prevent them from doing so:
Like MDs, a growing number of naturopathic doctors choose to specialize or focus their practices. Specialty associations currently exist for Endocrinology, Environmental Medicine, Gastroenterology, Parenteral Therapies, Pediatrics, Primary Care Physicians, Psychiatry, and Oncology. In addition, while practicing Family Medicine, many naturopathic doctors choose an area of focus based on a therapeutic, condition, or population subset.
Like the pseudo-medicine practiced by NDs, these are pseudo-specialties. With one exception, all you need to do to become a “specialist” in these fields is to pay a membership fee. (There was no publicly available information on the Parenteral Therapies “specialty.”) To become a “Fellow to [sic] the American Board of Naturopathic Oncology,” you must meet these low-bar requirements: paid membership dues, devote at least 65% of your practice to oncology patients, fill out an application form, and “present case studies and pass an exam.” By way of comparison, to become a board-certified oncologist in “conventional” medicine, you must be Board-certified in Internal Medicine (3-year residency), complete a fellowship in oncology, and pass an examination. That the AANP would call these “specialties” with a straight face says a lot about the organization’s commitment to providing truthful information to the public about naturopathy.
Once again, credulous legislators have fallen for the myth that naturopaths can successfully treat and prevent chronic disease, all at a lower cost than conventional medical care. There is simply no good evidence to support these claims but plenty of evidence that naturopaths can cause real harm. If SB 826 passes, it will be one of the few bright spots in the naturopathic legislative agenda for 2018. Naturopathic licensing and practice expansion have been rejected this year (so far) in Alaska, Connecticut, Hawaii, Indiana, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Washington and Wyoming. (Looks like their bill in Minnesota is not going anywhere either.) In fact, the majority of states do not license naturopathic doctors and have repeatedly rejected licensing efforts (also here and here). Michigan should follow suit.
Resources for opposing naturopathic licensing
    • 2018 Fact Sheet on Naturopathic Medicine
    • Naturopathic Diaries
    • American Academy of Family Physicians, Education and Training: Family Physicians versus Naturopaths

Connecticut “modernizes” naturopathic scope of practice
Jann Bellamy on October 16, 2014
Link
Naturopathy has been legal in Connecticut for almost 90 years, but with a scope of practice limited to counseling and a few treatments like physiotherapy, colonic hydrotherapy and “natural substances.” There was no specific authority to diagnose and treat. All of that changed on October 1, 2014, courtesy of the Connecticut legislature, which, in the words of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP), “modernized” the naturopathic scope of practice.
Actually, the legislature did nothing of the sort. Naturopathy is based on the prescientific concept of vitalism, and we find it right there in the very first paragraph of the new law. Naturopathy is defined as:
diagnosis, prevention and treatment of disease and health optimization by stimulation and support of the body’s natural healing processes, as approved by the State Board of Natureopathic [sic] Examiners, with the consent of the Commissioner of Public Health. . .
Also included in the expanded scope of practice are:
ordering diagnostic tests and other diagnostic procedures, . . . ordering medical devices, including continuous glucose monitors, glucose meters, glucose test strips, barrier contraceptives and durable medical equipment; and . . . removing ear wax, removing foreign bodies from the ear, nose and skin, shaving corns and calluses, spirometry, tuberculosis testing, vaccine administration, venipuncture for blood testing and minor wound repair, including suturing.
So, they will be measuring lung function with spirometry (and presumably treating lung diseases) and diagnosing and treating diabetes, as well as removing ear wax and shaving corns and callouses. What an odd hodgepodge! “Vaccine administration” obviously includes advice on whether to vaccinate, a disturbing thought given naturopaths’ anti-vaccination ideology. And I do have to wonder exactly how much suturing naturopaths have had the opportunity to do in their residency-free education and training.
The Connecticut Naturopathic Physicians Association (CNPA) appears to be unaware of their legislative success. (Yes, they will be able to call themselves “physicians.”) As of October 15, 2014, their website is still asking for support for practice expansion.
Naturopaths wanted, but were not given, the authority to “prescribe, dispense and administer legend and non-legend drugs in all routes of administration.” They vow to come back next year to ask again in accordance with the AANP’s strategy of naturopaths having full primary care physician scope of practice in all states.
In promoting this legislation, the naturopaths made the same arguments they always make. First, they that their education and training prepares them for full primary care scope of practice, which will help ease the primary care physicians shortage. This is what we call a “conclusory allegation” in the legal trade. There are no facts to back it up. It’s like saying “the defendant was negligent” in a personal injury case without presenting any facts to support that conclusion. You can’t get away with it in court and they shouldn’t get away with it before the state legislatures, but they do.
On the other hand, there is quite a bit of evidence that their education and training is wanting. As we know, the naturopathic educational system is virtually self-contained. Their schools are stand-alone, not part of any public or private university system. No objective evaluation of these schools by third parties has ever taken place and there are no studies to support this imagined equivalency.
Or you could just look at their practices: whether treatment of allergies or infertility, vaccination, pre-natal vitamins, women’s health, or the many other ways SBM posts have demonstrated that naturopathic practice is not science-based, or evidence-based or even reality-based. Or the fact that what little data there is shows that seeing a naturopath is associated with worse care. And if that doesn’t convince you, Orac’s posts last week (here and here), revealing some recently-discovered discussions among naturopathic practitioners, should leave no doubt.
Naturopaths contend they can safely prescribe drugs because there have been few malpractice and disciplinary claims made against them arising from prescribing medications. Of course, for those figures to be relevant, one would have to first show that there is a connection between provider negligence and malpractice claims. In fact, no such relationship has been established. (Also here.)
One good argument against their having prescription privileges is right there on the CNPA website. After the recent contaminated compounded drug debacle, Congress wanted to clean up the industry. The FDA is enacting new rules governing compounding pharmacies, and the naturopaths are terrified that their in-office compounding privileges might be taken away. The AANP is making a pitch on the CNPA’s website for everyone to rally to the cause. They want to pump their patients’ bodies with questionable treatments such as injectable vitamins and IV solutions and herbal suppositories, from which patients, according to the AANP, “derive tremendous benefit” and they want to do it in the privacy of their own offices.
The naturopaths also touted the enhanced ability to collaborate with other health care professionals. That hasn’t worked out so well elsewhere. One MD, the “Physician Lead for Integrative Medicine at Kaiser Permanente Northwest,” (KPNW) who is quite sympathetic to CAM, reported on the difficulties of managing patients with naturopaths.
At KPNW, medical physicians will refer patients “who have failed usual care” to naturopaths for a limited number of conditions based on an “evidence grid” developed by KPNW. (The grid is necessary due to the lack of adequate evidence for naturopathic treatments. If you don’t have much in the way of actual studies and such, you have to work something out, and they came up with a grid.) The article gives us a rare glimpse into the world of actual naturopathic practice and what we see is disturbing, although entirely consistent with what we might expect. (I’ve omitted citations in the interest of brevity.)
These problems included patients asking MDs to order tests recommended by naturopaths which “are either unrecognizable or seem inappropriate.”
The most frequent example relates to evaluation and management of thyroid disorders. Naturopathic physicians will commonly recommend multiple hormone studies, including T3 and T4 levels, in settings where, from a primary care internal medicine perspective, the sensitive thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) test is the only appropriate test. The patient is understandably confused, having received contradictory advice from the naturopath on the one side and internist, or endocrinologist, on the other. Whom to believe? Many patients do not discriminate that endocrinologists, who are residency and fellowship trained, have five more years of training than the naturopathic physician in this area.
That five years hardly begins to describe the differences between a naturopath and an endocrinologist. Of course, you’d think the naturopath would defer to the endocrinologist, as an MD or DO PCP would do, but apparently not.
Patient management is an issue as well.
Naturopaths will typically advise patients to supplement with combination T3-T4 preparations, such as desiccated thyroid. This contradicts conventional endocrine guidelines for Levothroid T4 supplementation in the setting of hypothyroidism. Desiccated thyroid preparations may provide inconsistent levels of thyroid hormone from one batch to the next. T3-containing preparations may also provide for more fluctuation, and less steady state, of thyroid hormone levels because of the rapid gastrointestinal absorption and the relatively short half-life of T3. In addition, blinded RCT data have shown no benefit of combination T3-T4 preparations over T4 in terms of patients’ symptoms and quality of life. The naturopathic community’s failure to clearly articulate responses to these points severely aggravates negative perceptions of naturopathy within mainstream medicine. Some naturopaths will recommend thyroid supplementation for patients who are biochemically euthryoid (normal TSH). A subset of these patients will later present to the primary care internist or endocrinologist on inappropriate doses of thyroid hormone, with a suppressed TSH. In the worst-case scenario, the patient rejects the internist’s advice to change and reduce thyroid supplementation, and assumes a hostile stance to the internist’s refusal to order T4 and T3 levels. Yet such inappropriate thyroid supplementation will increase the patient’s risk for atrial fibrillation, osteoporosis, and other complications of hyperthyroidism.
Yes, I suppose a physician’s “negative perceptions of naturopathy” would be “severely aggravated” if some naturopath were endangering his patients’ health. Just imagine being a fellowship-trained endocrinologist and dealing with this folderol from folks who’ve never even done a residency and spent a good bit of time learning the finer points of homeopathy in “medical” school.
Beyond management of thyroid patients “there are numerous other sources of contention” such as:
Many patients with fatigue and other nonspecific complaints will be given the diagnosis of “systemic candidiasis” by their naturopathic physician. This naturopathic diagnosis presumably suggests some imbalance or irregularity of the indigenous microbial flora. These patients sometimes present to their internists for further evaluation and management of this condition. However, as the patients generally have no clinical or laboratory evidence of candidemia, the baffled internist cannot locate or reinforce the diagnosis, leaving all parties frustrated.
And then there are the dietary issues:
Although most allopathic primary care physicians welcome additional attention and counseling for the patient toward proper and healthy dietary habits, many in the naturopathic community seem to promote eating patterns that may appear faddish to the internist. For example, patients who visit naturopaths are almost universally advised to discontinue consumption of wheat and dairy products.
Also:
Similarly, prescribing a strict gluten-free diet in the absence of objective biopsy or serologic evidence of celiac disease imposes extremely severe restrictions on the patient’s cuisine which may be largely unnecessary.
Patients and medical physicians aren’t the only ones who are disadvantaged by these practices. The author reports that, of the funds spent on referrals to CAM practitioners over the first 8 months of 2012, 72% was paid to acupuncturists, 23% to chiropractors, but only 4% to naturopaths. They cause too many problems and medical doctors simply don’t want to refer to them.
Look out, Connecticut
Connecticut naturopaths have already established a beachhead in quackademic medical centers at Yale and the University of Connecticut. According to the CNPA, naturopaths:
are trained to serve as primary care general practitioners who are experts in the prevention, diagnosis, management, and treatment of both acute and chronic health conditions.
What sort of “primary care” might Connecticut’s citizens expect from the state’s 228 licensed “naturopathic physicians” now that their scope of practice has been “modernized?” (By way of comparison, there are 17,294 physicians and surgeons and 9 homeopaths.)
Let’s visit the Connecticut Center for Health, a 5-member practice with offices in Middleton and West Hartford. One of their practitioners is a founding member of the AANP and another is the acting president of CNPA. All are graduates of naturopathic schools accredited by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education. Some are holding positions at these schools. Certainly, we would not expect such leaders to deviate from the naturopathic standard of care. In fact, they seem to be regarded as exemplars of naturopathic practice by their peers.
Remember those problems Kaiser Permanente medical doctors were having with naturopaths? Apparently, Connecticut MDs and DOs will be confronting the same issues.
Thyroid disorder:
We thoroughly evaluate thyroid function by looking at T3 and T4 and determine if they are optimum and not just normal.
“Systemic candidiasis”:
Antibiotics, high sugar diet, steroids, and a low fiber diet may cause an imbalance in either the bacteria or fungi (yeast) in your intestines. Once an imbalance takes hold, it can cause significant problems with the intestines directly causing irritable bowel, gas, bloating, colitis, and a depressed immune function leading to chronic infections and/or allergies, asthma, hives, and fatigue. (For more information on this you can read The Yeast Connection by William Crook).
Three different lab tests help identify these underlying problems. Candida antibody blood panel, dysbiosis markers in urine, and stool culture.
Faddish diets (in this case for autism):
    • Diet of foods that are unrefined, free of additives, varied, fresh, little or no sugar. Focus on minimizing carbohydrate and make sure there is an adequate intake of protein and essential fatty acids (EFAs).
    • A gluten (no wheat, oats, rye, barley) and casein-free (no dairy) diet, avoiding both for at least 12 weeks.
    • A yeast- and mold-free diet for a minimum of 6 weeks.
    • A diagnostic trial of avoidance of all common allergenic foods for a minimum of 4 weeks, including: dairy products, wheat, baker’s yeast, brewer’s yeast, sugar, eggs, corn, peanuts, orange, lemon, lime, soy foods, shellfish, and tomato.
    • A trial removing the foods your child is allergic to, as identified through food allergy testing.
In their discussion of autism’s causes, they posit that:
immunizations, particularly measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine, may precipitate autism. This is a very heated debate and research is still ongoing–no one knows for sure.
Well, I suppose if you are the vaccine-autism fraud perpetrator Andrew Wakefield there is a “heated debate.” Actually, we do know that the MMR vaccine never had any connection with autism and it doesn’t now. Remember, these folks can now administer immunizations. Wonder what they’ll tell parents about the MMR vaccine?
Unfortunately, their autism “treatments” are not limited to diet. They also recommend dietary supplements, non-fluoridated water and toothpaste, injections of secretin and IV gamma globulin, anti-fungal medication if intestinal “imbalances” are found, a trial of DMSA to chelate mercury if the child’s levels were high on testing (presumably the unvalidated and possibly harmful provoked urine test). As they don’t have the authority to prescribe, I am not sure how they are giving the injections and IV treatments. If the autistic child has “never been well” since being vaccinated, they say they can address this with homeopathy.
Autistic children are not the only victims of their pediatric quackery. They also claim they are “quite experienced in how to treat osteogenesis imperfecta.” Osteogenesis imperfecta is a rare genetic bone disorder characterized by fragile bones that break easily. It is also known as “brittle bone disease.” Specially trained medical professionals, such as pediatric orthopedists, supervise the management of a patient with OI. Notably, the OI Foundation does not count naturopaths among those professionals. But that doesn’t stop the naturopaths at Connecticut Center for Health, who promote herbal medicine, avoiding dairy, and (I kid you not) homeopathy for OI.
If you will permit me one more example from this target-rich website, just because naturopaths seem so enamored of the bowels:
The amount of stool that you eliminate each day has a tremendous impact on health and wellbeing. Stool volume eliminated in a 24-hour period should total 18 inches or more. If stool stays in the bowel longer than it should, the bowel reabsorbs a variety of potentially toxic chemicals into the blood. These chemicals cause the liver to overwork and may disorder the immune and nervous systems. . . Making sure you have daily adequate stool elimination is probably one of the most important things you can do to restore and maintain health.
Get out your rulers Connecticut! If you’re not producing 18 inches a day, you’re toast.

Oh no, not again! Massachusetts Legislature passes naturopathic licensing bill
The Massachusetts legislature passed a licensing bill giving naturopaths the right to use bogus lab tests to diagnose fake diseases and treat patients with useless remedies like homeopathy and herbs. It’s up to Gov. Baker to stop this.
Jann Bellamy on January 7, 2017
Link
UPDATE: Unfortunately, Gov. Baker signed the bill on January 11th. We’ll be watching, and reporting, as naturopathic quackery spreads throughout Massachusetts.
The Massachusetts Legislature (formally known as the “General Court”) passed a licensing bill for naturopaths on January 3, 2017. (Orac covered the bill’s passing as well.) The bill is now on the Governor’s desk for consideration. We’ll get to the legislative machinations behind the bill in a minute, but first let’s look at some key provisions of the bill and what they mean in actual practice.
Definition of naturopathy
Naturopathy is defined in the bill as
a system of health care practices for the prevention, evaluation and treatment of illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body through the use of education, nutrition, natural medicines and therapies and other modalities which are designed to support, stimulate or supplement the human body’s own natural self-healing processes.
What this means
Stimulating the body’s “natural self-healing processes” is vitalism, a long discredited, pre-scientific notion that there is some incorporeal force operating outside the realm of scientific knowledge controlling human bodily function. Massachusetts naturopaths will be free to discard evidence-based medicine and even the most basic principles of chemistry, biology and physiology, as long as they believe that this mythical force, which they call “vis,” is at work via their treatments.
While they are prevented by this bill from claiming they are physicians or practice primary care, this definition essentially obliterates any patient protection offered by those restrictions by giving naturopaths the right to diagnose and treat any disease or condition in any patient of any age. Comments like that of a physician quoted in the Boston Globe‘s story on the bill ignore this reality:
Dr. Michelle Dossett, a Massachusetts General Hospital internist who specializes in mind-body medicine, said that naturopaths often do a better job than physicians at ‘using lifestyle-based approaches to prevent and help to manage chronic disease.’
Even if that were true (which it isn’t, a point we’ll return to shortly), the Massachusetts Legislature isn’t limiting naturopaths to “life-style approaches to prevent and help manage chronic disease.” Instead, without limitation, naturopaths will be able to diagnose and treat what is known as the “undifferentiated patient” – anyone who walks in the door with a collection of symptoms, challenging the health care practitioner to figure out what those symptoms mean. The patient could have, for example, undiagnosed cancer, diabetes, hypertension, epilepsy, AIDS or a host of other infectious diseases, COPD, asthma, allergies, MS or other challenging-to-diagnose neurological disease. MDs and DOs spend thousands of hours in residency learning to evaluate and treat these diseases and, importantly, learning when to refer and to whom. Naturopaths do not do residencies. Their education and training is woefully inadequate to diagnose, manage or know when to refer these patients, a topic we’ll return to later.
Diagnostics
The bill allows naturopaths to use
non-invasive physical examinations and the ordering clinical and laboratory procedures from licensed clinics or laboratories to evaluate injuries, illnesses and conditions in the human body.
What this means
The use of unproven tests to diagnose fake diseases and conditions is the bread and butter of naturopathic practice, and this bill allows it. The mere fact that a clinic or lab is “licensed” does not mean that the testing it offers is legitimate.
It is well-documented that naturopaths employ an array of bogus tests to “diagnose” patients with fabricated diseases and conditions. These include:
    • IgG food allergy/intolerance testing
    • Hair analysis
    • Salivary hormone testing
    • Bioidentical hormones
    • Blood nutrition analysis
    • Electrodermal screening
    • MELISA testing
    • Autonomic response testing
    • MTHFR genetic testing
    • Various tests for “toxins”
    • Live blood analysis
Treatments
The bill says naturopathic practice includes
the prevention and treatment of human illness, injury or disease through education, dietary or nutritional advice and the promotion of health ways of living.
Treatments include
Natural medicines of mineral, animal or botanical origin, including food products or extracts, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, digestive aids, natural hormones, plant substances, homeopathic preparations [and] natural antibiotics. . . to prevent or treat illnesses, injuries and conditions of the human body.
What this means
Again, the bill gives naturopaths an extremely broad scope of practice: the treatment of any disease or condition in any patient of any age, essentially the same as an MD or DO. Treatment of fake diseases and substandard treatment of real diseases and conditions are endemic to naturopathic practice, and this bill does nothing to prevent it. Thus, far from “using lifestyle-based approaches to prevent and help to manage chronic disease,” naturopaths actually convince patients they are ill when, in fact, they may be perfectly healthy. Some examples of fabricated diseases and substandard treatment of real diseases:
    • “Wilson’s temperature syndrome“
    • “Chronic candidiasis“
    • “Adrenal fatigue“
    • Hypothyroidism (pseudoscientific version)
    • Diabetes
    • Autism
    • Infertility
    • Allergies
    • Cancer
    • Bipolar disease
The difference between physician scope of practice and naturopathic scope of practice is in the limitation on the methods of treatment they can use. Here lies another central fallacy of naturopathic licensing: that somehow preventing or treating disease with “natural” remedies is as effective as, but less dangerous than, using prescription drugs, so we should give naturopaths carte blanche to use “natural” remedies to treat real diseases.
Neither is true. In fact, among the substances listed in the bill, with limited exceptions for real vitamin deficiency (rarely seen in the U.S.) and a handful of other situations (like folate supplementation in pregnancy), the majority do not have an adequate body of evidence supporting their use and some are downright worthless, but are used by naturopaths in practice anyway (also here). One of those in the “worthless” category is homeopathy, a staple of naturopathic practice. Another is “ozone therapy.” Other problematic remedies include “natural hormones” and glandulars (desiccated animal glands), used to treat endocrine conditions. Both are considered substandard in medical practice. Dietary supplements, a category that encompasses vitamins, minerals, botanicals and enzymes, are not required to be tested for safety or efficacy prior to sale and contamination is an issue (also here).
Naturopaths will be able to sell these “remedies” to patients, at a tidy profit.
Dr. Dossett and others who think naturopaths simply offer “lifestyle recommendations” to manage chronic disease should read the accounts of three patients (here, here and here) whose chronic conditions were grossly mismanaged using naturopathic regimens typical of their grab-bag approach to patient care. (For even more dubious naturopathic practices, see here.)
The bill also allows “naturopathic physical medicine.” Significantly, physical medicine includes “hydrotherapy,” which means naturopaths will be able to employ “colonic irrigation;” essentially, a big enema. The purpose of colonics, in the naturopathic mind, is to remove ubiquitous “toxins” (never specified and never identified upon their supposed removal) that naturopaths believe are lurking in our digestive systems and elsewhere. This is not only useless, it carries the risk of bowel perforation, infection and depletion of electrolytes. Other naturopathic means of “detox” include ingestion of unproven herbs and sitting in saunas.
Restrictions on practice
In addition to preventing them from calling themselves “physicians” or claiming they practice primary care, naturopaths must track and document their patient’s immunization status and refer patients to a primary care practitioner when the patient has not been fully immunized. They may not prescribe drugs or practice surgery.
What this means
It is well documented that naturopaths are anti-vaccination (also here, here, here, and here) and the Massachusetts Legislature tacitly acknowledges this fact in the bill. It is disturbing that the legislators were well aware of naturopathic anti-vaccination ideology, yet chose to allow them a broad scope of practice and self-regulation.
The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians desires full primary care scope of practice in all 50 states, including full prescription privileges. Their strategy has been to accept more limited scope initially, then come back to the legislature for prescription privileges, or expanded prescription privileges, year after year. We can rest assured that they will do the same in Massachusetts.
Requirements for licensure
Naturopaths must have graduated from a four-year naturopathic school and must take an exam for licensure. While the bill allows regulators to create their own exam, it also permits them to use the NPLEX, which is created by naturopaths. (This is the option I imagine regulators will choose.) Licensure by reciprocity is also allowed. No malpractice insurance is required.
What this means
No one outside of naturopathy has ever seen a copy of the NPLEX exam nor has it ever been evaluated by outside experts for its scientific quality, or lack thereof. Given the combined factors of poor employment prospects elsewhere, the lack of licensure in other states, and the extremely generous scope of practice granted by this bill (other states have a more restricted practice), Massachusetts can expect more naturopaths to move to the state.
While naturopaths tout their education and training as equal to that of a primary care physician, this is a gross misrepresentation. The best source of accurate information on the subject is Britt Hermes, a former licensed naturopath who quit after becoming disgusted and disillusioned with her chosen profession. She has spoken out forcefully, and effectively, against licensing naturopaths and practice expansion. I can do no better than to refer you to her posts on naturopathic education and training on her own blog, Naturopathic Diaries.
Regulation
The bill creates a five-member naturopathic regulatory board, which will write regulations governing naturopathic practice, including “requirements for a specialty practice.” The Board will also approve continuing education courses, establish a code of ethics and oversee disciplinary proceedings. The Board will consist of two naturopaths, one physician who has experience working with naturopaths, one clinical pharmacologist and one public member.
What this means
Having a physician on the Board experienced in working with naturopaths is likely designed to ensure that a sympathetic “integrative physician” who also incorporates pseudoscience into his or her practice will apply and be appointed. That means the clinical pharmacologist may be the sole voice of science and evidence on the board. It is also possible that naturopaths will urge patients sympathetic to naturopathy to apply for the public member seat. Based on personal knowledge of the situation, this is what happened in Maryland, where the public member voted with the two naturopathic members and against the two physician members of a naturopathic advisory committee time and again.
Because naturopathy has no discernible standard of care and naturopaths do not practice evidence-based medicine, the board will have little to guide it when deciding complaints against naturopaths for substandard care. One wonders whether, except in the case of some sort of gross incompetence, a naturopath would ever be disciplined for malpractice, because malpractice doesn’t seem to exist in the naturopathic mindset. If there isn’t a standard of care, how does one fall below it? For example, an Arizona naturopath was caught illegally importing and giving patients a cancer drug that had not been approved by the FDA, but was only lightly disciplined.
Some naturopaths claim they are “specialists” in cancer and pediatrics, although they do not do real medical residencies or fellowships in these specialties. This provision means that the board will have the power to determine what “specialties” naturopaths can claim in advertising and what requirements (if any) these “specialists” must fulfill.
Legislative machinations
Based on the Multistate website’s calendar of legislative sessions, I was under the impression that the Massachusetts legislature adjourned December 31, 2016, and therefore the bill was dead. This is incorrect, and I apologize to any readers who were misled by that information. In the future, I will use a more reliable calendar.
Even so, the bill’s transformation from languishing in committee to a lightning-speed trip through the Legislature does raise suspicions that the legislators were less than well-informed about what the bill actually said and what it will do.
The Senate passed a naturopathic licensing bill in early June, 2016. The bill then went to the House, where it was referred to the House Ways and Means Committee on June 15. There it sat until January 3, 2017. Here’s what happened on that single day:
    • Bill amended and reported out of the House Ways and Means Committee
    • Bill referred to the House Steering, Policy and Scheduling Committee
    • Bill went from that Committee through the three required readings before the House (Because the House was in informal session, no attendance was taken and no votes recorded.)
    • House adopted an amendment to the bill
    • House passed the bill and sent back to Senate
    • Senate concurred in the House amendment (Because the Senate was in informal session, no attendance was taken and no votes recorded.)
    • House enacted the bill
    • Senate enacted the bill and sent to the Governor
The Governor could either sign the bill or veto it. Or, he could do nothing. If he chooses that option, according to the Massachusetts Bar Association, it either becomes law, after 10 days in which the Legislature is in session, or, if the Legislature has adjourned, it is “pocketed vetoed” after 10 days. The Legislature has adjourned the session in which this bill passed, although the effect of this is unclear. This is not the first time the Massachusetts legislature has engaged in last-minute legislative shenanigans in passing a naturopathic licensing bills. The last time this happened, then-Governor Deval Patrick vetoed it. A Boston Globe editorial urges the Governor to veto this bill as well. I agree. (You can reach Gov. Charlie Baker at 617-725-4005.)

Naturopathic conquest of New England nears completion
Rhode Island is poised to become the latest state to succumb to the false notion that licensing naturopathic “doctors” will protect the public health and safety, making naturopathic conquest of New England complete.
Jann Bellamy on July 20, 2017
Link


Rhode Island is poised to become the latest state to succumb to the false notion that licensing naturopathic “doctors” will protect the public health, safety and welfare. Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, and barring a gubernatorial veto, naturopathic doctors will soon be able to diagnose and treat any Rhode Islander with disease or condition, victorious in their sixth attempt at licensing in the state. With the conquest of Rhode Island, naturopathic takeover of New England will be complete, with all six states comprising that area of the United States licensing naturopaths. (Massachusetts passed a licensing law just last year.)
Fortunately, a variety of mechanisms to protect patients are included in the licensing bills. Unfortunately, as we shall see, RI naturopaths stand ready and waiting to foist their fake diagnoses and disproven treatments on unwitting Rhode Islanders without fear of prosecution for practicing without a license.
First, let’s see how RI naturopaths are currently practicing, even without legal authority to do so. Then, we’ll take a brief look at the licensing bills as introduced, which would have been far worse than the bills that passed. After that, we’ll review some of the committee testimony by supporters of the bills, including misrepresentations made to legislators about naturopathy. Finally, we’ll see just what naturopaths will be allowed to do in Rhode Island and, importantly, what they are prohibited from doing in their practices.
As is typical of other states, the lack of a licensing act has not stopped RI naturopaths from diagnosing and treating patients for a wide range of medical issues. Perusing the websites of RI naturopaths, one finds the typical quack diagnostic tests and treatments that fill naturopathic practices in both jurisdictions where they are regulated as well as those where they practice medicine illegally.
The president of the Rhode Island Association of Naturopathic Physicians (RIANP) (note: my web browser gives a security warning for this website) herself, Marcy Feibelman, advises patients how to concoct their own “warming socks” treatment, which essentially consists of wearing wet socks to bed. Indications for the treatment include, she says:
Any inflammation or infection of the throat (including a simple sore throat), neck pain, ear infections, headaches, migraines, nasal congestion, upper respiratory infections, sinus infections. Cold extremities, poor circulation. To prevent a cold.
She claims warming socks:
reflexively increase circulation and decrease congestion in the upper respiratory passages, head, and throat. . . This treatment is also effective for pain relief and increases the healing response during acute infections.
As SBM’s own Scott Gavura pointed out, this sort of nonsense simply demonstrates the limitations of naturopathic understanding of immunity.
The RIANP president also practices “biotherapeutic drainage,” a naturopathic treatment based on a combination of Chinese medicine, homeopathy and anthroposophy. Or, as David Gorski put it:
Biotherapeutic drainage. It’s three, three, three woos in one!
Other RI naturopathic offerings include:
    • Homeopathy, “the one quackery to rule them all.”
    • Chinese medicine, (see Mark Crislip’s take on TCM) including tongue and pulse diagnosis.
    • Bowen Therapeutic Technique, for which “there is no evidence whatsoever that [it] is helpful for patients suffering from any condition.”
    • Hair analysis for heavy metals, “a cardinal sign of quackery.”
    • Salivary hormone tests, which medical science has proven unreliable.
    • Botanical medicine, or unpurified, unproven drugs.
    • Detoxification (only $129.95!), a profitable scam invented by naturopaths.
Nationwide, naturopathic organizations and their licensing efforts are being supported by dietary supplement companies. The RIANP, the primary sponsor of the licensing bills, has the financial support of two dietary supplement companies (again note the security warning for the RIANP website), both of which sell their products through health care practitioners’ offices, allowing naturopaths to make a tidy profit on the products they prescribe.
If Designs for Health, one of the corporate sponsors, is typical of these “exclusive” deals, patients are paying a hefty markup for the privilege of buying from their naturopath. For example, Designs for Health aloe vera capsules are six times more expensive than aloe vera capsules available on the internet. Xymogen, the other corporate sponsor, does not make its prices available to the public on its website. Ironically, although dietary supplements available only through practitioners are promoted as superior to their off-the-shelf competitors, Xymogen received a warning letter in 2011 from the FDA, citing it for “significant violations” of the FDA’s good manufacturing practice regulations, as well as illegal therapeutic claims.
Broad scope of practice legislation fails
The licensing bills, House Bill 5474 and Senate Bill 327, as originally introduced in the Rhode Island General Assembly, were typical of the “opening bid” legislation introduced in other states, designed to give naturopaths the broadest possible initial licensing act, but short of the full-primary care scope of practice laws naturopaths really want, a feat achieved so far only in Oregon. (For this, they will pester legislators year after year.)
The original versions of HB 5474 and SB 327 would have allowed naturopaths to call themselves naturopathic “physicians,” prescribe drugs according to a formulary, perform minor office surgery, order diagnostic imaging studies, prescribe and dispense medical devices (including therapeutic devices, barrier contraception, and durable medical equipment) and use all routes of administration for the substances they can prescribe (e.g., minerals, vitamins, homeopathic remedies and prescription drugs on their formulary), including intramuscular and intravenous injections. Fortunately, none of those provisions survived in the final bills.
The Senate Health and Human Services Committee and the House Health, Education and Welfare Committee both took recorded testimony on the bills. As is too often the case, supporters showed up in far greater numbers than the one opponent who personally testified, although written testimony, which is not available on the General Assembly’s website, apparently augmented both the pro and con positions.
Testifying on the pro side in these hearings were two naturopathic “physicians” (one of whom was Marcy Feibelman), two MDs (one of whom was also an ND), two RNs, and a few patients who had positive experiences with naturopaths. Proponents testified that:
    • Naturopathy is safe. One proponent actually said it is “a lot safer” than traditional medical care.
Actually, there is no reliable evidence that the practice of naturopathy overall is “safe,” while there is plenty of evidence that the treatments they use have an unfavorable risk-benefit profile, like herbs, colon hydrotherapy, dietary supplements, and IV injections.
    • Naturopathy is effective. One proponent even went so far as to say there are “thousands of studies” demonstrating the effectiveness of naturopathic treatments.
Many naturopathic treatments are either unproven or disproven, including homeopathy, “detoxification” and quirky diets, as more expansively detailed in Scott Gavura’s “Naturopathy vs. Science” series here on SBM and former naturopath Britt Hermes blog, Naturopathic Diaries.
    • Naturopathy save on health care costs.
You can reduce health care costs to zero by simply not providing any care. Savings alone don’t mean that good care is being provided.
    • Naturopathy is cost effective.
As Scott Gavura explained, you can’t call CAM cost effective unless it’s actually effective, and what naturopaths typically offer the public simply isn’t science or evidence-based.
    • Naturopaths can help with the opioid crisis.
Again, no evidence.
    • Naturopaths treat the “root cause,” not just the symptoms, like medical doctors do.
This is a bit of alternative medicine nonsense nicely debunked by Harriet Hall.
    • Naturopaths have the same basic training as MDs and DOs, the “only difference” being in clinical training.
Putting aside the fact that the 15,000-hour difference in clinical training creates an enormous experience gap between medical doctors and doctors of naturopathy, former naturopathic doctor Britt Hermes has meticulously dissected naturopathic claims to medical school equivalency and found them wanting.
    • Naturopaths can effectively address chronic disease.
As best I can tell, this claim is based on a single study of naturopathic treatment for cardiovascular disease, or, more accurately, lifestyle and dietary counseling sanitized of the quackery typically included in naturopathic practice, rebranded as “naturopathic medicine,” and added onto usual care provided by a medical doctor.
Unfortunately, the only person who showed up to speak against the bills was a representative from the state’s Physicians Assistants organization, who spoke both for the PAs and the state medical society. While he effectively countered some of the naturopathic claims (like there are “thousands of studies” supporting naturopathic treatments and the lie that medical doctors treat “only the symptoms” and not the cause of disease), the presentations were painfully lopsided. Legislators did not hear about the deleterious health effects (including death) suffered by naturopathic patients (also here and here) or of the conflicts between evidence-based medical advice and pseudoscientific naturopathic advice that complicates patient care (also here).
Naturopathic “doctors” are not primary care physicians
Despite what appeared to be credulous acceptance of the naturopathic talking points by legislators at both hearings, the bills were heavily amended and sharply curtailed the naturopathic scope of practice provided in the original versions, as well as adding important consumer protections.
HB 5474, as amended, passed in both houses of the Rhode Island General Assembly, and is eligible for the governor’s consideration. SB 327, as amended, passed in the Senate and is on the House’s consent calendar.
Assuming the governor doesn’t exercise her veto power, RI naturopaths will be able to “prevent and treat” any disease or condition in any patient of any age (including children, unfortunately) using:
education, natural substances and natural therapies to support and stimulate a patient’s intrinsic self-healing processes . . .
In other words, in a perfect example of Legislative Alchemy, the RI General Assembly has incorporated the long-discredited, pre-scientific notion of vitalism into state law.
While diagnosis is not specifically included in their scope of practice definition, they will be able to:
. . . order and perform physical and laboratory examinations for diagnostic purposes.
This will leave patients vulnerable to the sort of unvalidated testing naturopaths favor, like the already-mentioned salivary hormone testing and hair analysis for “heavy metals.” (One naturopath actually mentioned the widely-debunked heavy metal testing in her committee testimony as a reason naturopaths need the authority to do diagnostic testing.) They can then use these bogus results to prescribe dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, botanicals, “neutriceuticals,” and other “natural” substances, as well as nonprescription drugs, all of which are allowed by the amended bills. These can be dispensed or ordered using oral, nasal, auricular, ocular, rectal, vaginal and transdermal routes of administration, but can be administered only using transdermal routes of administration. Naturopaths will also be able to use hydrotherapy (which includes colon hydrotherapy aka enemas) and naturopathic musculoskeletal mobilization.
Fortunately, RI naturopaths will not be able to prescribe drugs. They are also prohibited from:
. . . advis[ing] patients regarding prescription drugs beyond possible dietary supplement/herb-drug interactions.
Importantly, this will prohibit them from advising against immunization, because vaccines are prescription drugs. Given naturopathic anti-vaccination ideology, this is vital for consumer protection. Nor will they be able to advise patients to forego prescription hormone therapy in favor of desiccated animal glands, which are sold as dietary supplements and promoted by naturopaths as a “natural” treatment for thyroid disease.
Thankfully, the bills also make it absolutely clear that naturopaths are not primary care physicians. They cannot:
. . . practice or claim to practice as a medical doctor or physician, . . . a primary care doctor, a primary care practitioner, a primary care provider [or] a primary care naturopath . . .
Because of this, RIANP may be required to change its name, as has happened in Maryland and California, other states where naturopaths are not allowed to call themselves “physicians.”
In addition, naturopaths must have a written collaboration and consultation agreement with a licensed physician. Patients must read and sign a consent form that includes this information:
Rhode Island does not recognize doctors of naturopathy as primary care providers and a doctor of naturopathy is not responsible for the overall medical care of any patient.
Naturopathic care is intended only as an adjunct to, and not a substitute for, medical care . . . and doctors of naturopathy shall coordinate patient care with physicians and other health care providers.
Patients are urged to have a primary care provider and to have all specialty care provided by a properly credentialed physician specialist.
All questions regarding prescription medications should be directed to the prescriber or the patient’s primary care provider or licensed registered pharmacist.
They are also prohibited from making “willful misrepresentations in treatments,” raising the possibility that telling patients obvious falsehoods, such as a diagnosis of “adrenal fatigue” or “chronic candidiasis” would be subject to disciplinary action. On the other hand, one would be hard pressed to concoct a more scientifically dubious misrepresentation than homeopathy, which is specifically permitted.
A major weakness in the bills is that they create a Board of Licensure for Naturopathy consisting of two naturopaths, two physicians and one public member, appointed by the Director of the state department of health and approved by the Governor. The effectiveness of this board will hinge on appointing physicians who are not naturopathic sympathizers and who are familiar with their pseudoscience, as well as a public member who is not so enamored of naturopathy and so unschooled in science that he or she will automatically side with the naturopaths.
The Board will have the authority to adopt rules and regulations for the practice of naturopathy, investigate possible disciplinary violations and recommend the commencement of disciplinary proceedings to the Director, and approve continuing education courses. They also have the power to approve a licensing exam. I imagine the naturopaths will try to get the Board to sign off on using the NPLEX, which was created by and for naturopaths without outside expert analysis, but I hope the physicians and public member will demand to see and evaluate the NPLEX before agreeing to an exam. If they do so, they will become, to my knowledge, the first people outside of naturopathy ever to lay eyes on the exam.
Another weakness is that naturopaths are held to a naturopathic standard of care, which doesn’t seem to exist. The bills would subject naturopaths to discipline if they fail to practice naturopathy:
. . . with the level of care, skill, and treatment that is recognized by a reasonably prudent similar doctor of naturopathy as being acceptable under similar conditions and circumstances.
Given the wide range of quackery they regularly practice, it is difficult to imagine what might not be “acceptable” to a naturopath or how one might go about defining what a “reasonably prudent” naturopath is.
It is not difficult to imagine what happens next: RI naturopaths will be back year after year pestering legislators to expand their scope of practice. They always do.

SFSBM Report upsets naturopaths. We’re fine with that.
Jann Bellamy on December 11, 2014
Link

The Maryland Naturopathic Doctors Association is not pleased with the Society for Science-Based Medicine. Not at all.
That is a good thing, for several reasons. It demonstrates the importance of stopping naturopathic licensing (and practice expansion) legislation in the state legislatures. It shows how they handle legitimate criticism of their practices. And it is a lesson in their modus operandi of obfuscating the facts with platitudinous- but-vague pronouncements about their education, training and practice, pronouncements that wither under criticism.
Why is the MNDA so upset with the SFSBM?
We’ll answer that question soon, but some background first. The Maryland Legislature passed a naturopathic licensing bill this year. Fortunately, as I’ve written, the Legislature didn’t give naturopaths everything they wanted, such as the right to prescribe real drugs. That’s not stopping them from coming back to the Legislature to revisit the issue. According to naturopathic school Bastyr’s website:
The [Maryland] law limits some parts of the naturopathic scope of practice — such as intravenous (IV) therapies and prescription drugs — that the state association will work to secure in the future.
Instead of giving naturopaths their own regulatory board, like they wanted, the Legislature put them under the authority of the Maryland Board of Physicians. The Legislature created a Naturopathic Advisory Committee to recommend regulations governing naturopathic practice to the Board. The Maryland Naturopathic Doctors Association (MNDA) states, incorrectly, on its website that the Committee will actually be promulgating the regulations and implementing the law. The statute is quite clear that this is not the case. Those duties are entirely within the jurisdiction of the Board.
The Committee consists of two medical physicians, two naturopaths and one public member. It has met several times, with the next meeting scheduled for December 19th.
The Society for Science-Based Medicine took this as an opportunity to insert a much-needed dose of reality into the regulatory process. In October, we presented a Report to the Naturopathic Advisory Committee documenting how Maryland naturopaths are currently practicing, even before a licensing law goes into effect, which won’t be until March, 2016. We also recommended specific regulations. We’ll get to the substance of the report in a minute. (You can access the report on the SFSBM’s website.)
The naturopaths and their lobbyist had been meeting with legislators for several years. From what I can tell, their plan was to present themselves as benign souls who were simply interested in health promotion and disease prevention and were all about collaboration with other health care professions. This is in accordance with the public persona created by such groups as the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) and the MNDA, as well as their schools.
The naturopaths also took legislators on a field trip to the Casey Health Institute, an “integrative” practice in Maryland which employs a naturopath, Carrie Runde, whom you’ll see again later in this post. One can’t help but notice the tight reins Casey keeps on its staff naturopath compared to the scope of practice allowed in the new law. According to the website:
Dr. Runde works with people to achieve success in the foundations of health and wellness, working on diet, stress management, sleep habits, and movement.
It will be interesting to see whether Casey allows her practice to expand to the full extent permitted, such as seeing patients without MD supervision and ordering sophisticated diagnostic tests, in 2016.
Not so pretty
The reality, of course, is much different. Or, as my grandmother used to tell me, “pretty is as pretty does.” As we’ve documented time and again at SBM, naturopaths regularly employ quack treatments and diagnose patients with fake diseases. Even though they are few in number and have few patients, we at SBM have considered naturopaths and their expanding attempts to gain full primary care practitioner status a sufficient concern to warrant numerous posts. No one could come away from Scott Gavura’s excellent series, Naturopathy v. Science, and think naturopaths (including those with a four-year naturopathic “medical” education) are competent to diagnose and treat patients. Or David Gorksi’s chilling post revealing what naturopaths say to each other when they think no one is listening. (And Orac’s as well. Also here.) Finally, because Maryland naturopaths want the right to perform Pap smears, I’ll mention one more: Harriet Hall’s post on the naturopath who thought she’d cured cervical dysplasia. (She didn’t.)
A few simple internet searches will reveal what they are actually up to. So, that is what we at SFSBM did. We looked on the MNDA’s website and got the names of their members. Then we looked at the members’ websites (links for which are provided by the MNDA). And there it was. Many of the same unproven and disproven diagnoses and remedies we’ve discussed here at SBM were hiding in plain sight.
I won’t go into all the naturopathic websites, but here are some highlights from state naturopathic leaders. (The websites were accessed in September. They may have been changed, especially in light of the Report.)
Kevin Passero, ND, Advisory Committee chair:
“Natural treatment of hypothyroidism” includes “herbal therapy, vitamin/nutrient therapy, homeopathy and prescriptive thyroid hormones including natural glandular extracts and compounded thyroid hormone.” Criticizes standard medical diagnosis and treatment of thyroid disease.
Prescribes “bio-identical hormones”, claims that they do not have the same risks as prescription-only HRT [Editor’s note – they have the same risks because they are still hormones] and that their use can “reduce risk related to certain conditions including bone loss and even certain forms of cancer.”
Emily Telfair, ND, former president, MNDA:
Advertises “Fall Detox . . . adapted from Thorne’s MediClear Detox Plan.” According to the Thorne MediClear Detox website, “The MediClear Plus program is designed to do two things: first, to decrease your exposure to toxins and allergens, and second, to help your body cleanse.” [Editor’s note – “detox” is a marketing strategy pretending to be medicine] It is a “formula that blends a combination of rice and pea protein with a full complement of vitamins, minerals, amino acids, botanicals, probiotics, and other nutrients for the enhancement of detoxification.”
“Detox add-on kits” are also offered on Telfair’s website, which are “additional supplements to further enhance your detox experience.” These include “Belly Boost: To help aide digestion for those with sensitive stomachs.” “Liver Love: To help clear toxins while protecting the liver.”
Kristaps Paddock, ND, current president, MNDA:
“Homeopathy is a system of natural medicine [that] is used to treat a range of illnesses, from simple coughs to chronic conditions. It is known for . . . being able to alleviate symptoms where other treatments have been ineffective.” [Editor’s note – homeopathy doesn’t work]
In addition to exposing these practices, the Report provided an explanation, with citations, of what these treatments are and why naturopathic claims for them are unfounded. The Report does the same thing for each and every diagnosis and treatment quoted from Maryland naturopathic websites. Not surprisingly, in addition to these examples, we found naturopaths using biotherapeutic drainage, cranial-sacral therapy, alkaline diets, electrodermal screening, autonomic response testing, far-infrared saunas and chelation for improper purposes, use of DMSA challenge protocol, salivary hormone testing and blood nutrition analysis.
Our Report provided the Committee with recommendations for specific regulations to ensure that Maryland patients are not subjected to these fake diagnoses and treatments, some of which are dangerous. For example, we suggested that all continuing education courses be vetted by the Board. The MNDA’s CE offerings reinforced our point: “The Top Five Homeopathic Remedies in the Treatment of Depression” and “Naturopathic Treatment of Chronic Kidney Disease.” (More on the latter here).
The Report also urged the Committee to adopt a regulation recognizing a patient’s right to informed consent, which in Maryland means the health care provider must disclose:
the nature of the ailment, the nature of the proposed treatment, the probability of success of the contemplated therapy and its alternatives, and the risk of unfortunate consequences associated with such treatment.
Of course, many standard naturopathic treatments would be rejected if this information were given.
As one final example, because of naturopathic opposition to vaccination and other public health measures, the Report recommended that naturopaths be required to refer all questions regarding vaccination to the patient’s physician and that they not be allowed to give advice contrary to evidence-based based health care practices.
All in all, we at SFSBM are quite happy with our report. 25 pages (not including attachments) and 62 citations. And not a single challenge from naturopaths to our facts or citations of authority. Not bad for our first foray into the regulatory area.
Naturopaths take umbrage
And what was the naturopaths’ reaction to this? Professed shame at their dubious practices and a pledge to clean up their acts? No. Enthusiastic adoption of our perfectly reasonable suggestions for regulation? No. Even a teensy-weensy hint that SFSBM might have something worthwhile to say? No.
The MNDA’s reaction was to fire off a letter to the Board and Advisory Committee attacking the integrity of SFSBM and one of the Committee’s physicians, Gregory S. Pokrywka, MD, a private practitioner and an Assistant Professor of General Internal Medicine at Johns Hopkins, who supported our Report during Committee meetings.
The MNDA challenged the qualifications of Dr. Pokrywka to serve on the Committee and charged him with being “biased.” It said SFSBM was “comprised of unknown individuals in disparate parts of the country.” [Now, there’s a crime if I’ve ever seen one.] And they accused us of being founded recently “for unclear purposes.” [Suggestion: check out our website.] Accordingly, SFSBM should be “the subject of scrutiny.” [Fine with us.] We lack, per the MNDA, “an understanding of naturopathic training and practice” thus we “should not be consulted as a resource in the drafting of regulations.” [Actually, we understand these all too well, and we provided plenty of documentation regarding both.]
This is not the first time naturopaths have taken umbrage at criticism from the science-based community. Of course, what else can they do? I mean, the Report’s discussion of their practices came from their own words. We didn’t make anything up. We can’t help it if the authors of the journal articles and other sources we cited looked at the evidence and decided against the naturopaths. It’s not our fault. We didn’t come up with Avogadro’s number. Blame him.
We fired right back with our own letter:
we are not surprised that the MNDA has chosen to avoid a discussion of the extensive documentation concerning unproven, disproven and, in some cases, dangerous practices by Maryland license-eligible naturopaths. The MNDA’s recommendations wholly fail to address how the Board might ensure that these practices do not continue. Indeed, the MNDA’s recommendations would permit these very practices to continue unabated.
The MNDA has instead attempted to divert the attention of the Advisory Committee and the Board by attacking the integrity of both the Society and Gregory Pokrywka, M.D. We do not speak for Dr. Pokrywka, nor is he our representative at Board meetings, as the MNDA implies. We have no doubt he is perfectly capable of defending himself against the spurious charge that he is somehow unqualified to serve on the Advisory Committee or that he is “biased.” His concern for Maryland citizens who seek naturopathic treatment and his respect for the scientific method and evidence-based medicine are not “bias.”
You won’t be surprised to learn that the MNDA has come up with some regulatory suggestions of its own. They want to default to naturopathic organizations and naturopaths the authority that the Legislature has clearly placed with the Board of Physicians. Such as, they want all continuing education courses approved by the MNDA and the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians automatically accepted. They want a disciplinary committee made up of two naturopaths and one Board representative, even though the Maryland statutes clearly provide otherwise.
The new law says that their practices must be “consistent with naturopathic education and training” and gives the Board the authority to require additional testing and completion of more education and training before qualification for licensure. The MDNA wants none of it. They say it is “not necessary.” They want no restrictions placed on their diagnoses and treatment, except those clearly required by the statute, even though the Legislature has given the Board authority to do so.
The MNDA wants the AANP Code of Ethics, which consists of barely over 2 pages, adopted in their regulations as their ethical rules. And they want the State of Maryland (i.e., taxpayers) to finance, at no interest, their licensing fee ($5,140 initially; $4,000 renewal) over a 2 year period, a privilege not granted other licensed health care professionals nor one which finds any support in the law.
According to a another document submitted by one of the Advisory committee members (Runde, the naturopath), naturopaths want the authority to order:
Laboratory testing of all bodily fluids, blood, secretions, excretions, and human tissue . . . [and] obtain specimens for laboratory examination . . . [including but not limited to] phlebotomy, urinalysis, samples for bacterial culture, endothelial cells for pap test, and others [including] all CLIA-waive tests, which can be performed in-office.
And to the authority to perform:
All tests . . . to assess and diagnose physiological processes in all bodily systems.
Diagnostic imaging should, according to the naturopaths, include, but not be limited to:
X-ray, ultrasound, mammogram, bone densiometry [sic], CT scan, MRI scan, endoscopic exam, and all other forms of nuclear imaging.
They are not allowed to interpret these tests, but can interpret the reports. They also want access to the images themselves.
The definition of “electromagnetic energy” (which they are allowed to employ) should include (but not be limited to), they say:
Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, microcurrent electrical muscle stimulation, diathermy, infrared, UV treatments, and other devices which utilize electrical or magnetic force for therapeutic effect.
This voracious appetite for sophisticated diagnostic tests belies the MNDA’s claim that naturopaths offer “clinical nutrition, herbal medicine, lifestyle counseling, homeopathy, naturopathic physical medicine and pharmaceuticals” (which the MNDA admits they “currently” can’t prescribe.) Why on earth do they need to order CT scans, mammograms and endoscopic exams for those tasks? (I do hope that, if these regulations stand, the health care professionals who actually perform these tests will refuse to do so without an adequate clinical rationale.)
So what is going on with the Advisory Committee? (I have not attended but I am relying on staff documents and the accounts of Dr. Pokrywka.) One of the 2 naturopathic members nominated the other (Passero) for Committee chair and that was seconded by the public member, Eldon Miller, Ph.D, who apparently is a mathematician. According to the minutes of the last meeting (Nov. 21), the vote was unanimous for Dr. Passero, although the accuracy of that report will be questioned at the next meeting, December 19th. The Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Report has been ignored, despite protestations from Dr. Pokrywka. On the other hand, the recommendations of the MNDA and naturopaths have been embraced.
The naturopaths were livid at the charge that they are anti-vaccination, vigorously denying it even though SFSBM provided copious evidence to the contrary. Dr. Pokrywka, quite sensibly, wanted a limitation on testing for fake diseases we discussed in the Report. The naturopaths didn’t.
They defended homeopathy, saying that “obviously” interventions like homeopathy are deemed safe because they are allowed in the statute regardless of SFSBM’s questioning their efficacy. And just because there is no evidence of efficacy, it doesn’t mean it’s not safe. In other words, whether it’s effective or not, you can prescribe it anyway. If that is the case, why bother with all the dilutions and succussions, and the bottling and labeling? Why not just give patients a glass of water? (Perhaps that would be an overdose?)
In meetings, Dr. Passero has run through the regulations proposed by the Board staff quite rapidly, with little discussion. The naturopaths and the public member have voted in lockstep. Dr. Pokrywka and Dr. Suresh Gupta, the other physician on the Committee, wanted regulations that would protect the public from naturopathic practices but were regularly overruled.
Unfortunately, while the staffs’ recommendations are not quite as liberal as the naturopaths’, it appears the naturopaths are getting most of what they wanted. That is, in part, due to the statute itself, which never should have been passed in the first place. In giving the naturopaths a broad scope of practice, the Board’s hands are someone tied, although not nearly to the extent the naturopaths would have the Committee think. But that is a legal argument best left to be made before the Board.
The Committee’s recommended regulations default to the AANP and MNDA to approve continuing education courses, as the naturopaths wanted. There are no further education and training requirements or limitations on their practice, other than those set by the statute. (Again, despite the fact that the Legislature gives the Board the authority to impose such requirements.)
Here is what is unclear to me at this point. The staff has provided a packet of documents for the December 19th meeting. One document is labeled “Revised Scope of Practice Definitions” but its source is not clear. It appears to me to be the work of the staff. If this is true, then it means that the Committee has approved regulations adopting the naturopaths’ recommendations regarding use of diagnostic imaging (including nuclear imaging) and physiological function testing, and its definition of electromagnetic energy. Who knows what quack diagnostic methods and treatments that might engender?
For the next meeting, the naturopaths have also submitted information “FYI” listing the courses they are required to take and the textbooks for that course from Bastyr, a list of course requirements from another naturopathic school, and the CNME’s accreditation standards. All of these are already available on the internet and tell us little of substance about naturopathic education and training. It’s simply what the naturopathic organizations are willing for the public to see. It does not include, for example, a copy of any past NPLEX exam or other sufficient detail for their education and training to be fully analyzed.
Fortunately, what really matters is what the Board does. It has ultimate authority to accept or reject any or all of the Committee’s proposed regulations. One hopes that the Board won’t abandon evidenced-base medicine and science for 19th century philosophy. We’d hoped that debate was settled in the last century.

California legislature should repeal naturopathic licensing
Jann Bellamy on October 27, 2016
Link
On January 1, 2018, the California Naturopathic Doctors Act will be automatically repealed unless the California Legislature deletes or extends that date during the 2017 legislative session, which convenes on December 5, 2016. In addition, according to California law, the Naturopathic Medicine Committee of the Osteopathic Medical Board of California, which regulates naturopathic doctors (NDs), is subject to review by “appropriate policy committees of the Legislature” in the upcoming session.
The California Legislature should not extend the date of the Naturopathic Practice Act. Currently licensed naturopathic doctors could be allowed to continue their practices under a substantially revised practice act but no new licenses should be issued. Frankly, I do not think naturopaths, whether they claim they are “doctors” or not, should be allowed to practice at all. However, the political realities of getting a bill passed completely doing away with the practice of naturopathy may require some accommodation to currently licensed NDs.
The Naturopathic Doctor Act (Senate Bill 907) was passed in 2003. At the time, naturopaths with degrees from naturopathic “medical schools” could practice under California’s “health freedom” law, enacted in 2002, and still in effect. This law exempted “alternative” health care practitioners from prosecution for the unlicensed practice of medicine as long as they didn’t engage in certain acts, such as prescribing drugs or performing surgery. They could diagnose and treat any ailment as long as it was not
under circumstances or conditions that cause or create a risk of great bodily harm, serious physical or mental illness, or death.
Regular bodily harm, not-all-that-serious physical or mental illness, or near-death are apparently permitted.
Naturopathic doctors and other practitioners could tell patients about their education and training, but had to disclose that “natural and alternative medicines” are not licensed in California and that the practitioner is not a licensed physician. NDs, however, craved the legitimacy bestowed by having their own practice act and a greatly increased scope of practice.
The Naturopathic Doctors Act was supported by several groups, who told legislators how, in their view, the Act would benefit California patients.
The California Association of Naturopathic Physicians (now the California Naturopathic Doctors Association, because NDs are not allowed to call themselves “physicians.”):
improve consumer access to safe and effective complimentary [sic] and alternative medicine therapies in addition to allopathic ones, and because it will provide for licensure consistent with the naturopathic physician’s education and training, and their scope of practice in other jurisdictions.
American Specialty Health Plans, an insurer offering coverage of CAM treatments:
ensure public safety and accountability to appropriately trained and examined applicants for licensure, and that consumers deserve comparable regulatory standards and oversight mechanisms for all health care providers including naturopathic physicians.
California Citizens for Health Freedom:
help enhance the health/medical services in California, reduce the rising cost of health care, assist in meeting the crisis of a decline in primary care physicians, increase the professional resources of experts to the growing nutritional industry in California . . .
The Council on Naturopathic Medical Education:
licensing will help ensure that patients know the doctor they are seeing has been thoroughly trained at a four-year naturopathic medical school which is all important to making correct diagnoses and prescribing effective treatments.
National College of Naturopathic Medicine:
will ensure accountability that physician-level doctors be licensed and regulated . . . [T]he public deserves comparable (to allopathic medicine) regulatory standards for naturopathic physicians who are primary care providers . . . [T]he bill will improve public safety since, at present California has no standards to inform consumers whether their naturopathic physician has completed a four-year, graduate-level naturopathic medical school, passed standard board exams, and meets federally recognized standards of education and professional accountability.
That last sentence is not true, as NDs could tell patients those very things under the “health freedom” law.
The bill was opposed by the California Chiropractic Association, the California Medical Association, the California Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and traditional naturopaths, who do not have degrees from naturopathic “medical schools.” Opponents questioned the reliance on naturopathic education and training to support the scope of practice authorized by the Act, including the naturopathic claim that they could act as primary care providers.
As best I can tell, the legislature relied completely on the NDs’ and supporters’ claims that their education and training was sufficient to support the scope of practice they wanted, including their claims of proficiency in primary care, and no independent investigation of their education and training was ever done. Nor can I find that the legislature did any independent investigation of actual naturopathic practices, including whether they were supported by sufficient evidence of safety and efficacy, or whether the NDs were giving patients accurate information about those practices – in other words, ensuring informed consent.
ND “boutiques”
California’s Naturopathic Practice Act defines “naturopathic medicine” as
a distinct and comprehensive system of primary health care practiced by a naturopathic doctor for the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of human health conditions, injuries, and disease.
In other words, an ND can diagnose and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition.
NDs can order and perform physical and lab exams and order (but not perform or interpret) diagnostic imaging. They can prescribe, administer and sell dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, “nutraceuticals,” and natural and synthetic hormones. They can use oral, nasal, auricular, ocular, rectal, vaginal, transdermal, intradermal, subcutaneous and intramuscular routes of administration. They can also administer substances IV and practice “natural childbirth attendance” with additional education and training. Under physician supervision, they can prescribe certain drugs.
Originally, NDs were regulated by the Bureau of Naturopathic Medicine, which operated within the Department of Consumer Affairs. However, jurisdiction was later transferred to the Naturopathic Medicine Committee of the Osteopathic Medical Board. During the 2015-2016 legislative session, NDs fought to remove physician supervision over their prescribing and otherwise expand their practice act, a subject I covered extensively over on SfSBM. Fortunately, those efforts failed.
In the 13 years since California passed the Naturopathic Medicine Act, we’ve learned a great deal more about naturopathic doctors, their practices, and their education and training. That knowledge should be judiciously applied by the California Legislature when considering the future of the Act.
While I was not able to perform a comprehensive search of all naturopathic websites, my review of about a dozen sites representing the practices of some 25 NDs revealed a common theme: while they may say they practice “primary care,” what they’ve actually done is establish boutique practices offering numerous unproven, or disproven, treatments and unorthodox lab tests for both recognized conditions and diseases and those they have fabricated. Here’s a list of what I found offered by California NDs, as well those located by Britt Hermes in a post written earlier this year:
    • California Naturopathic Clinic:
        ◦ reverse T3 (thyroid hormone) testing
        ◦ “natural” dessicated thyroid
        ◦ bio-identical hormones
        ◦ escharotic therapy for cervical dysplasia
    • Sacramento Naturopathic Medical Center:
        ◦ IgG food allergy testing
        ◦ salivary hormone testing
        ◦ treatment of “adrenal fatigue”
    • Inland Naturopathic Medical Center:
        ◦ colon hydrotherapy
        ◦ heavy metal testing and chelation therapy “to remove toxic metals”
        ◦ hyperbaric oxygen therapy for unproven uses (e.g., “better sleep”)
        ◦ IV hydrogen peroxide
        ◦ hyperthermia for cancer, HIV and “detoxification”
        ◦ mistletoe injections for cancer
    • Dr. Robert G. Milisen, N.M.D.:
        ◦ thermography
        ◦ biopuncture
        ◦ anthroposophic medicine
    • Dr. Nirvana:
        ◦ “fat burner” shots
        ◦ HCG injections for weight loss
    • Walnut Creek Naturopathic:
        ◦ high dose vitamin C
        ◦ glutathione “push”
        ◦ ozone therapy
In addition, Britt Hermes found these practices advertised by California NDs. See her post on Naturopathic Diaries for more information:
    • ultraviolet blood irradiation
    • ABM Bioenergy Patches
    • prozolone therapy
    • IV vitamin infusions
    • homeopathy
    • biotherapeutic drainage
    • clinical “detoxification”
These observations are consistent with other surveys of naturopathic websites finding numerous unsupported claims.
In over a decade since California licensed NDs, there is still virtually no research supporting the safety and effectiveness of naturopathic care. On the other hand, we do know that naturopaths and their institutions subscribe to anti-vaccination ideology, a fact that has been confirmed in several studies. We also know that naturopathy is associated with substandard care in other areas, such as STD screening. Analysis of naturopathic diagnostic methods and treatment of other conditions has shown them wanting in safety and efficacy: diabetes, MTHFR testing (also here), autism, cancer, infertility, allergies, thyroid conditions, and prenatal vitamins. And we know that there is increasing evidence that dietary supplements, the stock-in-trade of naturopaths, are not useful in preventing or treating disease.
Education, training, and licensing
Thanks to the revelations of Britt Hermes, the California legislature now has far more information about naturopathic education and training than it did in 2003. A thorough review of all she’s written on the subject is beyond the scope of this post, but listed below are must-reads for anyone who wants to understand the naturopathic educational system. At the very least, the California legislature no longer has any excuse for accepting at face value naturopathic representations about the quality of their education or its ability to produce health care practitioners competent to diagnose and treat all comers, especially children. In fact, I have Britt to thank for originally proposing the idea of using the upcoming repeal to advocate for changes to the licensing law. I hope she’ll write on the subject herself, with her insider’s vast knowledge of naturopathic education and practice.
    • ND Confession, Part I: Clinical Training Inside and Out
    • ND Confession, Part II: The Accreditation of Naturopathic “Medical” Education
    • A question off the naturopathic licensing exam (NPLEX)
    • The Price of a Naturopathic Education
    • Fact-checking naturopathic talking points at DCFLI
    • Should I go to naturopathic school?
    • Accredited Naturopathic Education: Official Reading List
    • Naturopathic Scope of Practice Expansion Killed in North Dakota (discusses naturopathic education, especially in pharmacology)
One of the rationales for passing the licensing act put forth by the California Naturopathic Doctors Association was that it would be “consistent with . . . their scope of practice in other jurisdictions.” To be “consistent” with the scope of practice in other jurisdictions in 2016 means it is unlikely there would be a scope of practice and, if there were, it would be more limited than in California. Since California licensed naturopaths, only three small states have followed suit: North Dakota, Colorado, and Maryland. In each instance, the scope of practice is more restrictive than in California.
In North Dakota, licensed NDs do not have prescription privileges, cannot practice naturopathic childbirth attendance, or perform minor office procedures. A bill granting those additional privileges was defeated last year.
Colorado passed a registration, not licensing, act for naturopaths. Colorado naturopaths must advise patients they are not medical doctors and naturopathy is not described in the law as “primary care.” They are forbidden from telling patients to discontinue their medications. NDs are severely restricted in their treatment of pediatric patients, with provisions ensuring that children are also seeing a pediatrician and getting recommended vaccinations. NDs must advise patients to see a medical doctor and attempt to coordinate care with that doctor. They are prohibited from practicing obstetrics.
In Maryland, NDs cannot administer treatments IV, use colonic irrigation, or perform minor office procedures. They must have a collaboration and consultation agreement with an MD or DO physician, must attest that they will refer patients to and consult with physicians and other health care providers, and are regulated by the state medical board. They cannot claim they are primary care doctors. Patients must sign a consent form stating they understand that the ND’s scope of practice is limited. The law specifically states they cannot deviate from “safe care of patients” and they can be disciplined even without evidence of patient harm.
During the same period, the vast majority of state naturopathic licensing bills were voted down, in some cases multiple times: in Florida, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, New Jersey, Mississippi, Michigan, Nevada, Iowa, Indiana and Illinois. In 2015, Idaho actually delicensed naturopathic doctors, as did Florida in the 1950s. In the last few years, most practice expansion bills failed as well.
In sum, we now know that naturopathic medical education and training isn’t as naturopathic doctors represented it to the legislature in 2003. We know that California NDs are setting up “boutique” practices claiming to specialize in only a few diseases and conditions and offering a range of unproven remedies and diagnostic methods. We know that consumers aren’t being protected; quite the contrary, we know they are being defrauded by licensed naturopathic doctors. We know that most of what naturopaths do is lacking in evidence of safety and effectiveness. We know that NDs are anti-vaccination because it is well-documented. We know that most states have rejected naturopathic licensing and practice expansion since 2003, and that the three states passing some sort of regulatory act granted practice privileges more restrictive than California.
Given these facts, what to do?
Since naturopathic doctors cannot point to any meaningful contribution to the health and welfare of Californians, there is no good reason to continue licensing them. As of 2013 (I could not find a more current number) there were only 437 active NDs licensed in California. By way of comparison, according to figures compiled by the Kaiser Family Foundation, there are almost 50,000 licensed primary care physicians in the state, over 52,000 specialist physicians and 8,000 physician assistants. There are almost 13,000 Nurse Practitioners, almost 300,000 RNs and over 80,000 LPNs. (All of these are professionally active.) It is time to get rid of these fringe practitioners while the numbers are still small and few NDs are affected. State expenditure of money and effort can then be focused on increasing the number of health care practitioners with proven contributions to the welfare of Californians, like physicians, nurses, and physician assistants. If patients insist on “alternative” care providers, California has the “health freedom” law I just mentioned, plus about 14,000 chiropractors and (as of 2004, the latest figure I could find) 9,000 acupuncturists.
So, what to do with the 450 or so licensed NDs, once licensing is discontinued? (Again, I don’t think they should be allowed to practice at all.) A much-narrowed practice act could be passed with the following provisions:
    • Require a collaboration or consultation agreement with an MD or DO on all patients;
    • Require disclosure to patients of the limitations of their practice and urge patients to have a primary care physician;
    • Require informed consent;
    • Don’t allow the use of unproven remedies (like homeopathy and dietary supplements) to treat disease;
    • Prohibit the use of unvalidated diagnostic tests like salivary hormone testing;
    • Don’t allow them to treat children;
    • Prohibit them from diagnosing and treating fake diseases like adrenal fatigue and chronic yeast overgrowth;
    • Require the referral to a physician specialist for diseases and conditions like thyroid and endocrine disorders, cancer, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, or any other disease or condition that a family practice physician would refer to a specialist.
    • Prohibit them from giving advice on vaccination;
    • Don’t allow them to sell dietary supplements and other remedies they prescribe to patients, it’s an inherent conflict of interest; and
    • Require the Naturopathic Medicine Committee to give accurate information to the public about naturopathic practice and its limitations. For example, right now the NMC tells consumers that NDs are “trained as primary care practitioners,” that “naturopathic medicine can benefit all Californians,” and that some NDs “may focus on particular areas of health such as detoxification.” It also provides links to the California Naturopathic Doctors Association (which recently offered a continuing education course on “ozone therapy”) and the American Association of Naturopathic Doctors, which is filled with naturopathic boosterism and pseudoscientific health advice.
If you are a Californian, please contact your legislators and tell them it’s time to get rid of naturopathic licensing.

Board Disciplinary Actions. What Naturopaths Really Do Not Want You To Know
Disciplinary actions against ND’s in Oregon by the Board. How to find them and what they are.
Mark Crislip on February 3, 2017
Link

All states have a Medical Board that oversees the practice of medicine. In Oregon it is the eponymous Oregon Medical Board and the:
mission of the Oregon Medical Board is to protect the health, safety, and wellbeing of Oregon citizens by regulating the practice of medicine in a manner that promotes access to quality care.
Every quarter the OMB sends out a newsletter that includes Board Actions and there is a monthly Board Action Report. Both are available on the home page of the organization.
Sometimes the reasons for the actions are obvious (inappropriate prescribing) and sometimes not so much (unprofessional behavior, whatever that might be). There are over 12,000 physicians in Oregon and but only a handful of actions, but I can find no statistics on their work. It can’t be an easy job to oversee other physicians. The actions induce a queasy curiosity about what it takes to kill a medical career and how ostensibly-bright people can really mess up. 
Naturopaths have a similar board, the Board of Naturopathic Medicine. The BNM is a different website than the OMB. With a “Find a Physician (ND)” option as well as an “About Naturopathic Medicine” it as much more of partisan promoter of naturopathy as an oversight organization, despite their vision:
To protect the health, safety and welfare of the public in the matters of care provided by Naturopathic physicians in Oregon.
Which could only realistically be met by dissolving the organization and preventing the practice of naturopathy. But that’s me.
They do mention that their role is to:
… remain neutral as possible when carrying out regulatory functions
Which to my mind runs contrary to the boosterism that permeates the site.
But I wondered. What kind of actions does the Naturopathic Board take in response to practice complaints? The Medical Board, as a rule, is not involved with specific issues of malpractice and poor care. That is left to hospital peer review and the legal system. The Medical Board tends to look at inappropriate opiate prescribing, moral turpitude, and general unfitness to practice. Moral turpitude:
Crimes involving moral turpitude have an inherent quality of baseness, vileness, or depravity with respect to a person’s duty to another or to society in general.
You have to go pretty low to meet that standard and show up in front of the Board, but perhaps not to be the POTUS. The ‘T’ stands for turpitude?
Issues concerning individual patient/standard of care do not appear before the Board, and would not be issue for ND’s anyway as their white paper proudly states:
There is no naturopathic-specific standard of care. Naturopathic doctors are taught and held to the same standards of care as conventional providers.
Um, no. Most “conventional providers” do not offer the breadth of pseudo-medicine that defines the practice of naturopathy and makes their vision just one of the many fantasies of naturopathy. But that is neither here nor there. Just what kind of issues does the board find worthy of intervention with its practitioners?
But first how to find those actions? Transparency and ease of use, at least in comparison to the Medical Board, is not the strong suit of the site.
Unlike the Medical Board, there nothing on the home page.
The “Concern/Complaint” page does not have a search or results link.
If you go to the “Licensee Directory” page and search for a practitioner, you will find a link for a malpractice claim (more a disciplinary action) if you have a specific ND in mind, but who wants to search through every ND to find a handful of actions?
So I sent an email to the Board asking where a summary statement could be found and they directed me to their newsletter. Of course. Just like the Medical Board. So I looked a few.
2016 – Not out yet. Unlike the Medical Board they do not need to publish monthly updates. So we will see if any NDs warranted a Board evaluation in the last year.
2015 – No actions. A good year for Board. No transgressions. Or none reported.
2014 – Six actions. Two unknown, four for inappropriate opiate prescribing.
2013 – No newsletter. Another good year. Or none reported.
2012 – Seven actions. Two for opiate prescribing, one for treating minors, one for a DUI, one for a drug and firearm issue.
2011 – Five actions. One action, I would opine, sets a dangerous precedent for the ND Board. To me it sounds like the reasoning could be applied to most ND practices, since they note the:
continued practice of naturopathic medicine constitutes a serious danger to the health and safety of the public… and (he) did not use conventional, scientific or otherwise established methods to diagnose or treat the patients conditions…(and) presented himself as a medical specialist in diagnosing and treating difficult cases and conditions…
That’s naturopathy in a nutshell. Based on the ND websites, virtually every ND could be reported to the Board using this opinion as the criteria. Given the usual pseudo-medical and pseudo-scientific grounding of standard naturopathic practice, it is hard to imagine how far off the map the practice of this ND must have been for another ND to find it wanting.
One action was for giving HcG at a weight loss clinic without first examining the patients and another for lying on the application about a prior battery and a DUI. The reasons for the rest of the actions are opaque
2010 – Six actions.
At this point I gave up on the specifics as reading these legal documents is not very interesting. But it gave me a flavor for what the board has done, fairly similar to the actions of the medical board, but more difficult to find. Not in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet, stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying “Beware of the Leopard” hard to find. But not as easy as the OMB.
The Board meets 6 times a year. An outgoing board member notes that by:
…abiding by our statutes and providing appropriate care, we are maintaining a high standard for our profession so that our licenses are respected.
Cases come to the Board when someone has filed a complaint.
That someone can be a patient, family member, pharmacist or other provider.
Our investigator does an investigation and writes a report which DOES NOT INCLUDE THE NAME OF THE DOCTOR. Discussing these reports and deciding what to do makes up the bulk of our meetings.If you have never been on the Board you will never know: how many cases are dismissed with NO action! [Bold in the original]
With several years with no newsletters, I do idly wonder how many cases HAD an action and I just can’t find them. Is absence of evidence evidence of absence? Color me skeptical.
As part of the Great Legislative Mistake where the Oregon legislature gave NDs the legal designation of primary care providers, they included a peer review committee.
The Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine shall appoint a peer review committee consisting of five members. The peer review committee shall evaluate complaints against naturopathic physicians which are referred to it by the board, and make recommendations to the board regarding those complaints. The board exercises ultimate authority and control over all complaints considered by the committee, approving or disapproving the recommendations of the committee.
Senate Bill 22 would remove that provision:
Repeals provision establishing peer review committee for purpose of evaluating complaints against naturopathic physicians and making recommendations to Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine about those complaints.
Why this is at the request of Governor Kate Brown for the Board of Naturopathic Medicine I do not know and cannot find out from the site or Google. I am sure there is a perfectly good reason why, I just can’t think of one beyond removing an un-needed extra layer of bureaucracy. Currently an investigator does an investigation and reports to the board where, as I read the bill, an investigator would report to the peer review committee who would then report to the Board.
It kind of makes sense. You have the Board, consisting of 5 ND’s and two members from the public. Add another committee with another 5 ND’s and you get? Nothing plus nothing is still nothing as far as protecting the public is concerned.

Chiropractic

   Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic
Jann Bellamy
Link
As we learned in Legislative Alchemy I: Naturopathy, legislative alchemy is the process used by state legislatures to transform implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments into legal health care practices.
Today, we review how chiropractors are faring in the 2011 state legislative sessions.
Chiropractic 101
In 1895, a self-described “magnetic healer,” Daniel David Palmer, claimed to have discovered that every person possessed an “Innate Intelligence,” defined as the body’s capacity to heal itself, which flowed from the brain out through the nerves in the spinal cord. Misaligned vertebrae impinged on nerves and interfered with the flow of Innate Intelligence, causing “95 percent of all disease.”
Palmer named these putative misalignments “subluxations,” and began teaching students how to detect and correct them based on his notion that removing this interference would return the free flow of Innate Intelligence and the body would heal itself. In other words, chiropractic was — and, as we shall see, still is — simply another form of vitalism, a long-discredited notion that illnesses are caused by a disturbance or imbalance of the body’s “vital force,” which is distinct from the body’s biochemical processes.
Palmer and his disciples were arrested for practicing medicine without a license, which led to a strategy of chiropractors lobbying state legislatures for their own chiropractic practice acts. This effort stretched from 1913, when Kansas became the first state to license chiropractors, to 1974, when Louisiana became the last.
Subluxation: it’s the law
The non-existent chiropractic subluxation remains the central tenet of the 50 state chiropractic practice acts to this day.[1]
Twenty-one state chiropractic acts mention it specifically as the basis for chiropractic practice. For example, Connecticut defines chiropractic practice as:
the science of adjustment, manipulation and treatment of the human body in which vertebral subluxations and other malpositioned articulations and structures that may interfere with the normal generation, transmission and expression of nerve impulse between the brain, organs and tissue cells of the body, which may be a cause of the disease, are adjusted, manipulated or treated.
Twenty-three states refer to its purported attributes — without actually using the “s” word. In North Carolina, chiropractic practice is defined as:
the science of adjusting the cause of the disease by realigning the spine, releasing pressure on nerves radiating from the spine to all parts of the body, and allowing the nerves to carry their full quota of health current (nerve energy) from the brain to all parts of the body.
Did they say “science”? Here’s how much science is involved in chiropractic’s core concept — there’s not even a plausible hypothesis of what a subluxation is or how it might affect human functioning.
Six states simply incorporate by reference practices and procedures taught in chiropractic schools, which remain loyal to the subluxation although some have tried to distance themselves from the word, if not the concept.
This doesn’t mean, of course, that chiropractors are permitted by law to treat any disease or condition by detecting and correcting subluxations, just most any disease or condition, as long as the problem is defined in terms of the patient’s having one or more subluxations stopping up the “flow” of “nerve energy.” Asthma, allergies, ADHD, painful periods and earaches are a few of the many conditions widely advertised as treatable by chiropractic adjustment.
You might think it would cause the chiropractic industry some alarm that legislators might wake up to the fact that subluxations don’t exist. And apparently that is the case. In a few states chiropractors are attempting to expand the chiropractic scope of practice by including authority to prescribe that former anathema to chiropractic: drugs. For years chiropractors branded themselves as doctors who treat patients “without drugs or surgery.”
With drugs but not surgery
Chiropractic lobbying in New Mexico, the state where anyone can practice medicine, provides a perfect lesson in the insidious nature of CAM practitioner licensing. A few years ago, the state legislature invented a new iteration of chiropractor, the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician.” With minimal training, this new type can, by statute, “prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicines, homeopathic medicine, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen , epinephrine and vapocoolants.”
Then, in 2009, the New Mexico legislature granted the state chiropractic board authority to develop a formulary for the “advanced practice chiropractic physician.” The requirement that substances be “natural or naturally derived” was eliminated, but there was a catch: “Dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed [in the quoted section, above] shall be submitted to the board of pharmacy and the New Mexico medical board for approval.”
Apparently, approval was not forthcoming to the chiropractors’ satisfaction, so they returned to the New Mexico legislature this year, seeking to dump the pharmacists and medical doctors. A new, improved version of the “advanced practice chiropractic physician” was proposed: one with a “prescription certificate.”
And just to make the point clear, the term “chiropractic” would be discarded from the New Mexico chiropractic practice act in favor of “chiropractic medicine.” Thus, the purpose of the practice act went from “granting chiropractors the right to practice chiropractic as taught and practiced in standard colleges of chiropractic” to granting “chiropractic physicians the right to practice chiropractic medicine …” [Emphasis added.]
Gone was the requirement of a pharmacy and medical board approved formulary. Instead, those with the “prescription certificate” would be authorized by statute to “prescribe, administer and dispense dangerous drugs, including compounded preparations for topical and oral administration and injection, testosterone in all its forms and codeine in cough syrup.” [Emphasis added.]
One can read between the lines thinking that goes something like: “If the pharmacists and medical doctors won’t let us prescribe testosterone ‘in all its forms’ and cough syrup with codeine, we’ll just put it in the statute and they can’t do a damn thing about it.”
Instead of pharmacy and medical board approval, the proposed legislation provided that “the [chiropractic] board, with the New Mexico Medical Board and the Board of Pharmacy serving in an advisory capacity, and with all parties agreeing to act in good faith, shall establish by rule a formulary …” [Emphasis added.]
Yeah! That’ll show ‘em!
Except the proposed legislation didn’t pass. It was still in committee when the legislature adjourned. New Mexico’s governor recently declared a special session of the legislature to deal with certain pressing problems, such as redistricting, and that has begun. We can only hope the chiropractors don’t try to shoehorn their bill into the special session agenda.
As a cautionary tale about the dangers of mission creep in “CAM” practitioner licensing, it is instructive to look at the education and training which would have been required of the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician” in obtaining a “prescription certificate.”
In addition to the minimal requirements for “advanced practice” certification, the applicant must complete “pharmacological training from an institution of higher education approved by the [chiropractic] board or from a provider of continuing education approved by the board.” [Emphasis added.]
The applicant must complete a program, again approved by the chiropractic board, of 200 classroom hours in pharmacology, physiology, pathophysiology, physical and lab assessment and clinical pharmacotherapeutics, which, you’ll have to admit, is a really long word. Whether this is simply descriptive of, or in addition to, the education described in the previous paragraph is not clear. What is clear is that all of this can be accomplished within the current chiropractic educational system, a subject to which we will return in a future post.
But where, you might ask, would the chiropractor get experience actually treating patients with drugs, so essential to proper training? Well, remember those pesky medical doctors who were gumming up the formulary works? The ones the legislation sought to remove from the process? From them, that’s who.
In order to get the coveted “prescription certificate,” a chiropractor would have to complete 400 hours “of clinical rotation practicum in clinical assessment and pathophysiology” and 400 hours of 100 patients “with disorders relevant to the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician’s clinical specialty.” All done “under supervision of a medical doctor.”
One must wonder where one would find a medical doctor willing to take on supervision of a chiropractor treating patients with drugs.
A bad idea metastasizes
The chiropractic faction interested in foisting chiropractors as primary care physicians on the public was obviously not going to stop with New Mexico, and it didn’t.
In South Carolina, a bill would have created the same sort of “advanced practice chiropractic physician” as presently exists in New Mexico along with the option of obtaining a “prescription certificate” as proposed in the failed New Mexico legislation. The bill never made it out of the Senate Committee on Medical Affairs.
Likewise, in Alabama, a bill was introduced to allow prescription of “natural” compounds, “bio-identical hormones,” homeopathic remedies and other woo remedies favored by “CAM” practitioners. If the chiropractor took the same sort of 90-hour course as New Mexico allows, he or she could also prescribe and inject these substances even if they were classified as legend drugs. This bill also died in committee.
More scope of practice
Prescription authority was not the only means of increasing ways to make mon … I mean, increasing the scope of chiropractic practice attempted in this year’s legislative sessions.
In Illinois, lobbying efforts took a more subtle approach and attempted only an inclusion of authority to provide advice regarding the use of non-prescription products. Translation: they can advise patients regarding dietary supplements. And, of course, having given that advice, they can sell patients the supplements they’ve recommended. This bill, which also authorized chiropractors to administer atmospheric oxygen, made it into law. A bill in Hawaii, authorizing the use of “clinical nutritional methods” (whatever that means), died in committee.
Minnesota, another state where anyone can practice medicine, saw a failed attempt to include acupuncture within chiropractic scope of practice. Perhaps wary of attempts to make chiropractors actually go to acupuncture school and learn “real” acupuncture, this proposed legislation invented an entirely new form, defined as “a modality of treating abnormal physical conditions by stimulating various points of the body or interruption of the cutaneous integrity by needle insertion to secure a reflex relief of the symptoms by nerve stimulation as used as an adjunct to chiropractic adjustment.” Maybe they should have called it “acujustment”.
And on it goes
Last year, the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners issued a ruling that chiropractors need not warn patients of the risk of stroke following cervical manipulation, a ruling based largely on a study which specifically states it does not rule out such a risk.
In response, Connecticut Senator Len Fasano promised to introduce legislation in 2011 mandating a warning. Sen. Fasano testified at a hearing before the Board that he and others in the legislature were under the distinct impression the Board would indeed require this type of warning. Obviously, the Board did not do that, so Sen. Fasano kept his promise and introduced a bill requiring chiropractors to obtain informed written consent prior to any treatment of the cervical spine, including information on the risk of stroke. Unfortunately, the bill did not make it to the floor for a vote.
Finally, chiropractic lobbying in Florida screwed up passage of a perfectly good bill designed to protect the public’s health, safety and welfare.
A bill introduced to educate coaches, parents and young athletes about sports-related concussions and to require that an M.D. or D.O. sign off on return to play post-injury passed the House, where an attempt to include chiropractors was rebuffed in committee. However, the bill got bogged down in the Senate because of a similar attempt to force the inclusion of chiropractors in the type of health care practitioner with authority to clear the young athlete for continued play. The implication, of course, was that chiropractors were qualified to diagnose and treat traumatic brain injury, a conclusion not universally shared in the Senate, and rightly so. That squabble ran the clock out on what would have been a laudable safety measure for school athletes. And that’s a shame.
Conclusion
It is unfortunate enough that the state legislatures have legitimized a figment of the imagination first proposed by a charlatan in 1895 — the “subluxation” — by creating a licensed health care profession known as chiropractors to “detect” and “correct” them. Giving chiropractors authority to prescribe dietary supplements, and, even worse, drugs, only exacerbates their original mistake. Instead of expanding the scope of practice, state legislatures should remove diagnosis and treatment of the nonexistent “subluxation” from the chiropractic practice acts.
References
Bellamy J., Legislative Alchemy: the US state chiropractic practice acts, Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies (2010)15(3): 214–222.

Legislative Alchemy: Chiropractic 2013
Jann Bellamy on February 21, 2013
Link

Via the magic of legislative alchemy, chiropractors are already licensed health care providers in all 50 states. Thus their legislative efforts tend to focus on expanding their scope of practice and forcing public and private insurers to cover their services, in some cases at the same rate as medical doctors. Those efforts continue in 2013 with 65 bills impacting chiropractors introduced so far. Of those including substantive provisions (as opposed to, say, simply raising fees), only one is not to their advantage.
New Mexico chiropractors are once again attempting expansion of their scope of practice. In 2008 and 2009, the New Mexico legislature created a new iteration of chiropractor, called “the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician.” A certain faction of the chiropractic industry is attempting to rebrand chiropractors nationwide as primary care physicians and this was a signature event in those efforts. With 90 hours of additional education, these advanced practice chiropractors can administer a bevy of dubious remedies, such as bioidentical hormones.
The new law also permitted prescription of dangerous drugs and controlled substances and administration of drugs by injection, but only if on a formulary approved by the state pharmacy and medical boards. The chiropractic board didn’t like having to get approval from pharmacists and medical doctors, so they went ahead and added what they wanted to the formulary, ignoring the other boards despite their own attorney’s advice that they couldn’t do this. This got them into a couple of court battles with the pharmacy and medical boards. The International Association of Chiropractors (ICA), the traditional, subluxation-only chiropractic faction, jumped into the fray to oppose this power grab. The ICA believes chiropractic should remain drug and surgery free.
To rid themselves of annoying pharmacy and medical board oversight, chiropractors again appealed to the legislature last year and got a bill introduced which would, among other things, let them control their own formulary. That bill passed the New Mexico House but not the Senate.
NM chiropractors go for more
Which brings us to this year. The chiropractors are back with a new bill (Senate Bill 471) and a new attempt to expand chiropractic scope of practice and play at being real doctors. Toward this end, the bill liberally sprinkles the word “medicine” throughout the chiropractic practice act, so that a chiropractor (both advanced practice and the plain vanilla kind) would no longer be engaged in the practice of “chiropractic,” but rather of “chiropractic medicine.” Similarly, existing authority to sell “herbs,” “supplements’” and “homeopathic remedies” is transformed into authority to sell “herbal medicine,” “nutritional medicine,” and “homeopathic medicine.” How very grand!
Not only would chiropractors locate and remove subluxations to restore health and treat disease (so old school!), their scope of practice would now include, but not be limited to,
diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician [sic] has been educated and trained.
Exactly who would decide whether a chiropractor has been “educated and trained” sufficiently to diagnose and treat a particular condition is not specified.
The bill appears to do away with the limitation on invasive diagnostic procedures to those permitted by chiropractic board rule. (I say “appears to” because the limitation is deleted in one portion of the bill but remains in another. This bill is no model of careful statutory draftsmanship.) Here’s what the board already authorizes chiropractors to perform (as opposed to order – that’s a different list) to date:
The collection and testing of human fluids, such as saliva, blood, urnine, vaginal and seminal fluids, hair, feces, and conventional radiography.
MRI, CT, nuclear scans, ultrasonography; thermography, B.E.A.M. [apparently, Brain Electrical Activity Mapping], EEG, EKG, ECG and surface or needle EMG.
Imagine what chiropractors will do without such limitations, as loose as they are.
But wait, it gets worse
If, up to this point, the words “outrageous,” “dangerous,” “crazy,” and similar descriptives have occurred to you, wait ‘til you see what’s next:
Chiropractic medicine shall exclude operative surgery and prescription of controlled substances except where permitted by statute or rule.
In other words, no operative surgery or controlled substances unless the chiropractic board says it’s ok.
To get the full import of this provision, it must be read together with the proposed expansion of chiropractic scope of practice to include “treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained.” Under existing law, the chiropractic board attempted to include drugs on the formulary for uses which, according to the medical board, were not within the chiropractic scope of practice. This is what got them into a tussle over the formulary. That scope is currently defined in the traditional manner as “locating and removing interference with the transmissions or expression of nerve forces in the human body by the correction of misalignments or subluxations” and “the administering of all natural agents to assist in the healing act,” e.g., herbs, homeopathic products, and the like.
The “we are primary care physicians” faction of chiropractors thought this cramped their style. So if this bill passes, any chiropractic school can “educate and train” chiropractic students in whatever it pleases – say, psychiatry or gastroenterology – and the scope of practice will be practically unlimited, at least in New Mexico. You can bet the chiropractors will try this trick in other states.
The bill is confusing on operative surgery as its provisions are conflicting. The ICA thinks it “potentially” allows operative surgery so we’ll go with that interpretation. I don’t know if this is yet another example of bad drafting or the drafters are just being sneaky.
Thus, under this bill, the chiropractic board, which consists of four chiropractors and two public members, could decide on its own to allow chiropractors to perform operative surgery, “potentially.” There are no requirements in the bill which the board must follow in determining who is qualified to practice surgery or which surgical procedures can be performed, as long as the chiropractor is “educated and trained” in the subject. Chiropractors are forbidden from “procuring, aiding or abetting a criminal abortion,” the implication being that they can perform legal abortions if so “educated and trained.”
Under current law, an “advanced practice” chiropractor must complete 90 clinical and classroom hours and pass a test in addition to the usual requirements for a chiropractic license. The chiropractic board is given sole authority to develop a formulary for the prescription, administration (including by injection) and dispensing of certain substances such as herbal and homeopathic “medicines,” vitamins and minerals, glandular products, live cells products, enzymes, amino acids, lidocaine and procaine for the “advanced practice” chiropractor. To this list the bill adds carbohydrates and sugars. Any substances not listed in the bill can be added to the formulary by the chiropractic board if the pharmacy board approves. Gone is the requirement for medical board approval.
To prescribe, administer or dispense legend (prescription) drugs or Schedule III through V controlled substances, an advanced practice chiropractor must, in addition, hold a prescription certificate. This requires completion of a “primary care clinical rotation” at a chiropractic college or other accredited “institution of higher education or professional school.” The rotation consists of 500 hours of “clinical and hands-on instruction” in clinical pharmacology, evidence-based clinical assessment, clinical pharmacotherapeutics, primary care case management or (not “and” but “or”) patient safety and standards of primary care under the supervision of an M.D., D.O., nurse practitioner or advanced practice chiropractor. No exam is required.
So, let’s see. After what would equal a little more than 6 weeks of a medical residency, all of which could take place in a chiropractic college outpatient clinic, an advanced practice chiropractor could prescribe, administer and dispense Schedule III – V drugs if the chiropractic board wants them on the formulary and the pharmacy board agrees.
Just to further scare you out of your wits, here are a few of New Mexico’s Schedule III – V drugs that caught my untrained eye: anabolic steroids, codeine, testosterone, hydrocodone (Vicodin, Lorcet), morphine, opium, lysergic acid, pentobarbital (Nembutal), alprazolam (Xanax), chloral hydrate, clonazepam (Clonopin), dextropropoxphene, (Darvon, Darvocet), Diazepam (Valium), Esopiclone (Lunesta), phenobarbital (Luminal, Donnatal) and tramadol.
You can see where this is going. Together with the expansion of the scope of practice, this certificate will be a ticket for the advanced practice chiropractor to do pretty much anything a real primary care M.D. or D.O. can do.
So far, the only sponsor of this bill is Senator Cisco McSorley (D). Perhaps some of you might want to drop Sen. McSorley a line with your thoughts on his bill.
Before we move on to other areas, one other practice expansion effort is underway, this time in Texas. Currently, the chiropractic scope of practice includes
objective or subjective means to analyze, examine, or evaluate the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system of the human body
House Bill 1169 would add to the end of that sentence
. . . or the condition of another system of the human body that is affected by the musculoskeletal system.
Which leads me to wonder: considering the vertebrae-centered chiropractic belief system, what wouldn’t be “another system of the human body that is affected by the musculoskeletal system?”
Informed consent, finally?
In Oklahoma, Senate Bill 451 provides
Chiropractic physicians in this state shall obtain informed, written consent from a patient prior to performing any procedure that involves treatment of the patient’s cervical spine and such informed consent shall include the risks and possible side effects of such treatment including the risk of chiropractic stroke.
Needless to say, the Oklahoma Chiropractors’ Association opposes the bill. Chiropractors do not believe there is such a risk, a subject Harriet Hall, Mark Crislip and I have all written about on SBM.
Discrimination?
Washington State already has a law prohibiting the state and its subdivisions (such as counties) from
in any way discriminating against licensed chiropractors in performing and receiving compensation for services covered by their licenses.
To make the point, schools would be forced to include them in sports physicals per an amendment to the law:
Licensed chiropractors must be allowed to perform sports physicals for school athletes and physical examinations required for commercial driver’s licenses.
As Harriet Hall, herself a Washington resident, pointed out:
Physicians and properly trained, experienced PAs and NPs are qualified to do these exams. Chiropractors and other alternative providers are not, even with special certification and training.
As noted in my recent post on naturopathy, chiropractors are seeking to avoid exclusion, which they equate with discrimination, from Oregon’s Coordinated Care Organizations (CCOs) through a bill that would force CCOs to accept them as primary care providers. The CCOs, which provide care for Medicaid patients, were merely trying to follow a legal mandate to save money by requiring providers to practice evidence-based medicine and excluding those who don’t. Never underestimate the power of a state legislature to take away with the right hand taxpayer money the left hand is trying to save.
Insurance
The majority of chiropractic bills introduced so far seek greater public and private health coverage for chiropractic services. Pending bills would, among other things,
    • include or expand coverage of chiropractic services in Medicaid or other taxpayer-funded health insurance programs;
    • prohibit coverage limitations on chiropractic services unless there are similar limitations on physician services or require coverage of services on same basis as a physician;
    • require coverage for any service within the scope of chiropractic practice;
    • prohibit larger copayments for chiropractors than for physicians.
There is considerable financial pressure on chiropractors and thus an urgent need to increase income, even if it means singing up for low reimbursement programs like Medicaid. The total number of ambulatory visits to chiropractors decreased by 3 percent from 2002-2008. Quackwatch recently analyzed chiropractic income based on data from the U.S. Department of Commerce:
These figures indicate that between January 1992 and December 2007, the average gross income per chiropractic office rose at less than half the rate of inflation, which is equivalent to a loss of 20% in purchasing power. Since the cost of running the offices increased during this period, the purchasing power of the chiropractor’s take-home pay was even lower.
And just this week Scripps-Howard News Service published a news report revealing the large number of defaults still outstanding on government health care provider student loans. A complete list of the 930 providers (see bottom of report) reveals that chiropractors hold a distinct majority on the list.
Conclusion
Instead of ditching the subluxation and becoming an evidence-based provider of care for musculoskeletal problems, chiropractors appear to being going in the extreme opposite direction. They are attempting to become primary care physicians but with far less education and training than M.D.s, D.O.s, P.A.s and nurse practitioners have in diagnosing and treating the broad range of conditions seen by primary care providers. They compound the problem by using quack remedies like homeopathy. If they can fool some of the public some of the time with this nonsense, I don’t think it will be for long. As is true of “naturopathic doctors,” very few patients will see chiropractors for primary care even when their scope of practice permits it and insurance pays for it. And it will just compound the problem the public has figuring out just what it is chiropractors do.

Legislative Alchemy 2016 Update: Acupuncturists win; naturopaths and chiropractors don’t (so far)
Jann Bellamy on July 21, 2016
Link


Legislative Alchemy is the process by which state legislatures transform pseudoscience and quackery into licensed health care practices. By legislative fiat, chiropractors can detect and correct non-existent subluxations, naturopaths can diagnose (with bogus tests) and treat (with useless dietary supplements and homeopathy) fabricated diseases like “adrenal fatigue” and “chronic yeast overgrowth,” and acupuncturists can unblock mythical impediments to the equally mythical “qi” by sticking people with needles. In sum, by passing chiropractic, naturopathic, acupuncture, and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practice acts, states license what are essentially fraudulent health care practices and give them an undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy.
Only 6 of the 50 state legislatures are in regular session now. Many have ended two-year (2015-2016) consecutive sessions in which legislation from one year carries over into the next. The Texas, Montana, and North Dakota legislatures didn’t meet at all in 2016.
During 2015-2016, over a dozen naturopathic licensing or registration bills and at least 15 naturopathic practice expansion bills were introduced. (In some states, companion bills were introduced in each house. These were counted as one bill.) At least 19 chiropractic practice expansion bills were introduced in the same period. Four acupuncture/TCM practice acts were introduced, as were 14 practice expansion bills. This count does not include bills trying to force public and private insurers to cover CAM practitioner services.
At the beginning of this year, we reported on how naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists fared in 2015 (not all that well, actually), noting that a number of bills remained pending in the second of the two-year period in some states. Now that most legislatures have shut the doors until 2017, it’s a good time to update that report.
Acupuncture and TCM
Acupuncturists nailed another state – Kansas – in their quest for licensure in all 50 states. (They added North Dakota just last year, although with a fairly narrow scope of practice.) The new law defines acupuncture as the use of needles and “related modalities” for
assessment, evaluation, prevention, treatment or correction of any abnormal physiology or pain by means of controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy . . . and stimulating the body to restore itself.
Since physiology is
a branch of biology that deals with the functions and activities of life or of living matter (as organs, tissues, or cells) and of the physical and chemical phenomena involved
it appears the Kansas legislature has granted the acupuncturists an extremely broad scope of practice. One wonders exactly what patient complaint couldn’t be shoehorned into the “abnormal physiology” category.
Gina Halsey, a Lawrence, Kansas, acupuncturist who believes her irregular heartbeat was cured by acupuncture, pushed the bill as a public safety measure, emphasizing the education and training requirements. According to Halsey,
Sometimes people will use (acupuncture) in conjunction with medicine and sometimes people try it before resorting to a medication that has other side effects, and it’s just wonderful for that . . .
Frankly, the public has a lot more to worry about, safety-wise, from practitioners who think the body’s physiology can be affected by sticking a patient with needles, that acupuncture is effective for irregular heartbeat and that it is a reasonable alternative to medication. Halsey’s overblown claims for acupuncture demonstrate the disregard for science and evidence this ballyhooed education and training produce. Her website lists conditions she says she “regularly treats with great success:” herpes, “yeast,” incontinence, IBS, infertility, uterine fibroids, Bell’s palsy, MS, paralysis, stroke sequela, asthma, depression and psoriasis, among others. In fact, acupuncture is effective for none of those, or anything at all, for that matter. Fortunately, the new law requires acupuncturists to carry malpractice insurance.
In addition to traditional needle acupuncture, Kansas practitioners will be able to employ a number of other unproven methods, like “auricular detox,” magnetic and electromagnetic treatments, and cupping. They can also dispense unproven, often contaminated, and potentially dangerous herbal remedies and dietary supplements, which will be a real boon to their bottom lines.
In the past two years, acupuncturists have gotten substantial scope of practice expansion bills passed in Delaware, New York, and Rhode Island. This year, Delaware added the practice of “Eastern Medicine” to its acupuncture practice act, defined as
the practice of acupuncture, Chinese herbology and Asian bodywork therapy as part of a comprehensive health care system encompassing a variety of traditional health care therapies that have been used for more than 3,000 years to diagnose and treat illness, prevent disease and improve well-being.
Of course, “used for” is not synonymous with “is effective for.” Practitioners can make recommendations based on “eastern dietary therapy,” supplements and lifestyle and offer “nonfraudulent” information about herbs, vitamins, amino acids, carbs, sugars, enzymes, food concentrates, and dietary supplements. It’s always a wonder how acupuncturists and the like bootstrap themselves into legitimacy with the argument that their methods are “thousands” of years old, then tack on all sorts of stuff that the ancients either had no idea existed (amino acids, enzymes) or didn’t exist “thousands” of years ago (dietary supplements, food concentrates). The new law uses a criminal standard for fraud (“intentional misrepresentation for financial gain”), rather than a civil standard, which can encompass simply ignoring reality for financial gain, a key feature of acupuncture. It also says that
legitimate disagreement about the role of the above-listed nutrients and foods as they apply to human nutrition shall not, in and of itself, constitute fraud.
It will be interesting to see how the courts deal with this one. Does “legitimate disagreement” mean “legitimate scientific disagreement about the evidence” or does it enshrine into law the post-modern mantra that science “doesn’t know everything” and that myth is of equal validity as a basis for healthcare decision-making?
Similarly, Rhode Island added the practice of “Oriental medicine” to its acupuncture practice act last year, defining it as a form of “primary health care” using Chinese medical and acupuncture diagnostics, including those based on “newer scientific models” for “assessment, treatment, prevention or cure of any disease.” This year, the Rhode Island legislature gifted acupuncturists with self-regulation, creating a Board of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine. The state also has a new law allowing chemical dependency professionals to use “auricular acudetox,” or ear acupuncture, which is based on the “understanding”
that the external ear represents all parts of the human body, including the internal organs, and provides acupuncture points corresponding to these parts. Auricular acupuncture therapy was discovered by Dr. Paul Nogier based on observations that backaches were cured after the patient received a burn on their ear. Dr. Nogier pictured an auricle as a fetus that was curled up and upside down; he used his anatomical knowledge to treat diseases by applying pressure to the reaction points that represent the internal organs.
We have an opioid crisis in the U.S. and the state of Rhode Island wants to abandon the addicted to magical thinking.
New York also expanded the acupuncturists’ scope of practice. They may now recommend “traditional remedies and supplements,” and, with additional training, custom-made remedies and herbal formulations. (As of this writing, the Governor has not signed this legislation, but there is no indication he will veto it.)
Naturopathy
Naturopathic licensing and practice expansion bills have all failed so far in 2016, but important legislation remains in play. New York (for the eighth consecutive legislative session), Rhode Island (for the fifth time), North Carolina (for the seventh time), and Mississippi (for the second time), all rejected naturopathic licensing efforts in 2016. A resolution was introduced in the Indiana House asking that a study committee look into naturopathic licensing but that went nowhere too.
Licensing bills are still alive in Michigan, Massachusetts (where a bill passed in the Senate), Pennsylvania (where a bill passed in the House), and New Jersey (where bills carry over into 2017). All of these states have rejected licensing efforts in the past but, with money from dietary supplement and diagnostic testing companies now backing their lobbyists, the umpteenth time may be the charm. Each of the pending bills would give naturopaths a broad scope of practice, similar to that of a family practice physician. All would allow a naturopath to diagnose (including the use of diagnostic testing) and treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition. Only the means of doing so, consisting in the main of unproven or disproven remedies like dietary supplements and homeopathy, would be limited.
Fortuitously, naturopaths have recently endured a spate of publicity that presents a picture of naturopathy at odds with their PR. In addition to the revelation that they are accepting supplement and testing company money for lobbying, as well as for other operations, Britt Hermes’s outing their dirty laundry (and their despicable attacks on her), as well as the media reports surrounding the possible role of a naturopath in the death of a Canadian toddler, have countered their party line that they are all sweetness and light. Far from being the primary care physicians they claim they are, media reports (also here and here) have highlighted their quacky practices and insular group-think that prohibits honest inquiry into their shortcomings.
Practice expansion efforts also faltered this year. The only success so far is in Maryland. There, legislation established a formulary committee operating under the auspices of the Maryland Board of Physicians, which regulates naturopathic practice. The formulary can, but does not have to, include prescription drugs, although no controlled substances are permitted. In Connecticut, a bill passed allowing, but not requiring, the Commissioner of Public Health to establish a commission to look into naturopathic prescribing privileges. This legislation, as originally drafted, created a tiered naturopathic licensing system, with “advanced practice naturopathic care” being at the top of the heap. With only 45 hours of drug pharmacology education, plus 15 hours of continuing education a year, an “advanced practice” naturopath could prescribe drugs approved by the State Board of Naturopathic Examiners. Fortunately, that provision was dropped.
Vermont naturopaths wanted self-regulation by a Board of Naturopathic Physicians but didn’t get it from their legislature and remain under the regulatory authority of the Director of the Office of Professional Regulation. More interestingly, though, buried deep in House Bill 562, which passed and has been signed by the Governor, is another provision affecting Vermont naturopaths. Vermont previously passed a law requiring naturopaths with prescription privileges to pass a pharmacology exam by July 1, 2016, in order to retain those privileges. That deadline was extended by HB 562 until July 1, 2017. One cannot avoid the sneaking suspicion this is necessary because not enough of them could pass, or perhaps none could pass, by the deadline. I wrote the Office of Professional Regulation weeks ago for more information, such as the pass/fail rate for the exam, but have yet to get a reply.
Expansion of prescription privileges is still a possibility in California, although the bill as it now stands substantially whittled away what naturopaths originally hoped for, which was to be out from under the supervision of MDs/DOs when prescribing controlled substances. The original version of Senate Bill 538 would have allowed naturopaths to order, prescribe and administer Schedule III through Schedule V drugs with no MD or DO supervision. As amended, naturopaths would be limited to Schedule V drugs and certain other prescription drugs. Naturopathic practice could include Schedule III – IV drugs only under the supervision of an MD or DO and according to standardized procedures or protocols, including specifying which drugs can be used. As well, naturopaths must have additional coursework in pharmacology if they wish to expand their prescribing privileges. For Schedule III drugs, protocols must be patient-specific. The Naturopathic Medicine Committee of the Osteopathic Medical Board, which regulates naturopathic practice, may establish regulations regarding ocular or intravenous routes of administration, although apparently it is not required to do so. Provisions allowing more liberal diagnostic testing privileges, minor office surgery and parenteral administration were also removed. Disappointingly, the AARP supported this bill.
Elsewhere, expansion of prescribing privileges failed in Washington and Hawaii. Naturopaths also revived a dead bill which would have allowed them to corner the colon hydrotherapy market in Hawaii, but that ran out of steam as well. In California and Oregon, respectively, naturopaths and chiropractors sought the authority to perform school physicals for athletes and to return them to play after a concussion. Neither passed.
Chiropractic
Chiropractors are licensed in all 50 states, so their legislative efforts focus on practice expansion and mandated insurance coverage. In several states, chiropractors are trying to create what appears to be a sort of chiropractic naturopath, or maybe a naturopathic chiropractor, all in service of rebranding chiropractors as primary care physicians.
We’ve followed these efforts in New Mexico over the last few years, where chiropractors have managed to get limited prescription privileges, although further expansion was rejected last year by the NM legislature. Legislation in Arizona that would have permitted chiropractors “certified in pharmacology” to prescribe certain drugs failed as well in 2015.
The Ohio House passed a bill allowing chiropractors to sell vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, enzymes, glandulars, homeopathic remedies, non-prescription drugs and other supplements and some medical equipment to patients “to restore or maintain” their health. That bill is now before the Senate Committee on State and Local Government.
The Ohio State Board of Chiropractic already takes a generous view of chiropractic scope of practice:
The practice of chiropractic will include and permit the use of such diagnostic and treatment procedures as are taught by board approved chiropractic colleges except as prohibited by law and/or the rules of this board.
So, as long as a diagnostic procedure or treatment procedure is taught in one of the chiropractic colleges, unless the Ohio Legislature or the Board specifically prohibits it, it’s legal. According to the Board, this means that Ohio chiropractors can use venipuncture, blood analysis, and urinalysis as diagnostic tools. Board-approved continuing education courses extend far beyond musculoskeletal conditions. Courses include:
Endocrine System: “Overview of all hormones with special focus on estrogen dominance, metabolic syndrome, adrenal fatigue.”
Nutritional Support for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Chiropractic and Pregnancy, including how to recommend homeopathic remedies and herbs for pregnant patients.
See what I mean? The naturopathic chiropractor primary care physician emerges as the latest chiropractic fantasy practice.
An Idaho bill took an even broader approach. It would have allowed chiropractors not only to sell dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies to patients, but also administer them enterally and transdermally. In addition, with 120 hours of classroom and clinical instruction, they could obtain a “certificate in clinical nutrition,” which would allow them to administer vitamins, minerals, homeopathic remedies, and the like using IV, IM, intra-articular, subcutaneous and sub-dermal routes. Fortunately, the bill never got out of committee.
A bill introduced in Hawaii went even further, by allowing chiropractors to call themselves “physicians” and defining chiropractic as
a portal of entry for consumers to obtain services from licensees whose practice includes all hygienic, sanitary, and therapeutic measures incident to humans.
Any diagnostic methods and treatments taught in an accredited chiropractic college would be permitted, except for legend drugs and surgery. Thankfully, the bill failed to meet a legislative deadline for further consideration.
In Louisiana, a bill took a less direct approach to practice expansion. Had it passed, chiropractors would be able to advise patients on “health and wellness” and to use any diagnostic tests relevant to “the patient’s condition.” Other state bills were more modest in their expansion efforts. As mentioned, California rejected chiropractors performing physicals for school athletes. Bills failed in both Oregon and Kansas that would have allowed a chiropractor to return a student athlete to play following a concussion.
Helping you fight back
Over on SfSBM, we’ve been following CAM bills since 2013. By the time the state legislative sessions start in 2017, we hope to have an entirely new format in operation. Mark Crislip is creating a terrific new U.S. map that allows you to click on any state to follow what it going on, instead of sifting through a long list covering all states. We are also adding an RSS feed (a commenter request). Finally, we want to add more coverage of Congressional bills. Of course, we’re not doing this for the fun of it. You need to use it to fight CAM expansion in your state. Otherwise, your new PCP could be a naturopathic chiropractor or TCM practitioner.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic
Chiropractors are promoting themselves as primary care physicians. Some state legislatures are falling for it.
Jann Bellamy on January 4, 2018
Link


State legislatures routinely incorporate pseudoscience into health care practitioner licensing laws, a process I call “Legislative Alchemy.” These laws allow health care practitioners to use bogus diagnostic methods, diagnose fabricated diseases and conditions, and sell useless remedies to their patients. Legislatures credulously adopt the self-regulated educational and testing requirements of these practitioners instead of objectively evaluating their credentials.
Armed with the undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy bestowed by the state, naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists diagnose and treat millions of patients each year. Yet, they offer nothing beneficial that is not readily available from evidence-based practitioners. As for the rest, at best, patients lose only their money. At worst, they lose their lives.
Today, we look at chiropractic efforts to benefit from the magic of Legislative Alchemy in 2017, a subject I previewed earlier this year.
The DC as PCP
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the Council on Chiropractic Education, and chiropractic schools have declared, ipse dixit, that chiropractors are primary care physicians, a rebranding campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. (List of posts here.) For example, according to the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS), its chiropractic school:
prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat, and manage a wide range of conditions.
We’ll examine the veracity of that statement more closely in a moment, but first let’s look at two Tennessee laws passed in 2017 which gave a big boost to chiropractic’s rebranding efforts.
Chiropractic scope of practice under prior Tennessee law was basically limited to diagnosing and treating neuromuscular conditions via the detection and correction of the phantom chiropractic subluxation. House Bill 387 vastly expands that scope for chiropractic “physicians” in a way that might not be immediately obvious to those unfamiliar with the chiropractic “DC as PCP” campaign.
Essential to this rebranding is a redefined scope of practice, which the ACA calls “Six Elements of a Modern Chiropractic Act.” Key elements include:
     1.  An unrestricted right to diagnose any patient of any age with any disease or condition, including expanded authority to order and perform diagnostic testing.
     2.  Deference to chiropractic schools in determining chiropractic scope of practice – if they teach it, chiropractors can legally do it.
     3.  While giving lip service to chiropractic treatment of “neuromusculoskeletal” conditions, the authority to diagnose and treat an undefined “other health conditions or issues,” as well as “general health matters, wellness and health optimization.”
In other words, the ACA wants to sell the public on the notion that chiropractors should be everyone’s first stop for general health advice as well as a diagnosis of what ails them, no matter what the disease or condition, trusting the chiropractor to refer the patient to a real doctor should the need arise. In Tennessee, that’s pretty much what they got.
The scope of a chiropractor’s authority to diagnose was totally redefined to include “differential diagnosis,” defined as, without limitation as to disease or condition:
the source, nature, and extent of a disease or other physical condition for the purpose of establishing an appropriate plan of care, which may include referral to another provider for care that is outside the scope of practice of a chiropractic physician.
To conduct this differential diagnosis, the chiropractor can perform a “thorough examination and evaluation” of the patient as well as use “diagnostic procedures necessary to clinically correlate a physical examination to a diagnostic impression.” What diagnostic procedures can they use? A whole lot of them. They can:
    • Perform x-rays and non-invasive diagnostic procedures, not otherwise described.
    • Order advanced diagnostic imaging and “other diagnostic procedures,” again, not otherwise described.
    • Collect blood, urine, saliva, and hair for analysis.
    • Perform “minimally invasive procedures” if they learned it in chiropractic school and the state chiropractic board says it’s ok. (They must consult with the medical board but there’s no requirement that the medical board approve what they decide.)
Let’s pause for a minute to note that the chiropractic lobby wanted to include hair analysis (“a cardinal sign of quackery”) and saliva testing (used by quacks to diagnose hormone “imbalances” and validated only for Cushing’s syndrome, which no chiropractor has any business touching) along with the right to order, say, PET scans and MRIs.
But what about treatment? Are Tennessee chiropractors allowed to treat any disease or condition they diagnose? Probably not, but they can go well beyond musculoskeletal conditions. Again, you need to know a bit of background to understand how this will work.
Subluxation-based chiropractors will still be able to locate and remove “interference with nerve transmission and nerve function,” which they regard as beneficial to a host of diseases and conditions. For the rest, it depends on how expansively you are willing to read the statute. Under the new law, “treatment” means:
The treatment of neuromuscular, musculoskeletal, and related conditions . . . [and] the provision of supportive care with due regard for nutrition, hygiene, sanitation and rehabilitation designed to assist in the restoration and maintenance of a patient’s health. [Emphasis added.]
Recall that the chiropractors drafted this bill to include hair and saliva analysis. That’s a smoking gun showing they plan to diagnose non-existent “toxicities” and “hormone imbalances,” presumably with the intent to treat these “conditions,” most likely with dietary supplements (“nutrition”) under the rubric of “assisting in the restoration and maintenance of a patient’s health.” Of course, that’s just a small sampling of the many bogus “other diagnostic procedures” that can be used to diagnose all manner of “nutritional deficiencies” and assorted fabricated conditions, like “heavy metal toxicity” based on provoked urine testing and treated with dietary supplements.
In other words, in addition to detecting and correcting non-existent subluxations, chiropractors will have a scope of practice similar to a naturopathic “doctor” practicing in a state that does not allow prescription privileges: an unlimited right to diagnose and broad authority to treat with, for example, non-prescription drugs, dietary supplements and (presumably) homeopathy, as long as the treatment can be shoehorned into a vague category like “related conditions,” “supportive care,” “nutrition” and so on.
To bring home the point that a DC can be your PCP, the Tennessee legislature also passed a bill allowing chiropractors to enter into “direct primary care agreements” with patients, that is, agree to “provide primary care services” to the patient for a fee over an agreed period of time. The agreement must describe “the scope of primary service that is covered” by the fee.
“Primary care services” is defined to include:
the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment for the purpose of promotion of health or the detection and management of disease or injury within the competency and training of the direct primary care physician, or, if applicable, within the scope of practice of a chiropractic physician.
Note that an MD or DO physician is limited to diagnosis and treatment within his “competency and training” but chiropractors can provide care within their “scope of practice,” that is, anything the chiropractic lobbyists who wrote the new scope of practice law say they can do.
With that in mind, let’s return to the National University of Health Science’s claim that the school is training students to practice primary care “fully qualified to diagnose, treat, and manage a wide range of conditions.” A recent chiropractic journal article authored by three members of the NUHS Department of Clinical Practice faculty casts doubt on that claim. (Whole article is behind a paywall.)
The authors report their treatment of constipation in two 7-month-old twins who were born prematurely at 29 weeks, both of whom had undergone abdominal surgery. Treatment consisted of scar tissue mobilization, detection and correction of phantom subluxations, and acupressure to the feet. One of the infants also underwent Dynamic Neuromuscular Stabilization “to correct aberrant movement patterns.” This lasted for ten treatment sessions for one and eight for the other, both at two treatment sessions per week. Follow up visits after the supposed resolution of their supposed constipation were then reduced to one visit per week, then one per month.
It hardly bears mentioning that none of these is a proven treatment for constipation in infants, and two of them are based on fantastical concepts of human anatomy and physiology. As best I can tell, the principles behind Dynamic Neuromuscular Stabilization remain unproven (if not fantastical) particularly in infants, and not meant for constipation. Scar tissue mobilization, described as “gentle cross-frictional movement along the scar” was used to “loosen up tightness of the abdominal musculature” and “stimulate the mechanoreceptors and nerve endings in the skin,” along with a lot of hand waving about how this relieves constipation.
I ran the article by SBM’s own Clay Jones, MD, a pediatrician (have a read of his post on constipation in children ). He noted that the determination of constipation in infants is often very subjective and thought that these babies were probably not constipated in the first place. He noted that some of the supposed symptoms of constipation described in the article were actually normal behavior. If anything, he guessed that:
the chiropractor was taking credit for the natural course of the complaints, maternal placebo response, and possibly other interventions [not described in the article].
I point all of this out to demonstrate the folly of legislatures’ relying on self-regulated chiropractic education and training (especially scant in pediatrics) in granting licensure to chiropractors and giving them the authority to treat any patient with any disease or condition. It also gives lie to comments made in response to SBM posts on chiropractic that subluxation-based chiropractic is fading and no longer taught in chiropractic schools. And it is a perfect example of how, in the words of the new Tennessee law, conditions “related” to (at least in the chiropractic view of things) neuromuscular issues can be expanded to cover all sorts of medical problems chiropractors have no business treating.
Chiropractic “nutrition” and other imagined competencies
Idaho passed a practice expansion bill in 2017 allowing chiropractors “certified in clinical nutrition” to administer vitamins A, C and all B vitamins, plus minerals such as calcium, copper, magnesium, selenium and zinc, by means that include intravenous injections, as well as orally and topically. Apparently, the law was passed because chiropractors had been giving injections anyway and wanted to continue. This brings the ACA closer to another desired element of the Modern Chiropractic Practice Act: Prescription authority. (Vitamins and minerals are legally considered drugs if they are injected, despite chiropractors’ protestations otherwise.)
Becoming certified in clinical nutrition is a pretty easy prospect. All they will need is 77 classroom hours plus 24 clinical hours in administration, lab testing and blood chemistry interpretation, all of which they can get at a chiropractic school.
The new law will allow chiropractors to cash in on the health craze for vitamin and mineral infusions. Considering the plethora of bogus nutritional testing methods available, there should be no shortage of opportunities to upsell patients on the need. Except in cases of actual deficiency, which are rare, and use for a handful of diseases, vitamin and mineral infusions are not supported by adequate evidence of safety and efficacy. Fortunately for them, this is not considered a barrier to chiropractors.
There were two other minor legislative successes for chiropractors in 2017. In Texas, the legislature added “diagnose” to the chiropractic scope of practice, although the Senate made it clear this is not an expansion and chiropractors are limited to diagnosing a biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system. Virginia will allow chiropractors to perform physicals commercial driver’s licenses and learner’s permits.
Otherwise, chiropractic bills failed or, in three states, remain pending. (Links are provided for pending bills; for failed bills, see The Society for Science-Based Medicine.)
Two of the practices chiropractors covet are performing school physicals for student athletes and the authority to return students athletes to play after a concussion. (The cynic in me sees these as practice-building efforts.) Harriet Hall, MD, and Mark Crislip, MD, have analyzed chiropractors’ ability to perform these functions and found them wanting, but lack of education and training (not to mention reality-based practice) never stopped a legislator from introducing a practice expansion bill.
Both Connecticut and Oregon said “no” to chiropractors returning concussed athletes to play. Bills allowing chiropractors to perform school physicals remain pending in California, North Carolina (although it may have missed a deadline for further consideration), and Wisconsin. Even though the Wisconsin bills are opposed by the state medical society, medical specialty associations, the state nurses, and athletic trainers associations, hospitals and insurance groups, the Assembly passed its version of the bill. (Senate version here.)

Colorado allows animal chiropractic, which is based on the notion that non-existent subluxations exist in animals as well as humans and, as in humans, can be detected by x-ray. A bill failed that would have relieved chiropractors of the requirement that a veterinarian clear the animal prior to chiropractic treatment.
A bill granting chiropractors a Tennessee-sized scope of practice expansion didn’t make it in Indiana, while a substantial practice expansion bill remains pending in New York. Nevada rejected a practice expansion that would have allowed the correction of subluxations to “improve health.” Florida did not follow Tennessee’s lead in allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. A New Mexico bill allowing “advance practice” chiropractors expanded prescription privileges, including all drugs used in primary care practice except Schedule I controlled substances, didn’t pass. In Wyoming, chiropractors tried, once again, to call themselves “physicians.” That bill didn’t pass either.
And on it goes. A practice expansion bill has already been filed in Indiana for consideration in the 2018 legislative session. We’ll be watching.

Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues
Chiropractors are not properly educated and trained to be primary care physicians. Yet, their campaign to rebrand themselves as PCPs via legislation continues.
Jann Bellamy on December 20, 2018
Link

Today, we continue our annual review of Legislative Alchemy – the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience into health care via legislation – with a look at 2018 state bills (some carried over from their introduction in 2017) aiming to expand chiropractors’ scope of practice.
State chiropractic practice acts are the granddaddy of all Legislative Alchemy. The first were passed in the early 1900s, making the detection and correction of non-existent subluxations the legal basis for distinguishing chiropractic from medical practice and saving chiropractors from arrest on charges of the unauthorized practice of medicine. Since the 1970s, when Louisiana became the last state to legalize chiropractic practice, chiropractors’ efforts have focused on practice expansion and state-mandated insurance coverage, to the point of their lobbying for primary care physician status, just without the pesky and time-consuming education and training. (We have extensively covered the “DC as PCP” campaign on SBM; posts are collected here.) Along the way, chiropractors have managed to pick up an extraordinarily varied scope of practice, including, depending on the state, obstetrics, pelvic (including PAP smears) and breast exams, electrolysis, acupuncture, visceral manipulation, thermography, colonic irrigation, and semen analysis, among dozens of other diagnostic and treatment methods.
The DC as PCP
Sometimes attempts at rebranding DCs as PCPs take a head-on approach, with bills dramatically increasing the scope of diagnostic testing and treatments the chiropractor can employ. Others are more subtle, as we shall see.
Indiana’s House Bill 1384 and Senate Bill 160 are exemplars of the former. State law formerly defined “chiropractic” as the diagnosis and treatment of “interference with normal nerve transmission”, i.e., traditional subluxation-based chiropractic. As originally drafted, these bills would allow examination and treatment of all human ailments as long as no surgery or prescription drugs are used, and removed prohibitions on the use of ionizing radiation, conducting invasive diagnostic testing, and analysis of bodily fluids. Prohibitions on the treatment of infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, or atypical or abnormal histology were also eliminated. As originally drafted, chiropractors would be able to use any therapy to treat any “injury, condition or disorder” as long as the therapy is taught in a chiropractic college or in an approved postgraduate program. (While “post-graduate” may imply clinical training, as in medicine, that is not the case with chiropractors; these “post-grad” programs are often taught in hotel conference rooms and may not include actual patient care.)
Fortunately, subsequent amendments trimmed some of these privileges. The final bill, signed into law by the Governor, reinstated prohibitions on use of ionizing radiation, and treatment of infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, and abnormal histology, although chiropractors can apparently diagnose and treat any other injury, condition or disorder. The provision allowing anything taught in a chiropractic college or post-grad programs was removed. Nevertheless, chiropractors will be able prescribe and sell dietary supplements to patients to treat illness under the guise of “nutritional counseling”, use dry needling, and will have expanded use of diagnostic testing to “prepare a proper chiropractic diagnosis”, whatever that means. The authority to diagnose and treat phantom subluxations remains, no doubt necessary to retain the support of “straight” chiropractors.
Indiana chiropractors have thus gained several new options for rebranding. The legal authority to use diagnostic testing and prescribe dietary supplements gives chiropractors a green light to become so-called “functional medicine” practitioners. If you want to see how that works for patients, look no further than Dr. David Gorski’s Monday post on one chiropractor’s pseudoscience-filled “functional medicine” discourse. Or, chiropractors can essentially practice naturopathy, with all of its attendant quackery. Or – yet another option – they can become “chiropractic internists“. Either way, as a bonus to the bottom line, chiropractors can sell the supplements they prescribe to patients.
Similar bills “modernizing” chiropractic practice are pending in New York (Assembly Bill 8541, Senate Bill 7247), both stuck in their respective chamber’s Higher Education Committee, where they have yet to be taken up. Current law permits the detection and correction of fictional subluxations. These bills expand the use of that fiction by permitting chiropractors to diagnose “the human body” for “any human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition” [emphasis added] and treat by – you guessed it – detecting and correcting subluxations. The bills would also allow chiropractors to call themselves “physicians” who could, with vaguely described additional training, engage in “wellness care” and give dietary and nutritional advice, including dispensing dietary supplements. Expanded lab testing, electrodiagnostic testing and manipulation under anesthesia are included as well.
Fortunately, a Utah bill allowing chiropractors expanded privileges, including ordering diagnostic evaluations, imaging studies, and lab tests, and prescribing durable medical equipment, failed. It would also have permitted chiropractors to prescribe and sell dietary supplements, “cellular components”, and homeopathic remedies. As I noted in my last post, on naturopathic “doctor” licensing and practice expansion, state legislation continues to include homeopathic remedies in health care practitioner scope of practice, ignoring the FDA’s declaration that all homeopathic products on the market are there in violation of federal law for failing to undergo pre-market FDA approval, subjecting them to immediate regulatory action.
Stealth DC as PCP
Other legislative attempts to rebrand DCs as PCPs are more subtle. A favorite tactic is to mandate the inclusion of chiropractors among health care practitioners authorized to perform school physicals for student athletes, thereby falsely implying to the public that they have the education and training to examine and diagnose the undifferentiated patient. Of course, it’s a handy practice-building device as well, allowing the chiropractor to impress upon the patient, and perhaps the patient’s parent, the importance of “chiropractic care” for the entire family.
Wisconsin is an excellent example of how an organized pushback against such ill-advised legislation can be effective in voting it down. Per Assembly Bill 260 and Senate Bill 232, as originally drafted, chiropractors could have performed physicals for student athletes, including college athletes. A “certificate in health and physical examinations” would be required, but the education and training for the certificate would be solely up to the state chiropractic board. Many groups opposed the bills, including the Wisconsin Medical Society, specialty medical societies, the state nurses’ and athletic trainers’ associations, hospitals, and insurance industry representatives. The Medical Society rightly pointed out that chiropractors aren’t qualified to examine students for cardiovascular problems or mental health and substance abuse issues, among others. (SBM’s own Dr. Harriet Hall, herself a retired family physician, has explained why chiropractors aren’t qualified to perform these school physicals as well.) The bills also permitted something called “chiropractic acupuncture”, which was understandably opposed by acupuncturists. In the end, the bills were stripped of these provisions, although, as finally passed and signed by the Governor, chiropractors will be allowed to employ nurses and to perform federal motor vehicle safety physicals.
Bills were also introduced in North Carolina and California allowing chiropractors to perform physicals for participation in student athletics. With the legislature set to adjourn on December 31st, the N.C. bill is stuck in the same committee to which it was assigned in 2017. The language of the California legislation (which included naturopaths as well) has been revised and now addresses a different subject (guns, but not DCs or NDs) altogether.
Bills preying on the young in a different manner were introduced in Illinois and Maryland. Both failed. In Illinois, by defining chiropractors as “physicians” for the purposes of a statute addressing student athlete concussions, chiropractors would have been allowed to evaluate students for concussions and sign off on their returning to play. They would be included on “concussion oversight teams”, tasked with developing student concussion policy. Of course, chiropractors are not properly educated and trained to treat brain injuries and “chiropractic neurology” is grounded in pseudoscience.
Maryland House Bill 623 and Senate Bill 164 were essentially chiropractic practice building disguised as a public health initiative. These bills permitted county education boards to implement a policy allowing chiropractors to perform scoliosis exams on students. Routine screening for scoliosis is controversial. The Scoliosis Research Society, American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, Pediatric Orthopedic Society of North America and American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) believe that “screening examinations for spine deformity should be part of the medical home preventative services visit for females at age 10 and 12 years, and males once at age 13 or 14 years” and do not endorse routine screenings of the type described in this bill. Chiropractic treatment of scoliosis, which can result in delay of effective treatment, is not recommended by the Scoliosis Research Society and spinal manipulation for scoliosis is generally not covered by insurance. Even the General Assembly’s own staff analysis noted that the AAP recommends against this type of routine screening, perhaps contributing to the failure of both bills.
DC as PCP via DPC
Another back door to rebranding chiropractors as primary care physicians is state legislation allowing DCs to enter into direct primary care agreements with their patients. This year, Florida’s Governor signed a bill doing just that, an effort that one chiropractic lobbyist admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as primary care physicians.
Florida’s new law defines chiropractors, as well as MDs, DOs, and nurse practitioners, as “primary care providers” and “primary care services” as:
screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient conducted within the competency and training of the primary care provider for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury.
As I opined in a previous post, allowing DCs to enter into DPC agreements is a bad deal for patients. Their lack of education and training for primary care practice has been extensively documented here on SBM. Yet, as I pointed out in that post,
In a recent survey of chiropractic websites, about a third of chiropractors were claiming they treat allergies and asthma. But that’s not all. Chiropractic websites and other promotional material, including those of chiropractic professional associations, promote chiropractic diagnosis and/or treatment of ear infections, bedwetting, colic, Tourette syndrome, ADHD, breech babies, autism, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer prevention and detection, and endocrinology. A series of articles in an American Chiropractic Association publication (republished here and thoroughly demolished by Harriet Hall here) recommends that chiropractors employ diagnostic methods like fasting metabolic panels, lipid profiles, high sensitivity CRP to assess the level of endothelial inflammation and the risk of a cardiovascular event, hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) profile, auscultation, thyroid palpation, assessment of bowel sounds, palpation of the abdomen, prostate exams, and rectal exams. This same series suggests that chiropractors can “co-manage” metabolic syndrome, diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obesity, arthritis, osteomalacia, osteopenia, osteoporosis, malnourishment, and depression.
And just look at these amazing results claimed for “upper cervical” chiropractic for any number of conditions. (This is apparently what passes for research among chiropractors.)
This overreach can now be embodied in a binding DPC agreement, obligating the patient to pay a monthly fee to a provider not qualified to perform the covered services or offering treatments that confer no benefit and possible harm. The Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA) has drafted a form DPC agreement for its members (one I’d love to see but have not been able to get my hands on). It’s already caused one kerfuffle: The Florida Chiropractic Physician Association was busted for pirating the FCA’s form, which did not sit well with the FCA, legal action being threatened.
Alabama’s Governor signed a bill allowing chiropractors to enter into what is called a “direct payment agreement” with patients, avoiding the term “primary care”. However, these agreements have their own problems, permitting chiropractors to contract with patients to provide so-called “wellness care” or “maintenance care“, that is, regular spinal “adjustments” to rid the body of putative subluxations, although (unsurprisingly) it has never been shown this routine “maintenance” improves health.
Taxpayer-funded DC as PCP
Currently, Medicare covers “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation as demonstrated to exist,” meaning that taxpayers pay millions of dollars annually for chiropractors to find and treat a condition that, in fact, does not exist. Not only that, a number of federal probes into overpayments to chiropractors have found that chiropractors regularly, and illegally, bill Medicare for what investigators later determine is “maintenance care”, which is not covered by Medicare.
To exacerbate the problem, Rep. Erik Paulsen (R-MN) has introduced H.R. 7157 in Congress. It will amend the Medicare law to cover not only phantom subluxations, but also
all physicians’ services furnished by doctors of chiropractic within the scope of their license.
Presumably as a sweetener for passage, and allegedly to help solve the huge overpayment problem, chiropractors whose billings are “aberrant” are excluded from this coverage.
So, in exchange for punishing “aberrant” chiropractors, Rep. Paulsen wants to dump every diagnostic method and treatment allowed chiropractors under state law into Medicare coverage and let taxpayers pick up the tab. Surely the U.S. Treasury would come out much better by simply continuing to pay the “aberrant” chiropractors for maintenance care.
Fortunately, H.R. 7157 has no co-sponsors, Congress is (to put it mildly) otherwise engaged, and time is running out. Even the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), which launched an all-out campaign promoting the bill, admits its chances are nil. As the ACA makes clear, however, they plan to be back in the next Congress with a new bill.
Finally, puppies
In addition to scamming patients by convincing them they are afflicted with illusory subluxations, chiropractors, sometimes in cahoots with “holistic” veterinarians, have ventured into animal chiropractic, convincing pet owners their animals are suffering as well. Reliable evidence that this benefits your pet in any way is notably lacking. This year, Colorado, which previously legalized animal chiropractic, has a new law removing the requirement that the poor creature be cleared by a veterinarian before being subjected to animal chiropractic performed by a chiropractor. The law adds a requirement that the chiropractor undergo a whopping nine hours of course work on contagious, infectious, and zoonotic diseases, plus two hours of continuing education. In better news, bills (Senate Bill 746, House Bill 1911), legalizing the practice of animal chiropractic by veterinarians and chiropractors failed in Missouri.
Legislatures will be cranking open the statehouse doors for new sessions as early as January. You can bet chiropractic lobbyists will be back, promoting bills to expand scope of practice and rebrand DCs as PCPs. We’ll be watching.

Legislative Alchemy 2019: Chiropractors seek scope of practice expansion, including authority to prescribe drugs
In 2019, chiropractors continued their push for practice expansion, including prescription privileges, as well as co-opting the opioid crisis to mandate physician recommendations for “chiropractic care”.
Jann Bellamy on January 30, 2020
Link

In 2019, via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, chiropractors across the nation continued their push for practice expansion as well as their campaign to promote “chiropractic care” (whatever that means) as an alternative to opioids in the treatment of pain, to the point of legal mandates requiring physicians to endorse them.
This legislation should be viewed in the larger context of the ultimate, and partially achieved, goal to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” capable of treating, in the words of the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), “anything a medical doctor can”. The authority to prescribe drugs is a key element of the ACA’s plan. Remember, too, that chiropractors want you to pick up the tab for all of this, in the form of insurance premiums and tax dollars paid to private and publicly-funded insurers required by law to cover anything within the chiropractors’ state scope of practice.
Prescribing
In Florida, chiropractic “physicians” (as they are allowed to call themselves) can recommend and dispense (i.e., sell) dietary supplements* and over-the-counter homeopathic drugs to patients, but they are prohibited from injecting substances like vitamins, minerals and botanicals, as well as homeopathic products, because they lack the authority to prescribe drugs. (If administered by injection, substances that normally constitute dietary supplements, like vitamins and minerals, as well as homeopathic remedies, legally become prescription drugs.)
A bill was introduced lifting this ban by allowing chiropractors to prescribe and administer “articles of natural origin” (which has no legal definition), including vitamins, minerals, enzymes, antioxidants, botanicals, glandulars,** and homeopathic remedies. If passed, chiropractors would have been able to administer all of these substances by injection, including via IV, thereby allowing them to, for example, plug their patients with Myer’s cocktails as well as other “articles of natural origin” mixed up for them by a compounding pharmacy.
Expanded privileges would also include the drug Armor Thyroid, a prescription form of a pig thyroid extract (a glandular) used to treat hypothyroidism. In addition, the bill would have allowed chiropractors to prescribe and administer “cellular components”, a broad term that presumably includes stem cell therapies, granting them entrée into the lucrative stem cell clinic market without having to hire a medical doctor.
This vast expansion of their scope of practice would be allowed after a mere 36 hours of training. Fortunately, the bill didn’t pass. In fact, it didn’t even get a committee hearing and was eventually withdrawn from consideration.
Several years ago, New Mexico created the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician” who could, after 90 hours of education and training, prescribe and administer certain substances by injection if approved by the pharmacy and medical boards. In 2019, House and Senate bills were introduced to expand those privileges, eliminating the requirement that the pharmacy and medical boards approve some substances (like live cells, bioidentical hormones, and homeopathic remedies) for injection and allowing the administration of prescription drugs in any form, not just injection, although some would still need pharmacy and medical board approval. Fortunately, the bills failed.
More scope of practice expansion
One way to sneak in the back door of primary care practice is getting the authority to perform certain examinations, like school and sports physicals, or return student athletes to play after a concussion, despite the fact that chiropractors are not properly educated and trained for any of this.
Nevertheless, a 2019 bill remains pending in Illinois that would add “chiropractic physician” to the definition of “physician” in a law addressing student athletes and concussions, thereby allowing chiropractors to remove a student from play if a concussion is suspected and return the student to play after examination and treatment. In Connecticut, a bill allowing chiropractors to clear student athletes for participation in athletic activities after a concussion failed.
Companion bills have been introduced, and are still pending, in the New York Assembly and Senate to “modernize”, which actually means “greatly expand”, the chiropractic scope of practice, currently fairly narrow. Instead of detecting and correcting the phantom “subluxation” to remove “nerve interference” (although still allowed), chiropractors could call themselves “chiropractic doctors” and “chiropractic physicians”, and could examine patients for, among other things, clearance for school sports participation and school attendance. They could also “give patients consultation, advice, recommendations, and counseling” regarding anatomy, physiology, neurology, general health matters, wellness, and “health optimization”.
If approved by the state education department (not the state chiropractic board, which acts in an advisory capacity only), the bills would expand the use of diagnostic testing beyond X-rays to include other ionizing and non-ionizing imaging methods, clinical laboratory testing, and electrodiagnostic testing. Chiropractors could also provide “wellness care” (which is undefined in the bills), nutritional counseling, and dietary advice including (of course!) dispensing dietary supplements. The reduction of dislocations and manipulation under anesthesia are added to the scope of practice. In addition, the one medical doctor on the state board of chiropractic would be removed.
Interestingly, New York’s narrow scope of practice and regulation by the state department of education (as opposed to a chiropractor-controlled regulatory board) appears to have a laudable limiting effect on chiropractors’ foraying into so-called “chiropractic medicine” and “functional medicine“. The Institute for Functional Medicine’s proprietary courses allow chiropractors to become “certified” in functional medicine, but the state of New York is having none of it. The department does not allow continuing education credit for courses in functional medicine and considers functional medicine beyond the scope of chiropractic practice. It also currently limits the scope of nutritional advice chiropractors can give patients. Notably, the American Chiropractic Association’s list of “chiropractic internists” does not include any New York chiropractors, presumably because their scope of practice does not include the lab tests and broad-scope dietary supplement and homeopathic drug dispensing this “specialty” requires.
A bill introduced in Texas would have expanded the scope of practice for chiropractors from treatment of the musculoskeletal system to the “neuromusculoskeletal” system, giving chiropractors the authority to treat conditions of the nervous system. The bill was defeated with vigorous opposition from the Texas Medical Association, including legislative testimony from an Austin neurologist, who pointed out that
Adding the term “neuro” is not merely the addition of the nerves that may connect muscle tissue, or bones. It is the addition of the entire neurological system that includes the brain, spinal cord, and the regulation of many bodily functions beyond chiropractors’ education and training.
Regrettably, chiropractors in other jurisdictions do have the legal authority, if not the actual education and training, to treat disorders of the nervous system, to the point of manufacturing the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic neurology,” which SBM’s Dr. Steve Novella, himself a neurologist, has described as “rank pseudoscience“.
Finally, in Nevada, “dry needling” was added to the chiropractic scope of practice, while in Texas a bill was defeated which would have allowed chiropractors who had completed an acupuncture course to treat patients with acupuncture.
Co-opting the opioid epidemic to promote “chiropractic care”
Pennsylvania’s House Resolution 597, passed in 2019, is a master class in co-opting the opioid crisis for promotion of “chiropractic care”. After several paragraphs of scary stats on opioid abuse, the Resolution notes that “numerous published studies . . . document spinal manipulation as effective for the management of low back pain”. Thus, the House resolves to
raise public awareness that chiropractic care is the primary first-line, nonpharmacological approach to safely and effectively relieve acute, sub-acute and chronic pain.
See what they did there? The effectiveness of spinal manipulation for low back pain, a manual therapy also provided by physical therapists and physicians, magically becomes a prescription for “chiropractic care”, a nebulous term that can include all sorts of pseudoscience (subluxation detection and correction, dubious nutritional advice, unvalidated testing, and homeopathy, to name a few) which is “the” (not “a”) “primary first-line” method (not a choice among several of equal or greater merit) to “safely and effectively” (no evidence cited) treat all pain, whatever its origin (ditto for no evidence). Fortunately, this Resolution carries zero weight as legal authority, but does make for some good chiropractic PR.
As part of this continuing effort to sell chiropractic as an non-opioid alternatives in the treatment of pain, a bill was introduced, but did not pass, in Connecticut, “to encourage the treatment of chronic pain without the use of opioid drugs and in accordance with the treatment provided by chiropractors” although no details are given regarding exactly how this encouragement would be executed and by whom.
Tennessee law requires physicians to discuss “reasonable” alternatives to opioids for the patient’s condition and the benefits and risks of those alternative treatments. In another incident of co-opting the opioid crisis, the Tennessee legislature amended this law by defining “alternative treatments” as including, but not limited to:
treatments such as chiropractic care, physical therapy, acupuncture, and other such treatments that relieve pain without the use of opioids.
Hopefully, the adjective “reasonable” leaves some discretion in the hands of the physician who believes “chiropractic care” (and acupuncture, for that matter), are not appropriate for the patient because of lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness for the patient’s condition and the risk of subjecting the patient to pseudoscientific diagnoses and treatments.
That discretion is unavailable in Florida, where the legislature passed a bill requiring physicians to endorse chiropractic, acupuncture, and massage as non-opioid alternatives to pain, even if the physician disagrees with that advice.
Animal chiropractic
In Arkansas, chiropractors “certified by the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association” had to “perform chiropractic” on animals under the direct supervision of a licensed veterinarian. The supervision requirement was eliminated in 2019, passing unanimously in both the House and Senate. Animal chiropractic is based on the notion that animals, like humans, suffer from the chiropractic “subluxation” and require “adjustments”, which is just as nonsensical in veterinary medicine as it is in human medicine. Because it is permissible to ignore science (even basic anatomy) in veterinary chiropractic, other pseudoscientific practices, like applied kinesiology and craniosacral therapy have crept in.
Thankfully, a bill adding animal chiropractic to the scope of practice of both veterinarians and chiropractors failed in Missouri.
Finally, falling into no particular category, yet speaking volumes, the Idaho Board of Chiropractic Physicians convinced the state legislature that its peer review process, which is intended to “to review the appropriateness, quality, utilization and costs of chiropractic services”, was “unnecessary” and got the legislature to pass a bill (HB 0005) eliminating peer review.

Notes:
*A 2017 review of studies of chiropractic practice revealed that almost a third of chiropractic patients are treated with nutritional supplements. This seems an extraordinary number given the lack of evidence of effectiveness for supplements.
**Glandular extracts come from the hormone-producing glands of animals and contain dried and ground-up raw animal glandular tissues from the thyroid, thymus, adrenals, pituitary, ovaries, testis, and pancreas. As long as they are taken orally and are not marketed for the treatment of disease, they can be sold as dietary supplements. They are pushed by chiropractors and others without medical training for “adrenal insufficiency” and other “hormonal imbalances”. Even Dr. Weil admits they are a waste of money at best and, at worst, dangerous.

The Exciting Conclusion
Jann Bellamy on December 26, 2013
Link
On the slim chance that you’ve been perched on the edge of your seat wondering how the New Mexico appellate court ruled on chiropractic prescription privileges, whether the Council on Chiropractic Education got approved for another three years as an accrediting agency, if NCCAM ever came clean about spinal manipulation, and the fate of Brandon Babcock, DC, at the hands of the judicial system, here are your updates.
Prescription privileges for New Mexico chiropractors
A surprisingly titillating tidbit about New Mexico “advanced practice” chiropractors.
As discussed in previous posts, New Mexico “advanced practice” chiropractors succeeded in getting limited prescription rights. The statute specifically says they can:
prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicines, homeopathic medicines, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen, epinephrine and vapocoolants.
However,
Dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed [above] shall be submitted to the board of pharmacy and the New Mexico medical board for approval.
Apparently, the Chiropractic board couldn’t read the plain language of the statute and blew off this requirement, even though their own lawyer told them they couldn’t. This got them hauled into court by the medical and pharmacy boards. The International Chiropractors Association joined the fight.
The New Mexico Court of Appeals has now ruled unanimously that the chiropractors violated the statute in failing to get the required approval. This means they can’t inject any of the substances listed above because delivery by injection automatically kicks these products into the drug category.
The chiropractors remain undeterred. They attempted to get the legislature to broaden prescription rights this year, including controlled substances, but failed. At the heart of this effort is Bill Doggett, DC, who is committed to primary care physician status and full prescription rights for chiropractors. He was also instrumental in getting the limited prescription rights chiropractors now enjoy.
Let’s see what Doggett has in mind in the way of PCP practice and prescription rights if he eventually gets his way with the legislature. Back before the Court of Appeals quashed his hopes, Doggett planned to begin offering a procedure to regenerate healthy vaginal tissue. As quoted in an on-line article from the Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation subtitled “[Doggett] Says Chiropractors There [in NM] Are Already Providing Gynecological Exams”), Doggett stated:
It’s actually a PRP (plasma rich protein) procedure that DC’s in NM will be able to do when they settle the ICA suit. Using a proprietary technique, the growth factors in platelet-rich plasma (PRP) are extracted from that blood sample and injected into an area near the clitoris and into a the [sic] area of the upper vagina that is most important for the sexual response (the O-Spot) using a patent-pending procedure. Because these areas have been numbed with a local anesthetic cream, patients experience little or no discomfort during the procedure.
To be fair, Doggett isn’t the only health care provider pushing this procedure. It is being promoted by a group of MDs who will train physicians and nurse practitioners to use their system. (Also available, the Vampire facelift.) Best I can from the website, which has a soft-porn quality to it, there has never been a clinical trial of the O-Spot technique. Did Doggett complete the O-Spot training? I don’t know, but a search for his name does not show up in their list of providers.
Council on Chiropractic Education will probably get another three years
In my last post we looked at the battle among various chiropractic factions over continued recognition of the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) as the accrediting agency for chiropractic schools. According to a press release from the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) has voted to continue the CCE’s recognition for another three years. Significantly, there were three dissenting votes. The NACIQI is an advisory body and the final call is up to the US Department of Education.
According to the ICA, there were a “large number of witnesses” at the December 12th hearing, including 18 students and more than a dozen private practitioners. “The majority of those speaking expressed deep and well-documented issues and concerns with the CCE’s standards, policies and procedures and highlighted the degree to which division over the direction of the CCE has come to dominate debate within the chiropractic profession.”
If the CCE’s recognition is continued by the Department of Education, the battle is hardly over. The ICA vows to “hold the CCE accountable to their pledge on governance reform negotiations.” And no doubt the rest of the dissidents will be holding the ICA accountable on its pledge to hold the CCE accountable. We’ll be watching.
NCCAM still manipulates spinal manipulation
Over a year ago, the post “NCCAM manipulates spinal manipulation” decried the misinformation about spinal manipulation and chiropractic on NCCAM’s website. The main criticism was that the information rests on the false assumption that chiropractors always use spinal manipulation for the same purposes as other health care practitioners. NCCAM’s discussion failed to tell consumers that chiropractors may purport to “detect” subluxations and use spinal manipulation to “correct” these subluxations. NCCAM also presents only the chiropractic view of the risk of cervical artery dissection following neck manipulation. Finally, it naively assumes that chiropractors who “specialize” have adequate education and training in these “specialties” and that they will appropriately prescribe dietary supplements, including having sufficient knowledge of supplement-prescription drug interaction. In other words, NCCAM does an extremely poor job of applying its supposedly “rigorous” research standards to the subject of chiropractic.
Well, they can’t say they didn’t know better, because after the post appeared I told them. Here’s the rather mealy-mouthed response I got:
Dear Ms. Bellamy:
Thank you for your e-mail to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) about your blog post commenting on our Center’s spinal manipulation and chiropractic information.
We appreciate your thoughtful input on our information. We will keep your comments on file for future reference when we next update our content on these practices. Our goal is to produce accurate and informative publications, so we routinely review and update the information on our Web site.
To develop our materials, we use information from a wide range of science-based resources, which include peer-reviewed journals from PubMed, Federal Government Web sites, and subscription databases. Then our publications go through a review process, which includes reviews by experts in the field. We list at the end of each publication the references that we used to develop it.
Thank you for taking the time to write to us.
Sincerely yours,
Terry EvansNCCAM Clearinghouse
I don’t know what NCCAM’s definition of “routinely review and update” is, but it apparently does not fall within the parameters of (almost) two years. The last update of the article on chiropractic was in February, 2012, and my complaint (the post was in July, 2012) did not inspire them to take a second look at their information. The spinal manipulation article was updated this year, but simply perpetuates the same misinformation. So much for NCCAM’s promise to “maintain a strong commitment to providing objective and authoritative evidence-based information to the public and health care professionals.”
Functional Endocrinology practitioner Brandon Babcock sentenced
In “CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update,” we reported that Utah chiropractor Brandon Babcock was going to trial on 11 felony charges related to his functional endocrinology practice. He faced up to 30 years in prison if convicted. Babcock was found guilty of six counts of exploiting the elderly in October and was sentenced in early December to six months in jail.
Babcock lured patients with free “gourmet dinners” at which he pitched his “diabetes breakthrough.” Then, without their knowledge or consent, he signed them up for a credit scheme to finance their bogus treatments. It is not clear from the news story how much of the exploitation charges had to do with the financial shenanigans and how much had to do with his practice of functional endocrinology.
Over in Colorado, the medical board’s order to cease and desist directed against Babcock’s fellow chiropractor and functional endocrinology practitioner Brandon Credeur is, as best I can tell, still in effect. The medical board charged Credeur with practicing medicine without a license after he received a very light slap on the wrist from the chiropractic board. His Functional Endocrinology of Colorado website is still up.
Apparently chiropractors remain undeterred by these events. Within the last couple of months a chiropractor came through Tallahassee offering a free dinner and talk on the wonders of Functional Endocrinology for diabetes. I thought about going but just couldn’t stomach the idea.
Happy New Year!
If your New Year’s Eve plans include a free gourmet dinner make sure you know who’s picking up the tab. Whatever you do, have a safe and CAM-free evening.

Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way!
Harriet Hall on April 24, 2012
Link
A recent three-part article published in ACA News advocates turning chiropractors into “conservative primary care providers” who would be the initial point of contact for patients, would serve as gatekeepers for referrals to medical doctors and specialists, and would co-manage patients with those specialists on a continuing basis: essentially, family doctors. I think that’s a terrible idea. It might benefit chiropractors by increasing their market share, but it wouldn’t benefit patients. There is no evidence to indicate that chiropractors are capable of filling that role effectively or safely.
NUHS. The article was co-authored by several chiropractors on the faculty of the National University of Health Sciences, a school noted for integrating quackery with medicine. The “sciences” this school teaches are listed at the top of its website: chiropractic medicine, naturopathic medicine, oriental medicine, acupuncture, biomedical science, and massage therapy. The only one of those that even sounds like science, “biomedical science,” offers a bachelor of science degree with an integrative medicine focus and with no required core courses whatsoever!
Their doctor of chiropractic degree program says:
National University prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of conditions.
Background. The authors say proposals to classify chiropractors as primary care physicians date back to at least 1967, with the Comprehensive Health Planning Councils. Arguably, the concept of chiropractors providing comprehensive health care dates back to the origin of chiropractic, since its founder asserted that all human disease was attributable to subluxations, 95% in the spine and 5% elsewhere. On the other hand, chiropractors used to claim they didn’t diagnose or treat illness, but only kept the spine in proper alignment so that the vitalistic force they called “Innate” could take care of anything and everything. In essence, doesn’t their aspiration to become “family doctors” amount to an admission that chiropractic is not the panacea they once held it to be? Doesn’t their wish to branch out demonstrate the failure of their discipline?
Their Arguments. They argue that more primary care providers are needed, and that chiropractors can fill the gap. They argue that using chiropractors as gatekeepers will reduce costs.
When chiropractic physicians functioned as primary care gatekeepers, pharmaceutical costs fell by 58.1 percent and hospital admissions by 43 percent. These are statistics that clearly support the value of the chiropractic physician in the primary care, gatekeeper position.
These statistics, even if correct, do not support the value of the chiropractor as gatekeeper. Cheaper is not better if it reduces quality of care. Of course pharmaceutical costs went down, because chiropractors can’t prescribe pharmaceuticals and they typically discourage patients from using them. They discourage surgery and conventional medical care, so it’s not surprising that hospital admissions fell; but maybe some of those patients would have been better off in the hospital. And I would guess that vaccination costs dropped too, since only around half of chiropractors support vaccination. We need to know the health outcomes for those patients, not just how much money was saved. Parents who belong to faith healing cults and never take their children to a doctor can cut medical costs to zero, but sometimes the children die.
Apart from the question of costs, the ability of chiropractors to function effectively as gatekeepers has not been tested in any formal study. It is questionable, to say the least. There is anecdotal evidence that occasionally a chiropractor makes a diagnosis that MDs have missed and that many chiropractors refer appropriately, but there is at least as much anecdotal evidence that chiropractors have missed diagnoses that would be obvious to any MD, and that they have failed to send patients to the emergency room for medical emergencies such as classic heart attack symptoms or fevers in very young infants.
They recognize that not all chiropractors are willing or able to carry out their vision:
Among the challenges is the diversity of our colleagues—those wanting to participate in primary care who order technical diagnostic procedures and clinical laboratory tests versus those who want to remain subluxation based. There are those who want to treat the whole person versus those who want to treat only musculoskeletal conditions. There are those of us who want to use treatment modalities beyond the adjustment, as well as those who feel we should adjust only the spine.
Managing Chronic Disease
“Conservative primary care physician” is language intended to clarify that as chiropractic physicians we do not address the complex primary care disease states that require pharmaceutical intervention and management.
Unfortunately, many do. I am increasingly hearing about chiropractors who profess to cure diabetes. They call themselves “doctors” and many of their patients don’t realize they are seeing chiropractors.
Chiropractors aspire to being part of a health care team, managing musculoskeletal problems and “co-managing” chronic diseases by counseling on lifestyle, diet, and exercise. They want to manage psychosocial issues such as anxiety and depression, and they want to use preventive management strategies to reduce the incidence of cancer and dementia. They want to. But that doesn’t mean they can.
A Primer on the History and Physical. After saying in part 1 that chiropractors should provide primary care, they proceed in part 2 to a primer on how to take a history. The fact that they feel a need to explain this implies that chiropractors don’t already understand the basic principles. They proceed to explain how to ask about chief complaint, history of present illness, past medical history, family history, social history, and review of systems. They even feel a need to explicitly remind chiropractors to ask if the patient smokes!
Even their attempt to instruct chiropractors is flawed. For instance, they recommend simple lab tests, but their recommendations for sedimentation rates and CRP testing are not evidence-based and do not correspond to standard medical practice.
In part 3, they describe an office visit and comprehensive physical exam in great detail, with many recommendations that are non-standard and not evidence-based:
    • Routine pulse oximeter readings on every patient. (This may be routine in the ER, but it is not and should not be a routine part of every visit to a doctor’s office.)
    • If any vital signs are abnormal, instead of taking prompt and appropriate action, they recommend that “they should be tracked on a regular basis to determine if a specialist consultation and/or further medical intervention is needed.”
    • For trauma patients, they recommend assessing the patient’s short and long term memory and considering a mini-mental status test. (For most trauma patients this would be a waste of time.)
    • As part of the chest exam, they recommend testing tactile fremitus. Abnormal tactile fremitus is a sign of lung consolidation in patients with pneumonia. It is only appropriate as part of a directed physical to pin down a suspected diagnosis, and even then it is not a particularly useful test. It’s one of those things doctors learned in medical school but rarely if ever use in practice because there are far better ways to make the diagnosis.
    • “The role of testing for H. pylori infection in GERD (gastrointestinal reflux disease) remains controversial.” No, it doesn’t. There’s no controversy: there’s a clear consensus that such testing is not indicated. Some patients can be treated on the basis of symptoms alone; others will need endoscopy. H. pylori testing is done for suspected ulcers, not for GERD.
What really surprised me was their extensive coverage of the musculoskeletal exam. This is their particular area of expertise; surely chiropractors don’t need to be reminded about how to evaluate joint motion, muscle strength, and tender points. They ask “Is there any indication that the patient would be at increased risk for spinal manipulation of the neck?” It seems they recognize that neck manipulation can precipitate a stroke; unfortunately, there is no reliable way to rule out risk, and implying that chiropractors can do so is misleading and dangerous.
This whole exercise struck me as silly, condescending, and embarrassing. If chiropractors were already qualified to be primary care providers, they wouldn’t need to be given this information. If they are not qualified, a simplistic tutorial like this isn’t enough to educate them.
Legislation and Other Developments. Legislation has been proposed to expand the scope of chiropractic and even to authorize limited prescribing privileges. Government programs and insurance companies are considering expanding reimbursement policies. In some places chiropractors are authorized to do sports physicals as well as drug testing and DOT physicals for commercial drivers licenses. National University is even offering what they call a family practice residency.
Other Non-MDs Do It. It could be argued that other non-MD providers carry out primary care and gatekeeper functions. Physician assistants are one example whose training equips them to do the job well. My main concerns about chiropractors assuming these functions are:
    • Their thought processes and clinical judgment have developed in the context of a discipline that was originally based on erroneous ideas and that is still lacking in scientific rigor. (These authors still speak of the “subluxation.”)
    • Their training has not exposed them to seriously ill, hospitalized patients, which I think is essential to developing judgment about situations requiring emergency care or referral.
    • Many chiropractors espouse nonsensical tests and treatments. Just one example: according to an American Chiropractic Association survey, an appalling 38% of US chiropractors use applied kinesiology, one of the most ridiculous travesties in all of alternative medicine.
    • Patients under the care of chiropractors are less likely to get vaccinations; only around half of chiropractors recommend them.
    • Chiropractors should not be treating children, but many do so.
Bottom line: Some chiropractors are family doctor wannabes, but they are not equipped to fill that role.

The DC as PCP? Revisited
Jann BellamyonSeptember 6, 2012
Link
There is a disturbing effort afoot to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians, a subject both Harriet Hall and I have discussed in previous posts. Part of this effort includes convincing state legislatures to grant prescription privileges to chiropractors, an effort that succeeded in New Mexico, as reported in a post a couple of years ago. Let’s return to New Mexico and see how that is working out for everyone.
By way of background, in 2008, the New Mexico legislature created a new iteration of chiropractor called “certified advanced practice chiropractic physicians” with the authority to
prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicine, homeopathic medicines, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, naturally derived substances, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen, epinephrine and vapocoolants.
As those familiar with primary care will no doubt be aware, these aren’t exactly the type of thing the family practice doctor, pediatrician or internist would consider essential tools of practice.
The chiropractic formulary expands
The statute directed the Board of Chiropractic Examiners to develop a formulary for these substances but it had to be approved by the NM Medical Board and Board of Pharmacy. As might be expected, however, chiropractors wanted more expansive prescriptive authority and succeeded in getting it from the legislature in a subsequent amendment to the original law. This amendment eliminated the approval requirement for the listed substances and added the authority to prescribe “dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed” in the statute but only with approval from the medical and pharmacy boards.
This “advanced practice” status can be achieved with only 90 hours of education with whatever additional training the chiropractic board deems necessary for new substances it might want to add to the formulary. These hours can be obtained in weekend and online continuing education courses.
It didn’t take long for the chiropractors to clash with the pharmacy and medical boards over what should be included in the newly expanded formulary. (The details of this clash are chronicled, with supporting exhibits, in this document filed in the New Mexico Court of Appeals.) In September, 2009, the chiropractic board adopted a formulary which including certain drugs to be administered by injection which had not been approved by those boards. The pharmacy board appealed the chiropractic formulary to the New Mexico Court of Appeals. Later that month, representatives of the three boards ironed out their differences and a new formulary was put into place, to be effective in July, 2010.
In spite of this agreement, the chiropractic board nevertheless voted again, in June, 2010, to include in the formulary certain drugs to be administered by injection without getting the required approval. Although the chronology of events is not entirely clear, apparently the chiropractic board was about to add even more drugs for injection and dangerous drugs to the formulary in August of 2011. It will likely come as no surprise to anyone that the proposed formulary included the decidedly fringe practices of chelation therapy and prolotherapy. It also included glucosamine, which has not been approved by the FDA for medical use in humans, by injection. As well, it included a number of vitamins and minerals by injection, muscle relaxants (including metaxalone and baclofen), and glutathione for inhalation, an unproven remedy for pulmonary diseases.
Medical Board objections
At this point the medical board stepped in with a strongly worded letter to the chiropractic board stating it had voted not to approve the proposed formulary changes and set forth the reasons why. In addition to the problems noted above, the medical board complained that
    • New drugs have been added which have not been approved by the pharmacy board.
    • Drugs have been specified for injection which are not within the scope of practice of chiropractic.
    • Drugs were added without stating their intended use.
    • Additional hours of training specified by the chiropractic board do not appear to be sufficient.
The medical board also objected that no mention was made of a restriction previously agreed upon by the medical and chiropractic boards, which provided:
The patient must first be screened, by appropriate medical and laboratory means, for existing problems and contra-indications (such as renal or other diseases). Appropriate coordination with the patient’s allopathic or osteopathic physician is strongly recommended.
In another report, the medical board (here referred to as the NMMB) also said that
In February 2010, after a thorough review of the proposed chiropractic formulary and educational criteria, the NMMB adopted the position that they could not approve either the proposed drugs, or the proposed routes and dosages of administration or their safety and effectiveness. MDs and DOs would never use many of the proposed substances, especially in the manner which the chiropractors proposed for their use. . . . The NMMB also did not approve administration of dangerous drugs or controlled substances by the Advanced Practice Chiropractors based on the lack of sufficient, appropriate education, specific clinical training, and hands-on experience . . . .
So what did the chiropractic board do? Although it did drop chelation therapy, it went ahead with most of the formulary (including prolotherapy and glucosomine injections) without medical or pharmacy board approval. And it did so even though the general counsel for the New Mexico Department of Licensing and Regulation advised against approval. The attorney sat there at the meeting and specifically told the board they shouldn’t approve the formulary because no medical or pharmacy board approval had been obtained and that it was outside the scope of statutory authority granted the chiropractic board by the legislature.
At this point, the pharmacy board, this time with the medical board, went back to the New Mexico Court of Appeals seeking a stay of implementation of the new formulary. The International Chiropractic Association (ICA) filed its own action also seeking a stay. In February of this year, the Court of Appeals granted the ICA’s and boards’ motions, and stayed implementation of the 2011 formulary. These cases remain pending before the Court for a determination whether the chiropractic board exceeded its statutory authority in enacting these rules. It’s hard to imagine any reason why the Court wouldn’t strike down the challenged rules for good.
Meanwhile, back in the legislature . . .
Apparently New Mexico chiropractors determined that a more direct approach was necessary toward the goal of rebranding chiropractors as primary care physicians, with the full scope of practice that entails. So, in 2011, a sympathetic legislator, Ben Lujan, introduced a bill into the New Mexico House of Representatives. The bill’s aim was to increase substantially the scope of chiropractic practice, which was renamed “chiropractic medicine.” In addition to “locating and removing . . . misalignments or subluxations” the bill would expand “chiropractic medicine” to include “diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained. . . .” And who would make the decision whether the chiropractor had been “educated and trained” to treat a “condition?” The New Mexico chiropractic board.
I have to ask: doesn’t this seem awfully cumbersome? How would the chiropractic board decide whether a particular chiropractor has been sufficiently educated and trained to diagnose or treat a particular condition? I’m no doctor, but it is my understanding that there are lots and lots of conditions. (Thousands, maybe?) Is the board going to keep a list of all of them along with the training necessary to diagnose and treat each one?
Under the bill, practitioners of “chiropractic medicine” would also be allowed to use invasive diagnostic procedures, and, if permitted by chiropractic board rule, perform operative surgery, prescribe or use controlled or dangerous drugs, and practice acupuncture.
The “chiropractic advanced practice” status was retained, again only requiring 90 hours of additional education and training, the adequacy of which was solely within the purview of the chiropractic board. With board approval, the advance practice chiropractor could prescribe and administer
any dangerous drug or controlled substance and perform and procedure that is accepted for use within the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician’s clinical specialty and for which the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician can demonstrate appropriate clinical education and hands-on training that has been approved by a nationally recognized credentialing agency or nationally recognized institution of higher learning.
No standards were imposed to determine exactly how a “clinical specialty” would be defined or what constituted a “nationally recognized credentialing agency” or “institution of learning,” leaving those determinations solely in the hands of the chiropractic board. And gone were the pesky medical and pharmacy boards. From now on, the formulary would be determined solely by the chiropractic board.
In short, the proposed statute would empower the New Mexico chiropractic board to decide when and under what circumstances any chiropractor could perform surgery and prescribe controlled substances or dangerous drugs. I say “any chiropractor” because, although the bill retained the “chiropractic advanced practice” status, it did not limit the board’s ability to allow surgery and drug prescribing authority to that status. It would also allow chiropractors to immediately start using invasive diagnostic procedures. And it would permit some vague “clinical specialty” designations by advanced practice chiropractors.
And here’s the really scary part – this bill came very close to passing. With some amendments upping the hours of training, it passed the New Mexico House of Representatives. It was finally stopped in the Senate Judiciary Committee, mostly due to a massive lobbying effort by the ICA and other chiropractors who didn’t want these changes. According to one chiropractic publication, a spokesperson for the New Mexico Medical Board testified before the legislature that the Board did not oppose the bill. If true, this position is at odds with a legislative committee report, which noted that the Board had several objections to the bill. Among those was the misleading nature of the terms “chiropractic physician” and “chiropractic medicine.”
A national movement?
Unfortunately, this ill-advised attempt to transform chiropractors into primary care physicians with prescriptive authority is not limited to New Mexico. That this may be a national effort is hinted at in the Council on Chiropractic Education’s (CCE) removing the standard phrase “without drugs or surgery” from its description of chiropractic practice. (The CCE is the national accrediting agency for chiropractic schools.) This effort is also reflected in recent changes to the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Board’s new draft Model Practice Act for chiropractic and petitions to the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners to develop a “chiropractic advanced practice” exam.
There is a small national association of chiropractors, the First Chiropractic Physician Association of America (FCPAA), devoted to
expanding your rights as a primary care physician with full prescriptive rights and the ability to specialize you can increase your knowledge and your ‘bag of tools.’ It all adds up so you could offer more services to the public.
(Emphasis added.)
The FCPPA has 11 affiliated state organizations working toward its goal of passing legislation to accomplish this. Perhaps the reason for this movement is best summed up by one affiliate, the Florida Chiropractic Physician Association:
Aren’t you tired of worrying where your next patient will come from? Expansion means prosperity for you and better health for your patients.
Last year, the Alabama Board of Chiropractic Examiners proposed legislation (not yet introduced) which would allow that board to authorize prescribing of certain legend drugs without any additional education or training. It would expand the scope of practice to include any procedure or service taught in a chiropractic college or in courses sponsored by a chiropractic college, leaving the scope virtually open-ended.
Conclusion
The attempt to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians is bad enough, but giving them the legal authority to prescribe is beyond the pale. New Mexico’s ill-conceived legislation has turned into a debacle, with the pharmacy and medical boards having to haul the chiropractic board into court to comply with the law. And once they got limited privileges, chiropractors lobbied for increasing privileges to the point of wanting to prescribe controlled substances and dangerous drugs without any oversight and the right to practice surgery to boot. If you think this can’t happen in your state, think again. Remember that chiropractors got all 50 state legislatures to grant them the privilege of “detecting” and “correcting” the imaginary “subluxation.”

The DC as PCP? The battle continues
Jann Bellamy on January 24, 2013
Link
Chiropractors are trying to rebrand themselves as primary care physicians, a topic both Harriet Hall and I have addressed (here and here) on SBM. Toward this end, they are seeking the expansion of their scope of practice, via the magic of legislative alchemy, to include the prescription and administration of drugs. Not drugs that any self-respecting M.D. would use, but drugs nonetheless. That effort succeeded to an extent in New Mexico. Recently Colorado got into the act. Other states have followed suit.
Chiropractors have claimed from the very beginning they are primary care physicians. Chiropractic was born in 1895 with the notion that virtually all diseases could be resolved with chiropractic treatment. This was Daniel David Palmer’s original contention, that the interruption of “nerve flow” by “subluxations” caused disease which could be remedied by spinal adjustment to restore the flow, thereby allowing the body to heal itself.
State chiropractic practice acts have always given chiropractors a broad scope of practice which allows them to diagnose and treat virtually any condition as long as they can squeeze the treatment into the “chiropractic paradigm.” If they can pretend the condition is amenable to chiropractic treatment via the detection and correction of subluxations, they can diagnose and treat it legally. This is how they are able to claim, falsely, that asthma, allergies, colic, and many other health problems can be resolved by chiropractic care. This is how “straight” chiropractors still practice.

Over time, to the chagrin of the “straights,” “mixer” chiropractors sought to expand their treatment options. They’ve succeeded in all 50 states to some extent. This liberalization of their practice acts includes the right to use acupuncture and to give nutritional advice, including the sale of dietary supplements and homeopathic products. Now some of the mixers want to dump the subluxation altogether and become, by legislative fiat, real primary care doctors who use the same diagnostic methods and treatments as primary care M.D.s and D.O.s, while at the same time skipping the education and training the latter must go through.
Colorado chiropractors attempt an end run . . .
One of the main obstacles in their way is the lack of authority to prescribe drugs. Colorado chiropractors recently attempted an end run around the time-consuming and expensive process of lobbying the state legislature and getting their practice act amended to include prescription privileges. Perhaps they were aware of certain snafus (which we’ll get to soon) bedeviling New Mexico chiropractors in their quest for practice expansion. The Colorado Board of Chiropractic Examiners’ solution was to bypass the legislature altogether by simply passing a rule giving chiropractors the authority to administer and prescribe certain drugs. Never mind the fact that this was totally beyond the authority the Colorado Legislature gave the Board.
Here’s what the Colorado chiropractic practice act says, in part, chiropractors can do, in Section 12-33-102(1.7), Colorado Statutes (emphasis added):
“Chiropractic” means that branch of the healing arts that is based on the premise that disease is attributable to the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system. It includes the diagnosing and analyzing of human ailments and seeks the elimination of the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system by the adjustment or manipulation, by hand or instrument, of the articulations and adjacent tissue of the human body, particularly the spinal column, and the use as indicated of procedures that facilitate the adjustment or manipulation . . .
Up to this point, we are in familiar straight chiropractic territory. The statute goes on, reflecting the more recent addition of “nutritional measures:”
. . . and the use of sanitary, hygienic, nutritional, and physical remedial measures for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health, the prevention of disease, and the treatment of human ailments . . .
Colorado law specifically prohibits chiropractors from prescribing, compounding or administering drugs. Yet, in the phrase “nutritional remedial measures,” the Colorado Board of Chiropractic Examiners found an opening for the inclusion of real drugs in the chiropractic scope of practice. Or so it thought.
In November, 2012, the Board enacted Rule 7(C), which would have gone into effect on January 14, 2013:
Nutritional Remedial Measures as referenced in Section 12-33-102(1), C.R.S., means that a doctor of chiropractic may administer, prescribe, recommend, compound, sell and distribute homeopathic and botanical medicines, vitamins, minerals, phytonutrients, antioxidants, enzymes, glandular extracts, non-prescription drugs, durable and non-durable medical goods and devices.
Administer includes Oral, Topical, Inhalation, and Injection.
However, not just any chiropractor could administer these substances by injection. To do that, the chiropractor must have a “Certification in Injectables,” which can be obtained by, according to the new rule,
Successfully complet[ing] a minimum of a combined total of 24 hours of theoretical study and supervised clinical instruction . . . [and] passing a nationally recognized Injectable certification examination recognized by a CCE [Council on Chiropractic Education] accredited chiropractic college.
No, that is not a typo. It takes only 24 hours of combined instruction to use injectables, including intravenous administration of the listed substances, which are prescription drugs under federal law. (Per federal law, a substance that may be an over-the-counter dietary supplement if taken orally is a prescription drug when injected.) You do have to pass a test, but what does it say about the rigor of this examination if there is a reasonable opportunity to pass it after a 24-hour course?
. . . and get creamed
Rule 7(C) displeased just about everyone. The straight wing of chiropractic saw this move as simply another step on the road to chiropractic ruin, as detailed in a series of articles in The Chronicle of Chiropractic, an on-line publication the Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation. (You’ll need to hold your nose to avoid the smell of the National Vaccine Information Council plug on their website.) On December 5, the Colorado Attorney General issued an opinion that the rule exceeded the scope of authority granted the Board by the legislature.
Under the Colorado Administrative Procedure Act, new rules such as this one are reviewed by the Office of Legislative Legal Services (OLLS) to make sure they are within the Board’s rule making authority. OLLS quickly determined that Rule 7(C) most certainly was not within the Board’s authority and voted 8-0 to ask the legislature to repeal the rule. And on January 8, the Colorado General Assembly’s Committee on Legal Services did just that. It is unclear to me whether this repeals the rule for good, or whether the entire legislature must vote. What is not unclear is that the rule is, for all practical purposes, dead.
The Executive and Legislative branches having weighed in on the subject, the third branch of state government, the Judiciary, was also drawn into the controversy. The Colorado Medical Society and 12 more state and local medical groups sued the Board of Chiropractic Examiners. They sought an injunction against implementation of the rule, also citing the Board’s lack of authority. In addition, according to the complaint, Rule 7(C) is an intrusion into the practice of medicine as defined by statute, which gives M.D.s the authority to prescribe drugs. (Apparently, the medical society is suddenly upset about other groups practicing medicine even though they sat on their hands when naturopaths tried to do the same thing.) The suit remains pending, although I suppose it will be dismissed as moot.
How the Board of Chiropractic Examiners ever thought it could get away with this is beyond me. No doubt chiropractors will try the legislative route next time.
Chiropractic Cardiologists
Before we leave Colorado for its neighbor to the south, one more of the Board’s new rules bears mentioning, as it appears to be an effort at furthering the notion that chiropractors are somehow qualified to be PCPs. Rule 7(B)(3), which is unchallenged, states that “Electrocardiography (EKG/ECG)” is included in the chiropractic scope of practice, if the chiropractor has
One hundred and twenty (120) hours of initial and related clinical with didactic training and demonstrated competency in cardiac medicine.
“A demonstrated competency in cardiac medicine?” The very thought induces angina. No specifics are given for how said “competency” is achieved or what “initial and related clinical with didactic training” consists of. Typical of other chiropractic “specialties,” I suppose this competency is accomplished in weekend courses. Perhaps competency can be achieved by becoming a “Diplomate” of the American Board of Chiropractic Internists (DABCI), although it appears this course would actually over qualify its participants by a large margin. Here’s what an ABCI functionary says about the course, courtesy of the American Chiropractic Association website:
This specialty, says its council president, Cindy Howard, DC, DABCI, FIAMA [Fellow, International Academy of Medical Acupuncture], is essentially the chiropractic version of primary care. “We look at primary care a little bit differently,” she says. “A lot of people look at it in terms of being the first doctor someone comes to. We look at it from the perspective that we want to handle everything: work up the problem, diagnose you, and treat you. Instead of referring you to the ‘proper person,’ we want to be that person.”
Dr. Howard acknowledges that not all cases can be treated by a chiropractic physician, but thanks to the extensive training provided by the DABCI . . . certification, there are many that can. The 26 sessions of 12-hour weekends take three years to complete, followed by a three-part board exam—two written segments and one clinical competency examination.
“We do laboratory workups, blood chemistries, adrenal and hormone testing, GI function studies, EKGs,” says Dr. Howard. “We treat everything from allergies to thyroid problems to fatigue. It makes us more of a family doctor—not in the sense that we always take care of the whole family, but we can take care of all that ails them. I have people come into my office not for neck and back pain, people who don’t get adjusted, because we have other capabilities to treat naturally. If I’m adjusting somebody and not getting them better, [my training] gives me a broader range of things to look at as to what it might be.”
What family practice doctor or internist wouldn’t love to complete his training with “26 sessions of 12 hour weekends” instead of three grueling years of hospital-based residency working 80 hours a week. Let’s see, at 80 hours per week, you could do your whole residency in less than four weeks and avoid all the messiness involved in taking care of people who are really sick. Brilliant!
New Mexico: An update
Meanwhile, in New Mexico, the battle over chiropractic prescribing continues. As reported in a previous post, the legislature amended the chiropractic practice act to create a new iteration of chiropractor, an “advanced practice” version, which takes all of 90 hours of additional training plus passing a test.
The New Mexico Chiropractic Association describes part of this training on its website [capitalization and punctuation as in original]:
Routes of administration [for ‘naturally derived’ substances], of course, are oral, topical and rectal, which we may already do but new to us here are intravenous (IV) and intramuscular (IM) administration. Doctors completing the certification will be prepared to do: IM injections (B12, homeopathic, magnesium, trigger point, etc.), neural therapy injections Intravenous procedures (meyer’s [sic] cocktails, H2O2, chelation, ascorbates, amino acids, minerals, etc.), emergency procedures Laboratory testing and diagnosis.
In other words, a veritable pantry full of quack remedies, now conveniently available via an IV.
Not satisfied with the formulary it had stipulated to with the state’s medical and pharmacy boards, the Board of Chiropractic Examiners, like its compatriots in Colorado, tried an end run around its statutory authority by enacting a new formulary without the required approval of the other boards. This landed the chiropractic board in court, with the medical and pharmacy boards, as well as the International Chiropractors Association, all seeking an injunction against implementation of the formulary. The New Mexico Court of Appeals agreed with the plaintiffs and upheld a stay of the formulary. That proceeding remains pending.
Here’s an update: On September 13, 2012, the aforementioned American Chiropractic Association (ACA), filed an amicus curiae (friend of the court) brief. All the brief really says is that chiropractors, working through their state legislators and regulatory agencies, are best suited to determine their scope of practice. This is an ambiguous statement – if they mean that chiropractors should be the ones to determine what their scope of practice is, that is certainly not true. That is solely up to the legislature, which (at least ideally) takes into account all points of view, not just chiropractors. In any event, it is totally irrelevant to the issue before the court: whether the chiropractic board exceeded its authority, which it most certainly did. Even its own lawyer told the board that.
But the brief does make some interesting, if irrelevant, statements further demonstrating the ACA’s dedication to reinventing D.C.s as PCPs. The ACA actually says that chiropractors’
. . . academic and clinical training is both extensive and exhaustive and is very comparable to the level of the education and training received by medical doctors.
They go on to provide a handy chart which supposedly compares the hours required for a D.C. degree at Western States University with the hours required for a medical degree at Oregon Health Sciences University, along with the names of courses and number of hours. It purports to show that chiropractic students actually spend a few more hours in combined classroom and clinical training (4,896 v. 4,877). Of course, the Council on Chiropractic Education recently got into hot water with the U.S. Department of Education over just how accurate the system of credit hour determinations were among chiropractic colleges. Even without getting into that issue, I don’t know where this chart got its figures as the OHSU medical school curriculum doesn’t look anything like the chart. But you be the judge: Western States D.C. degree (click on “Program Curriculum” pdf) v. Oregon Health Sciences M.D. degree (see links under “Curriculum” in left column). Do you think they are “very comparable?”
The ACA brief totally fails to mention the fact that graduating from medical school is only the beginning for M.D.s. It skips the subject of residency entirely. The brief also describes several “post-graduate” training programs in a variety of “clinical disciplines and specialties,” including Chiropractic Pediatrics, Chiropractic Clinical Neurology (post-graduate training can be had at the “Carrick Institute for Graduate Studies”), and training provided by the American Board of Chiropractic Internists, whose Cindy Howard, D. C., is quoted above.
Before we leave New Mexico, let’s see what one advanced practice chiropractor, Stephen Perlstein, D.C., who was instrumental in getting the advanced practice legislation passed, is offering patients under the formulary currently allowed by law.
Biopuncture
a technique that bioregulates the body’s immune system, meaning that it heals the injury by enabling and enhancing the mechanisms that control inflammation, pain, and tissue regeneration. Biopuncture traditionally uses small needles to inject substances subcutaneously (just under the skin). On occasion, a deeper injection is required. In a single session, single or multiple injections may be necessary to cover the injured area. . . . Substances typically used in Biopuncture are homeopathic medicines, lidocaine or procaine (analgesics), sarapin (a natural pain reliever), and dextrose (an immune stimulant).
Now, you may be thinking this sounds awfully modest for a CAM treatment. Where’s the ubiquitous “one true remedy” claim. It’s right here:
Biopuncture is not only effective for sprain and strain injuries, both new and old, or pain at various joints or parts of the body of indeterminate origin, but is also remarkably effective for the following conditions:
Asthma
Eczema
Hayfever
Bronchitis
Sinusitis
Headache
Colitis
Constipation
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Homeopathic Flu Vaccines
After making misleadingly simplistic statements about the mutation of flu viruses and its effect on flu vaccine effectiveness, Perlstein goes on to make this absurd claim about the homeopathic “flu vaccine:”
These [homeopathic] vaccines also stimulate an immune response to a flu virus, but, unlike the conventional ones which rely on the actual virus itself which has changed, these homeopathic preparations stimulate an immune response designed to strengthen resistance to all flu viral elements, whether last year’s or any other years, making the mutating quality of flu virus irrelevant and not a factor in the effectiveness that conventional flu vaccines demonstrate.
Apparently this guy knows something that “130 national influenza centers in 101 countries [which] conduct year-round surveillance for influenza and study influenza disease trends” as well as five World Health Organization (WHO) Collaborating Centers for Reference and Research on Influenza located in the USA, the UK, Australia, Japan and China, don’t know.
Here we go again
The Arizona Association of Chiropractic has filed an application with the state legislature for an expansion of chiropractic scope of practice to include
the use of natural substances, homeopathic medication and orthomolecular therapy as an opportunity to enhance care for their patients.
According to the petition, these “services” are currently available to chiropractic patients in Oklahoma, Utah, Alaska, Oregon and Idaho, as well as New Mexico and Colorado. Ten other states are in the process of considering legislation.
We’ll return to these unfortunate developments in a future post.

Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy
Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, chiropractic lobbyists are trying to to convince state legislators to expand chiropractic scope of practice so they can rebrand as primary care physicians.
Jann Bellamy on February 16, 2017
Link
New legislative sessions have begun in all but a couple of states. Unfortunately, this means more legislative alchemy (the process by which state legislatures turn pseudoscience and quackery into licensed health care practices) is brewing across the U.S.
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) and the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE), the accrediting agency for chiropractic schools, are pushing the idea that chiropractors are primary care physicians, a topic we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. To carry out their scheme, the ACA, CCE and like-minded chiropractors need to amend the state chiropractic practice acts to broaden their scope of practice so that they are no longer limited to “detecting” and “correcting” the non-existent vertebral subluxation. Today, we look at several bills aiming do just that.
Indiana
In 2015, the ACA announced “Six Key Elements of a Modern Chiropractic Practice Act,” its ideal version of what chiropractors should be allowed to do under state law. They included:
    • “Chiropractic Physician” and “Chiropractic Medicine” as the Regulatory Terms of Licensure.
    • Scope of Practice Determined by Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Education, Training and Experience Obtained Through Appropriately Accredited Institutions.
    • Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for Patient Examination, Diagnosis, Differential Diagnosis and Health Assessment.
    • Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues.
    • Full Authority for the Delivery of Information, Advice, Recommendations and Counseling Regarding General Health Matters, Wellness and Health Optimization.
Indiana defines the practice of chiropractic as the diagnosis and analysis of “any interference with normal nerve transmission and expression” and “the correction thereof by an adjustment . . . of the vertebral column.” In other words, traditional subluxation-based chiropractic.
It is unlikely the average Indiana legislator reading Senate Bill 437 would be aware of the huge expansion in practice scope it portends or its implications for patient care. (I cannot find evidence that the Indiana State Medical Association has taken any position on this legislation.) But if you’ve followed the chiropractic industry for over a decade, as I have, you learn how to read between the lines. Here’s how SB 437 aligns itself with the ACA’s “Six Key Elements.”
“Chiropractic Physician” and “Chiropractic Medicine” as the Regulatory Terms of Licensure.
The bill allows chiropractors to call themselves “chiropractic physicians.”
Scope of Practice Determined by Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Education, Training and Experience Obtained Through Appropriately Accredited Institutions.
SB 437 authorizes a huge expansion of chiropractic practice, including sophisticated diagnostic testing and diagnosis and treatment of virtually any disease or condition. (We’ll return to the particulars in a moment.) The only limitation is that the chiropractor learned, in the language of the bill, “a therapy” he uses:
in a chiropractic college or chiropractic program in a university that has been accredited by the Council on Chiropractic Education [CCE] . . . or approved by rules of the [state chiropractic] board . . .
With this provision, the state will essentially default to the state chiropractic board and CCE-accredited chiropractic schools to determine chiropractic scope of practice. The board, by simply enacting a rule, could decide what therapies a chiropractor could use.
For its part, the CCE has already declared that all chiropractic schools are required to teach students to “practice primary health care as a portal-of-entry provider for patients of all ages and genders.” The CCE-accredited National University of Health Sciences, which has programs in chiropractic, naturopathy and acupuncture, among others, says that its “Students are well prepared to become first-contact, primary care physicians, ready to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of patients and conditions.” (Of course, this isn’t actually true, but it reveals the depth of their delusion that their education and training prepares them to become primary care practitioners or PCPs.)
In addition, the ACA has set up so-called “post-doctoral” programs to train, for example, “chiropractic internists” and “chiropractic pediatricians.” These 300-or-so-hour courses are taught on weekends, often in hotel conference rooms. Via affiliation with a CCE-accredited school, or by virtue of recognition of a “specialty” by the state chiropractic board, practices learned in these courses would automatically become part of the legal scope of chiropractic practice.
Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for Patient Examination, Diagnosis, Differential Diagnosis and Health Assessment [and] . . . for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues. (Emphasis added.)
SB 437 does not give chiropractors prescription authority, but they come close to getting everything else the ACA wants in this regard. The bill prohibits chiropractors from treating (but not diagnosing) infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, or atypical or abnormal histology, but otherwise allows them to diagnose and treat an unlimited array of diseases and conditions. They would be able to:
. . . evaluate and examine individuals to determine the presence of, or absence of, and diagnosis of physical or physiologic injuries, conditions, or disorders of the body.
What is striking is how hard the bill tries to avoid coming out and saying the word “disease” while at the same time clearly meaning exactly that.
They will also be able to “treat injuries, conditions, and disorders” with “the administration or dispensing of supportive therapies” and “any other therapeutic procedure or service (emphasis added).” It’s hard to get any more inclusive than “any other.” (Remember, the only limitation being that they learned this “therapy” in a chiropractic school or the chiropractic board approves it.)
Given these broad parameters, while never saying the words “dietary supplements” (which includes vitamins, minerals, herbs, enzymes, and glandulars) or “homeopathic remedies,” clearly chiropractors will be able to recommend and “dispense” (translation: sell) these and other “supportive” remedies to their patients. This is reinforced in a provision allowing chiropractors to give “nutrition” advice. The bill also allows chiropractors to “use filiform needles for the treatment of muscle pain,” or dry needling.
If you’re thinking it’s a stretch to interpret SB 437 as an attempt to vastly expand chiropractic practice, the bill’s provisions on diagnostic testing will erase your doubts. As long as the magic wand of board rule or instruction in a CCE-accredited institution is waved over it, chiropractors would be able to:
. . . order, perform, and interpret laboratory, radiological, electrodiagnostic, or any other diagnostic studies . . . including the ordering of advanced imaging of all parts of the human body. (Emphasis added.)
In sum, they will be able to order and perform any diagnostic test an MD can order: MRIs, PET scans, mammograms, EKGs, barium enemas, colonoscopies, hearing studies, pap smears, genetic testing, thallium stress tests, coronary artery cath studies, obstetric pelvimetry, pneumoencephalograms, xenon 127 pulmonary ventilation scan . . . you name it.
And that’s the legit tests. For the more quackery-minded chiropractor, there’s ALCAT and IgG food “sensitivity” testing, breast thermography for cancer screening, “functional” lab testing, salivary testing for hormones, MTHFR genetic testing (the quack version), and lab tests for heavy metals and “toxins.”
To mimic the language, if not the actual skill, of real primary care, SB 437 authorizes chiropractors to:
. . . manage, coordinate, or delegate patient care functions including initiating referrals, to specialists for concurrent, additional, or alternative services or care the chiropractic [sic] believes is most suited for the individual’s chiropractic condition.
I am not sure what limitation, if any, the term “chiropractic condition” puts on the chiropractor’s authority to manage a patient’s care. Given the extremely broad scope of practice this bill allows, I am chalking it up to poor drafting, not an intent to curb a chiropractor’s authority to diagnose and treat virtually any disease or condition.
Tennessee
Chiropractic practice is currently defined under Tennessee law as:
. . . the art of locating and removing interference with nerve transmission and nerve function . . . directed toward restoring and maintaining the normal neuromuscular and musculoskeletal function and health of the patient.
Again, traditional subluxation-based chiropractic. Tennessee Senate Bill 313 and House Bill 387 would expand chiropractic practice to include:
. . . differential diagnosis of human aliments through examination and evaluation of patients . . . through the ordering and performance of appropriate diagnostic procedures necessary to clinically correlate a physical examination to a diagnostic impression.
To achieve this differential diagnosis, the chiropractic “physician” could order x-rays, advanced diagnostic imaging “and other diagnostic procedures” and the “collection of bodily fluids and specimens for analysis.” The chiropractor could actually perform “other diagnostic procedures” if he has “received training” in them.
Under these bills, a chiropractor could treat not only neuromuscular and musculoskeletal conditions, but also what is referred to cryptically as “other conditions.” Treatment methods include, in addition to physical methods (such as “chiropractic adjustment and manipulation”), “other therapeutic care” and “chemical, electrical and thermal methods.” They can also provide “supportive care with due regard for nutrition . . . and rehabilitation.”
Given the vagueness of these terms, I would wager that the chiropractor could legally advise patients to take, and perhaps sell to them, non-prescription substances like OTC drugs, dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies. They are also specifically allowed to use acupuncture if they have additional training.
Chiropractors aren’t allowed to “practice medicine or surgery or osteopathy,” but that leaves little guidance as to just what it is a chiropractor can and cannot do if one of these bills becomes law. The practice of medicine is defined under Tennessee law as “diagnose, treat, operates on or prescribes for any physical injury or deformity.” Even if chiropractors are prevented from operating and prescribing, how is “differential diagnosis of human ailments,” any different from “diagnose [and] treat . . . any physical aliment or any physical injury to or deformity?”
Lest you think I’m reading too much into the intent of SB 313 and HB 387, two other bills pending in the Tennessee legislature should remove all doubt. Senate Bill 224 and House Bill 334 amend a state law allowing physicians to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. Pursuant to a direct primary care agreement, a physician provides primary care to a patient for a flat fee over a set time period (a year, for example) rather than, say, billing the patient’s insurer or accepting fee for service.
Primary care is defined in the law permitting such agreements as:
. . . the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment for the purpose of promotion of health or the detection and management of disease or injury within the competency and training of the direct primary care physician.
SB 224 and HB 334 would amend this law to permit chiropractic “physicians” to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients, leaving little doubt as to the intent of the chiropractic industry in lobbying for expanded scope of practice. Inexplicably, HB 334 is sponsored by Rep. Sabi Kumar, a general/vascular surgeon. I could not find evidence that the Tennessee Medical Association has taken a position on any of these bills.
New Mexico
For the third session in a row, the indefatigable chiropractic promoter Rep. Cisco McSorley has introduced a bill (Senate Bill 150) expanding chiropractic scope of practice beyond his previous accomplishments in that regard, which were substantial. Like other pending bills, scope of practice would extend beyond detecting and correcting subluxations, to include:
. . . diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained.
Chiropractic practice is renamed “chiropractic medicine” and chiropractors become “chiropractic physicians.” The bill does away with the current law’s definition of scope of practice, leaving it up to the state chiropractic board to determine what chiropractic “physicians” can and cannot do.
New Mexico is unique in giving “advanced practice” chiropractors limited prescription privileges. Their formulary contains quack favorites like dessicated animal thyroid and homeopathic remedies, including “homeopathic flu shots,” which, according to one New Mexico chiropractor, have this amazing advantage over the real flu vaccine:
[They] stimulate an immune response designed to strengthen resistance to all flu viral elements, whether last year’s or any other years, making the mutating quality of flu virus irrelevant and not a factor in the effectiveness that conventional flu vaccines demonstrate.
Someone call the CDC!
However, they cannot prescribe or administer dangerous drugs, controlled substances, any drugs for injection or substances not listed in their practice act without approval by the medical and pharmacy boards. Rep. McSorley’s bill does away with the requirement that the medical and pharmacy boards’ approve drugs for injection and expands the drugs they can use. “Collaboration” with (not approval by) the medical and pharmacy boards is required only if they want to expand the formulary even further. This means they would be allowed to inject patients with bioidentical hormones, vitamin cocktails and “live cell products,” among other substances. (I could not find that “live cell products” is an established regulatory term. Perhaps they mean stem cells?)
But wait, that’s not all: SB 150 would create a new category called the “Level Two advanced practice chiropractor,” who could, after an additional 650 hours of education and training beyond Level One (the current iteration of “advanced practice”):
. . . prescribe, administer, inject and dispense dangerous drugs that are used in a standard primary care practice,
with the exception of Schedule I and II controlled substances.
This 650 hours, presumably taught at a chiropractic or perhaps naturopathic school, would have to include “primary care case management” and “patient safety and standards of primary care.”
In past years, attempts to expand chiropractic prescribing privileges in New Mexico by statute or board rule has resulted in heated debate and litigation, pitting the medical and pharmacy professions, with an assist from the International Chiropractic Association (ICA), against the “DC as PCP” faction of chiropractors. This year, however, the bill isn’t even mentioned on the websites of the New Mexico Medical Society, the New Mexico Chiropractic Association or the ICA, which currently appears to be totally consumed in fighting (in cahoots with the National Vaccine [Mis]Information Center), California’s new law eliminating personal belief exemptions from vaccination and other pro-vaccination legislative initiatives. (Yes, many chiropractors are anti-vaccination, making the prospect of their practicing as PCPs particularly horrifying.)
Connecticut, Oregon, Colorado and Florida
More modest attempts to expand chiropractic scope of practice are pending in other states.
In Connecticut (Senate Bill 323; House Bill 6249) and Oregon (Senate Bill 217; House Bill 2390), bills are pending to allow chiropractors (and, in Oregon, naturopaths) to return students to play after a concussion. Connecticut House Bill 6029 would go even further by allowing chiropractors to diagnose a concussion. Mark Crislip, MD, has discussed in depth why their lack of education and training, plus their use of pseudoscience in the treatment of concussions, makes chiropractors wholly inadequate to the task of diagnosing and treating this form of brain trauma.
Finally, Colorado law permits the inhumane practice of “animal chiropractic,” defined as “diagnosing and treating animal vertebral subluxation,” including the use of x-rays for diagnosis. This is a neat trick to convince pet owners of the need for treatment by “showing” Fluffy’s “subluxation” on x-ray film. The law requires chiropractors to get clearance from a veterinary physician before “detecting” and “correcting” subluxations in animals. Colorado Senate Bill 135 removes the clearance requirement for chiropractors who are registered in animal chiropractic with the state.
Update: I just learned that bills are pending in my own state, Florida, which would allow chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. (Senate Bill 240; House Bill 161) As in other states, chiropractic is defined under Florida law as the detection and correction of vertebral subluxations. “Primary care service” is defined in these bills as
the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury within the competency and training of the primary care provider.
Again, chiropractors are incompetent to provide this level of care and it is misleading to the public to imply that they are by allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. It is important to remember that these agreements are not bound by the usual limitations imposed by health insurers based on the lack of evidence of safety or effectiveness. (See, for example, Aetna’s discussion of coverage of chiropractic services.) While patients are always free to pay out of their own pockets for services not covered by insurance, questions concerning the evidence base for a particular diagnosis or treatment will not be raised in the minds of consumers as they are when an insurer denies coverage.
We are following this and other Legislative Alchemy over on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website, where Mark Crislip has installed a nifty new map of the U.S. You can click on your state to see what’s brewing. For a depressingly comprehensive look at the entire country, there’s also a list of all pending legislation. The map and list are updated weekly, so check back often. To find out how to contact your state representative and voice your opinion on these bills, check out usa.gov.

H.R. 2654 forces Medicare to treat chiropractors and MDs as equals
Chiropractors are deceptively trying to sell H.R. 2654 as expanded Medicare coverage for musculoskeletal conditions. The bill actually mandates that Medicare treat chiropractors and medical doctors as equals, covering anything a chiropractors are authorized to do under their expansive state scope of practice laws.
Jann Bellamy on June 17, 2021
Link

The “Chiropractic Medicare Coverage Modernization Act of 2021” (H.R. 2654) would force taxpayer-funded Medicare coverage of chiropractors’ services for all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license. Deceptively promoted by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) as a means of increasing patient access to a broader range of pain management services and a cure for the opioid epidemic, the bill actually creates parity between medical doctors and chiropractors and requires coverage of a broad range of services going far beyond musculoskeletal issues. It is part and parcel of the ACA’s plan to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” who, in their own words,
can treat anything a medical doctor can.
Bait and switch
First, the “pain management” bait: H.R. 2654 is a reboot of a 2019 bill that tried, but fortunately failed, to do the same thing. The bill has bipartisan support of over 60 Representatives who have been fooled by the ACA into thinking this bill would simply, as the ACA puts it, expand Medicare to cover chiropractic’s “broad-based, non-drug approach to pain management” including spinal and extremity manipulation, evaluation and management services, diagnostic imaging and “utilization of other non-drug approaches”.
Now for the switch: The bill accomplishes this, per the ACA, by “appropriately defining” a Doctor of Chiropractic as a “physician” (just like an M.D. or D.O.) in the Medicare program and providing patients
access to all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license.
Unless you are familiar with the broad scope of practice the state legislatures have magnanimously gifted to chiropractors and the ACA’s push to redefine D.C.s as PCPs you might be forgiven for believing the ACA’s song and dance about pain management.
Co-sponsors of H.R. 2654 have apparently swallowed the bait, hook, line, and sinker. Congressional “findings” in the bill state that it would bring Medicare coverage “more in line” with that of the Veteran’s Administration, Department of Defense, federal employee coverage, and private health insurance. This is false: When these cover chiropractic services at all, it is limited to treatment of musculoskeletal issues, primarily pain.
With that introduction (and relying heavily on my post on the earlier bill), we’ll take a look at how chiropractors managed to get limited Medicare coverage in the first place. Then we’ll see just how H.R. 2654 could force taxpayers to fund chiropractors’ efforts toward redefining themselves as primary care physicians and subject seniors to their incompetent diagnosis and treatment of a wide variety of conditions.
Medicare and chiropractors: a contentious history
In the U.S., Medicare (Part B) covers people 65 years and older for “medically necessary” services and “preventive services”. “Medically necessary” services are broadly defined as “services or supplies that are needed to diagnose or treat your medical condition and that meet accepted standards of medical practice”. “Preventive services” are “health care to prevent an illness (like the flu) or detect it at an early stage, when treatment is most likely to work best”. This includes a yearly “wellness visit” to create a “personalized prevention plan” designed to help prevent disease and disability, as well as many other preventive and screening services, such as tobacco and alcohol abuse screening, obesity education, nutritional counseling, colonoscopies, mammograms, bone mass measurements, PAP smears, and so on. (Hospital services are covered under Part A.)
For M.D.s and D.O.s, Medicare will pay for any covered service. Coverage for chiropractic services is limited, however,
to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation.
As we know, the chiropractic “subluxation” is a fictional condition invented in 1895 by an uneducated self-styled “magnetic healer” and, most unfortunately, incorporated into the legal definition of chiropractic practice in all 50 states. This bit of legislative alchemy has permitted chiropractors, for over 100 years, to falsely claim their physical exams and wholly unnecessary x-rays have revealed “subluxations” in their patients’ spines that, unless “corrected”, can lead to all kinds of maladies. They proceed to treat these fictional subluxations with spinal “adjustments”, a process that must be repeated regularly lest their patients fall victim to the numerous ailments these non-existent subluxations are alleged to engender.
Interestingly, the ACA’s promotion of H.R. 2654 doesn’t mention the whole “subluxation” thing, presumably because they are well aware that subluxations are fictional and don’t want to open that whole can of worms by having to explain why they haven’t fessed up to Congress.
In any event, current coverage translates into just a handful of the 15,000 procedure codes used to bill Medicare. Chiropractors don’t like this, hence they want “parity” with M.D .and D.O. physicians and the ability to bill Medicare for any service that is within their expansive scope of practice, whether they are competent to perform that service or not.
Congress authorized limited Medicare coverage of chiropractic services in the early 1970s over objections of the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, as it was then called. Regulations further limit coverage to neuromusculoskeletal conditions for which manipulation is an appropriate treatment. Since inception, chiropractors and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), whose Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) administers the Medicare program, have been locked in a near-continuous battle over claims submitted for so-called “maintenance care (sometimes called “wellness care”) which basically consists of regular “spinal checkups” for the detection and correction of (fictional) “subluxations”, advertised by chiropractors as necessary to prevent health problems. There is no evidence that maintenance care is effective for this or anything else and it is not covered by Medicare, which hasn’t stopped chiropractors from submitting hundreds of millions of dollars in unauthorized claims. They are also notorious, as detailed in several HHS Office of the Inspector General reports, for failing to adequately document their Medicare claims.
This ongoing conflict is the reason H.R. 2654 contains a provision requiring chiropractors to take a course on documentation. [The ACA also conveniently omits the substantial history behind the documentation requirement in its discussion of the bill.] Oddly, the documentation requirement does not apply if the chiropractor is seeking Medicare payment for “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation”, the very portal through which they are being paid millions of dollars for unauthorized treatment. I have no idea why.
As the ACA explains, H.R. 2654 won’t add new services, “it only allows access to all Medicare-covered services that DCs are licensed to provide”. Of course, the unspoken corollary here is that each dollar that goes into a chiropractor’s pocket is a dollar of Medicare’s $731 billion in benefit payments (2018) that is not going into an M.D.’s, D.O.’s, or allied health professional’s pocket for the same service. Hopefully, this means they’ll fight this bill tooth and nail.
The DC as PCP
With this in mind, let’s take a look at what chiropractors claim they are capable of, and authorized to do, under state law. This is what chiropractic organizations had to say on the subject in “The Chiropractic Profession and Primary Care”, part of a white paper put out by a group of alternative medicine practitioners touting “the potential contributions of chiropractors . . . as providers of primary care”. Here’s how I summarized their position in a previous post:
The chiropractors claim, right off the bat, that they are primary care physicians. This is based on the Council on Chiropractic Education, the American Chiropractic Association, International Chiropractors’ Association and other chiropractic organizations saying that they are. The authors say that chiropractors can practice as a first-contact provider for patients of all ages and genders, assess a patient’s health status, formulate a clinical diagnosis, develop a case management plan that includes treatment, prognosis, and any necessary referrals. They can (according to the ACA) address “a large majority of personal health care needs.” The ICA says that the chiropractor can “provide all three levels of primary care interventions and therefore is a primary care provider, as are MDs and DOs.” The authors further claim that chiropractors “are trained to appropriately diagnose and manage the majority of healthcare issues that may present to their offices.”
The ACA has gone so far as to establish the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic internist“, billing it as “the only natural primary care doctors that are licensed in all 50 states”. One can become a “chiropractic internist” after a series of weekend classes in hotel conference rooms, taught by other chiropractors and containing little to no clinical training, and taking a test that, as far as I can tell, no one but chiropractors has evaluated or even seen. Perhaps realizing the obviously oxymoronic character of the term “chiropractic internist”, the ACA is now pushing the more nebulous term “ACA internist“.
According to the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, in answer to its rhetorical question: “Can a Chiropractic Internist treat anything a medical doctor can?”
The simple answer is YES! Chiropractic Internists use the same diagnostic tests commonly utilized by other medical professionals. . . . While it is true that the scope of practice varies from state to state, Chiropractic Internists practice in most states of the US as primary care practitioners helping people with a wide breadth of conditions and diseases.
Such as?
The list might include things like eczema, thyroid problems, diabetes, parasitic infections, cold sores, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, heartburn/reflux, autoimmune diseases (like lupus, or rheumatoid arthritis, or Crohn’s Disease), infertility, constipation, and vast amount [sic] of other diseases.
And,
Many illnesses that modern medicine has no cure for can be treated by ACA Internists with much success. Illnesses such as fibromyalgia, Crohn’s disease, IBS, migraine headaches, Lyme disease, heart disease, thyroid disease, infertility, low testosterone and diabetes can be greatly improved and often completely resolved with natural therapies offered by these natural physicians.
Of course, there is no proof whatsoever offered for these expansive claims.
In addition, according to the ACA, chiropractic/ACA internists are also
trained and licensed to draw blood, . . . [and] order saliva, urine, and stool tests . . . And since Chiropractic Internists are the natural version of a Medical General Practitioner, you’ll find they are trained to order and read a wide variety of tests (e.g., abdominal ultrasound, EKG, breathing tests, MRIs, CT scans, etc.)
As well, some chiropractors claim they are neurologists, practicing so-called “functional neurology”, about which a recent review concluded there is
no acceptable evidence on the effect or benefit of functional neurology in relation to various conditions and purported indications for intervention.
The American Chiropractic Neurology Board bestows the honorific “Diplomate” on chiropractors who have a whopping 300 hours of post-grad training in “functional neurology” and pass an exam. (An M.D. neurologist must complete four years of medical school and an additional four years of clinical training.) A current ACA continuing education course on “functional neurology” is taught by a chiropractor who co-founded “Plasticity Brain Centers”, which claim, among other things, the ability to treat
everything from Adult ADHD, Adult Autism Spectrum Disorders, early Alzheimer’s/dementia and other forms of cognitive decline, to brain injuries/concussions, dysautonomia, movement disorders, headaches/migraines, Parkinson’s disease, and even those with rare, unknown or un-diagnosable neurological challenges.
The breadth of state chiropractic scope of practice was exposed in a 2014 chiropractic journal article based on a survey of chiropractic regulatory officials. The survey reported that chiropractors are authorized by state law and regulations to order or perform a stunning variety of diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Here’s a partial list, with the percentage of states including the listed practice in parentheses:
Barium studies (74), cholecystography (X-ray visualization of gallbladder after administration of radiopaque substance) (80), thermography (95), electrocardiography (88), venipuncture (98), blood analysis (100), urinalysis (98), sputum analysis (95), fecal analysis (95), semen analysis (84), throat swab (92), skin scrape (92), school physicals (86), US DOT physicals (98), pre-employment physicals (95), pre-marital physicals (77), sign birth certificates (38), sign death certificates (50), EENT exam (90), abdominal exam (95), stethoscopic exam (98), sphygmomanometry (blood pressure) (95), bi-manual pelvic exam (73), speculum exam (72), recto-vaginal exam (72), Pap smears (79), female breast exam (80), rectal exam (85), male genital exam (85), prostatic exam (digital) (85), hernia exam (85), ultrasound (treatment) (100), IFC (interferential therapy) (100), microcurrent therapy (100), iontophoresis (not with prescription medication) (100), Russian stimulation (100), non-ablative laser therapy, nonadjustive treatment of female pelvic conditions (72), ear irrigation (83), TMJ (100), oral chelation therapy (76), IV chelation therapy (39), vitamin injection (43), limited prescription privileges (7), oxygen therapy (57), dry needling of trigger points (64), minor surgery (9), obstetrics (22), extremity casting sprains (71), extremity casting uncomplicated fractures (58), hypnosis (66), electrolysis (44), hyperbaric chamber (62), manipulation under anesthesia (71).
Lest you be misled into thinking chiropractic scope of practice indicates actual competency in this expansive array of diagnostic methods and treatments, it does not. While the scope of this article does not permit a deep dive into the murky waters of chiropractic education and training, suffice it to say that the whole business is controlled by the chiropractors themselves and they alone decide what they are sufficiently educated and trained to do, something they are known to vastly overstate. For example, a real primary care doctor, SBM’s Harriet Hall, M.D., has ably dissected their claim that they can competently practice primary care. (For one thing, many are anti-vaccination, a position that defies good primary care. For another, chiropractic clinical training is grossly inadequate for primary care and consists almost exclusively of seeing patients with musculoskeletal issues, like back pain.) A recent cross-sectional analysis of marketing claims made by chiropractor and other alternative practitioner websites found that a substantial number of chiropractors claim to treat allergies and asthma, despite the fact that there are no chiropractic treatments shown to offer meaningful objective benefits for these conditions. Nonetheless, efficacy claims were common.
Which brings us to their latest perfidy. During the pandemic, chiropractors falsely advertised the “immune boosting” powers of “spinal adjustments” to ward off COVID-19. They shilled for “immune boosting” dietary supplements as well.
Even as they tout themselves as primary care physicians under current state law, chiropractors, with the support of the ACA, are vigorously lobbying for the expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, a campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. They’ve lobbied for expanding chiropractic scope of practice to include diagnosis and treatment of all human ailments and removal of restrictions on treating infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, and abnormal histology. They’ve lobbied, with some success, to add diagnosis and treatment of student athlete concussions, performing school physicals and unnecessary scoliosis exams, prescription privileges, and nutritional counseling.
The latter is a favorite – coupled with the authority to order or perform diagnostic testing, chiropractors can fashion themselves into “functional medicine” practitioners, a lucrative alternative medicine “specialty” comprised of massive over-testing and prescription of dietary supplements, which they can turn around and sell to patients for a tidy profit. In fact, a 2017 review of studies of chiropractic practice revealed that almost a third of chiropractic patients are treated with nutritional supplements, an extraordinary number given the lack of evidence of effectiveness for supplements. But what a great sales opportunity, with taxpayers potentially picking up the tab under Medicare’s “nutritional counseling” coverage.
In several states, chiropractors have successfully included themselves in laws that allow direct primary care agreements with patients, which one lobbyist frankly admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as PCPs. Or they want to tack on anything they are taught in chiropractic school as a catch-all category to their scope of practice, leaving it to themselves to add whatever they wish.
Given their sweeping claims of competence and aggressive push for an ever-expanding scope of practice, one thing is certain: Despite giving lip service to pain treatment and alternatives to opioids, if H.R. 2654 passes, chiropractors are going to go full bore in forcing CMS to cover much more than musculoskeletal problems. If they had merely wanted more expansive coverage for the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal conditions, including pain, it would have been easy enough to draft language to that effect, but they didn’t.
While agencies have some wiggle room in interpreting what Congress tells them to do, HHS and CMS will be hard pressed to regulate around the plain language of the bill should it become law. “Any function or action . . . legally authorized by the State” is fairly unambiguous. Based on their history of unauthorized claims under a fairly simple, albeit scientifically deficient, coverage mandate from Congress, just imagine what they could do with “parity” and the authority to bill Medicare for the entire panoply of diagnoses and treatments bestowed upon them by credulous state legislators. Think of the possibilities for colossal battles between chiropractors and CMS over whether a treatment is “medically necessary” or just whose standard should apply when making that determination: evidence-based “conventional” medicine or “chiropractic medicine”?
Don’t let chiropractors deceptively sell H.R. 2654 as an expansion of pain management services and a solution to the opioid epidemic. Let your Representative in Congress know what this bill really does.

The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full chiropractic scope of practice
A bill pending before Congress (H.R. 3654) would expand Medicare coverage of chiropractic services to their full scope of practice under state laws. Chiropractors claim they are primary care physicians and want to force Medicare to pay them as such, just like an M.D. or D.O.
Jann Bellamy on August 15, 2019
Link

The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) and other chiropractic industry groups are promoting the “Chiropractic Medicare Modernization Act of 2019” (H.R. 3654), now pending in the U.S. House of Representatives, which would expand government-funded Medicare coverage of chiropractors’ services beyond “manual manipulation of the spine.” According to the ACA, which had a heavy hand in its drafting, the bill would mean Medicare coverage for chiropractic’s “broad-based, non-drug approach to pain management” including spinal and extremity manipulation, evaluation and management services, diagnostic imaging and “utilization of other non-drug approaches” to prevent opioid abuse.
The bill accomplishes this, per the ACA, by “appropriately defining” a Doctor of Chiropractic as a “physician” in the Medicare program and providing patients
access to all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license.
On reading the ACA’s description, one could be forgiven for thinking that a chiropractor’s scope of practice under state law is limited to treatment of pain, primarily via use of manual manipulation, and that this bill would simply allow patients to access additional means of pain management and attendant services, such as evaluation and diagnostic imaging. After all, a majority of the public sees chiropractors as “back doctors”.
This assumption is reinforced by Congressional “findings” contained in the bill itself, stating that the H.R. 3654 would bring Medicare coverage “more in line” with that of the Veteran’s Administration, Department of Defense (also here), federal employee coverage, and private health insurance. When these cover chiropractic services at all, it is limited to treatment of musculoskeletal issues, primarily pain.
But as the ACA damn well knows, chiropractic scope of practice under state law goes far beyond diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal issues and manual therapy. In fact, the ACA aggressively promotes the notion that chiropractors are fully capable of acting as your primary care physician under current state laws, a topic we’ve covered extensively on SBM: “The DC as PCP” (posts listed here).
Medicare and chiropractors: a contentious history
By way of background, let’s take a brief look at Medicare and how it covers chiropractic services, as opposed to that of MDs and DOs, a sore subject among chiropractors and the genesis of H.R. 3654.
In the U.S., Medicare (Part B) covers people 65 years and older for “medically necessary” services and “preventive services”. “Medically necessary” services are broadly defined as “services or supplies that are needed to diagnose or treat your medical condition and that meet accepted standards of medical practice”. “Preventive services” are “health care to prevent an illness (like the flu) or detect it at an early stage, when treatment is most likely to work best.” This includes a yearly “wellness visit” to create a “personalized prevention plan” designed to help prevent disease and disability, as well as many other preventive and screening services, such as tobacco and alcohol abuse screening, obesity education, nutritional counseling, colonoscopies, mammograms, bone mass measurements, PAP smears, and so on. (Hospital services are covered under Part A.)
For MDs and DOs, Medicare will pay for any covered service. Coverage for chiropractic services is limited, however,
only to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation.
This translates into just 3 of the 15,000 procedure codes used to bill Medicare. Chiropractors don’t like this, hence they want “parity” with MD and DO physicians and the ability to bill Medicare for any service that is within their expansive scope of practice, the ACA’s top regulatory and legislative priority.
[The ACA’s promotion of H.R. 3654 doesn’t mention the “subluxation” part, presumably because they are well aware that subluxations don’t exist and don’t want to open that whole can of worms by having to explain (1) why they haven’t pointed this fact out to Congress and (2) why HR 3654 permits continued Medicare coverage of the “correction” of a fictional pathology.]
Congress authorized limited Medicare coverage of chiropractic services in the early 1970s over objections of the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, as it was then called. Regulations further limit coverage to neuromusculoskeletal conditions for which manipulation is an appropriate treatment. Since inception, chiropractors and the Department of Health and Human Services, whose Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) administers the Medicare program, have been locked in a near-continuous battle over claims submitted for “maintenance care”,
a treatment plan that seeks to prevent disease, promote health, and prolong and enhance the quality of life; or therapy that is performed to maintain or prevent deterioration of a chronic condition.
This so-called “maintenance care” (sometimes called “wellness care”) basically consists of regular “spinal checkups” for the detection and correction of (fictional) “subluxations”, advertised by chiropractors as necessary to prevent health problems. There is no evidence that maintenance care is effective for this or anything else and it is not covered by Medicare, which hasn’t stopped chiropractors from submitted hundreds of millions of dollars in unauthorized claims. They are also notorious, as detailed in several HHS Office of the Inspector General reports, for failing to adequately document their Medicare claims.
This ongoing conflict is the reason H.R. 3654 contains a provision requiring chiropractors to take a course on documentation. [The ACA conveniently omits the substantial history behind the documentation requirement in its discussion of the bill.] Oddly, the documentation requirement does not apply if the chiropractor is seeking Medicare payment for “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation”, the very portal through which they are being paid millions of dollars for unauthorized treatment. Go figure.
As the ACA explains, H.R. 3654 won’t add new services, “it only allows access to all Medicare-covered services that DCs are licensed to provide”. Of course, the unspoken corollary here is that each dollar that goes into a chiropractor’s pocket is a dollar of Medicare’s $702 billion in benefit payments (2017) that is not going into an MD’s, DO’s, or allied health professional’s pocket for the same service. Hopefully, this means they’ll fight this bill tooth and nail.
The DC as PCP (again!)
With this in mind, let’s take a look at what chiropractors claim they are capable of, and authorized to do, under state law. This is what chiropractic organizations had to say on the subject in “The Chiropractic Profession and Primary Care,” part of a white paper put out by an group of alternative medicine practitioners touting “the potential contributions of chiropractors . . . as providers of primary care.” Here’s how I summarized their position in a previous post:
The chiropractors claim, right off the bat, that they are primary care physicians. This is based on the Council on Chiropractic Education, the American Chiropractic Association, International Chiropractors’ Association and other chiropractic organizations saying that they are. The authors say that chiropractors can practice as a first-contact provider for patients of all ages and genders, assess a patient’s health status, formulate a clinical diagnosis, develop a case management plan that includes treatment, prognosis, and any necessary referrals. They can (according to the ACA) address “a large majority of personal health care needs.” The ICA says that the chiropractor can “provide all three levels of primary care interventions and therefore is a primary care provider, as are MDs and DOs.” The authors further claim that chiropractors “are trained to appropriately diagnose and manage the majority of healthcare issues that may present to their offices.”
The ACA has gone so far as to establish the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic internist,” billing it as “the only natural primary care doctors that are licensed in all 50 states”. One can become a “chiropractic internist” after a series of weekend classes in hotel conference rooms, taught by other chiropractors and containing little to no clinical training, and taking a test that, as far as I can tell, no one but chiropractors has evaluated, or even seen. Perhaps realizing the obviously oxymoronic character of the term “chiropractic internist”, the ACA is now pushing the more nebulous term “ACA internist.”
According to the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, in answer to its rhetorical question: “Can a Chiropractic Internist treat anything a medical doctor can?”
The simple answer is YES! Chiropractic Internists use the same diagnostic tests commonly utilized by other medical professionals. . . . While it is true that the scope of practice varies from state to state, Chiropractic Internists practice in most states of the US as primary care practitioners helping people with a wide breadth of conditions and diseases.
Such as?
The list might include things like eczema, thyroid problems, diabetes, parasitic infections, cold sores, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, heartburn/reflux, autoimmune diseases (like lupus, or rheumatoid arthritis, or Crohn’s Disease), infertility, constipation, and vast amount [sic] of other diseases.
And,
Many illnesses that modern medicine has no cure for can be treated by ACA Internists with much success. Illnesses such as fibromyalgia, Crohn’s disease, IBS, migraine headaches, Lyme disease, heart disease, thyroid disease, infertility, low testosterone and diabetes can be greatly improved and often completely resolved with natural therapies offered by these natural physicians.
Of course, there is not one whit of proof offered for these statements.
According to the ACA, chiropractic/ACA internists are also
trained and licensed to draw blood, . . . [and] order saliva, urine, and stool tests . . . And since Chiropractic Internists are the natural version of a Medical General Practitioner, you’ll find they are trained to order and read a wide variety of tests (e.g., abdominal ultrasound, EKG, breathing tests, MRIs, CT scans, etc.)
The breadth of state chiropractic scope of practice was exposed in a 2014 chiropractic journal article based on a survey of chiropractic regulatory officials. The survey reported that chiropractors are authorized by state law and regulations to order or perform a stunning variety of diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Here’s a partial list, with the percentage of states including the listed practice in parentheses:
Barium studies (74), cholecystography (X-ray visualization of gallbladder after administration of radiopaque substance) (80), thermography (95), electrocardiography (88), venipuncture (98), blood analysis (100), urinalysis (98), sputum analysis (95), fecal analysis (95), semen analysis (84), throat swab (92), skin scrape (92), school physicals (86), US DOT physicals (98), pre-employment physicals (95), pre-marital physicals (77), sign birth certificates (38), sign death certificates (50), EENT exam (90), abdominal exam (95), stethoscopic exam (98), sphygmomanometry (blood pressure) (95), bi-manual pelvic exam (73), speculum exam (72), recto-vaginal exam (72), Pap smears (79), female breast exam (80), rectal exam (85), male genital exam (85), prostatic exam (digital) (85), hernia exam (85), ultrasound (treatment) (100), IFC (interferential therapy) (100), microcurrent therapy (100), iontophoresis (not with prescription medication) (100), Russian stimulation (100), non-ablative laser therapy, nonadjustive treatment of female pelvic conditions (72), ear irrigation (83), TMJ (100), oral chelation therapy (76), IV chelation therapy (39), vitamin injection (43), limited prescription privileges (7), oxygen therapy (57), dry needling of trigger points (64), minor surgery (9), obstetrics (22), extremity casting sprains (71), extremity casting uncomplicated fractures (58), hypnosis (66), electrolysis (44), hyperbaric chamber (62), manipulation under anesthesia (71).
Lest you be misled into thinking chiropractic scope of practice indicates actual competency in this expansive array of diagnostic methods and treatments, it does not. As is true with H.R. 3654, chiropractors have had a heavy hand in drafting their state licensing laws. While the scope of this article does not permit a deep dive into the murky waters of chiropractic education and training, suffice it to say that the whole business is controlled by the chiropractors themselves and they alone decide what they are sufficiently educated and trained to do, something they are known to vastly overstate. For example, a real primary care doctor, SBM’s Harriet Hall, MD, has ably dissected their claim that they can competently practice primary care. (For one thing, many are anti-vaccination, a position that defies good primary care. For another, chiropractic clinical training is grossly inadequate for primary care and consists almost exclusively of seeing patients with musculoskeletal issues, like back pain.) A recent cross-sectional analysis of marketing claims made by chiropractor and other alternative practitioner websites found that a substantial number of chiropractors claim to treat allergies and asthma, despite the fact that there are no chiropractic treatments shown to offer meaningful objective benefits for these conditions. Nonetheless, efficacy claims were common.
Put another way: Why would you trust anyone who promotes something called a “chiropractic internist” to accurately determine competency to do, well, anything?
Even as they tout themselves as primary care physicians under current state law, chiropractors, with the support of the ACA, are vigorously lobbying for the expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, a campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. They’ve lobbied for expanding chiropractic scope of practice to include diagnosis and treatment of all human ailments and removal of restrictions on treating infectious diseases, endocrine disorders and abnormal histology. They’ve lobbied, with some success, to add diagnosis and treatment of student athlete concussions, performing school physicals and unnecessary scoliosis exams, prescription privileges, and nutritional counseling. The latter is a favorite – coupled with the authority to order or perform diagnostic testing, chiropractors can fashion themselves into “functional medicine” practitioners, a lucrative alternative medicine “specialty” comprised of massive overtesting and prescription of dietary supplements, which they can turn around and sell to patients for a tidy profit. In several states, chiropractors have successfully included themselves in laws that allow direct primary care agreements with patients, which one lobbyist frankly admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as PCPs. Or they want to tack on anything they are taught in chiropractic school as a catch-all category to their scope of practice, leaving it to themselves to add whatever they wish.
Given their sweeping claims of competence and aggressive push for an ever-expanding scope of practice, one thing is certain: Despite giving lip service to pain treatment and alternatives to opioids, if H.R. 3654 passes, chiropractors are going to go full bore in forcing CMS to cover much more than musculoskeletal problems. If they had merely wanted more expansive coverage for the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal conditions, including pain, it would have been easy enough to draft language to that effect. But the drafters (that is, the chiropractors) intentionally chose these words:
It is the purpose of this Act to expand recognition and coverage of a doctor of chiropractic as “physician” under the Medicare program in connection with the performance of any function or action, including current service of “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation,” as is legally authorized by the State in which such doctor performs such function or action.
While agencies have some wiggle room in interpreting what Congress tells them to do (a subject that is complicated, in flux, and far beyond the scope of this post), HHS and CMS will be hard pressed to regulate around the plain language of this putative statute. “Any function or action . . . legally authorized by the State” is fairly unambiguous. Based on their history of unauthorized claims under a fairly simple, albeit scientifically deficient, coverage mandate from Congress, just imagine what they could do with “parity” and the authority to bill Medicare for the entire panoply of diagnoses and treatments bestowed upon them by credulous state legislators. Think of the possibilities for colossal battles between chiropractors and CMS over whether a treatment is “medically necessary” or just whose standard should apply when making that determination: evidence-based “conventional” medicine or “chiropractic medicine”?
H.R. 3654 is part of a larger strategy to “remove current limiting scope of practice language” in all federal legislation, such as the Medical Leave Act, Workers’ Compensation and Indian Health Care Services. According to an article in The American Chiropractor:
This proposed bill, if passed, will be the initial gateway law that will guide other federal healthcare laws. While it will take time, we must also work through many current laws, rules, and regulations that will need to conform to the new full-scope coverage legislation. Some federal laws that limit chiropractic coverage include those that guide nutrition [and] wellness exams.
(Told you! Nutrition and wellness exams.)
Don’t let this happen. The bill’s primary sponsors are Rep. Brian Higgins (D-NY-26) and Rep. Tom Reed (D-NY-23). Co-sponsors are Rep. Collin C. Peterson (D-MN-7), Rep. Kurt Schrader (D-OR-5), Rep. Don Young (R-AK-At large), Rep. Guy Reschenthaler (R-PA-14), Rep. Peter A. DeFazio (D-OR-4) and Rep. Brian K. Fitzpatrick (R-PA-1). If you are a constituent (and even if you’re not), let them know the error of their ways. If you don’t live in one of these districts, contact your representative in Congress and let him or her know H.R. 3654 is a scam.

The DC as PCP? Drug Wars Resume
Jann Bellamy on March 19, 2015
Link


Chiropractors are once again engaged in intra-fraternal warfare over the chiropractic scope of practice, a saga we’ve chronicled before on SBM. (See the references at end of this post.) Every time it looks like the warring factions have buried their differences, they come rising to the surface like zombies.
The International Chiropractors Association (ICA), representing the “straight” faction, wants chiropractic to continue as a drugless profession. They are happy to detect and correct subluxations, thereby removing “nerve interference” and “allowing the body to heal itself” in the tradition of Daniel David Palmer. But the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) has bigger fish to fry.
This time, the ICA is upset that the ACA House of Delegates up and decided to establish a “College of Pharmacology and Toxicology,” which would operate under the auspices of the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders. The ACA’s announcement of the “College” is rather vague on details:
The purpose of the College is to further educate the chiropractic profession on clinical matters related to the widespread use of both prescription and over-the-counter medications and nutritional supplements.
I e-mailed the ACA several days ago asking for more information but have yet to receive a reply.
The ICA sees this move as yet another attempt by:
forces at work within some organizations actively promoting incorporating drugs into the chiropractic scope of practice.
The ICA thought it had worked all of this out in 2013, at “The Chiropractic Summit,” when the warring parties met in Seattle to hammer out a deal settling their differences over the CCE and it’s troubles with the Department of Education. A treaty from those efforts declares:
The drug issue is a non-issue because no chiropractic organization in the Summit promotes the inclusion of prescription drug rights and all chiropractic organizations in the Summit support the drug-free approach to health care.
(We should note here that the Summit didn’t include all the warring parties. There was another faction – improbably named the DaVinci Group – made of other, non-Summit straights, such as the International Pediatric Chiropractors Association, who didn’t participate.)
So, as things stand now, the ICA and the ACA are officially at odds, once again, over drugs.
Chiropractic “internists”
Let’s spend a few minutes on this Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, under whose jurisdiction the College will operate, because it gives us some indication of the, um, quality of education chiropractors can expect regarding said “clinical matters.” If educating chiropractors about these “clinical matters” follows the modus operandi of the CDID, I suspect what we’ll see are weekend hotel conference room courses leading to some sort of ersatz certification in prescribing drugs.
The CDID is one of the ACA’s “specialty councils” and is “certified” by the American Board of Chiropractic Internists. (Yep, that’s right, chiropractic “internists.”) Its mission statement is:
To maintain and promote the chiropractic profession as primary health care providers, support the advancement of chiropractic, influence full scope practice within the profession and in current and future health reform legislation.
So I think you can see where things are going with the new “College.”
Their particular brand of “primary health care” looks a lot like naturopathy, but with even less education and training. According to their website, their practices include blood laboratory studies, electrocardiograms, spirometry, salivary assay hormonal and neurotransmitter tests, IgG food allergy testing, stool analyses “and many other diagnostic tools.” Treatments include dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, botanical medicine, natural hormone replacement and “pharmacologic counseling.”
To earn this coveted status, one must take a 300 hour “post doctorate course,” pass an exam and have 12 hours of continuing education per year. One becomes a “Diplomate” with this effort and earns a “post-graduate degree.” (I don’t know how one earns a “degree” unless it’s from an educational institution, but perhaps my definition of “degree” is too narrow.) There is also the 100-hour “Chiropractic Family Practice Functional Medicine” course sponsored by the CDID and the National University of Health Sciences. (As you will see below, chiropractors have really warmed up to the idea of functional medicine.)
I’ve written about the CDID before, and its weekend hotel conference room courses, most (all?) of which seem devoid of any clinical training. (Who knew you could learn everything about primary care pediatrics or dermatology in a single weekend?) This is cargo-cult specialization – all the trappings and titles of an American Board of Medical Specialties certification, with none of the education or training.
As if the ACA’s announcement weren’t enough for the ICA, the Wisconsin Chiropractic Association (WCA) recently put forth yet another iteration of the chiropractor in a White Paper with the unwieldy title: “Filling the Shortage of Primary Care Health Care Providers in Wisconsin: The Primary Spine Care Physician, a new class of health care provider.” In a nutshell, the proposal sounds a lot like the “Chiropractic as Spine Care” model we’ve discussed before on SBM except with prescription privileges.
The WCA proposes a “M.S. Degree in Advanced Clinical Practice: Board-certifed Primary Spine Care Physician,” (they seem to like long titles), with a 500 hour clinical training component including “neuro/orthopedic spine surgery, pain management, orthopedic and neurology practices.” It doesn’t say what institution would offer these degrees, but I think you can guess after reading the next few paragraphs. It isn’t clear where these clinical rotations would take place either. There would be a Board exam after that, but they don’t say under whose auspices this Board would operate.
The ICA was incensed that the WCA would suggest chiropractors weren’t already Primary Spine Care Physicians. And further incensed that anyone would suggest that drugs are necessary to provide competent spine care. This led to dueling letters from different chiropractic colleges published in the ICA’s Chiropractic Choice.
On the anti-drug side were Palmer Chiropractic College and the ultra-straight Life Chiropractic College. On the pro-drug side were the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS) and University of Western States. NUHS has been at the forefront of gunning for chiropractic prescription privileges and a broad scope of practice. A few years back, it announced establishment of a “Masters of Science degree” in “Advance Clinical Practice,” to prepare chiropractors for prescription privileges, but apparently that didn’t pan out, at least that I can find on its website. There was no entrance exam, the only requirements being a 2.5 GPA and graduation from a “first professional degree” program.
NUHS, which also grants naturopathy and acupuncture degrees, published a study a couple of years ago claiming it was nearing its goal of training chiropractic students as primary care practitioners, a study totally demolished by Harriet Hall. The NUHS was also co-author of an earlier ACA attempt to promote DCs as PCPs with a different white paper. Dr. Hall demolished that one too. The NUHS’s recently-retired president, James Winterstein, is a longtime cheerleader for a broad scope of practice.
Western States, although it is located in Portland, OR, had three representatives (of eight) on the “Authors/Contributors” attribution page of the WCA White Paper. While it doesn’t offer naturopathy or acupuncture degrees, it did recently sign an agreement that will lead to “further collaboration” with the Institute for Functional Medicine, the Jeffrey Bland initiative, on whose Board Dr. Mark Hyman sits. I had to chuckle when I read that Western States would include integration of what it called “IFM’s novel patient assessment criteria.” “Novel” hardly begins to describe it. (Of course, the Cleveland Clinic also recently expanded its descent into integrative medicine with the Institute.) I note with interest, therefore, that one area of training for the Primary Spine Care Physician model is “Nutrition for Musculoskeletal Health.”
Let me make a suggestion to the Wisconsin Chiropractic Association: dump the subluxation and all the quack diagnoses treatments chiropractors are famous for, concentrate on establishing yourselves as evidence-based profession specializing in back problems, and then maybe come back and ask for limited prescription privileges. Until then, no one should trust this proposed scheme.
Another strategy
Adding insult to the ICA’s injury was this year’s perennial attempt by New Mexico chiropractors to expand their prescription privileges. (NM is the only state with the dubious honor of having so-called “advanced practice chiropractors” as well as garden variety chiropractors.) With the help of their ever-reliable friend in the NM Legislature, Sen. Cisco McSorley, the pro-drug faction hatched quite an elaborate statutory scheme. Of course, this too is but part of a larger effort to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians.” Sen. McSorley’s bill took care of that aspect as well, but let’s deal with the drugs first.
The state’s existing “advanced practice” chiropractors would be divided into two tiers, “Level One” and “Level Two.” Both could prescribe any drugs approved by the chiropractic board. Level Ones currently have 90 additional hours of training after chiropractic school, and they would be grandfathered in, but requirements are changed to a “postgraduate degree in a clinical specialty” from a chiropractic school, with no minimum standards for such a course set.
According to the NM Chiropractic Association “advance practice” chiropractors can already perform:
IM injections (B12, homeopathic, magnesium, trigger point, etc.), neural therapy injections Intravenous procedures (meyer’s [sic] cocktails, H2O2, chelation, ascorbates, amino acids, minerals, etc.)
Under the bill, if the chiropractic board, in consultation with (but not necessarily the approval of) the pharmacy board, gives its ok, other drugs could be added. The medical board wasn’t given a say. Level Twos would require, in addition, 650 hours in a supervised “clinical rotation,” which could take place at a chiropractic college. Level Twos could prescribe, inject and dispense all dangerous drugs (as defined in by state law) except Schedule I and II controlled substances, that are used in standard primary care practice.
Bill amendments would have required that instruction for Level Two be okayed by the medical board and the existence of a collaboration agreement with a physician or certified nurse practitioner for first five years of practice for Level Two chiropractors who want to prescribe dangerous drugs, including chart reviews.
Fortunately the ICA descended on the legislature to oppose the bill and reports that it was defeated, although I’ve not been able to confirm that on the NM legislature’s website.
Arizona chiropractors made a more modest attempt to gain prescription privileges, limited to prescription-strength doses of ibuprofen, naproxen, methocarbomol and cyclobenzaphrine. They would need 75 hours of instruction and 300 hours of practical experience under the supervision of an M.D. or D.O. The bill is marked as “held” on the Arizona legislature website.
A second provision of the NM bill supporting efforts to rebrand DCs as PCPs is a bit sneakier in its language. And it is similar to language we are seeing pop up in bills in other states. This year, chiropractors in NM and Hawaii wanted a scope of practice including all diagnoses and treatments for which they have been “educated and trained.”
Hawaii’s bill, which also had a provision allowing chiropractors to call themselves “physicians,” was limited to education and training provided in an accredited chiropractic school. (Mississippi already defines chiropractic scope of practice this way.) What’s wrong with this? It defaults to the Council on Chiropractic Education to determine what the scope of chiropractic practice should be, because the CCE decides what chiropractic schools must teach their students. Fortunately, the bill failed a deadline for further consideration.
And what does the CCE itself say about this? In an apparent effort to please its various constituencies, the CCE’s accreditation standards state that:
An accredited DCP prepares its graduates to practice as primary care chiropractic physicians, and provides curricular and clinical evidence of such through outcome measures. CCE applies the understanding that in order to competently practice as a primary care chiropractic physician, DCP education trains its graduates to:
Practice primary health care as a portal-of-entry provider for patients of all ages and genders focusing on the inherent ability of the body to heal and enhance function without unnecessary drugs or surgery.
So if chiropractic students are trained as “chiropractic primary care physicians” who focuses on vitalism?
NM’s bill (it changed chiropractic to chiropractic “medicine”), on the other hand, did not contain the same limitation – the education and training presumably could come from other sources. And who would decide if a certain level of education and training had been achieved? The chiropractor?
Which brings us to another intriguing resolution just passed by the ACA, touting:
The identification of six key elements that should be considered or included in a modern chiropractic practice act. Variability of state chiropractic regulations has created uncertainty and confusion for the general public, chiropractic patients and chiropractic physicians, impeding development and progress of the profession.
It would be most interesting to find out exactly what these “key elements” are but my guess is that language along the lines of the failed NM and Hawaii bills will be included. Again, the ACA did not respond to my request for more information.
Finally, a third ACA resolution continued the “DC as PCP” theme:
The resolution, adopted by the House members, emphasizes the importance of allowing chiropractic physicians to practice and be reimbursed for the fullest extent of their licensure, training and competencies.
According to ACA President Anthony Hamm, DC, “The ACA will develop and implement a comprehensive strategy to ensure that doctors of chiropractic are recognized as being able to provide all existing Medicare services, as allowed under their state scope of practice, to beneficiaries.”
This would involve dumping the limitation on chiropractic coverage to detection and correction of subluxations (Congress having gone along with the fiction that subluxations exist when adding chiropractors as providers). If this scheme works, they would have to be reimbursed for whatever their state practice acts allow them to do, if it is covered by Medicare. No wonder they are so interested in having the CCE or, even better, individual chiropractors, determine their scope of practice.

The DC as PCP? Series (and related posts)
    • The DC as PCP?
    • The DC as PCP? Revisted
    • The DC as PCP? The battle continues
    • The DC as PCP: the battle resumes
    • Legislative Alchemy: 2014 (so far)
    • Legislative Alchemy:Chiropractic 2013
    • Legislative Alchemy: 2012.5
    • Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic
    • Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way!
    • Chiropractic Education for Primary Care
    • Dept. of Education to Council on Chiropractic Education: Straighten Up!
    • The Council on Chiropractic Education Straightens Up?
    • CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology
    • CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update
    • The Exciting Conclusion
    • ACA: Six Key Elements of A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act
    • Chiropractic Internist: A “specialty” to avoid
    • Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy
    • Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic
    • Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues
    • The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full scope of chiropractic practice

The CAM Docket: Texas MDs v. DCs
Jann Bellamy on May 3, 2012
Link
In April, the Texas District Court of Appeals (Third District) affirmed a lower court ruling that chiropractors are prohibited from performing manipulation under anesthesia and needle electromyography[EMG]. The lower court also ruled that the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners exceeded its authority in defining the chiropractic scope of practice to include “diagnosis.” This part of the ruling was overturned by the Court of Appeals, but with some interesting language in the opinion which could turn their one win into a Pyrrhic victory for Texas chiropractors. In a separate ruling, not on appeal, a lower court held that vestibular testing is outside the scope of chiropractic practice.
First, some background. Back in 1949, the Texas Legislature defined the scope of chiropractic practice as, among other things, “the practice of adjusting the vertebrae to correct any subluxation or misalignment thereof . . .” Over the ensuing years, the legislature amended the chiropractic practice act with an eye toward modernization, resulting in the current scope of practice being “nonsurgical, nonincisive procedures, including, but not limited to, adjustment and manipulation, in order to improve the subluxation complex or the biomechanics of the musculoskeletal system.” Now that’s progress!
Playing by the rules
Texas chiropractors are regulated by the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners [TBCE]. Normally, a regulatory body like the TBCE issues rules through a formalized procedure which gives stakeholders a voice in the rulemaking process. Once a rule is enacted, those adversely affected by it can challenge the rule in an administrative proceeding or in court. However, the TBCE for years avoided this process by relying instead on informal “statements” or “memoranda.” The effect of this was to prevent anyone from challenging the TBCE’s interpretation of chiropractic scope of practice.
In 2005, the Texas Legislature forced the TBCE’s hand by requiring it to adopt rules clarifying what is, and what is not, within the scope of chiropractic practice. In doing so, the TBCE would be limited by the Legislature’s definition of chiropractic but there was wiggle room to interpret the practice act as it saw fit. Requiring the TBCE to go through the normal rulemaking procedures would give any opponents of TBCE’s scope-of-practice delineations the chance to test the rules in court. Thus, the TBCE came to issue rules broadly defining chiropractic scope of practice, including authorizing chiropractors to perform needle electromyography, manipulation under anesthesia and vestibular-ocular-nystagmus testing. The rules also appeared to allow chiropractors expansive authority to “diagnose.”
A little too expansive, according to the Texas Medical Association [TMA] and the Texas Medical Board [TMB]. Because they now had specific rules they could challenge in court, the TMA and TMB (which I will collectively refer to, as the appellate court did, as the “physician parties” or “physicians”) sued the TBCE, along with its Executive Director and the Texas Chiropractic Association (referred to collectively as the “chiropractic parties” or the “chiropractors”). The physicians alleged that the TBCE’s rules were too broad and therefore went beyond the authority granted TBCE by the Texas Legislature. They also argued the rules were unconstitutional, a challenge yet to be ruled upon by the trial court and therefore not a subject of the appellate court’s opinion.
Vestibular testing
In a separate ruling, a Texas district (trial) court struck down the TBCE rule allowing vestibular-ocular-nystagmus testing as beyond chiropractic scope of practice. That decision was not part of this appellate opinion, but we’ll briefly look at it. According to the TMA website, its successful challenge was based on the contention that state law did not allow chiropractors to perform vestibular testing, because:
The vestibular system is a component of the inner ear and communicates with the central nervous system. Tests of vestibular function are diagnostic tests designed to evaluate the function and structure of the inner ear and/or brain, and they include hearing evaluations because the hearing and balance functions of the inner ear are closely related. . . . The vestibular apparatus is not part of the musculoskeletal system because the muscles that connect the eyes to the skull do not ‘move the body’ or ‘maintain its form.’ . . . Chiropractors are not authorized to diagnose medical conditions, including defects in the vestibular apparatus, because the Chiropractic Act does not include the diagnosis of diseases within the definition of chiropractic. Even if chiropractors can use the word ‘diagnosis’ in a rule, any such diagnosis must be limited to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system.
The court agreed.
Manipulation under anesthesia
Manipulation under anesthesia (“MUA”or “S[pinal]MUA”) is, according to Quackwatch, a
procedure in which a chiropractor performs manipulation while an anesthesiologist keeps the patient asleep. MUA has little appropriate use and is potentially dangerous. Because the normal protective reflexes are abolished, the manipulated joint can be overstretched.
Here is how the health insurance company Aetna describes chiropractic use of MUA,
Within the realm of chiropractic, SMUA is generally performed daily for 1 to 5 consecutive days on an outpatient basis, and is followed by a post-SMUA rehabilitation regimen, which entails 1 week of daily manipulation to maintain joint mobility and avoid re-adhesion of fibrotic tissue. Anesthesia is usually induced by intravenous Pentothal (sodium thiopental), and manipulation of the affected joints takes about 7 to 10 minutes.
Except in narrowly defined circumstances, Aetna considers MUA investigational and experimental, which translates as “we won’t pay for it.” Of course, in cases where the patient’s health insurer won’t pay, the patient pays the full freight, without discounts normally negotiated by the insurer or mandated by Medicare.
I don’t know how much a full course of chiropractic MUA would set a patient back, but add up the cost of the MUA itself, an anesthesiologist, an outpatient procedure facility equipped and licensed to handle administration of anesthesiology, multiply that by 5, then add 5 more days of in-office chiropractic manipulation, and I can imagine we’re getting into thousands of dollars.
Neither the trial nor the appellate court had much trouble deciding that MUA was outside the scope of chiropractic practice as defined by the Legislature. This is because the Legislature had specifically defined (by incorporating Medicare coding as a guide) MUA as a “surgical” procedure. Because chiropractors are statutorily forbidden from performing surgery, the rule permitting MUA fell.
Needle EMG
Needle electromyography measures the electrical activity of muscles. (This should not be confused with surface electromyography, a bogus diagnostic procedure sometimes used by chiropractors to detect “subluxations.”) A needle electrode attached by wires to a recording machine is inserted into a muscle to record the electrical activity. Needle electromyography is used to determine the cause of weakness, paralysis or muscle twitching and to diagnose diseases that damage muscle tissue or nerves, such as ALS or myasthenia gravis.
The trial court found, and the appellate court agreed, that insertion of certain types of needles used in the EMG met the definition of an “incision.” As chiropractors are prevented by state law from performing “incisive” procedures, the rule permitting their use of needle EMG was declared invalid.
To diagnose, or not to diagnose
The physicians also challenged TBCE rules allowing chiropractors to “diagnose,” a privilege is not specifically included in their practice act, which limits chiropractors to “us[ing] objective or subjective means to analyze, examine, or evaluate the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system of the human body” and “perform[ing] nonsurgical, nonincisive procedures . . . to improve the subluxation complex or the biomechanics of the musculoskeletal system.” One has to wonder how performing surgical or incisive procedures, should chiropractors be allowed them, could “improve the subluxation complex,” as the “subluxation complex” is a figment of the chiropractic imagination. The very thought raises the horrible specter of a chiropractor chopping away in an effort to redact a “subluxation” of, say, the second cervical vertebra.
The physicians won on this issue in the trial court, but lost on appeal. As I suggested earlier, this may be a hollow victory for Texas chiropractors.
TBCE rules challenged by the physician parties included:
Rule 75.17(d) Analysis, Diagnosis, and Other Opinions
(1) In the practice of chiropractic, licensees may render an analysis, diagnosis, or other opinion regarding the findings of examinations and evaluations. Such opinions could include, but are not limited to, the following,
(A) An analysis, diagnosis or other opinion regarding the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system including, but not limited to, the following . . . .
The rule then goes on to list pretty much everything one could possibly think of in the way of looking into “the biomechnical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system,” including:
(i) the health and integrity of the structures of the system;
(ii) the coordination, balance, efficiency, strength, conditioning and functional health and integrity of the system;
(iii) the existence of structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system;
(iv) the nature, severity, complicating factors and effects of said structural pathology, functional pathology, or other abnormality of the system;
(v) the etiology of said structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system; and
(vi) the effect of said structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system on the health of an individual patient or population of patients.
These references to “structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system” are apparently designed to encompass the latest iteration of the “subluxation,” known variously as the spinal lesion, joint dysfunction, manipulable lesion, and many other names. This formulation holds that the chiropractor can feel or otherwise detect something significant in the spine and then proceed to correct this significant something, although they’ve never been quite able to explain how what they say they feel or otherwise detect has anything to do with the patient’s problem. Nor have they been able to explain how what they do to this significant something, such as an “adjustment,” makes any difference to the patient’s health. At least that is what I have gathered from explanations of what they do posted in commentary on SBM. If I’m wrong about this, I’m sure I’ll hear about it.
Diagnose, but with limits
Two factors saved this rule from exceeding the scope of chiropractic practice in the appellate court’s view. First, the TBCE has interpreted the word “diagnosis” as synonymous with “analyze,” “examine,” and “evaluate,” which are within the statutory scope of chiropractic practice. Apparently the court thought this put some sort of limitation on their authority to “diagnose.” In other words, the court appears to be saying that “diagnosis” may have a meaning beyond “analyze,” “examine” or “evaluate” to a physician, but whatever that expanded meaning might entail, as long as chiropractors interpret “diagnosis” in this limited fashion, they are within their rights. This may be a distinction without a difference, but it is one the court makes.
Second, the court dismissed the physicians’ concerns that chiropractors defined terms in the rules so broadly that they could include virtually any disease or condition of any part of the body. Apparently unaware of the full extent of chiropractic claims of the near universal effect of spinal “structural” or “functional” pathology on the human body, the court found, over and over, that the physicians’ concerns should be allayed by the limitation to “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.” To each argument of the physicians that the rules included an impermissible expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, the court replied, in effect: “No, no, chiropractors are limited to ‘biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.’” In other words, the court seemed to think this term meant the same thing to chiropractors as it means to physicians and other health care professionals.
This may prove problematic for Texas chiropractors attempting to extend their diagnoses beyond the “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system” – as these terms are used in medicine — by employing the chiropractic concept of the “biomedical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system,” that is, to the subluxation or any of its current iterations.
In arguing that the rules permitted an overly broad scope of practice, the physicians pointed to the definition of the “subluxation complex” contained therein:
[A] neuromusculosketal condition that involves an aberrant relationship between two adjacent articular structures that may have functional or pathological sequelae, causing an alteration in the biomechanical and/or neuro-physiological relations of the articular structures, their proximal structures, and/or other body systems that may be directly or indirectly affected by them.
Of course, this is gibberish and most chiropractors well know it is gibberish but refuse to do anything about it, such as, say, letting the state legislatures in on this open secret. That would mean the states would have to redefine chiropractic practice to exclude the “detection” and “correction” of the non-existent “subluxation.”
In any event, the physician’s concern was that in using words like “pathology” and “etiology” the rules employed terminology that referenced the disease process. Because the diagnosis of disease was legally beyond the scope of chiropractic practice, they argued, the rules were invalid. The court disagreed, saying that their argument
presumes that ‘disease’ would extend beyond the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system of the body. This construction, as previously suggested, ignores the plain language of the rule restricting any such diagnosis to the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system. . . .
[R]egardless of whether diagnosis, pathology, or etiology invoke concepts of disease as the Physician Parties suggest, the bottom line is that [the rule] limits chiropractors to diagnoses regarding ‘the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system’ as required by the statutory scope of chiropractic.
The physicians also worried that the rule allowed chiropractors to
diagnose any diseases (pathology) that relate to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system (redefined [by chiropractors] to include nerves and other tissues), determine their origins (etiology) and provide a prognosis on the disease’s effect.
The court specifically rejected this interpretation as too broad, once again citing the limitation of chiropractic practice to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system.
Did the Court of Appeals adjust the subluxation?
This apparent limitation becomes even more clear in the court’s discussion of the “subluxation complex,” for which it accepted the TBCE’s definition, repeated here:
[A] neuromusculosketal condition that involves an aberrant relationship between two adjacent articular structures that may have functional or pathological sequelae, causing an alteration in the biomechanical and/or neuro-physiological reflections of the articular structures, their proximal structures, and/or other body systems that may be directly or indirectly affected by them.
[BTW, if anyone can tell me what this means, I would appreciate it. I once asked a friend who is a Ph.D neuroscientist specializing in the spine. He said it was “nonsense” but perhaps there are other views out there.]
The physicians argued that the rule’s subluxation definition would allow chiropractors to diagnose a broad range of “neurological conditions, pathological and neuro-physiological consequences that affect the spine and musculoskeletal system and ‘other body systems’ affected by subluxation.”
In what I view as an interesting limitation on the broad sweep of the chiropractic “subluxation,” the court disagreed that the inclusion of this definition of “subluxation” somehow expanded the scope of practice.
Although the definition of the ‘subluxation complex’ indicates that its existence may have functional or pathological consequences or that it may affect essentially every part of the body, the rule itself only allows chiropractors to render an analysis, diagnosis, or other opinion regarding a subluxation complex of the spine or musculoskeletal system.
To me, this says that a Texas chiropractor diagnosing the existence of a “subluxation” and then rendering an opinion that an “adjustment” of the “subluxation” may have consequences beyond the (once again) “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system” would be outside of his scope of practice. This would prohibit, in my view, a number of current chiropractic practices, such as opining that “adjustments” can be beneficial to asthma, allergies, painful periods, infant colic, bedwetting, otitis media, and any of the myriad other diseases and conditions chiropractors claim to treat. (Oh, wait, they don’t “treat” anything. They simply unleash the body’s self-healing ability.) It would also prohibit “maintenance” care, that is, regular “spinal checkups” and “adjustments” for general health, to the extent these claims extended beyond benefit to the “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.”
The physicians and chiropractors have not announced whether they will appeal to the Texas Supreme Court. The physicians will have another shot when the district court decides whether the rules allowing chiropractic diagnosis are unconstitutional. Stay tuned.

Chiropractors Lobby for Acceptance by the VA and TRICARE
Harriet Hall on October 6, 2015
Link


It seems alternative medicine is infiltrating into more and more organizations that should be based on science. We have quackademia in medical schools, integrative medicine clinics in hospitals and medical centers, government funding for alternative medicine research and education, coverage of alternative medicine by government and private health insurance, and acceptance of alternative practitioners in the VA and in military hospitals. Two weeks ago I wrote about an ill-advised effort to get naturopathy into the VA. Now it seems chiropractors have been lobbying to give all veterans and TRICARE beneficiaries access to chiropractic care. On the Society for Science-Based Medicine blog, Jann Bellamy has provided the details.
There are several bills pending: S. 398 and H.R. 1170 for the VA and H.R. 802 for TRICARE. There is also a bill (H.R. 542) that would include chiropractors in the National Health Services Corps. The American Chiropractic Association has issued statements in support of those bills. In their statements, they misrepresent what chiropractic is and what it can do.
Here are my objections:
Chiropractic is based on a myth
The chiropractic subluxation. Originally chiropractors were taught that all disease was due to subluxations: displacements of spinal bones causing nerve dysfunction. A recent study by chiropractors themselves concluded:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
Chiropractors have nothing unique to offer
They do spinal manipulation therapy, but so do doctors of osteopathic medicine (DOs), physical therapists, and MD physiatrists. They offer other conventional modalities like heat and massage. The whole concept of chiropractic is no longer viable. The minority of chiropractors who have rejected the subluxation concept and are trying to offer evidence-based care offer care that is indistinguishable from what a physical therapist can do; it’s hard to see how they can justify saying they are practicing “chiropractic.”
Chiropractic can be dangerous
Cervical manipulation by chiropractors has been associated with strokes and death. The form of neck manipulation most often used by chiropractors, high velocity, low amplitude thrusts (HVLA), can sometimes tear the delicate lining of the arteries in the neck, causing either immediate bleeding or the formation of a clot that later breaks off and travels to the brain. For neck pain, manipulation is no more effective than gentle mobilization and exercise. Chiropractors frequently use neck manipulation for other medical conditions where there is no evidence that it benefits patients. Half of all patients experience adverse effects from manipulation, ranging from mild temporary discomfort to broken bones, paralysis, and death. The risk of serious complications from cervical manipulation is small, but when there is no proven benefit, no degree of risk is acceptable.
There are other dangers of chiropractic care. Often patients are encouraged to get regular “maintenance” adjustments even when they feel well; these are useless and costly. Many chiropractors discourage conventional medical care; less than half of them support immunization. A large percentage of chiropractors use bogus diagnostic and treatment methods, from applied kinesiology to homeopathy. Since they are not well-grounded in science-based medicine, they tend to be magnets for every new kind of quackery. Some chiropractors treat newborn infants in the delivery room or shortly after in the belief that childbirth causes subluxations. Some of them claim they can cure diabetes. Some chiropractors are trying to gain acceptance as primary care providers or family doctors, a role that their education clearly does not prepare them for.
Chiropractors would not save the government money
The ACA claims that using chiropractors would save money. There is reason to think it would not. In 2000, a House Committee on Veteran’s Affairs Subcommittee on Health reviewed the results of a demonstration program and concluded that incorporation of chiropractic care into the DoD health care delivery model was not advisable. They found that adding chiropractic care increased costs and did not improve patient outcomes.
The ACA aims to benefit chiropractors, not patients
During the 120 years that have elapsed since chiropractic was invented by a grocer and “magnetic healer,” chiropractic has struggled to establish scientific credibility, and it has failed. If there were solid evidence of the safety and effectiveness of chiropractic care, it would have been accepted as part of mainstream medicine and would no longer be considered “alternative medicine.” Since the scientific evidence doesn’t legitimize them, chiropractors can only lobby and try to achieve legitimacy through political action. In their propaganda, they emphasize pain relief and patient satisfaction, in a blatant attempt to get a foot in the door where they don’t belong. Once they are in the system, they would be able to promote all kinds of pseudoscience, offer “maintenance adjustments,” and treat patients inappropriately for non-musculoskeletal conditions.
There is no way to sort the wheat from the chaff
Some chiropractors reject the subluxation concept and try to practice what is essentially evidence-based physical therapy; they have expertise in back care and might well be a valuable addition to the health care team. But others use all kinds of quack diagnostic and treatment methods and undermine conventional medicine. Many of them reject vital public health measures like vaccines and fluoridation. Some chiropractors even reject the germ theory. If the VA and TRICARE are required to admit chiropractors, the law will require them to admit any DC who is licensed to practice. There is no reliable way to distinguish the evidence-based chiropractors from the quacks. This is a recipe for disaster.
Conclusion: Veterans deserve real medicine
In my opinion, providing all veterans and TRICARE beneficiaries with access to chiropractic care would be a mistake. They deserve the best quality, up-to-date medical care. Treatment by chiropractors would turn back the clock. It would provide substandard care and expose patients to risks, and it would waste taxpayer money. Chiropractors offer nothing unique; the treatments they offer that are effective, including spinal manipulation therapy, can be provided by science-based conventional providers such as physical therapists, DOs, and physiatrists. I have sent letters of protest to TRICARE and VA officials. You might want to write your congressmen.

Direct Primary Care Agreements and Chiropractors: A bad deal for patients
Chiropractors are not “primary care physicians” and shouldn’t be allowed to pretend otherwise by entering into “direct primary care” agreements with their patients.
Jann Bellamy on March 29, 2018
Link

Last week, Florida became one of a handful of states allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with their patients. This bit of legislative alchemy is part and parcel of efforts to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” who are, in the words of the National University of Health Sciences (a chiropractic college), “ready to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of patients and conditions.”
Florida’s new law defines chiropractors, as well as MDs, DOs, and nurse practitioners, as “primary care providers” and “primary care services” as:
screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient conducted within the competency and training of the primary care provider for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury.
We’ll return to this rebranding campaign and state laws permitting direct primary care agreements between chiropractors and their patients in a moment. First, let’s look at the bigger picture: What are direct primary care (DPC) agreements and why are physicians and other health care providers pushing this sort of legislation?
What is “direct primary care”?
According to the American Academy of Family Physicians, which supports DPC:
The direct primary care (DPC) model gives family physicians a meaningful alternative to fee-for-service insurance billing, typically by charging patients a monthly, quarterly, or annual fee (i.e., a retainer) that covers all or most primary care services including clinical, laboratory, and consultative services, and care coordination and comprehensive care management. Because some services are not covered by a retainer, DPC practices often suggest that patients acquire a high-deductible wraparound policy to cover emergencies.
Direct primary care benefits patients by providing substantial savings and a greater degree of access to, and time with, physicians.
Patients pay a flat fee to their physicians, around $50 to $150 a month, for covered primary care services, which vary from practice to practice. (You can see examples of family practice DPC agreements here and here.) The physician accepts these payments in full for the services provided and does not bill a health insurer, freeing her from hassles like preapprovals and the prodigious paperwork involved in filing claims, leaving, proponents say, more time and energy for patients. However, as long as the patient’s insurance policy allows it, the patient can file a claim for reimbursement with his health insurer, as with any other out-of-network provider.
These claims of benefit are not without their critics. One concern is that, by reducing the number of patients each primary care physician sees (one goal of the DPC model), the supply of primary care physicians will be further reduced. And, at this point, it remains to be seen whether the DPC model can deliver on touted cost reduction and outcomes improvement.
As an NPR report on a failed chain of DPC clinics noted last year:
Some who analyze the use of health care are concerned that the approach encourages the “worried well” to get more care than they need. They describe unlimited primary care as a blunt instrument that doesn’t necessarily improve the odds that patients will get evidence-based services that improve their health. Others argue it’s important to find a way to provide cost-effective primary care within the health insurance context, not outside it.
Another problem with DPC agreements is that they can be construed as contracts of insurance under state law. That is where bills like the one recently passed in Florida come in: Proponents want to make sure providers won’t run into hassles with state insurance regulators. (There are also issues of compliance with the Affordable Care Act, Medicaid, and Medicare that must be worked out.)
So far, 24 states have passed some version of DPC legislation, although there is considerable variation. (Bills are pending in other states.) Some states, like Michigan and Kansas, permit “medical retainer agreements,” which:
means a contract between a health care provider and an individual patient . . . in which the health care provider agrees to provide routine health care services to the individual patient for an agreed-upon fee and period of time.
These are open to a broad range of providers, including chiropractors, but services are not specifically defined as “primary care.”
Proponents of DPC, however, prefer legislation tailored to a narrower category of practice, specifically focused on direct primary care. The DPC Coalition, an organization promoting direct primary care, has drafted model legislation that not only permits DPC agreements without running afoul of state insurance regulations, but also provides important consumer protections by requiring that covered services be spelled out, indicating the circumstances under which the physician and patient can terminate the agreement, and defining “primary care.”
The model legislation includes this provision:
Direct primary care practices may not decline to accept new direct primary care patients or discontinue care to existing patients solely because of the patient’s health status.
Interestingly, although Florida’s new DPC agreement law tracks the model legislation, this provision was excluded. One legislator’s attempt to add it by amendment during deliberations failed. Other states also fail to include the model provision, a protection that could negatively affect the DPC provider’s bottom line.
Some states, like Louisiana and Kentucky, specifically limit DPC agreements to MDs and DOs. Nebraska allows nurse practitioners as well, but limits DPC to those specializing in general practice, family medicine, internal medicine, or pediatrics.
Unfortunately, in addition to Florida, Virginia, Washington State, and Wyoming, specifically permit chiropractors to contract with patients to provide direct primary care services, although Virginia and Wyoming, unlike Florida, don’t specifically define what they mean by “primary care.” Tennessee includes chiropractors in its DPC law, it makes clear that chiropractors are not considered primary care providers.
The DC as PCP
A faction of the chiropractic profession is aggressively promoting the idea that chiropractors are competent primary care practitioners, an idea that we have exposed as nonsense many times here on SBM . Chiropractors do not have the education and training to practice primary care. In fact, in what little clinical training they do have, they may never have seen a pediatric or geriatric patient, a complicated medical case, or have had any experience diagnosing and treating conditions commonly seen in primary care practice. Their clinical education is a tiny fraction of the training a family practice physician undergoes. Chiropractors are traditionally anti-vaccination, which is the antithesis of good primary care.
That has not stopped them from establishing ersatz “specialties” like chiropractic internist and chiropractic pediatrics, designations awarded after taking courses in hotel conference rooms. Nor has it stopped them from pushing for scope of practice expansion, sometimes successfully, to include diagnosis and treatment of non-musculoskeletal conditions. Some chiropractors have become certified in so-called “Functional Medicine”, which massively misinterprets and abuses lab test results (including the misuse of genetic testing) in the service of selling dietary supplements to address putative “deficiencies.”
In a recent survey of chiropractic websites, about a third of chiropractors were claiming they treat allergies and asthma. But that’s not all. Chiropractic websites and other promotional material, including those of chiropractic professional associations, promote chiropractic diagnosis and/or treatment of ear infections, bedwetting, colic, Tourette syndrome, ADHD, breech babies, autism, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer prevention and detection, and endocrinology. A series of articles in an American Chiropractic Association publication (republished here and thoroughly demolished by Harriet Hall here) recommends that chiropractors employ diagnostic methods like fasting metabolic panels, lipid profiles, high sensitivity CRP to assess the level of endothelial inflammation and the risk of a cardiovascular event, hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) profile, auscultation, thyroid palpation, assessment of bowel sounds, palpation of the abdomen, prostate exams, and rectal exams. This same series suggests that chiropractors can “co-manage” metabolic syndrome, diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obesity, arthritis, osteomalacia, osteopenia, osteoporosis, malnourishment, and depression.
DPC is not for DCs
Allowing chiropractors to enter into medical retainer agreements is a bad idea; allowing them to offer direct primary care agreements is even worse.
A medical retainer agreement is the perfect vehicle to promote the thoroughly discredited notion that everyone, including infants and children, would benefit from regular “spinal checkups” and spinal “adjustments” to promote health and prevent disease, or “wellness care.” It has the added benefit to the chiropractor’s bottom line of avoiding insurance company limits on number of treatments and out-and-out refusal to cover quackery like the Webster technique, neuroemotional technique, cranial manipulation, and numerous other bogus diagnostic methods and treatments chiropractors offer and insurers reject for lack of evidence, not to mention basic biological plausibility.
But the direct primary care agreement can offer the chiropractor all this and more. In addition to signing patients up for quack treatments, the DPC agreement presents the chiropractor with the opportunity to claim that he or she is in fact capable of acting as a primary care physician. Don’t believe they would do this? Then look at these claims from the American Chiropractic Association’s Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders:
State medical societies and medical professional organizations appear to be oblivious to the fact that chiropractors are promoting this sort of nonsense. A call to the Florida Medical Association (FMA) pointing out the flaws of including chiropractors was met with the response that the Florida chiropractic practice act would limit their scope of practice. The FMA doesn’t seem to realize that the practice act allows a chiropractor to use any diagnostic method taught in a chiropractic college (which means the legislature has defaulted to the colleges to decide the scope of practice) and treat virtually any disease or condition with dietary supplements (“foods, food concentrates, food extracts”) and non-prescription “items” (which would include homeopathic remedies) in addition to the “adjustment” of “vertebral subluxations.”
According to the Institute for Functional Medicine, there are already several chiropractors practicing functional medicine in Florida. There are “chiropractic internists” practicing here as well. That should tell the FMA pretty much all it needs to know about the generous terms of the chiropractic scope of practice law in Florida.
Curiously, even the bill’s sponsor, who testified in person in favor of his bill, appeared unaware that chiropractors were included. In response to a question from the committee, he replied that the bill covered only “general practitioner primary care” providers and “only primary care physicians.” (The questioner was asking about other medical specialties, like OB/GYN.)
The DPC agreement bill was one of the most heavily lobbied bills in Florida’s 2018 session, with a whopping 108 lobbyists signed on to argue one side or another, clearly indicating that substantial financial interests were at stake. Appearing in favor of passage at the single House committee hearing on the bill were lobbyists from the Florida Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Physicians, and the Florida Medical Association. Only one person spoke against it and his objection had nothing to do with chiropractors.
Not surprisingly, the Florida Chiropractic Physicians Association, an organization promoting the:
advancement of the chiropractic physician to the level of true primary care physician, with full prescriptive rights and the opportunity to specialize . . .
appeared at the hearing voicing its approval.
Naturally, the Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA) is thrilled about the new law, because:
The FCA sought to include DC’s [sic] in this statute not only to provide a new business opportunity and better access to chiropractic care, but, also to express clearly in state statutes that chiropractic physicians provide primary care services.
Its announcement of the new law added:
Your FCA is now busy developing a host of new materials to assist you in better understanding this new, exciting concept and how you can best put it to work in your practice. Marketing and promotional guidelines, sample legal agreements, and new educational opportunities are among the many items on our drawing board all aimed at helping you take full advantage of this new law. Be sure to watch for our coming updates.
You can bet we’ll be watching to see just how far chiropractors will exploit this new law in rebranding themselves as primary care physicians.

Congress can easily end Medicare waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, saving billions
Yet another government report finds chiropractors are bilking Medicare billions for unnecessary services. A simple amendment to the Medicare law could end this, but will Congress act?
Jann Bellamy on March 1, 2018
Link

A new government report found that about half of all Medicare payments for chiropractic services between 2010 and 2015 were improper, costing some $250 to $300 million annually. Medicare beneficiaries also paid millions of dollars out of their own pockets in co-pays for chiropractic services deemed improper. Yet, despite years of proposed solutions to combat waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, necessary controls have not been implemented and remain inadequate to prevent several billion in further losses to the Medicare Trust Funds.
There is a simple solution to this problem, but it will take Congressional action, something that is in short supply these days. We’ll return to the solution in a moment, but first let’s take a look at this government report and some background information on Medicare payments for chiropractic services.
“Medicare Needs Better Controls to Prevent Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Related to Chiropractic Services”
Last month, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued yet another in a series of reports aimed at reducing improper Medicare payments to chiropractors, this one titled “Medicare Needs Better Controls to Prevent Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Related to Chiropractic Services.” OIG’s frustration with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for failing to act on previous recommendations practically leaps from the pages.
Medicare, as the OIG notes, covers chiropractic services for manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation, which can be diagnosed either by physical examination or by x-ray. According to the Medicare Benefit Policy Manual (Medicare Manual), the chiropractor must identify the precise level of the subluxation to substantiate a Medicare payment claim. While Medicare won’t pay for an x-ray to identify a subluxation, the x-ray can be used as documentation that the subluxation is there.
(At this point, faithful SBM readers will likely have guessed my simple solution to Medicare’s bleeding hundreds of millions of dollars in payments to chiropractors annually, but let’s continue with our present discussion for now.)
To qualify for Medicare payment, the chiropractic patient must have a “significant health problem in the form of a neuromusculoskeletal condition” and spinal manipulation must provide “reasonable expectation of recovery or improvement of function.” The Medicare Manual says that most spinal joint problems fall into one of two categories: “acute subluxation,” a new subluxation identified by physical exam or x-ray, and “chronic subluxation,” which is not expected to resolve with further treatment but where continued therapy can be expected to result in some functional improvement. To get paid, the chiropractor must place an “AT” modifier on the claim, indicating he provided “active/corrective treatment” for an acute or chronic subluxation, a requirement CMS added to help prevent chiropractic claims for unnecessary services.
The Medicare Manual also explains what is not covered: so-called “maintenance therapy,” subluxation correction that, according to chiropractors, prevents disease, promotes health, and prolongs and enhances quality of life.
Over a six-year period (2010-2015) Medicare paid $2.9 billion for subluxation correction. According to the OIG report, a whopping 44% to 54% of these payments were improper, the majority for medically unnecessary services, including maintenance therapy. This compares to a 10% to 13% improper payment rate for other Medicare-covered (Part B) services, which include doctor’s office visits, physical and occupational therapy, and outpatient surgery.
The OIG also found that, as the number of chiropractic services (again, limited to subluxation correction) a patient receives increases, the percentage of improper claims increases. In a 2013 nationwide review, 76% of claims for between 1 and 12 services were unallowable under Medicare coverage rules. Unallowable claims rose to an eye-popping 100% for patients receiving 31 or more services.
This most recent OIG report is one of at least 17 government reports since 1986 ferreting out chiropractic fraud and imploring CMS to employ more effective controls on improper chiropractic payments, especially those for maintenance therapy. (Chirobase lists all the reports here.) Unfortunately, some improvements aimed at addressing improper payments have backfired.
Instead of preventing fraud, the AT modifier has been turned into an instrument of fraud. Chiropractors simply slap it on all claims, knowing they’ll get paid regardless of whether it’s appropriate. In 2015, claims for all but 30 of the nearly 14 million chiropractic services paid by Medicare had the AT modifier, which is regularly used to get paid for uncovered maintenance therapy, according to the OIG report. Another anti-fraud mechanism – requiring the date of initial treatment on the claim, used as an affirmation that documentation of medical necessity is on file – is similarly misused. Chiropractors simply include the date on all claims even though, in two separate investigations, at least 90% did not appropriately document medical necessity.
Attempts to educate chiropractors and beneficiaries about improper payments are, in the OIG’s opinion, poorly executed or simply ignored. CMS doesn’t mention maintenance therapy in its explanation of benefits and fails to tell beneficiaries that some chiropractic services, like massage and acupuncture, aren’t covered. A CMS YouTube video on improving documentation is largely ignored by chiropractors.
The OIG thinks CMS could save millions of dollars by establishing a threshold beyond which chiropractic services (say, for example, 30 services a year) would be covered only if supported by medical review, a strategy employed by many private insurers and some Medicare contractors. The OIG estimates that this strategy alone would have saved Medicare almost $100 million, and patients over $24 million in co-pays, over a 2-year period. CMS doesn’t agree with this strategy and won’t implement it. In fact, CMS’s overall attitude seems to be that a few billion for chiropractic services is a small piece of the pie and it would prefer to go after bigger fish.
A better solution
I have a better idea for saving billions paid for chiropractic services: Stop paying for treatment of chiropractic subluxations. After over a century of claiming the detection and correction of subluxations is beneficial to health, chiropractors have never been able to prove these subluxations exist. All other healthcare professions, including medical doctors and physical therapists, reject the chiropractic subluxation. (An orthopedic subluxation – the partial dislocation of a joint – is a different thing altogether.) As well, in 2015, several foreign chiropractic colleges banded together to reject teaching of subluxation “theory” except as an historical concept. Even some chiropractors admit there’s no evidence:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal, this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
The General Chiropractic Council, the regulatory body for U.K. chiropractors agrees, finding that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex:
is an historical concept [and] . . . is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.
Somebody tell Congress. The Medicare law defines the term “physician” to include chiropractors and covers chiropractors for “medical and other health services,” but:
only with respect to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation . . .
In this, Congress was simply picking up the term “subluxation” from the states’ definition of a chiropractor’s scope of practice. In the early 1900s, the term “subluxation” was included in state chiropractic licensing laws to distinguish chiropractic practice from medical practice, laws passed to prevent chiropractors from being arrested for the unlicensed practice of medicine. At the time, it was a reference to the original definition of the word fabricated by “magnetic healer” D. D. Palmer, the inventor of chiropractic, out of thin air. Since then, subluxation has been redefined numerous times by chiropractors, without their even having bothered to prove such a thing exists, or agreeing on how to find one or its clinical significance.
Since Congress didn’t provide a definition of “subluxation,” Medicare chose this one out of the many available, a consensus definition cobbled together in the early 1990s by various chiropractic groups (Gatterman, 2005) and vague enough to satisfy the warring factions that permeate chiropractic practice:
a motion segment, in which alignment, movement integrity, and/or physiological function of the spine are altered although contact between joint surfaces remains intact.
CMS has washed its hands of any attempt to reconcile the chiropractic notion of the subluxation with its medical meaning, or the fact that no other health care profession believes the chiropractic version exists:
Implementation of the chiropractic benefit requires an appreciation of the differences between chiropractic theory and experience and traditional medicine due to fundamental differences regarding etiology and theories of pathogenesis of disease. Judgments about the reasonableness of chiropractic treatment must be based on the application of chiropractic principles.
In other words, Congress pretends this pseudoscience is fact, so we are forced to go along with it.
At least CMS limits subluxation correction to neuromusculoskeletal conditions, a limitation not obvious in the Medicare law and incongruent with the chiropractic concept of the subluxation, which they view as a contributing factor to any number of diseases and disorders. This notion is the origin of forbidden maintenance therapy: chiropractors promote the idea that regular “spinal checkups” for subluxation detection and correction to promote health and prevent disease.
In addition to wasting money on treating non-existent pathologies, location of “the precise level of the subluxation,” as required by Medicare, means that patients are being subjected to radiation for no good reason so chiropractors can document their (supposed) diagnosis. (It is sickening to see x-ray after x-ray of patients, including children, in chiropractic textbooks, instructing students on detecting subluxations via x-ray film.) To add insult to injury, Medicare doesn’t pay for the x-ray, meaning the patient must pay out-of-pocket.
This brings up a question: If Congress boots subluxation correction from Medicare coverage, should chiropractors be covered for any services at all?
On the one hand, however chiropractors see themselves, the public views them as “back doctors” (as does Medicare) and there is some less-than-robust evidence that generic spinal manipulation is effective for certain types of back pain. (Spinal manipulation is not synonymous with the chiropractic “adjustment” to treat the fictional subluxation, although chiropractors do use spinal manipulation as a means of making an “adjustment,” as SBM’s own retired chiropractor, Sam Homola, explains.)
As one solution, Congress could decide to cover spinal manipulation by chiropractors to the same extent it covers spinal manipulation by a physical therapist, doctor of osteopathy or medical doctor for medically necessary treatment of back pain, but it would need to exclude the subluxation as a proper diagnosis. Even in cases where spinal manipulation may be an appropriate treatment for back pain, it should not be based on a diagnosis of the non-existent chiropractic subluxation.
On the other hand, given the chiropractic track record for cheating Medicare, one wonders if they wouldn’t just fudge the diagnosis and continue improperly providing maintenance therapy. And it’s not like patients would be deprived of spinal manipulation in medically appropriate cases without them; they have other providers to choose from, providers who wouldn’t be so quick to use cervical manipulation for neck pain or cervicogenic headache, with their attendant risks.
Trying to amend the law creates a risk that chiropractors will use it as an opening to push for their dream of Medicare recognition of chiropractors as physicians who, in the words of the American Chiropractic Association:
should be allowed to practice to and be reimbursed for the fullest extent of their licensure, training and competencies.
It is a dream the ACA has been pushing to fruition for years, a piece of their larger plan to rebrand chiropractors as primary care providers with state licensing laws to match, efforts that are sometimes rewarded by states granting them huge scope of practice expansions. (These efforts continue in the 2018 state legislative sessions.)
Of course, the ACA would be put in the unfortunate position of arguing that Congress, having seen fit to kick chiropractors out of Medicare for repeated fraud, both in the form of pretending that subluxations exist for over 100 years and bilking Medicare to the tune of several billion dollars, should now grant them vastly expanded coverage under Medicare. Doesn’t sound like a winning argument, but you can bet they’ll try anyway.
Whatever the solution, taxpayers and Medicare beneficiaries shouldn’t be paying for treatment of phantom spinal lesions, whether allowed by law for covered ailments or via cheating by chiropractors billing for “maintenance therapy.” If you agree, tell your Congressional Representative and Senators.

Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Legal Support for Inappropriate Use of Spinal Manipulation
Legally licensed, unbridled subluxation-based chiropractors who offer unproven treatment for a broad scope of health problems endanger public health, stigmatize appropriate use of spinal manipulation, and deter development of chiropractic as a legitimate back-care specialty.
Sam Homola on June 9, 2017
Link

Since I am getting old (like Mark Crislip), one of the first things I do each morning is read the obituary to see who among my friends and acquaintances have died, most of whom are usually younger than I am. This morning I saw a familiar name ─ a chiropractor who opened a practice in my city many years ago. He was a subluxation-based chiropractor who employed an aggressive subluxation-oriented practice-building firm that provided him with canned newspaper advertising suggesting that he and his clinic offered the latest in scientific care for a variety of human ailments ─ care not provided by other chiropractors or any other health professional.
As a longtime critic of chiropractic subluxation theory and unethical advertising, I opposed the practice of this chiropractor, and I advised my patients not to seek his services. He eventually closed his office and moved away. According to his obituary, he had practiced in three different locations before his death, apparently struggling in his practice. I felt bad for this chiropractor and his wife and children, all of whom may have been adversely affected by his choice of chiropractic as a career, and I felt some degree of guilt for the effect my actions might have had on his family.
The uncertain aspects of chiropractic as a career
The nonfalsifiable chiropractic subluxation theory, which proposes that nerve interference caused by a vertebral subluxation can cause organic disease, still guides the practice of many chiropractors, most of whom now have undergraduate degrees. At least three years of undergraduate study (90 semester hours leading to a bachelor’s degree) are required to enroll in a chiropractic college. Several states require a baccalurate degree before a chiropractor can apply for a license to practice.
Unfortunately, an undergraduate degree or an unrelated graduate degree does not always offer protection against indoctrination in pseudoscience. Chiropractic students who do not have critical thinking skills will simply become products of what they have been taught. The result is that many well-meaning chiropractors struggle to defend and promote a practice based on a belief system that is sure to be opposed by the scientific community. Most newly-graduated chiropractors are unaware of the societal suspicion and the isolation resulting from rejection by the scientific community until they hang out their shingle.
The undergraduate requirements for enrolling in a privately-funded chiropractic college and to be licensed to practice as a chiropractor would permit enrollment in an academically-recognized college supported by state funding, offering degrees in physical medicine and other health-care occupations that provide more income and better opportunity for employment as well as a greater degree of social acceptance and professional recognition. Anyone considering chiropractic as a career should sit down at a computer and search the negative side of chiropractic before making a commitment that will have a profound life-long effect.
A degree in chiropractic offers no assurance for success in private practice. There is little opportunity for employment of chiropractors outside of private practice. Failure in private practice may force a chiropractor to leave the profession and seek employment in another field. Chiropractors who have the means and the ability to “start over” may leave the practice of chiropractic simply because of an inability to tolerate the pseudoscience in chiropractic and the isolation resulting from rejection by mainstream health-care professionals.
When I am asked about enrolling in a chiropractic college, I always suggest that it would be better to pursue a physical therapy degree, which would permit use of manual therapy in the mainstream of health care. Doctors of Physical Therapy (DPT) trained in use of spinal manipulation can be found in clinics, hospitals, and private practice in most cities. Every state now allows some level of direct access to physical therapy treatment without a prescription or a physician referral.
My personal struggle
When I began my chiropractic practice in 1956, I had already rejected subluxation theory, a view I expressed in my 1963 book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I believed that my use of spinal manipulation along with a few physical therapy modalities would provide a service not yet available in physical therapy departments. Some of my physical medicine textbooks recommended spinal manipulation as a treatment for mechanical-type neck and back pain. So I had good reason to believe that I offered a service of value. If I had believed that use of spinal manipulation in the treatment of back pain was quackery, I would not have gone into practice.
Offering treatment for musculoskeletal back problems, it was many months before I could take in enough money to cover the expense of operating my office. The public image of chiropractic was not good, insurance did not cover chiropractic, and physicians would not refer patients to chiropractors ─ for good reason. I could not have kept my office open long enough to build a practice if it had not been for my wife, Martha, who worked as an abstractor preparing property titles.
My published work about chiropractic and spinal manipulation brought support and referrals from other health-care professionals. Back-pain patients were channeled to my office by physicians and insurance carriers in order to bypass care by subluxation-based chiropractors. Although most health insurance now covers chiropractic care and chiropractors are better educated, chiropractic subluxation theory continues to define chiropractic in state laws that provide support for the pseudoscience of subluxation-based chiropractic care.
Finding a good chiropractor
There are, of course, some good chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately in a practice limited to treatment of musculoskeletal problems, using physical-treatment methods that include use of spinal manipulation as a treatment option, but they are hard to find. There is no way for the average person to distinguish such chiropractors from subluxation-based chiropractors. There are many chiropractors who claim to be advocates of musculoskeletal care but whose web sites include reference to subluxation nonsense. Until there is a national chiropractic association that openly rejects subluxation theory, limiting membership to science-based chiropractors with some way of identifying these chiropractors publicly, most physicians and health-care providers may simply refer patients to physical therapists for manual therapy that has not been contaminated by subluxation theory.
When I retired from private practice in 1998, one of the biggest problems I had was finding a chiropractor I could recommend for my former patients. I knew that patients who had received treatment in my office might assume that all chiropractors practiced the way I did, unaware of the great diversity of antithetical treatment methods among chiropractors. Listing as a “licensed chiropractor” in a telephone book offers no clue about the validity of the services offered. After reviewing the web sites and advertisements of the dozen or so chiropractors in my area, I found only one chiropractor that I thought was trustworthy. Today, I cannot find a nearby chiropractor that I would recommend. I am forced to recommend physical therapy for my friends and my former patients in order to avoid the possibility of chiropractic treatment based on subluxation theory.
Continued review of current chiropractic literature and web sites reveals that little has changed since my retirement from chiropractic practice. A broad scope of practice for chiropractors is still supported by subluxation theory under a variety of labels, such as a “vertebral subluxation complex,” an undetectable asymptomatic “joint dysfunction” alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs. Some chiropractors who have discarded the term “subluxation” continue to claim that manipulating vertebrae to correct a mysterious problem in the spine, such as a “neurobiomechanical lesion,” is an effective method of restoring and maintaining health.
Leaning toward “integrative medicine,” many chiropractors are subscribing to “functional medicine” and other alternative medicine procedures to further increase their scope of practice. Full-page ads offer treatment for thyroid issues, fibromyalgia, neuropathy, diabetes, and other problems, competing with services offered by multiple specialties and subspecialties that makeup the practice of medicine ─ a trend that is certainly a cause for alarm.
The guilt of pseudoscience
In addition to the struggle to succeed in private practice as a chiropractor, there is a price to be paid by those chiropractors who “go along” with subluxation theory in order to make a living. Burdened with misgivings, some chiropractors do what they feel they have to do to provide for their family. Some blatantly unethical chiropractors exploit subluxation theory in order to make as much money as possible, treating patients excessively and unnecessarily with treatment methods known to be useless if not downright quackery. Perhaps the most horrendous act of all is the pretense of chiropractors who claim to locate and adjust vertebral subluxations in the cartilaginous spine of a newborn baby, risking injury to epiphyseal growth centers (or worse).
At the end of the day and at the end of life, unethical chiropractors must deal with the guilt that occurs as a result of knowingly mistreating children or misleading patients who are allowed to suffer needlessly in order to complete a course of subluxation treatment “guaranteed to remove the cause of the problem.” Chiropractors with a conscience who take advantage of the suffering and the ignorance of patients who seek their help may have difficulty sleeping at night or may feel a sense of remorse at the end of life when memories replay the details of a selfish purpose that contributed little or nothing to society or to the welfare of mankind.
Although some chiropractors are abandoning subluxation theory and seeking specialization in conservative care for back pain and other musculoskeletal problems, portending a possible path for the chiropractic profession, there will always be a faction in chiropractic that will be devoted to the subluxation theory that gave birth to chiropractic. Belief systems never die since they are not subject to critical thinking or scientific analysis. A good example of this is the profession of osteopathy, which, although now scientific and mainstream, harbors a faction that is devoted to the principles of Andrew Taylor Still, a medical doctor who founded osteopathy with a claim that manipulation of joint and musculoskeletal structures is an effective treatment for most human ailments. Any practice that begins with a false premise and a founding father, such as chiropractic, osteopathy, and homeopathy, can never completely eliminate true believers who are bound together by the tenets of cultism.
Seeking a direction
My heart goes out to chiropractic students who have used their hard-earned undergraduate degrees to enroll in a chiropractic college, unaware of the controversy they must endure in competing with subluxation-based chiropractors who follow the tenets of D.D. Palmer, a magnetic healer and the founder of chiropractic. So far, there is no American chiropractic association or group that has publicly renounced subluxation theory and successfully united the chiropractic profession with a common denominator based on science. An effort in this direction failed with the demise of the National Association for Chiropractic Medicine (NACM) sometime after 2008 as a result of a low and declining membership. Advocating that chiropractic care be limited to treatment of neuromusculoskeletal problems of musculoskeletal origin, membership in the NACM required written renouncement of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
No applicability for chiropractic subluxation theory
The chiropractic subluxation alleged to be a cause of organic disease has never been demonstrated and is not the same as an orthopedic subluxation (a partial dislocation) or a joint strain that can cause musculoskeletal symptoms. While generic spinal manipulation can be of benefit in relieving the symptoms of mechanical-type back pain, which might occasionally involve an orthopedic subluxation, routine manipulation of the spine to correct a putative chiropractic subluxation as a treatment for conditions ranging from infant colic to back pain is classic cultism. Subluxation theory alone offers no justification for treatment of back pain. A spinal adjustment alleged to cure disease by correcting a vertebral subluxation, invented by Palmer in 1895, is not the same as generic spinal manipulation that has been around for thousands of years.
Today, there are chiropractors who claim to be primary care providers. The American Chiropractic Association offers certification in 10 different specialties, such as “Chiropractic Pediatrics” (often accompanied by opposition to vaccination) and “Diagnosis and Internal Disorders,” with a post-graduate diplomate awarded after attending weekends of classroom instruction. Many entrepreneurial chiropractors use the vague chiropractic “subluxation complex” paradigm to develop questionable techniques and specialties of their own, doing as they please under the umbrella of alternative medicine, relieved of the responsibility and the knowledge required to seek or offer appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis.
At the present time, it appears that subluxation theory will continue to dominate the practice of chiropractic. According to a survey of North American chiropractic students published in 2015, the majority of students would like to see an emphasis on correction of vertebral subluxations.
Chiropractic as a “spine specialty”
Some chiropractors claim to be a “spine specialist,” a specialty and a niche they cannot adequately fill because of limitations that do not permit utilization of multiple medical specialties and facilities that are needed to diagnose and treat “spinal problems,” a designation that includes a wide range of conditions, such as severe injury, disease, malignancy, infection, neurological complications, or pain of unknown origin. Physical therapists and properly trained chiropractors may be able to qualify as portal-of-entry practitioners capable of diagnosing and treating uncomplicated, mechanical-type back pain if they are backed up by the medical community, but “spine care” implies a broad scope that requires the attention of unlimited medical specialties and their subspecialties, such as orthopedics, physiatrics, physical therapy, and occupational therapy in a multi-disciplinary environment.
Justification for use of spinal manipulation
Every ethical chiropractor is concerned about the effects of his/her primary method of treatment, spinal manipulation. The theory that vertebral misalignment is a cause of disease or poor health has been rejected by the scientific community, but there is some evidence that spinal manipulation can be helpful in the treatment of some types of back pain. This evidence is weak, however, and there are studies which indicate that spinal manipulation may not be any more effective than other forms of treatment in facilitating recovery from back pain. Case reports of stroke caused by neck manipulation suggest that risk may always outweigh benefit when the upper cervical spine is manipulated.
Obviously, spinal manipulation has limited value and is only one treatment of many that might be helpful in the treatment of back pain, requiring that it be included in a physical-treatment armamentarium as an option among a variety of treatment methods.
Spinal manipulation is the only treatment used by “straight” chiropractic extremists who believe that a vertebral subluxation plays a role in the development of most health problems. Atlas Orthogonal and NUCCA (National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association) chiropractors believe that subluxation of the atlas (first cervical vertebra) is the primary cause of disease. Every patient gets a neck adjustment, no matter what the ailment might be, even low-back pain. Most subluxation-based chiropractors adjust every portion of the spine in order to correct or prevent alleged subluxations.
Use of spinal manipulation in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain can sometimes be justified by its effect in improving mobility and providing temporary relief of pain, buying the time needed to allow recovery without resorting to use of drugs, injections, or surgery. It goes without saying, however, that there is no substitute for medication in relieving severe back or radicular pain, which might be aggravated by inappropriate use of spinal manipulation. Victims of back pain often suffer unnecessarily when they respond to chiropractic advertisements promising “pain relief.” Any practitioner who offers treatment for acute back pain should have access to judicious use of pain medication as a short-term treatment option when pain is severe or incapacitating.
In rare, carefully selected cases, manipulation can be dramatically effective in restoring mobility in spinal joints locked or stiffened by post-traumatic adhesions. Office procedures such as massage and physical therapy modalities along with ongoing evaluation and observation can be an important part of caring for back pain. The relaxing effects of a good back-cracking back rub can enhance the effects of any treatment for chronic back pain, reducing or eliminating use of over-the-counter medication. The placebo effect of cavitation, a popping sound produced by manipulating the spine, may play a role in the patient’s perception of how effective a manipulative treatment might be.
Diagnosis: The most important part of back care
A correct diagnosis, which often requires multi-disciplinary involvement, is essential to determine what type of treatment might be needed. Most cases of acute uncomplicated back pain are self-limiting and will resolve with time, with or without treatment. Manual therapy, self-help measures, and instruction in exercise and ergonomics may be helpful in relieving symptoms until recovery is complete, depending upon the diagnosis. When there is acute back pain caused by disease or disc herniation, or when a nerve root is truly “pinched” or impinged by an osteophyte, symptoms may be exacerbated by manipulating the spine. Chiropractors who “analyze” the spine in a search for subluxations always manipulate the spine, offering treatment that is likely to be useless or harmful. When symptoms worsen as a result of such treatment, as they often do, they may be falsely attributed to “retracing,” a reaction alleged to be the result of removing the cause of the problem.
Subluxation-based chiropractors who “list a subluxation” rather than provide a diagnosis often explain that they do not diagnose or treat disease; they simply correct subluxations so that the body can heal itself. The success rate of treating a variety of ailments by adjusting imaginary subluxations is quite high since many ailments are self-limiting and will resolve on their own without treatment. Such “success” fails to provide appropriate care for patients who need special care based on a correct diagnosis.
The bottom line
While there appears to be no doubt in the scientific community that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory is not a valid construct, there is evidence to suggest that spinal manipulation can be a helpful procedure in the treatment of some types of back pain when it is part of a program that includes a variety of physical treatment options in a multidisciplinary environment. Evidence-based chiropractors who use generic spinal manipulation appropriately deserve some consideration as opposed to subluxation-based chiropractors who routinely “adjust” vertebral subluxations alleged to be a cause of disease. It is the moral and ethical duty of any science-based health-care provider to combat unproven subluxation-based chiropractic care, while taking care to be objective in evaluating the effects of spinal manipulation.
In addition to protection of public health, rejection of subluxation theory by conscientious chiropractors may be as important for the mental health of these chiropractors as it is for the physical health of their patients. I cannot imagine how I would feel at this stage of my life if I had devoted my career and my life to the pseudoscience of vertebral subluxation theory, fully aware of the falsehood involved. Hopefully, in the end, my published work, based on 43 years of practice as a chiropractor, will show that I did some good by separating the good from the bad in the use of spinal manipulation, steering the public away from inappropriate chiropractic care while providing a service of value to those who came to me for help.

.

Chiropractors, Naturopaths, Concussions and Senate Bill 1535
Is it a good idea that chiropractors be allowed to clear children to play sports after a concussion? No. It is not a good idea.
Mark Crislip on February 19, 2016
Link

There is a bill before the Oregon Legislature, Senate Bill 1535, that:
Allows chiropractic physicians and naturopathic physicians to provide release for athlete who sustained concussion or is suspected of sustaining concussion.
Unfortunately, the Oregon legislature has already granted naturopaths primary care physician status, so I expect this may well pass, despite the fact neither chiropractors nor naturopaths have much reality-based education and training in medicine.
You may wonder, why you should care about what is going on in Oregon? Well, it is likely similar laws are being considered in your state. You might be surprised at the shenanigans going on in your legislature. I was when I looked. To keep informed, go to Legislative Update at the Society for Science-Based Medicine for weekly updates.
Let’s go through the issues: why is it a bad idea for the athletes of the state, most of whom will be children, to be cared for by NDs and DCs?
What a concussion is
A concussion is a form for trauma, an injury to the brain. The brain floats in cerebral spinal fluid, which acts as a cushion. If the skull hits something, or is hit, hard enough by a fist or a football helmet or a wall, the cushion fails and the brain smashes into the skull. Trauma results.
The patient can then have a headache, confusion, ringing in the ears, seizures, double vision, and other neurologic symptoms. The number and severity of the symptoms depends on what part of the brain is injured, and the severity of the injury.
Treatment is resting the body and the brain and avoiding re-injury. There may be long-term sequelae to concussions, especially repeated concussions, such as depression, dementia and Parkinson’s. The brain is not physically, emotionally, or spiritually forgiving when injured.
It is a huge problem, with 300,000 sports related concussions a year in the US, and this only counts concussions that led to a loss of consciousness, perhaps 10% of the total. Children are both more prone to concussion and, perhaps, long term sequelae.
So concussion is a serious and widespread medical problem. It may not be an optimal approach to have those with little or no education, training or experience in medicine care for children with concussion. Except, probably, in Oregon.
Education
Chiropractors and naturopaths like to pretend that their ‘medical’ education is equivalent to medical school. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Chiropractic education
During the public hearing it was offered that the education of a chiropractor is equal to that of an MD. While there are superficial similarities, the whole of chiropractic education is through the lens of chiropractic theory: that there are misalignments of the spine, subluxations, that block that body’s ability to heal, and that chiropractors can identify and adjust these subluxations to restore health.
The whole underlying concept of chiropractic is a pseudo-science, with no basis in anatomy, physiology, or reality. As one review notes:
Chiropractic and allopathic medicine differ the greatest in clinical practice, which in medical school far exceeds that in chiropractic school. The therapies that chiropractic and medical students learn are distinct from one another.
Medical education is grounded in reality; chiropractic education is grounded in the fantasy of innate intelligence, subluxations, and spinal adjustments.
Naturopathic education
Naturopathic education also appears to be superficially similar in the number of hours devoted to the basic sciences. When compared to the education of a Family Practice Physician, it is clear that ND’s have a fraction of the training required to become and MD/DO.

It is more than the quantity of hours in education and training that makes a physician, it is also the quality of the content. ND curriculum is even more focused on pseudo-science than chiropractic: homeopathy, hydrotherapy, acupuncture, energy therapies, and more make up a significant portion of the naturopathic education. Time spent studying pseudo-science and pseudo-medicine is time not spent studying and understanding reality-based medicine. Those educated in the care and feeding of unicorns are not qualified to care for horses.
The naturopaths testifying at the hearing suggest that since they have been given primary care designation they should be allowed to diagnose and manage concussion as well. I would suggest that two wrongs do not make a right.
Post-education training
No MD or DO is even remotely ready for independent patient care upon graduation from medical school. After graduation MDs and DOs have a residency to learn their specialty. Internal Medicine, Family Practice, and Neurology residencies are three years; neurosurgery takes 7 years. It is the residency, practicing under the guidance of senior physicians, where doctors really learn their profession.
Neither naturopaths nor chiropractors have a residency; they usually go straight from school and into practice. The few that do complete a residency do so in the field of naturopathy or chiropractic, further reinforcing their pseudo-medical training.
There is no subspecialty naturopathic training in neurology; chiropractors can be certified as a chiropractic neurologist in 40 days of internet classes, or 300 classroom hours. Compare that to the over 8,000 hours (assuming a mythical 8-hour workday) it takes to be a real neurologist, much of which is spend in direct patient care. This is why Dr. Steven Novella, a Yale neurologist, says:
Chiropractic neurology appears to me to be the very definition of pseudoscience — it has all the trappings of a legitimate profession, with a complex set of beliefs and practices, but there is no underlying scientific basis for any of it…Chiropractic neurology does not appear to be based on any body of research, or any accumulated scientific knowledge.
Evaluating their education, training and practice, I would suggest that chiropractic and naturopathy are to real neurology and medicine what Guitar Hero is to Jimmy Page.
The medical literature
A search of the medical literature on PubMed for “naturopathic medicine concussion” yields zero publications. There are no trials to suggest that the pseudo-medical practice of naturopathy can be applied to brain injury. Or any other real disease for that matter.
For “chiropractic concussion” there are 19 hits on Pubmed, out of the 7,511 medical publications on concussion. None of the articles concern the competency or efficacy of chiropractors in the diagnosis and treatment of concussion.
There are no clinical trials demonstrating efficacy of chiropractic or naturopathic treatments for concussion. And there is no reason, based on known anatomy and physiology, to suspect that either pseudo-medicine would have benefit in the diagnosis or treatment of concussion.
Dangers of chiropractic treatment
The Palmer School of Chiropractic recommends manipulation of the cervical spine for concussion.
There is an association with cervical spine manipulation in the young and vertebral basilar artery stroke:
Results for those aged 45 years showed VBA cases to be 5 times more likely than controls to have visited a chiropractor within 1 week of the VBA (95% CI from bootstrapping, 1.32 to 43.87). Additionally, in the younger age group, cases were 5 times as likely to have had ≥3 visits with a cervical diagnosis in the month before the case’s VBA date.
The association between cervical spine manipulation and stroke is consistent enough that the American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association have released a scientific statement suggesting:
Although current biomechanical evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that cervical manipulative therapy (CMT) causes cervical artery dissections (CD), clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT and vertebral artery dissection stroke in young patients.
Complications fortunately are rare, as “Adverse Events Due to Chiropractic and Other Manual Therapies for Infants and Children: A Review of the Literature” showed:
Thirty-one articles met the selection criteria. A total of 12 articles reporting 15 serious adverse events were found. Three deaths occurred under the care of various providers (1 physical therapist, 1 unknown practitioner, and 1 craniosacral therapist) and 12 serious injuries were reported (7 chiropractors/doctors of chiropractic, 1 medical practitioner, 1 osteopath, 2 physical therapists, and 1 unknown practitioner).
But for an intervention that has no benefit, the risk should be zero. Young people have died after chiropractic manipulation, perhaps including the recent death of the “Queen of Snapchat,” Katie May.
And children are injured by manipulation when the correct diagnosis is missed:
Other (serious adverse events) leading to permanent neurological consequences have been reported. However all of these were attributable to a misdiagnosis leading to the inappropriate application of SMT with unfortunate consequences.
Yes. A child crippled by a useless intervention for the wrong reason is an “unfortunate consequence.” Given the lack of medical training by DCs and NDs, further unfortunate consequences would seem inevitable.
If stroke were due to a medication, the medication would receive a black box warning at a minimum or be pulled from the market. The major chiropractic organizations deny that chiropractic can cause strokes and continue to snap the neck, which can result in the same forces and injury as a hanging. But that is typical of pseudo-medicines: they never recognize that their interventions could be dangerous and alter or abandon practice accordingly.
The data suggesting a link between chiropractic manipulation and stroke is complicated and incomplete. However in medicine, but not chiropractic or naturopathy, the precautionary principle is applied:
if an action… has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is not harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking an action.
And the action avoided.
The majority of chiropractors are of the opinion that spine manipulation is a treatment for concussion, even though the brain is distant from spine:
Most respondents agreed or strongly agreed that manual therapies may be appropriate in certain circumstances in adults (80%) and minors (80%).
When all you have is a hammer, everything is a nail.
While there is no naturopathy-specific treatment for concussion, naturopaths do have their own naturopathic manipulation.
Bill 1535 should not pass
It should give anyone concerned with the health of children a frisson of terror at the thought of concussed children being evaluated and managed by naturopaths and chiropractors.
Naturopaths and chiropractors lack the education, the training, and the understanding of medicine and neurology to diagnose and treat concussion. Their therapies are at best useless and can result in strokes in one of our most vulnerable populations, children.
Senate Bill 1535 should not pass.

   Chiropractic Strokes Again! A Landmark Lawsuit in Canada
Harriet Hall 
Link
Sandra Nette is a prisoner, condemned to spend the rest of her life in the cruelest form of solitary confinement. Her intact mind is trapped in a paralyzed body and she is unable to speak. She can move one arm just enough to type on a special keyboard. She cannot swallow or breathe on her own, and must be frequently suctioned. She feels sensations and is in pain. Her condition is known as “locked-in syndrome” and has been described as “the closest thing to being buried alive.” She is suing those responsible for her cruel fate and I hope she wins.
She was a healthy 40 year old woman who wanted to stay healthy. She did all the right things like watching her weight, eating right, and not smoking. She followed the advice of a chiropractor to include regular maintenance chiropractic adjustments in her health regimen. On September 13, 2007 she had the last adjustment she would ever have.
There was nothing wrong with her. She didn’t see the chiropractor for headaches, neck pain, back pain or any other complaint. She went for a “tune-up” that she thought would help keep her healthy. The chiropractor did a rapid-thrust adjustment on her neck. Right afterwards, she complained of feeling “sore, dizzy and unwell.” She tried to leave but had to sit down. The chiropractor failed to recognize the medical emergency, and instead of calling an ambulance he recommended that she would benefit from purchasing massage therapy from his clinic. He let her leave the office and drive home alone. She only made it part way.
In the hospital, doctors determined that she had tears in BOTH vertebral arteries in her neck. One tear was 3 inches long.
Chiropractors would like us to believe that strokes after neck adjustments are mere coincidence, that patients like Sandra go to a chiropractor because they have neck pain from a stroke-in-progress and the manipulation is not the culprit. But cases like this are crystal-clear: she had no prior symptoms and there is no question that the neck maneuvers directly caused the tears in the arteries. One of the doctors in the ER took one look at her and asked her husband, “Chiropractor?” Neurologists, emergency physicians, and rational chiropractors all recognize that neck adjustments occasionally cause strokes, but the majority of chiropractors are still resisting reality.
Chiropractors tell us that strokes after neck adjustments are exceedingly rare, and that other forms of treatment, such as NSAIDs, are more dangerous. But in this case, it wasn’t a question of comparing treatment options, because nothing was being treated. There is no evidence to support the practice of maintenance adjustments. The absolute risk is small but the risk/benefit ratio is infinite because the benefit is zero. For a fuller discussion, see my previous blog article on Chiropractic and Stroke.
Sandra didn’t know that neck manipulation could cause a stroke. She didn’t know that maintenance adjustments only benefit the chiropractor’s bank balance. She wasn’t informed, so she couldn’t give informed consent.
Sandra isn’t just suing the chiropractor. She and her husband are suing:
• Gregory John Stiles,
• The Spa and Life Stiles,
• The Alberta College and Association of Chiropractors, and
• Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Alberta (Minister of Health and Wellness).
And they are seeking an order to make it a class action suit to cover every patient who received “an inappropriate and non-beneficial adjustment from any Alberta chiropractor since 1998.” Potential beneficiaries include those patients’ spouses and their estates if they are deceased.
Among other things, they contend that the defendants owed their patients a duty to not advise procedures that lacked scientific justification, to fairly disclose the benefits and risks of their interventions, and “not to charge them a fee for services that cannot restore, maintain or enhance human health.”
The Statement of Claim runs to 80 pages and describes the foundation of chiropractic, previous lawsuits, the published literature, and warning statements by groups like the 62 Canadian neurologists who spoke out in 2002. It provides extensive, detailed evidence to show that the College and the government were well aware of the risk of stroke and it argues that the College and the Minister of Health should have acted to regulate chiropractic to prevent disasters like Sandra’s.
They accuse the College of acting in bad faith, concocting evidence, sponsoring “methodologically inadequate research studies designed to validate rather than investigate the issue” and distorting scientific findings to support traditional chiropractic beliefs and economic interests. Strong words.
They are asking for $529 million dollars in damages.
Consumer advocates and victims of chiropractic have asked to meet with Canadian legislators and the Minister of Health to propose the following guidelines:
ONE: INFANTS AND CHILDREN: Highest neck manipulation should never be done in infants and children for claims to treat such conditions as ear infections, tonsillitis, infantile colic, asthma and gastro-intestinal disorders nor as an alternative to scientific immunization against diseases such as polio, tetanus, measles, mumps, German measles or chicken pox. The Chiefs of Paediatrics of our Canadian Hospitals have all condemned such claims by chiropractors.
TWO: PHILOSOPHICAL CLAIMS: Highest neck manipulation should never be done for the claim that it is effective to awaken the “innate intelligence of the spinal cord” and thereby provide “wellness or health” of the entire body. The idea that the spinal cord has some magical “innate intelligence” is a fundamental chiropractic belief. It is false.
THREE: REPETITIVE HIGHEST NECK MANIPULATIONS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done on a repetitive basis with claims that this will keep the neck vertebrae in proper alignment. It is false to claim that highest neck manipulation is necessary for the “maintenance” of the alignment of the highest neck vertebrae. The vertebrae are attached to each other by a complex structure of bone, ligaments and muscles. Manipulating the highest neck time and time again on people who have no complaints in that area should not be done.
FOUR: INFECTIONS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done for any claims that it alters in any manner, the immune system, to prevent or to treat infections such as Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome and other bacterial, viral or fungal infections.
FIVE: BODY ORGANS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done for claims that it can have a health benefit upon a body organ such as the heart, lungs, kidneys and liver or as a means of preventing the onset of genetic disorders or cancer.
SIX: VERTEBRAL SUBLUXATIONS: Highest neck manipulation should never be done for the claim that it can remove so called “vertebral subluxations” in the highest neck area. It is false to claim that these top vertebrae are out of alignment, even in new born babies, and that manipulating the highest neck area one can improve the function of the brain stem as well as treat conditions such as sinusitis and even multiple sclerosis. There is no neurological or scientific basis for such claims.
These guidelines make sense, and rational chiropractors should have no objections to them. They would not interfere with spinal manipulation therapy for musculoskeletal conditions, and they would eliminate much of the quackery in chiropractic.
The outcome of this lawsuit could have broad implications. If the judge finds that providers owe their patients a duty to not advise procedures that lack scientific justification, it will open the door to similar lawsuits involving other alternative medicine modalities. It might also open the door to lawsuits against scientific MDs who can’t convince the court that a treatment is adequately supported by scientific evidence. We want to eliminate quackery, but we don’t want to make the courts the arbiters of what constitutes sufficient scientific evidence.
Lawyers are smart and they will undoubtedly put up a good defense. If nothing else comes of this lawsuit, it should at least promote a useful discussion. There have been repeated recommendations to require chiropractors to at least disclose the risk of stroke to their patients, and no official body has yet acted on those recommendations. Maybe now they will. If not the official bodies, maybe the chiropractic malpractice insurance agencies, out of sheer financial self-interest, will start requiring their clients to get informed consent from their patients.
The transcript of the trial alone ought to furnish enough documentation for someone to write a book on the risks and benefits of chiropractic and the associated science or lack of science. This may do for chiropractic what Dover did for Intelligent Design. I will follow it with great interest.
References
Stroke Caused by Neck Manipulation Triggers Ambitious Lawsuit. Stephen Barrett, M.D.

CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update
Jann Bellamy on September 19, 2013
Link
Sometimes the media gets it right.
From time to time, SBM has reported on the disheartening credulity of reporters when they cover so-called “alternative” medicine. Denver’s Channel 7, an ABC affiliate, is a happy exception to the rule. Reporter Theresa Marchetta first broke the story of Brandon and Heather Credeur, chiropractors practicing “Functional Endocrinology.” And for three years Marchetta, with the assistance of reporter Phil Tenser, followed up, interviewing hundreds of patients who lost thousands of dollars paid to the Functional Endocrinology Center of Colorado for treatment of their diabetes and other endocrine disorders. They’ve reported regularly as the Credeurs legal travails progressed through various judicial and administrative forums. Channel 7 and its reporters deserve substantial credit for pursing this story. The Credeurs might have escaped further censure without their persistence.
Another recurring frustration at SBM is medicine’s embrace of alternative medicine, expressed repeatedly at SBM in posts on quackademic medicine and the branding device known as integrative medicine. We’ve also lamented the seeming complicity of the state medical societies in allowing quackery to be legalized in the form of complementary and alternative medicine provider practice acts.
But sometimes medicine gets it right.
The Colorado Medical Board has somewhat redeemed itself in ordering Brandon and Health Credeur to cease and desist the unlicensed practice of medicine. That’s right. A medical board has finally put its collective foot down and pushed back against chiropractic’s increasingly aggressive push to practice medicine.
And sometimes SBM appears to be making inroads into the hostile incursion of alternative medicine.
I recently discovered that if you google “functional endocrinology”, first up on the list is CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology, the very post updated today. Admittedly, it appears at the head of a depressingly long list of chiropractic websites advertising the practice, but at least we get a first crack at anyone who might be considering paying thousands of dollars and wasting time, and perhaps their health, on this useless nonsense.
A trifecta in the war on quackery! Revel in this victory, supporters of science-based medicine, for it is small and the victory may be fleeting. Let’s see how the battle is going.
In our last episode . . .
To summarize from the previous post, chiropractors Brandon and Health Credeur own Functional Endocrinology of Colorado. They attracted patients with free “gourmet dinners” and advertising, including a website, promoting their ability to treat diabetes with functional endocrinology. As is typical of alternative medicine pitches, their advertising offered a lot of MD-bashing and blather about getting to the “root cause” of diabetes, but little in the way of specifics and nothing in the way of actual evidence, only testimonials. Brandon Credeur claimed to be able to “reverse diabetes” in as little as three weeks. According to patients, actual treatments consisted of a diet book, supplements and chiropractic adjustments, for which they spent thousands of dollars. (One caller to the clinic was quoted a figure of more than $8,000 for treatments.) Some patients were not aware that the Credeurs were not MDs or endocrinologists.
Brandon Credeur also sold functional endocrinology practice building seminars, via a company called Functional Medicine Marketing, to other chiropractors. He bragged about hauling in hundreds of thousands of dollars per month and spoke of patients as if they were simply opportunities for self-enrichment.
The Colorado Board of Chiropractors filed a multi-count complaint against the Credeurs but wound up giving them only a slap on the wrist for errors in documentation. With a stipulation that they would improve on this, the Credeurs were back to shilling for their diabetes treatments. But some patients, outraged at the chiropractic board’s decision, banded together and filed a lawsuit against the Credeurs.
The battle continues
Channel 7 is still on the case. As it reported on June 13, 2013, the Medical Board of Colorado ordered the Credeurs to cease and desist the unlicensed practice of medicine. The Credeurs requested a full hearing on the matter, which they have a right to do under Colorado law. This meant that the Medical Board had to file a formal Notice of Charges fully setting forth its allegations of unlicensed practice and it did so on August 27, 2013. The Credeurs have not yet filed their Answer but a four-day hearing has been set for April 14, 2014.
The Medical Board is in interesting territory here. It does not have jurisdiction to discipline the Credeurs regarding their practice of chiropractic, including the suspension or revocation of their licenses. The Chiropractic Board has the exclusive authority to do that. It can only pursue them for practicing medicine without a license.
At the heart of the Medical Board’s allegations are the Credeurs’ statements on their website, which, according to the Board, suggest to the public that they
    • have an effective treatment or cure for endocrine dysfunction this is mutually exclusive to conventional medical endocrinology treatment by a licensed physician;
    • can permanently reduce and eliminate the risk factors of diabetes;
    • can eliminate low thyroid symptoms exclusively through chiropractic practice; and
    • can assume sole responsibility for treatment of patients regarding medications requiring a prescription by a physician without professional collaboration with or referral to a licensed physician.
(As to the last allegation, although this is not mentioned in the Notice of Charges, Channel 7 caught someone in the Credeurs’ office telling another person that “Synthroid promotes diabetes.”)
In addition, the Medical Board charges that the Credeurs’ website fails to indicate that they are chiropractors and that their services are exclusively chiropractic.
As examples of their alleged practice of medicine, the Notice of Charges quotes from the Credeur’s website. Here’s one example:
In functional endocrinology, the doctor identifies that function has been lost and asks a much more important question: Why has function been lost? And what can we do to restore function? In other words, the doctor looks to find the ROOT CAUSE or mechanism involved with any loss of function, which ultimately reveals why a set of symptoms is there in the first place, or why the patient has a particular disease label. . . . The point is the example and distinction made between the drug therapy model that is traditional medicine and a doctor who looks at mechanisms (i.e., contributing causes) and thus a doctor who practices within the model of “Functional Endocrinology.”
Ah yes, it’s that famous “root cause,” in CAPS, underlined, and boldfaced, in case you didn’t get the point. The website is still up and continues to make these claims.
The Chiropractic Board appears to agree with the Medical Board that chiropractors should not advise patients about their prescription medications and that they should confer with licensed physicians. The Chiropractic Board made similar charges in its complaint against the Credeurs, although the issue was never tried because of the parties’ stipulated settlement. And the Chiropractic Board agrees that it should be clear to patients that the practitioner is a chiropractor.
The two boards differ as to whether chiropractors can diagnose and treat endocrine dysfunction, diabetes and low thyroid. The Chiropractic Board went out of its way to reaffirm that treatment of endocrine system “ailments” is within the chiropractic scope of practice:
The Board affirms that the scope of chiropractic practice includes diagnoses and treatment of human ailments, including those affecting the endocrine system. [Credeur] and the Board expressly agree that it is appropriate for [him] to use the term “functional endocrinology” in his practice name and to describe his services provided that he continues to disclose his credentials “D.C.” when referring to himself as “doctor” to make clear that he is a chiropractor and that his services are provided pursuant to his chiropractic credentials.
(Emphasis added.)
Under Colorado law [Sec. 12-32-102(1.7), C.R.S.], the practice of chiropractic is premised on the subluxation, that is, the notion that “disease is attributable to the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system,” in the words of the Colorado chiropractic practice act. While chiropractic practice includes “diagnosing and analyzing of human ailments,” treatment is limited to “elimination of the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system by adjustment or manipulation” of joints. However, it also includes the use of “nutritional . . . remedial measures for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health, the prevention of disease, and the treatment of human ailments.” In addition, Colorado law gives chiropractors the authority to use venipuncture for diagnostic purposes.
The Chiropractic Board and the Credeurs appear to interpret a chiropractor’s legal authority to diagnose “human ailments” as unlimited by the fact that, in the chiropractic view of things, disease is attributable to the subluxation, even though that is how Colorado law specifically defines chiropractic practice. In essence, they ignore this limitation and interpret scope of their legal authority to diagnose to be the same as that of a medical doctor, although actual treatment is limited to dietary supplements and other “nutritional measures” and adjustments to eliminate subluxations.
Interestingly, while the Notice of Charges refers to diagnosis, its emphasis is on the fact that the Credeurs held themselves out as being qualified to treat, “exclusively through chiropractic practice,” diabetes, thyroid disorders, and endocrine dysfunction. Here, the board is on solid ground factually. There is no good evidence that functional endocrinology is effective for any condition or disease. However, whether that means they were engaged in the unlawful practice of medicine is not clear to me, although I am not familiar with Colorado law on the subject nor am I privy to what the Board’s strategy might be here.
Even if the Credeurs prevail, it is important that the Medical Board took action to protect the practice of medicine from further encroachment by chiropractors. If the Board can’t prove that the website representations constitute the practice of medicine, perhaps it will spur the state legislature to amend the chiropractic practice act to ensure that these and other diseases are out of the reach of chiropractors seeking to poach on medical territory.
As to their other legal troubles, Channel 7 reports that the Credeurs settled at least one class action complaint brought by former patients. The Credeurs filed for bankruptcy in August, listing assets of about one million dollars and liabilities of about three million. They report as a potential liability a lawsuit filed by patients, which they value at $100,000, and as a potential asset a possible suit against Channel 7 and other media for defamation and interference with contract.
The father of functional endocrinology?
One interesting tidbit in the bankruptcy documents is a description of a dispute between the Credeurs and a disgruntled former student at one of their Functional Medicine Marketing seminars. According to the student, the Functional Medicine Marketing system was, among other deficiencies, merely a rehash of a diabetes treatment plan developed by chiropractor Datis Kharrazian.
As it turns out, Datis Kharrazian is a San Diego chiropractor who appears to be the father of functional endocrinology. He’s written a book on the subject and runs seminars for chiropractors as well as other practitioners. He is also a Diplomate of the International Board of Applied Kinesiology and teaches at the Carrick Institute, if that tells you anything.
Here’s a description a functional endocrinology course available from Kharrazian.
Functional Endocrinology, 16 hours
This seminar teaches health care practitioners how to support hormonal balance by analyzing salivary and serum testing, then applying the appropriate nutritional support.
So that’s how you do it!
For a more critical look at Kharrazian than his website offers, he is featured on the website “Science Questions with Surprising Answers” as a case study under the topic, “How can I tell if a doctor is a quack?” Guess what the conclusion is.
Brandon Credeur’s pupil
The previous post on functional endocrinology also featured one of Brandon Credeur’s seminar students and fellow Parker College of Chiropractic classmate, Brandon Babcock, of Utah. Like his teacher, Babcock claimed the ability to “reverse” diabetes with functional endocrinology and had patients paying thousands of dollars for his services. He, too, drew patients in with free “gourmet dinners” and, according to patients, failed to tell them he is a chiropractor. As an additional flourish, Babcock allegedly engaged in a financial scheme to defraud patients, which earned him an 11-count felony charge. According to the court clerk’s office (as of Tuesday), that case goes to trial tomorrow. The city of West Jordan, Utah, revoked his business license due to the pending charges. Per an emergency order, his license to practice was temporarily suspended pending a further hearing but, according to state records, the license expired in 2012.
I suppose this gets one functional endocrinology practitioner off the streets, at least for now.
Functional Endocrinology for everyone!
Despite these small victories in Colorado and Utah, the practice of functional endocrinology persists around the country, as a quick google search will demonstrate.
Functional Endocrinology of Ohio
These chiropractors claim they can treat a wide range of diseases and conditions with functional medicine, cold lasers, trigenics, detoxification, and functional endocrinology. The latter is used to treat diabetes, among other things.
At Functional Endocrinology of Ohio, we have a proven track record of turning back the hands of time on diabetes (and other conditions). Our clients reduce their need for diabetic medication (including insulin) as well as other medications and, in some cases, eliminate the need for medications altogether with the help of their medical doctor. By finding out the cause of their diabetes, we are able to bring the body chemistry back into alignment, reverse diabetes, and improve the patient’s overall health dramatically.
Healing Partnership; Encinitas, California
This practitioner, Bryan Stern, LAc, has been a student in chiropractic, naturopathic and oriental medicine schools, but is practicing under an acupuncture license. Apparently he leaves no quackery stone unturned. According to his CV, he has studied cranial therapy, electromagnetic field therapies, advanced bio-electronic diagnosis, biological detoxification, Vegatest, photon resonance testing, vector point cranial therapies, contact reflex analysis, neuro emotional technique and quantum neurology (more on this below). He studied functional endocrinology under the tutelage of the aforementioned Datis Kharrazian. Here’s some of what he has to say on that subject:
Functional Endocrinology
A New Paradigm in Balancing Hormones
The dominant approach in western medicine when it comes to balancing hormones is based on the assumption that there are no restorative capabilities of the endocrine system; that is, if function is lost replacement therapy is the primary alternative.
However, physicians that provide hormone replacement without consideration to the causative reasons for the imbalance, as well as the alterations that might be created by the replacement, have no respect or understanding for [sic] human physiology.
I think we all know who has “no respect or understanding for human physiology” and it’s not physicians.
The Hayden Institute; Houston, Texas
Practitioners include a chiropractor/acupuncturist and a chiropractor/ applied clinical nutritionist/quantum neurologist. (Read Steve Novella’s post from yesterday to learn more about this “institute” and “quantum neurology.”) Among other services is the practice of functional endocrinology:
Using a Functional Endocrinology approach to health, a practitioner at The Hayden Institute reviews your history, blood and saliva tests, signs and symptoms in order to create a specific nutritional program for you. Functional Endocrinology focuses on identifying hormonal imbalance in the body when symptoms begin to develop rather than waiting for the organs or glands to be in a diseased state.
(Emphasis in original.)
Suncoast Functional Health Center; Sarasota, Florida
The practitioner is a chiropractor and another student of Dartis Kharrazian.
A medical doctor who specializes in the endocrine system is referred to as an endocrinologist. The prescribe medications and hormones in an attempt to address a dysfunctional or diseased endocrine system. Many times, these drugs carry a significant risk of dangerous side effects, and in fact, may not offer a viable long term solution to your problems. . . .
Below is an example of how we choose to shift the model
1 Thyroid doesn’t produce proper levels of hormones
2 Doctor [of chiropractic] determines the cause(s) associated with the loss of proper thyroid function
3 Doctor [of chiropractic] works to restore proper thyroid function using adjunctive and supportive therapy, so the body can once again produce proper levels of hormones ON ITS OWN for a lifetime.
I could go on, but I think you get the depressing picture.
Under the umbrella of their broad practice acts, chiropractors create, out of whole cloth, entirely new forms of quackery, which they then pass on to other chiropractors and alternative medicine practitioners. This ever-expanding galaxy of quackery won’t be stopped until the state legislatures act to limit the scope of alternative medicine provider practice acts and reign in their governing boards. Unfortunately, the trend is in the opposite direction.

Legislative Alchemy: State licensing of “the profession of reflexology”
Following the playbook of other practitioners of pseudoscience, reflexologists aim to become state-licensed health care professionals, a status they’ve already achieved in four states. With bills pending in New York and Nebraska, they move closer to their goal of legitimizing their quackery in all 50 states.
Jann Bellamy on March 25, 2021
Link

Legislative Alchemy, the incorporation of pseudoscience into state and federal law, has allowed chiropractors, acupuncturists, naturopaths, and other practitioners of quackery to join science-based professions like medicine and nursing in the pantheon of state-regulated health care professionals. This bestows the imprimatur of legitimacy on pseudoscience, implies a false equivalency, and gives the public the illusion it is being protected from harm. In some cases, it also forces all of us to participate in the financing of quackery via government-mandated insurance coverage.
Continuing in this tradition, a bill pending in the New York legislature (A3425) would license the “profession of reflexology”, as the bill calls it. A Nebraska bill (LB 211) would allow reflexologists to become registered professionals, a less regulated means of state recognition and sometimes a step on the ladder to full licensing. If the bills pass, New York and Nebraska will join North Dakota, Tennessee, New Hampshire, and Washington state in making reflexology a regulated health care profession. Over thirty other states indirectly recognize “the profession of reflexology” by exempting reflexologists from their massage practice acts, although not specifically making it a regulated health care profession.
Before we get to the pending bills and existing licensing laws, let’s briefly review reflexology, a topic we’ve covered here on SBM several times (see here and here), including Mark Crislip’s memorably titled “Reflexology: Insert Nancy Sinatra Reference Here”, a nod to what we might call reflexology’s foot fetish. We’ll also take a look at how reflexology is taking a page from the playbooks of chiropractic, naturopathy, and acupuncture to achieve its goal of licensing in all 50 states.
Like their fellow practitioners of pseudoscience, reflexologists have created an infrastructure to serve as a foundation for their legitimization: schools, a professional association, certification boards. Conveniently, the states can blindly incorporate the “standards” for reflexology education, training, and practice concocted by these organizations into state law, thereby entrusting the reflexologists themselves to determine their qualifications (such as they are) and scope of practice. This is the same system that gives us naturopathic “physicians” and chiropractic “primary care”.
You can see this plan at work in the Reflexology Association of America’s attempt to come up with a definition of reflexology suitable for licensing laws, where, ironically enough, pseudoscience can be something of a disadvantage. Once the parameters of science are tossed in favor of fabricated systems of anatomy, physiology, and the like, how do you settle on a description of your practice with sufficient detail to make it into the statute books, but with enough elasticity to ensure that future fabrications and additional iterations can be shoehorned into the legal definition of your scope of practice?
Toward this end, the Reflexology Association of America recently joined two other organizations gunning for legitimization via state regulation, the American Reflexology Certification Board and the National Council for Reflexology Educators, to create what they believe is a standardized, statute-worthy definition of reflexology. The American Reflexology Certification Board requires a minimum of 110 hours (that is, less than three 40-hour workweeks) of education and training, including all of 10 hours of clinical work, for certification. The National Council for Reflexology Educators prescribes a 120-hour, somewhat standardized curriculum.
Reflexology should be legally defined, according to them, as
a protocol of manual techniques, such as thumb- and finger-walking, hook and backup and rotating-on-a-point, applied to specific reflex areas predominantly on the feet and hands. These techniques stimulate the complex neural pathways linking body systems, supporting the body’s efforts to function optimally.
The effectiveness of reflexology is recognized worldwide by various national health institutions and the public at large as a distinct complementary practice within the holistic health field.
(For ease of reference, we’ll refer to this as the “reflexology consortium’s definition”.)
As an American Reflexology Certification Board article further “explains”, distinguishing reflexology from mere foot massage,
Although the benefits of reflexology include relaxation of mind and musculature, the primary intent is to support the health of the body’s internal systems . . . Reflexology typically focuses on reflexes corresponding to stressed organs and glands. . . [It can] safely help people of all ages restore homeostasis, optimize physiological functions and address system imbalances and weaknesses . . .
In other words, these manufactured “reflex areas” (illustrated in the above foot chart), are somehow connected by “complex neural pathways” (so complex they are apparently incapable of explanation by medical science) to the body’s organs and other “body systems”. “Manual techniques” applied to the “reflex areas” activates something or other in these “complex neural pathways” and this, in turn, positively affects “stressed organs and glands” in some unspecified manner, thereby bringing about suitably vague effects like “optimizing physiological function” and allowing the reflexologist plenty of room to claim that reflexology can benefit all manner of conditions and diseases. (And they do, as you’ll see.)
Nicely done! Science-wise, this is gobbledegook, but that’s no impediment to becoming state law, as we shall soon find out.
Of course, the medical profession should step in at this point and warn the public that this is all nonsense and intervene to prevent further exploitation of vulnerable patients by alerting state legislators to the reflexologists’ scheme.
But they don’t. To ensure that the public is kept reliably ignorant, presumably responsible medical sources like the Mayo Clinic and WebMD pretend they don’t know any better, acting as if reflexology’s fabulations are perfectly reasonable. Thus, from the Mayo Clinic:
The theory behind reflexology is that areas of the foot correspond to organs and systems of the body. Pressure applied to the foot is believed to bring relaxation and healing to the corresponding area of the body. Reflexologists use foot charts to guide them as they apply pressure to specific areas.
And, from WebMD,
There are different theories about the exact way that reflexology works, but the main concept of all is that different areas of the feet are linked to specific body parts, and that putting pressure on one area of the foot can have an effect on the organ that it corresponds with. . . Still another theory suggests that your body contains “vital energy” that is affected by stress. If you don’t work to relieve the stress, your body may not work as well as it should, which may lead to aches or illness. Reflexology is thought to help you maintain the flow of vital energy through your body.
Theory. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
And finally, from the NIH’s National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health:
Reflexology is a practice in which different amounts of pressure are applied to specific points on the feet or hands. These points are believed to match up with certain other parts of the body. Reflexology is claimed to cause relaxation and healing in those parts of the body, but this has not been proven.
“Not been proven”? How about “scientifically implausible to the point of impossibility”?
If the esteemed physicians at the Mayo Clinic, WebMD, and the venerable National Institutes of Health are willing to toss basic anatomy and physiology out the window, is it any wonder that mere state legislators would be willing to legitimize reflexologists by making them licensed health care professionals?
The road to legitimacy, one state at a time
As noted, North Dakota already licenses reflexologists, giving them their own regulatory board, consisting of three reflexologists appointed by the governor. This board determines licensing qualifications, including education and examination, and oversees discipline, just like a state medical board. North Dakota’s definition of reflexology tracks that of the reflexology consortium’s, although it describes only the method of reflexology (“finger walking” and such at “reflex points”), omitting the alleged purpose of all this (stimulating “optimal functioning” and the like).
Licensed reflexologists “may not diagnose or treat for specific diseases”, although presumably that leaves plenty of wiggle room for “restoring homeostasis” and “addressing system imbalances”. They are also prohibited from “false or deceptive advertising”. How that could possibly be enforced without wiping them all out is beyond me.
Tennessee law creates “registered certified reflexologists”, who must have 200 hours of education and training. Reflexology is defined simply as the “application of specific pressures to reflex points in the hands and feet only”, omitting any “theory” of operation or its purpose. Like North Dakota, reflexologists cannot “diagnose or treat for specific diseases” or engage in false or deceptive advertising.
Washington state “certifies” reflexologists, who practice under the state massage board. Certification requires 200 hours of instruction, which must include a “map of reflexes as they are anatomically reflected on the feet, hands and outer ears” and “how the reflexes are affected by stimulation to the feet, hands and outer ears”, thereby ensuring a thorough indoctrination in reflexology pseudoscience via the force of law. The state defaults to the American Reflexology Certification Board exam to determine if reflexologists are qualified to practice.
New Hampshire also licenses reflexologists, defining reflexology as the “use of alternating pressure applied to the reflexes within the reflex maps of the body located on the feet, hands, and outer ears” and likewise defaults to the American Reflexology Certification Board exam.
To briefly address the notion that state regulation somehow protects the public, let’s look at one example of a “registered certified reflexologist” from Tennessee, who advertises that
Reflexology is helpful to…
    • Improve blood circulation and energy in body by stimulating pressure points.
    • Give relief in Stress and helps in Stress Management.
    • Help relieve Back Pain, Neck Pain, Neck Stiffness, Shoulder Tension, Headache, Toothache, etc.
    • Help improve digestion functioning and reduce Stomach problems such as Acidity, Ulcer, Chest burn, Gas.
    • Remove craving for food and balance appetite and reduce amount of wastes.
    • Help relieve Depression, Nausea and other mental disorders.
    • Minimize Sinus Congestion and Nasal Problems.
    • Reduce Nasal pain and to get rid of Runny or Stuffy Nose.
    • Give relief in lung issues.
    • Relieve Ankle Pain, Knee Pain, Elbow Pain, etc.
    • Help improve Skin tone and heal skin disorders.
    • Help to improve Eyesight through massaging points.
    • Help to relieve cold, cough, constipation, Arthritis, Dizziness and Sore throat.
    • Help to Improve memory.
    • Help to reduce Menstrual Disorders in women.
    • Help to reduce emotional challenges of irritability, anger and frustration.
    • Minimize addictions to tobacco, smoking, etc. by stimulating some pressure points.
    • Improve healing from sports injuries.
    • Give Relaxation to the body.
So much for Tennessee’s prohibitions against treating disease and false advertising.
With that, let’s turn to the latest attempts at legitimization via legislation, the bills pending in New York and Nebraska.
New York A3425 would permit “licensed reflexologists”, who would be regulated by the state massage board, with one seat added for a reflexologist. According to the bill’s “Introduction”,
The effectiveness of reflexology is recognized worldwide by various national health institutions and the public at large as a distinct complementary practice within the holistic health field.
Sound familiar? It should. It’s straight from the reflexology consortium’s definition. Not only that, but the bill adopts, word for word, the rest of the consortium’s definition of reflexology (“stimulate the complex neural pathways linking body systems” etc.) as the legal definition of the practice of reflexology. There is no prohibition against diagnosing and treating disease. Reflexologists must have a high school education as well as reflexology training and pass an exam approved by the education department. Given the reflexology consortium’s obvious hand in drafting this bill, one can assume they will successfully influence the department to adopt their approved curricula and certification exam.
Nebraska LB 211 would register reflexologists, who would also practice under the jurisdiction of the state massage board. Reflexology is defined as “the application of specific pressure . . . to the soft tissue of the hands, feet, and outer ears . . . not designated or implied to be massage or massage therapy”. No specific training is required, only passing the examination given by the American Reflexology Certification Board or the Reflexology Certification Board, a different certification organization with its own education requirements (200 hours) and exam.
Reflexologists are following the well-trodden path of legitimization laid before them by chiropractors, naturopaths, and other practitioners of pseudoscience. (Ayurveda recently entered this sweepstakes as well.) It may take decades, but licensing in all 50 states is their goal and, given the support from certain quarters of the medical profession and Legislative Alchemy’s proven track record, “the profession of reflexology” has every chance of getting there.

Acupuncture

   Legislative Alchemy III: Acupuncture
Jann Bellamy 
Link
Acupuncture is typically depicted as sticking needles at various points on the body prescribed (inconsistently, it turns out) by charts indicating purported “meridians” through which “qi” flows in the human, or animal , body. However, from one of the many SBM posts on acupuncture , this one by Dr. Novella , we in fact know that:
the consensus of the best clinical studies on acupuncture show that there is no specific effect of sticking needles into acupuncture points. Choosing random points works just as well, as does poking the skin with toothpicks rather than penetrating the skin with a needle to elicit the alleged “de qi”. The most parsimonious interpretation of the evidence is that the needles (i.e. acupuncture itself) are superfluous — any perceived benefit comes from the therapeutic interaction. This has been directly studied, and the evidence suggests that the way to maximize the subjective effects from the ritual of acupuncture is to enhance the interaction with the practitioner, and has nothing to do with the acupuncture itself. Acupuncture is a clear example of selling a specific procedure based entirely on non-specific effects from the therapeutic interaction — a good bedside manner and some hopeful encouragement.”
Unfortunately, those who draft state legislation do not read SBM. They should. If they did, they wouldn’t be enacting acupuncture practice acts. But they do.
Through the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture or, in some cases, “oriental medicine,” is a licensed health care profession in 43 states. Like naturopaths, acupuncturists attempted to expand their geographic range in 2011 and, like chiropractors as well, tried to broaden their scope of practice to include methods and treatments far from their original tradition, wherever that may lie.
Kansas does not become the 44th state
Kansas does not license acupuncturists as a separate “healing art,”although, by statute, both naturopaths and veterinarians can employ acupuncture in their practices. In 2011, the “acupuncture and oriental medicine practice act” was introduced in the state Senate but never made it out of the Public Health and Welfare Committee.
Although it failed, it is worth reviewing for those unfamiliar with acupuncture practice acts as it demonstrates the startlingly broad scope of practice typically granted acupuncturists and “oriental medicine” practitioners by state law. It is as well a perfect example of legislative alchemy in its incorporation of sheer nonsense.
As with recent attempts by chiropractors to sound less chiropractic , acupuncturists are apparently trying to camouflage the more psuedoscientific- sounding concepts by re-casting them in what we might call faux biomedical language. Thus, nowhere in the Kansas legislation will you find any reference to “qi” or “meridians.” No, here acupuncture is
a form of health care that is based on a theory of energetic physiology that describes and explains the interrelationship of bodily organs or functions with an associated acupuncture point or combination of points that are stimulated in order to restore the normal function of the bodily organ or function.”
Thus, the “practice of acupuncture” is
the use of needles or of oriental medicine therapies for the purpose of normalizing energetic physiological functions including pain control and for the promotion, maintenance and restoration of health.”
“Qi” and “meridian” are out. “Energetic physiological functions” are in. And needles are not the only way to “normalize” these “energetic physiological functions.” Not by a long shot.
Acupuncturists would also have at their disposal “oriental medicine therapies.” And what exactly is “oriental medicine?” According to this proposed legislation, “oriental medicine”
means the distinct system of health care that uses health techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to diagnose, evaluate, examine, manage and treat for the prevention, cure or correction of disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function to restore, promote and maintain health.”
So, “oriental medicine” is health care that uses “oriental medicine.” Got it? I suppose the fact that it must achieve its purpose by “controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function” is somewhat of an explanation. I do not know, for there is no clue in the proposed statutory language, whether said “regulating the flow and balance of energy” etc. is the same thing as “normalizing energetic physiological functions.” Whatever that means.
In this vein of “daffy definitions,” we also learn that:
    • “biofeedback device” is “an instrument that is used to detect and amplify internal physiological processes and mental functioning.”
    • “herbal and animal-based substances” includes substances of “animal, vegetable or mineral origin.”(emphasis added) (I suppose the draftsman of this legislation missed that day in biology, or missed biology altogether.)
    • “Nutritional supplement means a nutritional substance, including a concentrate or extract of such a substance.” (That’s it — the entire definition.)
Under the proposed statute, the “practice of acupuncture includes, but is not limited to:”
dietary and nutritional counseling “based on traditional [but not "modern", apparently] Chinese medical principles”
recommendation, administration or dispensing of food, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, homeopathic preparations, amino acids or nutritional supplements (see above for definition).
So, homeopathy, supplements, diet, amino acids, vitamins, minerals, enzymes and biofeedback devices were all to become part of acupuncture practice under the new law. Apparently what acupuncturists, like chiropractors, really want to be is naturopaths.
Expanding scope of practice
Acupuncturists in Connecticut, where they are already licensed, were successful in expanding their practice by convincing the legislature to abandon any control over what they do as long as their practices are “consistent with accepted standards within the acupuncture and Oriental medicine profession.”
This was accomplished in a single section of a 98-section public health bill governing such diverse topics as regulation of day care, treatment of STDs, recording of vital statistics, and needle exchange programs. The term “sneaking it in” comes to mind.
Connecticut had already modernized, if you will, acupuncture by eschewing the old-fashioned terms “qi” and “meridians” for “the theory of physiological interrelationship of body organs with an associated point or combination of points for diseases, disorders and dysfunctions of the body.” The new practice act, however, abandons that definition for “modulation and restoration of normal function in and between the body’s energetic and organ systems and biomechanical, metabolic and circulation functions using stimulation of selected points.” Whether this is a new “theory” or simply a restatement of the old “theory” is not disclosed.
In any event, Connecticut acupuncturists are no longer limited to “needles, heat, pressure or electrical stimulation” of said points. Now any “method” is ok as long as it complies with the aforementioned “standards” of the “acupuncture and Oriental medicine profession.”
Also added as means for achieving “promotion and maintenance [as opposed to “modulation and restoration”] of normal function in the body’s energetic and organ system and biochemical, metabolic and circulation functions” are “Oriental dietary principles,” including (of course!) “supplements” and “other practices . . . consistent with the recognized standards of the . . . profession and accepted by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine.”
Acupuncturists can now also perform “assessment of body function, development of a comprehensive treatment plan and evaluation of treatment outcomes according to acupuncture and Oriental medicine theory.”
Putting it all together, the Connecticut acupuncturist will now be able to assess the body’s energetic system, treat the energetic system with any method consistent with professional standards, and know when the energetic system is modulated/restored/promoted/maintained through assessment of treatment outcomes. An amazing achievement considering that no research has ever demonstrated that this “energetic system” exists or what its properties might be.
The acupuncturist as naturopath
In addition to their try for licensing in Kansas, and success at expanding their scope of practice in Connecticut, acupuncturists attempted to become naturopaths in other states where they are already licensed. To date, success has eluded them.
In Ohio, a bill would have added a new type of practice — “Oriental Medicine” — separate from acupuncture, while at the same time increasing the scope of practice for acupuncturists. Acupuncturists would be allowed to use “supplemental techniques” including “the use of traditional and modern oriental therapeutics [the scope of which are not defined], counseling [including] the provision of information regarding lifestyle modifications and the therapeutic use of foods and supplements including homeopathics, gladulars, vitamins, and minerals.”
“Oriental medicine” practice, on the other hand, is defined as “a form of health care in which acupuncture is performed with or without the use of herbal therapy” which is not the same as “supplemental techniques” (see above). Once again demonstrating that one does not need to have taken biology to draft licensed health care provider legislation, “herbal therapy” is defined as “the use of herbs, vitamins, minerals, organ extracts, homeopathics or physiological materials for energetic or physiologic therapy.”
New York Senate and Assembly bills would expand “the profession of acupuncture” to allow “recommendation of traditional remedies and supplements including, but not limited to, the recommendation of diet, herbs and natural products, and their preparation in accordance with traditional and modern practices of modern East Asian or Oriental (Chinese, Korean or Japanese) medical theory.” What! No homeopathy?
Acupuncture for drug addiction
In Massachusetts, a bill would expand the scope of acupuncture practice to treat drug addiction via “Acupuncture Injection Therapy” defined as “the injection of herbs, homeopathic, and other nutritional supplements in the form of sterile substances into acupuncture points by means of hypodermic needles but not intravenous therapy.” The purpose of this is to “help prevent addiction to prescription drugs and prevent and reduce drug abuse; to promote, maintain, and restore health; for pain management and palliative care; and for acupuncture anesthesia.” This is so obviously dangerous that snark escapes me. The bill has not passed, although the Massachusetts legislature has not adjourned for the year.
“Acupuncture Injection Therapy” is not the only way acupuncture is used to treat substance abuse. In Colorado, licensed acupuncturists already use “five point NADA auricular acupuncture” which, as a bill summary explains, “is acupuncture done on the ear that is often used to treat substance abuse, mental health and behavioral health disorders.” “NADA” is the “National Acupuncture Detoxification Association.”
Apparently, other health care providers want to get in on the act, so proposed legislation would allow chiropractors, physicians, physician assistants, nurses, mental health professionals, and psychiatric technicians to perform this “five point NADA auricular acupuncture” but only if, as further explained in the summary, “they have successfully completed the proper training.” This bill actually made it to the Colorado House floor, where it failed to pass.
New Mexico
Faithful SBM readers will be wondering by now, “what about New Mexico, the state where anyone can practice medicine?” And they won’t be disappointed. There was, of course, a bill introduced in New Mexico to expand the acupuncturists’ scope of practice.
In New Mexico, as you might guess, acupuncturists already have limited prescriptive authority. Too limited, in their opinion.
First, they attempted to eliminate the requirement that prescription of “devices” be limited to those “necessary in the practice of oriental medicine.” As for drugs and their mode of administration, acupuncturists already had a formulary in the current practice act, but apparently didn’t like it. So, as did the New Mexico chiropractors, they tried to change it. It would have specifically included the following, although whether the acupuncturists could already prescribe and administer some of these under the current statute is unclear: subcutaneous and intramuscular epinephrine, injectable vitamin B-12, intradermal and subcutaneous injection of homeopathics, dextrose, minerals, sarapin and vitamins, and IV administration of water-soluble vitamins and minerals.
While, under the current statute, acupuncturists can prescribe “bioidentical hormones” they would be able to prescribe under the proposed expansion “topical estradiol, estriol, progesterone, testosterone and desiccated thyroid,” but only if the acupuncturist had “a signed collaborative practice agreement” with an M.D. or D.O. Thus, as with chiropractors and naturopaths who want to prescribe real drugs, adult supervision would be required. The bill died in committee. Even New Mexico has its standards.
Sticking needles in healthy people
As noted in the Introduction, research discloses that it doesn’t matter where you stick the needle in acupuncture. A bill introduced in the Oregon legislature was refreshingly honest about that fact. The bill, which died in committee, would have changed the statutory definition of acupuncture, currently “an Oriental health care practice used to promote health and to treat neurological, organic or functional disorders by the stimulation of specific points on the surface of the body by the insertion of needles.” “Oriental” would have been removed, as would have “specific points,” which simply became “points in and on the body.” In other words: stick it anywhere, it’s all the same.
As also noted, acupuncture doesn’t work. This makes it perfect for treating someone who isn’t sick, as a Pennsylvania bill — most certainly unintentionally — acknowledged. Under Pennsylvania law, acupuncturists can treat “a person’s condition” without the condition being diagnosed by a physician, dentist or podiatrist for 60 days. After that time, the treatment may continue only if the person “obtained a diagnosis of the treated condition” by a physician, dentist or podiatrist. A proposed amendment to this law would make these limitations inapplicable “if a person does not present any symptoms of a condition.”
It’s really the ideal “CAM” legislation — ineffective treatments for people who are not ill — and it may become state law. Both the House and Senate versions of this bill have made it to the floor of the Pennsylvania legislature, which meets year-round.
Conclusion
As I’ve said before, no person should be subjected to scientifically implausible diagnostic methods and treatments. States should be working to eliminate such practices, not giving out licenses to perpetuate them.
Which brings me to “The Cure,” anti-sCAM legislation I’ll be proposing in a future post. Stay tuned.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Acupuncture
Acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. Yet acupuncturists, defined as primary care practitioners in some states, are succeeding in licensing and practice expansion efforts in state legislatures.
Jann Bellamy on January 19, 2018
Link


Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. Its proposed mechanism of action is highly implausible and:
after decades of research and more than 3000 trials, acupuncture researchers have failed to reject the null hypothesis, and any remaining possible specific effect from acupuncture is so tiny as to be clinically insignificant.
In layman’s terms, acupuncture does not work – for anything.
Even the very CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), in its own weasel-worded way, comes close to conceding the point:
Research suggests that acupuncture can help manage certain pain conditions, but evidence about its value for other health conditions is uncertain. [Emphasis added.]
Somebody tell the state legislatures. Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, 47 states have legalized the practice of acupuncture along with, in some cases, Traditional Chinese, Oriental or East Asian medicine. In several states, acupuncture practice acts describe acupuncturists as primary care practitioners and/or give them the authority diagnose and treat any condition or disease. For example, in my state, Florida, the practice act says that acupuncture:
means a form of primary health care, based on traditional Chinese medical concepts and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs acupuncture diagnosis and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and diagnostic techniques, for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of disease. [Emphasis added.]
In Nevada,
“Acupuncture” means the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing the skin of the body to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy in the body and to cure, relieve or palliate:
(a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or
(b) Any wound, bodily injury or deformity. [Emphasis added.]
And in New Mexico:
“doctor of oriental medicine” means a person licensed as a physician to practice acupuncture and oriental medicine with the ability to practice independently, serve as a primary care provider and as necessary collaborate with other health care providers . . .
“oriental medicine” means the distinct system of primary health care that uses all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function to restore and maintain health. [Emphasis added.]
As with state chiropractic and naturopathic licensing, most states rely on a closed-loop system of education and examinations that is completely controlled by acupuncturists in determining who is qualified to become licensed. The National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM) administers the certification exams recognized by the states. Applicants for certification must have either graduated from schools accredited by the Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (ACAOM) or foreign schools meeting criteria set by the NCCAOM.
While the ACAOM is approved as an accrediting agency by the U.S. Department of Education, the Department does not review the scientific validity of what is taught or perform any independent analysis of the graduates’ ability to competently and safely practice. Its focus is on administrative matters and the financial stability of the schools. The ACAOM standards do not require a college degree for admission to an accredited acupuncture/Oriental Medicine school and only 500 hours of supervised patient care are required in accredited programs to graduate with a Master’s in acupuncture (700 hours for a Master’s in Oriental Medicine). A Master’s allows one to sit for the NCCAOM exam. In sum, someone with no college degree and 500 hours of clinical training can become a “primary care provider” in some states.
2017 bills
Today we look at bills filed in eleven states to license, or expand the practice of, acupuncturists during the 2017 state legislative sessions. Six were successful. Two bills were defeated; three remain pending.
Prior to last year, acupuncturists did not have a practice act in Wyoming. This year they succeeded in gaining one, although the Wyoming legislature stopped short of giving them the right to practice Oriental Medicine, which was eliminated in the final bill. Acupuncture is somewhat narrowly defined as inserting needles, with or without electric current or heat, into the body for:
therapeutic purpose of promoting, maintaining and restoring health, including [but, we note, not limited to] the treatment of dysfunctions of the body involving pain.
Wyoming also joins several states who’ve been bamboozled into thinking sticking needles into peoples’ ears, otherwise known as “auricular acupuncture,” is effective for substance abuse and mental health issues. Promoted based on an unpublished and cherry-picked review of the evidence by an organization called the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA), it is a perennial favorite with state legislatures looking to address mental health issues and drug abuse on the cheap.
New Hampshire enacted legislation creating something called a “Certified Acupuncture Detoxification Specialist,” who must be trained in the NADA protocol and supervised by an acupuncturist, although the “Specialist” needn’t be an acupuncturist himself. They can use “acu-detox” for:
behavioral health applications, including addictions, mental health, and disaster and emotional trauma.
One version of the bill specified that “acu-detox” could be used only in conjunction with other therapies but that bit of consumer protection against the ineffectiveness of pseudoscience in treating serious conditions was rejected.
Likewise, in Maine, a new law requires the state Department of Health and Human Services to develop a pilot project that will treat alcohol and substance abuse using the unproven NADA protocol. Fortunately, more sober minds prevailed in West Virginia, where a bill allowing the practice of NADA auricular acupuncture for chemical dependency failed.
Like their fellow CAM practitioners, naturopaths and chiropractors, once licensed, acupuncturists will return again and again to the state legislatures for practice expansion. In 2017, they succeeded in a big way in Illinois. There the legislature added the practice of “East Asian” medicine to the acupuncturists’ scope of practice, defined to include needle acupuncture, moxibustion, herbal medicine, and dietary supplements, among others, to:
normalize physiological functions, or for the treatment of diseases or dysfunctions of the body.
Acupuncture itself is broadly defined to include not only traditional needle acupuncture, but also far-infrared, electro- and magnetic stimulation, cold laser, cupping, dry needling (discussed below), and the bruising massage practice known as gua sha:

In a move reminiscent of the chiropractic lobby’s efforts to make chiropractic schools the arbiter of what chiropractors can and cannot do, Illinois practitioners of acupuncture and East Asian medicine are permitted to perform a differential diagnosis via principles and techniques taught in acupuncture schools, like the fanciful tongue and pulse diagnosis.
Acupuncture: ineffective but treats everything
Illinois practitioners must refer patients to a physician or dentist if the patient’s condition is beyond their scope of practice, which raises and interesting question: Just what is beyond the East Asian medicine/acupuncture practitioner’s scope of practice when he is permitted to perform a differential diagnosis (albeit based on total pseudoscience) and treat, without limitation, “diseases or dysfunctions of the body”?
If you consult the Acufinder acupuncture referral website, you’ll find acupuncture’s usefulness in treating disease is virtually unlimited:
Acupuncture and Chinese medicine are extremely successful in the treatment of a multitude of conditions. Many people try Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine as a “last resort” to serious and complex medical problems and find that it can help them when other treatments could not.
Acupuncture is also often used as a preventative medicine. Many people see their acupuncturist only 2-4 times a year for a “tune up” or “balancing” treatment. This can prevent disease and promote health, energy and vitality.
“While no means a complete list of what Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine can treat,” Acufinder lists, among many others, allergies, anemia, depression, high blood pressure, heart disease, bronchitis, impotence, infertility, fibrosis, candida, Epstein Barr virus, lupus, hepatitis, stroke, polio, emphysema and diabetes. No evidence is cited for any of these claims.
Acufinder is, by the way, on Heatlhline’s list of “Best Blogs: Alternative Medicine 2017.” Healthline, which is Hon@Code certified, apparently has a high tolerance for quackery. Sayer Ji’s GreenMedinfo blog, which our good friend Orac has anointed one of the “quackiest, crankiest sites on the Internet” (sample post: “The Homeopathic Answer to Mumps”) also made the list.
If we can’t trust Acufinder, how about a more responsible source for determining what acupuncture can successfully treat? How about the University of Miami’s Miller School of Medicine? Unfortunately, in a perfect example of “infiltrative pseudoscience,” the University agrees with Acufinder on a number of diseases and conditions “for which acupuncture is effective” or for which, more vaguely, “people commonly find acupuncture treatment to be effective,” including allergies, asthma, depression, high blood pressure, impotence, Bell’s palsy, infertility, heart disease, bronchitis, and stroke. In addition to “people,” the University lists the NIH (without any specific citations) and the discredited WHO report on acupuncture as its sources of evidence. Oddly, if the NIH really supports these claims, no one told the NIH’s own National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.
In fact, unsupported claims like those found on both Acufinder’s and the University of Miami’s websites appear to be more the norm than the exception. And herein lies the danger of Legislative Alchemy: States like Illinois give fantasy-based practitioners a broad scope of practice, allowing them to diagnose and treat both fake and very real diseases. Even presumably reliable sources, like medical schools, promote unproven (or disproven) uses, leaving the public with the false impression that acupuncture is effective for any number of conditions. (You can find another example here, from the University of California at San Francisco.)
A similar fate may await the citizens of Michigan, where a substantial practice expansion bill introduced in 2017 remains pending. Acupuncturists there are currently limited to needle acupuncture. In addition to giving acupuncturists licensed health care professional status, the bill would, like Illinois, give them the authority to diagnose and treat any disease or condition in patients of any age using “traditional and contemporary East Asian medical theory.” They would be able to use “electroacupuncture” (i.e., TENS rebranded as acupuncture), “dermal friction” (gua sha), cupping, herbal remedies, and homeopathy (which is German in origin, not East Asian). Acupuncturists could also supervise NADA-trained practitioners treating substance abuse.New Mexico, as noted, already defines acupuncturists as “primary care” practitioners and permits them to perform and order diagnostic testing, as well as practice bleeding. The state Board of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine can issue certificates expanding their practice to include the authority to compound drugs on their formulary, such as bioidentical hormones, and deliver these products by IV, as well as prescribing and administering live cell products, among others.
Fortunately, the New Mexico legislature refused to go further last year and allow the Board to issue certificates to practice “holistic integrative medicine” and add to the acupuncturists’ formulary “substances used for detoxification and chelation.” A bill permitting all that and more failed.
Mississippi and Nebraska used to require a physician referral for acupuncture treatment. Acupuncturists tried to dilute these patient protections in both states and succeeded, although Mississippi turned around and added even more limitations on their practice in the final bill. While the Mississippi legislature repealed the referral requirement, patients must, with very limited exceptions, have a physician evaluation within the last six months for the condition the acupuncturist will treat, and the acupuncturist must inform patients that acupuncture is not a substitute for medical care. Referral to a physician is required if the patient’s condition doesn’t improve and acupuncturists are prohibited from diagnosing.
Nebraska removed the referral requirement as well, but added that the acupuncturist must refer the patient to an “appropriate practitioner” if the condition is beyond his training, competence or experience. These limitations, as noted above, may not exist in the mind of the typical acupuncturist.
As if state budgets weren’t strained enough, pending companion House and Senate bills in Minnesota appropriate $375,000 of the public’s money to do what is essentially worthless “study” amounting to no more than a collection of anecdotes which will supposedly determine the effectiveness of acupuncture for pain and its potential to reduce opioid abuse. Why a much cheaper literature search on PubMed could not meet this goal is not explained, although the bills are perhaps a testament to the scientific illiteracy of the legislators who support it.
Finally, the turf wars: Physical therapists (PTs) and acupuncturists are fighting over a practice called “dry needling.” According to physical therapists, dry needling:
uses a thin filiform needle to penetrate the skin and stimulate underlying myofascial trigger points, muscular, and connective tissues for the management of neuromusculoskeletal pain and movement impairments.
It is based on, according to PTs, “western neuroanatomy and modern scientific study of the musculoskeletal and nervous system” and not on the mumbo jumbo of blocked “qi” and “meridians.” Just because the technique is similar to needle acupuncture, the American Physical Therapy Association points out, does not mean it constitutes the practice of acupuncture. Acupuncturists say it is just that and are trying to lock PTs out of using dry needling.
In addition to their huge practice expansion in Illinois, acupuncturists there convinced the legislature to define dry needling as “acupuncture,” thereby preventing PTs from performing it (unless they go to the trouble of getting a license to practice acupuncture). A similar bill defining dry needling as the practice of acupuncture remains pending in Massachusetts.
You can follow pending acupuncture/Oriental medicine/East Asian medicine/Traditional Chinese medicine (as well as chiropractic and naturopathic) bills on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website and find out how to contact your state legislators about them. Bills introduced in 2018 will be added to the SfSBM website soon.

Legislative Alchemy 2018: Acupuncturists seek practice expansion and competition elimination 
Acupuncturists want to expand their scope of practice far beyond sticking needles in people. Too many states are allowing them to treat pretty much anything with unproven and potentially dangerous remedies.
Jann Bellamy on January 3, 2019
Link

In the third and final installment in our annual review of Legislative Alchemy – the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience into health care via legislation – we take a look at 2017-2018 bills aiming to license and expand the scope of practice of acupuncturists and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practitioners, as well as eliminate their competition. (We previously covered chiropractic and naturopathic Legislative Alchemy.)
Acupuncture occupies an exalted place in the pantheon of CAM practices. Though it is no more scientifically plausible or evidence-based than a number of other CAM modalities generally rejected by “conventional” medicine (e.g., chiropractic, naturopathy, homeopathy), acupuncture has been embraced by the medical community.
The University of California San Diego School of Medicine’s Center for Integrative Medicine, for example, promotes acupuncture for a long list of diseases and conditions. The Center claims that “case-controlled clinical studies have shown that acupuncture has been an effective treatment” for, among others, leukopenia (low white blood cell count), turning a breech fetus, hypertension, and allergic rhinitis.
In the first place, case-control studies cannot determine the efficacy of a treatment. And, in fact, there is no reliable evidence (also here) that acupuncture is effective for any of these. The list specifically ignores a Cochrane Review conclusion that there is “no evidence that acupuncture is useful in the management of long-lasting hypertension.”
Disturbingly, the Center goes on to list several dozen more diseases and conditions for which it claims acupuncture has “limited but probable evidence” (that is, even less evidence) to support its therapeutic use, including bronchial asthma, cholecystitis (gallbladder inflammation), diabetes, hyperlipaemia, and schizophrenia.
The whole webpage is, in my view, irresponsible and potentially dangerous, yet is a useful demonstration of the credulous acceptance of acupuncture by the medical community.
Even putting aside the absurdity of promoting acupuncture to patients for all manner of ills, what most medical doctors likely don’t realize is that many acupuncturists have an extremely broad scope of practice, or would like to, if the push for initial licensing or practice expansion to include diagnosis and treatment far beyond sticking needles in “acupuncture points” is any indication. Thus, thanks to state legislators, a physician referring a patient to an acupuncturist will, perhaps unknowingly, expose the patient to the entire panoply of pseudoscience encompassed by a particular state’s acupuncture practice act.
Acupuncture “primary care”
Acupuncturists are licensed or otherwise regulated health care professionals in 47 states. A few states, like Michigan, limit the practice to needle acupuncture, although Michigan does not limit the diseases or conditions acupuncturists can treat. Other states give acupuncturists the authority to practice Traditional Chinese Medicine, with its plethora of pseudoscientific diagnoses and treatments (not to mention its threat to endangered species) or otherwise grant broad scopes of practice, including, in some cases, describing acupuncture as “primary care.” A few examples [boldface added in quotes]:
Nevada’s practice act defines “Oriental medicine” as
that system of the healing art which places the chief emphasis on the flow and balance of energy in the body mechanism as being the most important single factor in maintaining the well-being of the organism in health and disease.
“Acupuncture” is defined as
the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing the skin of the body to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy to cure, relieve, or palliate: (a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or (b) Any wound, bodily injury or deformity.
Even though most herbal remedies are unproven and too many contain contaminants and substitutions, “herbal medicine” is defined as:
Suggesting, recommending, prescribing or directing the use of herbs for the cure, relief or palliation of any ailment or disease of the mind or body, or for the cure or relief of any wound, bodily injury or deformity.
My state, Florida, defines “acupuncture” as
a form of primary health care, based on traditional Chinese medical concepts and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs acupuncture diagnosis and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and diagnostic techniques, for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of disease.
The Florida Board of Acupuncture has expansively interpreted “adjunctive therapies and diagnostic techniques” to include reflexology, laser biostimulation, Kirlian photography, thermography, nutritional counseling, and recommendation of homeopathic remedies.
And in Arkansas,
Acupuncture’ means the insertion, manipulation, and removal of needles from the body and the use of other modalities and procedures at specific locations on the body for the prevention, cure, or correction of a malady, illness, injury, pain, or other condition or disorder by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy and function of the patient to restore and maintain health.
In Arkansas’s practice act “related techniques” include magnets, cold laser, and something called “ion pumping cord.” The Arkansas State Board of Acupuncture has enacted rules which take the scope of acupuncture practice even further to include ordering radiological, laboratory, or other diagnostic tests, Oriental medicine injection therapy, biofeedback, and prescription or administration of homeopathic medicine, enzymes, and glandulars. The rules also permit:
The stimulation of points or areas of the body using needles, heat, cold, light, lasers, sound, vibration, magnetism, electricity, bleeding, suction, pressure, Gua Sha, or other devices or means.
Yes, you read that right: Bleeding patients is perfectly legal in Arkansas.
2017-2018 Bills: licensing, practice expansion, turf wars
Despite their stunning successes in incorporating nonsense into law in most states, it looks like acupuncturists will suffer the same fate as naturopaths this year, with a complete shutout. And, as was the case with its naturopathic licensing bill, Michigan turned out to be a real nail biter.
Michigan, as mentioned, currently allows acupuncturists to register with the state and limits their practice to needle acupuncture. Senate Bill 683 would have allowed acupuncturists to become licensed and vastly expand their scope of practice to include laser acupuncture, electroacupuncture and dry needling as well as “dermal friction” (gua sha), cupping, prescribing herbal remedies, and homeopathy (which has nothing to do with TCM). Acupuncturists would be able to diagnose and treat any disease or condition in patients of any age using “traditional and contemporary East Asian medical theory,” which is undefined.
The bill would also allow the practice of auricular acupuncture for substance abuse treatment, under the supervision of an acupuncturist or physician, by anyone with a certification from the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA). NADA auricular acupuncture is based on a highly implausible mechanism of action and has never been proven effective for substance abuse. NADA’s promotion of auricular acupuncture is based on an unpublished and cherry-picked review of the evidence.
SB 683 passed in the Senate, successfully navigated the House committee system, then made it to a second reading before the full House. Thankfully, the clock ran out before the bill came up for a final vote.
Oklahoma is one of the three states that does not license or otherwise officially regulate acupuncturists. Three different licensing bills were introduced in the state Senate. Two bills (Senate Bills 1119 and 1501) contained similar provisions, permitting needle acupuncture for “promoting, maintaining and restoring health” even though acupuncture has not been proven to do any of these things, including alleviation of pain. They also permitted the practice of NADA auricular acupuncture for treating mental and emotional health, post and acute trauma, substance abuse, and chemical dependency. An acupuncture board would regulate acupuncturists, giving the fox the keys to the henhouse.
Senate Bill 1523 went even further, describing acupuncture as “primary health care” and allowing acupuncturists to diagnose, using fanciful methods like tongue and pulse diagnosis. Acupuncturists could, in addition to needle acupuncture, employ moxibustion, herbal therapies, and “other adjunctive properties”, and practice Oriental medicine. Under SB 1523, regulation would be under the state osteopathic board in consultation with an acupuncture committee.
Despite the full-court press of having three licensing bills introduced in one session, all failed.
In West Virginia, House Bill 4465 created NADA-trained “auricular acupuncture detoxification specialists” and would have allowed these “specialists” to perform “auricular acudetox” for the treatment of substance abuse, alcoholism, chemical dependency, detoxification, behavioral therapy, and trauma recovery. The bill actually passed in the House and Senate. The session ended before House could concur in a Senate amendment, dooming the bill.
In Minnesota, proposed legislation (Senate Bill 1958; House Bill 2389) would have the state spend $375,000 of taxpayer funds to study acupuncture for pain relief and the potential of acupuncture treatments to reduce opioid prescriptions. Here’s how the “study” would be conducted:
The study shall include collection of data from at least 200 cases where an individual receiving acupuncture treatment for pain relief had more than six but not more than 30 acupuncture treatments within a six-month period. Data shall be collected from at least ten treatment sites and ten referral sites, including both rural and urban sites. . . . The report shall analyze the collected data . . . from the referral practitioner, the treatment practitioner, and the individual participant.
In other words, a $375,000 unrandomized, uncontrolled, and unblinded collection of anecdotes, which would prove nothing. Fortunately, the state treasury won’t have to shell out the money because the bills failed.
There is a turf war going on between acupuncturists and physical therapists over the practice of “dry needling.” Acupuncturists claim that dry needling is the practice of acupuncture and sought to enshrine their view in Massachusetts law (House Bill 3247; Senate Bill 1182) by defining the insertion of filiform needles as acupuncture, thereby granting themselves a monopoly on the practice. Physical therapists disagree, pointing out that
The objectives and philosophy behind the use of dry needling by physical therapists is not based on ancient theories or tenets of traditional Chinese medicine. The performance of modern dry needling by physical therapists is based on western neuroanatomy and modern scientific study of the musculoskeletal and nervous systems.
The PTs won this particular battle; both bills died in committee.
The only legislative victories for acupuncturists were minor and did not involve initial licensing or practice expansion. Louisiana eliminated a requirement that acupuncturists have a relationship with a physician to provide for referrals and follow-up care. California extended the Acupuncture Board and its authority to regulate acupuncturists to 2023.
Public health, safety and welfare? Where?
The majority of state legislatures convene this month for a new session and the rest will soon follow. Acupuncturists, chiropractors, and naturopaths will be waiting at the statehouse doors with freshly-drafted bills granting them licensure and practice expansion. To my knowledge, other than delicensing naturopaths in a handful of states or making the practice illegal, no legislation has ever been introduced protecting the public from the useless and sometimes dangerous diagnoses and treatments CAM practitioners foist on patients. This is despite the fact that the states’ authority to regulate health care practitioners is constitutionally grounded in the police power, that is, the authority to protect the public’s health, welfare and safety. They are doing just the opposite. As Steve Novella pointed out just yesterday, it is high time politicians put patients ahead of these profiteers of pseudoscience.

Legislative Alchemy 2019: Acupuncturists score Medicare coverage and scope of practice expansion 
Through the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture has already scored some big wins in 2020, including Medicare coverage.
Jann Bellamy on February 13, 2020
Link
Today we take a look at how the magic of Legislative Alchemy managed to incorporate even more pseudoscience into the American health care system in 2019 via licensing and scope of practice expansion, as well as taxpayer-funded insurance coverage, for acupuncturists. Based on a mythical, pre-scientific system of invisible meridians guiding an ethereal “energy” through the body, acupuncture has successfully invaded the most prominent medical institutions because, well, “integrative” medicine. Attempts to put lipstick on a pig by proposing a physiological basis for acupuncture’s methods and effects (such as they are) remain unconvincing and acupuncture is, in fact, a theatrical placebo.
Unfortunately, none of that matters to policy makers who succumb to the siren song of “popularity” or are just too scientifically illiterate to know better, or both. Riding acupuncture’s coattails into the realm of government-approved fantasy medicine, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), also known as East Asian Medicine, also known as Eastern Medicine, also known as Oriental Medicine, has become a licensed health care profession as well. Unbound by the strictures of science and the scientific method, practitioners claim success in treating cancer, asthma, allergies, infertility, neurological disorders, and cardiovascular disease, among other conditions. In fact, according to them, they can treat pretty much anything.
As with climate change denial and anti-vaccination propaganda, the rejection of evidence in favor of ideology and a good, old-fashioned profit motive can beat back science again and again. Now, on to the specifics.
Medicare coverage
Last July, I wrote a post titled “Medicare proposal covers acupuncture for back pain study participants: A prelude to full coverage?” And the answer is – yes, just without a the study. At the time, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (which makes Medicare coverage decisions) said:
While we believe the evidence is promising, we do not believe the evidence is sufficient at this time for representative older patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain. We believe additional research would be needed in order to make a favorable coverage determination . . .
Yet, without a jot of additional evidence, in January, 2020, the Trump administration announced it was skipping the proposed study and going straight to a decision allowing Medicare coverage of acupuncture for chronic low back pain for up to 12 visits in 90 days, with an additional 8 sessions for patients demonstrating an improvement. “Chronic low back pain” is defined as lasting 12 weeks or longer, nonspecific (i.e., not related to an identifiable cause, like infectious disease), and not associated with surgery or pregnancy. (Why pregnancy? Because Medicare beneficiaries can be under age 65 in certain circumstances.) If the patient is not improving, treatment must be discontinued.
But what kind of acupuncture? After all, SBM contributor emeritus Dr. Mark Crislip found
over 30 different types of acupuncture with many different modes of operation and fantasy explanations for their claimed effectiveness.
CMS doesn’t say. Given the seemingly boundless inventiveness of practitioners in fabricating new forms of “acupuncture”, expect this new revenue source to get their creative juices flowing. (CMS does say it considers “dry needling” to be “a type of acupuncture”.)
Even while covering acupuncture, without admitting it out loud, there seems to be a recognition that it is not a good idea to let acupuncturists, or chiropractors, loose with a big wad of taxpayer money. Physicians providing acupuncture “in accordance with applicable state requirements” are covered. Physician assistants and nurse practitioners/clinical nurse specialists are covered if they also have a degree in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine and a state license to practice acupuncture. Acupuncturists having a degree and a state license, but without other professional credentials, referred to in the decision as “auxiliary personnel”, are covered only if supervised by a physician, P.A. or nurse practitioner/clinical nurse specialist. Acupuncture provided by chiropractors, even if allowed by their state license, is not covered.
Licensing
Oklahoma is one of the few states that does not license acupuncturists. Introduced in 2019, pending Senate Bill 734 would change that by licensing acupuncturists to insert “acupuncture needles into the body”, with or without using an electric current or heat,
for the therapeutic purpose of promoting, maintain and restoring health, including the treatment of dysfunctions of the body involving pain . . .
Interestingly, the bill, unlike other licensing acts, does not acknowledge the existence any mystical meridians, their imagined blockage, or their putative unblocking via insertion of needles at specific points. That is not to say this omission is an improvement: It is hard to imagine what disease or condition wouldn’t fall under this fuzzy definition, including cancer.
“Auricular acupuncture” is separately licensed and approved for “treating mental and emotional health, post and acute trauma, substance abuse and chemical dependency” even though there is no reliable evidence that this highly implausible method (basically, sticking needles in the outer ear) is effective for anything.
Acupuncturists would be regulated by a Board of Acupuncture consisting of three acupuncturists, one public member, and one licensed health care professional who is not an acupuncturist. Given the expansive array of conditions both acupuncturists and auricular acupuncturists are authorized to treat, and the history of acupuncture boards fluffing the regulations with all manner of accessory pseudoscience, one can expect an equally expansive approach to the Board’s “promulgat[ing] rules and regulations as necessary to carry out this act”.
On the bright side, SB 734 was introduced over a year ago and has yet to have a committee hearing scheduled. This may prevent its meeting a March legislative deadline for further consideration.
More auricular acupuncture
Auricular acupuncture was also on the 2019 legislative agendas of West Virginia, Maine and Massachusetts. Like all auricular acupuncture legislation, the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA), which heavily promotes the practice, is written into the regulatory requirements for attaining a certificate or license, typically by adopting the NADA protocol for auricular acupuncture as the statutory definition of the practice or requiring NADA training.
In West Virginia, House Bill 2324 was signed into law, allowing certain licensed health care professionals (e.g., nurses, psychologists, and chiropractors) and others (e.g., social workers, emergency medical service providers) to practice “auricular acudetox” therapy “for the treatment of substance abuse, alcoholism, chemical dependency, detoxification, behavioral therapy, or trauma recovery.”
The Maine Legislature passed legislation (House Bill 809) creating a separate license for the NADA-trained “auricular acupuncture detoxification specialist”, who is allowed to treat “substance use and co-occurring disorders” as part of an established treatment program. Only alcohol and drug counselors, physicians, physicians assistants, nurses, nurse practitioners, psychologists and other professional counselors are eligible for licensing but they (physicians, PAs, and nurses included) can practice only under the supervision of a licensed acupuncturist. (An acupuncturist’s scope of practice would already include auricular acupuncture.)
Similar to Maine, bills were introduced in 2019 in Massachusetts (House Bill 1880, Senate Bill 1336) allowing physicians, nurses, psychologists, and other types of mental health practitioners trained by NADA to register as “acupuncture detoxification specialists” for “the treatment of addictions, mental and behavioral health, disaster relief, and emotional trauma”, but only under the supervision of a licensed acupuncturist. Those bills remain pending in 2020.
Practice expansion
With licensing come the perennial pleas for practice expansion. A popular ask is getting the legislature to take the mere sticking-needles-in-people variety of acupuncture and infuse it with the virtually unlimited quackery that Oriental/Traditional Chinese/East Asian/Eastern Medicine offers the practitioner. Maybe, instead of the abbreviation “TCM”, we should use “OTCEAEM” to cover all the bases, since they appear to differ in name only. For example, Maryland House Bill 404, signed by the Governor into law, changes “oriental” to “East Asian” medicine in the acupuncture practice act. “Normalizing energetic physiological functions” is the purpose of both, according to Maryland law.
This new law incorporates some stealth practice expansion as well. Like the proposed Oklahoma practice act, the legislature seems to be dumping the idea that acupuncture is limited to specified “points” on the body. (Maybe because no one can find them?) Thus, while the old acupuncture was based on “a theory of energetic physiology that describes the interrelationship of the body organs or functions with an associated point or combination of points”, the new acupuncture is “based on East Asian medical theories” that describe this same interrelationship, but all references to “points” are stricken from the law. The old definition of acupuncture included “stimulation of points of the body by the insertion of acupuncture needles.” The new definition eliminates “points of” and “acupuncture”.
In a similar practice-expanding vein, references to specific treatments included in the scope of practice (e.g., herbal and nutritional therapies) have been largely eliminated in favor of the far more elastic “East Asian medical therapies . . . performed in according with the principles of East Asian medical theories and practices”. All of this will leave the State Acupuncture Board (five acupuncturists, two public members) with plenty of room to fill in the regulatory blanks. Interestingly, it was on the Board’s recommendation that the legislature “updated” the definition of acupuncture “to more accurately reflect the therapies that are currently practiced by the acupuncture profession.”
Michigan is a textbook example of using a lower tier of acupuncture regulation as a springboard to becoming a licensed healthcare profession, with the state imprimatur of legitimacy that designation (falsely) bestows. Prior to a new law enacted last year, acupuncturists simply registered with the state. Now, thanks to the magic of Legislative Alchemy, acupuncturists are a licensed profession with a broad scope of practice that goes far beyond traditional needle acupuncture.
As Dr. David Gorski, SBM’s managing editor and a Michigan resident, described in his post on what was then a bill pending before the legislature, acupuncturists are, under the new law, allowed to use all sorts of acupuncture techniques: laser, electroacupuncture, dry needling and “intramuscular stimulation”. In addition to treatments one normally associates with traditional acupuncture practice, like moxibustion, cupping, and dermal friction, the new law includes the practice of “East Asian medicine”, which is not defined – a list “includes” certain practices, like herbal medicines, but “is not limited to” those practices – leaving an big, amorphous canvas upon which to paint a definition of one’s choosing. Case in point: Per the new law, East Asian medicine includes manual therapy, dietary counseling, therapeutic exercise, lifestyle coaching and homeopathy. Yes, homeopathy, German in origin, is now a part of East Asian medicine because the Michigan legislature said so. And, in an example of how slapping the term “East Asian medicine” on just about any method magically transplants it into the East Asian canon, “lifestyle coaching” is defined as “the process of advising a patient about healthy lifestyle choices and habits in accordance with East Asian medical theory”.
And who better to help fill in that canvas than the Michigan Board of Acupuncture, consisting of seven acupuncturists, three physicians, and three public members (you do the math), which is granted the authority to write the rules governing acupuncture and “East Asian” practice. As Dr. Gorski pointed out:
That’s the problem with the state regulating quackery. It isn’t science-based practitioners defining the standard of care and educational requirements for “professions” like acupuncture. It’s the quacks themselves.
In an example of poaching legitimate medical techniques to further quackery, Utah granted acupuncturists limited prescription privileges in 2019 by giving them the authority to employ “injection therapy”. This is defined as using a hypodermic needle to inject, either subcutaneously or intramuscularly, any of the following substances, in liquid form, into acupuncture points:
    • A nutritional substance (a term that is undefined, but presumably includes, at the least, substances that are classified as dietary supplements if taken by mouth, such as vitamins, minerals, and herbs)
    • A local anesthetic
    • Autologous blood (for what purpose, I have no idea)
    • Sterile water
    • Dextrose
    • Sodium bicarbonate
    • Sterile saline
“Injection therapy” cannot be performed on pregnant women or children under eight. But taking your nine-year-old to an acupuncturist for an injection of his own blood is perfectly acceptable to the Utah legislature.
Bills before the Rhode Island Senate and House attempted to change “Oriental medicine” to “Chinese medicine”, expand the scope of practice, and add NADA-trained auricular acupuncture practitioners to the practice act. Fortunately, they failed.
Like other bills creating variously-named auricular acupuncture practitioners, this one limited the practice to physicians, PAs, nurses and nurse practitioners, and mental health professionals, who would be called “auricular acupuncture technicians”, an appellation that doesn’t seem particularly appealing to health care professionals. Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine would include both traditional “pulse, tongue, palpation and observational diagnosis” as well as “diagnostic techniques based on newer scientific models”, another squishy term left to the imagination of practitioners. Acupuncture, “adjunct therapies”, and “Chinese herbal medicine” could be used “for the treatment of any ailment”. Herbal medicine included both preparation of formulas from Chinese herbal literature, modifications of those formulas, and “writing of new formulas”. In other words, in addition to mixing up herbal remedies other people made up, you could make up your own!
In Washington, a bill passed changing “East Asian medicine” to “acupuncture and Eastern medicine” in state law, as well as changing “East Asian medicine practitioner” to “Acupuncturist” or “Acupuncturist and Eastern medicine practitioner”. And, straight from a report of the House Committee on Health Care & Wellness:
A person licensed as an Acupuncturist may use the title Acupuncturist, Acupuncturist and Eastern medicine practitioner, or East Asian medicine practitioner and use the letters L. Ac., EAMP, or AEMP.
Well, that should clear things up!
Another Washington bill expands the scope of practice for acupuncturists (and whatever other names they go by) by defining their practice as “a holistic system of medicine” which includes “using needles therapeutically”, and
diagnosing and treating conditions according to medical traditions from China, Japan, Korea, and other East Asian countries, and application of modern evidence-based research to maintain and promote wellness, prevent, manage, and reduce pain, manage substance abuse disorder [including NADA auricular acupuncture], and prevent, diagnose, and treat conditions and diseases.
Query what wouldn’t be covered by this broad definition.
Washington acupuncturists (etc.) already have the authority to use injection therapy, which includes, in liquid form, herbs, minerals, vitamins, and homeopathic and “nutritional” substances. The bill would add the right to use oxygen, epinephrine and medical ozone “for potential emergency purposes” even though the FDA issued a rule in 2016 stating that “ozone is a toxic gas with no known useful medical application in specific, adjunctive, or preventive therapy”, effectively banning its use by banning the manufacture and sale of devices that produce it, although quacks still manage to get their hands on these machines.
Apparently, this last bill remains pending, held over from the 2019. If not, no worries. A 2020 bill has been introduced amending the acupuncture practice act with essentially the same provisions, minus (thankfully) the ozone. It never ends. Stay tuned.

Acupuncture practice acts: legalized quackery
Jann Bellamy on August 23, 2012
Tweet

As Ben Kavoussi observed recently,
[o]nce considered archaic and obsolete, Oriental Medicine has greatly benefited from the postmodern attitudes towards science and knowledge. This is because postmodernists consider the ‘truth’ as being relative to one’s viewpoint or stance. They do not see science as a superior process of acquiring knowledge, but as a ‘belief system,’ a ‘language game,’ which does not give more access to truth than other conceptual constructs.
This “postmodern fallacy,” he continued,
has allowed the return of mass professional delusions under the label of Chinese, Oriental or Asian Medicine. As an unfortunate byproduct, dangerous and outdated therapies have been legitimized, and quacks and charlatans can overtly defraud those who cannot distinguish scientific medicine from lore and fantasy.
There is probably no better example of this “unfortunate byproduct” than the state acupuncture and oriental medicine practice acts. These laws have indeed legitimized dangerous and outdated therapies, allowing quacks and charlatans to defraud the public.
State practice acts
Via the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture, or sometimes, more broadly, Oriental or Traditional Chinese medicine, is a licensed health care practice in 44 states in the U.S. and the District of Columbia. As with all licensed health care practices, each state defines the acupuncturists’ scope of practice via legislation commonly referred to as a practice act.
Some states, perhaps unwilling to let the genie fully escape the bottle, allow acupuncture only by prescription or under the supervision of a physician. Others, like New Jersey and New York, at least require that an acupuncturist advise patients about the importance of consulting with a licensed physician regarding the patient’s condition. In Louisiana, only physicians can become acupuncturists.
Yet in many states acupuncturists enjoy a broad and unsupervised scope of practice. Here’s a sample of practice acts typical in their definition of acupuncture and oriental medicine.
New Mexico:
‘acupuncture’ means the surgical use of needles inserted into and removed from the body and the use of other devices, modalities and procedures at specific locations on the body for the prevention, cure or correction of any disease, illness, injury, pain or other condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy and function to restore and maintain health.
‘oriental medicine’ means the distinct system of primary health care that uses all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function to restore and maintain health.
Florida:
‘Acupuncture’ means a form of primary health care, based on traditional Chinese medical concepts and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs acupuncture diagnosis and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and diagnostic techniques, for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of disease.
Maryland:
‘Practice acupuncture’ means the use of oriental medical therapies for the purpose of normalizing energetic physiological functions including pain control, and for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health.
Colorado:
‘Acupuncture’ means a system of health care based upon traditional oriental medical concepts that employs oriental methods of diagnosis, treatment, and adjunctive therapies for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of disease.
Arkansas:
‘Acupuncture’ means the insertion, manipulation, and removal of needles from the body and the use of other modalities and procedures at specific locations on the body for the prevention, cure, or correction of a malady, illness, injury, pain, or other condition or disorder by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy and function of the patient to restore and maintain health.
New Hampshire:
‘Oriental medicine means the distinct system of health care that diagnoses and treats illness, injury, pain, or other conditions by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy to restore and maintain health.
Nevada:
Nevada is even more expansive in its definition of Oriental medicine, which includes both the practice of acupuncture and herbal medicine. “Oriental medicine” is
that system of the healing art which places the chief emphasis on the flow and balance of energy in the body mechanism as being the most important single factor in maintaining the well-being of the organism in health and disease.
“Acupuncture” is defined as
the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing the skin of the body to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy to cure, relieve, or palliate:
(a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or
(b) Any wound, bodily injury or deformity.
“Herbal medicine” is
Suggesting, recommending, prescribing or directing the use of herbs for the cure, relief or palliation of any ailment or disease of the mind or body, or for the cure or relief of any wound, bodily injury or deformity.
Public health and safety?
A state’s constitutional authority to regulate health care practices is based on the state’s power to protect the public health, welfare and safety. Indeed, some of the practice acts begin with a statement about how the state needs to regulate acupuncture and oriental medicine in the interest of the public’s health and safety. Of course, as Dr. Edzard Ernst pointed out, “the most meticulous regulation of nonsense must still result in nonsense.” With acupuncture and oriental medicine, the nonsense is pernicious.
A cure for disease?
Note how each practice act assumes acupuncturists and oriental medicine practitioners can diagnose and effectively prevent or cure actual disease, among other supposed benefits. One can accept this as true only by believing in the entire traditional oriental medicine myth, aptly defined almost 80 years ago by a Chinese medical school dean as a “weird medley of philosophy, religion, superstition, magic, alchemy, astrology, feng shui, divination, sorcery, demonology and quackery.” I can only assume the good Southern Baptist lawmakers who populate the legislatures here in the deep South, where I live, had no clue about oriental medicine’s true nature when they voted for these practice acts. In fact, I’ll bet the vast majority of state legislators who made acupuncture and oriental medicine a licensed health care practice had no idea that they were legalizing superstition, magic, astrology, sorcery and demonology. They really should pay more attention to what they are voting on.
Legitimizing this “weird medley” has real consequences for the public. Acupuncturists claim they can treat a wide range of diseases and conditions. A small sample includes malaria, anorexia, fever, parasitic diseases, asthma, dementia, depression, epilepsy, paralysis, uterine bleeding, convulsions, heart palpitations, diabetes and jaundice. And it is perfectly legal for them to do so under many of the state practice acts.
Acupuncturists as primary care providers?
In enacting these practice acts, the states give acupuncture and oriental medicine an undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy by making it a form of “health care.” In Florida and New Mexico, it is specifically described as “primary health care.” After declaring oriental medicine is “a system of primary health care,” here’s how New Mexico defines “primary care provider,” and therefore defines an oriental medicine practitioner, in the practice act:
a health care practitioner acting within the scope of the health care practitioner’s license who provides the first level of basic or general health care for a person’s health needs, including diagnostic and treatment services, initiates referrals to other health care practitioners and maintains the continuity of care when appropriate.
Even without such explicit language, by allowing oriental diagnostic methods and treatment “for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of disease” the scope of acupuncture practice in some states approaches that of an M.D. or D.O. Compare this to the standard definition of the practice of medicine, this from Florida:
the diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription for any human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or other physical or mental condition.
It would appear the only real difference is in the methods of diagnosis and treatment employed. For example, by law an M.D. can treat with surgery and prescription drugs, whereas an acupuncturist cannot. Yet, according to the language of their respective practice acts, both can diagnose and treat any disease.
Adjunctive quackery
As well, these practice acts, and the regulations enacted pursuant to them, give acupuncturists the right to use a smorgasbord of implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments that go far beyond simply using needles to manipulate “qi.”
For example, by incorporating “modern oriental medicine concepts,” the door is left open to add to the existing implausible and unproven “oriental diagnosis and treatment” methods currently being passed off as “ancient.” Simply by labeling a “concept” as “modern,” new “concepts,” no matter how ill conceived, can legitimately fall within the permissible scope of practice.
In addition to “oriental medical diagnosis and treatment,” “adjunctive” or “related” treatments are legally permissible. Because that term is left undefined, again the door is left open to add whatever acupuncturists deem “adjunctive,” whether it be additional forms of quackery or legitimate means that acupuncturists would seem ill-suited to employ. For example, in Florida, the Board of Acupuncture has decided the following are “adjunctive:” reflexology, laser biostimulation, Kirlian photography, thermograpy, nutritional counseling, lifestyle and stress counseling, and recommendation of homeopathic remedies.
In Arkansas’s practice act, “related techniques” include magnets, cold laser, ion pumping cord, lifestyle counseling, eating guidelines, massage incidental to acupuncture, and exercise techniques. The Arkansas State Board of Acupuncture and Related Techniques has enacted regulations which take the scope of acupuncture practice even further to include ordering radiological, laboratory or other diagnostic tests, Oriental medicine injection therapy, physical medicine modalities and techniques, biofeedback, and prescription or administration of homeopathic medicine, enzymes, and glandulars. The regulations also permit:
The stimulation of points or areas of the body using needles, heat, cold, light, lasers, sound , vibration, magnetism, electricity, bleeding, suction, pressure, Gua Sha, or other devices or means.
That’s right. The barbaric practice of bleeding is legal in Arkansas.
Bleeding is also legal in New Hampshire, thanks to regulations adopted by the New Hampshire Board of Acupuncture Licensing. The Board’s regulations also permit “insertion and retention, for days or weeks, of intradermal needles or press tacks in acupuncture points.” And the Board allows acupuncturists to use (as defined in the regulations):
craniosacral therapy – “a treatment approach using gentle massage pressure to rebalance the craniosacral system”
polarity therapy – “a holistic therapy that combines bodywork, dietary adjustments, and exercises to restore the balance of the body’s vital energy through correction of the electromagnetic field of the body”
reiki – “a Japanese energy therapy that uses energy transmission to balance the biofield that surrounds the human body”
therapeutic touch –“ an energetic therapy . . . that employs a laying-on-of-hands technique based on oriental theories of energy flow”
zero balancing — “a touch technique for aligning the body’s energy and musculoskeletal system”
Which raises a few questions in my mind, if you’ll permit me a bit of digression. If you are sick, how does the New Hampshire acupuncturist know which system is out of whack? Or does being sick automatically mean that all of your systems – craniosacral, electromagnetic, energy flow, biofield and the alignment of your energy and musculoskeletal system – are malfunctioning? If so, it’s going to get awfully expensive to treat your illness. Time consuming too, what with having to spend all that time in treatment. And how does the acupuncturist know when your systems are properly aligned or balanced or flowing or whatever it is they are supposed to be doing?
Conclusion
Just yesterday, Steve Novella observed how the pseudoscience of homeopathy is a fraud being perpetrated on the public and how governments and regulatory agencies which are supposed to protect the public from medical fraud have failed to do so. Here we have yet another example of a pseudoscientific “CAM” practice foisted off on the public as legitimate medicine with the blessing of the government.
Acupuncture and oriental medicine belong in the Middle Ages, not in modern health care. We know acupuncture doesn’t work. And while some of the herbs used in oriental medicine may work, we can’t know that until they go through properly conducted drug trials. Licensing acupuncturists and oriental medicine practitioners and giving them the right to “diagnose,” “prevent” and “cure” disease and to employ other nonsensical “CAM” practices and products is most certainly not in the best interest of the public’s health, safety and welfare. Unfortunately, the problem is only getting worse as acupuncture schools crank out more graduates who then get their state licenses and go into practice.

California Acupuncture Board: a Mockery of Consumer Protection
Ben Kavoussi on June 22, 2012
Link
Many of the specific issues that the Governor and the Legislature asked the Commission to review have festered because the [California] Acupuncture Board has often acted as a venue for promoting the profession rather than regulating the profession.
— Little Hoover Commission, Regulation of Acupuncture: A Complementary Therapy Framework: September 2004, page 63.
On March 12, 2012, during a brief Sunset Review hearing, the California Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development asked the California Acupuncture Board (the Board) to respond to a set of harsh criticisms.
It is not the first time that the dysfunctional Board — which falls under the Department of Consumer Affairs — is being scrutinized by the legislator. The Board has a long history of operating in an inefficient manner, misreading its governing statutes, and potentially endangering the public by refusing to promulgate regulations concerning the sterilization of acupuncture needles or the wear of medical gloves by practitioners.
In the past, members and affiliates have even been investigated for taking bribes and selling licensing exam answers. The Board was replaced several times in order to clean up the quasi-anarchic and corrupt practice of acupuncture and Oriental medicine in California.
This time, the Senate Committee listed 10 major issues in a Background Paper, which is a worthwhile read for those interested in the regulation of acupuncture. The Senate expressed serious concerns about many administrative, educational, licensing, enforcement, consumer protection and budgetary matters. In response, the Board Chair and Executive Director offered little explanation. The Board now must respond to the Background Paper in specifics.
Trouble at the state acupuncture regulating authority goes back to 1982. The longtime chairman of the former acupuncture regulating agency (the Acupuncture Committee), Chae Woo Lew, was selling the answers to the California Acupuncture Licensing Examination for $10,000 to $20,000. He made $500,000 to $800,000 from an estimated 80 test takers. He was caught in 1988, but only a few dozen individuals who bought answers from him were ever caught. Lew was sentenced in 1990 to five years in prison.
In 1999 Acupuncture Committee became the Acupuncture Board. The Board was sunrisen until June of 2002.
During the 2002 sunset review of the Board, an independent state oversight agency called the Little Hoover Commission (LHC) was charged to assess longstanding and contentious issues regarding the State’s regulation of acupuncture — including a review of the scope of practice and educational requirements for acupuncturists, the process for accrediting acupuncture schools and for examining licensees.
LHC provided its assessment to the Legislature in September 2004 in a report called Regulation of Acupuncture: A Complementary Therapy Framework, (Report #175). LHC blamed the Board for many of the problems the profession faced. The report stated that the Board had “too frequently acted as a venue for promoting rather than regulating the profession.” It added that as a result, the Board had “missed opportunities to protect the public by providing accurate and complete information about the therapies that licensees can provide.” The report also stated that the Board had not “adequately incorporated emerging scientific evidence into board policies, regulations and public communications.”
The following Board review in 2005 found little improvements. Among the main concerns was the fact that the Board had misread its governing statutes concerning the scope of practice of acupuncturists. It also pointed out that the Board had potentially endangered the public by refusing to promulgate regulations concerning the sterilization of needles or even to discuss this issue as an agenda item in any public meeting.
During the most recent Board review, the Senate committee pointed out that most of the current issues are the same as those the former sunset review committees had struggled with. The persistence of these issues appears to indicate a general lack of accountability and follow-through on the part of the Board, making one wonder if there is a real willingness to take direction from the Legislature and to implement its recommendations.
The March 12, 2012, hearing ended with the Senate Committese letting the Board’s Chair and Executive Director know that it was very concerned about how the Board operates.
One of the persisting issue is the Board’s insufficient oversight of continuing education units (CEUs) . The Board has consistently approved material that is “grossly out of compliance” with it own regulations. The Senate Committee gave examples of courses in numerology, vitalism, astrology, “the Capacity and Function of Love,” cosmology, magic, sound healing with tuning forks; Reiki and “Four Energy Healing Theories,” whatever that means.
A 2003 CEU certificate in “Alchemical Acupuncture” taught by Jeffrey C. Yuen. A workshop in such outrageous nonsense is sufficient to renew an active acupuncture license in California.
The Board has indeed a long history of approving CEUs in hocus pocus. Examples are courses in mysticism, Taoism, alchemy, astrology, iridology, magic, geomancy (I-Ching), numerology, etc. The latest list is available here. What is most disturbing is the Board’s continuing denial that there is something wrong with approving a course in subjects such as astrology…
This flyer states in a different section that “This workshop is approved for 21 CEUs in Category 1 by the California State Board.”
After a complaint letter to the Board, its Executive Officer, Janelle Wedge, writes to me that: “Based on the comments received, there is no reason to alter the approval of the course.” Wedge resigned right after the Senate hearing.
Another Senate criticism was the disciplinary case management time-frame. The Board, which is responsible for regulating the practice of approximately 10,000 acupuncturists, takes at least 2½ years to investigate and take action. Since 2008, there has been an average of 223 enforcement cases per year; the majority involve unprofessional conduct, ethical issues, practice management issues and sexual misconduct. A list of disciplinary actions is available at the Board Actions webpage. The Board has received an average of 145 direct complaints complaints per year since 2008. It has also received 78 arrest/conviction reports from law enforcement since 2008.
And arrest and conviction there is — even for major crimes, such as trafficking in persons and sexual slavery. The media reports that since 2006, 17 people from 10 massage and acupuncture parlors in Redondo Beach, CA, have been arrested for alleged acts of prostitution (The Daily Breeze, Dec 8, 2010). In June 2009, 22 women – most of them Chinese nationals – were arrested in Vista, CA, in connection with 9 day spas and acupuncture clinics (FOX 5 San Diego, June 4, 2009). Prior to that, in March 2007, in one of the largest prostitution investigations ever in Orange County, CA, five individuals were arrested in business that advertised acupuncture and massage but sex was the only service provided.
According to District Attorney Tony Rackauckas, plastic food wraps were used instead of condoms in an acupuncture brothel in Orange County, CA. Photo source: Orange County Register.
Crime at acupuncture and massage parlors is such a concern that some local governments in Southern California have taken their own preventative measures by withholding business licensing. For example, the neighboring cities of Redondo Beach and Torrance have recently passed Urgency Ordinances that impose a moratorium on the issuance of any new permit, license, approval or entitlement pertaining to new massage/bodywork and acupuncture businesses, services and practitioners.
The picture that emerges here based on the Senate review and reports in the media, is that acupuncture in California is a poorly-regulated and corrupt profession with an ill-defined scope of practice. Many practitioners are deluded purveyors of New Age mumbo-jumbo, and a few are criminals involved in human trafficking and prostitution. The dysfunctional Acupuncture Board not only does not protect the public from quacks and criminals, but quite to the contrary, has a long legacy of acting in their favor. None of this serves the best interest of the public.
By looking at this picture, the world “Kafkaesque” comes to my mind. It is the only term that can accurately describe the senseless, disorienting and often menacing complexity of acupuncture regulation in California. The Board’s failure to follow a clear course of action, its unwillingness to implement its mission, the incomprehensible delays in disciplinary actions, and the bizarre and illogical rationale for some of its decisions, all point to the cynical dereliction of public safety by a group of defiant insiders.

California Acupuncture Licensing: Sinking Lower in the Slime!
Ben Kavoussi on February 1, 2013
Link
The sun shone down upon that putrescence,As if to roast it to a turn,And to give back a hundredfold to great NatureThe elements she had combined…— Charles Baudelaire, The Carcase1
Trouble for the struggling California Acupuncture Board (Board) is far from being over.
After being taken to task by the California Senate less than a year ago for acting “as a venue for promoting the profession” rather than regulating it, now the Board is being petitioned for reform by license applicants after a major compromise in the California Acupuncture Licensing Examination (CALI). This is the exam that allows the graduates of state-approved training programs to practice acupuncture, herbalism and Asian massage in California. Physicians who use these modalities are regulated by the Medical Board.
Bear in mind that California is the only state in the nation that has its own acupuncture licensing examination. In other states where the profession is regulated, candidates have to take a battery of computer-based tests developed by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM). The California test is designed by the Department of Consumer Affairs, and could be taken in English, Chinese or Korean. This means that an individual can get licensed and practice healthcare in California, without understanding a word of English!
The recent test compromise is so significant that the Office of Professional Examination Services (OPES)—an entity within the Department of Consumer Affairs which develops licensing examinations—was called to testify during the November 2012 Board meeting.
Bob Holmgren of OPES told the Board that following a tip, investigators discovered that test preparation seminars in the Los Angeles area were selling study guides that contained actual questions from former exams. How did this happen? Holmgren believes that a number of test takers have been memorizing questions, so that seminar organizers can reconstruct the whole examination—something that is in clear violation of Section 123 of Business and Professions Code. Holmgren called the level of accuracy of these study guides “shocking,” and added that the questions went back for years.
Bob Holmgren of OPES testified in Sacramento during the November 2012 Board meeting. The room was filled with students, school representatives and trade representatives.
Based on this finding, OPES disregarded the answers to the compromised questions in the August 2012 examination. As a result, there was a 30% drop in the passing rate of an exam that already had a low passing rate. A total of 439 candidates took the exam: 270 (61.5%) failed; 169 (38.49%) passed. A pass/ fail history of the exam shows these percentages to be at a record low.
It is not the first time that the State is dealing with cheating and corruption in its acupuncture licensing system. Back in 1980s, the chairman of the former acupuncture regulating agency (the Acupuncture Committee), Chae Woo Lew, was caught selling test questions for $10,000 to $20,000. Lew was sentenced to five years in prison. According to the Los Angeles County district attorney’s office, there may be over 100 acupuncturists involved in the licensing payoff scheme. Only a fraction of all the unqualified practitioners who may have become licensed with Lew’s alleged assistance were caught and prosecuted (Los Angeles Times, March 04, 1989).
Cheating and criminal behavior was a particular area of concern for the “Little Hoover Commission” (an independent oversight agency that investigates State government operations to improve efficiency, economy and service) in 2004. The Commission recommended that to prevent fraud, the responsibility of creating and administrating the licensing exam should be placed in the hands of an outside agency, preferably a national organization, such as NCCAOM.
The Hoover Commission’s policy recommendations and legislative proposals about acupuncture met stiff political opposition from the Board and professional organizations, and were never implemented.
However, on March 12, 2012, during the Sunset Review hearing, the California Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development brought up the Little Hoover Commission’s findings and expressed serious concerns about the ongoing administrative, educational, licensing and consumer protection issues that the Board has not been able to resolve for over a decade.
Added to this discontent and disconnect, is the political (and possibly legal) action by aggrieved license applicants who failed the last exam because of the removal of the comprised questions. A group of them operating under the name of CALE United Test Front (CTUF) has called upon the Board and the Dept. of Consumer Affairs to justify its recent 30% drop in the passing rate. They have also requested the institution of an exam that is “created, and administered utilizing professional methods, standards and industry input specifically from educators and acupuncturists to avoid less disconnect from exam content and what is being actually taught in the schools.”
Another group of applicants has hired an attorney who recently sent a letter to the Board, detailing the group’s concerns, in addition to charges of negligence if the Board does not respond to the test takers’ demands for the re-scoring of the August 2012 exam to a “customary 70% cut score.” He is also asking for greater transparency with respect to all processes associated with the creation, administration, and assessment of the exam.
Their attorney, Robert Sulnick, argues that the Board has a “fiduciary duty to ensure fair examinations,” and added that throughout its history, “independent oversight committees have identified breaches of fiduciary duty, identifying difficulties with the acupuncture examination (i.e. fraud and criminal charges).”
Notice that the referenced breaches of fiduciary duty that were discussed by several oversight committees were towards the people of California. Nowhere this failure to adequately protect the public is more evident than in the content of the licensing exam.
Indeed, since the Business and Professions Code Section 4926 defines the practice of acupuncture as being “subject to regulation and control as a primary health care profession,” the Board is therefore licensing traditional and folk healers so they can work as first-contact health care providers! And the licensing examination is a reflection of this regulatory lunacy.
In its current form, the exam does not assess the level of medical knowledge that provides the future practitioner with the knowledge, skills and abilities necessary to perform “primary health care.” To the contrary, the exam’s primary focus, and what is being taught in schools, is the practice of acupuncture and Asian Medicine, not “primary care,” as it is defined by the Institute of Medicine in Primary Care: America’s Health in a New Era (1996).
This immediately begs the following questions: how can individuals who do not have adequate competencies in the scientific basis of disease and evidence-based medicine, act as primary care providers? Don’t we have here an obvious disconnect between the regulation of acupuncture, and the reality of its teaching, licensing and practice? Isn’t this a legislative blunder that can negatively impact the public’s health and safety?
These are issues that the State oversight entities have actually brought to the Board’s attention in 2001, but have never been addressed–mostly due to political pressure by acupuncture organizations and training programs.
These influential training programs are by and large post-secondary vocational institutions existing as standalone schools. Some of them were actually founded as religious institutions, which exempted them from the usual post-secondary regulations. With student loan money pouring in, little oversight from the State, lax accreditation standards, and an easy pathway for international student visas, an acupuncture school is an easy start-up with big profit potentials. The key has been the sympathetic Board. Any regular attendee will tell you that at most Board meetings, the majority of attendees are school representatives or lobbyists looking after their interests by encouraging the status quo in the content of the exam and the regulation of acupuncture.
Regardless; the next exam is scheduled for February 14, 2013. According to the Board’s attorney, Spencer L. Walker, only after the completion of the cheating investigation and a review and evaluation by an independent expert, the Board will schedule this matter for discussion at a future Board meeting. A timeline for the investigation and discussion has not been set.
Meanwhile, countless Californians will continue to seek “primary care” from providers who do not have adequate training in scientific and evidence-based medicine. A few of these providers might even have obtained their license fraudulently. As for the wronged test-takers, their concerns seem unlikely to be addressed before the February 2013 exam. And it is almost a certainty that none of this convoluted mess will be cleaned up anytime soon, given that the Board has a long history of—as Robert Sulnick puts it–“kicking the can down the road.”
The opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not reflect the positions of the above mentioned individuals, agencies or organizations.
References:
1. Richard Herne Shepherd, Translations from Charles Baudelaire with a few original poems. (London: John Camden Hotten, 1869)

“Integrative medicine” advocates: Co-opting the opioid crisis to promote funding for acupuncture by Medicaid
The opioid epidemic is a serious public health crisis in the U.S., and new tools and treatments to deal with chronic pain are urgently needed. Unfortunately, where public health officials see a crisis, advocates of “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine see an opportunity. In this case, promoters of pseudomedicine are taking advantage of the opioid crisis to persuade state Medicaid systems to pay for quackery like acupuncture.
David Gorski on January 22, 2018
Link

SBM regular Jann Bellamy frequently writes about what she refers to as “legislative alchemy“; that is, attempts by advocates of unscientific, pseudoscientific systems of medicine like traditional Chinese medicine or naturopathy to slap a patina of legitimacy on their quackery through state licensure of practitioners. There is another form of legislative alchemy, however, that doesn’t involve licensing quacks. There are two keys to the perception of legitimacy of a medical specialty among the public, and certainly one is licensure by the state. However, a second key is reimbursement for services by third party payers, particularly government payers like Medicaid and Medicare. Although I had been vaguely aware of such efforts before, to my knowledge they have been scattered and in general relatively unsuccessful, in contrast to efforts to .
I learned recently that Medicaid is the most recent target, with acupuncture the desired treatment, as an article in STAT News reported:
The quickest way to erase pain is to give patients an opioid. But a rise in prescriptions has fueled a national epidemic of fatal overdoses, with a large share of the deaths occurring in low-income communities.
Under intense pressure to combat the problem, states across the country are expanding their Medicaid programs to cover alternative treatments such as acupuncture, massage, and yoga. The effort could increase non-opioid options for low-income patients suffering from pain. But it also opens states to criticism from skeptics who say taxpayers are being forced to fund unproven treatments based on political expediency instead of sound science.
Ohio’s Medicaid department took the most dramatic step this month by extending coverage of acupuncture treatments delivered by non-medical providers for patients with low-back pain and migraines, a step likely to allow much greater access and attract new practitioners to the field.
Because I trained in Cleveland and still have connections there, I had taken note of the Cleveland.com article referenced in the STAT story, which provides more detail:
Starting January 1, more than 108,000 Ohioans on Medicaid who have diagnosed low back pain or migraines will be able to see an acupuncturist for pain management. The change in policy is part of an effort to reduce the number of unnecessary opioid prescriptions and overdose deaths in the state that arise from treating chronic pain with addictive drugs.
For the past year, Ohio has been one of six states in the country to cover acupuncture treatments for Medicaid patients, but only when offered by a doctor. Starting tomorrow, Medicaid reimbursement will be open to licensed non-physician acupuncturists who register as Medicaid providers.
The agency hopes that expanding access to the treatment, a centuries-old pain-relief technique that involves inserting hair-thin needles into the skin at specific points, will save money over time on addiction treatment and other costs related to opioid use.
Practitioners and their patients say it’s about time more people had access to the proven and safe, but expensive, non-drug therapy, and that more insurers should follow suit.
These sorts of decisions are the culmination of a strategy that is as old as alarm in public health circles about the rise of opioid addiction and the wave of overdose deaths sweeping the nation.
Co-opting the opioid crisis: A calculated strategy to sell quackery
It’s become increasingly clear to me that the opioid crisis has been adopted by advocates of “integrating” quackery into medicine as the most important new “foot in the door” or “wedge” to open the way to the legitimization and funding of pseudoscientific treatments like acupuncture. Basically, advocates of “integrative medicine” are taking advantage of the urgency of the current search for non-opioid and non-pharmacologic treatments for chronic pain to promote their placebo-based pseudoscience as the solution to the crisis. It’s become one of the main talking points used by advocates to open the door for the “integration” of mystical, prescientific, and pseudoscientific treatments like acupuncture into medicine. Indeed, whenever you hear the terms “non-drug therapy” or “nonpharmacologic management of pain” used by advocates with respect to the opioid crisis and chronic pain management, it’s code for placebo-based quackery. The quacks are not even subtle about it.
It’s a rationale that comes right from the top, from the most prominent proponents of “integrative medicine.” For instance, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) featured the opioid crisis as a compelling reason for its existence in its latest five year strategic plan, which made the “nonpharmacologic management of pain” one of its top research priorities. Since then, NCCIH has been promoting such approaches, science-based or quackery like acupuncture, as its own, the better to seamlessly integrate pseudoscience with science. Elsewhere, the same sort of rationale is used to justify the introduction of quackery into the VA medical system. Even the FDA is considering encouraging knowledge about chiropractic and acupuncture as approaches for chronic pain.
It’s not just the NCCIH, the VA, and the FDA either. Journals, even prestigious medical journals, The BMJ and JAMA increasingly buy into the message that “nonpharmacologic treatment for chronic pain = ‘integrative medicine.'” Medical professional societies are jumping on the bandwagon as well. For instance, the American College of Physicians included acupuncture on its list of recommended strategies for low back pain. An entire professional organization, the Society for Integrative Oncology, is devoted to diluting the science of oncology with a mixture of lifestyle interventions that are in no way “alternative” or “integrative” plus pseudoscientific nonsense. Even NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers like Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center are increasingly “integrating” quackery with oncology. And don’t even get me started on “naturopathic oncology,” which is becoming increasingly accepted and metastasizing outside of academia.
The strategy is starting to work, as STAT reports:
But Ohio is not alone. Eleven other states have implemented policies to encourage beneficiaries to use alternative therapies to help manage their pain and limit reliance on opioids, according to a 2016 survey by the National Academy for State Health Policy. In addition to acupuncture, covered services include massage, yoga, chiropractic manipulation, and various forms of physical and behavioral therapy, among others.
Two states, Maine and Vermont, are currently considering whether to expand coverage of acupuncture to treat pain after conducting studies to test its effectiveness for beneficiaries.
More on Maine and Vermont later. First, back to Ohio.
Meanwhile, back in Ohio…
So let’s take a closer look at what’s going on in Ohio by going back to the Cleveland.com article:
Dr. Maya Myslenski, a pediatrician who practices in the emergency department at MetroHealth Medical Center, has been offering acupuncture to her patients for a variety of ailments for more than two years. It helps patients with both acute and chronic pain, anxiety, and some stomach ailments, she said.
“A lot of our [Medicaid] patients can’t afford to go to private offices for treatments,” Myslenski said. “I’m beyond thrilled about treatments being covered for them.”
Noooo! During my residency at University Hospitals of Cleveland, I did part of my training at MetroHealth Medical Center, particularly for trauma. I moonlighted as a helicopter flight physician for Metro LifeFlight, which is based at MetroHealth Medical Center.
Unfortunately, this article is quite credulous about acupuncture, repeating the usual tropes used to justify it:
In Ohio, the move to cover acupuncture for chronic pain conditions began in earnest in January of 2016, when Gov. John Kasich’s Cabinet Opiate Action Team (GCOAT) released a guideline for the management of acute pain outside of emergency departments. The guideline said that non-drug therapies such as acupuncture (as well as physical and massage therapies, biofeedback and hypnotherapy) should be considered as first-line treatments for acute pain. The Governor’s team also encouraged Medicaid to further research and review acupuncture.
Then in January of 2017, the Joint Commission, the not-for-profit organization that certifies hospitals have met certain safety standards, changed its pain management standards to require that accredited hospitals provide nonpharmacological pain treatments.
Around the same time, the American College of Physicians issued new guidelines for the treatment of low back pain, which recommended that doctors treat patients with non-drug therapies first, including acupuncture.
One more time: The ACP guidelines were poorly conceived and based on weak science. I’ve also mentioned the Joint Commission’s recommendations before. While it’s not unreasonable to promote the use of nonpharmacological approaches to pain, those approaches must be science- and evidence-based. So far, advocates of unscientific approaches like acupuncture have been getting away with using the opioid crisis as a cover to advance their quackery and even get the government and insurance companies to pay for it. They’re not even subtle about it:
“It may take another year or so, but I do think it’s going to lead to a change in policy,” he said. “The opioid crisis has helped the establishment catch up a little to research on acupuncture. There’s been a big change in attitude in terms of openness to this sort of thing.”
The person making the above statement is Robert Davis, a Vermont acupuncturist who led the state’s pilot testing acupuncture for back pain. Yeah, that gives me a lot of confidence in the scientific validity of the pilot studies being done in various states. I note that his website basically relies on testimonials to claim that acupuncture “works”; well, that and “ample clinical experience, supported by some research data.”
I also can’t help but note that even the author of this story lazily cites a “meta-analysis” from the Australian Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine Association that was not published in any peer-reviewed journal as “evidence” for the efficacy of acupuncture, as he lays down quotes like:
West said the research on acupuncture has become much clearer in recent years, both on how well it works and how it can save money.
“There are some really big, recent studies that clearly show that acupuncture is not only comparable to Western medicine in how effective it is, but it’s safer and it’s cost-effective,” West said. “In chronic low back pain, you can save money over the long-term, give people just as good care and they’re not getting addicted to pain medication.”
It costs the insurer between 70 cents and $1 per month, per policy, to add acupuncture coverage, West said. “It just doesn’t make sense not to when we’re spending $1 billion a year in Ohio on addiction treatment.”
No, when you’re spending $1 billion a year on addiction treatment for Ohio residents, it doesn’t make sense to waste money on ineffective and pseudoscientific treatments. What’s next? Narconon? Also, no, there are not “really big, recent studies that clearly show that acupuncture is comparable to “Western” medicine, much less cost effective. In general, most studies of acupuncture tend to be relatively small, poorly controlled, and equivocal in results, while meta-analyses of acupuncture studies are generally the epitome of “garbage in, garbage out.” In general, the larger and better designed the acupuncture study, the smaller the effect, with the effect size being in essence zero in the very best studies. Moreover, it doesn’t matter where you place the needles or even if you place the needles in; the effect is the same, nonspecific. Acupuncture doesn’t work. It is theatrical placebo.
As for Jared West, who was quoted above, he’s an acupuncturist, of course. Not surprisingly, he offers acupuncture, moxibustion, and cupping quackery. He’s also president of the Ohio Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine and is helping providers navigate the Medicaid registration process and has advised the state on reimbursement and other issues.
Beyond Ohio
The STAT article notes several other states considering letting Medicaid recipients choose acupuncture and other alternative treatments, which brings us back to Vermont:
“Acupuncture is not going to solve the opioid crisis,” said Robert Davis, an acupuncturist who led Vermont’s Medicaid study. “But acupuncture is one tool that helps patients. It helps them get their feet back under them.” Vermont’s study found that, among about 150 pain patients, acupuncture improved patients’ rating of pain, fatigue, depression, and other measures — though the study didn’t include a control group, and so may have reflected a placebo effect.
I encourage you to read the study. It was not published in any peer-reviewed medical journal, just on the Vermont Legislature website. It is an utterly worthless study, a total waste of Vermont taxpayer money. Indeed, you can tell this study is utterly useless from its design as described in the abstract:
A pilot-level prospective pragmatic intervention trial design was chosen as the most appropriate approach for this project after a thorough analysis of the legislative goals, resources, and timeline provided by Act 173, along with a review of the existing scientific literature. Several acupuncture trialists considered to be subject-matter experts by their peers were consulted in order to confirm the soundness of this approach. Qualitative interviews were also utilized to understand the experience from the patients’ perspective. Pragmatic trials are designed to answer questions useful to clinicians and policy makers because they aim to maximize external validity and generalizability to a real-world setting. This pilot included a heterogeneous group of chronic pain patients that were treated by Vermont-licensed acupuncturists who provided treatment in their private clinics in line with their standard practice. This design was intended to reflect what would happen if acupuncture reimbursement were offered for local chronic pain patients by the local population of acupuncturists. As a Phase 1 uncontrolled pilot, this study was designed to provide qualitative and implementation data that may help policy-makers. The Department of Vermont Health Access (DVHA) decided this was the best research design available in the short timeframe. A thorough description of the rationale for this approach is described in the Progress Report to the Legislature and a journal article published on this topic.
Whenever you hear the words “pilot” and “pragmatic” in a description of a study design for an intervention designed to treat a subjective complaint like pain, you know it’s guaranteed to show a positive result, thanks to placebo effects. Acupuncturists love pragmatic studies for this very reason. It is true that pragmatic studies are designed to test interventions as used in the “real world,” but there is an assumption behind them, namely that the treatment being tested has already been shown to be efficacious in well-designed randomized controlled clinical trials. Indeed, for real interventions, frequently what is found in pragmatic trials is that the treatment doesn’t work as well in the “real world” as it did in clinical trials, usually because of the variability and lack of consistency that inevitably arise when treatments are released “into the wild.” In the case of treatments that don’t work better than placebo but do induce placebo effects, pragmatic trials almost always show more efficacy than well-designed randomized trials. Again, that’s the point. This trial is so useless that it’s hardly worth even citing its results. If you want an idea of how biased this study is, just look at some of the comments from patients included in Appendix A:
    • “My acupuncture was life changing… I saw and felt and continue to feel a marked difference in my pain and mental clarity. I believe it saved my life.”
    • “Acupuncture helped me to get my life back.”
    • “I was very skeptical about this treatment being effective. As the weeks went by, I noticed different changes taking place in my body: my digestive system functioned much better, so my diet improved; I required less sleeping medication because my sleep was better; my pain level was much decreased; I had more genuine energy; and most especially, I had better mobility. The mobility change enabled me to walk more in fresh air and increased my good energy level. A circle of reinforcements that has made my life much better, more productive and happier. It has cut down my need for other medical interventions like physical therapy and medications for various ailments. People have noticed the outward improvement.”
    • “I went to a regular doctor for over six years and my pain only became more intense and more frequent. This is the longest I’ve gone without pain or medication in well over a year.”
    • “this is a very necessary way to treat pain. I am very allergic to many medications and during the study I was able to walk and do more without an allergic reaction.”
You get the idea.
STAT does note that the evidence base for acupuncture is pretty thin, citing Cochrane reviews on acupuncture as a treatment for various conditions. Cochrane, for instance, points out that the there is a short term small benefit for patients with chronic low back pain but “notes that most studies are of low quality”; that acupuncture can help arthritis patients, but that the benefits are “too small, and too susceptible to placebo, to be considered clinically relevant”; and that acupuncture can offer a small benefit for migraines. (Note: Acupuncture doesn’t work for migraine, as Steve Novella has explained.)
Despite how poor its own study is, Vermont is using it to guide policy:
As states weigh the evidence and opposing arguments, many are moving cautiously. In Vermont, the Medicaid department is still considering how to translate the findings of its study into recommendations to state lawmakers, who will ultimately decide whether to expand coverage.
Elsewhere:
Oregon has created a similar approach, according to the survey by the National Academy for State Health Policy. The state covers several treatment options for patients with low-back pain, including acupuncture, chiropractic care, physical and occupational therapy, and behavioral therapy. The state also recommends treatment plans that include yoga, massage, and exercise therapy, although applicability of those services is determined by organizations that coordinate care for Oregon’s Medicaid beneficiaries.
Mark Crislip has previously noted how woo-friendly Oregon is.
The future of Medicaid?
Given the seriousness of the opioid epidemic and the public health imperative to institute policies to bring it under control, it is not surprising that integrative medicine advocates saw an opening. I don’t believe that they are being cynical or disingenuous (at least not the vast majority of them). Rather, they really believe that their quackery really can function as nonpharmacologic treatments for chronic pain. In other words, the vast majority of them are true believers, not scammers. The problem is that they are incorrect.
Alternative medicine, in particular acupuncture, is not the answer—or even one among many answers—to the opioid crisis. Worse, government funding tends to be a zero sum game, particularly now, which means that any funds diverted to pay for acupuncture and other alternative medicine, be it to provide services to those with chronic pain or to do research on non-opioid and non-pharmacologic treatments for pain, are funds not available to pay for science-based treatment. Unfortunately, I predict that acupuncture advocates and advocates of other unscientific treatments will likely be as persistent as naturopaths in pursuing their state-by-state legislative goals. As much as I’m half tempted to welcome them to the bureaucratic pain that is accepting Medicaid reimbursement and the very low reimbursement rates with a hearty, “Be careful what you wish for, you just might get it,” we proponents of science-based medicine need to resist these incursions in each state where we become aware of them.

Medicare proposal covers acupuncture for back pain study participants: A prelude to full coverage?
Medicare coverage of acupuncture is under consideration. A new proposal would provide coverage to Medicare patients participating in studies of acupuncture for back pain. This research would be used in making a final decision.
Jann Bellamy on July 18, 2019
Link

Medicare will cover acupuncture treatments under a proposal announced by the Trump administration on July 15, but only for Medicare beneficiaries with chronic low back pain enrolled in research to determine whether the treatment decreases their pain, improves function, or decreases the use of other medical treatments, such as opioids. According to Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, the proposal is part of an effort to address the opioid addiction epidemic by providing patients with “new options while expanding our scientific understanding of alternative approaches to pain”.
This decision is part of a larger effort to decide whether acupuncture should be covered for all seniors insured by Medicare:
CMS [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] is opening this national coverage analysis (NCA) to complete a thorough review of the evidence to determine if acupuncture for CLBP is reasonable and necessary under the Medicare program.
CMS says it reviewed the literature on the effectiveness of acupuncture for chronic low back pain, as well as guidelines and professional society recommendations. Unfortunately, these included some unreliable sources on acupuncture, such as the Veterans Administration and the American College of Physicians guidelines. CMS decided that
While we believe the evidence is promising, we do not believe the evidence is sufficient at this time for representative older patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain. We believe additional research would be needed in order to make a favorable coverage determination . . .
Hence, the decision to help fund that research.
Any fair review of the evidence for acupuncture answers the question the government is about to spend taxpayer money asking all over again: We already know that acupuncture is nothing more than an elaborate placebo and that it does not work, for anything. Thus, this effort is not justifiable based on any real need to do more research. Here’s what SBM’s Steve Novella, MD, had to say in a Washington Post story on the subject:
“The whole thing is a big scam,” said Steven Novella, an assistant professor of neurology at the Yale School of Medicine and editor of the “Science-Based Medicine” website. “The only honest interpretation of the data is that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.” . . .
Novella said that the efficacy attributed to acupuncture in the 2018 review [referred to in the story] could easily be explained by various research biases and that no drug would be allowed on the market based on that level of proof.“We never get that threshold of evidence that you need in medicine, where you get that persistent effect, and it’s replicable” across numerous studies, he said.
Exactly. The only explanation in my mind, then, is political: It is another success in the relentless campaign by CAM proponents to promote pseudoscience as the best thing since sliced bread for pain relief and therefore the cure for America’s opioid crisis. And, given the state of the evidence that prompted CMS’s proposal, I fear that similarly weak evidence produced by this research could prompt national coverage.
There are reasons other than wasting taxpayer money to oppose this proposal. CMS should not be considering Medicare coverage of acupuncture at all because of what I’ve referred to as integrative medicine’s “collateral damage”. If CMS were to decide to cover acupuncture outside of research, that necessarily means patients would be seeing licensed acupuncturists in private office settings, giving acupuncturists the opportunity to sell patients on the vast array of pseudoscience covered by the acupuncturist’s scope of practice. (In fact, as we shall see, given the nature of the clinical trials under consideration, this could well occur within the context of research covered by CMS’s current proposal.)
For example, depending on their scope of practice, licensed acupuncturists have broad authority to diagnose and treat any disease or condition with, not just acupuncture, but also bleeding, reflexology, Kirlian photography, thermograpy, homeopathy, gua sha, Chinese herbs (basically, unrefined and unproven drugs), magnets, reiki, therapeutic touch, cranial sacral therapy, Oriental medicine injection therapy (including caffeine and other substances), polarity therapy, dietary supplements, cupping, and, in New Hampshire, “insertion and retention, for days or weeks, of intradermal needles or press tacks in acupuncture points”. One study that reviewed acupuncturists’ websites showed that a majority advertised treatments for allergies and asthma that were unsupported by evidence. About 92 percent of seniors have at least one chronic disease and 77 percent have at least two, making them prime targets for cross-selling. Conditions like dementia, cognitive decline, and other mental health issues make older adults even more vulnerable.
CMS may also want to consider Florida’s experience in covering acupuncture for motor vehicle accident injuries. (Although, interestingly, cost-effectiveness analysis is apparently not a part of determining Medicare coverage.) A 2010 study by the Department of Insurance found that acupuncture was the second most expensive average provider charge per claim, clocking in at $3,674, more per claim than ER doctors, general practitioners, and orthopedic surgeons. The legislature responded by eliminating acupuncture coverage from no-fault auto insurance.
Medicare-supported studies
The 47-page “Proposed Decision Memo for Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain” describes the requirements for the acupuncture research, which must be performed in clinical trials supported by the NIH or “CMS approved studies meeting AHRQ [Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality] criteria.” Of note, the NIH has already announced a “large-scale pragmatic trial to evaluate the impact of, and strategies to best implement, acupuncture treatment of older adults (65 years and older) with chronic low back pain.” Interesting language there: Why a “pragmatic trial” of a treatment with, at best, highly dubious evidence of effectiveness? Why “impact of” – what does that even mean in a research context? And why announce you are going to study “strategies to best implement acupuncture treatment” before you know the results of the “impact” studies, such as they are? Also of note: the NIH will not fund studies that propose a sham control. Why?
Here’s why, as explained by SBM’s own David Gorski, MD, PhD, himself an NIH-funded researcher:
Whenever you hear the words “pilot” and “pragmatic” in a description of a study design for an intervention designed to treat a subjective complaint like pain, you know it’s guaranteed to show a positive result, thanks to placebo effects. Acupuncturists love pragmatic studies for this very reason. It is true that pragmatic studies are designed to test interventions as used in the “real world,” but there is an assumption behind them, namely that the treatment being tested has already been shown to be efficacious in well-designed randomized controlled clinical trials. Indeed, for real interventions, frequently what is found in pragmatic trials is that the treatment doesn’t work as well in the “real world” as it did in clinical trials, usually because of the variability and lack of consistency that inevitably arise when treatments are released “into the wild.” In the case of treatments that don’t work better than placebo but do induce placebo effects, pragmatic trials almost always show more efficacy than well-designed randomized trials. Again, that’s the point.
CMS’s proposed Medicare coverage for research studies requires:
A minimum 12-week acupuncture intervention versus usual care or other intervention for chronic low back pain. Endpoints must be measured at 12 weeks, 6 months, and 12 months . . . with comparison to usual care, or other planned comparator arm.
In other words, CMS’s research will suffer from the same deficiencies as the NIH’s pragmatic trial.
In keeping with Medicare coverage requirements under the Social Security Act, acupuncture can be furnished in these studies only by physicians, or by physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and “auxiliary personnel,” all of whom (save physicians) must be licensed acupuncturists, have a graduate degree in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine from a school accredited by the Accreditation Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, and certified by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, both fox-guarding-the-henhouse organizations that, respectively, accredit acupuncture schools and test their graduates. “Auxiliary personnel” (presumably, acupuncturists who are not PAs or nurses) must be under the direct supervision of a physician, PA, NP, or clinical nurse specialist.
Thus, while physicians, depending on state licensing requirements, may have taken a “medical acupuncture” course to learn acupuncture, all others will be fully steeped in the mysticism and pseudoscience that comes with an acupuncture degree.
In its discussion of acupuncture, CMS does not acknowledge the recent political origins of TCM and contemporary forms of acupuncture, although it does (sort of) admit that it’s not really “thousands of years” old. While stating that it found insufficient evidence for covering acupuncture, CMS then turns around and declares that “Western medical acupuncture” employs the “principles of evidence based medicine”. It also dutifully marches through surrogate outcomes that are widely claimed as explaining acupuncture’s mechanism of action; e.g., endogenous opioids and release of adenosine. And, perhaps without realizing that it is doing so, CMS admits that “acupuncture” can mean whatever the practitioner wants it to mean.
[T]here is a diversity of theoretical models and techniques that are all described as acupuncture . . . [including] needling at specifically chosen points . . . [and] “non-needling” techniques focused on these points. Modern medical acupuncturists choose anatomically and physiologically important treatment points which many include both traditional acupuncture points and other non-traditional fixed points. . . . [T]here are several variations to traditional acupuncture including shallow needling, intradermal needling or intramuscular needling . . . twirling, plucking or thrusting [the] acupuncture needles. There are numerous variations of manually or electrically stimulated “needling” techniques, as well as multiple “non-needling” acupuncture techniques.
All of which raises the question: if a study uses one method of selecting acupuncture points and one method of needling (or non-needling), how generalizable are its results to other methods? And, if Medicare is to cover acupuncture nationally, how could it ever describe just which “acupuncture” it covers? Or, will it cover all acupuncture, despite the negative studies of particular methods? How would that be justifiable as “reasonable and necessary to the diagnosis and treatment of illness or injury,” the legal standard for Medicare coverage?
Finally, CMS’s criteria for studies include:
    • “The rationale for the study is well supported by available scientific and medical evidence.”
    • “The research study is in compliance with all applicable Federal regulations concerning the protection of human subjects. . .” [which requires studies to be based on sound science].
    • “All aspects of the study are conducted according to appropriate standards of scientific integrity.”
The implausibility of acupuncture (hand-waving about surrogate measures aside) should (but won’t) disqualify any study of acupuncture if these criteria are enforced.
CMS will accept comments on the proposal until August 14, 2019, and is “particularly interested in comments that address current studies of acupuncture (randomized controlled trials, observational trials, and registries) in the Medicare population.” (Thus, it would be especially helpful if those with a background in medicine or research would comment.) Many SBM readers complain about the infiltration of CAM; here’s the chance to do something about it. When CMS previously floated the idea of Medicare coverage for acupuncture, proponents came out in droves. Only “a few commenters did not support CMS coverage.” Let’s do better this time.

Damn the evidence and regulations: VA goes full speed ahead with medical pseudoscience
The VA recently mandated inclusion of acupuncture, reiki, reflexology and other CAM in veterans medical benefits and will require that they be offered at VA medical facilities, ignoring the lack of evidence and federal rules on what medical benefits can be covered.
Jann Bellamy on December 7, 2017
Link

The Veterans Health Administration (VHA) has announced (VHA Directive 1137: VA Provision of Complementary & Integrative Health) that acupuncture, reiki, and reflexology, among other “complementary and integrative health [CIH] practices” will now be included in the standard veterans’ medical benefits package. [Translation: You, the taxpayer, will foot the bill.] The VHA found “adequate evidence exists to support the use” of some of these CIH practices, despite their own evidence review showing otherwise (“List I”). These must be offered at all VHA medical facilities, either on-site or by referral to community providers. Other CIH approaches (“List II”) will be included in veterans’ medical benefits because they “are generally considered to be safe,” any pretense of efficacy having been totally abandoned; whether to offer them at any particular facility is optional.(Aromatherapy has since been added to List II.)
To make it easy, the VHA has created its own codes for inclusion of CIH in the VHA system: “RFLX” for reflexology; “CGQC” for Qi Gong, and so on. (For codes, see the CIH resource guide) And so enthused is the VHA about this new endeavor, it’s offering a bonus to veteran’s health facilities for promoting it, according to this VA powerpoint. Facilities will receive up to $7,000 in additional funds per veteran if he or she receives 10 CIH visits in one fiscal year.
Borrowing from the quackademic medicine playbook, this mandate is wrapped in the protective coating of what the VHA calls the “Whole Health System,” the definition of which is adapted from the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health:
Whole Health is patient centered care that affirms the importance of the relationship and partnership between a patient and their community of providers . . . This approach is informed by evidence and makes use of all appropriate therapeutic approaches, healthcare professionals and disciplines.
In other words, it is no different from the biosocial model of medicine, except that, like “integrative medicine,” it incorporates:
a full range of conventional and complementary and integrative health.
As David Gorski has pointed out regarding integrative medicine, it is, in short, an excuse to incorporate quackery into conventional medical care. And as with quackademic medicine, conventional modalities like exercise (tai chi, yoga) and massage are somehow rebranded as “integrative.”
This is appalling enough on principle alone. In addition to the ethical issues posed by integration of pseudoscience into medical care, funding for veteran medical care is a zero-sum game. Congress allocates a finite amount of money to the VA, so monies absorbed by, say, therapeutic touch, do not get spent on, for example, cognitive behavioral therapy for PTSD. But, however willing the VHA might be to sidestep the ethical and financial implications, it cannot ignore federal regulatory requirements for veterans’ medical care. In my view, the VHA has done just that, a point we’ll return to in a moment.
Acupuncture tops the list
Mandating unproven treatments for veterans is the culmination of a long-term campaign by integrative medicine ideologues, like Wayne Jonas (also here) and Tracy Gaudet, the current director of the VHA’s Office of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation, who aspire to dumb down evidence of safety and efficacy to accommodate pseudoscience. For integrative medicine advocates, the maxim “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” is turned on its head: extraordinary claims (e.g., that humans can transfer an undetectable “energy” to one another; that our bodily functions are controlled by “qi“) require no evidence. Thus, this from a RAND Evidence Map of Acupuncture, published in 2014 by the VA:
In general, acupuncture is the stimulation of specific acupuncture points through penetration of the skin with needles, which aims to correct imbalances in the flow of qi, a concept of energy in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), through meridians (i.e., energy channels.)
Nowhere in this 48-page report do the authors question the concept that ill health is the result of imbalances in our qi, even though, after “thousands” of years, no one has ever demonstrated that this qi and its meridians exist. Studying it is a perfect example of Tooth Fairy Science, that is, doing research on a phenomenon before you establish that the phenomenon exists.
Yet studied it has been: there are thousands of published acupuncture studies. And the evidence is? According to the Evidence Map authors:
the effectiveness and adverse events associated with acupuncture are not firmly established [and] [r]esults from existing reviews of reviews about the effectiveness of acupuncture are non-conclusive.
(No surprise there.)
Nothing in this Evidence Map constructed for the VA mitigates those conclusions. In fact, the authors specifically state that their report:
was not designed to inform policies regarding the use of acupuncture.
But note which CIH “approach” (the VHA avoids the terms “treatments” and “therapies” when discussing CIH) is number one on List I: Acupuncture. In fact, so enamored of acupuncture is the VHA that it is now making arrangements to hire acupuncturists as regular VA employees.
As Benjamin Kligler, MD, MPH, the VHA’s Integrative Health Coordinator, explains in a November 4, 2017, article in (where else?) Medical Acupuncture:
A major initiative is now underway to expand CIH nationally, with a primary focus on a number of CIH therapies with the best evidence of effectiveness, including acupuncture . . . [Emphasis added.]
And what is this “best evidence of effectiveness?” According to a VHA CIH Directive Memo signed by Kligler on Oct. 26, 2017, it’s really just:
published evidence of promising or potential benefit. [Emphasis added.]
And where is this “published evidence?” According to the VHA, it’s the aforementioned RAND Evidence Map of Acupuncture.
In sum, the VHA is including acupuncture in veterans’ medical benefits and directing all VHA facilities to provide it based on a conclusion it has “promising or potential benefit” even though it’s been told not to make policy grounded in that conclusion and even though the RAND report clearly states the evidence is “non-conclusive.”
(Unfortunately, I cannot link to the VA document citing the Evidence Map in support of mandating acupuncture because it is not publicly available, although you can find the Evidence Map cited here by the VHA as supporting its offering CIH.)
To add insult to injury, VHA acupuncture offerings will presumably include so-called “Battlefield Acupuncture” (BFA, or, in VHA coding parlance, “IACT”). BFA is a fabrication of Col. Richard Niemtzow, who based it on auricular acupuncture. Despite the fact that BFA is ludicrously implausible and there is no evidence it is effective for anything, the VHA, according to Dr. Kligler:
has rolled out large-scale training [in BFA]. . . . To date, more than 1000 providers have been trained in BFA . . . and we have more than 50 BFA VHA instructors trained as well.
Is that even legal?
While we can quibble over whether List I modalities like guided imagery, hypnosis, and biofeedback are “conventional” or “integrative,” there is no doubt that List II, with the exception of animal-assisted therapy and the Alexander Technique (although it has little evidence of effectiveness), is full-blown quackery.
But before we move on, you’re probably wondering: Where’s chiropractic? Not to worry: it’s not on any list because it is already fully covered in VA medical benefits, thanks to Congress, which was successfully lobbied by the American Chiropractic Association to include it.
Healing touch, reiki and therapeutic touch are all forms of “energy medicine,” based on the notion that one person can channel “healing energy” into another, with positive health benefits. It hardly bears mentioning that energy medicine is both highly implausible and its benefits remain unproven. Reflexology is based on the equally fanciful notion that the body is divided into 10 longitudinal energy zones that end in the hands and feet. The reflexologist claims that by massaging these zones, she can heal disease and otherwise alter bodily functions. As Mark Crislip observed:
Safe to say that the basic premises of reflexology have no bearing in reality.
Acupressure is, as the name implies, applying pressure to acupuncture points, and, by extension, suffers from the same lack of plausibility and evidence of effectiveness as acupuncture itself. Emotion Freedom Technique is based on the notion that blockages in our “energy fields” result in health problems, which can be resolved by a series of taps on the sufferer’s “energy meridians.” Aromatherapy is the use of essential oils with therapeutic intent, but without evidence that they are effective.
Of course, the VHA doesn’t claim that List II CIH approaches are effective, merely that they are safe. (Oddly, they adopt the FDA standard for food additives as their definition of safety.) And therein lies their legal problem.
Federal regulations prescribe the type of care covered in the veterans’ medical benefits package. This includes such routine items as periodic exams, immunizations, surgery, nutritional counseling, medical equipment and the like, with this caveat:
Care referred to in the “medical benefits package” will be provided to individuals only if it is determined by appropriate healthcare professionals that the care is needed to promote, preserve, or restore the health of the individual and is in accord with generally accepted standards of medical practice. [Emphasis added.]
In VHA Directive 1137, mentioned earlier, the VHA states that List I and List II CIH practices:
meet the definition of care in 38 CFR 17.38(b), thereby making them suitable for inclusion in VA’s medical benefits package
Meaning they, in the VHA’s view, promote, preserve or restore health and are in accord with generally accepted standards of medical practice. (The Directive also says that “conventional medicine and CAM should be held to the same standards for validating clinical effectiveness.” So much for that idea.)
Two problems with meeting these criteria immediately present themselves. First, if a practice lacks evidence of effectiveness, as many of these do, how can they be said to “promote, preserve or restore health” unless the VHA is willing to accept anything that elicits a placebo response as promoting, preserving or restoring health?
Second, it is highly doubtful that battlefield acupuncture, reflexology, energy healing, acupressure and Emotional Freedom Technique meet “generally accepted standards of medical practice” as that term is commonly understood.
“Generally accepted standards of medical practice” is not defined in the regulation. However, because government regulations are presumed to use words and phrases in accord with their normal meaning, we can look to how other responsible authorities have defined the term. The National Academies of Science quoted these definitions with approval:
Based on credible scientific evidence published in peer-reviewed medical literature generally recognized by the relevant medical community, or otherwise consistent with the standards set forth in policy issues involving clinical judgment. (Kaminiski, 2007)
Known to be effective in improving health outcomes. For new interventions, effectiveness is determined by scientific evidence. For existing interventions, effectiveness is determined first by scientific evidence, then by professional standards, then by expert opinion (Singer et al., 1999)
In an article on utilization management, the authors used the definition:
“generally accepted standards of medical practice” means standards that use clinical guidelines that are based on credible scientific evidence published in peer-reviewed medical literature generally recognized by the relevant medical community; [i.e., Evidence Based Medicine] (taking into account Physician Specialty Society recommendations, the views of Physicians practicing in the relevant clinical areas, and any other relevant factors) when making medical necessity determinations.
Finally, according to Cigna, a large health insurance company:
“generally accepted standards of medical practice” means:
    • standards that are based on credible scientific evidence published in peer-reviewed, medical literature generally recognized by the relevant medical community;
    • Physician Specialty Society recommendations;
    • the views of Physicians practicing in the relevant clinical area; and
    • any other relevant factors.
Simply put, nothing on List II meets these criteria and, arguably, acupuncture (and perhaps others on List I that I didn’t review) doesn’t either. I propose that this makes the VHA’s decision subject to a legal challenge as being in conflict with the federal regulations governing what can be included in veterans’ medical benefits.
A recent RAND report, Complementary and Alternative Medicine in the Military Health System, showed that over 80% of military treatment facilities already offer some form of CAM services. The same report said that 64%-84% of facilities cited evidence or clinical practice guidelines in support of CAM recommendations. Yet, the report also reveals that acupuncture is used for stress management, anxiety disorder and sleep disturbance, conditions for which there is insufficient evidence for acupuncture use. The report also shows that military health system already spends millions of dollars each year on provision of CAM services.
Use of CIH, or CAM, or whatever term you might prefer, will only increase under the VHA’s new mandate. Further inappropriate use of CIH “approaches” and a drain of fiscal resources away from proven treatments will naturally follow, evidence and regulations be damned.

HB 4710: Licensing and expanding the scope of practice of acupuncturists in Michigan
Last week, HB 4710, a bill to license acupuncturists, was considered by the Michigan House of Representatives Health Policy Committee. If passed into law, HB 4710 would do far more than license the quackery that is acupuncture. It would also expand the scope of practice of acupuncturists to include homeopathy, “health coaching”, and dietary advice, and is yet another example of what practitioners of pseudoscientific medicine crave: The imprimatur of state approval for their “profession.”
David Gorski on June 24, 2019
Link

If there’s one thing that practitioners of pseudoscientific medicine and quackery crave, it’s respectability. They want to be taken seriously by patients and physicians, because with respectability means no longer being viewed as quacks or even fringe and acceptance as legitimate health care providers. This is a fight that they’ve been waging at least 50 or 60 years. The success that they’ve had can be seen in the evolution of how a lot of quackery is described. As I discussed several years ago, way back in the mists of time, say, 50 years ago, “quackery” was the preferred term used to refer to ineffective and potentially harmful medical practices not supported by evidence. Not surprisingly, quacks and charlatans did not like this.
Beginning in the 1960s and 1970s, supporters of quackery decided that they would never get anywhere selling their products, except to a small minority of people, if they continued to allow physicians to define their favorite quackery as being…well, quackery. Thus was born the term “alternative medicine”. Although practitioners of alternative medicine liked this term better than the terms “quackery” and “quacks”, they were, not surprisingly, still not satisfied. Thus was born in the 1990s the term “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). Because CAM therapies are used in addition to real medicine, over a relatively brief period of time the name change had its intended effect. No longer did many physicians automatically view modalities that were once considered quackery, later considered “alternative”, and now considered “CAM” as quackery, and those that still did were dismissed as close-minded, stubborn, and dogmatic, relics who were trying to swim against the coming tide of wonderful CAM magic that would transform medicine in the future.
Of course, the latest evolution of this term is “integrative medicine”. It came about beginning around 20 years ago because “complementary” in CAM implied that the nostrums that fell under the rubric of CAM were somehow less than real medicine (which, of course, they are—much less—but that’s not what their advocates belief). They were, after all, “complementary” or “alternative”. Medicine was the cake, and their wares were just the icing. That wasn’t good enough. They craved respect. They wanted to be co-equals with physicians and science- and evidence-based medicine. The term “integrative medicine” (IM) served their purpose perfectly. No longer were their treatments merely “complementary” to real medicine. Oh, no. Now they were “integrating” their treatments with those of science- and evidence-based medicine! The implication, the very, very, very intentional implication, was that alternative medicine was co-equal to science- and evidence-based medicine, an equal partner in the “integrating”. Further permutations are evolving as well, the most common of which is “integrative health”, in order to imply that “integrative medicine” is about more than just medicine, but rather overall health. Unfortunately, this moniker for integrating quackery into medicine (or health) is catching on.
That, of course, was still not enough. What’s the ultimate demonstration that a medical practice is accepted by society? Obviously, it’s licensure by the state. Practitioners of unscientific modalities, such as chiropractors, acupuncturists, naturopaths, and others crave licensure by the state. Chiropractors have been the most successful, having achieved licensure in all 50 states, and we’ve frequently written about attempts by naturopaths to claim licensure and be accepted as equivalent to primary care physicians, but acupuncturists have not been idle. They’ve been trying to be licensed in my state, and last week I did my part to oppose the licensure of acupuncturists. I’ll discuss the current state of the legislation and then provide an example of what can happen in a state that actually does license acupuncturists to show the consequences of licensing a pseudoscientific mystical modality that’s far more based on a prescientific superstitious understanding of how the body works than it is of anything resembling a modern scientific understanding of human physiology, genetics, and biochemistry.
HB 4710: Michigan acupuncturists try to claim licensure and expanded scope of practice
Last week, Jann Bellamy and I got an email from CFI-Michigan asking for assistance opposing HB 4710, a bill that was going to come before the Health Policy Committee last Thursday. Unfortunately, Thursday is my main clinic day, and I only had two days’ notice. I couldn’t very well cancel clinic on such short notice, particularly given that I’m going to miss a clinic on July 4 because it’s a holiday. That didn’t mean I wasn’t willing to help. Of course, these sorts of legislative hearings are often announced on short notice, which means in many cases that only those without jobs or the most passionately engaged can manage to drop everything they’re doing and journey to Lansing to attend these meetings. I had experienced the same thing a few years ago when misbegotten right-to-try legislation was pushed through the Michigan legislature.
First, however, let’s take a look at HB 4710 itself. Before I discuss the content of HB 4710 itself, I should point out that in the State of Michigan, acupuncturist is a title that is a registered profession. Basically, right now all that acupuncturists have to do is to register with the state, submit a background check, and pay a $275.75 fee.
So what would HB 4710 do? It would change the profession of acupuncturist in Michigan from a registered profession to a licensed profession. It would also turn “acupuncturist” into a protected term that can only be used by licensees and seems to establish a presumption in favor of being awarded a license as long as an individual has education or training “appropriate to the practice of acupuncture”. There would also be a continuing education requirement for acupuncturists seeking license renewal.
If that were all that HB 4710 would do if passed into law, that would be bad enough, but licensing acupuncturists is not all that it would do. Come, my friends, let’s read a bit of the text. Basically, the bill expands the scope of practice of acupuncturists to include:
(A) “ACUPRESSURE” MEANS A FORM OF MANUAL THERAPY IN WHICH PHYSICAL PRESSURE IS APPLIED TO VARIOUS POINTS ON THE BODY.
(B) (a) “Acupuncture” means the insertion and manipulation of needles through the surface of the human body. at specific locations on the human body for the prevention or correction of disease, injury, pain, or other condition. ACUPUNCTURE INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, LASER ACUPUNCTURE, ELECTROACUPUNCTURE, PRICKING THERAPY, DRY NEEDLING, AND INTRAMUSCULAR STIMULATION.
(C) (b) “Acupuncturist” means an individual who practices acupuncture and is registered, or otherwise authorized, LICENSED under this part TO ENGAGE IN THE PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE.
(D) “CUPPING” MEANS THE PLACEMENT OF A SPECIALLY DESIGNED CUP ON THE BODY TO CREATE SUCTION.
(E) “DERMAL FRICTION” MEANS THE USE OF REPEATED, CLOSELY TIMED, UNIDIRECTIONAL PRESS-STROKING WITH A SMOOTH-EDGED INSTRUMENT OVER A LUBRICATED AREA OF THE BODY.
(F) “DIETARY COUNSELING” MEANS THE PROCESS OF ADVISING A PATIENT ABOUT HEALTHY FOOD CHOICES AND HEALTHY EATING HABITS IN ACCORDANCE WITH EAST ASIAN MEDICAL THEORY.
(G) “DRY NEEDLING” MEANS A REHABILITATIVE PROCEDURE USING FILIFORM NEEDLES TO PENETRATE THE SKIN OR UNDERLYING TISSUES BY TARGETING ONLY MYOFASCIAL TRIGGER POINTS AND MUSCULAR AND CONNECTIVE TISSUES TO AFFECT CHANGE IN BODY STRUCTURES AND FUNCTIONS FOR THE EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT OF NEUROMUSCULOSKELETAL PAIN AND MOVEMENT IMPAIRMENT. DRY NEEDLING DOES NOT INCLUDE THE STIMULATION OF AURICULAR POINTS OR OTHER ACUPUNCTURE POINTS.
(H) “EAST ASIAN MEDICINE TECHNIQUES” INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, ACUPUNCTURE, MANUAL THERAPY, MOXIBUSTION, HEAT THERAPY, DIETARY COUNSELING, THERAPEUTIC EXERCISE, ACUPRESSURE, CUPPING, DERMAL FRICTION, HOMEOPATHY, LIFESTYLE COACHING, AND TREATMENT WITH HERBAL MEDICINES.
(I) “HEAT THERAPY” MEANS THE USE OF HEAT IN THERAPY, SUCH AS FOR PAIN RELIEF AND HEALTH.
(J) “HERBAL MEDICINE” MEANS THE INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL USE OF A PLANT OR A PLANT EXTRACT, A MINERAL, OR AN ANIMAL PRODUCT, THAT IS NOT A PRESCRIPTION DRUG AS THAT TERM IS DEFINED IN SECTION 17708.
(K) “HOMEOPATHY” MEANS THE USE OF A HIGHLY DILUTED NATURAL REMEDY FROM THE PLANT, MINERAL, AND ANIMAL DOMAIN.
(L) “LIFESTYLE COACHING” MEANS THE PROCESS OF ADVISING A PATIENT ABOUT HEALTHY LIFESTYLE CHOICES AND HABITS IN ACCORDANCE WITH EAST ASIAN MEDICAL THEORY.
(M) “MANUAL THERAPY” MEANS THE APPLICATION OF AN ACCURATELY DETERMINED AND SPECIFICALLY DIRECTED MANUAL FORCE TO THE BODY, EXCLUDING A HIGH-VELOCITY, LOW-AMPLITUDE THRUST TO THE SPINE.
(N) “MOXIBUSTION” MEANS BURNING THE DRIED PLANT Artemisia vulgaris ON OR VERY NEAR THE SURFACE OF THE SKIN AS A FORM OF THERAPY.
(O) “PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE”, SUBJECT TO SUBSECTION (2), MEANS THE USE OF TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY EAST ASIAN MEDICAL THEORY TO ASSESS AND DIAGNOSE A PATIENT, TO DEVELOP A PLAN TO TREAT THE PATIENT, AND TO TREAT THE PATIENT THROUGH EAST ASIAN MEDICINE TECHNIQUES.
Of all of these, H is the key. Basically, if passed into law, this provision would grant acupuncturists the scope of practice to do anything that is associated with “East Asian Medicine”, including acupuncture, manual therapy, moxibustion, heat therapy, dietary counseling, therapeutic exercise, acupressure, cupping, dermal friction, homeopathy, lifestyle coaching, and herbal medicine. Two of these stand out. For instance, since when has homeopathy ever been a part of “East Asian medicine”? When has homeopathy had anything whatsoever to do with traditional Chinese medicine or acupuncture? It’s its own quackery, “Western” or European quackery! Homeopathy was invented by Samuel Hahnemann in the late 1700s…in Germany! Yet, for some reason, acupuncturists in Michigan want to embrace it. It’s almost as though the acupuncturists promoting HB 4710 want to grab as much quackery as they can get away with and codify it into law allowing them to do almost anything, as long as it isn’t chiropractic (which this bill would prohibit them from doing, although it would let them do “manual therapy”) and they can claim it as part of “Eastern Asian medicine.”
Note also how this bill would let acupuncturists embrace “lifestyle coaching” and dietary advice as well. Apparently acupuncturists don’t think that acupuncture is woo enough for them and want to expand their scope of practice as much as possible, in much the same way naturopaths try to expand their scope of practice to be able to prescribe actual pharmaceutical drugs and represent themselves as primary care providers. (Never mind all that vitalistic nonsense and how strongly antivaccine most naturopaths are.)
Of course, there would be a board to regulate acupuncturists:
Sec. 16525. (1) The WITHIN 12 MONTHS AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE AMENDATORY ACT THAT AMENDED THIS SECTION, THE department, in consultation with the board, shall promulgate rules setting forth the minimum standards for registration as an acupuncturist. The department, in consultation with the board, may adopt by reference the professional standards issued by a certified program that is recognized by the national commission for certifying agencies or by a nationally recognized trade association.THAT ESTABLISH THE MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR LICENSURE AS AN ACUPUNCTURIST AND IMPLEMENT THE LICENSURE PROGRAM FOR THE PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE. IN PROMULGATING RULES FOR PURPOSES OF SECTION 16515(1), THE DEPARTMENT, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE BOARD, MAY ADOPT BY REFERENCE THE PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS ISSUED BY A CERTIFIED PROGRAM THAT IS RECOGNIZED BY THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR CERTIFYING AGENCIES. IN PROMULGATING RULES FOR PURPOSES OF SECTION 16515(2), THE DEPARTMENT, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE BOARD, SHALL CONSIDER WHETHER AN APPLICANT HAS COMPLETED SYSTEMATIC ACUPUNCTURE EDUCATION THAT INCLUDES LIVE LECTURES, DEMONSTRATIONS, AND SUPERVISED CLINICAL TRAINING SPECIFIC TO ACUPUNCTURE.
That’s the problem with the state regulating quackery. It isn’t science-based practitioners defining the standard of care and educational requirements for “professions” like acupuncture. It’s the quacks themselves. We’ve seen this issue with naturopaths, whose board in California, for instance, sought to sweep the particularly egregious death of a patient due to quackery under the rug. It’s why I argue that licensed quack “professionals” (like naturopaths) are no safer or less quacky than unlicensed ones.
Let’s look at an example in acupuncture.
Arizona acupuncture board “takes on the opioid crisis”
Acupuncture is a licensed profession in Arizona, complete with an Acupuncture Board of Examiners, as are so many other forms of quackery, such as homeopathic physicians, naturopaths, and more. On Friday, I came across an article on Cronkite News by Tim Ryan entitled “Arizona acupuncture board takes on the opioid crisis“:
The State of Arizona Acupuncture Board of Examiners has entered the fight against opioid abuse, approving chemical dependency programs for a form of acupuncture that involves the outer ear. Supporters say auricular acupuncture helps people break free of addiction, but a skeptic says there’s zero evidence acupuncture relieves any condition.
“I don’t think (auricular acupuncture is) the complete answer, but I think it can really help change the tide,” said Dr. Mario Fontes, clinic director of Natural Medicine & Detox in central Phoenix, which offers a board-approved chemical dependency program.
That skeptic, as you’ll see, is our very own Steve Novella. Unfortunately, this article plays out as a typical annoying article about quackery in mainstream press, full of false balance. Basically, it’s a “he said/he said” article, pitting Novella against a member of the State of Arizona Acupuncture Board of Examiners, Mario Fontes. You can tell where the reporter’s sympathies lie in the way that he gives Fontes the last word. After listing Novella’s reasonable criticisms of acupuncture that any regular reader of this blog or Neurologica Blog would be familiar with (acupuncture is a theatrical placebo; acupuncturists cherry pick studies; acupuncture is not benign; licensing acupuncture grants legitimacy to pseudoscience), Ryan allows Fontes to dismiss it all thusly:
Fontes said he has faced critics like Novella his entire career, but he remains undeterred.
“Anytime there’s something that’s not mainstream, eventually, it becomes integrated, and there’s always going to be the people opposed to that,” he said. “The people who want our help, we’re here for. The people who don’t, that’s OK.”
Noting that acupuncture has been practiced for millennia, Fontes contends that something more than a placebo effect is occurring, while medicines we’ve had for only a century, such as antibiotics, already are failing.
“It’s the predominant belief that the true path to health is drugs, radiation and surgery,” Fontes said. “I just don’t believe that.”
Of course, acupuncture, at least as we know it, has not been “practiced for millennia.” Acupuncture evolved from the Eastern version of a very well known European form of ancient medical practice, namely bloodletting. As Steve Novella noted, needles were originally lancets and acupuncture points were located over veins to be opened. Qi, or the Chinese concept of the life force, was believed to be at least in part in the blood, and bloodletting was thus thought to free the flow of qi. Unsurprisingly once you know this, this concept was closely related to the Galenic concept of using bloodletting to free the flow of static blood in the tissue. It’s also been argued that some acupuncture points are based on astrology. Indeed, reading descriptions from as recently as 106 years ago of the use of acupuncture in China by a Scottish surgeon named Dugald Christie produces horrifying examples of how acupuncture was practiced in the far more recent past than advocates would have you believe:
Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie an artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only mode of treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture, practised for all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are frequently used red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having no practical knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into large blood vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes resulted. A little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable spectacle. The doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire in its body, to let out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the abdomen deeply in several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly afterwards. For cholera the needling is in the arms. For some children’s diseases, especially convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails. For eye diseases they are often driven into the back between the shoulders to a depth of several inches. Patients have come to us with large surfaces on their backs sloughing by reason of excessive treatment of this kind with instruments none too clean.
That bit about “excess of fire in the body” reminds me of something, namely how the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) concepts underlying acupuncture involve “imbalances” in the “Five Elements”. In that, TCM is very similar to “ancient Western concepts”, namely humoral theory, which posited that disease is due to an “imbalance” in the four humors. As I like to say (sarcastically, of course), TCM is so very trendy, but where’s the love for traditional Western medicine? Indeed, TCM isn’t even very ancient. What we know today as TCM was a result of Chairman Mao, who was facing a dire shortage of real physicians, instructing his medical authorities to harmonize the many forms of Chinese folk medicine into a seemingly consistent whole and promote its “integration” with “Western medicine”. Basically, the history of TCM as promoted by its advocates has been retconned to leave that aspect out. Indeed, acupuncture itself, at least as practiced now, is not ancient. In the 1930s a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an proposed that needling therapy be resurrected because (he thought then) its actions could be explained through neurology. He also replaced the previously used coarse needles with the fine filiform needles in use today. No wonder there are so many “styles” of acupuncture.
Of course, I’ve written many times about how acupuncturists and other advocates of integrative medicine have been co-opting the opioid addiction crisis to promote whatever pseudoscientific medicine they believe in. Basically, the claim is that acupuncture, naturopathy, or whatever pseudoscience the advocates believe in can alleviate the opioid crisis by providing “nonpharmacological treatments” to relieve chronic pain. This has led to acupuncture advocates, for instance, to lobby various states to have Medicaid programs cover acupuncture. Some of the ways this misuse of the opioid crisis have been quite horrible, such as the proposal in Oregon to require that Medicaid patients be involuntarily weaned from opioids in favor of these “integrative” nonpharmacological approaches to pain, damn the evidence. Not surprisingly, three acupuncturists and a chiropractor sit on the committee that made this proposal.
Of course, one aspect of this article is that, whether intentionally or not, it reveals just how much other quackery is associated with acupuncture. This occurs through the focus on Mario Fontes, whose interest in alternative medicine “began with homeopathy, and later he expanded into acupuncture.” Yes, that’s homeopathy, or, as I like to call it, The One Quackery To Rule Them All. He’s also the one pushing auricular acupuncture as a treatment for opioid addiction:
First developed by French physician Paul Nogier in the 1950s, auricular acupuncture, also known as acu-detox, uses needles placed in one to five acupuncture points in the outer ear. Proponents say the practice offers a non-pharmacological approach to managing a range of issues, from pain to stress to post traumatic stress disorder to opiate withdrawals.
The acupuncture board has made efforts to make it easier for auricular acupuncturists to gain certification for the past few years to help address the opioid crisis, said the board’s executive director, David Geriminski.
Unfortunately, auricular acupuncture has become popular in the military in the form of “battlefield acupuncture” (no, I’m not kidding) and in the Veterans Health Administration. It is, unsurprisingly, even more quacky than regular acupuncture.
That’s not all, though. Mario Fontes offers quite the cornucopia of what I and skeptics consider quackery himself, as the perusal of his website, Natural Medicine & Detox, quickly reveals. For instance, here he is in his role as a clinical instructor at the American Medical College of Homeopathy and the Phoenix Institute of Herbal Medicine and Acupuncture, waxing poetic about combining The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy) with acupuncture:
Hilariously, Fontes goes on about how the “energetics” of acupuncture can be applied to the “energetics” of homeopathy and how homeopathy is safer than herbal medicine, which is probably true (because most homeopathic remedies are diluted to the point of being just water) but irrelevant. He also offers colon hydrotherapy; homeopathy (of course!); detox foot baths (the quackiest of quacky); “nutritional IVs” (also very quacky); chelation therapy (dangerous quackery); and much, much more.
Basically, acupuncturists often offer far more quackery than just acupuncture, and HB 4710 would license them in Michigan to do just that.
Acupuncture in Michigan
Checking out the website of a member of the State of Arizona Board of Acupuncture Examiners and observing all the quackery this board member offers led me to wonder whether the same would be true in Michigan. Some Googling rapidly led me to a listing of acupuncturists in Michigan. One practice that’s seemed to have well-optimized its SEO such that it shows up high on Google searches for acupuncture in Michigan is, appropriately enough, Michigan Associates of Acupuncture and Integrative Medicine. It offers the usual unproven acupuncture treatments along with TCM, craniosacral therapy, herbal medicine, and “nutrition”. Another large acupuncture practice, Acupuncture of West Michigan, offers acupuncture and herbal medicine, claiming that acupuncture and TCM can treat cardiac conditions (angina pectoris, atherosclerosis, anemia, hypertension, palpitations, coronary heart disease); neurological disorders (Bell’s palsy, dizziness, headaches, migraines, neuralgia, stroke, paralysis, tics, tremors); addictions (smoking, drugs, alcohol); GI conditions (low appetite, food sensitivities, peptic ulcer, constipation, colitis, Crohn’s disease, diarrhea, indigestion, irritable bowel syndrome, nausea, vomiting, gastritis); and, well, basically almost everything except, fortunately, cancer, noting:
With our modern diet and lifestyle, Acupuncture and Herbs are usually needed to effect a cure. But, making these changes will almost always get people better faster and help them stay healthy. Acupuncture is for treatment. Lifestyle is for prevention.
Other prominent acupuncture clinics include the Family Wellness Center, which in addition to acupuncture offers BioSET (R) Allergy Treatment and herbal therapy; Grand Wellness, which also offers reiki, distance healing, and crystal therapy; and Michigan Laser and Acupuncture Center, which offers something called Meridian Regulatory Acupuncture (MRA), which “introduces electrons where they are needled in the body to activate its defense, compensatory and regulating mechanisms in the control of pain and of disorder. MRA is a standardized acupuncture application, and controls the delivery of pure flow of electrical energy into the precise points making the treatment more efficient and effective”.
Yes, I think that, should acupuncturists in Michigan become licensed, they will expand their offerings of quackery to match those of acupuncturists in Arizona.
Oppose HB 4710 and bills licensing acupuncture, wherever they are introduced
Fortunately, my state representative (Matt Koleszar) is on the Michigan House Health Policy Committee. Unfortunately, one of the sponsors of HB 4710 (Hank Vaupel) is the chair of the Health Policy Committee. Still, I wrote to both Rep. Kolezar and cc’ed the secretary responsible for organizing testimony and statements before the committee:
Dear Rep. Koleszar:
As a constituent in your district, I am writing to express the strongest opposition that I can to HB 4710, the bill currently before the House Health Policy Committee to change the profession of acupuncturist from a registered profession to a licensed profession. My presumption is that you—along with everyone on the Health Policy Committee—will agree that medicine should be based on solid science showing that the interventions used are effective and safe. Thus, state licensure should only be granted to medical professions whose practices are supported by science and evidence. The reasons are two-fold: First, to protect the public from dubious and potentially dangerous practitioners and, second, because state licensure confers the imprimatur of the state, with all the respectability that provides, on the profession. Contrary to what its practitioners and supporters claim, acupuncture is supported by neither science nor evidence.
Although I do not presume to speak for anyone other than myself on this topic, to make you aware of my qualifications, I will state that I currently hold the title of Professor of Surgery at Wayne State University. I am also a surgical oncologist and breast cancer researcher at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute and have been a medical blogger for nearly 15 years. In that latter role, I write my personal blog (respectfulinsolence.com) and serve as managing editor of Science-Based Medicine (sciencebasedmedicine.org), a group blog dedicated to discussing the interface of science, pseudoscience, and medicine, and there is copious material published on both blogs to support my arguments here.
Acupuncture has no basis in human physiology or science. “Meridians” used by acupuncturists to guide the insertion of their needles have no basis in anatomy, and “qi,” the “life energy” whose flow, acupuncturists claim, is unblocked or redirected, has no basis in physics or chemistry and has never been detected or characterized. It is claimed that acupuncture is effective for a wide variety of conditions with little or no relationship in pathophysiology (cause), which, in my experience, is a huge red flag that it doesn’t work for anything, other than through nonspecific effects. Indeed, there is a reason why acupuncture has been referred to as a “theatrical placebo,” because that’s what it is. (Please see attached PDF for an excellent discussion of this.) I would remind you and the committee that the usual standard that the FDA uses for approving a new treatment is that it be more effective than placebo. Although there are individual studies that report acupuncture to be better than placebo for some ailments, when you critically examine the totality of the evidence, the effects of acupuncture are indistinguishable from sham acupuncture. Basically, it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles, and it doesn’t even matter if you stick the needles in. Consistent with the lack of specificity of acupuncture effects, there is a 2009 German study [Arch Intern Med.2009;169(9):858-866] that shows that twirling toothpicks against the skin is just as effective as “true” acupuncture.
If all this bill did were to license acupuncturists, that would be bad enough, but it goes beyond that. If passed, it would expand the scope of practice to include moxibustion, homeopathy (which has nothing to do with acupuncture or Traditional Chinese Medicine), acupressure, cupping, and dermal friction (otherwise known as gua sha) among other “treatments.” Homeopathy, in particular, is pure quackery based on pseudoscience and mystical thinking that has nothing to do with acupuncture. Acupuncture originated in Asia, although it is unclear how long ago; homeopathy originated independently in Germany in the late 1700s and has never been part of traditional Chinese medicine. From a historical and factual point of view, to claim, as this bill does, that homeopathy is part of “East Asian medicine” is so inaccurate as to be risible.
As for why I call homeopathy “pure quackery, I will explain. Homeopathy is based on two “Laws”: (1) the Law of Similars, which states that, to relieve a symptom you need to use something that causes that symptom; and (2) the Law of Infinitesimals, which states that a remedy becomes stronger the more it is diluted. The Law of Similars has no basis in science, physiology, or biology; it is, in essence sympathetic magic turned into medicine by Samuel Hahnemann, the creator of homeopathy. The Law of Infinitesimals is even more ridiculous. Chemists know that any dilution more than around 12C (twelve 100-fold dilutions) is unlikely to have any starting substance left. This is because a mole of a substance only has around 6 x 10^23 molecules, and a 12C solution is a 1 x 10^24 dilution. I would point out to the committee that many homeopathic remedies are diluted to 30C (a 10^60-fold dilution) or even 100C—or even higher. I would also point out that the number of atoms in the known universe is only estimated to be around 10^78 to 10^82. The math and chemistry of homeopathy are ridiculous. Not surprisingly, homeopathy is no better than placebo, because it is, in essence, water. The other treatments encompassed by the scope of practice expansion granted acupuncturists by this bill are scarcely any better in terms of their evidence base. Traditional Chinese medicine, for instance, is based on prescientific beliefs about how the body works not validated by science and includes such diagnostic modalities as “tongue diagnosis” and “pulse diagnosis,” neither of which is validated by science.
In addition to the issue of state licensure conferring respectability to pseudoscience, a major problem with licensing a specialty that is not based in science is that it will be members of that specialty who form a board to oversee the practitioners of that specialty, which means that there will be no scientific standards regulating that specialty. In other words, acupuncture will be what acupuncturists claim that it is, and the standard of care will be what acupuncturists dictate it to be. Neither will be based in science, and, contrary to the intent of the bill, the public will not be protected from bad actors any more than they are by the present system. In addition, the reason practitioners of unconventional specialties like acupuncture so crave state licensure is that it is the first step to requiring insurers to pay for their services. This, if it comes to pass (as it likely will if acupuncture is licensed), will result in a diversion and waste of precious health care resources to pay for ineffective therapies.
In conclusion, acupuncture does not meet the minimal requirements for a medical specialty to be licensed by the state. It is not based in science, but rather in prescientific mysticism; there is no clear standard of care to guide regulation; there is no clear standard of education for practitioners; and available scientific evidence is most consistent with its effects being all nonspecific or placebo effects, an expected finding given the scientific implausibility of the practice. Worse, HB 4710 would broaden the scope of acupuncturists to include the use of modalities that, like homeopathy, can only be described as pure quackery. I urge you and the committee to reject this bill and not send it to the full House for consideration and request that my email and the accompanying article be included in the evidence presented during the June 20 committee meeting.
Sincerely,
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD
For good measure, I included Steve Novella and David Colqhoun’s famous article, “Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo: the end of a myth“. If anyone else wants to comment on the licensure of acupuncture in Michigan, feel free to use my letter as a template. In addition, Jennifer Beahan, executive director of CFI-Michigan, testified in person, providing more points to make:
And CFI-Michigan issued a call to action, Stop The Grab Bag Of Quackery In Michigan!, which provides a nice summary of arguments against licensing acupuncturists.
If you live in Michigan, now is the time to contact your state representative to express opposition to HB 4710, particularly if your representative sits on the Michigan House Health Policy Committee, as my representative does. This isn’t the first attempt by acupuncturists to attain licensure, and it surely won’t be the last; that is, assuming they are unsuccessful, an outcome that I will do my best to help to bring about. Unfortunately, the transcript of the testimony is not (yet) online, but I very well might discuss on my not-so-super-secret other blog when the transcript is published.
If you don’t live in Michigan, keep an eye out for these sorts of bills in your state. Often they are introduced on the down-low, and that results in only advocates writing to legislators and showing up to testify at meetings of the relevant committees. It truly is, as Jann Bellamy describes it, legislative alchemy.

Legislative Alchemy: Licensing reflexologists and other practitioners of pseudoscience
State legislatures are considering bills that would legitimize pseudoscience like reflexology and reiki by recognizing their practitioners as health care professionals.
Jann Bellamy on April 7, 2026
Link

Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, once again, states are considering licensing reflexologists as health care practitioners, just like medical doctors and nurses. To add insult to injury, some proposed legislation expands licensing to other alternative medicine practices, like Ayurvedic and energy healing.
Legislative Alchemy playbook
Briefly, Legislative Alchemy is the incorporation of pseudoscience into the law. One widespread example is the chiropractic “vertebral subluxation”, “an asymptomatic and undetectable ‘joint dysfunction’… alleged to affect organ system function and general health.” There is no credible evidence that these subluxations exist, yet Congress mandates that Medicare pay chiropractors for manual manipulation of the spine to correct them. More to the point of our post today, chiropractors are licensed health care practitioners in all 50 states, their scope of practice defined by law as the detection and correction of these mythical subluxations.
Following what I call the Legislative Alchemy playbook, chiropractors have created, and control, organizations such as chiropractic schools, the Council on Chiropractic Education (which accredits the schools), and the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (which administers their licensing exam). State legislators incorporate these organizations into licensing legislation as guarantors of chiropractors’ fitness to practice, ensuring that chiropractors alone are in control of what they learn and their practice standards. To prevent outsiders from meddling in their affairs, a regulatory board controlled by chiropractors is placed in charge of rule-making and discipline.
Superficially, it looks a lot like licensing for medical doctors. And if you don’t actually read the practice act, you’ll have no idea that it’s all based on pseudoscience.
(For a more complete discussion of health care licensing and the elements of a typical practice act, see here.)
Reflexology
Reflexology is in something of a regulatory limbo, with some states regarding it as a type of massage and therefore requiring a massage therapy license to practice. Other states specifically exempt reflexology from massage licensing requirements, leaving it either unregulated or giving reflexologists their own practice act.
The American Reflexology Certification Board (ARCB) pushes for the latter via legislation and, toward that end, came up with this definition, suitable, they feel, for inclusion in licensing bills:
‘Reflexology’ means a protocol of manual techniques… that are applied to specific reflex areas predominantly on the feet and hands of an individual who is fully clothed, except for footwear. The protocol stimulates the complex neural pathways linking body systems and supports the body’s efforts to function optimally. Reflexology does not include the diagnosis of or treatment for specific diseases, or joint manipulations.
The ARCB further “explains” that the “primary intent” of reflexology is “to support the health of the body’s internal systems” by focusing on “reflexes corresponding to stressed organs and glands”. Thus, in their view, reflexology can “safely help people of all ages restore homeostasis, optimize physiological functions and address system imbalances and weaknesses”.
Or, as I less credulously summarized their claims in a previous post:
In other words, these manufactured ‘reflex areas’ (illustrated in the above foot chart), are somehow connected by ‘complex neural pathways’ (so complex they are apparently incapable of explanation by medical science) to the body’s organs and other ‘body systems’. ‘Manual techniques’ applied to the “reflex areas” activates something or other in these ‘complex neural pathways’ and this, in turn, positively affects ‘stressed organs and glands’ in some unspecified manner, thereby bringing about suitably vague effects like ‘optimizing physiological function’ and allowing the reflexologist plenty of room to claim that reflexology can benefit all manner of conditions and diseases.
Following the typical Legislative Alchemy playbook, which has been wildly successful for chiropractors, naturopaths, and acupuncturists, reflexologists have created schools, a proto-accrediting agency, a credentialing agency (the ARCB), and a professional organization, all run by reflexologists. These organizations stand at the ready to be incorporated, if needed, into a proposed practice act, along with a scope of practice (which they’ve defined as above) and a regulatory board, on which they hold a majority of seats.
With that, let’s turn to proposed legislation regulating reflexology and see how practitioners are following the Legislative Alchemy playbook.
North Carolina
The “North Carolina Healing Arts Act” (House Bill 122) would regulate reflexologists under the auspices of a newly created Healing Arts Commission, tasked with protecting the public from “unqualified persons” and ensuring “the highest degree of professional services” by issuing “healing arts” practitioner licenses. “Healing arts” are expansively defined as
allopathic, complementary, or alternative approaches to the art and science of medicine for the prevention, identification, and treatment of human physical or mental conditions, diseases, ailments, illnesses, infirmities, pain, defects, or injuries and promotion and restoration of health and wellness.
Note that this definition specifically endorses alternative medicine, generally understood as the use of unproven practices instead of “conventional” medicine.
Initially, only reflexologists and music therapists are eligible for licensing, but the Act anticipates further “healing arts professions” being added by future legislation, leaving the door open for all sorts of licensed quackery.
(The American Music Therapy Association defines music therapy as “clinical & evidence-based”. I’ve not looked into their claims, but my discussion of this bill is concerned only with reflexology and other potential quackery, not music therapy.)
Each “healing arts profession” has its own Advisory Committee, consisting of two practitioners and one public member. The Commission itself is also composed of practitioners, thereby ensuring a double layer of foxes guarding the proverbial henhouse.
Reflexology is defined in the bill as
A protocol of manual techniques… applied to specific reflex areas predominantly on the feet and hands and that stimulate complex neural pathways linking body systems and support the body’s efforts to function optimally.
Notably, it excludes the ARCB definition’s prohibition against the diagnosis and treatment of specific diseases.
In fact, taken together with the generous definition of “healing arts” quoted above, reflexologists would be able to “stimulate” these illusory “complex neural pathways linking the body systems” to treat any patient of any age with any disease or condition.
Qualifications for this immense responsibility are—to be generous—modest. Reflexologists would have to be all of 18 years old, “of good moral character”, and—adhering closely to the Legislative Alchemy playbook—hold a certification awarded by the ARCB.
ARCB actually offers two certifications: feet and hands. Each requires a high school diploma (or “equivalent”) and a 200-hour reflexology course (either in-person or hybrid in-person and online), including 30 hours (thus, less than a typical workweek) of “practical instruction”.
Applicants for certification can choose the foot exam, the hand exam, or a combination. To ensure that everyone is marching in step and not confused by other charts showing a different array of targeted body parts,
The ARCB utilizes the American Standard Reflexology Foot and Hand Maps. Please base your documentation and exam prep on these charts.
Applicants must also “successfully complete the ARCB SOAP [presumably, Subjective, Objective, Assessment and Plan] Note”. You can see a blank SOAP note form and find a link to a completed example here. Note how, in the latter, the reflexologist presumes to have diagnosed clinically significant abnormalities in the client’s feet and to have located “reflex points” for various body parts she deems clinically significant based on the client’s symptoms. Building on the late, great Dr. Harriet Hall’s “Tooth Fairy Science”, we could call this “Tooth Fairy Clinical Practice”.
The ARCB doesn’t require, or endorse, completion of any particular reflexology school to apply for certification. Rather, it lists topics one’s curriculum should cover, including, paradoxically, both “Critical Thinking” and “Foot Reflexes and Maps”. It does refer candidates to the National Council for Reflexology Educators, which aims to develop national standards for reflexology education. As might be expected, these “standards” include teaching nonsensical reflexology maps and how to locate “reflexes”, as well as marketing.
Under the proposed Act, continuing education (12 hours every 2 years) is also farmed out to the ARCB, leaving it to decide which CE providers can sell their courses to NC reflexologists.
A competing North Carolina bill, House Bill 99, the “Reflexologists Right to Work Act”, would simply remove reflexologists from the jurisdiction of the Board of Massage and Bodywork Therapy and allow them to practice with no regulatory oversight, as long as they are “ARCB-certified”. The bill uses the same science-free definition of reflexology as House Bill 122.
Massachusetts
Massachusetts Senate Bill 261 is entitled “An act regulating alternative [that word again] healing therapies”. The proposed law replaces the massage therapy board with a “board of registration of massage therapy and alternative healing therapies.” Naturally, massage therapy and alternative healing practitioners themselves would make up a majority of board members and would decide, aided by an advisory council composed solely of alternative medicine practitioners, what their scopes of practice and qualifications for licensing should be.
Per the bill, serving as a perfect example of the Legislative Alchemy process, standards for professional and ethical conduct and education should reflect “acceptable national, state, or other recognized professional organization or certification standards of each discipline”.
The foxes could not have asked for better.
This is a truly frightening bill. “Alternative healing therapies” include:
Asian bodywork therapy, bodywork, reflexology, structural integration or Rolfing, and energy and somatic health practices as identified by the advisory council [made up of alternative therapy practitioners] . . .
In addition to reflexology, a few practices are specifically defined. For example, Asian bodywork therapy is the treatment of
the human body/spirit/mind, including the electromagnetic or energetic field, which surrounds, infuses and brings that body to life.
Sounds like someone read, or watched, Frankenstein.
“Energy and somatic healing practices” are to be further defined by the advisory council, and may include, but are not limited to:
The Feldenkrais Method; the Trager Approach; Ayurvedic Therapies; Polarity or Polarity Therapy; Qi Gong [caution: typically credulous NCCIH explanation]; Body/Mind Centering; and Reiki, levels II and above.
In sum, the bill would license all manner of quackery, limited only by the imagination of the advisory council and board.
The board would have the authority to investigate complaints
for fraudulent, deceptive, or professionally incompetent and unsafe practices.
If one assumes, based on established science, that telling a client his electromagnetic field is out of whack, and charging to fix it, is deceptive and fraudulent, then this provision has the potential to wipe out a lot of practitioners. I’ll wager that is not the intent.
Iowa
Finally, Iowa House File 2178 would allow practitioners to use the term “certified reflexologist” if they met certain educational requirements, although the bill eschewed naming a particular educational or certifying organization. Practitioners would operate under the jurisdiction of the board of medicine. The bill uses the reflexologist-approved definition of their practice, including the prohibition against diagnosis and treatment of disease.
No matter the fate of any particular bill this year, reflexologists and other alternative medicine practitioners appear determined to become licensed health care professionals, so they’ll be back, year after year, with ready-made practice acts in hand.


Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left
Jann Bellamy on April 4, 2013
Link

Homeopathy is quackery but it is perfectly legal to prescribe homeopathic products and to sell them directly to consumers in the United States as well as other supposedly civilized countries such as the United Kingdom and Germany. This makes as much sense as allowing the sale of batteries that don’t produce electricity.
What makes this state of affairs even stranger is that homeopathic products are classified as drugs under U.S. law. Does this mean that they undergo the same pre-market approval process and are subject to the same post-market requirements as pharmaceutical drugs? No, not by a long shot. In fact, the federal government and the FDA have pretty much handed regulation of homeopathic products over to their manufacturers.
How did this happen?
In 1938, Congress passed the Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act. The Act’s principle author was Senator Royal Copeland, a physician who practiced homeopathy. He managed to include all articles monographed in the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS) in the definition of drugs within the FDCA, although why he did so remains in dispute. The HPUS is a source for monographs, identity, methods of manufacture, standards and controls and potency levels of homeopathic products, both prescription and OTC. (The vast majority of homeopathic products are OTC.) In short, if the product is in the HPUS, it’s legal.
Since the FDCA’s enactment, any attempt at imposing any reasonable regulation of these products has failed. As noted in a previous post, a federal district judge found that:
“As evidenced by the FDA guidance documents. . .the Court concludes that the FDA has largely abdicated any role it might have had in creating standards for homeopathic OTC drugs, and has instead attempted to delegate this authority to the non-governmental organization that determines whether homeopathic substances should be included in the HPUS. In addition, the FDA explicitly states that it makes no guarantee about the safety or efficacy of homeopathic OTC drugs even if they meet the unknown standards for inclusion in the HPUS.”
As explained in one excellent review of homeopathic product regulation reprinted on Quackwatch, part of the reason is that, all along, regulators and politicians thought that surely the demise of homeopathy was right around the corner and the problem would solve itself. Here they were partially correct. The practice of traditional homeopathy has all but died out, and only three states actually license practicing homeopaths, who must be medical doctors. Unfortunately, no one seemed to see the boom in over-the-counter homeopathic product sales coming, which in the U.S. amounted to $3.1 billion in 2007. And while traditional homeopaths may go the way of the horse and buggy, “integrative” medical doctors and naturopaths are taking up the slack.
Both the lack of regulation and the sales boom are directly attributable to the visionary leadership of the homeopathic product industry, specifically one John A. Borneman, III. Borneman made these claims during his Founder’s Day Address at the University of the Sciences in Philadelphia, upon the occasion of his being awarded an honorary doctorate. The University of the Sciences was formerly known as the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and Science, and holds an honored place in the history of pharmacy education as the first college of pharmacy in the U.S., established in 1821. SBM’s own David J. Kroll, Ph.D., obtained his undergraduate degree in toxicology there and was, needless to say, distressed to learn that his alma mater was awarding an honorary Doctorate of Science degree to this man. In 2009, Kroll protested to the University’s president in a characterization that may inform your opinion of Mr. Borneman when we return to his explanation of how homeopathy has escaped regulation.
I wish to register my strongest objection to the recognition and University endorsement of an individual who has led an organization dedicated to the most egregious form of pseudoscience in pharmacy: homeopathic medicines. Awarding Mr. Borneman an Honorary Doctor of Science is an affront to every scientist who has ever earned a degree from the University and, I would suspect, all current faculty members who are engaged in scientific investigation.
Homeopathy is a fraudulent representation of pharmacy and the pharmaceutical sciences that continues to exist in the United States due solely to political, not scientific, reasons. . .But scientifically, homeopathic remedies are nothing more than highly-purified water misrepresented as medicine based upon an archaic practice that is diametrically opposed to all pharmacological principles. The mental gymnastics required to teach chemistry, pharmacology, and therapeutics while also embracing homeopathy are beyond the skills of anyone trained in the scientific method.
In awarding an Honorary Doctor of Science to Mr. Borneman, the University will be endorsing an “entrepreneurial spirit” that seeks to defraud health care consumers with “potentized” water as a medicine to treat and prevent disease. . .To reward Mr. Borneman’s leadership of a pseudoscience practice and its marketing to a public that holds pharmacy among the most trusted of professions is to return to the days of snake oil and deception that our founders worked tirelessly to remedy.
(You can read about University president’s response here.)
Borneman was a principal in his family’s homeopathic products company. He then joined Standard Homeopathic Company, of which Hyland’s is a subsidiary, as well as creating Homeopathic Laboratories of Pennsylvania and TxOptions Pharmacy, which also provides advice to consumers about homeopathic remedies.
In his Founder’s Day remarks, Borneman spoke of three pivotal events which guaranteed that the homeopathic products industry would be in complete control of their own regulation.
First, in the 1980s, there was an attempt to regulate all homeopathic products as prescription drugs. The FDA postponed any action toward that end by consulting with the homeopathic product manufacturers. The FDA ultimately decided it didn’t have the expertise to know what to do, so the agency left it up to the industry to draft a Compliance Policy Guide (CPG), which are directives from the agency to personnel providing guidance on a particular issue. The industry naturally obliged, the result being Compliance Policy Guide (CPG) 7132.15, “Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs may be Marketed.” Borneman is refreshingly (although perhaps unintentionally) honest about how the industry wrote the rules in this instance:
We sent them a streamlined document in 1983, and a revision in June 1986. They [FDA] circulated it internally for review & comment, including the Justice Department, and published a document in the Federal Register in June 1988. It was enforced in 1990 and still, unmodified, continues to be effective today. The CPG put to rest the OTC/Rx controversy. . .With the CPG well established, homeopathy in the US was investable and the Europeans seized the opportunity and purchased outright or appropriated almost all of the languishing American firms.
Fortunately for the Borneman family, the “investable” companies included his own, Borneman & Sons, which entered into a joint venture with Boiron, a French company and the world’s largest manufacturer of homeopathic products.
Enter the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States
That task out of the way, Borneman next concentrated on “refurbishing” the HPUS and the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States (HPCUS). The HPCUS decides what can be included in the HPUS, which, as you recall, is incorporated wholesale into the definition of “drug” under federal law. As I said, if it’s in the HPUS, it’s legal. As he explained:
I understood that regulators would not act favorably if it appeared I was looking out for the industry or myself. Economics could not be an issue. I had to make the argument that the consumer had rights and FDA could not disenfranchise them. They were obligated to accommodate the consumer. This struck a chord and the work began.
And here I was thinking that the FDA had some duty to actually protect the consumer, not accommodate. What really occurred was that the FDA apparently felt it had an obligation to accommodate the homeopathic product manufacturers. What happened next exceeded Borneman’s most optimistic expectations and was the third and final step in assuring that the industry gained control of its own regulation.
Borneman and other industry representatives met with Mark Novitch, MD, Deputy Commissioner of the FDA, and put on their dog and pony show. Two presenters were practicing MD homeopaths, Sandra Chase and David Riley, who explained “Basic Tenets, Corollaries, basic features, provings and methods of Cure.” (Cure?) Others were homeopathic pharmacists. Borneman continues:
I believed the meeting went well, but was not prepared for what was to follow. Dr. Novich told us the Agency was not prepared to run a new drug review and approval process for homeopathic drugs. . .Dr. Novich liked what he had seen and heard and asked if we would serve as the gatekeeper for new homeopathic drugs. We eagerly accepted the task and have been rigorous in its implementation since.
Having already dumped the entire homeopathic formulary into federal law in 1938 and succeeded in fending off regulation of original or added products since then, the homeopathic industry was thus poised to secure its future as the sole arbiter of what homeopathic products could be legally sold in the U.S. And all of this with only occasional interference by the FDA when products were, say, harming infants or causing loss of the ability to smell.
So, how does the HPCUS operate? Does it, for example, include public or consumer representatives? Does it have a process for insuring that those who do not share the view that homeopathy is safe or effective are included to provide a more balanced view? Let’s find out by looking at the organization’s own Bylaws and Procedure Manual.
The HPCUS is a non-profit corporation. It controls both the addition of new products and changes to existing ones. Application for inclusion of a new product must be supported by a monograph which goes through various committees for review and there is a period for public comment, although access to the monographs for comment is via homeopathy journals. Changes to the products already listed in the HPUS also go through a committee review process.
Proving nothing
Products are reviewed for safety and effectiveness by these committees. As to the latter, according to one journal article, while the traditional homeopathic proving is one way to approach this,
Overall, adequately designed and well-controlled clinical trials have become the norm for homeopathic medicine as they are for most allopathic [sic] medicines.
I don’t know of any such trials, but perhaps adequately designed and well-controlled has a different meaning in homeopathic research. Of course, the conclusion of this same article was
Homeopathic drugs in the United States are subject to well-defined regulatory processes that more closely resemble those that apply to allopathic medications than to dietary supplements.
So it is advisable to take the article’s conclusions with a grain of undiluted salt. Of the two authors, one was John P. (“Jay”) Borneman, John A. Borneman’s son. Jay is a principal owner of Standard Homeopathic Company and CEO of Hyland’s.
Once a product or change is approved, that information is incorporated into the HPUS, which is sold by the HPCUS to the public through subscription. For $100, you can get access for 24 hours. It is $1,000 per year for an individual and $15,000 per year for a corporate subscription.
More interesting than the process are the persons who are making these decisions. Membership in the HPCUS is vetted by the Board of Directors. Committees responsible for reviewing both new products and changes to the HPUS are appointed by the President, who is a member of, and chosen by, the Board. All final decisions on what is and isn’t included in the HPUS must be approved by the Board. And who chooses the Board? The Board. It is self-perpetuating and not elected by the members, so each Board elects new Board members. While a Board term is three years, there is no limit on the number of terms a Board member can serve.
So let’s see who is on the Board of the HPCUS. Because it has been granted charitable organization status (501(c)(3)) by the IRS, it does not pay federal income tax on contributions or earnings from subscription sales but it must file a federal tax return, which becomes public information. These returns list the current Board of Directors and are available for the last three years (2011, 2010, 2009) through Guidestar.
For 2009-2011, Chair of the Board is none other than John A. Borneman III, who has to be at least in his 80s. President of the Board (that is, the person who appoints all the committees reviewing HPUS additions and changes) is his son Jay. But they are not they only two Standard/Hyland’s connected directors. Another is Mark S. Phillips, who is Standard’s President. (A 2011 warning letter from the FDA to Phillips can be viewed here.) The Secretary and Treasurer are Sandra Chase and William Shevin, respectively, the two MD homeopaths who helped convince the FDA to allow self-regulation back in 1993. Rounding out the Board are David Riley, a homeopathic physician and “integrative medicine” consultant, and Eric Foxman, a homeopathic pharmacist. The Executive Director in 2009, since deceased, was Andy Bormeth, who also worked for a homeopathic products manufacturer before he opened his own homeopathic products consulting service. For 2010 and 2011, Todd Hoover, another homeopathic physician, served on the Board.
Conclusion: Conflicts of interest and homeopathic regulation
In summary, all decisions on the content of the HPUS (and therefore what may be legally sold or prescribed as a homeopathic product) are made by either practicing homeopaths, homeopathic pharmacists, or current or former officials or owners of homeopathic products manufacturing companies. And three are from a single company! Does this seem a bit too cozy? Does anyone think the Board is going to elect Board members who will rock the boat? Or who might be the least bit interested in telling the public the truth about homeopathy?
To be fair, the HPCUS does have a conflict of interest policy which requires disclosure of conflicts and recusal from deciding issues which may affect them financially. (Which makes me wonder how they get anything done, considering.) Even so, it is appalling that the federal government has totally defaulted in its responsibility for determining what homeopathic drugs can be prescribed and sold to a private non-profit completely controlled by industry insiders.
In my last post, I suggested that instead of the Quack Miranda Warning a more accurate disclaimer of FDA involvement in dietary supplement regulation might be:
FDA WARNING: Safety and effectiveness unknown. Use at your own risk.
Perhaps a more accurate FDA disclaimer for homeopathic product regulation might be:
FDA WARNING: Safety unknown. Effectiveness unknown but highly unlikely. Use at your own risk.

More Political Science: Proposed laws protect “Lyme literate” doctors from discipline
“Lyme literate” doctors are scamming patients out of thousands of dollars with needless long-term antibiotics based on a fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme.” So why are state legislators trying to protect these doctors from discipline and make insurers pay for unnecessary treatments?
Jann Bellamy on March 15, 2018
Link


In yet another example of the ubiquitous practice of Legislative Alchemy, bills are pending in several state legislatures this year giving sustenance to the fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme” disease and its treatment with unorthodox and potentially dangerous means. The most troublesome bills protect so-called “Lyme literate” physicians and other practitioners from discipline for substandard practice. “Chronic Lyme” patients want to protect their doctors from what they see as persecution by the medical establishment, even as these same patients are being fleeced out of thousands of dollars for unproven treatments. Other bills force insurers to pay for discredited treatments for “chronic Lyme” or require that burdensome and misleading disclosures be given to patients about Lyme disease.
Before we get to the specifics of these proposals, a brief refresher on “chronic Lyme” and “Lyme literate” physicians, a subject we’ve covered covered many times on SBM.
Lyme literacy
Lyme disease is an infectious disease transmitted by a tick bite. Its symptoms are a rash, fever, headache and fatigue, although not all symptoms may appear. According to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), it is diagnosed by medical history, physical exam, and sometimes a blood test. Treatment with a short course of antibiotics usually eliminates the symptoms, but delayed treatment can result in more serious problems.
“Chronic Lyme” is not recognized as a disease in the medical community. Its symptoms are, well, pretty much anything. One description from a post by Harriet Hall:
[Chronic] Lyme is a multi-systemic illness, and may affect every part of the body causing fatigue, stiff neck, headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), anemia, dizziness, joint and muscle pain, brain fog, tingling, numbness and burning sensations of the extremities, memory and concentration problems, difficulties with sleep (both falling asleep and frequent awakening), chest pain and palpitations and/or psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety.
As Dr. Hall correctly notes, “that pretty much covers everyone.”
A new term, post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, has been coined for those who had Lyme disease but whose symptoms remain, although there is no good evidence that these symptoms can be attributed to persistent Lyme infection. There is no scientific controversy, however, that “chronic Lyme” disease, as applied to patients with nonspecific symptoms who show no objective evidence that they have been infected with Lyme disease, is a fabricated diagnosis. (As are the newer, move-the-goalposts putative infections to which “Lyme literate” doctors attribute “chronic Lyme.”) It is these patients who have been victimized by “Lyme literate” physicians and alternative medicine practitioners.
As you would expect in cases where a collection of vague symptoms have been bootstrapped into a disease (e.g., chronic candidiasis, adrenal fatigue) there are also a number of bogus diagnostic techniques and worthless quack treatments available. The main treatment is long-term antibiotics, for which there is no evidence of effectiveness but serious risks. (Also, here and here.)
The CDC, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, the Medical Letter, and the American Academy of Neurology all reject the notion that “chronic Lyme” exists and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment. Over a dozen international organizations, like the Canadian Public Health Network and the European Federation of Neurological Societies, agree.
That has not stopped “Lyme literate” doctors from banding together to form the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) and issuing their own guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme,” guidelines based on very low levels of evidence that are accepted only by themselves and, in contrast to the IDSA guidelines, no other professional medical organization. ILADS teaches physicians and other practitioners how to become “Lyme literate.” ILADS, again in contrast to IDSA, is not an ACCME-accredited provider of continuing medical education and, to my knowledge, none of its courses qualify for continuing medical education credit. Nor are ILADS guidelines taught as appropriate in any medical school, residency or fellowship program.
Making a fake diagnosis and treating the patient with unnecessary long-term antibiotics can put a “Lyme literate” doctor on the state medical board’s radar, especially when patients are harmed by the treatment or there is a failure to diagnose the patient’s real condition, such as Parkinson’s disease. Hence, the need to protect the “Lyme literate” from prosecution. This effort is assisted by a small but vocal contingent of patients who see their “Lyme literate” doctors as saviors and flood medical boards with letters of support. These same patients, armed with anecdotes of their supposed cures, petition their legislators for protection of what they deem persecution of their physicians.
Maryland: All in on “chronic Lyme”
In 2016, the Maryland legislature passed a bill substituting its healthcare advice for that of physicians. The law requires labs to tell patients that current tests for Lyme are “problematic,” that a negative test does not mean they don’t have Lyme disease, and that they should contact a health care provider if they continue to exhibit “unexplained symptoms” to “inquire about the appropriateness of retesting or initial or additional treatment.”
The IDSA opposes this type of notice as “non-evidence based.” That being the case, I question the constitutionality of the law because:
the First Amendment prohibits the government from compelling people [including physicians] to make false or misleading statements or to express the government’s point of view as their own.
At the time, Delegate Kathy Afzali, a co-sponsor of the bill, whose background is in theater and real estate, said it was only the first of a series of bills she hoped to get through the legislature:
The question is, what is the proper treatment for the disease [sic] There’s many different schools of thought. We want to be able to pass legislation that helps these patients who have long-term treatment for Lyme.
Even though there are not “many different schools of thought,” true to her word, Delegate Afzali and 38 of her fellow Delegates are sponsoring a bill (House Bill 880) in this legislative session forcing insurers to pay for long-term antibiotic treatment of “chronic Lyme” disease, which includes a clinical diagnosis that does not meet the CDC’s criteria:
but presents other acute, persistent, or chronic signs or symptoms of Lyme disease as determined by a licensed physician, whether that diagnosis is based on knowledge obtained through medical history and physical examination only or in conjunction with testing.
In other words, if the “Lyme literate” physician says it’s Lyme, it’s Lyme, and the health insurer must provide coverage for:
the full length of the long-term antibiotic treatment to be administered in the manner prescribed . . . [The insurer] may not impose a quantitative limitation on the long-term antibiotic treatment . . . [and] may not deny coverage . . . solely because the treatment may be categorized as unproven, experimental, or investigational in nature.
In sum, Maryland legislators, including the Senators who support a companion bill (Senate Bill 793) are willing to put the force of law behind a fake diagnosis, as well as unproven treatments for the fake diagnosis, and make everyone (though the shared cost of insurance) pay for it. This won’t be the first time. In 2016, Massachusetts legislators were so enamored of a similar bill that they overrode Governor Baker’s veto so insurers would have to pay for long-term antibiotic treatment.
Sadly, testimony in favor of the bills only serves to demonstrate just how badly “Lyme literate” physicians are scamming patients. In one media report, a mother said she had taken her daughter to 51 doctors before she was “properly diagnosed” with “chronic Lyme.” One legislator told a reporter that people were being bankrupted paying for long-term treatment. That’s unsurprising, considering media reports that “chronic Lyme” treatment can cost $10,000 to $35,000. (After one of my posts on the discipline of a “Lyme literate” physician by a state medical board, I received a thank-you email from a parent who had been scammed out of $30,000 for a child’s treatment.) In contrast, the cost of the IDSA-recommended treatment for Lyme disease with antibiotics is about $40 and is covered by most insurance. Fortunately, good citizens with no connection to the insurance industry showed up as well (although in far fewer numbers) to testify against these bills.
But that’s not the worst “chronic Lyme” bill pending in Maryland. That honor goes to House Bill 1266 and its companion Senate Bill 950. These would protect not only “Lyme literate” physicians from disciplinary action by the medical board, but “Lyme literate” chiropractors and naturopaths as well – anyone, in fact, who is licensed under the state’s health practitioner licensing statutes. Typical of the ill-advised state laws protecting quacks in general, the bills allow a “Lyme literate” practitioner to avoid the constraints of evidence-based medicine as long as he or she makes a few disclosures. The bills’ saving grace may be that they are so poorly drafted that the quack practitioner won’t be able to figure out how to comply, thus forgoing the proposed law’s protection.
“Lyme literate” practitioners could not be disciplined:
solely because of the . . . practitioner’s diagnostic evaluation, testing, or treatment of Lyme disease or another tick-borne disease in a patient if [he] . . . discloses to the patient
that the evaluation, test or treatment:
is integrative, complementary, alternative, nontraditional or nonconventional, but none of these terms is defined;
has risks and benefits, and what they are, and its FDA “status;”
may not be widely recognized in the medical profession and “subject to disagreement among qualified medical experts.”
If the patient has a “potentially significant medical condition” and hasn’t yet had a “conventional diagnosis or treatment,” she must be told of medical specialties that may provide her with other options. All patients must be told of “significant known risks of deferring widely accepted treatments, if any, for the patient’s condition.”
This last bit really got me confused. If the practitioner thinks the patient has “chronic Lyme,” does that mean no other specialties could provide her with other options, because no other specialties believe in its existence? Or, on the other hand, is the “Lyme literate” practitioner going to be forced to consider that she may have a “conventional” disease or condition and not “chronic Lyme,” in which case, how is he going to justify his ruling out that condition in favor of “chronic Lyme?” And when determining the risks of deferring accepted treatments for the patient’s condition, do we pretend the condition is “chronic Lyme” or are we talking about the patient’s real condition?
In any event, none of this exempts the practitioner from discipline if the evaluation, testing or treatment has a “significant safety risk greater than the conventional methods” and the risk is not outweighed by the potential benefits. By “conventional” medical standards, this would seem to rule out long-term antibiotics in every case. But, having been legislatively forced to accept the existence of “chronic Lyme,” do we also have to accept the benefits of long-term antibiotics claimed by “Lyme literate” practitioners, or are we allowed to point out that several clinical trials showed that they provide no benefit?
In other words, once pseudoscience is made into fact by this bit of Legislative Alchemy, will the medical board prosecutors be allowed to rely on science at all in making their case? Just how far does the medical board have to go in pretending to believe in a fake diagnosis and its attendant “treatment?”
While passing a law shielding substandard practice is ill-advised and will make prosecution more difficult, fortunately it is not an absolute bar to prosecution. In 2014, New York passed a similar bill. Yet, 2017, two leading lights of ILADS were successfully prosecuted by that state’s medical authorities using the clever strategy of avoiding the “chronic Lyme” issue altogether and simply focusing on the atrociously bad medical care these two delivered. After all, if a physician is willing to ignore efficacy and safety to the point of prescribing long-term antibiotics for a fake diagnosis, it is unlikely he or she is otherwise meeting the standard of care in his overall treatment of patients. One particular requirement that tripped up these “Lyme literate” physicians was failure to keep adequate medical records, such as documenting a rationale for treatment.
The “Lyme literate” cabal seems to have learned from its substantial experience in disciplinary proceedings. Maryland’s proposed legislation also protects them from being disciplined for record-keeping and, much more broadly, all other regulatory requirements, “for acts or omissions that arise from professional differences of opinion” if the practitioner has acted in good faith to comply with the intent of the requirements. It is interesting to note that only “chronic Lyme” practitioners are legislatively blessed with this particular good faith exception.
Finally, if the medical, chiropractic or other healthcare practitioner board uses a system of peer review in standard of care cases, these bills ensure that at least one member of the review panel include a practitioner with “demonstrated training, competence, and experience in the same methods” as the licensee facing discipline, thereby insuring that quacks will be protected by other quacks.
Pennsylvania, Indiana and Illinois
Similar bills are pending in Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Illinois, although none is as complicated, or provides as much protection for “Lyme literate” practitioners, as Maryland’s.
Pennsylvania House Bill 174 begins with a swipe at the IDSA, noting that there are “multiple” diagnostic and treatment guidelines for Lyme disease but the National Guideline Clearinghouse maintains only the ILADS guidelines, having removed the IDSA guidelines because of their being “outdated and not in compliance with current standards.” (In fact, the IDSA is reviewing the evidence and developing new guidelines.) The bill fails to note the very low level of evidence that support the ILADS guidelines.
HB 174 forces insurers to cover antibiotic treatment for Lyme and related tick-borne illnesses even if the treatment is “unproven, experimental or investigational” for whatever “duration the health care practitioner determines appropriate for the patient” for controlling both the patient’s [presumed] infection or symptoms. It also provides immunity to physicians, nurse practitioners and physician’s assistants from disciplinary action “solely for” diagnosing Lyme disease or prescribing long-term antibiotic therapy as long as the diagnosis, treatment plan and ongoing monitoring has been documented in the patient’s records.
HB 174 passed in the House and has moved to the Senate for consideration. A similar bill, Senate Bill 100, is also pending there.
Indiana’s Senate Bill 284 manages to combine these provisions (which are almost identical to Pennsylvania’s) as well as those similar to Maryland’s law requiring that patients be told that standard lab tests for Lyme are “problematic” and “often result in false negative and false positive results” and that, if the patient’s results are negative, it doesn’t necessarily mean he doesn’t have Lyme disease. If he continues to have symptoms, according to the mandated statement, he should consult a health care provider about retesting “or additional treatment.” Even though this sort information isn’t back by good evidence, it is the perfect segue into the “Lyme literate” physician’s office, who will happily offer unvalidated testing and “additional treatment.”
Finally, in Illinois, House Bill 4515, also prohibits the medical board from disciplining physicians who diagnose and treat “chronic Lyme.” The physician must have examined the patient, gotten informed consent, provide a “medical reason” for the treatment, informed the patient of “other treatment options” and his or her credentials, and make a medical judgment based on “a thorough review of all available clinical information on Lyme disease.” Of course, “Lyme literate” physicians already rationalize their way through all of these steps to a diagnosis of “chronic Lyme,” so how much protection this offers patients is questionable. On the other hand, patients can be comforted by the fact that the legislation requires the physician to determine:
the treatment will not, in the opinion of the [physician], result in the direct and proximate death of or serious bodily injury to the patient.
Indirect causation of death and minor bodily injury are apparently ok and no risk-benefit analysis appears to be required.
You can gauge the passion behind HB 4515 by what the Illinois General Assembly calls “witness slips,” indicating pro and con stances on the bill. There are 286 witness slips in favor of the bill and only one opponent, the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, upon whose unfortunate shoulders will fall the task of trying to discipline “Lyme literate” physicians after the legislature ties one hand behind its back.
You can check on the status of bills mentioned in this post by clicking on the links, which will take you to the states’ legislatures’ websites. The website Lyme Science has a list of all state “chronic Lyme” bills with summaries and links to bills and other helpful information. (Yes, there are more, although none, as of this date, protecting “Lyme literate” practitioners from prosecution.) To oppose these efforts, check out the American Lyme Disease Foundation’s excellent list of questions and answers exposing common misinformation about Lyme disease. The IDSA also has helpful materials on its website, especially its Lyme Disease and State Policy Primer for State Legislators.
Don’t just complain about quackery. Do something about it.

Political Science: Chronic Lyme Disease
Jann Bellamy on November 13, 2014
Link

New York may soon join a handful of other states who reject science-based guidelines for the treatment of Lyme disease in favor of ideological guidelines based on the vociferous lobbying of patients and “Lyme literate” health care providers. Ignoring science is an unfortunate but well-known legislative phenomenon. I’ve discussed it a number of times on SBM, in the form of Legislative Alchemy, the process by which credulous state legislators turn practitioners of pseudoscience into state-licensed health care professionals, such as naturopaths, chiropractors, homeopaths and acupuncturists.
Lyme disease is an infectious disease transmitted by a tick bite. Its symptoms are a rash, fever, headache and fatigue, although not all symptoms may appear. According to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA):
Lyme disease is diagnosed by medical history, physical exam, and sometimes a blood test. It may take four to six weeks for the human immune system to make antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi and therefore show up in a positive blood test. That is why patients with the Lyme rash usually have a negative blood test and diagnosis is based on the characteristic appearance of the rash. Patients with other clinical manifestations such as Lyme arthritis will usually have a blood test. Anyone who has symptoms for longer than six weeks and who has never been treated with antibiotics is unlikely to have Lyme disease if the blood test is negative.
Treatment with antibiotics usually eliminates the symptoms, but delayed treatment can result in more serious problems.
“Chronic” Lyme disease (CLD) is not recognized as a disease in the medical community. Its symptoms are, well, pretty much anything. One description from a post by Harriet Hall:
Lyme is a multi-systemic illness, and may affect every part of the body causing fatigue, stiff neck, headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), anemia, dizziness, joint and muscle pain, brain fog, tingling, numbness and burning sensations of the extremities, memory and concentration problems, difficulties with sleep (both falling asleep and frequent awakening), chest pain and palpitations and/or psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety.
As Dr. Hall correctly notes, “that pretty much covers everyone.” Mark Crislip, SBM’s very own infectious disease guru, uncovered an even broader list of symptoms.
A new term, post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, has been coined for those who had Lyme disease but whose symptoms remain, although there is no good evidence that these symptoms can be attributed to persistent Lyme infection. There is no scientific controversy, however, that “chronic Lyme disease,” as applied to patients with nonspecific symptoms who show no objective evidence that they have been infected with Lyme disease, is a fabricated disease. It is these patients who have been victimized by “Lyme literate” doctors and alternative medicine providers. The main treatment for CLD is long-term antibiotics, for which there is no evidence of effectiveness but serious risks. (Also here.) As you would expect in cases where a collection of vague symptoms have been bootstrapped into a disease (e.g., chronic candidiasis, adrenal fatigue) there are also a number of bogus diagnostic techniques and worthless quack treatments available. (And here too.)
The whole idea that the scientific community is somehow ignoring the evidence is nonsensical when you think about it. What possible incentive would the IDSA and others have to deny the existence of CLD or reject long-term antibiotic therapy? Infectious disease doctors could make a bundle from treating patients with oral, IM and IV antibiotics, especially if it is fee for service. Of course, doctors who promote these treatments, and provide them, likely make a tidy profit doing so (again, especially if they are fee for service). What do you imagine their incentives are?
State legislatures fall for the manufactroversy
But never let the lack of controversy among scientists get in the way of a good manufactroversy, as we’ve seen again and again over in the anti-vaccination department of the nation’s wildly successful anti-science movement. After the manufactroversy has poisoned the well, a variation on the “teach the controversy” strategy can be deployed, whereby credulous legislators, convinced that a controversy among scientists actually exists, proceed to legislate the manufactorversy into existence. That turns the manufactroversy into a real controversy, you see, because the law now says the controversy exists. (Just like the law says chiropractic subluxations and acupuncture meridians exist.)
Lobbying by CLD advocacy groups has resulted in several states passing laws blocking state medical boards from taking action against a physician because he prescribes long-term antibiotic therapy. Currently, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts and California all have these laws on their books. In addition, Maine passed a law requiring state health authorities to provide information to the public about Lyme disease from both the Infectious Diseases Society of America and the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society, the latter of which promotes the validity of CLD diagnosis and the use of long-term antibiotics. Minnesota, Connecticut and Rhode Island require insurers to cover CLD treatment.
Rhode Island’s law bears a closer look, as it demonstrates how lobbyists can successfully insert unsupported assumptions into a law. In its preamble, the bill which eventually became law states that:
Physicians whose practices are devoted to treating chronic Lyme disease patients, and who continue to provide treatment if they feel such treatment is medically necessary, have noted significant improvement in the condition of their patients.
As Steve Novella explained, this perceived improvement could well be due to the placebo effect. Or, it is possible that the antibiotics are having an anti-inflammatory or other pharmacological effect that offers symptomatic relief, in which case we should explore treatments that offer these benefits without the risks of long-term antibiotics. Yet the Rhode Island legislature saw the reported benefits (which could also be due to a number of other reasons, such as confirmation bias) as reason to exonerate these physicians, while at the same time ignoring the evidence against the existence of CLD and the use of antibiotics to treat it.
The preamble also says that “consensus guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of chronic Lyme disease have not been developed.” I don’t know if that was true in 2002, when the law passed, but it certainly isn’t true now. And just because consensus guidelines haven’t been developed, it doesn’t mean “anything goes.” The law goes on to define “Lyme disease” as an infection consistent with the CDC surveillance criteria,
but also includes other acute and chronic manifestations of such an infection as determined by the physician.
In other words, it gave physicians carte blanche to ignore the substantial evidence disconfirming CLD and warning against long-term antibiotic use.
New York appears poised to join those states protecting “Lyme literate” doctors from prosecution, a position supported by at least one credulous newspaper editorial board. Both the Senate and the Assembly passed just such a bill, which awaits the Governor Cuomo’s signature. He’s indicated he will sign it.
In the hearings leading up to passage of the bill, one legislator said he’d been asked by his constituents “suffering from chronic Lyme disease” to pass legislation like this for a long time because:
This will offer a great amount of relief to families that are truly suffering, that are going bankrupt, they’re mortgaging their homes, trying to find a way to deal with this devastating disease.
Sadly, that indicates to me that a lot of people are being ripped off by “Lyme literate” doctors.
This bill is unlike the others in that it begins with this startling introductory sentence:
Neither the board for professional medical conduct nor the office of professional medical conduct shall identify, charge, or cause a report made to the director of such office to be investigated based solely upon the recommendation or provision of a treatment modality by a licensee that is not universally accepted by the medical profession, including but not limited to, varying modalities used in the treatment of lyme disease and other tick-borne diseases.
This seems to cover not only treatment with long-term antibiotics but pretty much anything any physician wants to dream up in the way of a “treatment modality” for any disease or condition as long as there is not “universal acceptance” that this is not a good idea. Of course, anytime a small group of dissenters wants to take exception to the medical profession, they can argue that there is not “universal acceptance,” no matter how kooky their ideas are.
This interpretation appears to be confirmed by the next sentence in the bill, which says a physician can employ these “varying modalities” as long as the treatment is in accord with this “health freedom” provision of the NY physician practice act that permits the use of:
whatever medical care, conventional or non-conventional, which effectively treats human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition.
I suppose there two outs here for the science-minded. One is that the bill covers only treatments, not diagnoses, perhaps providing some leeway for disciplinary action based on a diagnosis of CLD. The other is the provision in the existing law, which says the treatment must be effective.
All I can say is good luck to the state medical board and the courts in interpreting this one.
The legislature also passed a resolution asking the CDC, the NIH, and other federal agencies for additional Lyme disease prevention efforts and research. One does wonder, however, if they will pay attention to the research produced. If the legislature is ignoring the medical consensus at this point, what exactly is it that would convince them of their folly? And will they go back and repeal the new law (if it becomes law) if this new research somehow persuades them that the IDSA and other responsible experts are, in fact, correct?
Blumenthal: still promoting CLD after all these years
As I explained in an earlier post, former Connecticut Attorney General, and now U.S. Senator, Richard Blumenthal:
sued the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) for antitrust violations because both groups reached the same conclusion regarding the non-existence of Chronic Lyme disease.According to Blumenthal, both groups’ reasoning in reaching the same conclusion “at times used strikingly similar language.” He smelled a conspiracy. In his view, the guidelines “improperly ignored or minimized consideration of alternative medical opinion and evidence regarding Chronic Lyme disease.” Apparently, Blumenthal knew so little about science he didn’t realize that when the same evidence is reviewed by two different groups it is perfectly reasonable for them to come to the same conclusion. Nor did he realize that, in reviewing evidence, it is not appropriate to consider any quack theory that comes along, no matter how ludicrous. The irony is obvious: Blumenthal was willing to accept Chronic Lyme disease despite the lack of evidence that it exists. He then turned around and sued the doctors’ groups for relying on good evidence to support their conclusion that it didn’t.
The suit was settled when the IDSA agreed to review its position. That review has now been completed with the IDSA reconfirming its earlier position after another look at the evidence.
Sen. Blumenthal remains unrepentant and as far as I know has never acknowledge the IDSA’s confirmation of its earlier position in 2010. At a forum last year hosted by, among others, Sen. Blumenthal, he continued to maintain that there is a legitimate controversy in the medical community and that insurers should cover treatments doctors think is best, noting Connecticut’s insurance mandate. The latter sentiment, if applied to quacks and charlatans and all diseases, real or imagined, could drive us all to bankruptcy with increased premiums.
A similar hostility to the current evidence was displayed by U.S. Rep. Chris Gibson (R-NY), who also spoke at the forum. He is the sponsor of legislation recently passed by the House of Representatives, the “Tick-borne Disease Research Transparency and Accountability Act,” now pending in the Senate. Rep. Gibson accused the CDC of “Lyme illiteracy” and spoke of a “bifurcation in the medical community” concerning Lyme disease.
The House bill may not be a bad idea. It forms a “Lyme and Tick-Borne Disease Working Group” to look into the evidence and make recommendations, although it provides no money for the Group to perform its duties. It requires the inclusion of advocacy groups. The bill also requires that a “diversity” of scientific opinion be represented.
As with NY’s effort, however, one wonders exactly what level of evidence would be acceptable to those convinced that their symptoms are due to chronic Lyme disease and that long-term antibiotic therapy is the proper course of treatment. Or to Lyme literate doctors who treat them, whose income is jeopardized by further evidence of the lack of safety and effectiveness. There is clearly a scientific consensus among responsible parties that CLD is not a valid disease and that long-term antibiotic treatment is not only not beneficial, it can be dangerous. What else is necessary to sway the dissenters?
I don’t think anyone doubts there are people who experience fatigue, joint stiffness, neck pain and the like, but for whom no clear diagnosis exists. Nor does anyone doubt that some medical professionals brusquely dismissed their symptoms. And no one doubts that real Lyme disease exists or that improvements in diagnosis and treatment, as well as research into other tick-borne diseases and prevention, is warranted. But none of that is an excuse to take advantage patients with a fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme disease” or treat them with long-term antibiotics and other dubious remedies. Nor is it a valid reason for advocacy groups to browbeat legislators into enshrining CLD into law or for legislators to equate popularity with scientific evidence.

Nevada’s new quack protection law
Jann Bellamy on July 9, 2015
Link

Practicing a licensed health care profession, such as medicine, without a license used to be a felony in Nevada. Not any more. As of July 1, quacks and charlatans are free to ply their trades unencumbered by the threat that they might have to answer to the regulatory authorities for their misdeeds, as long as they follow a few simple rules.
This new law, passed overwhelmingly in the Legislature and signed by the Governor, is yet another success of the “health care freedom” movement. It was shepherded through the legislative process by Alexis Miller, a lobbyist for the Sunshine Health Freedom Foundation (Sunshine), which is affiliated with the National Health Freedom Coalition. It’s Director of Law and Public Policy, Diane Miller, also spoke in favor of the bill. We’ll get back to these groups and their comrades in arms in a moment.
First, let’s take a look at what the new law does. A person who provides “wellness services” is protected from prosecution as long has he doesn’t practice medicine, podiatry, chiropractic, homeopathy (homeopaths are licensed in Nevada) or another licensed profession. Some forbidden services are listed in the law, including surgery, setting fractures, prescribing or administering x-rays or prescription drugs, or providing mental health services in the exclusive domain of psychiatrists and psychologists. Of course, while there is certainly danger in untrained persons doing any of these things, they aren’t generally on your average quack’s list of services, nor are they likely interested in them in the first place.
The law does have some good provisions. The wellness service provider can’t recommend that his client discontinue or alter current medical treatment or make a “diagnosis of a medical disease.” I suppose this leaves open the possibility that one could diagnose a “non-medical disease” such as chronic candidiasis or adrenal fatigue. He can’t state or imply that he is a “provider of health care,” although I imagine that is a distinction lost on the average consumer.
He must also recommend that the client notify her primary care physician or other health care providers about the wellness services she is getting and provide certain other disclosures in writing. That’s about it for actually protecting the public.
The rest of the statute may look like it’s for public protection, but it actually serves the interests of the “wellness services provider.”
Here’s how “wellness services” are defined:
“wellness services” means healing arts therapies and practices, and the provision of products, that are based on the following complementary health treatment approaches and which are not otherwise prohibited . . .
(a) Anthroposophy.
(b) Aromatherapy.
(c) Traditional cultural healing practices.
(d) Detoxification practices and therapies.
(e) Energetic healing. [As opposed to lethargic kind?]
(f) Folk practices.
(g) Gerson therapy and colostrum therapy.
(h) Healing practices using food, dietary supplements, nutrients and the physical forces of heat, cold, water and light.
(i) Herbology and herbalism.
(j) Reflexology and Reiki.
(k) Mind-body healing practices.
(l) Nondiagnostic iridology.
(m) Noninvasive instrumentalities.
(n) Holistic kinesiology.
Other than a few supplements with sufficient evidence to support their use and maybe a heating pad for muscle pain, the list of one big “get out of jail free” card for charlatans.
Miller, the Sunshine lobbyist, helpfully provided the legislators with definitions of these practices. (And they passed this bill anyway!) Note how she uses alt med dog whistles to carefully tiptoe around any implication that these might be used to treat any medical (as opposed to imagined) condition or disease. For example:
Aromatherapy: the use of substances such as essential oils, food, nature, or dietary supplements that have aromas, to enhance positive experiences or wellness. [Since when do dietary supplements “have aromas?”]
Gerson Therapy: . . . A natural treatment that activates the body’s ability to heal itself through an organic, plant-based diet, raw juices, enemas and natural and dietary supplements.
Herbology and Herbalism: the study of and the use and sharing of, herbs and herbal products to promote well being.
She used the same tactic to dance around the prohibition against diagnosing.
Non-Diagnostic Iridology: the review and observation of a picture of the iris of the eye of a person to gain information and understanding of a person’s body, not including disease diagnosis.
Holistic Kinesiology: the use of muscle testing to assist a person in increasing their self-awareness and wellness needs for balancing energy and electromagnetic flow.
These two are actually scams used to convince people they need to buy herbs and dietary supplements, as demonstrated by the website of “Dr.” Jim Jenks, who testified in favor of the bill at a legislative hearing. (Jenks is on the Sunshine board of directors, along with three naturopaths.)
As Jenks explains in an online video, you can learn holistic kinesiology in minutes with his CD course. Once enlightened, you can proceed to have your child hold a loaf of white bread. Whether his muscles are “strong” or “weak” will tell you if he has an allergy to a substance in the white bread. Jenks’s word salad explanation of iridology avoids any direct claim that it can actually diagnose disease. Rather, he claims it is an “early warning” system to avoid disease.
While we’re on the subject, let’s look at some of the other treatments available in Nevada that will fall under the protection of the new law.
There’s “sound therapy” from the Steamboat Healing Center & Spa, which, in another nice word salad, is claimed to:
Promote the body’s natural healing abilities through the use of electronic sound application devices to transmit frequencies associated with healthy cells to the body’s organs and tissues. Modern science has shown that the human body is a dynamic energy system and that our cells, organs, and tissues have their own vibratory nature. This natural resonant frequency can become upset and unbalanced, leading to pain, illness, or disease.
No, modern science doesn’t show this at all. But more to my point, the clear implication here, of course, is that sound therapy will have a positive effect on this “pain, illness, or disease.”
And there’s “Energy Healer Steve,” who provides his particular brand of energy healing via long-distance. Steve claims energy healing can, among many other benefits, reduce blood pressure, “adjust the flow of the endocrine system,” and reduce the side effects of drugs. Here’s his treatment for tinnitus, in answer to the question posed on his website: “Can Tinnitus Be Cured or Healed?”
You book a session through Paypal . . . I get some initial history on how the tinnitus started. We then get what I call a SUDS level or Subjective Units of Distress from 1-10, 10 being the highest level of distress or in this case tinnitus.
I then send bio-energy into the inner ears for about 20 min and then we take another SUDS level or distress level. In many cases the tinnitus level is reduced. I then repeat this sequence several times within the hour session. Most clients experience a good deal of relief after the first session. It may take several sessions to get the tinnitus level to zero or to a place my clients are happy with.
I note that none of these “wellness providers” include the law’s required disclosure that the provider “is not licensed, certified or registered as a provider of health care in this State.”
It is interesting that, while these charlatans are making money from their nostrums, the new law places almost the entire burden for the harm they might cause on others. First, as mentioned, the wellness provider must give clients a written statement telling them to notify their licensed health care provider before beginning any “wellness plan” and tell him the nature of the services she is about to undertake. The statement must also tell the client to ask her PCP about potential drug interactions, side effects, risks or conflicts between any medications or treatments the PCP or other health care provider has prescribed.
Of course, patients should share this information with their health care providers. But this provision is based on the assumption that the already-busy PCP has the duty to keep up with the ever-growing field of pseudoscience and, in essence, perform some of the duties normally placed on the shoulders of the provider who prescribed the treatment. If Dr. Smith prescribes drug X to his patient, it is not normally up to Dr. Jones to provide a risk-benefit analysis of Dr. Smith’s recommended treatment to their mutual patient. And if the patient is already taking a drug prescribed by Dr. Jones when he sees Dr. Smith, it is up to Dr. Smith to advise the patient of any potential interactions between the two drugs. But if a wellness provider Smith prescribes a dietary supplement, Dr. Jones is now burdened with having to explain all the risks of Smith’s treatment.
One can well imagine how this plays out when an ENT physician is treating tinnitus and the patient explains he is about to embark on a round of remote energy healing with Healer Steve. Is there a “conflict . . . between [the] treatments” here that the ENT should explain?
What happens when the supplement or other wellness service prescribed by our hypothetical wellness provider Smith causes harm to his client? If he were Dr. Smith, he would be subject to discipline by the medical board if he fell below the standard of care for physicians. In other words, if he were negligent, he would be liable to the patient for damages as well and would likely have medical malpractice insurance to cover any judgment.
But wellness provider Smith’s ignorance operates to his advantage under this statute. He is subject to sanctions only if he:
Treats a person’s health condition in a manner that intentionally or recklessly causes that person recognizable and imminent risk of serious or permanent physical or mental harm.
So, just being stupid or negligent doesn’t result in any sanction. Or, even if the provider is reckless or intentionally harms the patient, there is no sanction if the harm isn’t recognizable, imminent and serious or permanent.
Not that much happens to the wellness provider even if he does intentionally cause permanent physical harm or in any other way violates the law’s prohibitions. The only sanction is being charged with a misdemeanor. And there is no specific law enforcement or regulatory authority given the job under the new law of investigating or prosecuting these transgressions. Interestingly, there are a number of criminal acts in Nevada resulting in less harm to the victim that are classified as felonies. Buying or receiving stolen goods worth less than $2,500, violating a restraining order, or stalking by text-messaging are all felonies that can result in 2-5 years in jail and a fine of up to $10,000. Practicing medicine or another health care profession without a license used to be a felony as well, but the new law reduces the penalty to a misdemeanor.
Of course, the injured party can sue the offending wellness provider, but there is no requirement that the provider carry liability insurance, leaving the seriously or permanently injured client without recourse unless the provider has financial resources available to satisfy a judgment. And if he doesn’t, or they are minimal, the client is unlikely to find an attorney to represent her anyway.
Let’s take our promised look at the fine folks who were behind this law’s successful trip through the Legislature and on to the Governor’s desk. The Sunshine Health Freedom Foundation claims it is a non-profit foundation “created exclusively for the promotion, maintaining and expanding health freedom for Nature’s Sunshine Distributors and Managers.” Nature’s Sunshine is a multi-level marketing operation selling dietary supplements, with net sales revenue of almost $84,000,000 in the first quarter of 2015, according to the company’s SEC filing. About 300,000 people participate in it MLM operation as distributors worldwide. In addition to Alexis Miller, Sunshine has three other paid lobbyists in Nevada.
Sunshine is part of the National Health Freedom Coalition, whose Director of Law and Public Policy assisted in lobbying for the bill. It is also a voting member of the Coalition’s Health Freedom Congress, whose other illustrious members include Autism One, The Bolen Report, DAMs Inc. (Dental, Amalgam, Mercury Solutions), and mercola.com. The Congress gave Barbara Loe Fisher, the grand dame of the anti-vaccination movement and head of the execrable National Vaccine [Mis]information Center, an award for:
protecting the human rights of parents, children and all the members of the human family as it applies to vaccine safety.
Yes, that’s how bad these groups are – they gave an award to Fisher for protecting human rights, human rights being a venerable concern purloined by the anti-vaccination movement for its own purposes.
So, who else is responsible for this bill’s success? According to the Sunshine lobbyist, they worked with the Nevada Medical Association and the Board of Medicine “to craft a bill they could support.” Sure enough, neither group was anywhere in sight during the committee hearing on the bill nor did they file anything in writing. I could not find any official position on the bill taken by the Medical Association on its website.
The only real opposition to the bill came from – of all places – the Board of Homeopathic Medical Examiners. Cyrus Pourzan, MD, HMD, a member of that Board, made some excellent points.
    • The bill opens Nevada up to the unregulated practice of medicine.
    • There is no administrative structure to review wellness practitioners’ practices.
    • A felony offense is downgraded to a misdemeanor.
    • Because the word “aromatherapy” contains the word “therapy,” it implies the practice treats a diagnosed illness.
    • Herbs are powerful medicine that can cause problems. He referenced his own 3-inch thick book on herb-drug interactions.
    • Holistic kinesiology is a diagnostic tool with no wellness purpose and questionable reliability. (He admits it is used in homeopathy.)
    • More people could be driven to the emergency room and delay diagnosis of illnesses because they are under the false impression that they are being accurately treated.
    • Anyone can come to Nevada, legally or illegally, and open a wellness clinic.
The homeopathy Board’s Executive Director testified that she regularly fields calls about people who offer “dream cures” though herbs, vitamins or other treatments. Normally, she’s required by law to contact the authorities about these calls. Her interpretation of the bill was that the Board could no longer involve itself in chasing after “purveyors of cancer cures and their ilk.”
In his testimony, Dr. Pourzan pointed out that there didn’t seem to be a constituency for the bill. No one in state history had ever been prosecuted for recommending a dose of vitamin C.
The constituency is an unholy alliance of ideologues who want to protect quack practitioners from being held accountable for their actions and companies, like Nature’s Sunshine, who are making millions selling dietary supplements. This has nothing to do with public demand for “wellness services.” It has nothing to do with wellness at all.

The Quack Full Employment Act
Jann Bellamy on April 18, 2013
Link
Quacks, charlatans and snake oil salesmen are closely watching “The Colorado Natural Health Consumer Protection Act,” Senate Bill 13-215 (SB 215) as it wends its way through the Colorado Legislature. I imagine a few felons about to be released from prison are keeping tabs on the bill too, for reasons we’ll get to in a minute. SB 215 passed the Senate on Tuesday. It will now go on to the House, where it has the support of Rep. Joann Ginal, the mover and shaker behind a bill giving “naturopathic doctors” a right to practice, House Bill 13-1111 (HB 1111). That bill passed the House and is now parked in the Senate awaiting committee assignment. Apparently, critical thinking skills have abandoned the state capital. Things are looking grim.
If the “Colorado Natural Health Consumer Protection Act” passes, Colorado will become one of a handful of states where anyone can practice medicine. Of course, these laws don’t come out and say that exactly. In fact, the Colorado bill states that if you don’t have a medical license you cannot practice medicine, which in Colorado is defined to include:
Holding out one’s self to the public within this state as being able to diagnose, treat, prescribe for, palliate, or prevent any human disease, ailment, pain, injury, deformity, or physical or mental condition, whether by the use of drugs, surgery, manipulation, electricity, telemedicine, the interpretation of tests, including primary diagnosis of pathology specimens, images, or photographs, or any physical, mechanical, or other means whatsoever; . . . Suggesting, recommending, prescribing, or administering any form of treatment, operation, or healing for the intended palliation, relief, or cure of any physical or mental disease, ailment, injury, condition, or defect of any person . . .
But, as we shall see, what SB 215 actually does is allow rank amateurs to diagnose and treat just about anyone for any disease or condition with means of no known safety or effectiveness. In other words, they can practice medicine, it’s just quack medicine. At the same time, the bill strips away important consumer protections. And guess who’s supporting it? The Colorado Medical Society, although I suppose we can be disappointed but not surprised. The Colorado Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics is remaining neutral. As I said, critical thinking skills have decamped from Denver.
Pay attention folks. Passage of this bill will energize the Health Freedom crowd. They’ll be in your state soon.

Why is the legislature doing this?
Let’s begin at the beginning, with a look at the legislative findings. Such findings are often set forth at the beginning of a bill to explain the legislature’s purported reasons for the law’s necessity. Legislative findings are supposedly based on facts but, in my experience, all too often they are no more than a bit of political theater. True to the tradition, SB 215’s legislative findings are pretty much fact-free.
First, the bill’s draftsmen trot out the shop-worn “complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is popular” gambit. For this they rely on the 2007 survey by Barnes et al. As we have discussed many times before on SBM, by suddenly transforming such conventional practices as diet, relaxation and exercise into CAM, the survey was able to make it look like CAM use is much greater than it actually is. That is, of course, if anyone could really define “CAM” in the first place. Even the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), itself cited in the legislative findings, admits it’s hard-pressed to define this amorphous and ever-changing category.
Second, from this survey they extrapolate that 1.5 million Coloradans “currently receive a substantial volume of health care services” from CAM practitioners, a conclusion actually contradicted by the survey they rely upon. The overwhelming majority of health care expenditures for CAM is for self-care, such as buying off-the-shelf products like as fish oil supplements. Less than two percent of consumers use a type of CAM that requires seeing a practitioner currently unlicensed in Colorado.
Third, the bill claims that CAM practitioners “are not regulated by the state.” Again, not true. According to the survey, the most commonly visited CAM practitioners are chiropractors, osteopaths and massage therapists, all of whom are regulated by the State of Colorado. (Of course, this also demonstrates another flaw in the survey — counting all visits to massage therapists and to chiropractors and osteopaths for manipulation as CAM, another error that inflates the numbers.) Acupuncturists are also licensed.
Finally, the legislature finds that CAM “practices do not pose an imminent and discernable [sic] risk of significant harm to public health and safety.” Or, in other words: “What’s the harm?” And whoever drafted this bill should check with the Colorado Attorney General on the extent of the state’s constitutional power to regulate for the health, safety and welfare of its citizens. The risk of harm needn’t rise to “imminent and discernible” for the state to step in and protect the public. And apparently, they didn’t thoroughly review the NCCAM website in cherry-picking their legislative findings. If they had, they would find, in NCCAM’s own words, “the safety and effectiveness of many CAM therapies are uncertain.” Others are actually known to be dangerous or ineffective or both. Or maybe they did review the website but they just don’t care.
What will an unlicensed CAM practitioner be able to do?
Under current law, an unlicensed CAM practitioner is subject to prosecution if they do anything that requires a license to practice medicine. This bill creates a “safe harbor” from prosecution if the unlicensed practitioner follows certain rules. And who is eligible for this protection as an unlicensed practitioner? Pretty much anyone who isn’t a licensed health care practitioner and wants to call himself (or herself) a CAM practitioner, a point we’ll return to shortly. But first, let’s look at what they can do. In other words, how is “CAM” defined in the bill? It is
advice and therapy services . . . within the broad domain of health care and healing arts therapies and methods that are based on complementary and alternative theories of health and wellness. . . [These] include healing practices using food; food extracts; dietary supplements [as defined in DSHEA] including vitamins, herbs, minerals, and enzymes; nutrients; homeopathic remedies and preparations; . . . the physical forces of heat, cold, water, touch, sound, and light; stress reduction healing practices; and mind-body and energetic healing practices.
The CAM practitioner cannot practice massage therapy, but can employ
stroking of the hands, feet, or ears; or . . . the use of touch, words, and directed movement of a health art within the bodywork community, including healing touch, mind-body centering, orthobionomy, reflexology, rolfing, reiki, qigong and practices with the primary purpose of affecting energy systems of the human body.
If the practitioner has “board certification” from the International Association of Colon Hydrotherapy or the National Board for Colon Hydrotherapy he can perform enemas or colonic irrigation.
My interpretation is that this definition permits every form of quackery I’ve ever heard of and some that will be invented. And one I had never heard of: “ortho-bionomy.” In fact, CAM is limited only by the imagination of anyone who can fit what he dreams up into this broad and fuzzy list. I predict the word “quantum” will be getting a real workout in Colorado. Personally, I would go for the “mind-body and energetic healing practices” category if I were setting out as an unlicensed practitioner. Almost unlimited opportunities there. Of course homeopathy is tempting because you would get to sell little bottles of water at extravagant prices to the unsuspecting public.
What are they prohibited from doing?
Let’s now turn to what unlicensed practitioners are prohibited from doing under SB 215. Then we’ll look to a few hoops they must jump through before they get to do whatever it is they choose to do.
These are the things unlicensed practitioners cannot do:
The CAM practitioner cannot perform surgery and certain other invasive procedures, prescribe or administer drugs or certain medical devices, set fractures, provide chiropractic “adjustments,” practice dentistry, use or prescribe radiation, use spinal anesthetics (topical anesthetics are permitted), or use “invasive” laser devices. The practitioner cannot provide a “conventional medical disease diagnosis” although an “unconventional” diagnosis or diagnosis of a condition other than a disease is apparently permitted. They cannot “recommend the discontinuation of a course of care, including a prescription drug, prescribed by another health care professional.”
But what about ordering lab tests, that reliable means of finding “unconventional” diseases to treat with CAM, such as adrenal fatigue, chronic yeast overgrowth, chronic Lyme disease, toxicities, imagined vitamin and mineral deficiencies and so forth? While the bill doesn’t allow skin puncture, it doesn’t mention other types of tests. In any event, all the practitioner has to do is recommend that the “client” [which is what the bill calls consumers] visit a walk-in lab, such as Any Lab Test Now. There he will find a number of tests whose results might be catnip for quacks, such the “fatigue panel,” the “telomere test,” the “micronutrient test” and the “saliva hormone test.”
Who can a CAM practitioner treat?
The unlicensed practitioner can see just about anyone who walks in the door. They cannot “directly administer medical protocols to a pregnant woman or to a client who has cancer.” I thought they couldn’t practice medicine at all, so I’m not sure what this means. In any event, they are apparently free to administer quack protocols to pregnant women and cancer patients.
They cannot treat a child under two without having informed consent of the parent, disclosing they are not licensed physicians, and recommending that the child “have a relationship with” a board-certified pediatrician. Of course, the parent is free to ignore this recommendation. Informed consent is an interesting requirement because it highlights the lack of a key consumer protection. A patient must give informed consent to any treatment by a medical doctor. Except for children under two, no informed consent is required for treatment by an unlicensed practitioner.
What must a CAM practitioner do to avoid prosecution?
There are a few things the unlicensed practitioner must do to avoid prosecution. The practitioner must tell the client the nature of the CAM health care services to be provided, that the practitioner is not licensed, whether he has liability insurance (I’ll wager he doesn’t) and any degrees, training, experience, credentials or other qualifications the practitioner has. The latter is small comfort as the many on-line certificates and do-nothing degrees available can fill the walls of even the most dim-witted practitioner. All of this must be reduced to writing and signed by the client. This statement must advise the client that he should discuss any recommendations made by the CAM practitioner with his PCP or certain other board-certified specialty physicians. (Be prepared for some doozies, you Colorado physicians!)
Who can become a CAM practitioner?
So what are the qualifications for becoming an unlicensed CAM practitioner? Next to none. Just about anyone can do it. The only exceptions are licensed (or registered or certified) health care providers whose licenses are suspended and the mentally incompetent. Also excluded are felons who have “not satisfied the terms of the sentence imposed for the crime.” But as soon as they walk out of prison or complete parole, convicted felons can go straight into practice as a CAM practitioner. This could prove a solution for the seemingly intractable problem of chronic unemployment among convicted felons. Plus, those convicted of financial crimes are often excellent flim-flammers. And how about allowing those convicted of sexual assault and child molestation “to stroke the hands, feet, or ears or . . . the use of touch”? Excellent idea!
Consumer Protection? What consumer protection?
Under current Colorado law, unlicensed practitioners of complementary and alternative health care are subject to prosecution for the unlicensed practice of medicine. This bill provides a “safe harbor” from prosecution if the unlicensed practitioner follows certain rules. Thus, consumer protection is decreased by removing some conduct — no matter how egregious — from the reach of prosecution. For example, if a homeopath did a homeopathic diagnostic workup on a Coloradan and sold her homeopathic remedies as a “cure,” the homeopath has likely engaged in the unlicensed practice of medicine. If this bill becomes law, as long as the homeopath otherwise complies with the rules, the homeopath can diagnose and prescribe homeopathic remedies with impunity. And no matter how much public harm he may be causing, the medical board can do absolutely nothing about it. In addition, the bill also provides that unlicensed practitioners who don’t follow the rules violate the Colorado Consumer Protections Act (CCPA). But the CCPA already protects consumers for most of the conduct permitted by the bill. So here the bill adds nothing the consumer doesn’t already have.
An injured person can still sue a CAM practitioner for negligence if the bill passes. But what exactly would constitute negligence? All persons owe a duty to others to act reasonably in any particular circumstance. In a negligence case, an injured party must show that the person causing harm breached that duty in some manner. So how would the plaintiff show that the CAM practitioner breached this duty of care? For licensed health care practitioners, such as a medical doctor, the duty of care is established by a standard of care, or what a prudent practitioner would do in the same or similar circumstances. If the practitioner falls below that standard, he commits malpractice. But since there is no standard of care for the unlicensed CAM practitioner, how would one establish the breach of duty necessary to succeed in a negligence case?
That would leave the plaintiff with a run-of-the-mill reasonable person standard. But wait – the legislature has specifically said that these CAM practitioners can practice homeopathy and other such nonsense and they have no obligation to provide informed consent and no obligation to refer to a physician (merely “to discuss” the CAM practitioner’s recommendations with one’s physician). They aren’t educated and trained to diagnose medical conditions and, in fact, are forbidden from “conventional” medical diagnoses, so how would they recognize the need to refer in the first place? (In contrast, for example, a chiropractor has a duty to refer to a medical doctor for any disease or condition beyond his scope of practice or ability to treat. He would also have liability insurance to compensate for injuries if he fails to do so. CAM practitioners do not.) Apparently, then, an unlicensed practitioner could get off scot-free for failing to refer a person desperately in need of medical care in any case where a “reasonable person” would not recognize the danger. If you aren’t a licensed health care provider, do you know which headaches signal danger and which ones don’t? How about back pain? Stomach aches? Coughing? Chest pains? No? Well, neither do they.
Just how bad is it?
Let’s put this all together and see just what would happen should this bill become law. Virtually anyone can set up shop without any education or training in health care whatsoever, or a worthless on-line certificate if they prefer, and practice complementary and alternative “health care and healing arts therapies and methods.” They can see anyone who walks in the door, no matter how sick. They can provide any unconventional disease diagnosis they want, including making up diseases and conditions that don’t exist. CAM practitioners can then proceed to practice virtually any “healing arts therapies and methods” they can dream up, including recommending various nostrums that they then sell to the consumer. They have no duty to provide informed consent, no education and training in recognizing the need to refer to a physician and no duty to refer to a physician. And even if the CAM practitioner is injuring his “clients” right and left, the medical board must sit on its hands and do nothing as long as the CAM practitioner complies with a few rules. The board has no authority whatsoever to step in and stop it. Unlike every licensed health care professional in Colorado, who must answer to a regulatory authority, the unlicensed practitioner answers to no one.
The injured clients could sue for negligence. But even if they could overcome the substantial obstacles I’ve already mentioned, CAM practitioners don’t have to carry liability insurance. And, rest assured, few (perhaps no) plaintiff’s attorney is going to take one of these cases unless the practitioner has substantial assets to pay any judgment against him and therefore the attorney’s fees and costs.
Natural Health Care Consumer Protection? Hardly. It’s the Quack Full Employment Act.
Author’s Note: Linda Rosa, RN, and Larry Sarner have worked tirelessly to defeat SB 225 and HB 1111, on their own time and with their own money. Whatever happens in Colorado, we owe them a great deal of gratitude for getting in there and fighting to defend science-based medicine. We could all learn a lesson from their example.

Ayurvedic practitioners push for licensing in Colorado
Ayurvedic practitioners’ attempt to become licensed health care professionals in Colorado failed an initial review but that is unlikely to stop them from pursuing their goal. Ayurveda is pseudoscience and its practices can be dangerous. Unfortunately, that is no barrier to state licensing.
Jann Bellamy on November 21, 2019
Link

A year ago, a Sunrise Review Application (Application) was submitted to the Colorado Department of Regulatory Affairs (DORA), proposing the licensing of Ayurvedic “doctors” and other Ayurvedic practitioners in that state. Per Colorado law, DORA reviewed the Application and, last month, issued its Sunrise Review recommending that the state not regulate Ayurvedic “professionals”, but this does not prevent a licensing bill from being introduced, or from passing, in the Colorado legislature. (The deadline for bill introduction is in January, 2020.) Based on information submitted in the Application, it appears that this effort may be the beginning of a national campaign to legitimize Ayurvedic practice via licensing. With this, we start a new chapter in the rich history of Legislative Alchemy, that is, the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience into the American healthcare system via legislation in lieu of evidence.
We’ll return to this effort in a moment, but first, let’s take a brief look at Ayurveda, a prescientific belief system that originated, and is still practiced extensively, in India. Ayurvedic practitioners believe that all people are made up of five basic elements (space, air, fire, water, and earth) that combine into three “life forces” or “energies”, called “doshas”. These doshas (vata, pitta, and kapha), control different bodily functions. Each person is, according to this belief system, a unique mixture of these doshas, although one usually dominates. Whether you get sick, and the illnesses you develop, depend on the balance of your doshas.
The vata dosha is thought to be the most powerful, controlling basic bodily functions, such as cell division, as well as one’s mind, breathing, blood flow, heart function, and elimination. Things like “eating again too soon after a meal, fear, grief, and staying up too late” can disrupt one’s vata dosha. If vata dosha is your main dosha, Ayurvedic practice predicts you are more susceptible to developing conditions like “anxiety, asthma, heart disease, skin problems, and rheumatoid arthritis”.
According to Wikipedia,
Ayurveda has eight ways to diagnose illness, called Nadi (pulse), Mootra (urine), Mala (stool), Jihva (tongue), Shabda (speech), Sparsha (touch), Druk (vision), and Aakruti (appearance).
Treatments include herbal remedies, oils, enemas, bloodletting, diets, meditation, yoga, and, of course, “detoxification”, called “Panchakarma”, the “benefits” of which were described in a previous SBM post:
Panchakarma will remove the excess doshas and correct imbalances in them as well as eliminate the harmful ama out of your system through the body’s own organs and channels of elimination (colon, sweat glands, lungs, bladder, urinary tract, stomach, intestines, etc). Panchakarma purifies the tissues at a very deep level. It involves daily massages and oil baths, herbal enemas, nasal administrations. It is a very pleasurable experience. Ayurveda recommends Panchakarma as a seasonal treatment for maintaining mental and physical hygiene and balance.
Personally, I had not thought herbal enemas would be “very pleasurable” but, then again, I’ve not tried one.
There is, of course, no evidence that these doshas exist, and the dangers of basing diagnosis and treatment on a fantasy-based system of human functioning should be obvious. For example, the “Ayurvedic Practitioner Certification Exam Detailed Reference Guide” (2019 Ed.) lists as possible causes of psychosis demons, the influence of snakes, spirits, divine intervention, celestial musicians, and possession.
Even according to the CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine, regrettably ignoring the fact that the whole system is based on magical thinking, says that while there is very limited evidence that some Ayurvedic herbal remedies might possibly be effective for a few conditions, “there is little scientific evidence” of its value for other health issues.
There are, however, a number of well-recognized dangers of Ayurveda, one of the most worrying of which is the use of metals like gold, mercury, copper, and silver in its remedies, a subject we’ve addressed here on SBM and noted by the NCCIH:
A 2015 published survey of people who use Ayurvedic preparations showed that 40 percent had elevated blood levels of lead and some had elevated blood levels of mercury. About one in four of the supplements tested had high levels of lead and almost half of them had high levels of mercury.
There is also a danger of arsenic poisoning. This is in addition to the usual risk of taking any herbal remedy, which, due to lack of effective regulation, may be contaminated or suffer from other quality issues.
Sunrise Review Application
With that background, let’s turn to the Sunrise Review Application and DORA’s recommendation against licensing Ayurvedic practitioners.
First, we learn from the Application that Ayurvedic practitioners have taken a page from the chiropractic, naturopathic, and Traditional Chinese Medicine/acupuncture (TCM) playbook and set up a system of organizations that, on their face, mimic those of the medical profession, but are actually designed to incorporate and perpetuate their pseudoscientific belief systems and, via self-regulation, shield them from outside scrutiny. These are the
    • National Ayurvedic Medical Association, an private association of Ayurvedic “doctors” and other Ayurvedic practitioners with “more than 800 Ayurvedic professional members in the United States.”
    • National Ayurvedic Medical Association Certification Board, a private association which establishes the number of hours of instruction needed to complete training for the three levels of practice for which they seek licensure in Colorado: Ayurvedic Doctor, Ayurvedic Practitioner and Ayurvedic Health Counselor, and administers the “rigorous” exams required for certification. (You can find the study guide for the “rigorous” Practitioner certification exam here. For clarity, I will use “Practitioner” when referring to that specific level of practice and “practitioner” or “provider” to refer to those who practice Ayurveda in general, whatever their level.)
    • National Ayurvedic Medical Association Accreditation Council, a private organization, which is gearing up to apply for recognition from the U.S. Department of Education as the accrediting agency for Ayurvedic schools in the U.S. If successful, their students will be eligible for taxpayer-funded student loans and their educational institutions eligible for federal research money.
Although no specific licensing bill is proposed, it is apparent that the Application contemplates that the state, as in the case of chiropractic, naturopathic and TCM licensing, would default to these private organizations, created and run by Ayurvedic practitioners, to control the education, training, examination, and continuing education requirements for Ayurvedic practitioners, thereby ensuring that science and protection of the public’s health will not intrude.
Second, the Application makes no apologies for the fantastical practices of Ayurveda (which it sets out in some detail) nor does it pretend that there is any evidence to support their effectiveness or safety. (In fact, the Application admits to some of their dangers, a point we’ll return to shortly.) Rather, the case for licensing is based on familiar logical fallacies we frequently see trotted out in the promotion of pseudoscientific practitioners. One, CAM is “popular”, based on the logical fallacy which
tells us that if something is popular, it must be good/true/valid, but this is not so, especially in a society where clever marketing, social and political weight, and money can buy popularity.
Two, an appeal to authority, in this case invoking the World Health Organization which “recognizes Ayurveda as a form of traditional and complementary medicine” in its “Traditional Medicine Strategy” and “encourages Member States to consider [Traditional and Complementary Medicine] as an important part of the health system,” a move that has been widely criticized as “antithetical to the [WHO’s] commitment to evidence-based medicine, a desertion of duty to uphold the highest scientific standards”, and which the WHO itself says is not an endorsement of T&CM.
Third, in spite of its basis in pseudoscience and the lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness, the Application seeks an extremely broad scope of practice. Ayurvedic “doctors” and Ayurvedic Practitioners need have only 6 college credits in anatomy and physiology plus, respectively, 3,000-4,500 hours of education and training in Ayurveda and 300 patient encounters, or 1,500-2,500 hours and 150 patients encounters, to be eligible for “certification”. How these hours are calculated is not explained. Of course, much of this time is spent learning nonsensical concepts such as:
Changes in vikṛti due to changes in agni, guṇas resulting in digestive disorders, appetite and elimination changes
Attributes (guṇas) that cause the doṣas to accumulate and become aggravated
Diet (āhāra) and lifestyle (vihāra); how diet, climate, season and age impact the prakṛti and subsequently contribute to doṣa vikṛti and cause of disease
What constitutes excess, deficient and the imbalance of doṣas within their own site
Theory of similar and dissimilar and balancing the doṣa vikṛti through a proper daily routine, seasonal routine and basic six tastes (rasa) for a person of each constitutional type
And so on.
Yet, for both “doctors” and Practitioners, the Application does not propose any limitation on the scope of practice. It includes diagnosis, treatment, and management “from the Ayurvedic perspective” of any disease or condition in any patient of any age, unsupervised by any other health care professional. The Ayurvedic Health Counselor, with 600-1,000 hours of education and 50 patient encounters, offers “health promotion and disease prevention” using “principles of Ayurvedic medicine”, including assessment of the patient’s Ayurvedic constitution and the imbalance and state of his or her doshas. They refer patients to Ayurvedic “doctors” or Practitioners when the patient’s “disease state” requires diagnosis and treatment, but also practice unsupervised.
Fourth, the Application claims that licensure would “ensure that Ayurveda recommendations be given in coordination and cooperation with the client/patient’s licensed healthcare team” although no actual requirement for “coordination and coordination” is proposed. Presumably to shore up this notion, and perhaps to allay any fears that Ayurvedic providers might harm patients because they don’t know what they’re doing, the Application makes some extraordinary claims for Ayurvedic providers’ proficiency in “Western” medicine. According to the Application, Ayurvedic “doctors”
have a working knowledge of Western medical pathology, pharmacology, diagnostic reports, and treatments, in order to interface with the Western medical community and modify the Ayurvedic management of cases accordingly, as needed.
They also
have a working knowledge of Western medical diagnostic and treatment terminology and practices, sufficient to enable them to correlate those terms and diagnosis into Ayurvedic understanding and practice.
As well, they have
an informed awareness of public health and epidemiology . . . from the Western and Ayurvedic perspectives.
Ayurvedic Practitioners “must be able to refer a patient for assessment and possible treatment by a medical practitioner” and “have knowledge of red flag symptoms that require immediate referral” and (in a statement of breathtaking hubris) “must understand how other health care professionals can complement the care being provided by the Ayurvedic Practitioner”.
Even Ayurvedic Health Counselors “have the knowledge of symptoms that require referral to a licensed medical professional”.
In my opinion, these claims are both disingenuous and dangerous. Ayurvedic providers are educated and trained (such as it is) wholly outside the mainstream American medical educational and training system and fully accept prescientific beliefs as a substitute for “Western” science-based medicine. Yet, they are somehow able to both put aside their fantastical notions about predetermined disease susceptibilities based on inborn doshas and their imbalances and magically transform themselves into competent “Western” medical diagnosticians. Not only that, they can take these two irreconcilable systems and combine them in their management of patients, much like NASA and astrologists work together to combine “Western” astronomy, physics, and chemistry with the predetermined fates ascribed to one’s “sign” into one successful space program. (Actually, they don’t.)
Judge for yourself just how credible this claim could be by examining the curricula of the school ranked number one by universities.com for “Best Colleges with Ayurvedic Medicine/Ayurvedic Degrees in the United States”, Southern California University of Health Sciences, a school that also offers chiropractic, acupuncture, and oriental medicine degrees.
Upon completing the one-year program conferring the Ayurvedic Wellness Educator Certificate, consisting of online and weekend courses, recorded lectures, and working in the school clinic, a student can enroll in the Ayurvedic Practitioner Certificate program. This program lasts one year as well, and also consists of online and weekend courses and recorded lectures. The “Clinical Internship” is four weeks long, for 15 hours per week, or a total of 60 hours. The description says nothing about learning or employing “Western” medicine.
Fifth, the Application admits that Ayurvedic remedies include dangerous metals, such as lead, and dangerous herbs, such as Ashwagandha, which can affect adrenal hormones, citing medical literature exposing these risks. It promises that licensing will solve these issues with vague assurances of compulsory adherence to best practices and practitioner competency and training. At best, this might work to exclude therapies once the harm is discovered, but it does nothing to address the problem of using unproven therapies whose harms are not yet known because testing for safety is considered unnecessary. (The Colorado Citizens for Science in Medicine filed Comments with DORA opposing licensing and listed even more dangers for DORA’s consideration.)
In fact, the one remedial step Ayurvedic organizations have taken does not appear to be working. According to the Application, in 2008, several organizations agreed practitioners should stop using any product to which lead, mercury, or arsenic (but not copper, silver, gold or herbs) have been intentionally added “until modern Western science have proven the safety of such products” underscoring that Ayurvedic practitioners do not consider it their job to evaluate the safety of their therapies. (Leave that task to “modern Western science”.) Yet, several of the harms reported in the medical literature occurred after that date.
Sixth, and finally, the Application fully admits that one goal of licensing is increased prestige:
Regulation gives a measure of authenticity, professionalism, credentialing, integrating and complimenting other healthcare modalities. . . Regulation also achieves an enhanced status in the eyes of the public, which equates Ayurvedic professionals with professionals licensed in other fields.
In other words, the public will be completely fooled.
They may also seek coverage under health insurance plans. Indeed, at least theoretically, insurers would be required to cover their services under Section 2706 of the Affordable Care Act. (Although that has not been the financial boon anticipated by CAM providers.)
DORA recommends a “no”
Fortunately, as noted, DORA recommended against regulation, via licensing, of Ayurvedic “professionals”, although, as also noted, this does not prevent the legislature from passing a bill doing just that. Now, a normal person might think: “Of course they didn’t recommend licensing! Ayurveda is total nonsense!” Unfortunately, being nonsense-based does not legally preclude licensing or registration (another form of regulation, with its attendant imprimatur of legitimacy) in Colorado, which also regulates chiropractors and naturopathic “doctors” or, more accurately, allows them to self-regulate.
Instead, DORA considered the criteria mandated by law, the first of which asks whether the practice of Ayurveda “clearly harms or endangers the health, safety, or welfare of the public”. In other words, the more dangerous you are, the more likely you are to be awarded the honor of being licensed and, as the Ayurvedic providers put it, achieving an “enhanced status in the eyes of the public”. Based on the information it had, DORA concluded that “Ayurvedic professionals are not causing widespread harm to consumers who utilize their services” and that most examples of consumer harm were “product-related, not practice-related” ignoring the fact that many of these products were supplied by Ayurvedic practitioners (although some were in India).
The second criterion is whether the public needs and can benefit from initial and continuing professional competence through, for example, educational and examination requirements. DORA decided it wasn’t necessary to address this one, as there was insufficient evidence to conclude the unregulated practice of Ayurveda harms the public. (Again, apparently, the fact that this education and examination would be fantasy-based is not a consideration in the eyes of the law, had DORA chosen to address this criteria.)
In fact, its decision on the first criterion pretty much allowed DORA to skip consideration of all the remaining criteria. The agency did note that Colorado’s Natural Health Consumer Protection Act or, as I prefer to call it, the Quack Full Employment Act, permits the practice of Ayurveda, which, in DORA’s view, provides some pubic protection. Indeed, lack of licensing doesn’t seem to be stopping anyone: There are about 70 Ayurvedic practitioners currently plying their trade in the state.
While this is the first attempt in recent years at licensing Ayurvedic practitioners, a bill was filed in New Hampshire back in 1999 to license Ayurvedic “physicians”, who would be allowed to diagnose and treat any patient, regardless of age, disease, or condition. They could employ physical and orificial examinations, pulse analysis, X-rays, electrocardiograms, ultrasound, phlebotomy, clinical laboratory tests and examinations, and physiological function tests, do minor office surgery, prescribe according to a formulary, prescribe barrier contraceptives, and practice “natural” childbirth. They would have been self-regulated by their own Ayurvedic Board of Examiners. Fortunately, the bill was defeated.
The Indian Medical Association, whose members see first-hand what the widespread practice of Ayurveda looks like, were faced with the prospect of licensing Ayurvedic practitioners in their country. They opposed licensing, saying:
The government is giving sanction to quackery. If those doctors make mistakes and people pay with their lives, who is going to be held accountable?
Exactly. State legislatures in the U.S. should heed their warning.

Missouri tackles primary care shortage with “assistant physicians”
Jann Bellamy on September 18, 2014
Link


A new law in Missouri will allow medical school graduates who have not completed a residency to practice in underserved areas. They will be able to call themselves “doctor” but will be licensed as “assistant physicians” with significant limitations on their practice. (The first link is to Senate Bill 716, the bill that was passed and signed by the governor. It covers several subjects, so you will need to skip to page 8 to find the portion we’re discussing.)
The Missouri State Medical Association supports the new law and helped draft the original bill. It is designed to address the state’s critical need for primary care physicians – 40% of Missouri’s population lives in underserved areas but only 25% of the state’s physicians practice there, according to a 2009 survey. Underserved areas have high poverty rates, high infant mortality, large senior populations and fewer primary care physicians per capita.
To address this primary care shortage, other states have expanded nurse practitioner scope of practice and allowed pharmacists to give immunizations, but Missouri is the first state to create a new type of practitioner licensing. Chiropractors and naturopaths argue that they, too, are primary care physicians and can help ease the shortage. Fortunately, no one seems to be taking them seriously. (We’ll return to DCs and NDs as PCPs shortly.)
All other states require at least a one-year residency to be eligible for licensing as a physician. Most physicians complete an additional 3-7 years of residency training before going into practice; usually 3 years for primary care family practice doctors, internists and pediatricians. Med school graduates who become assistant physicians are, according to medical ethics expert Dr. Arthur Caplan, “not likely to be the cream of the U.S. crop.” Prime candidates for assistant physicians are those who didn’t get into a residency, got low scores on the U.S. Medical Licensing Examination, foreign med school grads, and some who would simply prefer that role. But Dr. Caplan also thinks we should give the program a chance and expresses optimism that it could work out.
According to Governing magazine:
The total number of residency applicants has exceeded the total number of positions available since the 1980s. In 2014, 29,671 available positions were filled by 28,490 students, but the number of active applicants topped 34,000. About 7,000 of those were non-U.S. citizens who graduated from international schools, and about half of them found residencies.
The American Medical Association, the Association of American Medical Colleges and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) all oppose this type of fast-track licensing. The Missouri Hospital Association and the state’s medical board, which will write the regulations, did not take a position on the bill during the legislative session. The American Association of Physician Assistants also opposes the law, saying it will be confusing to patients.
ACGME board member Rosemary Gibson told Governing:
“On the surface, it looks like a quick fix, but I think it really behooves [policymakers] to do their homework, to understand what it means to have a graduate of a medical school be called doctor, to have prescriptive authority for powerful drugs like narcotics, to accurately dose and treat people,” she said. “Primary care is not simple. If you have a lot of older people living in rural areas, they have a lot of co-morbidities [such as diabetes combined with heart disease].”
Dr. Thomas Nasca, ACGME’s CEO, agrees:
“These are physicians with only rudimentary experience,” he told Medscape Medical News. “In Missouri, without direct supervision, they’d be able to manage patients with complex diabetes, congestive heart failure, arrhythmias, and malignancies. This doesn’t make sense.
“Physicians in the United States are not trained to enter practice upon graduation from medical school,” Dr. Nasca said. “They don’t have the skill sets required for independent practice. It’s a flawed assumption to suggest that novices are prepared to provide clinical care on their own in a rural area where any medical condition could present itself. This isn’t an emotional response. It’s a data driven response to a very bad idea.”
Despite recognizing the need to serve challenged areas, he doesn’t see this as the appropriate remedy. “I don’t underestimate the challenges we face in delivering care to rural populations and the urban poor. But to provide inadequate care is no solution. There is a dramatic difference between a medical school graduate and a doctor trained in a residency program. Why go back to the 1940s when doctors just out of medical school provided care without supervision? The idea that primary care is somehow simple is ludicrous,” Dr. Nasca said.
The Missouri State Medical Society’s general counsel and government relations director Jeffrey Howell strongly disagrees with critics of the law. He told Medscape:
The opposition puzzles me . . . The physician shortage in Missouri is so bad that communities with 2,000 to 5,000 people barely have access to a doctor one day a week. And they share that doctor with 2 or 3 communities. The new rules are no different than those for older doctors who didn’t have to go through a residency program. They just graduated from medical school and began treating patients.
Assistant physician practice
To be eligible for assistant physician licensing, a med school graduate (including graduates of osteopathic medical schools) must successfully complete the first two parts of the U.S. Medical Licensing Exam no more than 3 years after graduation. He must clearly identify himself as an assistant physician, including an ID badge, and may use the title “doctor.” The state medical board will work out continuing education requirements with med schools and primary care residency programs. Rules regarding prescription drugs must be approved by the state pharmacy board and, if controlled substances, also the state health department.
All must have an “assistant physician collaborative practice arrangement” with a fully licensed physician, who can oversee no more than 3 assistant physicians. These arrangements must be written agreements, jointly agreed-upon protocols or standing orders. The arrangements can, but do not have to, include the authority to prescribe certain drugs and the physician can limit the locations where this may occur. Patients at these locations must be notified they have the right to see the licensed physician. If these drugs are controlled substances there are additional requirements.
The assistant physician must practice in the same physical location as the physician for 30 days, longer if he will prescribe controlled substances. After that, they must be within “geographic proximity” of one another. The assistant physician must submit at least 10% of his charts to the collaborating physician every 14 days for review. If controlled substance prescribing is allowed, that jumps to 20%.
The collaborating physician “is responsible at all times for the oversight of the activities and accepts responsibility for primary services rendered by the assistant physician.” However, as long as the licensed physician follows the procedures set forth in the law, he won’t be held vicariously liable.
Compare and contrast
It is interesting to compare the cautious (but nevertheless controversial) medical approach to granting a limited, supervised primary care scope of practice license to an MD with that of chiropractors and naturopaths. Missouri, by the way, saw naturopathic licensing bills introduced every year but one from 2000-2010. None passed, and naturopaths are not licensed in Missouri. In fact, there is case law holding that a naturopath who diagnosed and treated patients without a license to practice medicine can be enjoined as a public nuisance.
There is a movement among chiropractors to claim they are primary care physicians. (We’ve discussed this before several times on SBM – see here for references to all posts.) Some chiropractors seem to have the term mixed up with “portal of entry,” which means the patient can see a practitioner without a referral. The notion that chiropractors can move beyond musculoskeletal care is not universally shared. It’s not even agreeable to some to move beyond straight subluxation-based practice. This simply reflects the internecine wars that have been going on in chiropractic for years.
The most eager proponents of full-scope primary care practice appear to reside in New Mexico, where the “advanced practice chiropractor,” with a few additional hours of education and a limited formulary, can practice. This has led to some interesting attempts to, shall we say, “specialize” among NM DCs. Fortunately, the legalization of an “advanced practice” DC scope of practice does not appear to have seeped beyond the state borders and we hope it won’t, although that was not for lack of trying elsewhere.
Naturopaths with “naturopathic doctor” degrees seem dead serious about their claim to PCP status, although their latest licensing successes have fallen far short. (Also here.) They even have the audacity to claim that their education and training is “substantially equivalent to” the MD primary care physician. Never mind that a portion of these hours are spent learning pseudoscience, like homeopathy. This led to a misleading chart, handed out to legislators, trying to bend and stretch the two curricula until the chart showed, under torture, supposed similarities. (Chiropractors have attempted similar nonsense. Also here.) The American Academy of Family Physicians apparently took umbrage at these shenanigans, rightly so, and put together its own chart. Using the same basic idea – that number of hours, and not content, is the relevant measure of comparison – the AAFP gave the naturopaths a dose of their own medicine.

And so it is we find that the MD assistant physician will have had twice as many hours, including over twice as many clinical hours, as a naturopathic “physician” who goes into practice straight from naturopathic school. Even if the naturopath did a one-year optional residency (most don’t), which can be as few as 535 hours, the naturopath barely squeaks by the MD assistant physician in total hours, and will still have fewer hours than the MD clocked during the clinical portion of his education (the combined clinical and lecture hours of the last two years of med school).
Even without a residency, med students must practice in a variety of clinical settings and put in far more hours of clinical training. Naturopathic students are mostly limited to school-based ambulatory clinics where they see a narrow range of diseases and prescribe fantasy treatments, yet want full PCP scope of practice.
Of course, if you look at a board-certified family practice physician versus a naturopathic “physician,” even one with a residency, the NDs’ comparison becomes a joke. So much for the “equivalent education and training” argument. And if naturopaths would like to go toe-to-toe with the AAFP on actual content, we’d all love ring-side seats.
The contrast between the approaches of MDs/DOs and NDs to the limitations of practicing before education and training meets medical licensing standards is telling.
    • MDs/DOs obviously realize that med school grads are not ready for prime time without a residency and worked with the state legislature to ensure strict limitations. NDs deny that a residency is necessary and sponsor legislation permitting full PCP practice right out of school.
    • MDs/DOs realized that supervision is absolutely necessary. NDs deny that supervision is required to safely practice. (Interestingly, Maryland’s recently passed licensing act requires NDs to have a collaboration agreement with an MD or DO. Needless to say, this wasn’t the NDs’ idea.)
    • MDs/DOs carefully limit the prescribing authority of assistant physicians. NDs say they are ready for full prescription authority.
    • MDs/DOs enforce limitations on assistant physicians with chart review and other restrictions. Even brand new NDs going into practice don’t have to report to anyone.
Whatever you might think of Missouri’s new law, you’d have to agree that any patient is far better off getting primary care from an assistant physician than a naturopath or a chiropractor. Dr. Nasca made the very point I’ve argued before in opposition to ND licensing:
Patients don’t come to primary care physicians sorted into simple problems and complicated problems. . . The idea that primary care is simple and this idea that primary care can be done by people who are not well trained is a flawed concept. It is wrong. The primary care physician, in my opinion, has the most difficult job in the healthcare delivery system. That’s because they must not make errors of omission. They must not make errors of failure to recognize. It is a very challenging task.
Dr. Nasca is absolutely right when he says that “the idea that primary care is somehow simple is ludicrous.” To which we might add: the idea that DCs or NDs can serve as primary care physicians is even more ludicrous.

Legislating Ignorance
John Snyder on September 12, 2014
Link
Science is under attack, and not just from anti-vaccine celebrities and parents with degrees from Google University. Scientific illiteracy is being woven into the very fabric of our society through legislative assault. If you dismiss this as alarmist hyperbole, you haven’t been paying close enough attention.
Every day thousands of pediatric health care providers throughout the country provide safety advice to patients and their parents during routine health maintenance visits. As part of this important routine we ask a series of standard questions to assess the safety of our patients’ environment. Some of these questions are easy and straightforward, and some are more personal and potentially awkward for patients and their parents, including questions pertaining to sexual practices and preferences and psychosocial history. An important series of questions focuses on potential hazards in the home, such as how toxins and medicines are stored, how pools are secured against curious toddlers, and whether there are guns in the home and how they are stored and secured. Parents are usually appreciative of the advice we provide, and thankful for our concern and attention to these issues. Occasionally patients or parents are taken aback by some of these questions, and very rarely they prefer not to answer them (in my 20 years in practice, I can recall only one time this has occurred). We ask these questions because accidental injuries and deaths are common occurrences in the pediatric population, and there is good evidence that patients tend to follow the advice we provide our patients.
Subverting science and endangering health
In 2010, as part of a routine health maintenance visit, a pediatrician in Ocala, Florida asked the mother of one of his patients whether there were guns in the home. The mother was angered by this question and refused to answer. By the end of the visit, she had been asked to find another pediatrician. This argument eventually led to the creation of the Florida Privacy of Firearm Owners Act, which, with support from the NRA, was signed into law in June of 2011. This law made it illegal for healthcare providers to ask about the presence of guns in the home. In 2012 the law was blocked by an injunction as a result of a lawsuit filed by the Florida chapters of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP), the American College of Physicians (ACP), and individual plaintiff physicians. In July the law was upheld on appeal, though the injunction remains in effect until the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals makes a final ruling. The judge who upheld the law weighed in stating:
the practice of good medicine does not require interrogation about irrelevant, private matters.
Despite this law, if I were practicing in Florida, I would not change the way I inquire about guns in the home. The law specifically states that a health care practitioner:
may not intentionally enter any disclosed information concerning firearm ownership into the patient’s medical record if the practitioner knows that such information is not relevant to the patient’s medical care or safety, or the safety of others.
It goes on to state that:
a health care practitioner or health care facility that in good faith believes that this information is relevant to the patient’s medical care or safety, or the safety of others, may make such a verbal or written inquiry.
While this leaves it wide open as to what constitutes information relevant to a patient’s safety, most pediatricians, and all rational people, would have no problem assuming knowledge about the presence and safe storage of firearms in the home to be always relevant. The NRA and certain members of Congress would disagree, and that is where the chilling effect of this law comes into play. The intent of the law is clearly to prevent health care providers from pursuing this line of questioning, and places the second amendment squarely above the first.
My patients’ medical records can and do contain information about a wide range of environmental, health, and social information. Information that I have obtained because I, as a trained clinician, think it may be important to the health and safety of my patients. This includes information about a wide range of issues from what kinds of pets are in the home and whether carbon monoxide detectors are installed, to family medical histories, patient’s sexual activities, and often-complex social and family dynamics. But for some segments of society, those who cling to the second amendment with end-times religious zealotry, questions about guns in the home cross the line. This line of inquiry is just too personal and threatening for them to bear. And now, thanks to this Orwellian legislation, health care providers in Florida can’t do their job of advising and protecting their patients without fear of prosecution. Somehow, by asking a routine question about home safety, pediatricians are violating the second amendment rights of their patients. As if simply by asking about the presence of guns in the home denies a parent the right to own a gun. This has to be one of the most preposterous pieces of legislation passed in modern times, and it speaks to just how dangerously gun-centric our country has become.
Anti-science legislation prohibits research into gun safety
So just how is this an example of anti-science legislation? The tragic irony is that another piece of anti-science legislation, specifically developed to block research on gun safety, prevents us from gathering and analyzing the data to adequately answer this question. In the 1990s, NRA-backed lawmakers inserted into The Consolidated Appropriations Act, (P.L. 112-74, Section 503, Division F, Title V) language prohibiting the CDC from using funds to promote:
any activity to advocate or promote … any proposed, pending, or future requirement or restriction on any legal consumer product, including its sale or marketing, including but not limited to the advocacy or promotion of gun control.
Additional Requirement 13 adds the following language,
None of the funds made available for injury prevention and control at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention may be used to advocate or promote gun control.
In 2011, Congress extended this restriction to include not just the CDC, but also the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Health and Human Services.
While at first glance this language may not seem to explicitly prohibit these agencies from funding studies on gun related injuries, deaths, and gun safety, the fact that such research could be used to lobby Congress has blocked them from doing so. No such restrictions apply to the study of obesity, heart disease, or overall accident and injury prevention even though these areas of research could also be used to lobby for changes to policy. Yet because of the political reach of the gun lobby, an entire line of scientific inquiry has been effectively halted, with far-reaching and profound consequences for public health and safety. It is the main reason we do not have answers to some very important and basic gun safety questions such as:
    • What is the overall number of accidental gun deaths?
    • How many children are behind the trigger in gun-related injuries and fatalities?
    • How many children are the victims of accidental shootings?
Despite these limitations, the data we do have regarding children and guns clearly indicates that the presence of guns in the home increases the risk of accidental injury and death, homicides, and suicides. The American Academy of Pediatrics and American Medical Association recommend that firearms in the home be kept locked and unloaded, and stored separately from ammunition. A study demonstrating that a large percentage of unintentional firearm deaths occur in states where guns tend to be stored loaded supports these recommendations. The greatest risk occurs in states where loaded guns are also more likely to be kept unlocked. This association held true after controlling for rates of firearm prevalence, poverty and urbanization. In another study looking at the impact of safe gun storage, four safety practices (keeping a gun locked, unloaded, storing ammunition locked, and storing guns and ammunition in separate locations) were found to independently protect children from unintentional and self-inflicted injury and death.
Despite this, 2.6 million children in the US are exposed in their homes to firearms stored either unlocked and loaded, or unlocked, unloaded, and stored with ammunition. According to the CDC, there were 269,871 gun-related fatalities in the 8 years between 1999 and 2007. This included nearly 20,000 child fatalities. Because of the limitations on data collection and analysis, we do not know how many of these were a result of children getting their hands on dangerously stored and accessible guns.
Now, back to the Florida physician’s gag law. We know we can’t answer precisely how anti-science this legislation is because of the anti-science restrictions placed on gathering the data to begin with. We certainly have good evidence about the positive impact of physicians asking general questions about safety and providing guidance on accident and injury prevention. Several studies (Bass, et. al., Miller, et. al.) have demonstrated that providing office-based, standardized injury prevention advice can significantly decrease the incidence of childhood injuries. Other studies have shown that parents prefer and are most likely to follow safety information provided by their pediatrician (Stylianos, et. al., Laraque, et. al.).
But even with the current restrictions imposed on the study of gun safety, we do have some compelling evidence for the positive impact of provider-instituted gun safety counseling as well. A variety of simple, office-based intervention strategies have been shown to have a positive impact on the safe storage of guns in the home (Albright, et. al., McGee, et. al.), and the use of trigger locks (Grossman, et. al.). It has also been shown that parents are likely to follow their pediatrician’s advice about safe gun storage (Webster DW, et. al.).
So from what we do know about the positive impact of gun safety counseling, it appears safe to conclude that the Florida “physician’s gag law” is solidly anti-science. And because anti-science seems to be spreading like a vaccine-preventable plague, similar legislation has now been introduced in 12 other states. Most have been overturned, but laws are still pending in Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Ohio, and Minnesota. And now, thanks to the NRA’s influence on Harry Reid, even the Affordable Care Act contains stealth language further restricting health care providers, insurance companies, and the Department of Health and Human Services from collecting information about gun use or the presence of guns in the home (See page 19 here).
The intrusion and detrimental effects of politics on the advancement of science and public health is not new, though it has become more and more flagrant and potentially dangerous. Lawmakers with political agendas, constituents to please, and a poor grasp of science have been able to enact legislation and influence policies with the potential to produce extremely dangerous and long-lasting consequences. From climate change deniers such as Senator James Inhofe of Oklahoma, and anti-vaccine fear-mongers like former Congressman Dan Burton and now Darrell Issa, to presidential candidates mocking important scientific research, anti-science politicians have been weighing in and eroding science policy in this country with alarming frequency. The frequency with which antievolution legislation is introduced in this country should make us all shudder with fear. Perhaps the most flagrant and troubling anti-science legislative effort at the moment is that of Representative Lamar Smith of Texas (ironically, chair of the House of Representatives Science Committee), who is pushing a bill that would replace the peer-review system at the National Science Foundation (NSF) with a system based on a set of Congressional funding criteria. This “High Quality Research Act” is intended to eliminate what a select group of politicians deem to be areas of inquiry undeserving of federal support. Such politically and ideologically motivated restrictions on scientific inquiry are truly horrifying, and could have devastating consequences.
The unhindered progress of science is central to the advancement of public health and societal good, yet political forces and personal belief continue to impede and influence the path to progress. Perhaps what we need is a Committee on Scientific Integrity to vet legislation that could impact public health and safety. Whatever steps we take, clearing a path for science and giving it the place it deserves in our society is long overdue.

Vaccination mandate exemptions: gimme that ol’ time philosophy
Jann Bellamy on December 15, 2011
Link
Each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia require vaccination against certain diseases as a prerequisite to public and private school attendance, most commonly polio, mumps, measles, diphtheria, rubella, chicken pox, Heamophilus influenza type b, pertussis, tetanus, pneumococcal disease and hepatitis B. Unfortunately, mandatory vaccination for home-schooled children is rare. (1)
All states provide medical exemptions to vaccination mandates for those for whom vaccination poses a health threat. Indeed, it is doubtful that a state could constitutionally deny such medical exemptions.
Forty-eight states also allow exemptions based on religious beliefs. While it might be assumed that religious exemptions are required by the protection afforded religion under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution that is not the case. The opposite is true. Religious exemptions themselves are constitutionally suspect. In fact, to pass First Amendment muster, a state’s religious exemption statute may have to be so broad as to become, in essence, a “philosophical” exemption.
Vaccination mandates survive early challenges
Compulsory vaccination laws have enjoyed strong support in the state and federal courts for over a century. Early in the 20th century, the U.S. Supreme Court considered the constitutionality of a statute authorizing a municipal board of health to require and enforce vaccination, in this case during a smallpox epidemic. The Court found the legislation represented a valid exercise of the state’s police power. In a statement that proved prescient about the failed constitutional challenges to vaccination mandates which followed, the Court said that “we do not perceive that this legislation has invaded any right secured by the Federal Constitution.” Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11, 38 (1905).
In 1922, the Court specifically addressed the subject of school vaccination, holding that it is a valid exercise of the state’s police power to make vaccination a condition of attending public or private school. Zucht v. King, 260 U.S. 174 (1922).
First Amendment challenges to mandates
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof . . . .” U.S. Const., amend. I.
The First Amendment protects religious freedom in two ways. First, the “Establishment Clause” prohibits excessive involvement of government in religion, such as by establishing a state religion or by granting special privileges to members of a particular religion. Second, under the “Free Exercise Clause,” the freedom to hold religious beliefs and opinions is absolute, although the freedom to act in accordance with those beliefs is subject to regulation by government for the protection of the public.
Although the case did not involve a challenge to compulsory vaccination, the U.S. Supreme Court, in Price v. Massachusetts, 321 U.S. 158 (1944), considered a challenge to a child labor regulations based on the Free Exercise Clause. The plaintiff had her young niece handing out Jehovah’s Witness literature on the streets and the Court upheld the right of the authorities to prevent her from doing so.
The state’s authority to regulate in the interest of the public’s health, safety and welfare (the “police power”), said the Court,
is not nullified merely because the parent grounds his claim to control the child’s course of conduct on religion or conscience. Thus, he cannot claim freedom from compulsory vaccination for the child more than for himself on religious grounds. . . . [t]he right to practice religion freely does not include liberty to expose the community or the child to communicable disease or the latter to ill health or death. . . . Parents may be free to become martyrs themselves. But is does not follow [that] they are free . . . to make martyrs of their children before they have reached the age of full and legal discretion when they can make that choice for themselves.” 321 U.S. at 166-167, 170.
While the Court used vaccination as an example in Prince, it has not directly addressed the issue of whether vaccination mandates run afoul of the First Amendment. It again declined to address the issue this year, when it refused to hear a case arising out of a challenge to West Virginia’s mandatory vaccination law.
West Virginia is one of two states which does not have a religious exemption to statutorily-required immunization. Mississippi is the other – its state supreme court struck down a religious exemption as unconstitutional and the state legislature has not enacted another in its place.
West Virginia’s mandatory vaccination law was challenged by a woman whose daughter was refused admission to public school without the required immunizations. The U.S. District Court ruled against her, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed, finding that the West Virginia vaccination law passed even the “strict scrutiny” test, the most difficult constitutional standard of review. Workman v. Yeager, 419 Fed. Appx. 348 (4th Cir. 2011).
As part of her constitutional argument, Workman proposed that “because West Virginia law requires vaccination against diseases that are not very prevalent, no compelling state interest can exist,” completely ignoring the fact that, were exemptions to be freely granted, diseases that are currently “not very prevalent” could come roaring back. In any event, the court was unimpressed: “on the contrary, the state’s wish to prevent the spread of communicable diseases clearly constitutes a compelling interest.” Id., at 353.
The court gave similarly short shrift to Workman’s free exercise claim:
In sum, following the reasoning of Jacobson and Prince, we conclude that the West Virginia statute requiring vaccinations as a condition of admission to school does not unconstitutionally infringe Workman’s right to free exercise [of her religion]. This conclusion is buttressed by the opinions of numerous federal and state courts that have reached similar conclusions in comparable cases.” Id., at 353-354.
Statutory exemptions
Despite the clear indications from the U.S. Supreme Court, and actual opinions of lower federal courts, that a religious exemption to vaccination mandates was not constitutionally required, the state legislatures began to enact statutory religious exemptions during the latter half of the 20th century. (2) It is these exemptions – not the lack thereof – which got the states into constitutional trouble.
A 2005 survey of religious exemption statutes found that
[a] minority of states limit codified religious exemptions to those who belong to ‘organized,’ ‘recognized’ or ‘established’ religions. Other states allow exemptions if they find that the petitioner’s beliefs are ‘genuine and sincerely held.’ Finally, some states’ requirements for exemption are met simply if a parent or guardian submits a form or an affidavit, stating opposition to vaccination based on religious grounds.” (3)
The first type of exemption has been held unconstitutional in several states. The second is constitutionally suspect. And the third may allow practically anyone to claim an exemption.
An often-cited case is Sherr v. Northport-East Northport Union Free School District, 672 F. Supp. 81 (1987), although as a district court case it has no precedential value. Parents whose children were denied a religious exemption from mandatory vaccination challenged the New York law, which exempted “children whose parent[s] . . . are bona fide members of a recognized religious organization whose teachings are contrary to the practices herein required.”
Here’s how the complaint described the beliefs of one set of parents, the Sherrs:
All persons must live in harmony with the natural world and its order and must not interfere with the natural order. . . . Health is the unhindered expression of life (God) moving through the body, mind and heart. Therefore, anything that hinders life’s expression is contrary to [the Sherrs’s] religious belief. Immunization hinders life (God) and thus is contrary to God. To deviate (immunize) from this natural order would be to sin.” Id., at 92-93.
When I read this, my CAM radar pinged. I wrote in the margin, “sounds like naturopathy & D.D. Palmer,” the latter a reference to the chiropractic founder’s belief in “Innate Intelligence” flowing through the body via the spinal nerves, the interruption of which by “subluxations” causes disease.
Sure enough, that’s exactly where the Sherrs’ “religious” beliefs came from. The affidavit requesting that their son be exempted from immunization due to the family’s religious beliefs stated that they were members of the American Natural Hygiene Society, which is “opposed to inoculations as violating the natural laws of life and health by introducing pathological toxins into a healthy, human body.” According to Quackwatch, the Society is an offshoot of naturopathy.
In addition, according to the court,
Alan Paul Sherr [the father] is a chiropractor, and during the course of his testimony, it became clear that his opposition to vaccinations and attitudes toward sickness and health in all likelihood derive for the most part from his medical and philosophical perspective as a chiropractor and chiropractic ethics . . . .” Id., at 96.
Taken together with other evidence, this meant to the court that the Sherrs “do not sincerely hold the religious beliefs that they put forth” and they weren’t entitled to relief. However, the court did find that New York’s limiting religious exemptions to “bona fide members of a religious organization” violated both the Establishment and Free Exercise clauses of the First Amendment, and that the state “must offer the exemption to all persons who sincerely hold religious beliefs that prohibit the inoculation of their children . . .” Id., at 97.
Likewise, two federal district courts struck down Arkansas’s religious exemption statute, which was limited to parents who object “on the grounds that immunization conflicts with the religious tenets and practices of a recognized church or religious denomination of which the parent . . . is an adherent or member.” McCarthy v. Boozman, 212 F. Supp. 2d 945, 947 (W.D. Ark. 2002), Boone v. Boozman, 217 F.Supp. 2d 938 (E.D. Ark. 2002).
The court in McCarthy quickly dismissed a challenge to the constitutionality of mandatory immunization: “It has long been settled that individual rights must be subordinated to the compelling state interest of protecting society against the spread of disease.” 212 F. Supp. 2d at 947. However, “[i]f the legislature chooses to provide a religious exemption from compulsory immunization . . . the exemption itself must pass constitutional muster.” Because the Arkansas statute limited exemption to “only those who are members or adherents of a church or religious denomination recognized by the State,” the statute “clearly runs afoul” of the First Amendment, as well as the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Id.
“Sincerity” test
Despite the language of Sherr indicating that an examination of the sincerity of religious belief is permissible, this test for religious exemption may itself be constitutionally suspect under the Establishment Clause. According to one commentator:
Under the sincerity test, the party desiring exemption must demonstrate to the satisfaction of the court that his or her asserted beliefs are ‘sincerely’ held. Evidence a court might use in a sincerity analysis includes (1) whether the adherent acted inconsistently with the belief at issue; (2) whether the adherent materially gained by masking secular beliefs with a religious veneer; and (3) the religion’s history and size. Courts must further exercise ‘extreme caution’ when conducting a sincerity analysis because the inquiry ‘in essence puts the individual on trial for heresy.’ The court therefore becomes excessively involved and ‘entangled’ in an analysis of an individual’s religious beliefs when it engages in a sincerity analysis . . . and therefore this form of exemption statute violates the Establishment Clause.” (4)
Everybody’s got religion
Unfortunately, the religious exemption statutes most likely to survive constitutional challenge are the most inclusive – those that automatically allow an exemption without proof that the beliefs are indeed religious in origin or that they are “sincere.” (5)
The problem is exacerbated by the lack of statutory authority in many states to challenge claims based on religious beliefs or the relaxed enforcement of existing rules. (6) As one commentator points out,
Parents wishing to offer additional proof that their opposition to exemption is for religious reasons can seek out the assistance of numerous websites offering relevant Biblical quotations to include in letters of petition for exemption. Also, for a little as $1, parents can join mail-order religious groups, such as the taxpaying Congregation of Universal Wisdom, headquartered in the New Jersey Pine Barrens.” (7)
The ease with which parents can transform anti-vaccination sentiment into a religious belief is demonstrated in Turner v. Liverpool Central School District, in which the court upheld a claim of religious exemption based on membership in the Congregation of Universal Wisdom, a church whose principles were founded on chiropractic philosophy and which held no regular meetings. The court found that “the one consistent aspect of plaintiff’s testimony was that she believed in a universal life force or wisdom and that immunization would be violating that life force.” This was sufficient to meet the state’s statutory religious exemption requirements. (8)
In essence, religious exemptions have the potential to swallow the rule in that they allow transformation of a “philosophical” belief into a “religious” belief by prohibiting inquiry into the origin, nature or sincerity of belief, without the state actually enacting an exemption based on philosophical beliefs.
This subterfuge is unnecessary in the twenty states which have explicit philosophical exemptions. (9) These basically allow anyone to claim an exemption and are more widely used than religious exemptions. In states with both religious and philosophical exemptions, parents claiming the latter far exceed the number claiming the former. (10) This, of course, leads to greater risk of children contracting vaccine-preventable diseases.
Conclusion
There is no constitutional right to exemption from mandatory vaccination laws on religious grounds. Thus, religious exemptions to state vaccination mandates are not constitutionally required. Indeed, they may be constitutionally suspect. If a state’s intention in enacting a religious-based exemption – to accommodate those who sincerely believe their established religious tenets prohibit vaccination – cannot be achieved by constitutional means, then the only way to achieve such accommodation is to open the exemption up to essentially everyone who claims a religious reason, whether sincerely held or fabricated for the occasion. This essentially creates a “philosophical” exemption. The consequences of this meaningless exemption, open to anyone who opposes vaccination, are a threat to public health.
Notes
1. Donya Khalili & Arthur Caplan, Off the Grid: Vaccinations Among Homeschooled Children, 35 J.L. Med. & Ethics 471 (2007).
3. Note, A Bad Reaction: A Look at the Arkansas General Assembly’s Response to McCarthy v. Boozman and Boone v. Boozman, 58 Ark. L. Rev. 251 (2005).
3. Id., at 268-269 (footnotes omitted).
4. Alicia Novak, Comment: The Religious and Philosophical Exemptions to State-Compelled Vaccinations: Constitutional and Other Challenges, 7 U. Pa. J. Const. L. 1101, 1114 (2005) (footnotes omitted).
5. Id., at 1114-1115.
6. Ross D. Silverman, No More Kidding Around: Restructuring Non-Medical Childhood Immunization Exemptions to Ensure Public Health Protection, 12 Ann. Health L. 277, 285.
7. Id.
8. Linda E. LeFever, Comment: Religious Exemptions from School Immunization: A Sincere Belief or Legal Loophole? 110 Penn St. L. Rev. 1047, 1047 (2006).
9. Unpublished Opinion (N.D.N.Y., March 8, 2001) reported in N.Y.L.J., Mar. 20, 2001, at 29, discussed in, Silverman, note 6, at 286-288.
10. Silverman, note 6, at 1116-1117.

An antivaccine tale of two legal actions
David Gorski on March 12, 2012
Link
I don’t know what it is about the beginning of a year. I don’t know if it’s confirmation bias or real, but it sure seems that something big happens early every year in the antivaccine world. Consider. As I pointed out back in February 2009, in rapid succession Brian Deer reported that Andrew Wakefield had not only had undisclosed conflicts of interest regarding the research that he did for his now infamous 1998 Lancet paper but that he had falsified data. Then, a couple of weeks later the Special Masters weighed in, rejecting the claims of autism causation by vaccines made in three test cases about as resoundingly as is imaginable. Then, in February 2010, in rapid succession Andrew Wakefield, the hero of the antivaccine movement, was struck off the British medical register, saw his 1998 Lancet paper retracted by the editors, and was unceremoniously booted from his medical directorship of Thoughtful House, the autism quack clinic he helped to found after he fled the U.K. for the more friendly confines of Texas. Soon after that, the Special Masters weighed in again, rejecting the claims of autism causation by vaccines in the remaining test cases. Then, in January 2011, Brian Deer struck again, publishing more damaging revelations about Wakefield, referring to his work as Piltdown medicine in the British journal BMJ.
This year, things were different.
When you don’t have science, sue for libel!
By saying that this year things were different, I don’t mean “different” in the sense that there wasn’t another major story that roiled the antivaccine crankosphere. There certainly was. However, in 2009, 2010, and 2011, for antivaccine activists it was all unrelenting bad news as each year began. This year, something happened that, at least to supporters of Andrew Wakefield, seemed like a great thing. To those of us who know his case and know how far Wakefield’s fallen, it smacked of sheer desperation every bit as much as when the National Vaccine Information Center’s Barbara Loe Fisher sued Paul Offit, journalist Amy Wallace, and her publisher Conde Nasttwo years ago for libel, yes, in January. (She lost spectacularly.) Yes, as 2012 dawned, Andrew Wakefield, for some inexplicable reason, decided to sue journalist Brian Deer, BMJ editor Fiona Godlee, and the BMJ for libel for Deer’s 2011 expose. Actually, the reason wasn’t so inexplicable. My favorite legal folks informed me that the statute of limitations in Texas for libel is one year. The lawsuit is dated very close to one year after the BMJ’s first article is published.
So what was in Wakefield’s complaint against Brian Deer? It was the usual stuff, in particular claiming that the content of the BMJ articles by Deer and BMJ editors was not only just false but knowingly false, stating:
The Defamatory Statements were and are false and written and published with actual malice and intended to cause damage to Dr. Wakefield’s reputation and work as a researcher, academic, and physician and to permanently impair his reptation and his livelihood.
Wakefield’s attorney even had the audacity to play the “pharma shill” gambit. In a legal document! The mind boggles:
Interestingly, at the time of the editorials and the Deer article were Published, the Defendents failed to disclose the fact that the BMJ received significant revenue from the very vaccine manufacturers whose products need further investigation. It was only monthslater, after the issue was raised by others, that the BMJ posted the following: “The BMJ should have declared competing interests in relation to this editorial by Fiona Godlee and colleagues. The BMJ Group receives advertising and sponsorship revenue from vaccine manufacturer, and specifically from Merck and GSK, which both manufacture MMR vaccines.”
Yes, indeed. Wakefield’s attorneys were actually trying to argue that the BMJ libeled Wakefield to protect its big pharma sugar daddy, the vaccine manufacturers. Seriously, Wakefield’s lawyer, William M. Parrish, should know better. Or maybe he doesn’t. He doesn’t list libel as one of his areas of specialty, which are listed as intellectual property disputes (e.g., trade secret, trademark, trade name, trade dress, copyright and patent disputes) business torts (e.g., unfair competition, deceptive trade practices, tortious interference with actual and prospective contracts and/or business relationships, fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, unfair advertising practices, etc.) and breach of contract claims. Yet here there he was, suing for libel.
I find it very amusing that Dr. Wakefield claimed his “professional reputation” was damaged by Deer’s 2011 articles. The reason, of course, is that Dr. Wakefield’s reputation was destroyed long before by his having done and publicized his bad science, by his having intentionally consorted with the antivaccine movement, and his having continued to crank out bad science in the service of smearing the MMR with the claim that it causes autism. Wakefield destroyed his own reputation by doing fraudulent science; Deer only dug up the evidence to demonstrate that. That happened years before Brian Deer ever wrote that BMJ article a year ago. Wakefield had already been found guilty by the General Medical Council of “serious professional misconduct,” which included acting in ways not in the clinical interests of disabled children. Shortly after that, one remembers, he was struck off the medical register, and fired from Thoughtful House. All of this happened many months before Brian Deer wrote his article.
To put it bluntly, Andrew Wakefield no longer had any professional reputation to be trashed. This will be a major problem for him in any libel action, because one has to prove damage to one’s reputation to be successful in a libel suit.
In fact, this whole lawsuit strikes me as incredibly ill-advised, as it opens Wakefield up to discovery. Of course, it might well be that part of the motivation for the lawsuit is to subject Brian Deer, the BMJ, and Fiona Godlee to discovery, and I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised to see bits of information from discovery show up on the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism; that is, if the case gets that far. If I were part of the antivaccine bloggerati at AoA, I might be worried now, because, given AoA’s campaign to discredit Brian Deer, particularly over the last year, it’s likely to be in the defense’s crosshairs. Communications between Wakefield and any AoA blogger might be subject to discovery. Any financial transaction between Generation Rescue and Andrew Wakefield could also be subject to discovery. Wakefield might think that because Deer, Godlee, and the BMJ are in the UK that they won’t engage in a full and vigorous defense to the extent of going whole hog (sorry, the lawsuit’s in Texas; I couldn’t resist) on discovery. Is Wakefield sure he wants to risk that? BMJ is part of a large company, and publishing companies tend not to take kindly to libel actions. Of course, even if the Generation Rescue/AoA/Wakefield connection isn’t a worry, everything else is. After all, everything about the Lancet paper would definitely be subject to discovery, and there’s no question about its relevance to the lawsuit.
Whatever Wakefield’s motivation, this move reeks of desperation. In taking this action, Wakefield both demonstrated the characteristics of a crank (the need to silence using the courts rather than to refute using science) and showed just how far he’s fallen. In any case, I highly doubt Brian Deer has anything to worry about, other than the irritation this might cause and whether the company providing his libel insurance will go all wobbly on him. After all, the truth is an absolute defense against libel.
On the other hand, Wakefield might just be one of the luckiest bastards I’ve ever seen.
An assist from Justice Mitting
Last week, there was quite a bit of whooping it up in the antivaccine crankosphere, which appeared to be partying like it’s 2005, when Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. first published his antivaccine screed in Salon.com and Rolling Stone. From the rejoicing that’s been going on, you’d think that Andrew Wakefield had been completely exonerated of fraud and proven right about his fear mongering that blamed the MMR vaccine for autism. This is odd, given that the news story that broke last week was not about Andrew Wakefield directly. Rather, it was about Professor John Walker-Smith, one of the co-authors of Andrew Wakefield’s discredited and retracted 1998 Lancet paper. The antivaccine crank blog is going wild with the news that Professor Walker-Smith has succeeded in his appeal of the General Medical Council’s decision that he should be struck off the medical record along with Andy Wakefield.
On AoA, no less a figure than Jenny McCarthy herself has returned to demonstrate that, as much as she has been keeping her antivaccine activism on the down-low lately, she hasn’t given it up. She did this by posting an article on the antivaccine blog affiliated with her group Generation Rescue entitled MMR Doctor Exonerated—Who’s Guilty Now? In it, McCarthy asks:
Now what? If the foundation of the proof that the MMR does not trigger autism is crumbling, what in the world are parents supposed to believe? If Professor Walker-Smith is not guilty on all charges, will Dr. Wakefield be next?
The answer is no, Jenny. Not that that stops her from asking hopefully:
Unfortunately, the GMC’s decision to turn Dr. Wakefield and Prof. Walker-Smith’s paper into a three-ring circus has put a chill on research into all the possible environmental causes of autism. Will this finally open the floodgates?
In other words, because Professor Walker-Smith succeeded in his appeal, Andrew Wakefield was right. Seriously. That’s the argument being made. The full ruling can be found here. As usual, what the antivaccine movement is promoting and what is in the ruling are not necessarily the same thing. If there’s one thing that’s obvious from the outpouring of verbiage from various antivaccine blogs, Twitter feeds, and press releases, it’s that the antivaccine movement somehow thinks that this decision exonerates Andrew Wakefield, too. Let’s disabuse them of that delusion right now, shall we? According to Mr. Justice Mitting:
At a press conference, which Professor Walker-Smith did not attend, convened to accompany publication, Dr. Wakefield stated publicly the view which he had previously expressed privately to Professor Walker-Smith that he could no longer support the giving of MMR vaccine. The joint view of Professor Walker-Smith and Dr. Murch, stated in a letter to Dr. Wakefield on 21st January 1998, was that it was inappropriate to emphasize the role of MMR vaccine in publicity about the paper and that they supported government policy concerning MMR until more firm evidence was available for them to see for themselves. They published a press release to coincide with publication stating their support for “present public health policy concerning MMR”. Dr. Wakefield’s statement and subsequent publicity had a predictable adverse effect upon the take up of MMR vaccine of great concern to those responsible for public health. There is now no respectable body of opinion which supports his hypothesis, that MMR vaccine and autism/enterocolitis are causally linked.
Correct. There is no respectable body of opinion supporting Wakefield’s hypothesis that the MMR is somehow linked to autism or the entity Wakefield made up called “autistic enterocolitis.” It’s rather annoying that Mitting would refer to it as a “body of opinion.” One can only speculate that it’s his legal background that leads him to use this particular phraseology. No scientist would. Scientists would (and do) point out that not only is there no good scientific evidence supporting Wakefield’s hypothesis, but there is a lot of evidence that falsifies his hypothesis. There’s a reason why Wakefield is viewed with such contempt in the scientific world. Actually, there are multiple reasons, not the least of which is that Wakefield is an incompetent scientist willing to commit research fraud to provide evidence for trial lawyers to use in lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers, a plot that Brian Deer uncovered and described in excruciating detail and with excruciatingly detailed documentation. This ruling says nothing about that; it’s primarily about methodology and Mitting’s legal ruling that the GMC didn’t adequately explain the rationale behind its findings that Walker-Smith committed professional misconduct. Mitting’s decision also relies a lot on his clearly poor understanding of medical research issues. (More on that below.)
It’s a simple fact, though, that Mitting’s decision regarding has nothing to do with whether Wakefield is a fraud or a pseudoscientist or not. Nor does it have anything to do with the question of whether vaccines, specifically the MMR vaccine, cause autism, as much as Wakefield’s many apologists would like to convince people otherwise. In fact, as I’ve pointed out before, Wakefield’s being struck off the British medical registry has nothing to do with the validity of the science. Even if Wakefield had prevailed and been allowed to keep his medical license, his claimed findings that vaccines cause autistic enterocolitis and/or autism would have been just as bogus. Legal rulings are not science. They can be based on science, but often they are not. It’s nice when they don’t go against science and nicer still when they resoundingly agree with science, but such is not always the case. To try to argue that a legal ruling such as the one regarding Professor Walker-Smith exonerates Wakefield is an even worse folly than arguing that his being struck off necessarily proves he is a quack. He’s an antivaccine quack based on science; it matters not what the courts say.
Admittedly, I haven’t paid much attention to Professor Walker-Smith. Back when I wrote about Andy Wakefield being struck off, I said very little, if anything about Walker-Smith. The reason, of course, is that I viewed the Walker-Smith decision as being at best peripheral. I didn’t know enough about him to decide for myself whether the GMC decision was justified or not. Still, it’s useful to look at the court’s decision to see why it concluded that Walker-Smith didn’t deserve to be struck off. Here is the conclusion of the appeal decision:
For the reasons given above, both on general issues and the Lancet paper and in relation to individual children, the panel’s overall conclusion that Professor Walker-Smith was guilty of serious professional misconduct was flawed, in two respects: inadequate and superficial reasoning and, in a number of instances, a wrong conclusion. Miss Glynn submits that the materials which I have been invited to consider would support many of the panel’s critical findings; and that I can safely infer that, without saying so, it preferred the evidence of the GMC’s experts, principally Professor Booth, to that given by Professor Walker-Smith and Dr. Murch and by Dr. Miller and Dr. Thomas. Even if it were permissible to perform such an exercise, which I doubt, it would not permit me to rescue the panel’s findings. As I have explained, the medical records provide an equivocal answer to most of the questions which the panel had to decide. The panel had no alternative but to decide whether Professor Walker-Smith had told the truth to it and to his colleagues, contemporaneously. The GMC’s approach to the fundamental issues in the case led it to believe that that was not necessary – an error from which many of the subsequent weaknesses in the panel’s determination flowed. It had to decide what Professor Walker-Smith thought he was doing: if he believed he was undertaking research in the guise of clinical investigation and treatment, he deserved the finding that he had been guilty of serious professional misconduct and the sanction of erasure; if not, he did not, unless, perhaps, his actions fell outside the spectrum of that which would have been considered reasonable medical practice by an academic clinician. Its failure to address and decide that question is an error which goes to the root of its determination.
As you can see, the decision all boils down to the question of research and whether Walker-Smith thought he was doing research or actually treating autistic children using interventions that were clinically indicated. If the interventions were clinically indicated, then it could be argued that he did not commit professional misconduct. If the interventions were done with the knowledge that they were being done for research purposes rather than to treat the children, then Walker-Smith is guilty of misconduct. The reasons, of course, are the lack of ethical committee approval yet, as is discussed in the decision:
At the heart of the GMC’s case against Professor Walker-Smith were two simple propositions: the investigations undertaken under his authority on eleven of the twelve Lancet children were done as part of a research project – Project 172-96 – which required, but did not have, Ethics Committee approval; and they were clinically inappropriate. Professor Walker-Smith’s case was that the investigations were clinically appropriate attempts at diagnosis of bowel and behavioural disorders in children with broadly similar symptoms and, where possible, treatment of the bowel disorders or alleviation of their symptoms. The GMC’s case was that he was conducting research which required Ethics Committee approval. His case was that he was conducting medical practice which did not. Accordingly, an unavoidable and fundamental question which the panel had to answer was: what is the distinction between medical practice and research?
In light of this introduction, what follows is profoundly contradictory in that the judge acknowledges that what Walker-Smith did could be reasonably viewed as research, but exonerates him because it could also be viewed as therapeutic:
The panel made no express finding on this issue and cannot have appreciated the need to do so. It was not helped by the premise upon which the GMC’s case was founded. There was a good deal of evidence, to which I refer in greater detail below, that Professor Walker-Smith and his team were undertaking what any reasonable body of medical practitioners would categorize as research – but also that he intended and genuinely believed that what he was doing was solely or primarily for the clinical benefit of the children. When such an issue arises, a panel will almost always have to determine the honesty or otherwise of the practitioner.
Justice Mitting then lists facts supporting and negating the proposition that what Walker-Smith was doing was research. I must admit, I find some of the “facts negating’ to be questionable. Particularly bizarre was Mitting’s listing of a fact that no parent other than one was required to sign the consent form in the proposals submitted to the Ethics Committee or in the revised form approved by it. Well, duh! That was part of the problem, now, wasn’t it? You know? Doing research without having obtained adequate informed consent from the parents?
Also rather odd was Mitting’s other reasoning that “none of the five clinicians involved in the investigation of the Lancet children who gave evidence to the panel considered that they were following Project 172-96.” So what? The children’s information and clinical histories ended up being used in Wakefield’s Lancet paper. I suppose one could argue that Walker-Smith was an unwitting dupe of Andy Wakefield an therefore was not guilty of research professional misconduct, but, if that’s the case, it’s hardly flattering to Walker-Smith. it’s also hard to imagine what clinical indications existed to subject these children to lumbar punctures. As a clinician, I always had a hard time figuring out how Wakefield, Walker-Smith, and the rest justified doing lumbar punctures on these children.
The implications of Mitting’s ruling are frightening in their potential. Think about it. Basically, if his ruling stands, it’s hard not to wonder whether it’s open season on human research subjects in the UK. As long as the physician can construct a quasi-legitimate-sounding rationale that he can point to aside from a research protocol for doing research-related tests on human subjects, he apparently doesn’t need to get ethical approval anymore. He can cite Mitting’s ruling that, as long as he doesn’t think he’s doing research–even if that is incorrect–then he’s not, and the GMC can’t do anything about it. So much for the Helsinki declaration! Similarly, his “any reasonable physician” test fails spectacularly as well, at least in the way he applied it. “Any reasonable physician” would not subject autistic children to a battery of invasive tests including lumbar punctures for dubious clinical reasons. Those tests were quite correctly judged by the GMC to have been ordered for research purposes rather than for routine clinical care. Autism quacks in the UK have good reason to rejoice. As it stands, one has to wonder whether they can now get away with essentially anything.
And one has to wonder whether Brian Deer is one of the luckiest guys alive.
Brian Deer responds
At this point, it’s hard not to wonder whether the timing of Wakefield’s lawsuit against the BMJ and Brian Deer was related to more than just the end of the statute of limitations for libel suits in Texas. Certainly, the ruling in the Walker–Smith case serves Wakefield’s interests, both in terms of rallying his base but more importantly in terms of seeming to provide him with ammunition for his lawsuit. As much as Wakefield might wish to believe that and as much as antivaccinationists might want to believe that Justice Mitting’s ruling somehow exonerates Andrew Wakefield, they are sadly mistaken. The two cases, although they were about the research leading up to the publication of Wakefield’s 1998 study, the reasons for the decisions in the case of Andrew Wakefield and in the case of Professor Walker-Smith were quite different. As I said above, I don’t agree with the decision for the simple reason that I think that it reveals a profound misunderstanding of medicine and research. Even so, there’s no way that the same sort of reasoning can be applied to Andrew Wakefield. For just a taste of the reasons why, it’s instructive to look at Brian Deer’s response to Wakefield’s attempt at legal thuggery. Not only is it instructive, but it’s amusing to read because it reveals things that I didn’t know about the case. In a way, I had hoped that Deer would let Wakefield embarrass himself more before hitting him with the an anti-SLAPP motion, but on the other hand it would be unreasonable to expect the defendants to do that just so that I could be enlightened by the revelations that might come out of the discovery process. Legally, given that Texas has recently passed an anti-SLAPP law.
For those not familiar with the term, SLAPP stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation. Basically, SLAPPs are lawsuits designed to silence critics in important public matters. They succeed in this by intimidation and burdening critics with the cost of legal defenses. In general, wealthy interests, because they have more resources, can afford the expense of pursuing libel suits of this sort, while the defendants usually cannot. As a result, often defendants are silenced. Anti-SLAPP statutes are designed to allow victims of SLAPPs to quash lawsuits and recover damages. Not surprisingly, Wakefield’s libel suit reeks of SLAPP.
So, naturally, Deer’s lawyers are hitting that aspect hard in their response, and Deer himself has provided a 104 page supporting document. Its key pillars include arguing the factual background and pointing out that the truth is an absolute defense against libel, arguing that the Texas anti-SLAPP statute applies, arguing that Wakefield cannot show malice, and pointing out that Wakefield meets the definition of a public figure, making the bar for libel much higher. It’s worth reading the entire response for its richness of detail, but I’ll “cherry pick” a few of the choice bits for my post. For example, one of the amusing bits occurs when Deer’s lawyers point out that off-the-cuff remarks made by Deer are not actionable:
For similar reasons, Texas courts have long held that a statement of rhetorical hyperbole or one using colorful language is nonactionable. Such a statement “does not, in its common usage, convey a verifiable fact, but is, by its nature, somewhat indefinite and ambiguous. . . .”
Falk & Mayfield, L.L.P. v. Molzan, 974 S.W.2d 821, 824 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 1998, pet. denied). For example, Texas courts have identified a long list of statements that are simply too indefinite to sustain a viable libel claim. See, e.g., id. (accusing a law firm of “lawsuit abuse” nonactionable); Zimmer, 257 S.W.3d at 512 (accusing coach of using “obscene gesture” nonactionable); Kerr, 706 S.W.2d at 799 (holding that an accusation of “cheating” in an editorial was nonactionable); Associated Press v. Cook, 17 S.W.3d 447, 454 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2000, no pet.) (labeling the plaintiff a “blight on law enforcement” who has caused “unbelievable problems” was nonactionable); Yiamouyiannis v. Thompson, 764 S.W.2d 338, 339-40 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 1988, writ denied) (holding that statements calling the plaintiff a “quack, a hoke artist, and a fearmonger,” are “vintage hyperbole, and are not capable of proof one way or the other”). In fact, courts in other cases have considered the very same expressions challenged by Dr. Wakefield here and found them to be nonactionable.
Imagine my relief that, in Texas at least, calling Wakefield a “fraudster” is protected speech.
My relief that many of my more—shall we say?—colorful utterances and writings about Andrew Wakefield are almost certainly protected speech notwithstanding, there’s no doubt that Andrew Wakefield has to clear a very high bar to have any chance of prevailing. He has to demonstrate the following:
Dr. Wakefield may have figured that, in Texas, there would be little “downside” to filing frivolous libel claims and using the suit to raise money and harass his critics. Not so anymore. To avoid dismissal under our State’s new anti-SLAPP statute, Dr. Wakefield must submit evidence to support each essential element of his libel claims. He cannot do this for several reasons. First, the statements he challenges are true. The GMC findings against him—numerous proven charges of “dishonest” and “unethical” conduct—are binding in this case, and they leave no room for Wakefield to argue that he was defamed by Defendants’ reporting and editorial comment. And Defendants have overwhelming additional evidence to establish the truth of the challenged statements.
Moreover, even if Dr. Wakefield could produce evidence of falsity and overcome Defendants’ other defenses, his claims would still fail. He is indisputably a public figure, and therefore must prove that Defendants acted with actual malice—that they knew what they were publishing was false. Again, this will be an impossible burden for Dr. Wakefield. The reporting he challenges was the product of years of investigation by one of the United Kingdom’s best reporters, exhaustively sourced, then subjected to multiple editorial reviews, including an external review by an expert pediatrician. And Dr. Wakefield’s credibility on these matters had been so thoroughly eviscerated by his repeated obfuscation, posturing, and outright lying that Defendants had no doubts about the accuracy of their reporting, despite Wakefield’s protestations of innocence.
Also, as is noted numerous times, Wakefield’s history of frivolous lawsuits does not help his case. As Popehat notes, this motion, on an initial reading, looks very strong.
Particularly strong is the excruciatingly detailed reconstruction of the evidence against Wakefield, both from the GMC hearings and Deer’s own investigations. If you want to know why it’s purely wishful thinking on Olmsted’s and McCarthy’s part to think that the reversal of Walker-Smith’s loss of his medical license has any significant bearing on either Wakefield’s GMC case or, in particular, this frivolous lawsuit, you’d do well to read the sections in the anti-SLAPP response and Brian Deer’s response to Wakefield’s lawsuit describing Wakefield’s activities and the evidence against him. For example, in Walker-Smith’s case, the primary offense that the GMC found him guilty of doing tests (such as lumbar punctures, MRIs, and colonoscopies) for research purposes rather than clinical purposes. That’s it. Wakefield did so much more:
The GMC panel handed down its findings on January 28, 2010, concluding that Dr. Wakefield had been dishonest, violated basic research ethics rules, and showed a “callous disregard” for the suffering of children involved in his research.32 Included among them were four different proven findings of dishonesty against Dr. Wakefield, all proven to a standard of criminal fault—akin to “beyond a reasonable doubt” in the United States.33 Among other things, the panel found that Dr. Wakefield improperly subjected some children to invasive medical procedures such as colonoscopies and MRI scans. Dr. Wakefield also paid children at his son’s birthday party to have blood drawn for research purposes. The GMC panel found that Dr. Wakefield’s Lancet research was “dishonest,” “irresponsible,” “misleading,” and inaccurate. The panel found that Dr. Wakefield improperly failed to disclose his connections to planned litigation, his patents for a competing vaccine, and the bias inherent in his selection of study subjects. The GMC panel further found that Dr. Wakefield’s conduct “was such as to bring the medical profession into disrepute.”
Basically, at the very best if you accept the reasoning behind Mitting’s ruling, you must conclude that Walker-Smith was Wakefield’s dupe. At worst, if you don’t accept the reasoning behind Mitting’s ruling, Walker-Smith was complicit. Either way, Justice Mitting’s ruling will not help Wakefield in his libel action. After all, Wakefield’s lawsuit was all about the article that Deer published in the BMJ and the accompanying editorial written by Fiona Godlee. Neither rehashed of the GMC hearings, even though it’s clear that Wakefield is trying to relitigate the GMC hearings using the vehicle of a libel suit. More importantly, even if Deer’s and Godlee’s articles were nothing more than rehashes of the GMC hearings, to prevail Wakefield must prove that Deer and/or Godlee believed or suspected what they wrote was false. They clearly did not. The only thing Justice Mitting’s decision held was that the GMC gave more weight to the expert witnesses against Walkers-Smith than the expert witnesses for him (and hence its decision should be reversed) and that the GMC didn’t consider whether or not Walkers-Smith believed the medical procedures were clinically indicated (and hence the GMC decision should be reversed). I’m not sure about the former, and I find Mitting’s understanding of medical research and its ethics to be dubious at best, but even if his reasoning were spot on, neither of his conclusions sheds any light on whether Deer or Godlee thought what they were publishing was accurate or not, while Deer’s and Godlee’s anti-SLAPP response delineates the incredible lengths to which the BMJ went to assure that Deer’s article was accurate:
Not only did the BMJ fully trust Deer and his reporting, it and Dr. Godlee took extra steps to ensure the reporting was truthful. For Deer, who was ever mindful of Dr. Wakefield’s prior litigation and regulatory-complaint history, this meant five months of work to ensure that every word and every citation was verified.166 For the BMJ, this meant a separate fact-check of the first article by a deputy editor (Smith) and an external review for scientific accuracy by an expert pediatrician (Dr. Marcovitch).167 Pre-publication review by outside sources constitutes affirmative evidence of no actual malice. See, e.g., Doubleday & Co., Inc. v. Rogers, 674 S.W.2d 751, 756 (Tex. 1984).
In other words, the reversal of the ruling in Walker-Smith’s case has no bearing on Wakefield’s libel suit. Remember, Walker-Smith’s argument basically boiled down to throwing Wakefield under the bus by admitting he did everything in the GMC complaint but arguing that at the time he hadn’t been aware that Wakefield was conducting a research project, much less one without proper approval by an ethics board. It’s the “dupe” defense.
As Sullivan points out, one has to wonder whether Andrew Wakefield’s lawyer was aware just how shaky the basis of his lawsuit was, given that he appears to have taken on the case as a favor. Why do I say that? Well, there is a rather odd link between Wakefield and his lawyer. This link is through the Autism Trust USA. Look at this webpage describing the National Board. Note that Carmel Wakefield, Andrew Wakefield’s wife, is on the board and the executive committee. Note that Imogon Wakefield (apparently Andrew Wakefield’s daughter) is on the Junior Advisory Board. Now look at who else is also on the Junior Advisory Board.
Anna Christine Parrish.
And remember who Andrew Wakefield’s lawyer bringing the libel suit is.
William M. Parrish.
Coincidence? Possibly, but I tend to doubt it.
So what now? In a way, I’m rather surprised that Wakefield put himself in such a situation. Surely he had to be aware that Texas had recently passed an anti-SLAPP statuted designed specifically to punish the filing of lawsuits of the type that Wakefield is known for. Even worse, Wakefield might have unwittingly set himself up to be the first major test case for the new law.
Whatever Wakefield’s motivations, to rally his supporters, hubris and vanity demanding that he try to salvage a shred of reputation, or just a desire to punish those who did the public such a great service in revealing the depths of Wakefield’s perfidy, Wakefield is following an unfortunately well-worn path in suing the legal system to try to silence critics. It is what cranks do. What makes this interesting is that this time Wakefield might pay a price.
What’s also revealing is how antivaccine cranks view not just Wakefield’s libel suit but how they view legal processes in general. In a way, they view such issues in a manner similar to how people in general do, but with our normal tendencies to view results that we like as correct and results that we don’t like as incorrect cranked up to 11. For example, to them Walker-Smith’s success on appeal is not just a ruling that disagreed with the General Medical Council’s explanation of its reasoning for striking off Walker-Smith based on questionable understandings of clinical trial ethics and how medicine is practiced, it’s a vindication of their world view as embodied in Andrew Wakefield. Similarly, Wakefield’s lawsuit is also vindication. It’s not difficult to predict that, when Wakefield’s libel suit is dismissed (and, make no mistake, a frivolous lawsuit like this will be dismissed) and he is hit with Deer’s and the BMJ’s legal expenses, antivaccinationist will view it as more persecution of their hero.
It’s important in considering such issues to remember that the law and science are, unfortunately, related (when they’re related) only by coincidence. More often, the law has little to do with science.

California Bill AB 2109: The Antivaccine Movement Attacks School Vaccine Mandates Again
AB 2109 in California makes it harder for parents to claim personal belief exemptions to school vaccine requirements by requiring that parents visit a physician or other enumerated health care provider to counsel them on the risks of leaving their child unvaccinated, thus providing informed consent. Not surprisingly, antivaxers do not like it.
David Gorski on March 26, 2012
Link
Of all the preventative treatments ever developed through science- and evidence-based medicine, vaccines have arguably saved more lives, prevented more illness and disability, and in general alleviated more suffering than any single class of treatments or preventative measures throughout history. Given the obvious and incredible success of vaccines at decreasing the incidence of infectious diseases that used to ravage populations, it seems incredible that there would be such a thing as an antivaccine movement, but there is. Indeed, when I first encountered antivaccine zealots on the Usenet newsgroup misc.health.alternative about ten or twelve years ago, as a physician I really had a hard time wrapping my head around the fact that such people existed. No doubt the same is true of many physicians, who take the scientific evidence for the safety and efficacy for vaccines for granted. However, I am a cancer surgeon, and I do not treat children; so until I discovered antivaccine rhetoric on the Internet I was blissfully ignorant that such views even existed. Other health care professionals knew better. Pediatricians, nurses, and any health care professionals who deal with children and the issue of vaccinations know better, because they face antivaccine views on a daily basis. It is because of the incredible importance of vaccination and the danger to public health the antivaccine movement represents that we at Science-Based Medicine write so frequently about vaccines and the antiscientific, pseudoscientific, and misinformation-packed fear mongering about vaccines that is so prevalent today.
The success of vaccination campaigns has recently been endangered by a number of factors, in particular the antivaccine movement. Because of various groups opposed to vaccination, either for philosophical reasons or because they incorrectly believe that vaccines cause autism, neurodevelopmental disorders, sudden infant death syndrome, and autoimmune diseases, among others, one of the most potent tools for encouraging high rates of vaccine uptake, school vaccine mandates, have come under attack. Alternatively, increasing numbers of parents have taken advantage of religious or philosophical exemptions in order to avoid the requirement to have their children vaccinated prior to entry to school. As a result, of late some states with lax vaccination requirements have begun to try to tighten up requirement for non-medical vaccine exemptions. The arguments used by the antivaccine movement against such legislation are highly revealing about their mindset, in particular their attitude towards issues of informed consent, which I will discuss a bit. But first, here’s a little background.
Antivaccinationism throughout history
The success of vaccination campaigns depends upon as many members of an at-risk population as possible being vaccinated in order to achieve herd immunity. Herd immunity (also known as community immunity, a lovely rhyme) been discussed on this blog many times, most prominently by Drs. Mark Crislip and Joseph Albietz. Basically, when a sufficiently large percentage of the population is vaccinated against a disease, even those not immune to the disease obtain a measure of protection against infection because the immunity of a large percentage of the population prevents the infectious agent from being readily spread from person to person. The agent thus never gets a “foothold” in the community, and the greater the proportion of the population vaccinated the less the chance of a susceptible individual coming into contact with an individual carrying the infection. Herd immunity is very important because it helps to protect population members who can’t be vaccinated for whatever reason, be it immunodeficiency or other medical reason or because they are too young to be vaccinated. Vaccines aren’t perfect. Even highly effective vaccines only protect 90 to 100% of the vaccinated population in the case of an exposure to the infectious agent vaccinated against. The precise percentage of the population that needs to be vaccinated to achieve herd/community immunity varies depending upon the efficacy of the vaccine and the infectiousness of the disease being vaccinated against, but a good, serviceable ballpark estimate is usually somwhere in the 90% range.
Herd immunity is the reason why it is so important to vaccinate as large a percentage of the at-risk population as possible. To this end, public health officials have at times tried a number of strategies, ranging from cajoling to compulsory vaccination. Legislating compulsory vaccination, in particular, has traditionally been problematic, for almost immediately after vaccines were invented and public health officials started looking for ways to increase vaccine uptake rates, in response have sprung up antivaccination movements. For example, in the U.K. the Vaccination Act of 1853 ordered mandatory vaccinations for infants up to three months old, with failure of parents to do so punishable by a fine or imprisonment, a requirement that was extended to age 14 by the Vaccination Act of 1867. The 1853 act immediately provoked violent riots in Ipswich, Henley, Mitford, and several other towns, and resulted in founding of the Anti-Vaccination League later that same year. Over the next few decades, in response to compulsory vaccination laws a large number of antivaccination books, journals, and tracts appeared. The titles of these books and journals, at least, were more honest than titles of similar websites today. For instance, there were the Anti-Vaccinator (founded 1869), the National Anti-Compulsory Vaccination Reporter (1874), and the Vaccination Inquirer (1879). Meanwhile, similar movements flourished elsewhere in Europe and the United States, challenging such laws as infringements on personal liberty. Ultimately, in England, the Vaccination Act was amended to allow exemptions for parents, based on conscience, which introduced the concept of “conscientious objector” into English law.
A different strategy to achieve high rates of vaccination is the use of vaccine mandates. School vaccine mandates differ from laws requiring vaccination in that no one from the state will hunt parents down to force them to vaccinate. However, if parents want to take advantage of state services, such as public schools, for their children or if they want to use services that place a lot of children together (such as day care facilities) they have to have their children vaccinated. This is a practice with very old precedent. For example, in 1827 Boston became the first city to require parents of children enrolling in public school to present evidence of vaccination against smallpox. The trend continued, as described in this review of school vaccine madates:
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts incorporated its own school vaccination law in 1855, New York in 1862, Connecticut in 1872, and Pennsylvania in 1895. Other Northeast states soon passed their own requirements. The trend toward compulsory child vaccination as a condition of school attendance eventually spread to states in the Midwest [e.g., Indiana (1881), Illinois and Wisconsin (1882), Iowa (1889)], South [e.g., Arkansas and Virginia (1882)], and West [e.g., California (1888)], though not without considerable political debate.
School vaccine mandates, although they were opposed by antivaccination leagues from the beginning, tended to provoke less virulent opposition and better compliance, making them not only politically more palatable, but more effective. However, of late, the effectiveness of school vaccine mandates has been weakened by a steady expansion of non-medical exemptions, in particular religious or philosophical exemptions. Forty-eight states currently allow religious exemptions that vary in requirements, from parents simply signing a form stating that vaccination is against their religion to allowing exemptions only to religions that have a history of opposing vaccination, such as Christian Scientists and Jehovah’s Witnesses. Twenty states currently permit philosophical exemptions, in which parents must declare a personal belief against or philosophical objection to vaccination. Usually, parents must file a form, ranging from just once to annually, with their school district stating their personal objection to vaccination. Not surprisingly, in states that allow personal belief exemptions they are the most commonly invoked reason by parents to refuse vaccinating their children. Even in states that allow only religious exemptions, however, parents are not above lying about their religion in order to obtain a vaccine exemption.
California responds to the increasing use of personal exemptions
Over the last couple of decades, the percentage of parents claiming personal exemptions to vaccination has more than doubled. In California, a state with a particularly lax personal exemption law that only requires that the parent sign a form stating that they have a personal belief against or philosophical objection to vaccination, although statewide the percentage of children with parents claiming the personal belief exemption remains low (2%), there are schools where exemption rates are as high as 58% (one kindergarten reported a 76% exemption rate) serving as incubators for outbreaks of measles and other contagious diseases. After all, unvaccinated children have a 23-fold higher risk of contracting pertussis and a 35-fold higher risk of contracting measles than vaccinated children. Unfortunately, the non-vaccinating populations tend to cluster, and their refusal of vaccines leads to there being areas with large pockets of unvaccinated children, ripe for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases.
Part of the problem in California is that philosophical exemptions are so easy to obtain that they are actually easier to obtain than it is for parents to have their children vaccinated according to California requirements for school entry. It is, in effect, so easy to obtain a personal belief exemption from vaccination requirements for school entry that even parents with no strong feelings who are simply too harried to claim this exemption just to make their lives a little easier. Just sign a piece of paper. That’s it.
To try to make sure that parents who refuse vaccines on a personal belief basis do so with full informed consent and to make it just a bit more difficult to obtain such exemptions, Assemblymember Richard Pan (D-5th District), who also happens to be a physician, introduced California bill AB 2109. (According to Liz Ditz, as of March 24, the bill is still in the Assembly Health Committee.) The bill is very simple and not a major change from California’s current lax policy. Basically, in addition to signing a personal belief exemption form, if AB 2109 is passed, parents will be required to obtain a signed form from a pediatrician stating that they have been counseled on the risks and benefits of vaccines. The law would, in essence, require that the parents make such a monumental decision only after having had a physician provide them with informed consent, so that they understand the potential consequences of not vaccinating, as well as the risk-benefit ratio for vaccination. The text of the bill can be found here.
Unfortunately, even so mild a change in the law designed to boost vaccination rates has not gone unnoticed among the antivaccine movement.
The antivaccine movement and its sympathizers react by advocating misinformed consent
I’ve discussed the concept of “misinformed consent” multiple times before. Quacks in general, particularly the “health freedom” movement proclaim their dedication to “informed consent.” “All we’re asking for,” they will say, “is informed consent.” The antivaccine movement in particular demands “informed consent” about vaccines. Be it founder of the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) Barbara Loe Fisher, the bloggers at the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism, or any of a number of antivaccine warriors, demanding “informed consent” seems to be every bit as much of the antivaccine arsenal as the “toxins gambit” or ranting about “fetal cells” in vaccines. None of this is to try to say or even imply that informed consent isn’t incredibly important. It is critical to everything we do in medicine, both in clinical practice and research in the form of clinical trials. It is, quite correctly, considered a major failure when adequate informed consent is not given, and when the failure to provide informed consent is intentional or comes about through neglect it’s considered highly unethical. Medical ethics demands that patients be aware of what it is they are getting as well as what the potential benefits are relative to the potential risks, and that they have the freedom to choose to undergo or refuse the proposed therapy.
However, what the antivaccine movement means when its representatives demand “informed consent” resembles true informed consent only by coincidence–and, let’s be frank, not even then. In fact, as Todd points out, the actions of the antivaccine movement are profoundly inconsistent with a real desire for real informed consent, and California Bill AB 2109 is a golden opportunity for the luminaries of the antivaccine movement to prove that they support informed consent. As he also put it, “Parents are still free to put their children and their communities at risk of disease outbreaks based on personal opinions rather than facts. They just aren’t allowed to be quite as lazy about it any more.”
Unfortunately, the antivaccine movement has rallied not for AB 2109, but against it. Barbara Loe Fisher, all her protestations for “informed consent” notwithstanding, has issued what is in essence a call to arms to her fellow antivaccinationists to try to defeat the bill. It’s full of appeals to “personal freedom,” claims that doctors would not sign such forms, and the like:
AB2109, introduced by Assembly Member Richard Pan, who himself is a pediatrician, would impose these additional costly and time consuming burdens on parents wanting to use a personal belief exemption to:
     1.  pay for an expensive appointment at a medical doctor’s office to be given vaccine risk and benefit information that is already available online for free; and
     2.  jump through the bureaucratic hoops of obtaining yet additional new forms provided by the Department of Public Health which state that the health care practitioner has provided risk and benefit information to the parent; and
     3.  find a health care provider actually willing to take the appointment and then sign the new forms within 6th months of starting school for the exemption to be valid.
This raises many questions legislators need to answer including:
    • How will the state pay for all these extra required office visits for families on public assistance and for the kids of state employees who have their health coverage provided by the state?
    • What happens to a parent who can’t find a provider willing to make these types of appointments and then sign the form?
    • What will stop doctors from using this law to deny access to philosophical exemptions? It is already hard enough for families to find providers who are willing to just treat children in their practice at all when they deviate from the required vaccination schedule.
Then, to hammer home the connection between quackery and antivaccine beliefs, the NVIC adds these reasons for opposing AB 2109:
    • Especially in California, many families utilize health care providers not reliant on pharmaceutical drugs and vaccines, and only practitioners part of the pharmaceutical paradigm or medicine are allowed to provide the information and sign the form under this bill.
    • AB 2109 discriminates against families utilizing complementary and alternative medicine by forcing them into paying money to a medical practitioner they wouldn’t otherwise use who is already philosophically opposed to the parent’s personal and religious convictions regarding vaccination.
Barbara says that as though prodding parents who take their children to quacks to take them to a real doctor for just one visit is a bad thing. Of course, it’s “health care providers not reliant on pharmaceutical drugs and vaccines” who tend to promote antivaccine beliefs. Of course, I expect such nonsense from someone like Fisher. I don’t expect such nonsense from a physician. In fact, call me naive, way too optimistic, or just someone who falls into the occasional temptation to defend his tribe too much, but I don’t expect nonsense this ridiculous even from someone like Dr. Jay Gordon.
Or Dr. Robert Sears.
Unfortunately, I was quite wrong. Dr. Sears has joined Barbara Loe Fisher’s voice against AB 2109 by writing an editorial that was published first on that other wretched hive of scum and antivaccine quackery, Mothering.com, entitled California Bill AB2109 Threatens Vaccine Freedom of Choice. Not surprisingly, two days later Dr. Sears crossposted the very same article on the original wretched hives of scum and quackery, The Huffington Post. His reasons for being opposed to AB 2109 are virtually indistinguishable from the reasons posted at the NVIC website, right down to Dr. Sears claiming that doctors won’t sign the form:
However, what gravely concerns me is that some doctors will refuse to sign this form. I know how doctors think. Many doctors strongly believe that vaccines should be mandatory, and that parents should not have the right to decline vaccines. Some doctors are willing to provide care to unvaccinated kids, despite this difference in philosophy. But now the power over this decision will be put directly into doctors’ hands. He or she can simply refuse to sign the form. Doctors who oppose vaccine freedom of choice have been frustrated for years over this issue. Finally, they will have the power to impose their beliefs on their patients. Patients will be forced to find another doctor to sign the form, submit to vaccines, or get kicked out of public school.
And, of course, there’s the question of liability fears, which leads Dr. Sears to state that he knows for an “absolute fact” that some doctors will not sign the form “out of principle or fears of liability.” How he knows this “for an absolute fact” he doesn’t say. The only part where Dr. Sears makes a modicum of sense is that some doctors might be reluctant to sign the form for a child based on a single visit, particularly when it’s obvious that that’s the only reason the parents brought the child in to be seen and evaluated. That might be so for some doctors, but how many doctors do sports physicals, insurance physicals, physical exams for workers’ compensation, and the like, even though they know that the patient probably won’t come back to see them again? How many physicians in California, for that matter, refuse to sign medical exemption forms for vaccination? Not very many.
If you don’t believe me that Dr. Sears is cribbing from the NVIC playbook, though, read this passage:
Natural and alternative health care providers can NOT sign the form; it must be a “regular” medical professional. Some families only see naturopathic or holistic health care practitioners instead of pediatricians. These families will have a difficult time getting the form signed.
Again, Dr. Sears, you say this as though that were a bad thing. Also note how his language is almost indistinguishable from that of the NVIC. Getting kids whose parents are using quacks for their primary care physicians brought in, even just once, to see a real doctor can only be a good thing. Here’s a hint for Dr. Sears: It’s not a good thing when passages of your blog post look as though they’ve been directly cribbed from an NVIC position statement! If you don’t want to be perceived as antivaccine, then don’t use NVIC arguments in language that could fit right in on the NVIC website without raising a single eyebrow of Fisher’s fans. Besides, there are plenty of antivaccine-sympathetic (or even antivaccine-friendly) doctors like yourself, Dr. Janet Levitan (who, it should be recalled, is perfectly happy to encourage parents to lie about their religious beliefs in order to obtain religious exemptions from vaccination for their children), or Dr. Jay Gordon out there, who will probably be more than happy to sign such forms after having provided a generous portion of misinformed consent to the patient’s parents.
In fact, it wouldn’t surprise me at all if one result of this law would be the creation of a cottage industry of antivaccine-sympathetic pediatricians advertising their willingness to sign philosophical exemption informed consent forms in California with only the most perfunctory of visits. It could be quite the little cash cow. Unfortunately, requiring that parents see a real pediatrician for real informed consent is no guarantee that they will actually get real informed consent based on science, but it makes it more likely. Certainly it’s far more likely that parents will get something resembling informed consent if they go to a real pediatrician than if they go to a chiropractor, naturopath, or homeopath. Moreover, chances are that insurance will pay for most, if not all, of any visit required to obtain a vaccine exemption informed consent form from a physician. It’s largely a win-win situation, although Dr. Sears doesn’t see it that way. In fact, he doesn’t even seem to agree with the purpose of the bill, namely to try to increase vaccination rates:
The sponsors of this bill may have some good intentions, as their primary “public” reason for the bill is to make sure that parents who don’t vaccinate their children are making an informed medical decision under the guidance of their doctor. But it isn’t difficult to see the REAL reason for the bill: to increase vaccination rates in our state by making it more difficult for parents to claim the exemption.
Again, Dr. Sears, you say that as though that were a bad thing. Or, to put it another way, why don’t you think it’s a good thing to try to increase vaccination rates? Certainly that seems to be the implication of your argument, that the real “hidden” reason for AB 2109 (hidden presumably because it’s so nefarious) is to increase vaccination rates and decrease the number of pockets where there are schools in which 50-70% of the children aren’t vaccinated because their parents claimed personal belief exemptions. Except that the reason isn’t exactly hidden; the sponsors and supporters of AB 2109 are quite explicit that the goal is to increase vaccine uptake rates. They’re intentionally trying to make it a little more difficult to get a philosophical exemption approved. Hard core antivaccinationists will take that extra step; those who are more lazy than actually committed to not vaccinating their children will probably not. In any case, the real reason that Barbara Loe Fisher, Dr. Sears, and the rest of the antivaccine movement don’t like AB 2109 is exactly because it makes it a little harder to get a philosophical exemption. More importantly, it will require some parents to take their children to a physician and have a talk about vaccines and maybe—just maybe—get a science-based perspective and something approximating real informed consent. Dr. Sears points out that by the time a parent has made up her mind to get an exemption that talking to a physician about it will probably not change her mind. That’s probably true, but the current state of affairs in California is that it’s so easy to get a philosophical exemption that it’s much easier than actually bothering to get one’s children vaccinated.
Personal belief exemptions from vaccination in the 21st century
A strictly public health standpoint results in the conclusion that non-medical exemptions do nothing other than decrease vaccination rates and degrade herd immunity. Thus, from a strictly scientific standpoint, eliminating all non-medical exemptions to school vaccine mandates would be the most effective means of making sure that children who attend public school are fully vaccinated. Moreover, there is no Constitutional issue involved in doing so, either. We do not, however, live in a world where only scientific considerations prevail. As various SBM bloggers have pointed out on numerous occasions, science-based medicine is based in science, but it is not, strictly speaking, pure science. Science informs and guides what we recommend as treatments, but sometimes other factors play a role. School vaccine mandates, I believe, are just such a situation when other factors cannot be avoided, at least in most states. We must accept that we live in the real world, and in the real world religious and philosophical exemptions to vaccination are not going away.
The reason is that, in the U.S. at least, there is a long history of being wary of government mandates, particularly in health care. Compulsory “anything” laws tend to be very politically unpopular, as has been so thoroughly demonstrated by the political resistance to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (or, as its opponents sneeringly refer to it, Obamacare), for example. Vaccine mandates that go too far politically, as scientifically justified as they may be, have the potential to provoke major backlashes against vaccine programs, as compulsory vaccination laws for all children did in the 1800s in England, Europe, and the U.S. Going too far, even for public health, risks a very real backlash, and even supporters of mass vaccination campaigns (myself included) worry about government overreach and intrusion into personal medical issues. That is probably why only two states do not allow for either religious or philosophical exemptions, and in at least one of those states (West Virginia) there is a movement to allow such exemptions. It is also why it is unlikely that religious and personal belief exemptions will ever be eliminated. We can and should, however, decrease greatly the ease with which such exemptions can be obtained, as California is trying to do through AB 2109.
We can, however, apply a rule to religious and philosophical exemptions by twin approaches. First, vaccination should be free. Parents who cannot afford it or who are uninsured should be eligible for state-funded vaccination. This is true to varying degrees in many states, but it should be universal. Second, I support a general principle described by Douglas S. Diekema, MD, MPH, at the University of Washington, published in a recent issue of the New England Journal of Medicine:
Although eliminating exemptions for religious and personal beliefs may seem logical, such efforts would encounter substantial resistance and probably increase antivaccinationist fervor. Some states might improve immunization rates by addressing the ease of obtaining exemptions and enforcing school-entry requirements. The exemption process should not be easier or less costly than the vaccination process. Obtaining a religious or personal-belief exemption should at least require a visit to the physician’s office, including counseling on the risks posed by remaining unvaccinated; insurance should pay for such visits. States could also require that exemption requests be signed by both parents (if both possess legal decision-making authority). Although such measures wouldn’t change the stance of the most resistant parents, they would eliminate many exemptions sought because of convenience rather than conviction. Finally, lax enforcement of school-entry requirements sends the message that vaccination is merely a bureaucratic requirement, rather than a prerequisite for school attendance and a mechanism for ensuring students’ safety.
One notes that Dr. Diekema’s philosophy is actually not as strict than what was recommended by the Pediatric Infectious Disease Society in 2011. Here is an excerpt from the PIDS position statement regarding personal belief exemption from immunization mandates:
It is recognized that in some states, failure to pass personal belief exemption legislation or regulation could result in public backlash that will erode support for immunization mandates. If legislation or regulation is being considered in this situation, it should contain the following provisions, which are intended to minimize use of exemptions as the “path of least resistance” for children who are behind on immunizations (whereby it would be easier to obtain an exemption than to catch-up the child’s immunizations):
    • The personal belief against immunization must be sincere and firmly held.
    • Before a child is granted an exemption, the parents or guardians must receive state-approved counseling that delineates the personal and public health importance of immunization, the scientific basis for safety of vaccines, and the consequences of exemption for their child as well as other children in the community who are vulnerable to disease and cannot otherwise be protected.
    • Before a child is granted an exemption, the parents or guardians must sign a statement that delineates the basis, strength, and duration of their belief; their understanding of the risks that refusal to immunize has on their child’s health and the health of others (including the potential for serious illness or death); and their acknowledgement that they are making the decision not to vaccinate on behalf of their child.
    • Parents and guardians who claim exemptions should be required to revisit the decision annually with a state-approved counselor and should be required to sign a statement each year to renew the exemption.
    • Children should be barred from school attendance and other group activities if there is an outbreak of a disease that is preventable by a vaccination from which they have been exempted. Parents and guardians who claim exemptions for their children should acknowledge in writing their understanding that this will occur.
The decision not to vaccinate one’s children is every bit as much a medical decision as the decision to vaccinated, and it needs to be made with adequate informed consent. Moreover, although any competent adult has the right to choose or decline any treatment he chooses, society has an interest in protecting children. Contrary to what some seem to believe, parents do not have an unrestricted right to decide medical treatments for their children, particularly if their decisions are very likely to cause harm compared to alternatives. The least that can be asked of parents refusing vaccination for their children is that they listen to a science-based assessment of the potential consequences of that decision.
The real reason antivaccinationists are so opposed to AB 2109 is because they fear informed consent, As I’ve pointed out on more than one occasion, both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, the antivaccine version of “informed consent,” like the “alternative” medicine version of informed consent, is a parody of real informed consent. It is, as I have characterized it many times before, in reality misinformed consent, in which the risks of vaccination are hugely exaggerated while the benefits downplayed to the point that any rational person, if she accepted such “risk-benefit” analyses at face value would decide not to vaccinate her child. Unfortunately, the average person doesn’t have the background knowledge and understanding to see through the misinformation at the heart of misinformed consent. They have a hard time knowing that the claims of people like Barbara Loe Fisher that vaccines cause autism, neurodevelopmental disorders, autoimmune diseases, and so many other ills that they attribute to vaccines are without a basis in science, epidemiology, or clinical evidence. A pediatrician can help them do that by providing them with genuine informed, rather than misinformed, consent.
And that’s exactly what the antivaccine movement fears.

Battles over non-medical exemptions to vaccination festering in state legislatures
Bills to eliminate, as well as to add, non-medical exemptions to school vaccination requirements are pending in state legislatures. Some bills make harder to claim an exemption. Others discourage vaccination by requiring “misinformed consent” and weakening public health officials’ ability to act.
Jann Bellamy on February 2, 2017
Link

Bills to eliminate non-medical exemptions to school vaccination requirements are pending in state legislatures. Bills to add non-medical exemptions are pending as well. Some bills make it harder to claim an exemption. Others discourage vaccination by requiring “misinformed consent.” Still others try to weaken the authority of public health officials to combat vaccine-preventable diseases. Today, we look at a number of bills currently before the state legislatures and how they might affect immunization of school children.
All states require students to have been vaccinated against certain diseases to attend school and all states allow medical exemptions to vaccination. Unfortunately, every state except three allows religious or personal belief exemptions, even though neither is constitutionally required. While West Virginia and Mississippi have allowed only medical exemptions for some time, California repealed its non-medical exemptions less than two years ago, over the strenuous objections of anti-vaccination groups.
Mississippi would have been eliminated from that list in 2017 had one of two bills passed. House Bill 1439 established a conscientious belief exemption to vaccination and House Bill 1457 recognized both religious and philosophical exemptions. Fortunately, both bills died in committee this week.
Senate Bill 52 and Assembly Bill 1810 would make New York the fourth state by repealing the religious exemption, leaving only medical exemptions. However, just across the border, a New Jersey bill would allow parents to exempt a child “for any reason,” effectively making the state’s existing religious exemption unnecessary. A Rhode Island bill would reinstate the personal belief exemption there.
Oklahoma allows parents to exempt a child merely by signing a statement “objecting to the immunization of the child.” Sen. Ervin Yen, a cardiac anesthesiologist, has introduced a bill eliminating this broad exemption, leaving only medical exemptions valid. A bill filed in Arkansas to do away with religious and philosophical exemptions was, unfortunately, withdrawn by its author.
In Iowa, a bill would add an exemption for children of parents who oppose immunization due to “personal conviction.” A Hawaii bill would add to the state’s religious exemption by permitting a philosophical exemption because, as the bill’s preamble says,
the legislature also finds that individuals may object to vaccines due to philosophical objections, which include concerned parents who want to wait until their child’s immune system is more functional.
They got one thing right. Waiting “until their child’s immune system is more functional” is certainly based on philosophy, not science.
If you find this sort of legislative “alternative facts” depressing, you will be cheered by a bill in Pennsylvania that relies on real facts. While retaining the religious exemption, the bill eliminates those based on “strong moral or ethical convictions.” The bill’s sponsor explains that the state has the second lowest vaccination rate in the country, but doing away with the philosophical exemption would reduce the number of non-medical exemptions by more than half.
Short of actually getting rid of non-medical exemptions, pending state legislation would make it more trouble to claim one, which can be an effective strategy in increasing vaccination rates.
Minnesota law allows parents to exempt their children from school immunization requirements based on “conscientiously held beliefs” by simply signing a notarized statement. Companion bills (House File 96 and Senate File 143) would require parents to specify which vaccines they want to exempt and to say why the exemption is sought. (It would be interesting to see if of the reasons had any basis in fact.) They would also need a statement from a physician verifying that he or she reviewed the risks and benefits of vaccines and would have to acknowledge that their child could be excluded from school during an outbreak.
Religious exemptions are currently allowed in New York, but there is no established protocol for claiming them. To remedy this, a bill directs the Commissioners of Health and Education to work together on rules for this and hopefully introduce some stringency in the matter.
Two bills have been filed in Texas to ensure parents realize the risks of not vaccinating their children. Texas permits “conscience” exemptions, “conscience” being defined as “including a religious belief.” Per House Bill 241, sponsored by a legislator who is an RN, to take advantage of the conscience belief, a parent would have to submit a form from a health care practitioner stating that the practitioner has provided the parent with “information on the risks and benefits of immunization.” As an alternative, under House Bill 126, a parent would have to complete an internet-based “immunization education module” that presents “evidence based information” consistent with that provided by the CDC. The state could charge a fee for developing and maintaining the module.
Similarly, in Connecticut, if House Bill 6971 passes, parents would be required to attend a science-based educational session regarding the efficacy and safety of vaccines if they sought a religious exemption from immunization for their children.
An Iowa bill takes a different tack by requiring some back up before a religious exemption can be claimed. Iowa law allows religious exemptions only when immunizations conflict with the tenets and practices of a “recognized religious denomination.” The bill adds a requirement that the religious leader of a local congregation where the exemption applicant is a member in good standing sign the application and state that the immunizations actually do conflict with the religion’s tenets and practices.
Undermining student immunization
On the other hand, a number of bills seek to undermine school immunization requirements. One way to do this is to prevent public health officials from questioning medical exemptions, no matter how dubious their provenance or rationale. In Mississippi, current law permits a local health official to refuse a medical exemption if, in his or her opinion, it would cause undue risk to the community. House Bill 1456 would have prevented further inquiry, making the physician’s decision absolute. (The bill died in committee.) As a public health official explained when a similar bill failed last year, the state feared that out-of-state physicians were sending in exemptions for children under dubious circumstances. Assembly Bill 1810, pending in New York, provides that a medical exemption signed by a physician, nurse practitioner or physician’s assistant “shall prevail,” eliminating questions from local authorities.
Another way to undermine public health officials is to take away their authority to determine vaccination requirements. In New Hampshire, the commissioner of health can issue regulations regarding vaccination against diseases other than those specified by the legislature. House Bill 361 eliminates this provision, leaving immunization requirements within the sole discretion of the legislature. (As regular readers of SBM are aware, I tend to take a dim view of the scientific literacy of the average state legislator.) House Bill 362 prevents the legislature itself from establishing school immunization requirements for diseases that are “noncommunicable in a child care or school setting” including hepatitis B. Likewise, Rhode Island Senate Bill 47 prevents the department of health from setting vaccination standards for diseases that aren’t transmitted “in the school environment” and requires the department to hold public hearings before making any further changes in the vaccination schedule.
Imposing onerous “misinformed consent” requirements on health care providers can discourage vaccination. In Oklahoma, the “Parental Rights Vaccine Act” bill (companion Senate Bill here) requires informed consent prior to vaccination, which is defined, as a minimum, as giving parents a Vaccine Information Statement and “information concerning” the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. Each of these requirements is superfluous because, as with any medical procedure, informed consent is already required before vaccination, federal law already requires that health care practitioners give patients a VIS on each vaccine prior to administration and each VIS already includes information on the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (see, e.g., this meningitis VIS).
There is one particularly troubling addition to this “minimum” requirement for informed consent. The practitioner must make “available for review” the CDC’s Epidemiology and Prevention of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases: Vaccine Excipient and Media Summary. Epidemiology and Prevention of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases (known as the “pink book”) is a 512-page reference work on all things vaccine for health care practitioners. The “Vaccine Excipient and Media Summary” is one subpart of an appendix to the “pink book.” It is a chart of the ingredients in each vaccine. Not an explanation of why they are necessary, not a risk-benefit determination, not an indication of how much of each is actually in the vaccine. Just those scary-sounding chemical names, like “aluminum hydroxide” and “formaldehyde,” one after another.
It’s not hard to see where this is going. Taking vaccine ingredients out of context and misrepresenting them as harmful is a favorite tactic of the anti-vaccination crowd. So is overemphasizing risk.
Misinformed consent bills have also been filed in Texas and Oregon. In Texas (where one of the sponsors is a veterinarian, who should know better), in addition to providing risks and benefits and a copy of the VIS, the practitioner must tell parents about procedures available under the National Vaccine Injury Act to seek:
possible recovery for unreimbursed expenses for certain injuries arising out of the administration of certain vaccines.
Practitioners must also provide a copy of the Vaccine Excipient and Media Summary to parents. Oregon Senate Bill 579 goes even further. The entire 512-page “pink book” must be made available for review, as well as notice of how to file a petition for a claim under the National Vaccine Injury Act. Anything to overwhelm parents with information most of them are not competent to interpret and to undermine confidence in vaccination by emphasizing the possibility of adverse reactions, however remote.
Finally, some physicians have decided not to see unvaccinated patients, a decision that recently received some support from the American Academy of Pediatrics. Texas House Bill 1070 would take away their right to make that decision, no matter what the circumstances, by prohibiting health care practitioners from refusing to provide services to a patient if he or she is unvaccinated for a particular disease. Penalties include withholding payments from public health insurance programs.
Well-funded anti-vaxx lobbyists
The anti-vaccination lobby is up and running, opposing any bill that eliminates exemptions, makes them harder to get or adds new vaccination requirements. They even oppose collecting more vaccination statistics, a position that belies their claims they are concerned only about vaccine safety.
I first learned about some of these bills in an email from the Alliance for Natural Health, an organization supported by the dietary supplement industry and physicians who eschew evidence-based medicine.
From there, I went to the National Vaccine (Mis)Information Center’s “Advocacy Portal,” an obviously well-funded effort that lists several dozen bills and facilitates lobbying by the NVIC’s flying monkeys. In fact, as far as I know, this is the only comprehensive list of vaccination bills publicly available anywhere, a sad commentary on the lack of resources for the science-minded. If we were really in the pocket of Big Pharma, it should have bought us a nice “advocacy portal” like the NVIC’s, where we could take the opposite position on these bills and have a fancy internet-based system for lobbying. Sadly, that’s not the case. Until we have resources to match groups like the NVIC and Alliance for Natural Health, please use your own resources to contact state legislators to let them know what you think about these bills.

Anti-vaxxers try to kill Florida bill ending childhood vaccination religious exemption
Anti-vaxxers and their misinformation campaign may have killed Senate Bill 64, repealing Florida’s religious exemption to childhood immunizations, which is being abused by parents. Sen. Laura Book, the bill’s sponsor, remains undeterred, citing the high risk of disease outbreaks in Florida.
Jann Bellamy on December 5, 2019
Link

Sen. Lauren Book (D-Plantation) has filed a bill (SB 64) for consideration by the 2020 Florida Legislature which includes elimination of the state’s religious exemption to K-12 school-entry immunization requirements. That portion of the bill, the focus of this post, would make Florida the sixth state (along with Mississippi, West Virginia, California, New York, and Maine) to allow only medical exemptions. In 2019, legislators in seven states introduced bills to remove religious or personal belief exemptions but were successful in only two: New York and Maine. SB 64 also eliminates the religious exemption to school health exam requirements and directs the Florida Boards of Medicine and Osteopathic Medicine to create a panel to review all medical exemptions to school vaccinations.
Sen. Book filed the bill after a Tampa Bay Times report that religious exemptions in Florida have risen from about 6,500 in 2011 to about 25,000 in 2018, a 375% increase in less than a decade. Sen. Book is concerned, according to her spokesperson, for public health and tourism (the state’s top industry), as well as the fiscal impact of measles outbreaks like those experienced in New York and California. According to the Florida Department of Health, 25 of the state’s 67 counties failed to meet the Department’s goal of 95% vaccination among kindergarten students in 2018. Almost 3% of kindergartners received a religious exemption, an all-time high. Stats improve at the seventh grade mark, with 61 counties meeting or topping the 95% goal. Medical exemptions have remained stable.University of Florida medical ethicist Bill Allen told the Tampa Bay Times that the religious exemption is not being used for its intended purpose and is being abused.
‘If parents don’t want to vaccinate because they think vaccines cause Autism, they’ll claim a religious exemption,’ he said.
University of South Florida Health assistant professor Jill Roberts added that parents are claiming the exemptions after being persuaded by sophisticated online anti-vaccination misinformation groups. According to the report,
Those groups, with official-sounding names like the National Vaccine Information Center, propagate conspiracies like the debunked link between vaccinations and autism.
It is gratifying to see the media call out the NVIC for what it is.
The personal finances website WalletHub recently attempted to quantify how good the states are at vaccination by examining the 50 states and D.C. “across 18 key categories” ranging “from share of vaccinated children to share of people without health insurance to presence of reported measles outbreaks.” Florida came in 49th overall, hitting near rock bottom on several metrics:
    • Lowest influenza vaccination rate in children aged 6 months to 17 years old: ranked 50th
    • Lowest share of adults with tetanus vaccination: 49th
    • Lowest share of adults aged 60 and over with zoster vaccination: 47th (tied with Tennessee)
    • Highest share of civilian non-institutionalized population without health insurance coverage: 48th (tied with Oklahoma)
WalletHub’s stats on the benefits of vaccination are worth repeating here:
The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that vaccines prevented at least 10 million deaths worldwide just between the years of 2010 and 2015. A similar study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found vaccines prevented 732,000 deaths in the U.S. between 1994 and 2013, as well as eliminated $1.38 trillion in total societal costs that those diseases would have caused. Vaccines are also very safe, and according to the WHO, ‘so few deaths can plausibly be attributed to vaccines that it is hard to assess the risk statistically.’
It is very, very easy to get a religious exemption in Florida and Kehoe Family Chiropractic of New Port Richey, Florida, is happy to tell you how. Their surprisingly comprehensive guide covers not only religious exemptions to vaccinations required for K-12 students but also how to take your children out of the state’s immunization registry. As well, it advises parents on how to get out of vaccinating their children in day care, college students on how to get out of recommended vaccinations for meningococcal meningitis and hepatitis B and required measles and rubella vaccinations, employees on how to get out of employer-required vaccinations (including the hepatitis B vaccine for those handling blood-borne pathogens), and everyone on how to avoid vaccination during public health emergencies. They perform this valuable service because, in their view, “all vaccines are made in violation of God’s word” even though vaccination is outside the chiropractic scope of practice in Florida and chiropractors are, in fact, prohibited from treating several vaccine-preventable infectious diseases (including hepatitis) by state law. The good chiropractors at Kehoe, in the tradition of anti-vaccination chiropractors everywhere, are perfectly willing to spout anti-vaxx talking points widely discredited by medical authorities as part of their advice, while at the same time telling parents that their infants and children should be checked for phantom subluxations and falsely claiming these can have a deleterious effect on their children’s health. They also regularly take full-spine X-rays of their patients to detect these non-existent subluxations and sell dietary supplements. But heaven forbid that your children be subjected to an immunization that, with an infinitesimally low risk of harm, can save their lives.
In any event, to claim a religious exemption to the K-12 public or private school vaccination requirements, all the parent or guardian must do is fill out the Department of Health’s Religious Exemption from Immunization Form (DH 681 Form), issued by county health departments for
a child who is not immunized because of his/her family’s religious tenets or practices. . . This form must be issued upon request. No other information should be solicited from the parent or guardian.
The form simply states that
I am the parent or legal guardian of the above-named child. Immunizations are in conflict with my religious tenets or practices. Therefore, I request that my child be enrolled in school [or other facility, such as day care] without immunizations required [by state law].
Only the child’s name, date of birth, and the parent or guardian’s name are required. The form is kept on file by the school (or other facility) so that unimmunized children can be identified and excluded from school during the outbreak of a vaccine-preventable disease, as is authorized by state law.
While there is no First Amendment right to refuse vaccination for one’s child based on religious belief, the state of Florida has nevertheless granted one by statute, and one Florida appellate court (although not the Florida Supreme Court) ruled, in 1998, that the law does not give the state any authority to inquire into a parent’s religious belief:
The issue which we are called upon to decide implicates two very important social policies-the desire to protect the public health and welfare and the desire to protect a parent’s fundamental right to raise his or her child according to the religious tenets that he or she chooses.   After considerable reflection, we conclude that the legislature intended that when, as here, the two policies collide, greater protection be afforded to the latter by prohibiting any inquiry by the Department into the bona fides of the parent’s or guardian’s objection.
Thus, although Florida does not recognize a philosophical exemption to vaccination, the religious exemption has essentially become one. This is fortunate for parents wanting to claim bogus religious objections, as none of the major world religions forbid vaccination and further inquiry might reveal their mendacity.
On the other hand, it puts parents who object to only some vaccinations in a bit of a bind. Because the religious exemption is a blanket one, parents claiming the exemption can appear insincere in their “religious” objections if they allow some, but not other, vaccinations although, again, further inquiry would be prohibited, at least by the state. And, if there were an outbreak, the exemption on file would presumably allow exclusion from school, even if the child had, in fact, been immunized against the disease causing the outbreak, at least until the parent could provide proof of immunization, with the attendant appearance of duplicity that would involve.
Interestingly, although the religious exemption applies to both public and private schools, the same appellate court, in 2017, citing the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, refused to intervene in a dispute between a parent claiming the religious exemption for his child and the Catholic Diocese of St. Augustine, Florida, which required immunization for all students enrolled in its schools. Somewhat ironically, this means that schools run by religious organizations can ignore the religious exemption, at least in this appellate court’s jurisdiction.
The anti-vaccination crowd strikes
For her concerns about the health of Florida’s children, Sen. Book has been viciously attacked on social media, including a posting on her Facebook page of a doctored photo showing Sen. Book, who is Jewish, with a Hitler mustache and wearing a Nazi uniform. Of course, she is also accused of being in Big Pharma’s pocket.
Unsurprisingly, the anti-vaccine crowd has come out in force, attending local events with legislators to oppose the bill even when it wasn’t on the agenda. According to one media report,
Anti-vaccine groups Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense, the National Vaccine Information Center, Florida Health Action Network and the Florida Freedom Alliance orchestrated social media opposition and spurred large anti-vaccination turn-outs at public discussions on the bill in Broward, Manatee and Escambia counties.
Again, I’m pleased to see that these were correctly identified as “anti-vaccine groups”.
There’s even a website devoted exclusively to opposing SB 64, although it appears the site’s creators don’t want the public to know who’s responsible for its content, as they’ve chosen Domains by Proxy to register the website. There is no information on the website about its owners, authors, or funding sources. An educated guess points to two anti-vaccine organizations for funding: The World Mercury Project, headed by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., and Stop Mandatory Vaccination. According to an investigation recently published in the journal Vaccine and reported in the Washington Post:
The majority of Facebook advertisements spreading misinformation about vaccines were funded by two anti-vaccine groups, including one led by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., according to a study published this week.
The World Mercury Project, headed by Kennedy, and a California-based organization called Stop Mandatory Vaccination bought 54 percent of the anti-vaccine ads on Facebook, the study found.
Researchers said the results surprised them. Much of the anti-vaccine content posted on social media platforms such as Facebook and Twitter may appear to be organic, grass-roots discussions led by neighborhood groups and concerned parents, said David A. Broniatowski, an associate professor at George Washington University and one of the authors of the study.
‘In fact,’ said Broniatowski, who studies group decision-making, ‘what we are seeing is a small number of motivated interests that are trying to disseminate a lot of harmful content.’ The small group of anti-vaccine ad buyers successfully used the ads to reach targeted audiences.
I won’t attempt to catalog, or refute, the firehose of misinformation being spread by the anti-vaccination cabal in opposing SB 64. (The lies and half-truths of the anti-vaccinationists have been covered many times on this blog, as well as by our good friend Orac and by others.) Unfortunately, their campaign has been somewhat successful. According to a spokesperson for Senate Health Policy Chair Sen. Gayle Harris (R-Stuart), the bill won’t get a committee hearing “in its current format”, but that does not exclude an amended bill or a newly submitted proposal. Another obstacle is that no companion bill has yet been filed in the House of Representatives, as is required by Florida law. (The deadline for filing a bill is Jan. 14, 2020.) And, as one news reporter pointed out, the Republican-led Legislature has an easy out by simply categorizing SB 64 “as a blow to religious freedom and parental choice, potentially dooming it even without the organized campaign that has been mounted in opposition”.
Sen. Book remains undeterred:
it’s worthwhile, substantive legislation and I will not be withdrawing it. . . We need to be discussing this issue . . . Researchers warn Miami-Dade is in the top three most vulnerable to an outbreak like those in New York and California – and Broward [Ft. Lauderdale] and Hillsborough [Tampa area] (counties) are in the top 15 most vulnerable.
I admire Sen. Book for her willingness to stand up to the well-financed, vicious, misinformation-spreading, public-health-menacing anti-vaccine lobby. Even if SB 64 fails, she has succeeded in making at least some legislators go on record as being against the bill and therefore holding them responsible when the anticipated outbreaks of disease occur.

The war in California over nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates
California is about to pass a law that would eliminate personal belief exemptions to school vaccine requirements. The antivaccine movement is losing its collective mind over it. Let’s just say that Holocaust analogies are flying fast and furious.
David Gorski on June 15, 2015
Link
As I write this, I am currently at the Center for Inquiry (CFI) Reason for Change conference, where on Friday Steve, Harriet, and I did a panel on—what else?—alternative medicine and how it’s become “integrative medicine.” As a result, I’ve been very busy, which means that parts (but by no means all) of this post will look familiar to those of you who follow me at my not-so-super-secret other blog. However, it occurred to me after we did our panel discussion that there are important things happening in California that we’ve only barely touched on here on this blog. I’m referring, of course, to a bill (SB 277) that’s wending its way through the California legislature. SB 277, if passed, would eliminate nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates. That’s not to say we haven’t discussed the issue of nonmedical exemptions, of which there are two types: religious and personal belief exemptions (PBEs), which can all be simply described as PBEs. Both Steve Novella and I have addressed them on SBM. For example, when an earlier bill (AB 2109) was passed that mandated that parents seeking PBEs consult with a physician or other listed health care professionals (which, unfortunately, included naturopaths) before a PBE would be granted, I documented how the antivaccine movement strenuously objected even to this minor tweak in the law that would make PBEs slightly more difficult to obtain. Unfortunately, even though, against all expectations, the bill passed, Governor Jerry Brown sabotaged it with a signing statement that betrayed California children by reinstating, in essence, religious exemptions. Specifically, Gov. Brown ordered the California Department of Public Health to include a check box on the form that parents could check to say they have religious objections to vaccines. Parents who checked that box could thus bypass even the anemic requirement to consult with a pediatrician before being granted a PBE.
The problem with nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates is that vaccine-averse and antivaccine parents tend to cluster mostly in areas where white, affluent people live, as demonstrated in California and my own state of Michigan. So, even though antivaccinationists frequently tout high statewide vaccination rates as evidence that the process for obtaining PBEs does not need to be tightened up, they are disingenuously using a straw man argument against vaccine mandates, because it’s the pockets of low vaccine uptake that compromise local herd immunity that are the problem. We see these in Oregon, California, Michigan, and many other states with PBEs, and we also know that ease of obtaining PBEs is correlated with more PBEs and more outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases.
All of this came to a head earlier this year with what is now known as the Disneyland measles outbreak, a large multistate outbreak originating at Disneyland and traced to unvaccinated children. This outbreak so shocked California that the unthinkable happened. The possibility of passing a law eliminating nonmedical exemptions to vaccine mandates, something virtually everyone would have considered as much a fantasy as many of the characters played by the recently deceased great Christopher Lee played during his career, suddenly became an attainable goal. Senators Richard Pan and Ben Allen introduced SB 277, which would eliminate the personal belief exemption for children attending state licensed schools, daycares, and nurseries in California.
The antivaccine movement strikes back
Given how vociferously and relentlessly the antivaccine contingent opposed AB 2109, it’s not surprising that SB 277 has resulted in a major pushback. Indeed, it was the anticipation of the resistance to the bill that led me to be rather pessimistic at first about its chances of becoming law. But then SB 277 passed the California State Senate three weeks ago, and the usual suspects just about lost it, with Barbara Loe Fisher likening it to medical blackmail and invoking Elie Wiesel, just in case you don’t get the message that she thinks we’re dealing with Nazi-like fascism. Along the way, antivaccine celebrities like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. (who is also fond of Holocaust analogies) and Rob Schneider were trotted out with the same old pseudoscience and “health freedom” arguments, although RFK, Jr. might have done more harm to his cause than good when he explicitly likened the vaccine program to the Holocaust and was forced to apologize, although it was a classic “notpology”:
“I want to apologize to all whom I offended by my use of the word holocaust to describe the autism epidemic,” Kennedy said in a statement. “I employed the term during an impromptu speech as I struggled to find an expression to convey the catastrophic tragedy of autism which has now destroyed the lives of over 20 million children and shattered their families.”
In other words, the “vaccine-induced autism epidemic” is as bad as the Holocaust, but I won’t use the word anymore because it offends people who know what a real Holocaust is. Of course, this is not the first time RFK, Jr. has used Holocaust analogies with respect to vaccines. He did it two years ago and, for all I know, has been using such offensive analogies for much longer. Unfortunately, RFK, Jr.’s not the only one who likes Holocaust analogies. For example, Heather Barajas caught some justified flak for photographing herself and her child wearing badges shaped like a syringe juxtaposed with photos of Jews in Nazi Germany forced to wear yellow Stars of David:

Yes, because under SB 277 nonvaccinating parents will be treated exactly like Jews during the Holocaust. And she was surprised that the uproar was so great that she was forced to take it down!
Unfortunately, not all opponents to SB 277 are quite so…unrestrained. (Co-opting the Holocaust, the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, and other horrors generally reveals them to be fringe cranks.) The more “mainstream” antivaccine movement has learned to leverage social media. I remember back in 2005, before SBM was even an action potential in one of Steve Novella’s neurons, I did pay attention to the antivaccine movement, but initially it wasn’t one of my highest priorities when it comes to promoting science-based medicine. That all changed when Robert F. Kennedy published his incredibly conspiracy-packed black whole of antivaccine pseudoscience entitled “Deadly Immunity“. Sadly, almost exactly ten years later, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. hasn’t changed. He’s still spewing the same nonsense with no sign of letting up. In contrast, the social media landscape has changed quite a bit. Back when I first started blogging, pretty much all that was available were websites and blogs. On the antivaccine side, there were pretty much websites, most of them not particularly well-designed or attractive, and some of the “big name” blogs that served as amplifiers of the antivaccine message, such as Age of Autism, didn’t even exist yet. Jenny McCarthy was still into “Indigo Child” woo and had not become an antivaccine celebrity. Overall, the antivaccine movement wasn’t particularly good at leveraging these tools.
Over the years, different forms of social media proliferated. There came Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, Tumblr, and who knows what else. Yet, for a while, the antivaccine movement was fairly slow to adopt these new tools. Truth be told, so were skeptics, but that is changing. In fact, arguably, last year was the year the antivaccine movement discovered Twitter. I noted it myself when I was fairly dismissive of the inept attempts of antivaccinationists to use Twitter to capitalize on the “CDC whistleblower” scandal, that fake scandal based on a hapless CDC psychologist flirting with antivaccinationists and misinterpretation of a major study that failed to find a link between the MMR vaccine and autism.
Unfortunately, since their first attempts at using Twitter to get the attention of news reporters and legislators, antivaccinationists have turned their attention to defeating California SB 277. In addition to the offensive Holocaust imagery that backfires on them, they’ve started to successfully co-opt the language of “health freedom” to portray their opposition as an issue of “personal choice,” “parental rights,” and other antivaccine dogwhistles that resonate with conservative and libertarian politics, including a subset of the white, affluent parents who make up the bulk of the antivaccine movement.
It turns out that I’m not the only one who’s noticed these changes, either. Just last week, an excellent article by Renee Diresta and Gilad Lotan appeared on Wired entitled “Anti-Vaxxers Are Using Twitter to Manipulate a Vaccine Bill“:
But a small group of vocal anti-vaxxers is fighting hard to keep it from passing. This group, which leverages the power of social media, has launched a full-scale attack on the bill as it travels through the legislature. Each day, leaders craft tweets and instruct followers to disseminate them. Several senators who voted in favor of the California legislation have found themselves receiving extensive attention from the group—one, Senator Hannah Beth Jackson, has been @-mentioned (often unfavorably) in a particular Twitter hashtag more than 2,000 times since casting her vote in favor of the legislation.
This anti-vax activity might seem like low-stakes, juvenile propaganda. But social networking has the potential to significantly impact public perception of events—and the power to influence opinions increasingly lies with those who can most widely and effectively disseminate a message. One small, vocal group can have a disproportionate impact on public sentiment and legislation. Welcome to “Anti-Vax Twitter.”
So far, you might ask yourself: So what? How is this different from any other interest group trying to harness the power of social media to get its message heard? To some extent, it’s not, but one thing Diresta and Lotan note as distinguishing this effort from those of other interest groups is just how much Twitter is used to attack and bully legislators who voted for the bill and prominent supporters of the bill. Antivaccine activists are particularly ruthless about going after these people:
“Tweetiatrician” doctors, lawyers, and pro-vaccine parents often do attempt to join the conversation around the antivax hashtags. Unfortunately, many of the most active accounts experience the same attention received by the legislators: They become the target of harassment that includes phone calls to their places of employment, tweets posting identifying information or photos of their children, or warnings that they are being watched. Pro-vaccine activists and legislators alike often encounter paranoia when they attempt to engage the anti-vax community. They face accusations of being shills paid by Big Pharma to sway the narrative and keep “vaccine choice” activists from spreading The Truth.
Yes, this is typical behavior for the antivaccine movement, and I’ve been at its receiving end more than I can recall, beginning within a year after I started blogging. The most “spectacular”—if you can call it that—example occurred a few years ago, when our old buddy Jake Crosby wrote a post accusing me of a major undisclosed conflict of interest, resulting in a campaign on the part of antivaccinationists to contact my Dean, my department chair, and the board of governors of my university demanding an investigation and my firing. Fortunately, I work for a university, and the tradition of academic freedom at universities is such that such campaigns almost always fail, with the administration politely listening and then ignoring the cranks. At a private company, I might not have been so lucky. I might have been fired, or the company might have ordered me to stop blogging, and there would have been little or nothing I could do about it. This is how antivaccinationists silence their critics.
So far, so good. Diresta and Lotan’s article rings true, but it doesn’t tell those of us who try to counter the antivaccine movement anything we haven’t already known for a long time. What Diresta and Lotan did that was interesting (to me, at least) was to look at how the hashtags associated with Tweets in opposition to SB 277 were clustered. Basically, they analyzed hashtags used by people in Twitter, generating images in which circular nodes are Twitter handles and large nodes indicate accounts with more followers, making their Tweets more likely to be seen (“high centrality”). Lines between the nodes represent follower relationships, and different colors represent communities sharing similar messages, with the distance between regions based on common ties: The more common ties, the closer one group is to another, the more shared connections they have, and the more likely information is to spread among them.
First, Diresta and Lotan note the “Twitter party” that I made fun of back in August, particularly the instructions given by more “experienced” antivaccine Twitter users to all the newbies they were trying to recruit. In the end, Lotan and Diresta found one thing that I thought to be true without quantifying last year: Large numbers of these Tweets came from a few accounts. Indeed, 63,555 of these Tweets came from 10 prominent anti-vax accounts, such as @tannersdad and @ThinkerMichelle (yes, one of the “not-so-Thinking Moms’ Revolution“).
The second thing Diresta and Lotan did was to analyze these clusters with reference to the #SB277 hashtag to look at trends over time, specifically at how the antivaccine Twitter community, the autism Twitter community, and conservatives, many of whom use popular Tea Party hashtags, interact. Remember how I’ve discussed how antivaccinationists have of late been aligning themselves with more conservative talking points? Well, take a look at these results.
In the first graph, the conservative Twittersphere is pretty separate from the antivaccine Twittersphere, which has some overlap with the autism Twittersphere. At that intersection are some names you’re probably familiar with, such as @AgeofAutism, @The_Refusers, @TannersDad, and others. But the second network graph for SB277:
But as you look at this second network graph, you can see how antivax political strategy has shifted. A new group emerges in the space between “Antivax Twitter” and “Conservative Twitter”—we call it “vaccine choice” Twitter. The tweeters are the same individuals who have long been active in the autism-vaccine #cdcwhistleblower network. And originally, much of the content shared in #sb277 focused on the same anti-vax pseudoscience underlying #cdcwhistleblower. However, as bad science and conspiracies repeatedly lost in legislative votes, anti-vaxxers updated their marketing: They are now “pro-SAFE vaccine” parental rights advocates. Instructions to the group now focus on hammering home traditionally conservative “parental choice” and “health freedom” messaging rather than tweeting about autism and toxins.
Twitter activity around #sb277 is part of a multipronged strategy that takes place alongside phone, email, and fax campaigns, coordinated by well-funded groups including the Canary Party and the NVIC. The net effect is that legislators and staffers feel besieged on all fronts. In one unfortunate video, a movement leader encouraged supporters to use Twitter to harass and stalk a lobbyist, who has since filed police reports. In a very recent creation, that same leader excoriates her “Twitter army” for diluting the power of the #cdcwhistleblower movement by creating their own hashtags rather than using the ones they’ve been assigned. She also requests that the entire network tweet at Assembly representatives to inform them that their political careers will be over if they vote in favor of SB277. Much like Food Babe leverages her #foodbabearmy to flood corporations with demands for change, the goal of anti-vax twitter is to dominate the conversation and make it look as if all parents are vehemently opposed to the legislation.
It’s amazing how much what Diresta and Lotan have found resembles what I’ve been saying all along in other venues. Specifically, I’ve been pointing out for several months now how the antivaccine movement has been co-opting conservative rhetoric, to the point where some conservative politicians have found it worthwhile to pander to these kooks, as Rand Paul does and, unfortunately, my very own state senator. Yes, antivaccine beliefs are, as I’ve pointed out so many times before, the pseudoscience that transcends politics and party lines, but over the last year or so, the loudest voices in the antivaccine movement appear to be increasingly leaning conservative/libertarian, thanks to its intentional co-optation of “health freedom” rhetoric and messages based on distrust of the government and being against government regulations and mandates with respect to health. It’s a potent message that can appeal not just to conservatives, too.
And who opposes this on Twitter?
That’s the depressing thing. Diresta and Lotan note that, despite the vast majority of the population supporting vaccination, there is no pro-vaccine Twitter machine to speak of to oppose the antivaccine Twitter machine. That’s because most parents just vaccinate. They don’t organize into groups around the activity, or, as Diresta and Lotan put it, people “don’t organize in groups around everyday life-saving measures,” which is why there is no pro-seatbelt movement on Twitter. Worse, the goal of the antivaccine movement on social media like Twitter, its disingenuous claim to be “not antivaccine but ‘pro-safe vaccine'” notwithstanding, is to make new parents question everything about vaccines and erode confidence in vaccination.
SB 277 powers on
So as of last week, SB 277 had passed the California Senate, which still left the Assembly and the Governor as the two remaining hurdles. In the Assembly, there were two hurdles, first the Assembly Health Committee, after which the bill would go to the full Assembly for debate and a vote. Shockingly (in a good way), last week SB 277 cleared the Assembly Health Committee, and it wasn’t even a close vote:
California lawmakers on Tuesday approved a hotly contested bill that would impose one of the strictest vaccination laws in the country, after five hours of highly emotional testimony that brought hundreds of opponents to the Capitol.
SB277 is intended to boost vaccination rates after a measles outbreak at Disneyland that sickened more than 100 in the U.S. and Mexico. It has prompted the most contentious legislative debate of the year with thousands of opponents taking to social media and legislative hearings to protest the legislation.
The Assembly Health Committee approved the legislation 12-6 Tuesday evening with one lawmaker abstaining, sending it to the full Assembly for its final legislative hurdle.
If the bill becomes law, California would join Mississippi and West Virginia as the only states with such strict requirements.
I can’t help but say again that this news amazed me—in a good way. I never thought that a bill that would eliminate religious and philosophic exemptions to school vaccine mandates would get anywhere near this far in a state with high concentrations of antivaccine belief and some of the most famous antivaccine pediatricians out there (e.g., Jay Gordon and Bob Sears, who are antivaccine although they swear otherwise), as well as a large Hollywood contingent of celebrity antivaccinationists like Rob Schneider. Yet now the bill has made it to the full Assembly, after the antivaccine movement failed spectacularly to prevent it from passing its major committee hurdle. I and other observers had been concerned that the vote would be close and that SB 277 might die in committee, but the Assembly Health Committee provided the antivaccinationists a resounding rebuke. This occurred despite their bringing in protesters, as well as antivaccine luminaries like Dr. Jay Gordon, who tried to argue that because the Disneyland measles outbreak didn’t occur in a school and SB 277 wouldn’t have prevented it then it’s not necessary, which is akin to arguing there’s no need to enforce a fire code at a warehouse because the last fire leveled a barn. Not surprisingly, Barbara Loe Fisher testified as well. It also probably didn’t help the antivaccine cause that in the lead up to the committee hearing the American Medical Association weighed in at its annual meeting as supporting the elimination of nonmedical exemptions, producing stories like this appearing on the morning of the hearing:
The American Medical Association, the country’s largest association of physicians, is weighing in on the vaccination debate by supporting the end of personal vaccination exemptions on both the state and federal levels.
At the group’s annual meeting in Chicago on Monday, members voted to mobilize the organization in order to persuade state legislatures to eliminate nonmedical reasons for exemption, such as religion, which are used to dodge crucial immunizations against diseases such as measles and whooping cough.
“As evident from the recent measles outbreak at Disneyland, protecting community health in today’s mobile society requires that policymakers not permit individuals from opting out of immunization solely as a matter of personal preference or convenience,” said board member Dr. Patrice Harris, according to Forbes. “When people are immunized they also help prevent the spread of disease to others.”
Exactly.
So what’s next? SB 277 will go in front of the full Assembly for debate and final vote. Look for the antivaccine Twittersphere and the antivaccine contingent to crank up the angry and offensive rhetoric to 11, even though arguably in a way they are their own worst enemies when they make threats against legislators and use full-blown conspiracy theories to justify their opposition. Unfortunately, that’s normal behavior in the antivaccine movement. The real question is: Will SB 277 pass? That, I don’t know, but it’s gotten further than I ever would have predicted, and its progress is starting to take on an air of inevitability, to the point where a guest blogger has posted a Resolution in Response to the California Democratic Party (CADEM) “Resolution in Support of Repealing California’s Personal Beliefs Exemption to Mandatory Vaccinations” in which she swears never to vote Democratic again. (In this case, most of the opposition to SB 277 comes from Republicans on the basis of “health freedom” and “parental rights” arguments.)
Meanwhile, as AoA regular Dan Olmsted uses his status as a gay man to draw parallels between how medicine used to view homosexuality and how now (in his view) it ignores “vaccine injury,” another AoA regular, Ginger Taylor, is now declaring that SB 277 is a “victory” for the antivaccine cause because its passage “advances our cause” because will let the antivaccine movement challenge the law in court. Given how previous challenges to various school vaccine mandate laws have generally been decided in the past (hint: not in favor of “vaccine freedom”), all I can say to Ms. Taylor is: “Good luck with that. You’ll need it. A lot of it.”
If SB 277 passes, though, I do worry about some things. Most importantly, I worry that Governor Jerry Brown will once again betray California children and sabotage the new law, as he did when AB 2109 passed, by adding a signing statement instructing the California Department of Public Health to allow a check box for a religious exemption on the form that needed to be signed, thus bypassing the requirement for consulting with a pediatrician or health care provider to learn the benefits and risks of vaccines. There was no provision for doing that in AB 2109, but that didn’t stop Brown from crippling the law. Given his deference to religion, I could easily see him doing that again. I could also see him putting pressure on the legislature not to eliminate religious exemptions, with the implicit threat of a veto if the legislature does not amend the bill. We shall see. It would be an amazing thing indeed if California were to pass SB 277 in its present form. If that were to happen, it might embolden other states to consider similar laws, or at least to make nonmedical exemptions harder to obtain.
We can hope, can’t we?

The war in California over nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates, part 2
California has passed SB 277 into law. Beginning in the 2016-2017 school year, SB 277 will eliminate personal belief exemptions to school vaccine requirements. This will benefit the health of California schoolchildren, but the law is not perfect and already antivaxers are looking for loopholes.
David Gorski on July 6, 2015
Link

Last week, in the run-up to the 4th of July holiday weekend, something happened that I truly never expected to see. SB 277 became law in the state of California when Governor Jerry Brown signed it. In a nutshell, beginning with the 2016-17 school year, the new law eliminates nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates. When last I wrote about SB 277 for this blog three weeks ago, I explained why I thought it was unlikely that SB 277 would ever become law, so that California could join West Virginia and Mississippi as the only states that do not permit religious or personal belief exemptions to school vaccine mandates. Basically, it was because California is not Mississippi or West Virginia. It’s a hotbed of antivaccine activism. Although statewide vaccination rates are high, there are a number of areas where antivaccine and vaccine-averse parents have led to low vaccine uptake with resultant outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. Most recently, a large outbreak centered at Disneyland served as the catalyst that made it politically possible for a bill like SB 277 even to be seriously considered by the California legislature. Even so, given that California is home to a number of antivaccine celebrities such as Rob Schneider, Alicia Silverstone, Bill Maher, Charlie Sheen, Mayim Bialik, and Jim Carrey, antivaccine pediatricians such as “Dr. Jay” Gordon and “Dr. Bob” Sears, and many of the activists at the antivaccine crank blogs Age of Autism and The Thinking Moms’ Revolution, I was not optimistic.
I was mistaken in my pessimism, and I’m happy about that. I’m grateful to all those who didn’t see passing this law as an impossible task, such as Senators Richard Pan and Ben Allen, and who worked tirelessly to see it through, as some of our regular readers did. I was also pleasantly surprised that Governor Jerry Brown didn’t betray California children by watering down the bill with a signing statement, as he did three years ago when an earlier bill (AB 2109) was passed to make it more difficult for parents to obtain personal belief exemptions to school vaccine mandates.
So since SB 277 is law in California, what now?
The backlash
The first issue that will not go away is that antivaccine activists are very, very angry. Already, they are threatening to mount a recall campaign against Sen. Pan, complete with a Recall Pan website. Let’s just put it this way. I don’t get the feeling that this campaign will have much traction. Nor do I think that efforts to overturn the law through a referendum are likely to go very far, particularly if antivaccine activists keep trotting out Andrew Wakefield and Tony Muhammed of the Nation of Islam to speak at their rallies.
Its penchant for publicly featuring discredited scientists and religious cranks aside, the antivaccine movement, although small, is if anything very vocal and quite unafraid to go into full conspiracy mode. For instance, the aforementioned Jim Carrey unleashed a flurry of Tweets after the Governor signed SB 277, calling the law fascist, repeating old antivaccine tropes I like to refer to as the “toxins” and “pharma shill” gambits:
Greed trumps reason again as Gov Brown moves closer to signing vaccine law in Cali. Sorry kids. It’s just business. ;^[
— Jim Carrey (@JimCarrey) June 27, 2015
And then:
California Gov says yes to poisoning more children with mercury and aluminum in manditory vaccines. This corporate fascist must be stopped.
— Jim Carrey (@JimCarrey) July 1, 2015
Next:
They say mercury in fish is dangerous but forcing all of our children to be injected with mercury in thimerosol is no risk. Make sense?
— Jim Carrey (@JimCarrey) July 1, 2015
Plus:
I am not anti-vaccine. I am anti-thimerosal, anti-mercury. They have taken some of the mercury laden thimerosal out of vaccines. NOT ALL!
— Jim Carrey (@JimCarrey) July 1, 2015
Concluding with:
I repeat! I AM PRO-VACCINE/ANTI-NEUROTOXIN, as is Robert Kennedy Jr. Please read the following article and book http://t.co/GTr9lReaXO
— Jim Carrey (@JimCarrey) July 1, 2015
There were others, but you get the idea. As I said at the time, to Carrey, apparently Dumb and Dumber is more than just a movie he made with Jeff Daniels. It’s a way of life. Also, either Jenny McCarthy had a more permanent effect on him than previously thought (I always thought he went antivax because he was in love with her), or he was always antivax, which is part of why McCarthy was attracted to him in the first place. Whatever the case, Carrey got so carried away (so to speak) that in one of his Tweets he posted a photo of an autistic boy named Alex Echols without his mother’s permission to illustrate his point of children being “poisoned.” In response, Alex’s mother complained on Instagram and Twitter thusly:
@JimCarrey Please remove this photo of my son. You do not have permission to use his image.
— Karen Echols (@karen_echols) July 2, 2015
The reason Echols was so unhappy was because her child’s autism was a result of tuberous sclerosis and couldn’t even semi-plausibly be linked to vaccines, as she pointed out on her Instagram account. Carrey ultimately was forced to apologize. Even though Carrey went too far and had to apologize, Reuben over at The Poxes Blog was correct to point out that Carrey’s Twitter meltdown was the perfect microcosm of how the antivaccine movement thinks, if thinking it can be called, by pointing out that “if Jim Carrey is not anti-vaccine, he is just as weird as all the other anti-vaccine cult members who claim to not be anti-vaccine but can’t endorse one single vaccine. Then they run off yelling, ‘Parental choice! Parental choice!'”
Rather like Sandy Fleming, an antivaccine mother who was recently profiled in Los Angeles Magazine:
Why do you oppose SB 277?Because we don’t have a situation or a pandemic that warrants the government forcing parents to make medical decisions. Being able to make decisions between you and your doctor is a right we have had for all of our lives, and it’s so important. Think about being able to decide with your doctor how you’ll be treated for cancer or a simple flu. There’s never been a one-size-fits-all medicine. This bill breaks the parent-doctor conversation. Don’t even bother reading warning labels, you don’t have an option in this case.
This all sounds reasonable on the surface, but I can’t help but note when reading quotes from parents like Fleming: It’s always about parental rights to them, never about the child’s right to proper medical care that protects them from preventable diseases. Indeed, Rand Paul himself made this argument explicit when he said:
The state doesn’t own the children. Parents own the children, and it is an issue of freedom.
In this, antivaccine activists are very much like the parents who refuse chemotherapy for their child with cancer, who also routinely invoke “parental rights.” In their opposition to SB 277 (or any law that makes it even just slightly more difficult to obtain a personal belief exemption to school vaccine mandates) antivaccine parents like Fleming routinely invoke their rights over those of their children. Actually, they go farther than that. They invoke their rights over not only those of their children, but over those of other people’s children with whom their children will come into contact at school. In this, “health freedom” is simply a dog whistle for the antivaccine movement which, translated, really means, “I invoke the ‘freedom’ to do whatever I want with my children, regardless of the consequences.”
Don’t believe me? Take a look at the reaction to the antivaccine movement to the death of a woman with a compromised immune system from the measles. On Thursday, the Washington State Department of Health issued this press release:
OLYMPIA – The death of a Clallam County woman this spring was due to an undetected measles infection that was discovered at autopsy.
The woman was most likely exposed to measles at a local medical facility during a recent outbreak in Clallam County. She was there at the same time as a person who later developed a rash and was contagious for measles. The woman had several other health conditions and was on medications that contributed to a suppressed immune system. She didn’t have some of the common symptoms of measles such as a rash, so the infection wasn’t discovered until after her death. The cause of death was pneumonia due to measles.
This is a horrible tragedy that I’ve been fearing for a long time, and it has finally happened. The measles has claimed its first victim in the latest series of outbreaks. Indeed, this was the first measles death recorded in the US in 12 years.
I knew right away what antivaccinationists were going to say. They were going to say that they’re sorry, that this is horrible. Then they would make excuses, adding that this woman was immunosuppressed and that’s why she died. Next, they’d claim that measles is a benign disease. Of course, that’s only partially true. The mortality rate from measles in otherwise healthy individuals is quite low (approximately 1 to 2 per 1,000), but it’s not zero. Complications like pneumonia are by no means uncommon. Less common, but still to be feared, are complications such as encephalitis (again, approximately 1 in 1,000) or, even worse, the uniformly-deadly complication of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). This is a rare but fatal disease of the central nervous system that results from a measles virus infection acquired earlier in life, usually developing 7 to 10 years after a person has measles, even though the person seems to have fully recovered from the illness. Elsewhere in the world, measles is far deadlier. It’s also incredibly infectious, caused by one of the most easily-transmissible viruses known to medical science. Moreover, the measles virus itself is temporarily immunosuppressive, and vaccinating against the measles protects against more than just the measles.
But how could this woman have gotten so sick and died before it was realized that she had the measles? After all, the measles is nothing if not recognizable (at least to those who’ve seen it before), thanks to a characteristic rash caused by the disease. Here’s why:
It’s not surprising that the woman had no obvious measles symptoms; people with compromised immune systems often don’t develop a rash when infected with the virus, said Paul Offit, chief of infectious disease at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.
The woman’s death was a preventable, but predictable, consequence of falling vaccination rates, said Peter Hotez, president of the Sabin Vaccine Institute and Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Vaccine Development in Houston.
As noted over at io9, rashless measles is rare, but far from unheard of. An overreview of measles warns:
Among immunocompromised persons, diffuse progressive pneumonitis caused by the measles virus is the most common cause of death [97–104]. These patients may first have typical measles with pneumonia, or they may have a nonspecific illness without rash followed by pneumonitis without a rash. In general, signs of pneumonitis develop in the 2 weeks after the first onset of symptoms [90, 96, 105]. Other patients have had reappearance of rash and pneumonitis after long intervals following “classical” measles [97, 106].
In other words, if you’re immunocompromised, you might not know you have the measles until you develop severe viral pneumonitis due to the measles virus. Make no mistake, in immunocompromised patients with the measles, pneumonitis is the most common cause of death.
This woman’s death was not tied to the Disneyland measles outbreak, but Clallam County had a small outbreak of measles earlier this year, which is not surprising given that Washington has been a hotbed of low vaccine uptake and antivaccine activity, to the point that the legislature moved to make it more difficult to obtain nonmedical exemptions. Clallam County has not been immune to parents declining to protect their children from vaccine-preventable diseases by claiming personal belief exemptions.
The bottom line is that there was an outbreak a few months ago in Clallam County, and, even though it wasn’t linked to the Disneyland measles outbreak (health officials report that it was a different strain of the measles), it almost certainly was linked to low vaccine uptake in areas of the county. That is why the antivaccine movement is dangerous.
Not surprisingly, the usual suspects are quick to claim that low vaccine uptake had nothing to do with why this woman died, that this death was not preventable. First up, there’s Dr. Jay Gordon, our favorite “I’m not antivaccine” antivaccine pediatrician, responding to questions on Twitter:
Yes, that’s Dr. Jay telling someone that this unfortunate woman’s death was not preventable! Not preventable? Nonsense! MMR is very effective at preventing measles, and if MMR uptake is adequately high, herd immunity will protect people who are unfortunate enough to be immunosuppressed. Dr. Jay is basically trying to pass the buck and duck responsibility.
Meanwhile, Dr. Bob Sears, master of the antivaccine dog whistle, is furiously trying to distance the Disneyland measles outbreak from this woman’s death:
MEASLES DEATH NOT LINKED TO DISNEYLAND OUTBREAK, ACCORDING TO ABC NEWS AND WASHINGTON STATE HEALTH DEPT SPOKESMAN
Here is an update from ABC News. Again, our condolences to the family.According to the last line in the story, this case was NOT linked to the Disneyland outbreak. We don’t yet know what that means. It may have been a measles strain from somewhere else? We don’t know yet. Vaccine strains can also be picked up by immunocompromised people, as this woman was. But be [sic] have no facts about that whatsoever.Update. One news outlet – king5.com – reports that according to a spokesperson it was the D9 strain, a wild strain that was identified in other people in the county outbreak. Sounds like it was not a vaccine strain.Again, our heartfelt condolences to the family.
That’s nice. You can almost hear Dr. Bob backing away and saying, “Don’t blame me!” Even worse, he is trying to blame this woman’s death on viral shedding from vaccinated people, which is simply not justified, as secondary transmission of the vaccine strain of measles has not been observed. Of course, it doesn’t matter that this outbreak was due to a different strain of measles virus. It really doesn’t. What matters is MMR uptake. The reason it’s low in certain affluent areas is, at least in part, due to the fear mongering spread by Dr. Bob’s and Dr. Jay’s patients, some of whom are quite active in the antivaccine movement. (Remember, Dr. Jay was Jenny McCarthy’s son’s pediatrician back when she was transforming herself into a “warrior mother” going to war against vaccines.) It’s low because irresponsible pediatricians like Dr. Jay and Dr. Bob are sympathetic to the views of antivaccine parents, to the point where they not-infrequently parrot antivaccine talking points. Indeed, Dr. Jay, relying on his “30 years of clinical experience,” has been known to insist that vaccines cause autism even as he admits that there’s no good evidence to support that belief.
If you want despicable, though, check out this comment by someone named Jen Glover Bishop:
If pneumonia was the cause of death then measles is a non issue. Pneumonia is a complication that can occur after the common cold in an immune compromised person. Anything would have led to pneumonia in a person like that. Life is not illness proof.
This is sort of true. Even if it were totally true, there’s one big difference between the common cold and the measles. We can’t prevent the common cold easily. We can prevent the measles. With a vaccine. And antivaccinationists do everything to deny and minimize their contribution to outbreaks. If you really want to see how low they can go, check out this comment by Christina Wright:
honestly, i call bullshit on this story. i’m sorry if it’s actually true, but its just way too vague and really sketchy that someone just so happens to die from measles as people are starting to wake up about all these bills being introduced. this is a scare tactic to whip the public back into shape. hello pharma pays $$$$$$ for marketing, thats all this is…a marketing strategy to set the tone of what’s to come.
Yes, it’s time for the conspiracy theories to come out. Same as it ever was. Of course, if conspiracy theories aren’t enough, then there’s always outright denying the importance of this story—and even that it’s legitimate—as Colleen Cron Oleksinski does:
With ALL due respect, why is this making national news? People die everyday without national recognition, why is this any different? By the way, Im not buying it either.
Oleksinski was answered by a chorus of Hallelujahs like this:
Setting the stage. They wasted no time. This is tragic absolutely. And what did they say, she passed in the spring? Did they wait this long to have an autopsy? Bring this out now, two days after CA signs BS277 and it is from a different state…perfect to infect the whole country with PANic and misinformation. Federal bill…I can’t wait.
And:
It’s making the news so that the sheep will once again become paralyzed with fear…and they won’t put up a fight when forced vaccinations come to their state.
And:
Getting the fear nice and deep to then roll out adult mandatory vaccines!
You get the idea: It’s not our fault, and this poor woman’s death is nothing more than a conspiracy by big pharma and the government to pave the way for jack booted thugs wielding syringes to force children and adults to be vaccinated. It’s a fantastical, paranoid delusion, but it’s what they believe, even at the expense of denying the human tragedy that has just occurred. What do you expect from people who routinely compare SB 277 to the Fugitive Slave Act and the Holocaust?
This is what we’re up against in trying to build on the success of the pro-SB 277 forces in California and introduce similar laws in other states.
SB 277’s one big weakness
SB 277 is a major improvement in the law regulating vaccination and vaccine exemptions in California that protects children from infectious disease. However, it is not perfect, and we do not know how it will work in practice yet, when it goes into effect next year, because the California Department of Public Health has not yet issued regulations. For example, a question came up for me reading Gov. Brown’s signing message:
The Legislature, after considerable debate, specifically amended SB 277 to exempt a child from immunizations whenever the child’s physician concludes that there are “circumstances, including but not limited to, family medical history, for which the physician does not recommend vaccination.”
Thus, SB 277, while requiring that school children be vaccinated, explicitly provides an exception when a physician believes that circumstances — in the judgment and sound discretion of the physician — so warrant.
What does this mean? I went and took a look at the text of the bill as passed, specifically, Section 5:
SEC. 5. Section 120370 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:
120370. (a) If the parent or guardian files with the governing authority a written statement by a licensed physician to the effect that the physical condition of the child is such, or medical circumstances relating to the child are such, that immunization is not considered safe, indicating the specific nature and probable duration of the medical condition or circumstances, including, but not limited to, family medical history, for which the physician does not recommend immunization, that child shall be exempt from the requirements of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 120325, but excluding Section 120380) and Sections 120400, 120405, 120410, and 120415 to the extent indicated by the physician’s statement.
It’s hard not to wonder whether this means that antivaccine pediatricians in California, like Dr. Bob Sears and Dr. Jay Gordon, are already putting money down on a new Lamborghini. No, that’s not my joke; I stole it from someone on Twitter:
@gorskon @MyHealthyBabies @JayGordonMDFAAP No doubt some CA doctors will profit from this. I hear Bob just ordered a new Lamborghini.
— Greg Hinson (@ackdoc) June 30, 2015
That might be going too far, but it does bring up a point. The biggest weakness in SB 277 is that it appears to leave it pretty much up to a child’s pediatrician regarding whether an exemption to the school vaccine mandate is medically indicated. In that, it is similar to the Mississippi law. In contrast, in West Virginia, it isn’t just the word of the child’s physician that matters; all requests for medical exemptions are reviewed by an Immunization Officer, who determines if they are appropriate “based upon the most recent guidance from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), and the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) with respect to medical contraindications or precautions for each vaccine.” In other words, SB 277 does not appear to have any oversight regarding what reasons doctors invoke to issue medical exemptions, and, indeed, in his signing statement Gov. Brown explicitly mentioned that feature of the law as the reason why he was willing to sign it.
On the surface, this provision would indeed seem to be a godsend to antivaccine pediatricians, who will likely see their business boom in the wake of SB 277 as parents, no longer able to obtain nonmedical exemptions, start looking for medical exemptions in much the same way parents in states that allow religious exemptions but not personal belief exemptions suddenly found religion and used it as a justification for not vaccinating. Resistance to vaccination will flow wherever it can. I’m just happy that, in this case at least, only letters from a physician will be valid for obtaining a medical exemption. One can only imagine what would happen if letters from naturopaths and chiropractors, who, unfortunately, are licensed “health care professionals” in the state of California, were permitted. This was the case for AB 2109, where naturopaths were listed as one of the medical professions whose members could counsel parents on the benefits and risks of vaccinating and sign their personal belief exemption.
Be that as it may, there is clearly wide latitude given to California physicians on this issue. Indeed, Dr. Jay himself wrote yesterday:
Governor Brown signed this law because of the strong medical exemption provisions. He recognized that parents with reasonable medical objections—as opposed to personal or religious objections—must still have access to exemptions for their children.
Consult with a physician who knows your child and your family.
No one should scare you into or out of vaccinating.
This is the sort of thing that irritates me about Dr. Jay. He knows that the parents of some of his patients are antivaccine activists. How could he not? He was the pediatrician who took care of Jenny McCarthy’s son Evan back when she was emerging as America’s foremost antivaccine celebrity activist. Does he ever, in the privacy of his office, suggest to these parents that maybe—just maybe—it’s not such a good idea to spread misinformation demonizing vaccines as toxin-laden poisons causing autism, autoimmune diseases, neurodevelopmental disorders, SIDS, and even shaken baby syndrome? Only he and his patients’ parents know for sure, but I sure doubt it. Certainly, he rarely, if ever, publicly calls out anyone on “his side” for promoting such misinformation. Instead, he falls back on a vague false equivalency that paints pro- and anti-vaccine activists both as irrationally trying to frighten people to their position, as he did above. Of course, even if that were true, there would still be a big difference. What pro-vaccine activists say about the dangers of vaccine-preventable diseases is true. What antivaccine activists say about the dangers of vaccine is almost always untrue. In fact, Dr. Jay himself engaged in such fear mongering just a few months ago when he declared that the MMR is not controversial because of Wakefield, and I haven’t forgotten his many articles for The Huffington Post dating back a decade and appearances on TV that spread misinformation and fear about vaccines, invoked the “toxins” gambit, and likened vaccine manufacturers to tobacco companies.
His protestations to the contrary (which, to be fair, I really think he sincerely believes thanks to massive cognitive dissonance), we know what side Dr. Jay is on.
But back to Twitter. There was an exchange just last week in which Dr. Jay asserted:
@unhealthytruth Medical exemptions will be solely at the discretion of doctors. #SB277 Families unable to choose their MDs will have issues
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
Dr. Jay replied about “family history” in SB 277 and was asked:
.@jaygordonmdfaap Tell me how YOU as a PEDIATRICIAN would apply that. Be specific. #SB277
— David Gorski (@gorskon) June 30, 2015
He was therefore asked how he, as a pediatrician, would decide whether to recommend a medical exemption to school vaccine mandates, now that SB 277 basically gives him the power to do that. At first, he said, simply, “Nope”:
@gorskon Nope.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
After some prodding, he did get one thing right:
“@geekpharm: @gorskon @JayGordonMDFAAP if I say I’m worried the mercury will cause autism, would you give my kids a medical exemption?”__No
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
Which is a relief.
However, elsewhere, he remained maddeningly vague, going on about “family history” of reactions to vaccines, even though he admits that the AAP does not consider this a contraindication. He sparred with a couple of doctors, who asked him what specific medical conditions he’d consider a contraindication to vaccination. Oddly enough, he didn’t mention any of the contraindications that no one disagrees about, such as the accepted contraindication that children with severe immunosuppression (such as due to chemotherapy or illnesses that compromise the immune system) should not receive attenuated live virus vaccines. It would have been so easy to say that, because such a contraindication is on firm medical ground. But instead, Dr. Jay went here:
-2- Just the usual health care situation: If your doctor talks with you and respects your judgement your child will get needed exemptions
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
And:
-3- If not, some families w very reasonable requests for medical exemption will be turned down. “No shots, no school.”
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
And:
@davidjuurlink @gorskon An adverse reaction to previous vaccine in patient or sibling is one good example.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) June 30, 2015
So what does this mean? The cynic in me thinks it might mean this:
.@MyHealthyBabies I suspect @JayGordonMDFAAP‘s “medical criteria” for exemption under #SB277 will be “Mommy and Daddy want it.”
— David Gorski (@gorskon) June 30, 2015
Certainly, for some physicians, that will be the main criterion. The question will come when it is parents who have a perfectly healthy child with no generally-accepted contraindications to vaccination (such as immunosuppression) or even typical “contraindications” promoted by the antivaccine movement, such as a sibling who had an adverse reaction to vaccination, a sibling with autism, the child having autism himself, and the like. How far will pediatricians like Dr. Jay go to give their patients’ parents what they want? It will be a fascinating question, something to keep an eye on as SB 277 is implemented next year. One thing that I expect to happen is for dubious laboratories, like Doctors Data, to come up with more (and ever more bogus) panels of laboratory tests purported to predict “sensitivity” to adverse reactions from vaccines. Just you watch.
One comforting observation is that there doesn’t seem to be much of a problem with pediatricians writing up dubious recommendations for medical exemptions in Mississippi, whose law doesn’t require review of doctors’ requests for medical exemptions for their patients by an Immunization Officer. But Mississippi is not California, and the law has been in place there for many years. People are used to it. Also, California is one of the great paradises for the many “alternative” practitioners there, including physicians who have gone to the dark side, making the supply of physicians willing—shall we say?—to stretch the boundaries of indications for a medical exemption to vaccines likely much greater in California than it is in Mississippi.
Perhaps the most effective means of making sure that doctors sympathetic to antivaccine parents don’t come up with excessively creative rationales for recommending medical exemptions is vigilance by the state medical board, the federal government, and insurance companies. For instance, one quality metric that is being increasingly examined among pediatricians is the percentage of children who are up-to-date on the recommended vaccines. Pediatricians who fall short on that measure because they issue way more medical exemptions than average could well come under scrutiny. At the very least, they might be risk losing pay-for-performance bonuses. (Not all antivaccine-sympathetic pediatricians are in concierge practices that do not belong to any insurance plans, like Dr. Jay and Dr. Bob.) Unfortunately, state medical boards tend to be toothless so I have little hope that complaints to the Medical Board of California about physicians issuing dubious medical exemptions will have much of an impact.
Don’t think that my pointing out this weakness in SB 277 means that I don’t think it’s an excellent law. It is. Its passage is a major victory in the struggle to protect children from the ravages of infectious disease and a major defeat for the antivaccine movement, which marshaled pretty much everything it had to defeat it and still came up short. The California legislature and Governor Jerry Brown are to be commended, as are the innumerable advocates for children “on the ground” who worked tirelessly for its passage. But it is not perfect. It’s politics. Compromises had to be made.
SB 277 makes the situation in California much better than it was before with respect to child health and should serve as a model for the remaining 47 states that allow religious and personal belief exemptions. It is a beginning, not an end, and part of what needs to be done now is to keep an eye on its implementation. While I suspect that there will be some doctors who profit as a result of the law, fortunately I also suspect that the number of doctors who will be willing to go much beyond the CDC/AAP guidelines for medical contraindications to vaccination is and will remain small.

California SB 277: New evidence that restricting nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine requirements works
The 2016-2017 kindergarten numbers are in. SB 277, the new California law banning personal belief exemptions to school vaccine requirements, works as intended. Early numbers show that vaccine uptake has increased, and personal belief exemptions are down dramatically.
David Gorski on April 16, 2017
Link

[Editor’s note: This is a special bonus post. Dr. Gorski will have another post tomorrow.]
The Disneyland measles outbreak began over the Christmas holidays of 2014 and continued for several months into 2015, ultimately spanning eight states and two additional countries (Canada and Mexico). It also represented a seismic shift in the battle to contain the malign influence of the antivaccine movement in that the outbreak centered at the Magic Kingdom made it possible for California legislators to do something that would definitely not have been possible before the outbreak: Pass a law outlawing “personal belief exemptions” (a.k.a. nonmedical exemptions) to school vaccine requirements. Indeed, given that, prior to the outbreak, only two states (Mississippi and West Virginia, not-coincidentally also two states with very high vaccination rates) allowed only medical exemptions and the other 48 states allowed some combination of religious or personal belief exemptions (PBEs, or, as I like to call them, “I don’t wanna” exemptions), California was the last state I would have imagined passing a law to become like Mississippi or West Virginia. Happily, I was in error. Co-sponsored by Senators Richard Pan and Ben Allen, SB 277 was approved by the California legislature in June 2015 and signed into law by Governor Jerry Brown on June 30, 2015. The new law took full effect in the 2016-2017 school year; i.e., this school year.
The bill (and later law) itself mobilized the antivaccine movement in a way I don’t recall ever having seen it mobilized before. Indeed, there’s a reason why Andrew Wakefield and Del Bigtree bookended their antivaccine propaganda film VAXXED with reports of the Disneyland measles outbreak. It was such a major event in their world view and, given that California is the most populous state in the union, looked to be a profound threat to what they call “freedom” and “parental choice” (conveniently leaving out the rights of the child). Indeed, one could argue that, without SB 277, there very well might not have been a VAXXED, which has been unfortunately influential.
Not suprisingly, SB 277 was a topic of extensive blogging here all through the battle to pass it in 2015 and beyond, when I described how antivaccine-sympathetic pediatricians and other quacks were advertising medical exemptions to school vaccine requirements (which are, of course, still allowed—have to be allowed) as basically being for sale.
When last I looked at the topic a little more than a year ago, preliminary data were suggesting that SB 277 was beginning to have its intended effect. PBEs were declining and vaccine uptake was increasing, both good things. Yesterday, it was pointed out to me that the California Department of Public Health has published the most recent vaccine uptake rates for kindergarten for 2016-2017. The news is good. Vaccinate California provided the “money shot” graph:
What happened when California passed a law to eliminate Personal Belief Exemptions to vaccines? This! CA DPH released analysis just now. pic.twitter.com/OFigphuhIG
— Vaccinate California (@VaccinateCal) April 12, 2017
Notice the trends. PBEs had been increasing inexorably beginning around 1996, with few blips in the upward trend, increasing to nearly four-fold over the course of approximately 18 years. Those of you who haven’t been following vaccine issues (or this blog) for very long might ask: What was AB 2109? Basically, it was the precursor to SB 277. A few years ago, alarmed at the steady upward march of PBE rates, the California legislature passed AB 2109, a law that required parents seeking PBEs to undergo counseling by a pediatrician, advanced practice nurse, or other enumerated health care provider over the risks of foregoing vaccines. The resistance to AB 2109 was almost as fierce as the resistance to SB 277, even though it was a much less stringent law. Indeed, AB 2109 first showed me that Rob Schneider was antivaccine, because that’s when he came out in a big way. Unfortunately, Governor Brown eliminated most of the bill’s impact by adding a signing statement instructing the California Department of Public Health to make an exception for religious exemptions, not requiring parents seeking them to undergo counseling. It was almost certainly an illegal instruction, given that it directly contradicted the language of the law as passed. Unfortunately, the CDPH did not ignore the signing statement, as it should have, and follow the clear language of the actual law.
Even so, as you can see from the graph, for the first time in nearly 20 years, there was a significant dip in the rate of PBEs. This observation is consistent with what we’ve seen here in Michigan after the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services imposed a regulation that was very much like AB 2109, only more stringent in that it isn’t just any doctor in Michigan who can provide the required counseling to parents seeking PBEs. No, here in Michigan, the MDHHS requires that parents actually visit a state or county health department office for standardized counseling. And it works, even better than AB 2109 did in California. Unfortunately, antivaxers in my state have successfully lobbied the legislature to have a bill introduced that would not only overturn the rule requiring counseling but would prevent health officers in our state from barring unvaccinated children from school in the event of an outbreak. Truly, the stupidity of our legislature astounds even me sometimes, as the most recent bill was not the first attempt.
That dip after AB 2109, though, is nothing compared to the dramatic decline in PBEs among kindergarteners. Basically, in a bit more than one year, PBEs fell to levels not seen since the early 1990s. Yes, there was an uptick in medical exemptions, no doubt due to the machinations of Dr. Bob Sears and all the other antivaccine and antivaccine-sympathetic pediatricians and practitioners who saw a chance to profit in a way that aligns with their antivaccine ideology, but that increase is overwhelmed by the rapid decline in PBEs. This is a very good thing indeed. It’s hard not to conclude from these data that eliminating PBEs works—and works very well.
If that doesn’t convince you, check out this graph from the report itself. It shows that the percentage of kindergarteners with all their required vaccines climbed from 90.2% in the 2013-2014 school year to 95.6% in the 2016-2017 school year:
Perusing the data in the report a bit more, I see that the good news just keeps on coming. For instance, here’s another way of showing that the percentage of children with all their required vaccines is increasing not just overall, but for individual vaccines:
And:
Of course, overall statewide vaccine uptake is important, but arguably what is even more important are the areas with the lowest vaccine uptake. The reason, of course, is that these areas provide the raw material for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases through degradation of herd immunity to the point where outbreaks become possible. That’s why these maps of county-wide vaccine uptake should be music to the ears of pro-science, pro-vaccine advocates. For instance, here are maps indicating total vaccine uptake (i.e., the percentage of kindergarteners who had all the required vaccines), with dramatic increases in the percentage who’ve had all vaccines and decreases in the numbers of students with PBEs. Basically, this graph, as the first one does, suggests that both AB 2109 and now SB 277 worked:
And here’s a map indicating the percentage of kindergarteners with two or more doses of MMR:
Notice how, in both maps, multiple counties have increased their vaccine uptake out of the “red zone,” which represents levels of vaccine uptake where herd immunity is likely to be degraded. Granted, most of the counties that “flipped” from red or yellow to yellow or green are counties that aren’t very populous, meaning that what we could be seeing is, at least in part, due to low numbers. It will take data from subsequent years to confirm whether this trend is durable or not. However, I’d be willing to bet that it is. We already know that making PBEs more difficult to obtain increases vaccine uptake; so this increase in vaccine uptake in California is plausible. It’s also welcome.
Per the report:
Of 562,924 kindergarteners whose schools reported their status, 537,991 (95.6%) had received all required immunizations, an increase from the previous school year of 2.8 percentage points (Table 1) and an increase over two school years of 5.2 percentage points (Figures 1, 6). Compared to the 2015-2016 school year, the percentage of students with all required immunizations increased in 50 (86%) of 58 counties (Table 5). For counties reporting at least 25 students, the highest rates were reported in Tulare (98.5%) and San Benito (98.1%) Counties (Tables 3-5). In 2016-2017, 9 (16%) of 58 counties in California have rates of kindergarteners with all required vaccines that are below 90%, compared to 20 (34%) counties in 2015-2016 (Tables 4 and 5, Figure 9).
As in past years, a higher proportion of students in public compared to private schools were reported as having had all required immunizations (95.9% vs. 91.6%; difference of 4.3 percentage points) (Table 1, Figures 7 and 8). However, this gap is smaller in 2016-2017 than it was in 2015-2016 (93.2% vs. 88.2%; difference of 5.0 percentage points), as the one-year increase by 2.7 percentage points in public schools was not as large as the increase by 3.4 percentage points in private schools.
And:
When comparing the 2016-2017 school year to 2015-2016, the proportion of students reported to enter kindergarten in California after receiving all required immunizations increased by 2.8 percentage points to 95.6%, following an increase by 2.4 percentage points between the 2014-2015 and 2015-2016 school years. The 2016-2017 rate of 95.6% is the highest reported to CDPH since varicella vaccine became the most recent addition to the immunizations required for kindergarteners, which began in the 2001-2002 school year.
The CDPH report contains a wealth of information on vaccine uptake, PBEs, and permanent medical exemptions (PMEs). As I documented since the passage of SB 277, antivaccine activists are doing their damnedest to abuse PMEs. For instance, I note an interesting observation in Marin County, PMEs increased from 0.2% in 2015-2016 school year to 2.1% in the 2016-2017 school year, whopping ten-fold increase. In Orange County, another hotbed of antivaccine activity, PMEs increased from 0.2% to 0.8%, a four-fold increase. Interestingly, by comparison in San Francisco County the PME rate only increased from 0.2% to 0.5%. By way of comparison, in Los Angeles County PMEs increased from 0.1% to 0.4%. To be fair, some of this increase could be due to parents whose children need a genuine medical exemption but instead just took a PBE before because it was easier, but it’s also likely that the majority of this increase is due to abuse, in which unscrupulous physicians basically sell medical exemptions based on dubious indications. We already know this started happening not long after SB 277 passed; so it is not surprising that PMEs increased as much as they did in one year. Again, data from future years will determine at what level this increase levels out.
In an ideal world, there would be no PBEs, no exemptions to school vaccine mandates based on anything other than medical indications. Of course, this is not an ideal world. Fortunately, measures that make PBEs difficult to obtain, such as AB 2109 in California and my state’s policy that requires parents who wish to obtain a PBE to visit a state or county health office for counseling on the risks of not vaccinating, also work to increase vaccine uptake. They don’t work as well as eliminating all nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine requirements, but they work and thus are reasonable alternatives to banning nonmedical exemptions in states where it is just politically impossible to do something as radical as SB 277.
Unfortunately, as my own state of Michigan and the state of Texas show, there will be pushback against such efforts. Even worse, somehow over the last several years antivaccine beliefs have been embraced by a segment of the right that lumps antivaccine beliefs as part of “freedom” and “parental rights,” resulting in a dangerous politicization of what was once a bipartisan issue. I fear that California might be the last state to take a step like SB 277 for the foreseeable future. However, all is not lost. Many states are looking into tightening up the requirements for nonmedical exemptions, which is almost as good. From a scientific viewpoint, both work, but eliminating nonmedical exemptions works better than simply making PBEs more difficult to obtain. Given the current political situation, the best that can likely be expected is for some states to tighten up their PBE requirements, and we should support and encourage such efforts wherever they occur. As we say in surgery, “better”—or, even worse, “perfect”—is often the enemy of good.

Laws Limiting Vaccine Exemptions Work
Steven Novella on February 3, 2016
Link

It’s nice when a question can be resolved with objective numbers of unequivocal outcomes. Subjective outcomes give scientists a headache.
In this case we are talking about the effect of vaccine exemption laws on vaccine compliance rates. The question here is not the ethical one, the rights of parents to determine the fate of their children vs the right of the state to protect the health of children and the public health. I think the latter trumps the former, but some disagree.
Regardless of what you feel about the ethical question, we need to know if the laws we pass to achieve our goals actually work, or if they don’t work, or even have unintended consequences. Having an admirable goal is not enough; when you make actual decisions (practice decisions, policy decisions, healthcare decisions for you and for family) you want to know that those decisions are having the desired effect.
We recently had another opportunity to test the effect of vaccine exemption laws, with California law SB 277 making it more difficult for parents to obtain vaccine exemptions. We’ll get to that below.
Vaccine exemption laws
One of the advantages of the US health care system is that in many ways it is 50 statewide systems. This provides the opportunity to experiment – each state is a type of experiment and we can compare the various statewide health care policies on outcomes.
There are a range of policies among the states. All 50 states require some vaccinations for entry into public school. Most offer religious exemptions to vaccines, all but Mississippi and West Virginia. As of 2016, 18 states allow for personal belief or philosophical exemptions (California and Vermont passed laws that remove philosophical exemptions this year). In addition, some states make it more difficult to obtain exemptions – you may have to just check a box on a form, or you may need a notarized note from a doctor, or you may need to be counseled by a doctor about the dangers of vaccine-preventable diseases.
How do these ranges of policies affect vaccine exemptions and therefore the incidence of vaccine-preventable diseases? The answer has consistently been that the more permissive the state regulations, the higher the rate of vaccine exemptions, and the higher the rate of vaccine-preventable illness. The correlation is strong.
For example, a 2006 study looking at state laws and statistics governing vaccine exemptions from 2001-2004 found:
Permitting personal belief exemptions and easily granting exemptions are associated with higher and increasing nonmedical US exemption rates. State policies granting personal belief exemptions and states that easily grant exemptions are associated with increased pertussis incidence.
A 2014 systematic review of state vaccine exemptions concluded:
Findings from 42 studies suggest that exemption rates are increasing and occur in clusters; most exemptors questioned vaccine safety, although some exempted out of convenience. Easier state-level exemption procedures increase exemption rates and both individual and community disease risk.
The easier it is to obtain an exemption the higher the exemption rate, and the higher the incidence of vaccine-preventable diseases like pertussis and measles. Further, private schools have a higher incidence of vaccine refusal than public schools. The exemptions also geographically cluster.
The clustering is important because of herd immunity. If we look only at overall vaccine rates, they usually remain high, enough for herd immunity to prevent outbreaks. But vaccine exemptions cluster, both geographically and in schools, which means there are pockets in which herd immunity is lost. Unsurprisingly, pertussis outbreaks tend to cluster in the same places that vaccine refusal clusters.
It should also be emphasized that the primary reason for vaccine refusal is concerns about vaccine safety. There is no scientific basis for this concern – it is entirely due to a campaign of fearmongering and misinformation on the part of those ideologically opposed to vaccines.
California Law SB277
Comparing different states is useful, and provides a powerful correlation with an obvious causation. However, when one state changes its laws that provides and even stronger source of evidence for the effects of vaccine exemptions laws – because everything is the same except for the law itself.
Largely in response to the Disneyland measles outbreak, California passed a law eliminating personal belief exemptions from the vaccine requirements for public school. The full effects of this law do not kick in until July 1 of this year, but parents were already informed of the upcoming change.
Here come the objective numbers I so love:
Of 551,123 kindergarten children whose schools reported their status, 511,708 (92.9%) had received all required immunizations, an increase from the previous school year of 2.5 percentage points overall, 2.5 percentage points in public schools, and 1.6 percentage points in private schools (Table 1).
Already there has been a 2.5 percent absolute increase in kindergarten children receiving their full vaccination schedule. This is huge from a public health perspective, and will likely have a measurable effect on disease outbreaks in the state.
This also sends a clear message to other states with philosophical exemptions, especially easily-obtained exemptions – this policy does have an effect on public health, which is a direct responsibility of the state.
The net effect of eliminating vaccine exemptions
Requiring vaccines for entry into public schools is a sensible public health policy that is incredibly effective in terms of protecting the public and cost. The cost effectiveness should not be overlooked or minimized at a time when rising healthcare costs literally threaten the quality of our healthcare.
All exemptions increase vaccine noncompliance and increase the risk of outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. The data are clear. This cannot be a point of disagreement when crafting public policy.
There is a reasonable case to be made for not allowing any vaccine exemptions. However, for those states who feel that some exemptions, such as religious exemptions, are appropriate, the data also show they should make those exemptions as limited and difficult to obtain as possible.
I don’t see any justification for philosophical exemptions. They essentially represent allowing a parent to substitute their own ill-informed opinion about the scientific facts for the carefully vetted consensus of scientific opinion. Most parents object because they fear vaccines are not safe, and they are simply and objectively wrong. The benefits of vaccines vastly outweigh the tiny risks. Their children should not suffer, and the public health should not suffer, because of their incorrect beliefs regarding the scientific facts.

NY federal court hands triple loss to anti-vaccination ideology
Jann Bellamy on June 26, 2014
Link

The state of New York allows religious and medical (but not philosophical) exemptions from school vaccination mandates. New York City has a policy of excluding unvaccinated schoolchildren from classes when there is an outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease reported in a particular school. Two sets of parents whose children had religious exemptions sued New York City and the state in federal court when their children were temporarily excluded from school under the policy, in some cases for up to a month. In other words, they were demanding that their unvaccinated children be allowed to attend even though there was an outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease at the school.
These cases were consolidated with another filed by parents, the Checks, who claimed their child had been improperly denied a religious exemption. The parents had applied for a medical exemption, which was denied, as well as a religious exemption, which was granted, but then revoked. (The record is somewhat confusing on this sequence of events, but that sequence is not relevant to our discussion.) The unvaccinated child was ultimately sent to a private school, even though she should have been excluded from admission under New York City law there as well.
Last week, a federal judge dismissed all three cases (they had been consolidated and assigned to one judge) in an opinion holding that neither the students’ nor the parents’ constitutional rights were violated, including their First Amendment right to free exercise of religion. The plaintiffs have filed an appeal.
The New York Times provided some interesting stats as background for its story on the lawsuits. New York City schools granted 3,535 religious exemptions in 2012-13. Public and private schools in the city have an overall immunization rate of around 97 percent, but 37 private schools were below 70 percent. According to Daniel Salmon, deputy director at the Institute for Vaccine Safety at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, the rate of immunization necessary to maintain herd immunity for measles, which is highly contagious, is 95%.
(There are over 300 comments to the story. I couldn’t wade through all of them, but the supporters of vaccination and science were in a clear lead over the anti-vaxxers and pseudoscientific rhetoric when I left off. It was encouraging to see the SBM-style rejoinders posted against the same shop-worn arguments trotted out by the anti-vaxxers.)
A 1905 case defeats ideology (again)
No new legal ground was broken here. The court simply relied on well-established U.S. Supreme Court and appellate court precedent, including the 1905 Supreme Court decision in Jacobson v. Massachusetts. It took the court less than 6 pages to dismiss the constitutional claims in their entirety for failure to state a claim upon which relief could be granted. (State law claims were dismissed as well, on jurisdictional grounds.) This means that, even accepting everything the plaintiffs said in their complaints as true, the plaintiffs cannot win. Metaphorically, they didn’t even make it to first base. They struck out entirely.
In fact, the case is interesting for being so uninteresting legally. We are so accustomed to hearing overwrought declarations of “parental rights” to make “informed choices” that we might forget just how solid the constitutional precedent is in upholding a state’s authority to require vaccination against disease to protect the public’s health, safety and welfare. States are not constitutionally required to allow non-medical exemptions at all. (Mississippi and West Virginia permit only medical, but not religious or philosophical, exemptions.)
That the court was able to so handily reject these claims is a testament to just how well-settled the law is in this area. It is also a demonstration of why anti-vaccination and other “parental rights” activists would love to haul Jacobson before the U.S. Supreme Court and argue that it should be overturned, or at least modified. The case (and its progeny, such as Prince v. Massachusetts) has served for over a century as a brake on parents who attempt to impose their religious and “philosophical” belief system at the risk of their children’s (and your) health. The case is an inconvenient barrier between them and their ideological goals.
For the record, in Jacobson, the Supreme Court upheld a $5 fine imposed by Massachusetts on a man who disobeyed an order to vaccinate during a smallpox outbreak. Jacobson’s claims were not unlike those we here from anti-vaccinationists to this day:
The defendant offered to prove that vaccination “quite often” caused serious and permanent injury to the health of the person vaccinated; that the operation “occasionally” resulted in death; that it was “impossible” to tell “in any particular case” what the results of vaccination would be or whether it would injure the health or result in death; that “quite often” one’s blood is in a certain condition of impurity when it is not prudent or safe to vaccinate him; that there is no practical test by which to determine “with any degree of certainty” whether one’s blood is in such condition of impurity as to render vaccination necessarily unsafe or dangerous; that vaccine matter is “quite often” impure and dangerous to be used, but whether impure or not cannot be ascertained by any known practical test; that the defendant refused to submit to vaccination for the reason that he had, “when a child,” been caused great and extreme suffering for a long period by a disease produced by vaccination; and that he had witnessed a similar result of vaccination not only in the case of his son, but in the case of others.
The Supreme Court specifically rejected a claim that Jacobson’s substantive due process rights were infringed and the case has subsequently been interpreted as precluding a First Amendment challenge to school vaccination mandates as well.
Attack of the “pharma trolls”
What is far more interesting than the legal issues is how the court record in the Check case reveals the extent to which anti-vaccine activism and the spread of misinformation is fueling parents’ fears, resulting in their decisions not to vaccinate and to claim exemptions for their children. (For the rest of this post, we’ll focus solely on the Check case.)
The Checks, as well as the other parents, were represented by Patricia Finn, an anti-vaccination activist/lawyer. According to her website, Patricia Finn, P.C., is “a Vaccine Injury and Exemption litigation firm” which “represents thousands of parents and children throughout the United States.” This has not escaped our friend Orac’s notice.
Ms. Finn is apparently reveling in the attention conferred on her by the Times story. One has to admire her cheerfulness in the face of a total loss in three cases, all on the same day. Here’s her June 23 entry on her Facebook page:
Time to respond to the pharma trolls pounding away at this story in the NY Times…please take a minute to comment with the real facts, and share this story with everyone you know…let’s flood the comments the same way they do with our proof…our stories. Bring It On!!*
“Pharma trolls” apparently being anyone whose comments in the Times do not reflect adherence to the anti-vaccination ideology.
Ms. Finn’s tendency to see Big Pharma as omnipotent is not limited to her Facebook page. From her blog, under the tab “Vaccination Law:”
The practice of vaccinating is dangerous. People are being deluged with vaccines because of fear mongering and profit. Mobilizing a global community to line up and inject should not be taken lightly, after all what if it is indeed weird science out of control, terrorism or maybe just a dose of bad shots because the contractors making and transporting the vaccines were skimming [sic] on ingredients, safety controls or refrigeration because it simply cost too much to adhere to pesky safety standards and formulas. Cutting corners might save a few bucks also. And what if the Pharma factory workers simply don’t like Americans and could care less if the shot is safe? The ProVax Choice community is not saying you can’t get the shot if you want it, but it is saying do so with caution because others could be affected.
I’ll rest my case with that quotation.
Her client, Dina Check, blames the devil instead of Big Pharma. She explained her opposition to vaccination to the Times thusly:
… she rejected vaccination after her daughter was ‘intoxicated’ by a few shots during infancy, which she said caused an onslaught of food and milk allergies, rashes and infections. Combined with a religious revelation she had during a difficult pregnancy, she said, the experience turned her away from medicine. Now she uses holistic treatments.
“Disease is pestilence,” Ms. Check said, “and pestilence is from the devil. The devil is germs and disease, which is cancer and any of those things that can take you down. But if you trust in the Lord, these things cannot come near you.
So, there you go. Your disease is your fault because you didn’t trust in the Lord. This type of thinking is, of course, prime raw material for making one into a poster child for the anti-vaccine movement. Other statements by Ms. Check made part of the court records reveal the hand of both the anti-vaccine misinformation machine and pseudomedicine as guiding her decisions.
(The name of Ms. Check’s child is redacted from the court’s records to protect her privacy, but she is referred to as “Mary” on Ms. Finn’s Facebook page, so that is what we will call her as well.)
According to the court records, Ms. Check says that Mary began life with medical problems, including what she describes as a “compromised immune system.” Apparently frustrated by conventional medicine, she turned to “holistic” medicine. She states that all vaccines contain “toxic chemicals that are injected into the bloodstream by vaccination” and views vaccination as “injecting diseases” and “poisons” into her daughter’s immune system, a view she repeats throughout the court record. She describes the vaccine manufacturing process as being “cultured on tissues from monkeys, chicks or aborted fetuses, which have produced antigens which cannot be filtered out.”
There are two interesting printed forms, at least one downloaded from the internet, all neatly typed up and complete with lines for signature and notarization, signed by the Checks and attached to their request for a religious exemption. In these, the Checks state that “one or more aspects of vaccination . . . are in violation of more or more doctrines of at least (5) of the world’s major religions.” The forms also make these alarming and utterly false statements:
It is an uncontested scientific fact that a minimum of 90% of today’s public health achievements originated in the improvements in sanitation, nutrition, hygiene and insect control which preceded both specific vaccination and antibiotics.
No adequate scientific study has ever proved that vaccines give a net benefit to the recipients. For certain diseases, it is beyond controversy that UNVACCINATED children have a considerable advantage over their vaccinated counterparts.
All vaccines are harmful and do not protect anyone form [sic] disease.
You’ll see some of these same ideas from an M.D. later in the record.
Although she describes herself and her family as deeply devout practicing Catholics, and the church’s teachings as the source of her religious objections to vaccination, Catholic doctrine does not, to my knowledge, prohibit or even discourage vaccination. In reading all of this, it is difficult to tell where the Checks’ genuine religious beliefs leave off and the incorporation of anti-vaccination junk science steps in to fill in the blanks.
In any event, the City denied the request because “it does not substantiate a finding that you hold genuine and sincere religious beliefs which are contrary to immunization.”
The medical experts weigh in
A request for a medical exemption from all required vaccinations for Mary was denied by the City as well, after a review by a Department of Health physician, because “the documentation provided by your child’s health care provider does not meet nationally recognized standards for medical contraindication of immunization.”
The medical exemption form was signed by a Michael Gabriel, M.D., and is all but illegible. It refers to “health problems related to foods” and “GI issues and illnesses,” but that is about all I could make out concerning his diagnosis.
There are only two MDs licensed to practice in NY named Michael Gabriel and I am betting Mary’s doctor is (or, at least, was) Michael E. Gabriel, who runs the PATH Family Center on Staten Island, where the Checks live. You are free to draw your own conclusions. According to its website, the Center offers integrative and nutritional interventions for individuals diagnosed with autism, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, food allergies and other related conditions. As well:
We discover the underlying problems through a series of lab tests. The team then creates a custom nutritional protocol with diet plans and integrative guides that begin the process of recovery, as well as offering educational guidance. We also offer Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy which is used for a variety of illnesses, including Lyme Disease, Microcephaly, Crush injuries, Multiple Sclerosis, Traumatic Brain Injuries, Cerebral Palsy, Autism and many more.
It is true that HBOT is used for a “variety of illnesses,” but this list suggests Dr. Gabriel is going way beyond the evidence.
Dr. Gabriel offers a “Bio Med 101” class:
In this class Dr. Gabriel will review what the concept of DAN [“Defeat Autism Now!”] is and how we will mix it with medicine. Dr. Gabriel will review the importance of the Gut and yeast overgrowth and the need for enzymes, probiotics, and a yeast protocol.
The Center also offers “detoxification,” although further information is not available on the website.
To top things off, the plaintiffs filed a Motion for Reconsideration of the court’s ruling. For some inexplicable reason, the Motion was filed after their Notice of Appeal, which divests the district court of jurisdiction over the case, a bit of procedural law duly noted by the judge in summarily denying the motion. Plaintiffs based this motion on “new evidence” including an “expert report” from Yehuda Shoenfeld, MD, an Israeli physician. (Dr. Schoenfeld has not escaped Orac’s notice either.)
As best I can tell, Dr. Schoenfeld thinks that the risk of an autoimmune response to vaccines is underrated and goes on to tell us why. I have no idea whether he is correct or not. I will leave that to others. However, he doesn’t come out and say that Mary is at risk from such a reaction, or explain what his explication of autoimmune response has to do with Mary’s case. Rather, he simply makes the conclusory statement that he agrees with Dr. Gabriel.
Whatever might be the merits of Dr. Schoenfeld’s other theories, he goes dead wrong with this one and jumps right in with the conspiracy crowd:
There is little proof that vaccines are responsible for eradicating disease even when heard [sic] immunity vaccination levels have been reached. . . . Long-range historical data shows that vaccines are not responsible for the decline of heath rates from infectious disease. . . Pertussis is now hot news and the unvaccinated interrupting herd immunity is raised over and over, despite the science that shows the vaccinated are by far and away the most affected by whooping cough. Evidence to the contrary of the value of vaccination is consistently snuffed out and kept away from the mainstream media, so that the herd never hears a peep of the truth. Instead, they get the “herd immunity” sound bite, which gives unserved credit to the risk-benefit ratio of vaccination. Inside the web of half-truth and misinformation, the vaccine advocates somehow justify the public display of resentment and fear of the unvaccinated.
As noted, an appeal has been filed. In a very similar 2010 case, one cited by the district court in this case, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals (where this case will be heard) ruled against the plaintiffs, who were represented by Ms. Finn. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case, thereby defeating Ms. Finn’s goal of getting rid of Jacobson and the long line of cases following it. No doubt she is hoping for a second bite at the apple here.
And what happens to Mary?
So there you have it. Mary Check, conscripted by adults as an underage foot soldier in the vaccine wars, some of whom are clearly driven by an anti-vaccination ideology that rests on a shaky foundation of bad science and Big Pharma conspiracy theory. Mary apparently has very real health issues, although it’s not clear what the diagnosis is, and yet she goes about unvaccinated against serious and potentially deadly diseases, such as polio, pertussis, hepatitis, tetanus, pneumonia, varicella, diphtheria, influenza, measles, mumps, rubella, and meningitis. And she lives in New York City, where, probably more than anywhere else in the entire country, a vaccine-preventable disease is just a plane ride away. How could anyone possibly think this is in Mary’s best interests? I certainly don’t, but it’s not my call.

Review of Vaccine Whistleblower: A Legal Perspective 
Dorit Reiss on August 24, 2015
Link


This post addresses some legal issues raised in the Vaccine Whistleblower book. The first part explains whistleblower protections and how Dr. Thompson’s allegations fit into them. The second part addresses Dr. Thompson’s suggestion of an independent research agency. The third part explains why the book’s claim that school mandates violate international human rights is incorrect.
A note on the book: Chapters 1 is an executive summary of Chapters 2-5, the interview transcripts; Chapters 6-12 are the author Kevin Barry’s thoughts on what should be done. (Note that Dr. Gorski has also discussed this book from the perspective of the science.)
Prologue: to set the scene
The “Vaccine Whistleblower Book” has four transcripts of telephone conversations between William Thompson and Brian Hooker, recorded between May 1, 2014 and July 28, 2014.
Hooker has elsewhere stated that these conversations were only four of over thirty conversations between Thompson and Hooker. Hooker asserts these conversations began in November, 2013, and that Thompson initiated the conversations. It is not clear if these four recorded conversations were the only ones during that time frame, or what was discussed in the non-recorded conversations.
William Thompson was a co-author on a number of vaccine-safety studies published by the CDC. The most salient one for this discussion is (hereinafter DeStefano 2004):
DeStefano F, Bhasin TK, Thompson WW, Yeargin-Allsopp M, Boyle C. Age at first measles-mumps-rubella vaccination in children with autism and school-matched control subjects: a population-based study in metropolitan Atlanta. Pediatrics. 2004 Feb;113(2):259-66. PMID 14754936
It is not clear why Thompson became concerned enough to reach out in 2013 about a paper that had been published almost a decade previously.
Part I: Whistleblower protections in the United States:
When a federal employee discloses wrongdoing that he or she has a “reasonable belief” falls into certain categories in the United States, the law protects the employee from retaliation by the agency he or she exposed (or tried to expose). That’s the heart of whistleblower protections. It’s important to remember that both the Whistleblower Protection Act and the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act seek to provide broad and strong protections to employees disclosing wrongdoing, and Congress clearly signaled a desire to interpret doubts in the disclosing employee’s favor — though that does not translate into automatic protection.
It’s also important to point out that these protections only come into play if there was alleged retaliation by the agency in response to a disclosure.
An employee does not claim whistleblower status in abstract. An employee discloses information about wrongdoing; then, if the agency retaliates, whistleblower protections provide a remedy to the employee (there are a number of other contexts in which we use the term whistleblower that are less relevant here).
How do these whistleblower protections apply to Dr. Thompson?
Disclose to whom?Dr. Thompson did not go higher up in CDC, to another agency, to the administration, to Congress or the press directly. What he did do is have a long series of phone conversations with a private citizen — Dr. Brian Hooker — in which he complained about his colleagues’ conduct. But that does not negate the protections: they come in to force, with some exceptions that don’t apply here, regardless of to whom the disclosures were made (5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A)).
That said, if Dr. Thompson’s goal was to correct wrongdoing, his choice of channel to correct it was strange, to say the least. According to the transcripts, Dr. Thompson only hired legal representation in May 2014, when the possibility of his involvement becoming public was raised (p. 24, chapter 3). So he didn’t have the benefit of legal counsel when he decided to call Dr. Hooker initially. But if you think there is serious wrongdoing in your agency and you want to effectively redress it, is calling an individual that is not only part of the administration but is in many ways an outsider the best way to do so? Dr. Thompson could have hired legal counsel in 2013, or done a Google search on, for example, whistleblower, government and wrongdoing — the first result of which is the Office of Special Counsel whose mandate includes protecting whistleblowers. He could have gone to the press. He could have tried a number of things that would be more effective than calling Dr. Hooker, even if he thought Dr. Hooker had some connections to members of Congress. It may be unfair to criticize Dr. Thompson in hindsight — he may not have thought of this or been well informed on how to report alleged government misconduct — but it is still a strange choice.
Do his allegations fall into protected categories?
In 2012, to broaden protection for whistleblowers, Congress passed the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act (WPEA). Relevant to us, section 110 of the Act applies whistleblower protections to scientists that seek to disclose acts they reasonably believe consist of “censorship related to research, analysis, or technical information that cause, or will cause, gross government waste or mismanagement, an abuse of authority, a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety, or any violation of law.” Censorship is defined as: “any effort to distort, misrepresent, or suppress research, analysis, or technical information.” Dr. Thompson claims he saw acts of suppressing research and analysis that could be directly related to the public health, to harm to children. If his belief is reasonable, whistleblower protections would apply to him.
What is reasonable belief, and Did Dr. Thompson have it?
Reasonable belief asks:
whether, given the information available to the whistleblower, a person standing in his shoes could reasonably believe that the disclosed information evidences one of the identified conditions in the statute.
from The U.S. Office of Special Counsel’s Role in Protecting Whistleblowers and Serving as a Safe Channel for Government Employees to Disclose Wrongdoing, drawing on these cases: Fitches v. Dep’t of the Air Force, 82 M.S.P.R. 68 (1999); Gores v. Dep’t of Veterans Affairs, 68 M.S.P.R. 100 (1995)
The information does not have to be true, and the focus is on the whistleblower’s state of mind, not the listener. The whistleblower’s motives — for example, a desire to get even with a co-worker — do not negate the protection and are not directly connected to the reasonableness of the belief.
Given the holes in the facts in the book and my lack of familiarity with the day-to-day realities of the scientific process, I cannot really assess whether Dr. Thompson had reasonable belief that his co-authors engaged in “any effort to distort, misrepresent, or suppress research, analysis, or technical information.” I would assume his belief was sincere, but I don’t know if it was reasonable. All I can say is that there is a good chance that an administrative official or judge that does not have a background in science will, given the intent to make whistleblower protections broad, give Dr. Thompson the benefit of the doubt — if his agency acted against him and whistleblower protections were needed.
So far, there is no indication the CDC acted against Dr. Thompson, so there was no retaliation to trigger the protections in the Act. It’s important to note that if there is reasonable belief by the employee that he is disclosing something that falls under the headings in the act, the agency has a heavy burden to support any action against him. If there is evidence that the disclosure was a contributing factor in the act against the employee, and knowing about the disclosure and the action being close in time to the disclosure can create such a case (as can other types of evidence), the agency:
can avoid liability only if it demonstrates by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same action in the absence of the whistleblowing.
It makes sense, therefore, that the CDC will be very careful not to take actions that could be seen as retaliation against Thompson if they believe his claims could possibly meet the standards in the whistleblower protection acts.
One more point on this deserves addressing. On page 111 Mr. Barry, the book’s author, claims that Dr. Thompson needs to be subpoenaed to testify before Congress because “it is unlikely that his attorney, an expert in whistleblower cases, would allow him to testify unless compelled.” It’s not quite clear why Mr. Barry thinks that. First, Dr. Thompson is an adult; he doesn’t need permission to testify, though he would be wise to listen to the experienced legal counsel he hired. Second, if his goal, as suggested in the transcripts, is to achieve meaningful reform, why wait for a subpoena? As his lawyer, who specializes in these areas, could have pointed out, the OSC can require an investigation by the agency and then make recommendations to Congress and the CDC. Neither is bound by the OSC’s recommendations, but recommendations by a specialized agency focusing on whistleblowing will almost certainly have an impact. And if Congress decided to investigate before the OSC is done, it could. If the CDC wanted to retaliate, whistleblower protection would come into play with or without a subpoena.
Why wait?
The only explanation I can think of is that Dr. Thompson thinks he may be criminally liable for something, and thinks a subpoena would guarantee immunity. It won’t, however. The only situation in which a subpoena would mean immunity is if Dr. Thompson was forced to testify after asserting a Fifth Amendment claim before Congress. Congress can grant immunity, or partial immunity (meaning Dr. Thompson can still be prosecuted, but not using his own testimony), but doesn’t have to, and it’s not an automatic part of a subpoena. These are two separate things.
Part II: Thompson’s suggestions for reform of vaccine safety oversight
On page 69 to the book, Dr. Thompson explains his suggestion for solving the problems he identifies in CDC’s decision making. He says:
It would end this way. That you would end up with an agency like the National Transportation Safety Board. You know, the FAA; then there’d be NTSB. The FAA is responsible for regulating all sorts of things, but then when an accident happens, you bring in the NTSB. So, you would have the equivalent of an NTSB-like organization that would do vaccine safety studies independently.
Dr. Thompson suggests an institutional solution to the problem he identified. Institutional design is a well-accepted — and heavily studied — part of public administration. But both Dr. Thompson’s problem definition and his proposed solution seem simplistic. Dr. Thompson — and the authors of the book — seem to think the problem is that the CDC has complete control over studying and monitoring vaccine safety, which enables the agency to rig results, and that there is a lack of independence (from industry, presumably?) that motivates it to actually do so. Thompson also seems to think a separate agency will solve the independence problem. Neither part is correct.
Vaccine safety monitoring is done by multiple actors
Even in the United States alone, vaccine safety is handled by more than one body, with a complex interaction both at the federal and state level. To give a simplified and partial picture, the FDA regulates licensing of vaccines, including governing clinical trials, pre and post licensure safety and effectiveness studies, labeling, manufacturing quality, and so forth. A CDC advisory committee recommends vaccines that are then approved by the CDC Director for specific populations. Even there, it’s not the CDC staff, but an advisory committee made of experts and a consumer representative, that makes recommendations which the head of the CDC confirms, and recommendations are also made, on that issue, by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians. Federal advisory committee are heavily regulated by the Federal Advisory Committees Act, which among other things imposes requirements of transparency. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices debates in public and provides detailed, heavily referenced recommendations that are then published (though often a while after they are made): nothing is hidden. The recommendations draw on studies not only from the United States but from the entire world. And those are recommendations: they do not automatically translate into mandates in any state, though they certainly influence the mandates.
In other words, the CDC is not a classic regulatory agency at all. It certainly has an influence on vaccine usage; but it’s not the CDC that can fine manufacturers for wrongdoing or oversees clinical trials. The CDC has additional roles — vaccine distributor; information provision to the public; a role in programs funding vaccines for certain populations; monitoring vaccine usage; and a responsibility for preventing diseases beyond vaccinating alone, for example, via monitoring cases. None of these make it a regulatory agency in the classic sense, and it has not been treated or studied as one.
A large part of the CDC’s role in vaccine regulation is close to NTSB’s role in air safety — research and investigate and recommend after the fact, though Dr. Thompson is right that it is more involved in actually handling vaccines and their influence than NTSB is. But the CDC is still probably closer to NTSB than FAA in this comparison. FDA is the main regulatory agency.
The CDC has a role in monitoring vaccine safety. Part of that role is doing studies. Another is that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System is partly managed by the CDC. But the CDC is not alone in handling vaccine safety: the FDA has a part in that, as does the Institute of Medicine, a private body. Vaccine safety studies post-licensure (which are massive) are done through the Vaccine Safety DataLink. And the studies and results are collected and analyzed primarily by academic researchers independent of the CDC. Researchers in other countries also do studies, and other governments also monitor vaccines, with the information coming from multiple directions.
The diffusion of responsibility between several actors prevents each single actor from completely controlling the information on vaccine safety. The fact that many studies are done abroad also limits the ability of the CDC to control the information. Why would creating one specialized agency guarantee more accountability than a variety of actors that can check each other?
Independence and its feasibility
The second concern those promoting the CDC whistleblower story have is that the CDC’s personnel is too involved with industry in some way — a claim certainly made by Mr. Kennedy in his forward (p. xix) and by Mr. Barry himself (p. xxi and 6). It may be that this is part of Dr. Thompson’s concern.
If that’s what is on his mind, Dr. Thompson should ask himself where members of NTSB come from. According to the board’s website there are currently four members of the board. One previously served with the FAA, one has served with both the CDC and the American Automobile Association; the third was a professional pilot for three decades and worked in regulatory affairs in US Airways; and the fourth had a long career with an airplane manufacturer. The last two, in other words, came from industry, and the Chair came from the FAA.
Reality check: in a specialized area, the majority of people involved in regulation and policy would often have served in more than one role and moved between the players. That’s because their expertise will be sought out. Specialized training takes a long time and is then often sought out by different actors. And often experts have to get hands-on experience somewhere, and in a specialized field the options are limited. And you often want the people regulating to have a mixture of theoretical knowledge and hands-on experience in the area.
You do not want people with no background in air safety having the major say in regulating it or investigating accidents, because lack of expertise, however good the intentions, can easily lead to bad results in a technical area that have real safety implications. For exactly the same reason you do not want people who do not understand infectious diseases and the vaccines that prevent them having the main say on regulating or monitoring them, because they will get it wrong, potentially with very, very bad results. Experts can get it wrong too — but hopefully, much less often. Is there a risk of corruption? Of course. That’s why we want multiple actors and divisions of labor, as well as mechanisms of accountability in place. That’s why you want to think about designing incentives. But you will not be able to get rid of interconnections between the players in a specialized field. Not going to happen, not without sacrificing expertise and knowledge, again, with potentially much, much worse consequences.
Thinking that you can create a magically independent agency to regulate vaccine safety and populate it with people that know what they are doing but do not have connections to industry or other government agencies involved with vaccines is simply unrealistic.
Even if there was extensive evidence of corruption and wrongdoing of the CDC — and the book has not provided that — creating another agency is no panacea, and has very real costs, monetary and in terms of the coordination that will need to happen with that agency. Some more sophisticated thought would be needed to truly analyze what, if any, are the problems with CDC and how to solve them.
Part III: School Mandates and Human Rights
On pp. 128-129 (Chapter 11: First Principles and Moral Courage), Barry argues that freedom from vaccination — and in that case explicitly the freedom of a parent to refuse vaccination for her child — is a human right. This is not the first time we have heard that argument — it was made by Ms. Holland in her article in the book Vaccine Epidemic, chapter 1. Here, as there, it’s used as an attack on school mandates, claiming they violate informed consent. The twist added in Vaccine Whistleblower is to base the opposition on what Barry interprets Dr. Thompson to have disclosed. The passage reads:
If a state is going to force its judgment on a citizen or a parent regarding vaccination (a preventative medical intervention), the safety studies supporting those vaccines must be rock solid. According to Dr. Thompson, the studies are anything but rock solid. The quality of vaccine safety studies is insufficient to support mandatory vaccination.
Given what Dr. Thompson has disclosed, parents should not be removed from the decision-making regarding the health of their children. Parents know their own children’s and their own family’s health history better than their pediatricians and their elected representatives. Parents also know their religious beliefs and their personal relationships with God better than pediatricians, their elected representatives, and employees of their school districts.
The initial premise is incorrect in several ways; and the additional claim also doesn’t hold water.
Whose rights?
First, while I would agree that generally an adult of sound mind should not be forced physically to undergo any medical procedure, including vaccination, though there may be consequences to such refusal (such as quarantine or limiting access to some jobs), the protections do not apply in the same way to children — who do not have a choice either way. This discussion is not about bodily autonomy — which is why the comparison to rape made by anti-vaccine activists is not just reprehensible but incorrect. The question here is the extent of parental rights to make medical decisions for their child.
The view that parents have a human right to refuse vaccination for their children is problematic. Parents usually have a right to make medical decisions for their child — but that right is not, and for some time has not been, absolute — and that’s a good thing. Children are no longer property of their parents, to break and use as the parents will. Modern thinking raises three reasons to support the rights of parents to make those decisions (for a more complete discussion, see “The Rights of the Unvaccinated Child: The Legal Framework“).
First and most important, a child is — generally correctly — considered cognitively unable to make those decisions. Someone has to make them for the child, and in most circumstances it’s the parent who stands as the child’s agent, and makes decisions for the child, since usually the parent can be trusted to represent the child’s best interests.
Second, the parent usually has the responsibility to cover costs of treatment and to deal with the child in many ways. With such responsibility should come the power to make decisions that fit the family’s means and abilities.
Third, we respect privacy of the family and its autonomy, and want to minimize government interference in it. Most iterations of the “my child, my choice” argument seem to emphasize the third reason — but that is, clearly, much weaker than the first.
The main reason to give parents rights is because we hope and believe that usually parents will be the best person to protect the child’s interests. The child is an autonomous being, and children have rights. Parental rights are already limited and regulated by the state. Parents cannot starve or abuse the child. Parents cannot, in California, leave a young child unattended in a car. There are already clear limits on parental powers over a child’s welfare. Given the dramatic imbalance between the risks of vaccinating and the risks of not vaccinating, the state has the authority to step in in this area, too.
If anything, the human right at issue here is the child’s right to health, the right to be protected against preventable diseases via the simple, safe precaution of vaccinating. Not the right of the parent to deprive their child from such protection because they subscribe to anti-vaccine misinformation.
Indeed, in Prince v. Massachusetts, the seminal case about the limits of religious rights when it comes to children’s welfare, the Supreme Court, in a statement that wasn’t part of the ruling but has been incredibly influential, based its support of forced vaccination in part on that:
[a parent] cannot claim freedom from compulsory vaccination for the child more than for himself on religious grounds. The right to practice religion freely does not include liberty to expose the community or the child to communicable disease or the latter to ill health or death.
Prince v. Massachusetts, 321 U.S. 158, 166–67 (1944)
And in another case from New York, a court found not vaccinating against measles, during an outbreak, can amount to medical neglect. (In re Christine M., 595 N.Y.S.2d 606, 616 (N.Y. Fam. Ct. 1992)).
To be clear, my view is that as long as dangerous diseases are reasonably under control in the United States, as long as the threat is not immediate, the state usually should not intervene and force vaccinating. But that’s not because the state does not have authority to intervene. It’s because parental rights, for the reasons above, matter, and where we can respect them without irreversible harm to the child, we should. We have other ways to increase immunization rates besides forcing unwilling parents to vaccinate, and as long as rates of non-vaccination are kept low, herd immunity can protect children. We should avoid the most extreme step unless the child is at immediate risk.
But the state can and should use other means to increase rates, to protect all children and others who may be harmed by disease — including, perhaps especially, children whose parents deny them vaccines.
School mandates are not force vaccinating
Furthermore, school mandates are not “force vaccinating”. Yes, it can seem intrusive and hard to parents who find homeschooling very difficult. But there is a difference in the degree of state intervention and the level of coerciveness. Contrary to some of the language we have heard, school immunization mandates do not mean anyone will be coming to the house of parents with a gun and force vaccinating, or throwing parents in jail. It’s just not direct coercion.
Even if we acknowledge parental rights to refuse vaccination in most circumstances, that does not mean they have a corresponding right to send that child to school unvaccinated and risk other students’ health. School immunization mandates are a traditional public health policy in the United States, dating back to the 19th century, and they have been upheld by every court, state or federal, that ruled on them, because even the strongest formulation of parental rights does not give a parent a right to impose the risk of disease they choose for their own child on others or their children. Your child is not the only one at school; low vaccination rates make schools less safe for others; and a parent does not have a right to make that choice for other parents and their children.
School mandates and Dr. Thompson’s claims
As to the claim that Dr. Thompson’s allegation are an argument against mandates — first, it’s not clear that Dr. Thompson’s claims undermine even the 2004 paper, as Dr. Gorski’s review of the book demonstrates. Second, the 2004 paper is not the only one on MMR, and is not actually a “principal” one, in spite of the book’s claims; even for MMR, it’s one of many studies — and a small, localized study, with substantially less power than, for example, the large scale Danish or Finnish studies. Third, even if the alleged connection had power, and if the 2004 paper was the only or principal paper on MMR, it would be relevant, at most, for African American boys who received the MMR between 18-36 months: so if an African American boy was not vaccinated on time, the solution is simple: vaccinate after the age of 36 months, where no correlation was found. It certainly does not support the wholesale exemption of children from immunization mandates, something that would increase the risk of disease in schools.
Contrary to the author’s claims, the transcripts do not negate the science examining if there’s a link between MMR and autism, or vaccines and autism generally. They are not an argument against school immunization mandates — a traditional policy, aimed at making schools safer.

Maine considers protecting quacks from accountability to regulators and patients
The Maine Legislature is considering a bill that would put quacks beyond the reach of state healthcare regulatory authorities and leave patients without effective redress for harms.
Jann Bellamy on April 25, 2019
Link

UPDATE: The bill described in this post passed in the Maine Legislature and became law without the Governor’s signature on June 11, 2019. 
Quacks who misrepresent the safety and effectiveness of their treatments or cause physical or financial injury to patients will be protected from accountability for their harms under a bill now before the Maine Legislature. The “Right to Practice Complementary and Alternative Health Care Act” would protect CAM practitioners, such as homeopaths, herbalists, energy healers, and assorted other purveyors of pseudoscience, from prosecution for violating state health care regulations, including the unlicensed practice of medicine or any other health care profession, in exchange for, well, pretty much nothing in the way of protecting their patients.
The bill, S.P 104 (also referred to as L.D. 364), allows any person who provides “alternative or complementary health care services,” but who is not licensed in Maine as health care practitioner, to provide those services as long as he or she doesn’t do some things that normally fall within the purview of physicians or other licensed health care practitioners, such as surgery, setting fractures, prescribing drugs, performing chiropractic adjustments, administering or prescribing ionizing radiation, or recommending the discontinuance of drugs or devices prescribed by a licensed practitioner.
In exchange for this substantial protection, all the CAM practitioner has to do is give the patient some contact information (address, phone number), tell the patient about his “degrees, training, experience, credentials or other qualifications” (although no such education and training is required, nor does anyone check on its content) and that he is not licensed, and explain “the nature of the health care services to be provided.” Once these boxes are checked, the bill declares, the CAM practitioner is deemed not to have violated “any law relating to the licensing of health care professionals”, no matter what he does or the harm he may cause.
Several deficiencies immediately come to mind:
    • The bill does not define what is meant by “healthcare services,” other than they be “complementary or alternative,” which is also undefined. Basically, this leaves it up to individual CAM practitioners to determine their scope of practice.
    • There is no prohibition on diagnosing or treating any disease or condition, real or fabricated.
    • There is no requirement that the CAM practitioner urge the patient to seek medical advice or refer to a licensed health care practitioner when a condition is outside of his scope of practice, whatever that might be.
    • There is no requirement of informed consent. The patient need not be told of the risks of a therapy, the evidence (if any) of its benefits, nor advised regarding what other treatments may be effective for the patient’s condition.
    • There is no oversight of these CAM practices by any regulatory body. The Board of Medicine, as well as other health care regulatory authorities, would have no power to step in and stop any CAM practitioner, no matter how dangerous. The state cannot set education and training requirements; require criminal background checks; prevent false advertising, conflicts of interest, or financial or sexual exploitation of patients (at least those prohibitions established by the state’s licensing laws); or require reporting (e.g., of infectious diseases, adverse events, or child or elder abuse).
    • While patients maintain their right to sue for negligence or seek other civil remedies, there is no requirement that practitioners have insurance to satisfy their claims. (Which, in turn, is a huge impediment to finding an attorney to take one’s case, not to mention collecting on any judgment.) And because there is no standard of care, how would one define negligence? What is, for example, the standard of care for, say, iridology and how does one fall below it?
    • There is no requirement that a practitioner maintain patient records of symptoms, examination, diagnosis, prognosis, or treatment and response thereto, nor are there confidentiality requirements for patient information.
S.P. 104 was heard by a joint Committee on Health Coverage, Insurance, and Financial Services on April 17. According to the Maine Legislature’s website, the Committee voted “ought to pass” with an amendment, but no information on the amendment is available. There were 81 separate testimonies on the bill filed with the Committee. Of those, only one, the Maine Nurse Practitioner Association (MNPA), to their credit, testified against the bill. The MNPA made a number of very good points, for which none of the promoters offered any solutions. In addition to some of the problems listed above, the MNPA noted
these unlicensed providers can perform an exhaustive list of things normally assigned to a licensed health care provider, including counseling, evaluations (including mental health evaluations, diagnosis, and therapy), procedures such as pelvic, breast, rectal exams and wound care, osteopathic manipulation, occupational and physical therapy, and dental hygiene.
Homeopaths; herbalists (including the “intuitive energetic” variety); reiki masters (including long-distance reiki); healing touch practitioners; “certified” “holistic” health coaches; Ayurveda practitioners; essential oil sellers; and practitioners of polarity and cranial sacral therapies, Emotional Freedom Technique, Neuro-Linguistic Programming, and other assorted purveyors of pseudoscience, submitted testimony in favor of the “right” to practice complementary and alternative medicine unimpeded by pesky state regulators who might call them to account for their actions. Some of their patients chimed in with their “it worked for me” anecdotes. In reading these testimonies, several themes were repeated:
    • CAM is “popular” so it must be allowed, with no acknowledgment that this alleged “popularity” could be based on optimistic expectations of benefit promoted by practitioners but unsupported by the evidence.
    • The absolute conviction that their treatments “worked” despite not one citation to convincing evidence of effectiveness, although there was a heavy reliance on anecdotes.
    • The equally absolute conviction that CAM treatments do no harm.
Testimony from the committee hearing demonstrates these convictions, as well as the proponents’ attempts to paint the most benign portrait possible of CAM practices. This soft-pedaling is belied in some cases a perusal of their websites, which revealed more enthusiastic claims for their abilities. Some examples:
A healing touch practitioner told the committee about its use for cancer “support services” such as pain management, yet the website of her practice claims healing touch actually “enhances the immune system accelerating the body’s self-healing abilities” and “speeds up recovery time from surgery” (neither of which is proven) based on a totally implausible mechanism of “clearing energy congestion that forms in our energy fields and centers.”
A “certified holistic health coach” and reiki practitioner told the committee she does not diagnose or treat disease, yet her website claims that regular treatments with reiki and doTERRA essential oils will “support the body in healing” during “an acute health crisis” and prevent disease. She says that proactive health care and doTERRA essential oils take care of “most health issues for her and her family”, implying that the same can be true for you. A video on her website maintains that the positive health benefits of essential oils are “boundless”.
One woman, a Bowen practitioner, conveniently failed to explain to the committee just what that is. Her website claims Bowenwork can “help” with “practically anything” by, among other nonsensical mechanisms of action, “trigger[ing] the autonomic nervous system to switch from ‘fight – flight’ to ‘rest – restore’ mode.” She says Bowenwork is effective for asthma, concussions, migraines and depression, and, for babies, colic, and digestive issues.
One homeopath told this disturbing anecdote in her testimony:
When my son was born with the cord around his neck and after receiving oxygen would not stop screaming. The midwife gave him a homeopathic remedy for shock. Within seconds my son stopped screaming and looked into my eyes for the first time.
Her website claims, without evidence, that homeopathic remedies prescribed by her after consultation “help” depression, addition [sic], diabetes, eating disorders, cancer, high blood pressure, Lyme disease, STDs, autism, ADD/HD, Alzheimer’s, infertility and hormonal imbalances. She also offers homeoprophylaxis “to expose the individual to the energy state of a disease prior to exposure” for childhood “infections [sic] diseases.”
Another homeopath testifying in favor of the bill (who also practices Heartmath, therapeutic touch, flower essences and “attunement” as well as homeopathy) is less coy about the uses of homeoprophylaxis on her website: She openly promotes it as an alternative to vaccination. Understandably, neither woman mentions homeoprophylaxis to the committee.
Other homeopaths supporting the bill testified, more openly, that they have used homeopathy to treat epidemics in third-world countries and trained medical personnel and birth attendants there in “acute care homeopathy” and that homeopathy “has demonstrated efficacy” in treating addiction and decreasing relapse rates among those with opioid dependence.
(It hardly bears repeating, but, for the record, homeopathy is not, and cannot be, effective for anything.)
One reflexologist benignly described reflexology as
the application of pressure to reflex maps found in the feet, hands, and outer ears. The techniques applied stimulate neural pathways and the relaxation response, to support the body to function optimally.
Yet, on her website she says that reflexology improves the “function of internal organs and glands” and “balance all body systems” and that the reflexologist has the requisite knowledge to understand “how the body works and how specific conditions or illnesses work.” She also claims that something called “reflexology lymph drainage” “really works” for autoimmune diseases, depression, pain and Lyme disease, but needs to do “one or two case studies” on effectiveness for Parkinson’s disease, so “please get in touch if you are interested, and we can chat about it,” “it” apparently meaning your becoming a guinea pig in an non-IRB approved human trial.
An “intuitive energetic herbalist” and herbal apothecary owner with no medical training told the committee her current specialty is providing “herbal support options and information to those suffering from Lyme Disease and Lyme Co-infections,” presumably including “Chronic Lyme.” Her website claims she creates “extraordinary medicines”. Another herbalist maintained that she is not diagnosing and treating but appears to be doing exactly that by, per her website, considering a patient’s symptoms and recommending herbs (in other words, untested, unpurified drugs that are only lightly regulated by the FDA) for treatment. A third herbalist told the committee she has given herbal remedies to everyone from a five-day-old infant to patients in their 90s. Another herbalist who testified believes, according to her website, that “chronic Lyme” is a valid diagnosis and that ILADS is a “wonderful resource” on Lyme disease.
Others presenting testimony to the committee included an Ayurvedic practitioner who is clearly diagnosing and treating patients without any sort of license, and practitioner of “biosonic repatterning,” a nonsensical method on Quackwatch’s list of questionable therapies, and a practitioner of polarity therapy (also nonsensical) who claims it is “profoundly effective in resolving or relieving physical and mental health issues.”
In an obviously unintentional demonstration of just how effective CAM practitioners are in selling patients on their nostrums, people told the committee that homeopathy had improved a son’s autism, helped a child recover from a serious auto accident, cured migraines, asthma, allergies, and food poisoning (in 15 minutes!), helped with digestive issues, and ameliorated a detached retina to the point that less extensive surgery was required. Ayurveda treatments cured “hyperthyroid” and anemia in one month; herbal remedies and Qigong cleared up psoriasis.
According to the National Health Freedom Action, an organization that promotes a consumer’s right to be bamboozled by quackery (as well as “vaccine choice”), nine states currently have some sort of “health freedom” law protecting quacks from accountability for their actions, and bills similar to Maine’s are pending or about to be introduced in three additional states. Other states have somewhat greater protections, though, such as registration requirements, additional disclosures, prohibitions against convicted felons from practicing CAM, penalties for violations, and prohibitions against sex with patients. Nevada requires that the practitioner advise the patient to tell his real doctor what he is up to, prohibits diagnosing, defines (sort of) the services that can be provided and imposes liability on the practitioner in some situations, although only the most egregious.
None of this makes so-called “health freedom” laws a good idea. Ironically, healthcare practitioners with the most education and training are subjected to licensing requirements (even if they are inadequate) while those, including convicted felons, with credentials from on-line “certification” outfits, or no education and training at all, are free to lie to patients about the safety and effectiveness of their remedies, as well as act as infectious agents for pseudoscience promoted by others. Patients harmed financially, emotionally and physically will be left with virtually no redress and state regulators are rendered helpless to act on their behalf.

Sen. Rubio’s proposed tax shelters for quackery
Sen. Marco Rubio has again introduced a bill that would subsidize quackery by providing a tax-sheltered way to pay for homeopathy, herbs, and other pseudoscience.
Jann Bellamy on July 1, 2021
Link

Once again, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) has introduced a bill (S. 380) providing a tax sheltered way to pay for quackery. The bill allows taxpayers to include homeopathic remedies as “medical care” for the purposes of itemizing federal tax deductions. Because Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) use the same rules for allowable medical expenses as itemized deductions, homeopathic remedies will also be a permitted medical expense for HSAs. The bill also adds herbs, vitamins, minerals, and other dietary and nutritional supplements as allowed “medical care” for itemized deductions and HSAs, whether medically necessary or not, as well as exercise equipment, personal trainers, and health coaches, among other goodies.
Regrettably, as you shall see, itemized deductions and Health Savings Accounts are already being used to subsidize healthcare pseudoscience. Sen. Rubio’s bill simply adds to the problem by encouraging the use of ineffective and possibly harmful products with tax incentives. This is yet another example of Legislative Alchemy: instead of protecting consumers from pseudoscience, the law perversely protects pseudoscience by legalizing it and promoting its use.
Today, we’ll briefly review itemized deductions and HSAs and take a look at how they are currently being employed to pay for quackery, a topic I covered on SBM several years ago (also here). Then we’ll see how S. 380, if enacted, would operate to subsidize (as Dr. Gorski aptly calls it) the one quackery to rule them all – homeopathy – as well as supplements and other “natural” remedies.
But first, a few things to keep in mind as you read this post:
Homeopathic remedies do not, and cannot, work. As CAM expert Dr. Edzard Ernst pointed out a just few days ago, (1) homeopathic remedies are dangerous when they contain nothing because they leave illness untreated; and (2) homeopathic remedies are dangerous when they contain something because they may poison patients. Because none of the homeopathic remedies on the U.S. market today have gone through a legally-required FDA review, the agency has announced that all homeopathic remedies on the market are subject to enforcement action, although it is pursuing a risk-based enforcement policy for now. As well, the FTC issued a policy statement that
An OTC homeopathic drug claim that is not substantiated by competent and reliable scientific evidence [in other words, all of them – JB] might not be deceptive if the advertisement or label where it appears effectively communicates that: 1) there is no scientific evidence that the product works; and 2) the product’s claims are based only on theories of homeopathy from the 1700s that are not accepted by most modern medical experts.
Except for certain populations or those with demonstrated deficiencies, the vast majority of dietary supplements have insufficient evidence of safety and effectiveness to warrant their use and may even be harmful.
Herbs are not only unnecessary, they are too often adulterated, as are dietary supplements.
Tax shelters for quackery
Most U.S. taxpayers are already familiar with itemized deductions, which allow certain expenses (such as charitable contributions and medical and dental expenses) to be deducted from taxable income in prescribed circumstances, although recent changes to the tax laws made them less beneficial for most taxpayers.
You may be less familiar with Health Savings Accounts, which are paired with high-deductible health insurance policies. Consumers make tax-free contributions to their HSAs and the money grows tax-free. (For calendar year 2021, the IRS limits on annual contributions to HSAs are $3,600 for individuals and $7,200 for families.) Consumers pay the full cost of medical care out of their HSAs until the deductible is met, although some preventive services, such as vaccines and screenings, are exempt from this requirement. No tax is paid on the distributions from the HSA either, giving the taxpayer a triple benefit.
(Yes, Canadians, Englishpersons, and residents of other countries with logical healthcare systems, the U.S. really is that screwy.)
When I last wrote about HSAs, then-President Trump was attempting to follow through on his promise to “repeal and replace” Obamacare “on day one”. Various plans were in the making, most of which involved an expansion of HSAs combined with high-deductible health insurance policies. Obamacare is still with us, having recently survived yet another attack by Republicans, but so are attempts to expand the use of HSAs, which are seen in certain conservative circles as requiring consumers to have more “skin in the game” when they purchase health care services and products. If consumers can save money tax-free and decide when to spend that money for health care, the thinking goes, they will make smarter choices and slow rising health care costs. Current research does not support this assumption and some evidence suggests that consumers with HSAs may actually forego necessary medical care.
My particular problem with itemized medical deductions and HSAs is that they avoid the evidence-based medical care requirements imposed by traditional public and private health insurance policies, partly as a means of controlling costs. Although, in my view, public insurance like Medicare and some private insurers are too liberal in covering pseudoscience like acupuncture and chiropractic, the rules for itemized deductions and HSAs pretty much abandon any requirement that medical care be evidence-based.
HSAs can be used to pay for “qualified medical expenses“, which are, as I said, defined by the IRS using the same rules as if you were taking a deduction for unreimbursed medical expenses.
“Medical expenses” include:
the costs of diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease, and the costs for treatments affecting any part or function of the body. These expenses include payments for legal medical services rendered by physicians, surgeons, dentists, and other medical practitioners.
According to the IRS, in addition to physicians and dentists, chiropractors and Christian Science practitioners are specifically included, so there is no question that “medical expenses” incurred by their patients are eligible for itemized deductions or payment via an HSA. Acupuncture is also included among permissible treatments.
The phrase “payments for legal medical services rendered by . . . other medical practitioners” in the IRS’s rules at least implies that naturopaths, homeopaths, acupuncturists and TCM practitioners are covered in states where they are regulated if they have the legal authority to diagnose and treat. Unfortunately, via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, diagnosis and treatment is, to my knowledge, legal in all states where these practitioners are licensed or registered.
According to the non-profit C.H.I.L.D. (Children’s Healthcare is a Legal Duty):
In 2000, the IRS wrote that the “experience, qualification, or title” of the person rendering the services is irrelevant to whether they are allowed as a deductible medical care expense. Whether anyone besides the person paying for the service thinks it is medical is also irrelevant. (Letter from Congressman Tom Latham to Rita Swan, Dec. 15, 2000) Thus, the only real criterion was that the person paying for the service believes its primary purpose is to heal, prevent, relieve, or diagnose disease. If the customer believed that, then the service was deductible medical care.
(I have not been able to verify that this is the IRS’s current position although, even if it’s been amended, quackery is still very much deductible.)
Companies offering HSAs have differing takes on the scope of CAM eligible for payment via an HSA. (For a fee, these companies manage the money in your HSA and provide a debit card or on-line account for disbursements.) For example, HSA for America takes a liberal view of coverage:
Only health insurance policies that allow to [sic] you open a health savings account give you tax deductions to offset the cost of therapies not covered by traditional health insurance. You can use HSA funds for acupuncture, aromatherapy, Ayurvedic Medicine, homeopathy, nutritional consulting, and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), among other therapies.
Unsurprisingly, naturopaths have an expansive view of HSA coverage as well. Per the California Naturopathic Doctors Association
Money in your HSA can be used to pay for qualifying medical expenses, including medical appointments with your naturopathic doctor, lab tests, prescribed supplements, over-the-counter products, and other medically necessary prescribed services (for instance, massages for back pain). . . . You may ask your [naturopathic] doctor for a Letter of Medical Necessity detailing your dietary supplement prescriptions for reimbursement.
In contrast, private health insurers exclude most quackery from policy coverage. For example, Aetna substantially limits coverage for acupuncture and chiropractic and excludes a long list of diagnostic methods and treatments “because there is inadequate evidence in the peer-reviewed published medical literature of their effectiveness”, including naturopathic favorites like (potentially dangerous) IV infusions of curcumin, micronutrients, and Vitamin C, applied kinesiology, bioidentical hormones, chelation therapy, ozone therapy, colonic irrigation, Gerson therapy, live blood cell analysis, and visceral manipulation, among others.
In any event, while taking disproportionately large itemized deductions can be a red flag for the IRS, the chances of being penalized for an unauthorized itemized medical deduction or payment from an HSA are vanishingly slim. The IRS audited only 0.4% of all individual tax returns in 2019.
Which brings us, finally, to S. 380. In addition to Sen. Rubio, whose press release fails to mention the parts about homeopathy, dietary supplements, and exercise equipment, the bill has one co-sponsor, Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC). Sen. Scott serves as co-chair of the industry-controlled Congressional Dietary Supplement Caucus. (You can see who else is a member here, although note that the list is undated and may not be current.)
S. 380 would supplant the IRS’s (already liberal) position on the deductibility of supplements. In its most recent publication on deductible medical expenses (and therefore expenses eligible for use of HSA funds) the IRS states that
You can’t include in medical expenses the cost of nutritional supplements, vitamins, herbal supplements, “natural medicines,” etc., unless they are recommended by a medical practitioner as treatment for a specific medical condition diagnosed by a physician.
Unfortunately, this still leaves a lot of wiggle room for quackery: in some states, naturopaths and chiropractors can legally call themselves “physicians”. And one can have, say, one’s cancer diagnosed by a real physician (that is, an MD or DO) and still be “treated” for cancer by a naturopath or acupuncturist.
In any event, S. 380 would effectively overrule the IRS’s current interpretation by allowing an itemized deduction for, or the use of HSA funds to pay for, any herbs, vitamins, minerals, meal replacement products and “other dietary and nutritional supplements”, as well as homeopathic remedies, up to a limit of $1,000 annually. This accomplishes two things. First, it will remove any impediment to paying for these products with HSA funds or claiming a medical deduction when recommended by a naturopath, acupuncturist, chiropractor, or other medical practitioner, even in the absence of “a specific medical condition diagnosed by a physician”. Even more expansively, it will allow consumers to purchase these products with HSA funds off the shelf, or deduct their cost, without any recommendation from a practitioner and without having to show medical necessity.
Interestingly, while “meal replacement products” are defined to jibe with FDA rules, there is no legal definition provided for herbs, dietary and nutritional supplements, or homeopathic remedies.
In a boon for another industry, the bill also expands “medical care” to include amounts paid (again with a $1,000 annual limitation):
(i) for equipment for use in a program (including a self-directed program) of physical exercise or physical activity,
(ii) to participate, or receive instruction, in a program of physical exercise, nutrition, or health coaching (including a self-directed program), and
(iii) for membership at a fitness facility.
Again, none of these terms are defined. Outside of established professionals like physical therapists and registered dietitians, jobs like personal training, nutrition counseling, and health coaching are largely unregulated and evidence-based standards are lacking. (“Certification” programs are no guarantee of safety or effectiveness.) And how many NordicTracks and Pelotons sit gathering cobwebs in the basement?
To be complete, I should note that a similar Senate bill has been introduced by Sen. Kevin Cramer (R-ND), S. 1654, to make amounts spent on dietary supplements tax deductible (and therefore allowable HSA expenses). Unlike Sen. Rubio’s bill, there is no annual limit and it does not cover homeopathic remedies or exercise equipment, health coaching, and the like. This bill has no co-sponsors.
GovTrack gives both bills a 1% chance of being enacted, although I don’t know how reliable their methodology is. While I am happy to see this, it does not make it any less important to call the Senators out. The law should protect consumers from quackery, not subsidize it. It is especially appalling to see the disconnect between Sen. Rubio’s bill and the two federal agencies charged with protecting consumers from ineffective and unsafe products: the FDA and the FTC. The latter basically acknowledge homeopathy is pseudoscience and are doing something (albeit far too little) about it. Sens. Rubio and Scott, on the other hand, want to encourage consumers to use homeopathy by providing a tax sheltered way to pay for it. That is inexcusable.

Legislators want “pharmaceutical cost transparency”. Are they asking the wrong question?
Scott Gavura on May 21, 2015
Link

If science-based medicine is unaffordable, then your care won’t be science-based. Prescription drug costs are one of the biggest concerns in health care today. There seems to be no upper limit on prices, with some new treatments costing over $1,000 per day. The arrival of new drugs to treat (and cure) hepatitis C has created a perfect pharmaceutical storm: highly effective treatments, a large population of potential patients, and huge per-patient costs. It’s renewing the debate about whether important medical treatments are being priced out of the reach of the patients that need them. It’s not just hepatitis. Cancer drug costs are rising as well, driven by more patients and new drugs that in some cases are transforming our expectations about what cancer drugs can do. And while many of us rely on some form of drug insurance to protect us from high drug costs, insurers are struggling with balancing coverage and premiums: A report by Express Scripts paints a grim picture:
An estimated 576,000 Americans spent more than the median household income on prescription medications in 2014. This population of patients grew an astounding 63% from 2013. Further, the population of patients with costs of $100,000 or more nearly tripled during the same time period, to nearly 140,000 people. The total cost impact to payers from both patient populations is an unsustainable $52 billion a year.
This isn’t just an issue in the United States. Prescription drug costs are climbing around the world, because we’re effectively all in this together: We all rely on private companies to bring new drugs to market, and we’re largely buying the same drugs from the same small group of companies. Because ready access to safe and effective prescription drugs is so important to the practice of medicine and the delivery of health care, the pharmaceutical industry is heavily regulated – not just by the FDA, but by regulators worldwide. Yet despite the dual requirements of regulatory disclosure and the financial obligation to be transparent (as many pharmaceutical companies are publicly-held), little is known about how much it costs to bring drugs to market, and how manufacturers arrive at their selling prices. Pharmaceutical manufacturers claim that high drug costs reflect the high costs of research and development (R&D), and provide the incentives for companies to invest heavily and take risks, when many drugs may never make it to market. Are they correct? 
I’ve written before about different attempts to estimate how much it costs to develop a drug. This is obvious a point of contention, with pharmaceutical companies interested in profiling the risk and significant investments they make, while using high prices as the justification to support continued risky R&D. Detractors and critics believe that these estimates are overstated by industry. The most well-known analysis of drug development costs is by Joe DiMasi at the Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development. DiMasi collected R&D data for a basket of drugs that were volunteered by pharmaceutical companies, in order to come up with average drug development estimates. His original calculation was $802 million per drug, back in 2003. Today his updated estimate is $2.6 billion per drug. But there have been multiple critiques of DiMasi’s methodology and estimates over the years. Even Andrew Witty, the head of GlaxoSmithKine, one of the largest pharmaceutical companies, has called the $1 billion price tag “a myth” of industry. A critique of the latest DiMasi cost estimate appeared the New England Journal of Medicine earlier this month. In a commentary, Jerry Avorn made the following observations:
    • The raw data from DiMasi is not available for analysis (and likely never will be, given it was provided in confidence by manufacturers).
    • The analysis assumes 80% of new compounds are abandoned during development (and costs them accordingly) yet this number cannot be independently verified.
    • $1.2 billion of the $2.6 billion is the “cost of capital”, rather than a direct cost of development. The cost of capital is estimated at 10.6% which seem high compared to rates pharmaceutical companies pay on their own bonds. Given the significant cash holdings by the bigger companies, access to capital does not seem to be an issue.
    • Public subsidies into drug development are not addressed or accounted for.
Avorn highlights that not all costs are climbing: FDA approval times are shortening (compared to prior analyses), reducing the overall estimated costs of development. Given the collective costs of the “failures” are higher than the costs of the successful drugs, the DiMasi analysis suggests that it is the development process itself, rather than regulation, that may be driving the pricing of drugs. Avorn concludes with a call for more transparency on development costs as a first step in a dialogue on how to support research, while appropriately rewarding innovation. Some American state legislators aren’t waiting for industry reaction – and they’re proposing legislation to force the discussion.
Forcing R&D cost disclosure
Responding to repeated calls for transparency, and struggling with their own prescription drug cost bills, some states are looking to legislation to help manage prescription drug costs, perhaps by publicly pressuring manufacturers into reconsidering their pricing. The latest strategy was announced recently by New York Senator Ruben Diaz:
New York is the latest state to introduce a “pharmaceutical cost transparency act,” following five others—California, Oregon, Massachusetts, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania. Like the bills before it, New York would require pharmaceutical manufacturers to submit a report to the state outlining the total costs of the production of certain expensive drugs, with the information to be published on a public website.
The bill would force pharmaceutical manufacturers to disclose specific information for a drug that costs more than $10,000 per year – a detailed disclosure of production and sales data:
    • Total R&D paid by the manufacturer (and any predecessor)
    • The total costs of clinical trials and regulatory costs
    • Total costs to manufacture (fabricate) the drug product itself
    • Total costs paid by other entities (e.g., governments) on direct R&D
    • Any other costs to acquire the drugs (e.g., patents and licensing)
    • Total marketing and advertising costs, including costs of promotion to physicians
    • The average wholesale price, with changes over time
    • Total profit attributable to the drug
    • Financial assistance provided by manufacturers
While this sounds like it might be an attractive approach to forcing transparency, it ignores a very real cost that the DiMasi analysis acknowledges: Most new drugs don’t succeed, and companies depend on the “hits” to stay profitable. Looking only at the cost of the “hits” ignore much of the real cost of drug development. Hundreds of millions of dollars, if not billions, have been invested in studying drugs to treat Alzheimer’s disease with strikeout after strikeout. Pfizer had invested about $800 million in torcetrapib when it discovered the drug was killing patients instead of preventing cardiovascular disease. The road to blockbuster drugs, like the new hepatitis treatments, is paved in part by well-documented, very costly, pharmaceutical development failures.
Even if we acknowledge (and I think we must) that companies have to cover the costs of their failures as well as their hits, is there any value in forcing disclosure about the hits alone? This approach is almost certainly going to underestimate the “real” cost of development, as not every cost can be traced to a specific drug. DiMasi estimated the costs of some of the earliest development stages of drug development, recognizing that you can’t attribute costs to any specific chemical. How else can you allocate the costs of pre-clinical research that may generate dozens or even hundreds of possible drug candidates? The development stage includes screening promising chemicals, validating them, and then modifying the chemical structure repeatedly to find the compound that represents the best possible candidate for future study. Only a fraction of drugs ever proceed beyond this step. Derek Lowe goes over this in much more detail in one of his old posts – he’s in the business of drug development, and knows of what he speaks. This is a tedious, time-consuming, often unproductive process.
There are also the ongoing costs of making a drug available – the costs of meeting regulatory requirements, and the overhead cost of running a business with tens of thousands of employees. The legislation ignores all of those costs as well, focusing only on that can be directly linked to a chemical. If this type of legislation succeeds, while it may be more transparent (in part) than the DiMasi paper, it will be no more helpful in helping us understand pharmaceutical R&D costs and pricing.
Another approach to estimating costs
Matthew Herper writing in Forbes in 2013, took a crude yet simple approach to estimating costs. He added up the R&D expenses disclosed by pharmaceutical companies on their financial statements and divided it by the number of drugs produced over time. What he concluded was that some companies were spending astonishing amounts to produce new drugs. Abbott (now called AbbVie) was spending $13 billion per drug (and device) produced. Sanofi appeared to be spending $10 billion per drug. And so on, down to small companies which appear to be bringing new products to market for well under $100 million. Herper noted that 66 companies launched only one drug in decade, with a median cost of $350 million for that single product. Herper’s analysis adds some credibility to the high estimates from Tufts, and only seems to suggest how unproductive the R&D process appears to be for the bigger companies. But his analysis misses a lot of context: It doesn’t adjust for new uses for old drugs. Nor does it clarify the effects of mergers and acquisitions on costs. And while these are real limitations, the analysis looks like a reasonable approximation of the challenge. As I’ve noted before, while there have been some remarkable new and effective drugs developed, the industry as a whole appears to be suffering from a productivity problem, as illustrated by this 2012 image from a paper by Scannell et al. (now paywalled), showing the number of drugs produced per billion of dollars in R&D:

Will breaking patents help?
Companies can only maintain high prices in the market when they have patent protection. Another approach that’s been proposed to deal with high prices has been to allow patents on high-cost drugs to be broken, to allow early generic competition. Driven in part by skepticism about development costs, advocates for this approach argue that drug costs that bankrupt individuals are immoral and unethical. Better to change the rules, they argue, rather than let patient suffer. And this kind of proposal isn’t restricted to poor countries. Senator Bernie Sanders has proposed the same approach to help the Department of Veterans Affairs afford the cost of the new hepatitis drugs:
Our nation’s veterans cannot, and should not, be denied treatment while drug companies rake in billions of dollars in profits.
In some cases, pharmaceutical companies are breaking their own patents. Gilead is the patent-holder and manufacturer of the hepatitis blockbuster sofosbuvir (Sovaldi) and it is allowing generic companies to produce and sell their product into developing countries. Realistically, I don’t see arbitrary patent-breaking as gaining much traction, as most realize that it would possibly do more to undermine R&D investment in new drugs than any other strategy. Changing the rules of the game, when drug development can take decades, could jeopardize any investment in the areas where we need new treatments, particularly where the rewards seem modest at best. Antibiotics are an example of the disconnect between medical need (high) and drugs in development (few). Growing concerns about antibiotic resistance are heightened by the reality that there are few new antibiotics in development. If we don’t have effective antibiotics, even everyday infections can be deadly. What seems necessary, perhaps is a better linkage between the value of new treatments and the incentives that in place to develop them. Breaking the patents on drugs we don’t want to pay for wouldn’t address this problem, or the overall productivity challenge in development.
Is “cost of development” even the right question to ask?
To continue to improve science-based medicine, we need to find a way to introduce new innovative treatments at prices that that are affordable. Looking at R&D costs for solutions may be the wrong question to ask. What really matters is if a particular treatment delivers value. A new treatment may be worth the high cost if it avoids other costs, such as the potential for a vaccine to prevent cancer (e.g., HPV) or for a drug to eliminate the need for a liver transplant (e.g., the new hepatitis treatments). From that perspective, the R&D costs aren’t something we should focus on. We don’t ask (or care) what it costs to develop a new car, or the latest phone. What matters is whether we value the benefits of the “new” versus the status quo. The challenge with drugs (and with healthcare in general) is that (1) assessing value is difficult when it comes to health treatments and (2) we are often shielded (via insurance) from directly bearing the costs ourselves. New drugs need to show value in the calculation of their cost. And we also need to do what we can to bring the costs of development (and innovation) down. Otherwise we run the risk of less innovation and fewer new treatments that don’t offer value for the price.
Conclusion
As health professionals, consumers and as patients, it’s perhaps relevant to question what it is we expect in terms of new medicine. We’ve become accustomed to new treatments that transform diseases or even prevent them. Yet productivity is dropping and costs are rising. Is there a common ground we can agree on? There would likely be a strong consensus that we want new treatments that are truly innovative (safer and more effective) compared to current treatments. And these innovations have to be valued by patients as delivering meaningful benefits. To get there, we can likely all agree that we must support measures that foster R&D, particularly those that help identify promising drug candidates sooner, thereby reducing the costs of failures. We need to balance rigorous regulation during development with the imperative to ensure patient safety during trials, and after the drug is released. And we cannot overlook the need to understand how much better a new treatment is compared to what we’re doing now. In doing so, we should get a better sense of what it should cost to develop a new drug. And the price we eventually pay needs to support a R&D culture that continues to advance, in an affordable way, improvements in the way we deliver medical care today, and into the future.

   No Education? No Training? No License? No Problem!
Jann Bellamy 
Link
When Daniel David Palmer, the inventor of chiropractic, and his acolytes first took up the practice of chiropractic, around the turn of the last century, they were jailed for the unlicensed practice of medicine. If history had left them there, we might not be fighting a continuing battle with the pseudoscience that is “alternative” medicine today.
Unfortunately, the Kansas legislature intervened on the chiropractors’ behalf and passed the first chiropractic practice act in 1913. Over the years, state by state, the notions that subluxations interfere with nerve flow, causing ill health, and that only chiropractors could “correct” these subluxations, thereby restoring health, were incorporated into state law. As well, chiropractors were given a broad scope of practice and allowed to call themselves “doctor.” In 1974, Louisiana’s passage of a chiropractic practice act made chiropractic legal in all 50 states.
Acupuncturists and naturopaths copied this successful formula by convincing state legislatures to incorporate their pseudoscientific ideas directly into practice acts, thereby managing to become licensed health care providers. Legislative fiat triumphed over scientific facts time after time.
Laws allowing the practice of “alternative” medicine did not totally eliminate resistance to pseudoscientific practices from some quarters. Insurance companies, for example, refused to pay for treatments they considered experimental. Medicare did not cover chiropractic. Labs and x-ray facilities wouldn’t allow use of their services. But for each roadblock science tried to put in the way, state and federal legislators were there to remove it, paving the way toward “acceptance.”
Finally, even medical doctors were unable to resist the enticing smell of money wafting over from “alternative” clinics. Again legislators smoothed the transition from medicine to “alternative” medicine by effectively doing away with a science-based standard of care.
Still, this was not enough in the eyes of some. It deprived those seeking “health freedom” the “right” to choose whatever health care they wanted from whatever practitioner they wanted. So the legislatures of three states — Minnesota (2000),Rhode Island (2002) and New Mexico (2009 ) — came up with an equitable solution by essentially setting up a separate health care profession: the unlicensed practice of health care. In fact, the laws of both Rhode Island and New Mexico are titled the “Unlicensed Health Care Practice Act.” At least they’re up front about it.
(Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana and Oklahoma also provide some legal cover for unlicensed practitioners, mainly by protecting them from prosecution for the practice of medicine.)
Ironically, these laws are promoted as public safety measures, so that the state can exercise some control over health care practices not officially licensed. Perhaps some legislators really believe this is effective — as opposed to, say, requiring that all practices have a plausible basis in science and maybe even some evidence of effectiveness.
The acts passed by Rhode Island and Minnesota are almost identical. New Mexico’s is more liberal, but contains many of the same provisions. This suggests these laws are based on templates fed to drafters by promoters of “health freedom” and are passed with few changes.
The statutes contain various provisions common to licensed health care practice acts: a supervisory authority, a bill of rights for the consumer, reporting requirements, confidentiality requirements, prohibitions on sex with patients (who are called “clients” in Minnesota and Rhode Island), and penalties for violations.
On the other hand, no malpractice insurance is required nor is there a specific provision for informed consent of the patient/client. As is common with other licensed “alternative” practitioners, unlicensed practitioners can’t perform surgery, prescribe drugs, invade the human body, use medical devices, or practice dentistry. They also cannot manipulate or adjust the articulations of joints or the spine, obviously in deference to the chiropractic lobby.
Then things get really weird.
First, other than as stated above, there is virtually no limitation on what these unlicensed practitioners can do, as long as it falls into “the broad domain of complementary and alternative healing methods and treatments.” Given the facts that (1) these “healing methods” are made up, and (2) some are of fairly recent origin (e.g., cranial sacral therapy), it appears reasonable to conclude that one can simply create a “healing method,” call it “alternative,” and set up shop. The unemployed should take note.
Specifically mentioned in the statutes as permissible treatments are acupressure, Alexander technique, aroma therapy, ayurveda, craniosacral therapy, crystal therapy, detoxification practices and therapies, energetic healing (as opposed to the lethargic kind, I guess), Rolfing, Gerson therapy, colostrum therapy, therapeutic touch, herbology, herbalism, polarity therapy, homeopathy, nondiagnostic iridology, Qi Gong, culturally traditional healing practices, anthroposophy, folk practices, healing practices utilizing food, dietary supplements, nutrients, and the physical forces of heat, cold, water, touch, and light, healing touch, homeopathy, body work, massage, meditation, mind-body healing practices, naturopathy, noninvasive instrumentalities, holistic kinesiology and other muscle testing techniques. However, it’s made clear in the statutes that this list is not meant as a limitation on the therapies which can be legally offered to the public.
Minnesota and Rhode Island add an extra layer of practitioner protection: having already ok’d unlicensed alternative medicine “healing methods,” these states assure practitioners on the cutting edge of pseudo-medicine that use of a “less customary approach” will not per se subject them to discipline. So now we have conventional alternative medicine and alternative alternative medicine? If the “less customary approach” is used with conventional alternative medicine, should we call it complementary alternative alternative medicine? So much to figure out!
Unlicensed practitioners cannot provide a “medical diagnosis,” or, as New Mexico puts it, the practitioner cannot “make a specific conventional medical diagnosis,” which is “a medical term that is commonly used and understood in conventional western medicine.” In another dig at “conventional western medicine,” plain old prescription drugs become “dangerous drugs” under New Mexico law. A “dangerous drug” is defined as “a drug that is required by applicable federal or state law or rule to be dispensed pursuant to a prescription.” Thus unlicensed practitioners are prohibited from prescribing or dispensing “dangerous drugs.”
To make sure unlicensed practitioners don’t pull one over on the public, Minnesota and Rhode Island (but not New Mexico) list as “prohibited conduct:”
“Advertising that is false, fraudulent, deceptive or misleading;” and
“Conduct likely to deceive, defraud, or harm the public.”
Good luck with that!
As further public protection, these states require their own version of a written quack Miranda warning. For example:
THE STATE OF MINNESOTA HAS NOT ADOPTED ANY EDUCATIONAL AND TRAINING STANDARDS FOR UNLICENSED COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONERS BUT WE ARE GOING TO LET THEM PRACTICE MEDICINE ANYWAY.
Actually, I made up that last part, after “PRACTITIONERS.” The rest is right out of the statutes.
As part of disclosure requirements, this must be followed by,
THIS STATEMENT OF CREDENTIALS IS FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY.
These “credentials” are “the degrees, training, experience, or other qualifications of the practitioner regarding the complementary and alternative health care being provided.” Considering this, the reader might look into investing in the diploma mill industry.
And note that credentials aren’t required — it’s just that if you have some you must let the client know what they are.
Perhaps to prevent their states from becoming havens for parents who want unrestricted access to “alternative” practices for their children, both Minnesota and Rhode Island (but, again, not New Mexico) make clear that “a parent who obtains complementary and alternative health care for the parent’s minor child is not relieved the duty to seek necessary medical care [for the child].” In fact, unlicensed practitioners are required to report to the authorities that a child is not receiving necessary medical care, although if the practitioner’s world view dictates that medical care is unnecessary, what happens then?
Minnesota prevents the unlicensed practitioner from using the title “doctor,” “Dr.” or “physician.” Rhode Island prevents “false or misleading” use of these terms. New Mexico simply prevents the practitioner from describing himself as a “licensed doctor or physician.”
That New Mexico! Here’s what else they do there. The other two states, as might be expected, prevent a person from providing unlicensed services if he has been convicted of a felony. Not New Mexico! The convicted felon is prevented from practicing only until he satisfies the terms of his sentence. After that, it’s back to aromatherapy, iridology, polarity therapy, or whatever else he was up to before his unfortunate encounter with the criminal justice system.
I must ask: Is it really good public policy to allow a convicted thief such easy access to a person’s wallet?
And here’s the best part, saved for last: Minnesota and Rhode Island require the practitioner to provide, in writing, “a brief summary, in plain language, of the theoretical approach used by the practitioner in providing services to clients.” What we wouldn’t give to see that! In fact, if you are ever in either of these states, be sure to have a complementary or alternative health care treatment from an unlicensed practitioner, and be sure to get your written, plain language summary of her “theoretical approach.” Send it to me here. [After, of course, signing a complete release absolving me of all liability for anything bad that happens to you at the hands of the unlicensed practitioner.] If my SBM editors agree to it, I’ll write a post about them. And bonus points for any summary containing the phrase “on a quantum level.”

